www.washingtonpost.com Open in urlscan Pro
23.45.108.250  Public Scan

Form analysis
2 forms found in the DOM

<form class="wpds-c-gRPFSl wpds-c-gRPFSl-jGNYrR-isSlim-false">
  <div class="transition-all duration-200 ease-in-out"><button type="submit" data-qa="sc-newsletter-signup-button" class="wpds-c-kSOqLF wpds-c-kSOqLF-uTUwn-variant-primary wpds-c-kSOqLF-eHdizY-density-default wpds-c-kSOqLF-ejCoEP-icon-left">Sign
      up</button></div>
</form>

<form class="wpds-c-gRPFSl wpds-c-gRPFSl-jGNYrR-isSlim-false">
  <div class="transition-all duration-200 ease-in-out"><button type="submit" data-qa="sc-newsletter-signup-button" class="wpds-c-kSOqLF wpds-c-kSOqLF-uTUwn-variant-primary wpds-c-kSOqLF-eHdizY-density-default wpds-c-kSOqLF-ejCoEP-icon-left">Sign
      up</button></div>
</form>

Text Content

Accessibility statementSkip to main content

Democracy Dies in Darkness
SubscribeSign in
worldWar In UkraineAfricaAmericasAsiaEuropeMiddle East
worldWar In UkraineAfricaAmericasAsiaEuropeMiddle East


IRAN TURNS TO HELLS ANGELS AND OTHER CRIMINAL GANGS TO TARGET CRITICS


IRAN HAS CULTIVATED TIES WITH CRIMINAL NETWORKS IN THE WEST TO CARRY OUT A
RECENT WAVE OF VIOLENT PLOTS IN THE UNITED STATES AND EUROPE.

24 min
582

(Rob Dobi for The Washington Post)
By Greg Miller
, 
Souad Mekhennet
and 
Cate Brown
September 12, 2024 at 5:00 a.m. EDT

LONDON — In the months before his attackers tracked him down, the exiled Iranian
journalist had been moved in and out of safe houses by London’s Metropolitan
Police, given a secret way to signal rescue units and had monitoring devices
installed in his home.

British authorities had done even more to protect Iran International, the
London-based satellite news channel that airs the weekly program of the
journalist, Pouria Zeraati, and has built an audience of millions in Iran
despite being outlawed by the Islamic republic.



Police assigned a team of undercover officers to safeguard the channel’s
employees, arrested a suspect caught surveilling the station’s entrances, put
armored cars outside its headquarters and, for one seven-month stretch last
year, convinced the network to move temporarily to Washington.

Advertisement

Story continues below advertisement



None of these measures managed to protect Zeraati from the plot that Iran is
suspected of setting in motion this year. On March 29, he was stabbed four times
and left bleeding on the sidewalk outside his home in the London suburb of
Wimbledon by assailants who were not from Iran and had no discernible connection
to its security services, according to British investigators.

Instead, officials said, Iran hired criminals in Eastern Europe who encountered
few obstacles as they cleared security checks at Heathrow Airport, spent days
tracking Zeraati and then caught departing flights just hours after carrying out
an ambush that their victim survived — perhaps intentionally, investigators
said, to serve as a warning but not trigger the fallout that would come with the
murder of a British citizen.

Iran’s alleged reliance on criminals rather than covert operatives underscored
an alarming evolution in tactics by a nation that U.S. and Western security
officials consider one of the world’s most determined and dangerous
practitioners of “transnational repression,” a term for governments’ use of
violence and intimidation in others’ sovereign territory to silence dissidents,
journalists and others deemed disloyal.

Skip to end of carousel


REPRESSION’S LONG ARM

Iran is using criminal gangs to target exiled dissidents, journalists and human
rights activists in the United States, Europe and the Middle East. The
Washington Post is investigating a global surge in campaigns of cross-border
repression. The previous stories in the series examined Indian assassination
plots in North America and China’s efforts to silence critics in an American
city.
The United States and other Western governments have struggled to stem this
phenomenon. As a result, sanctuary for those fleeing persecution is shrinking on
nearly every continent.

