nypost.com
Open in
urlscan Pro
192.0.66.32
Public Scan
URL:
https://nypost.com/2024/02/10/opinion/coleman-hughes-offers-a-new-way-to-reconsider-race/
Submission Tags: trump republican maga conservative democrat progressive news laws immigration taylor swift Search All
Submission: On February 12 via manual from US — Scanned from US
Submission Tags: trump republican maga conservative democrat progressive news laws immigration taylor swift Search All
Submission: On February 12 via manual from US — Scanned from US
Form analysis 1 forms found in the DOM
<form class="search__form">
<div class="search__inner" role="search">
<label for="search-input-header" class="screen-reader-text"> Search </label>
<input type="search" name="s" class="search__input" id="search-input-header" placeholder="Type to Search" tabindex="-1" data-search-header="input">
</div>
<button class="search__submit" type="submit" tabindex="-1" aria-label="Click to Search" data-search-header="submit">
<span class="search__submit-text">Search</span>
</button>
</form>Text Content
Primary Menu Sections
* News Open sub menu
* Politics
* Metro
* Page Six
* Sports Open sub menu
* NFL
* MLB
* NBA
* NHL
* College Football
* College Basketball
* Post Sports+
* Sports Betting
* Business Open sub menu
* Personal Finance
* Opinion
* Entertainment Open sub menu
* TV
* Movies
* Music
* Celebrities
* Awards
* Theater
* Shopping
* Lifestyle Open sub menu
* Weird But True
* Health
* Sex & Relationships
* Viral Trends
* Human Interest
* Parenting
* Fashion & Beauty
* Food & Drink
* Travel
* Real Estate
* Media
* Tech
* Astrology
* Video
* Photos
* Visual Stories
* Sub Menu 1
* Today’s Paper
* Covers
* Columnists
* Horoscopes
* Crosswords & Games
* Sports Odds
* Podcasts
* Careers
* Sub menu 2
* Email Newsletters
* Official Store
* Home Delivery
* Tips
Log In
Search Email
New York Post
Log In
Search
Search
RECOMMENDED
Skip to main content
JOE BIDEN THROWS ISRAEL UNDER THE BUS IN A SAD PLOY TO WIN ON ELECTION DAY
BIDENS SHOULD FEAR TONY BOBULINSKI — THE MOST DEADLY IMPEACHMENT WITNESS WITH A
PATRIOTIC FAMILY HISTORY
WHEN BIDEN LOST ‘24,’ THE FAKE ‘VIOLENT SETTLERS’ CASE AND OTHER COMMENTARY
DROP DEAD, NEW YORK. DROP DEAD, DEMS: HOW MIGRANT CRISIS WILL SINK BIDEN
NO, OLD MAN BIDEN CLASSIFIED DOCUMENTS REPORT IS NOT A REPUBLICAN HIT JOB
OLD MAN JOE BIDEN’S ONLY CHANCE OF WINNING NOW IS JUST PUTTING TRUMP DOWN
JILL BIDEN CAN SPARE US THE FAKE OUTRAGE OVER THE DAMNING SPECIAL COUNSEL REPORT
PRINCE HARRY RESEMBLES A JERK IN TWO COUNTRIES
BREAKING NEWS
Chiefs escape with wild overtime victory in Super Bowl 2024
Opinion
* Facebook
* Twitter
* Flipboard
* WhatsApp
* Email
* Copy
*
* 3636 Comments
AUTHOR COLEMAN HUGHES OFFERS A NEW WAY TO RECONSIDER RACE
By
Social Links for Coleman Hughes
* View Author Archive
* Get author RSS feed
Thanks for contacting us. We've received your submission.
Back to Reading
Published Feb. 10, 2024, 8:00 a.m. ET
The new book "The End of Race Politics" sees young author Coleman Hughes
consider ways beyond our nation's obsession with identity. Hearst Newspapers via
Getty Images
MORE ON: IDENTITY POLITICS
* WILL GAVIN NEWSOM COPY TRUMP AND OVERTHROW THE DEM ELITE?
* IT’S NOT RACIST OR SEXIST TO WORRY KAMALA HARRIS IS A HEARTBEAT FROM THE
PRESIDENCY
* AI FINDS CONSERVATIVE WOMEN MORE ATTRACTIVE AND HAPPIER IN PHOTOS
* ‘EQUITY’ SICKENS US MEDICINE, TRUMP SIDES WITH DISNEY AND OTHER COMMENTARY
Few political commentators have caught the national spotlight quite like
27-year-old Coleman Hughes, a Columbia University graduate and New Jersey native
whose observations on race, class, and politics reveal wisdom and insight far
beyond his years. Critical of both the nation’s obsession with race and the
reliance on diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) programs to redress
race-based inequalities, Hughes is the rare young writer of color who rejects
progressive “woke” orthodoxies in exchange for hard data – and old-fashioned
common sense.
In 2019, Hughes testified before Congress, where he opposed a federal effort to
develop a formalized plan for slavery reparations — publicly opposing the far
better-known (and far older) author Ta-Nehisi Coates, who has long
supported reparations for African Americans. Now Hughes has released “The End of
Race Politics: Arguments for a Colorblind America” (Thesis), in which he argues
that structural policies to redress America’s racist past — particularly DEI —
are only hurting its present. In the excerpt that follows, Hughes explains how
America reached this contentious racial reckoning — and suggests that the nation
might actually be far more united than our dividers might like us to believe.
8
The Bush years and early Obama years represented a fairly healthy equilibrium
for America on the issue of race. The majority of Americans — both black and
white — believed that race relations were good. Then, after 2013, something
changed. Around that time American attitudes toward race relations took a
nosedive. By 2021 about half as many Americans felt that we were in a good place
as felt that way in 2013.
It’s not an exaggeration to say that whatever happened after 2013 represents the
biggest setback in American race relations in at least a generation.
So what happened? Why did people’s attitudes toward race relations take a
nosedive in 2013? We can rule out a few explanations. It probably was not the
election of President Obama, since he presided over five years of good race
relations. And it probably wasn’t President Trump either, as the downward trend
began three years before he was elected, and doesn’t appear to have reversed
itself since his departure from office. As much as we like to blame presidents
for everything, the reality is that sweeping social trends have causes that run
deeper than a single individual.
8
In 2019, Hughes testified before Congress during hearings to consider
reparations for slavery. Hughes opposes the idea. Getty Images
We can also rule out the idea that actual racism suddenly increased in 2013. If
there had been an uptick in the popularity of white supremacy or an uptick in
the number of unarmed black people shot by police, then we might have reason to
suspect that there was an increase in racism. But neither of those is the case.
Support for white supremacy has been steadily declining for decades, and so has
the annual number of police shootings.
The more plausible explanation is that 2013 is about the time that a critical
mass of Americans had two pieces of tech: camera-enabled smartphones and social
media. The widespread use of social media and smartphones increased the speed at
which content could spread throughout the world. But not all content was able to
take advantage of this development equally. The ideology I call “neoracism” —
which casts whites as an oppressor race and everyone else as victims — was able
to take advantage of this development in a way that other ideologies could not.
8
In his book, Hughes reviews and reconsiders the causes and extent of the police
brutality against African Americans that have resulted in mass protests and
social justice movements. AFP via Getty Images
Here’s an analogy: Imagine that the speed limit on a highway was suddenly raised
from 75 mph to 200 mph. Not all cars would be able to take advantage of this
change. If you drive a Chevy Spark (with a top speed of 89 mph), the new speed
limit change wouldn’t benefit you much. But if you drive a McLaren Speedtail
(with a top speed of 250 mph), you’d suddenly be able to travel much faster.
What happened around 2013 is that the speed limit on the information highway was
suddenly raised—not by a factor of two or three, but by several orders of
magnitude. And it turns out that certain content has a much higher “top speed”
than other content. Anything that appeals to our tribal identities, us versus
them narratives, or historical grievances travels fast. These pieces of content
are the McLarens of the Internet. Anything that emphasizes common humanity,
rational analysis, or fact-checking, on the other hand, travels far more slowly.
These are the Chevy Sparks.