End of carousel

Senior security officials said that the use of criminal proxies by governments
has compounded the difficulty of protecting those who have sought refuge in the
United States, Europe and elsewhere. Security services formerly focused on
tracking operatives from Russia’s GRU spy agency or Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary
Guard Corps (IRGC) now confront plots handed off — often through encrypted
channels — to criminal networks deeply embedded in Western society.

🌎

Follow World news

Follow

In recent years, Iran has outsourced lethal operations and abductions to Hells
Angels biker gangs, a notorious Russian mob network known as “Thieves in Law,” a
heroin distribution syndicate led by an Iranian narco-trafficker and violent
criminal groups from Scandinavia to South America.

This story reveals new details about how Iran has cultivated and exploited
connections to criminal networks that are behind a recent wave of violent plots
secretly orchestrated by elite units in the IRGC and Iran’s Ministry of
Intelligence (MOIS). It is based on interviews with senior officials in more
than a dozen countries, hundreds of pages of criminal court records in the
United States and Europe, as well as additional investigative documents obtained
by The Washington Post from security services.

With hit men it has hired in the criminal underworld, Iran has commissioned
plots against a former Iranian military officer living under an assumed identity
in Maryland, an exiled Iranian American journalist in Brooklyn, a women’s rights
activist in Switzerland, LGBTQ+ activists in Germany and at least five
journalists at Iran International, as well as dissidents and regime critics in a
half dozen other countries, according to interviews and records.



Other nations have begun to embrace this strategy. India’s security services
enlisted criminal groups to kill a Sikh activist in Canada last year and target
another in New York, according to U.S. and Canadian officials. Russia, which has
traditionally relied on its own agents for lethal operations, turned last year
to mob elements in Spain to kill a military helicopter pilot who had defected to
Ukraine and then resettled in the Mediterranean.

Iran’s turn to criminal proxies has in part been driven by necessity, officials
said, reflecting the intense scrutiny that Iran’s own operatives face from
Western governments. The attack on Zeraati avoided these Iran-focused defenses.



“We’re not dealing with the usual suspects,” said Matt Jukes, the head of
counterterrorism policing in the United Kingdom and assistant commissioner for
special operations with Scotland Yard. He acknowledged that Zeraati’s assailants
remain at large more than five months after his stabbing. They have been
identified and their travels traced to countries in Eastern Europe but have so
far not been detained. Officials said the suspects remain in Eastern Europe and
that other security services are cooperating with British authorities, but they
declined to explain why the suspects have not been taken into custody.

“What we’ve got is a hostile state actor that sees the battlefield as being
without border and individuals in London every bit as legitimate as targets as
if [they were] in Iran,” said Jukes. Along with Britain’s domestic spy agency,
MI5, the Metropolitan Police have tracked more than 16 plots from the Islamic
republic over the past two years, according to British intelligence and security
officials, many of whom spoke on the condition of anonymity to discuss sensitive
and ongoing investigations.

The United States has faced a wave of similar threats, including several that
have been detailed in criminal indictments connecting biker gangs in Canada and
mob elements in Eastern Europe to planned assassinations commissioned by Iran.

Matthew G. Olsen, who heads the national security division at the Justice
Department, said that “Iran is clearly at the top of the list” of states that
year after year seek to kill or abduct dissidents and journalists outside their
borders. Other nations, particularly China, seek to intimidate or repress
diaspora populations, Olsen said, but Iran is consistently “focused on actions
at the extreme end of [transnational repression] because of their lethal
targeting.”

Iran dismissed the accusations as Western disinformation. “The Islamic Republic
of Iran harbors neither the intent nor the plan to engage in assassination or
abduction operations, whether in the West or any other country,” Iran’s mission
to the United Nations said in a statement. “These fabrications are concoctions
of the Zionist regime, the Albania-based Mujahedin-e Khalq terrorist cult, and
certain Western intelligence services—including those of the United States—to
divert attention from the atrocities committed by the Israeli regime.”


A SURGE IN ATTACKS

Iran’s overseas operations have intensified in response to a period of political
upheaval driven by mass protests over economic conditions and the regime’s
treatment of women.