8
In his book, Hughes revisits the case of Michael Brown, the teen killed by
police officers in Ferguson, Mo. in 2014. EPA
When Michael Brown was killed by Darren Wilson in Ferguson in 2014, the
narrative that a racist cop had killed an unarmed black teenager who had his
hands up spread quickly. As far as narratives go, this one tapped into every
psychological trigger that would lead people to share it widely: black v. white,
historical grievances, violence, and so on. The fact-check of this event — that
Michael Brown did not have his hands up, had physically overpowered the officer,
punched him, and tried to steal his gun — traveled slowly because it appealed
more to reason than to outrage. Indeed it traveled so slowly that it still has
not reached the countless individuals who, years later, still believe the
mythical version of events. To this day, “Hands Up, Don’t Shoot” remains one of
the most popular slogans at Black Lives Matter protests.
Back when all information spread more slowly, the fact-checked version of events
could arrive in time to preempt false representations (the Chevy and the McLaren
arrived at the same time). But those days are over. In the age of social media,
myths, and half-truths can more easily outrun the facts.
Neoracist ideology — because it casts every event as an instance of us versus
them, good versus evil, black versus white — has been able to take advantage of
the increased speed and decreased quality of the information people circulate.
The majority of black Americans pre-2013 believed that race relations were good.
Consider the following chart, which tracks the percentage of black Americans who
believe that racial discrimination was the main issue causing disparities in
housing, jobs, and income:
8
During his 2019 appearance at Congress, Hughes faced off against the far-older
author Ta-Nehisi Coates, a major proponent of reparations. The Washington Post
via Getty Im
As late as 2013, a clear majority of black Americans did not think that
discrimination was the main driver of racial disparities. That is back when
people were judging societal issues mainly by reference to their own lived
experience — in addition to a slow-moving information diet that consisted of
reading newspapers and watching the news on TV.
8
Gallup
Prior to 2013, most blacks and whites in America thought race relations were
good. The trend line showed that fewer and fewer blacks every year saw racial
discrimination as a big issue. Then everything changed. We saw a tenfold
increase in mentions of race and racism — despite every indication that
viewpoints about actual racism against blacks were trending downward.
Why, then, did people’s perception of race relations take a nosedive after 2013?
The answer is that smartphones and social media changed the speed limit of
information — which in turn gave a massive competitive advantage to ideas,
information, narratives, and arguments that tap into division, tribalism, and
grievances. Neoracism was among the ideologies able to take advantage of this
seismic change. Ultimately, this change resulted in an information diet that is
less tethered to reality, not more.
8
“Hands-Up/Don’t-Shoot,” just one of the many seminal slogans to emerge from
America’s social-justice movements. SOPA Images/LightRocket via Getty Images
Correlational data show that black people who use social media are more likely
to report being victims of racial discrimination than black people who don’t.
Correlation does not imply causation. But the data, at least, are consistent
with the view that social media has caused a major shift in how people view
themselves and the world — a shift away from reality and toward paranoia,
pessimism, and catastrophizing.
The news doesn’t report on the millions of black people who never encounter
racism in their daily lives. Their experiences aren’t newsworthy. The upshot:
the media is heavily biased toward reporting emotionally charged stories of
racism — stories that create a misperception that racism is a more widespread
social problem than it is. It’s important to see the media for what it is: a
business—one that aims at increasing views, clicks, and subscriptions. The media
has realized that anti-black racism sells, so it highlights anything that can be
spun in that direction.
8
Hughes suggests that America’s obsession with race and identity belies the
actual data behind it — and is leading the country toward “paranoia, pessimism,
and catastrophizing.” Evan Mann
36
What do you think? Post a comment.
You might object that social media and smartphones have merely made us more
aware of the widespread racism that’s actually out there. If this were true,
then we’d expect Americans in the age of social media to have an accurate
perception of the amount of racism in society. That proposition has been tested
and has come back negative. For instance, 54% of “very liberal” Americans — the
section of the population most active on social media — believe that over one
thousand unarmed black men were killed by the cops in 2019. The real number was
twelve. Social media isn’t educating us. It’s miseducating us.
From “The End Of Race Politics: Arguments for a Colorblind America,” by Coleman
Hughes, published on Feb. 6 by Thesis, an imprint of Penguin Publishing Group, a
division of Penguin Random House, LLC. Copyright (c) 2024 by Coleman Hughes.
SHARE THIS ARTICLE:
* Facebook
* Twitter
* Flipboard
* WhatsApp
* Email
* Copy
*
* 3636 Comments
Filed under
* books
* identity politics
* race
* 2/10/24
Read Next Latest NYC housing corruption is just the tip of the icebe...
SPONSORED STORIES
Skip
Ads by
Skip
Ads by
Around The Web
Travis Kelce's Outburst At Super Bowl Coach Is Beyond UnhingedPageSix.com
49ers Player Gets Freak Major Injury Just Walking Onto The FieldNYPost.com
Here's What Taylor Swift Really Looks Like Without MakeupNickiSwift.com
Here's What All Of Taylor Swift's Exes Have Said About HerNickiSwift.com
Buckingham Palace Is Very Unhappy With William & KateNYPost.com
Michelle Obama's Former Secret Service Agent Spills The TeaKatiecouric.com
Kardashian & Beckham Jr. Live It Up At Super Bowl PartyPageSix.com
The Tragedy Of Guy Fieri Just Gets Sadder And SadderMashed.com
Kanye & Censori Split Up After Only 11 Months Of MarriageHollywoodlife.com
Powered by ZergNet
COLUMNISTS
* MIRANDA DEVINE
BIDENS SHOULD FEAR TONY BOBULINSKI -- THE MOST DEADLY IMPEACHMENT WITNESS
WITH A PATRIOTIC FAMILY HISTORY
* NICOLE GELINAS
NOW IT'S FREE CASH: HOCHUL AND ADAMS' NEVER-ENDING MIGRANT-MONEY SPIGOT
* CINDY ADAMS
PRINCE HARRY RESEMBLES A JERK IN TWO COUNTRIES
SEE ALL COLUMNISTS
COVERS
TODAY'S COVER
FRONT COVER BACK COVER
FLIP FOR BACK COVER
BROWSE COVERS
TRENDING NOW ON NYPOST.COM
* This story has been shared 97,986 times. 97,986
SUPER BOWL 2024 LIVE UPDATES: CHIEFS DEFEAT 49ERS IN OVERTIME THRILLER
* This story has been shared 90,874 times. 90,874
NYC TEACHER, FORMER PRODIGY TOOK STUDENT INTO BATHROOM — BEFORE HANDING HIM
WAD OF CASH: PROBE
* This story has been shared 86,079 times. 86,079
DISNEY ON ICE PERFORMER LEFT IN 'CRITICAL' CONDITION AFTER FALL DURING
'BEAUTY AND THE BEAST'
In 2019, Hughes testified before Congress during hearings to consider
reparations for slavery. Hughes opposes the idea. Getty Images
In his book, Hughes reviews and reconsiders the causes and extent of the police
brutality against African Americans that have resulted in mass protests and
social justice movements. AFP via Getty Images
In his book, Hughes revisits the case of Michael Brown, the teen killed by
police officers in Ferguson, Mo. in 2014. EPA
During his 2019 appearance at Congress, Hughes faced off against the far-older
author Ta-Nehisi Coates, a major proponent of reparations. The Washington Post
via Getty Im
Gallup
"Hands-Up/Don't-Shoot," just one of the many seminal slogans to emerge from
America's social-justice movements. SOPA Images/LightRocket via Getty Images
Hughes suggests that America's obsession with race and identity belies the
actual data behind it — and is leading the country toward "paranoia, pessimism,
and catastrophizing." Evan Mann
You are viewing 1 of 8 images Previous Image Next Image
Advertisement
MORE STORIES
PAGE SIX
USHER BRINGS OUT ALICIA KEYS, LUDACRIS AND MORE SPECIAL GUESTS DURING SUPER BOWL
HALFTIME SHOW
DECIDER
*
‘The Drew Barrymore Show’: Demi Moore Says Tom Cruise Was “Mortified” When
She…
NYPOST
SUPER BOWL 2024 LIVE UPDATES: CHIEFS DEFEAT 49ERS IN OVERTIME THRILLER
* Facebook
* Twitter
* Instagram
* LinkedIn
* Email
* YouTube
* Sections & Features
* News
* Metro
* Sports
* Sports Betting
* Business
* Opinion
* Entertainment
* Fashion & Beauty
* Shopping
* Lifestyle
* Real Estate
* Media
* Tech
* Health
* Travel
* Astrology
* Video
* Photos
* Visual Stories
* Alexa
* Covers
* Horoscopes
* Sports Odds
* Podcasts
* Crosswords & Games
* Columnists
* Classifieds
* Post Sports+
* Subscribe
* Articles
* Manage
* Newsletters & Feeds
* Email Newsletters
* RSS Feeds
* NY Post Official Store
* Home Delivery
* Subscribe
* Manage Subscription
* Delivery Help
* Help/Support
* About New York Post
* Customer Service
* Apps Help
* Community Guidelines
* Contact Us
* Tips
* Newsroom
* Letters to the Editor
* Licensing & Reprints
* Careers