The security services in Tehran are targeting those outside the country whom
they accuse of stoking these internal divisions, Western officials and analysts
said.

Amid worries that the conflict in Gaza might break out into a regional war,
Tehran has also been linked to plots against U.S. and Israeli officials and
members of Jewish communities in France and Germany.

The Justice Department filed charges last month against a Pakistani man with
ties to Iran who was accused of seeking to hire a hit man to assassinate
political figures in the United States, possibly including former president
Donald Trump. It was the latest in a series of plots against members of his
administration, including former secretary of state Mike Pompeo and former
national security adviser John Bolton, in response to a 2020 U.S. drone strike
in Iraq that killed IRGC leader Qasem Soleimani.

Advertisement

Story continues below advertisement



Security officials and experts said the pace of operations emanating from Iran
is unprecedented. Data published by the Washington Institute in August listed 88
assassination, abduction and other violent plots linked to Iran over the past
five years — exceeding the total for the preceding four decades following the
1979 revolution. At least 14 of those recent cases involved criminal
organizations.

“We’re seeing a major escalation in lethal plotting from a government that has
used this tactic from the outset,” said Matthew Levitt, a counterterrorism
expert at the Washington Institute.

The results have been mixed.

For every plot that has succeeded, others have failed, often because of blunders
committed by those hired. Iran appears to accept the downsides of the
outsourcing model because of offsetting advantages. These include making it more
difficult for authorities to attribute attacks to Tehran, an abundance of
criminals willing to commit violence for relatively modest sums of money and a
negligible price of failure.

Rather than putting Iran’s own agents at risk, a U.S. intelligence analyst said,
“two guys they barely know will spend 20 years in jail.”



Zeraati, 36, had faced threats since starting his program in 2022 at Iran
International, a Saudi-funded satellite and online news platform that bypasses
Iran’s censors and beams news and commentary to millions of viewers.

In November 2022, Zeraati’s wife, a real estate agent, was approached by two men
on a motorcycle outside a London health club. “We know where you live,” one
said, according to Zeraati. “We will kill your husband.”

Zeraati was one of five Iranian journalists whose pictures appeared on “Wanted,
Dead or Alive” posters hung from signposts in Iran and circulated widely on
social media outlets tied to the government.



Yet the stabbing took place at a time when the threat level facing Iran
International was perceived to have declined. The channel had returned from its
Washington relocation to new London studios ringed by blast walls, guard
stations and surveillance cameras. After multiple stays at safe houses, Zeraati
had returned to his residence, a flat in a four-story apartment building so
close to the famed Wimbledon tennis complex that you can hear the thwack of
balls being struck on practice courts.

The assailants appear to have taken advantage of security vulnerabilities. His
home address could be found in online property records. His broadcast schedule —
one weekly show airing Friday nights — pointed to a predictable commute pattern.

As Zeraati crossed the street to his car around 3 p.m. to head to work, he
caught sight of a disheveled man approaching him. “Brother, can I have three
pounds change,” the man said, Zeraati recalled in an interview.

While Zeraati continued toward his car, a second man emerged from a driveway
obscured by foliage. The second seized Zeraati’s arms while the first, smiling
broadly, plunged a blade into his leg repeatedly. The decision to stab his thigh
rather than his heart or other vital organs led police to believe the attack was
intended as a warning.

Advertisement

Story continues below advertisement



The assailants then raced up the street to meet an accomplice with a car.
Zeraati’s first thought was that he had been mugged. But as he reached for his
phone to call an ambulance, he realized that the attackers had not taken any of
his belongings, including a wallet, a watch and a Montblanc pen.

“At that moment it clicked,” Zeraati said. “It had been related to my job.”

If the stabbing was meant to silence Zeraati and sow fear among the regime’s
Western critics, it was only partially successful.

Zeraati returned to the airwaves after a brief hospital stay. “I wanted to send
a message that the flow of information in the 21st century can’t be stopped,” he
said.

Other journalists, dissidents and regime critics acknowledge that they remain
deeply shaken.