* Vulnerability Disclosure Program
* Apps
* iPhone App
* iPad App
* Android Phone
* Android Tablet
* Advertise
* Media Kit
* Contact
© 2024 NYP Holdings, Inc. All Rights Reserved Terms of Use Membership Terms
Privacy Notice Sitemap
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Your California Privacy Rights Do Not Sell or Share My Personal
Information/Opt-Out
SHARE LINK
click to copy
This page is not available in your area.
NYP - STRICTLY NECESSARY COOKIES AND SIMILAR TECHNOLOGIES
Strictly necessary cookies are essential for the website to function correctly.
These cookies may also be used to assist in fraud prevention and security. You
can set your browser to block or alert you about these cookies, but without
them, performance of the site may be affected and you may not be able to take
full advantage of all services and/or features of the site.
STRICTLY NECESSARY COOKIES
These cookies are necessary for the website to function and cannot be switched
off in our systems. They are usually only set in response to actions made by you
which amount to a request for services, such as setting your privacy
preferences, logging in or filling in forms. You can set your browser to
block or alert you about these cookies, but some parts of the site will not then
work. These cookies do not store any personally identifiable information.
NEWSCORP.COM ANALYTICS COOKIES
We and our service providers, such as Google Analytics, use analytics cookies to
collect information about your use of the website to help create reports and
statistics on the performance of the website, which enable us to improve the way
they work. Analytics cookies collect information such as your IP address, type
of device, operating system, referring URLs, country information data and time
of page visits, and pages visited. This information allows us to identify
overall patterns of usage on the website, and help us record any difficulties
you have with website. For information about how to opt-out of Google Analytics
cookies, please use the following link: Google Analytics
SUBMIT AN ACCESS, CORRECTION OR DELETION REQUEST TO NYP PRIVACY
Residents of CA , CO, CT, UT and VA have certain other rights with respect to
their personal information. Should you wish to exercise any of those other
rights, please indicate your preferences through the “Submit Request” link
provided below.
Submit Request
DO NOT SELL OR SHARE MY PERSONAL INFORMATION ONLY FOR NYP PRINT SUBSCRIBERS
If you are a CA, CT or VA resident and currently subscribe for (or are a former
subscriber of) home delivery of the print edition of the New York Post, you may
opt out of offline third party sales by using the “Submit an Opt Out Request”
link below. (Note: this option does not apply to residents of CO or UT because
there is no home delivery service in CO or UT.) Submit an Opt Out Request
DO NOT SELL OR SHARE MY PERSONAL INFORMATION FOR NYP INTERNET AND MOBILE USERS
Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information for NYP Internet and Mobile Users
If you do not wish for us or our third party partners such as advertising
networks and social media platforms to sell or share your personal information
to others, please click the red "Do Not Sell or Share My Personal
Information/Opt-Out” button provided below. If you access this site and/or app
from other devices or browsers, or clear your cookies on your devices or
browsers, you will need to indicate your preferences again from those devices or
browsers. Please note that after making your “Do Not Sell or Share” request, you
may still see advertising and we may continue to share personal information with
our service providers who use such information on our behalf. To learn more
about interest-based advertising across sites and additional opt-out choices,
you can visit http://optout.aboutads.info and
http://optout.networkadvertising.org.