“It sent a chill through my spine,” said Alireza Nader, an independent Iran
analyst based in Washington. “I look over my shoulder now,” he said. “Everybody
who is active against the regime, speaks publicly against the regime, felt that
attack.”



British officials have not publicly accused Iran of responsibility. Security
officials said they see no alternative explanation but are still gathering
evidence.

Iranian officials have said the country was not involved in the stabbing. “We
deny any link to this story of this so-called journalist,” the country’s
ambassador to the United Kingdom said in a post on X the day after the attack.


ENLISTING HELLS ANGELS

Iran has outsourced assassinations and abductions to at least five criminal
syndicates, officials said. At the center of this web is an alleged heroin
trafficking kingpin based in Iran, Naji Sharifi Zindashti.

U.S. criminal charges made public earlier this year outline an alleged scheme in
which Zindashti negotiated a $350,000 contract with two Hells Angels members in
Canada to kill an Iranian defector and his wife living under false identities in
Maryland.

In exchanges over encrypted texts, the would-be assassins discussed their
client’s insistence that the slaying be symbolically vicious. One assured the
other that he would “make sure I hit this guy in the head with ATLEAST half the
clip,” according to the U.S. indictment, adding, “we gotta erase his head from
his torso.”

The name of the targeted defector has not been disclosed, but U.S. officials
said the individual had served as an officer in the IRGC, a powerful wing of
Iran’s military created after the 1979 revolution, and become an informant for
the CIA.

The incongruous partnership between an Islamic theocracy and a notorious biker
gang was driven in part by necessity, officials said, given the resources U.S.
security agencies devote to preventing Iran from deploying operatives to the
United States.

The Hells Angels, however, has chapters across the country as well as a powerful
grip on narcotics trafficking in Canadian provinces, officials said. And there
were previous connections between Iran and Hells Angels. In another plot, Iran
used a German member of the gang, Ramin Yektaparast, who had fled to Tehran to
escape murder charges, to orchestrate the bombing of a synagogue in Essen. An
alleged associate balked at bombing the synagogue but fired shots into its
windows.

The point man in the Maryland plot was a “full patch” member named Damion Ryan,
who has a string of convictions in Canada for crimes including drug trafficking,
assault, robbery and home invasion, according to court records. Those documents
list aliases for him including “Berserker” and “Mr. Wolf.”



Ryan, 43, in turn enlisted a younger Hells Angels affiliate, Adam R. Pearson,
29, who was in hiding in Minneapolis to escape arrest on murder charges in
Canada, according to U.S. and Canadian officials and court records.

An attorney representing Ryan declined to comment. Attorneys who have previously
represented Pearson did not respond to requests for comment.

By March 2021, the Hells Angels pair had agreed on the six-figure price tag and
Zindashti had sent photos and maps as well as an initial $20,000 payment to
cover travel expenses, according to the U.S. indictment. It is unclear how Iran
identified the location of the defector.

Then, just as it entered its final stage, the plot stalled. The indictment
provides no explanation for why Pearson never made the trip to Maryland, but
that same month security services in Europe achieved a breakthrough that rippled
through criminal networks around the world.

Zindashti and the two Hells Angels members had been corresponding through an
encrypted messaging service known as Sky ECC. Launched by a Vancouver-based
company in 2008, the system became a mainstay among criminal syndicates by
turning ordinary cellphones into seemingly impenetrable devices, disabling their
cameras, microphones and GPS trackers while adding a “kill switch” to delete
incriminating data.

By early 2021, however, Belgian and Dutch security services found a way to
breach the network’s security. On March 9, Belgian police carried out hundreds
of raids, arrested dozens of alleged traffickers and seized 17 tons of cocaine.
Among those taken into custody in Belgium and the Netherlands were members of
Hells Angels.

U.S. officials said the Maryland plot came to their attention as investigators
sifted through the Sky ECC trove. Pearson was arrested by the FBI in Minnesota
and extradited to Canada. In February 2022, Ryan was arrested following a raid
on his house in Ottawa, where authorities found a cache of weapons, body armor
and roughly $95,000 in cash.


A DRUG LORD IN TEHRAN

Zindashti has emerged as a linchpin in Iran’s operations.