KNEWZ - ANALYTICS COOKIES AND SIMILAR TECHNOLOGIES
We and our service providers, such as Google Analytics, use analytics cookies to
collect information about your use of the website to help create reports and
statistics on the performance of the website, which enable us to improve the way
the site works. Analytics cookies collect information such as your IP address,
type of device, operating system, referring URLs, country information data and
time of page visits, and pages visited. This information allows us to identify
overall patterns of usage on the website, and help us record any difficulties
you have with website.
KNEWZ - ADVERTISING COOKIES AND SIMILAR TECHNOLOGIES
We may also partner with our affiliated companies, social media platforms and
other third parties where those companies and platforms gather information
through advertising cookies of users of our site in order to deliver targeted
advertising campaigns or advertisements to such users while they are on those
social media platforms.
NYP - FUNCTIONALITY COOKIES AND SIMILAR TECHNOLOGIES
Functionality cookies collect information regarding your choices and preferences
(such as, your language preference, user name, or location) to provide a more
personalized online experience and show you content relevant to where you are,
such as customizing a certain webpage or remembering if we have asked you to
sign up for our Services. With mobile or other internet enabled devices,
functionality cookies may collect a unique identifier assigned to an internet
enabled device (mobile, tablet), geolocation data or other traffic information
for that device. These features help us improve your experience with the
website, for example, to determine the appropriate device location during a
session or count articles viewed.
NYP - ANALYTICS COOKIES AND SIMILAR TECHNOLOGIES
We and our service providers, such as Google Analytics, use analytics cookies to
collect information about your use of the website to help create reports and
statistics on the performance of the website, which enable us to improve the way
the site works. Analytics cookies collect information such as your IP address,
type of device, operating system, referring URLs, country information data and
time of page visits, and pages visited. This information allows us to identify
overall patterns of usage on the website, and help us record any difficulties
you have with website.
NYP - UNKNOWN
Unknown
NYP OBSOLETE
Obsolete/cookies not in use
SOCIAL MEDIA COOKIES
These cookies are set by a range of social media services that we have added to
the site to enable you to share our content with your friends and networks. They
are capable of tracking your browser across other sites and building up a
profile of your interests. This may impact the content and messages you see on
other websites you visit. If you do not allow these cookies you may not be
able to use or see these sharing tools.
TARGETING COOKIES
These cookies may be set through our site by our advertising partners. They may
be used by those companies to build a profile of your interests and show you
relevant adverts on other sites. They do not store directly personal
information, but are based on uniquely identifying your browser and internet
device. If you do not allow these cookies, you will experience less targeted
advertising.
PERFORMANCE COOKIES
These cookies allow us to count visits and traffic sources so we can measure and
improve the performance of our site. They help us to know which pages are the
most and least popular and see how visitors move around the site. All
information these cookies collect is aggregated and therefore anonymous. If you
do not allow these cookies we will not know when you have visited our site, and
will not be able to monitor its performance.
FUNCTIONAL COOKIES
These cookies enable the website to provide enhanced functionality and
personalisation. They may be set by us or by third party providers whose
services we have added to our pages. If you do not allow these cookies then
some or all of these services may not function properly.
NEWSCORP.COM STRICTLY NECESSARY AND FUNCTIONALITY COOKIES
Strictly necessary cookies are essential for the website to function correctly.
These cookies may be used to assist in fraud prevention, security and to enable
filling in forms. You can set your browser to block or alert you about these
cookies, but without them, some parts of the website may not work. Functionality
cookies may collect a unique identifier assigned to an internet enabled device
(mobile, tablet), geolocation data or other traffic information for that device.
These features help us improve your experience with the website, for example, to
determine the appropriate device location during a session or store language
settings.
NEWSCORP.COM - UNKNOWN COOKIES
Newscorp.com - Unknown cookies
Cookies on the newscorp.com website that show up in the scan, but were not
identified in the cookie audit of 2022.
Back Button
COOKIE LIST
Search Icon
Filter Icon
Clear
checkbox label label
Apply Cancel
Consent Leg.Interest
checkbox label label
checkbox label label
checkbox label label
Confirm
Before you go ...