A hulking figure who stands over 6 feet tall and weighs 250 pounds, Zindashti
was described by one U.S. intelligence analyst as a “Pablo Escobar-type
narco-trafficker.”

Now in his early 50s, Zindashti acquired that status after emerging triumphant
from a bloody regional drug war touched off by one of the largest busts in
European history. It involved a cargo ship named the Noor One that arrived at a
Greek port in June 2014 carrying more than two tons of heroin.

Zindashti was accused by some of tipping off authorities to undercut rivals. He
has survived several attempts on his life, but his daughter and a nephew were
killed in 2014 by gunmen who pulled up alongside their Porsche Cayenne in
Istanbul, mistakenly believing Zindashti was in the vehicle, according to
Turkish court records obtained by The Post.

A brutal campaign of score-settling ensued in which more than a dozen people
linked to the Noor One deal were killed. One of the murders had striking
parallels to the Hells Angels plot that Zindashti is alleged to have later
orchestrated on behalf of Iran’s MOIS.

Advertisement

Story continues below advertisement



In May 2016, a Turkish drug trafficker identified as Cetin Koc was gunned down
in Dubai by two hit men who had traveled from Canada where they had links to
local narcotics networks. The gunmen became targets themselves upon returning to
Vancouver. The bullet-riddled body of one was found in a blueberry field and the
remains of the other were recovered from a burned car, Canadian officials said.

In statements to Turkish investigators, Zindashti acknowledged that he had
motive to kill Koc, saying that “he wrote me threatening messages about ten days
before my daughter’s murder.” Still, Zindashti claimed to “have nothing to do
with the murder” and dismissed the accusations as “a conspiracy.”

As the killings continued, the target list expanded to include dissidents and
journalists branded disloyal by Tehran.

In 2017, Saeed Karimian, the founder of a Persian language television network,
GEM TV, was killed in Istanbul by suspects including a man that Zindashti
acknowledged had worked as his family’s driver, according to the Turkish court
records.

In 2019, Masoud Molavi, a dissident who had created a popular Telegram channel
that campaigned against corruption in Iran, was killed in Istanbul by an
assailant who then hid in one of Zindashti’s apartments, according to the
Turkish files, which refer to the drug lord as the “instigator” of multiple
attacks.

In 2020, Habib Chaab, a political activist living in Sweden, was abducted during
a visit to Turkey and smuggled by Zindashti operatives to Iran where he was
tortured and, in 2023, executed, U.S., Western and Turkish security officials
said.



Zindashti’s ruthless effectiveness appears to have reignited Iran’s enthusiasm
for working with criminal syndicates after experiments years earlier ended in
failure, officials said. An attempt in 2011 to assassinate the Saudi ambassador
at Café Milano, a Georgetown restaurant, unraveled when Iran enlisted a hapless
used-car salesman from Texas — the cousin of an official in Tehran — to manage
the plot.

Taking on these assignments may also have paved the way for Zindashti’s return
several years ago to his native country after an arrest and other legal problems
prompted him to abandon Istanbul. The apparent sanctuary provided Zindashti and
Yektaparast suggests that Iran’s religious hard-liners are willing to
accommodate criminals who are useful against their enemies, officials said.
Yektaparast, who posted photos of his Lamborghini and other luxury trappings on
an Instagram account, was killed by unknown assailants in Iran earlier this
year.

“Café Milano was, in hindsight, a signifier of things to come,” said a U.S.
intelligence analyst. But it was Zindashti, the analyst said, who brought a
“significant shift in terms of realizing this is a lucrative tactic.”

Iran’s security services have poured additional resources into supporting such
operations, officials said. The Quds Force, an elite paramilitary wing of the
IRGC, established a special unit, Department 840, dedicated to assassination
operations outside Iran, U.S. and other officials said.

Zindashti has been more closely aligned with the MOIS, which functions as Iran’s
main domestic security service but also has its own assassination branch, U.S.
officials said. Iranian nationals who oppose the government are considered
“internal” adversaries, officials said, even when residing in others’ sovereign
territory.

The U.S. Treasury Department and its U.K. equivalent imposed financial sanctions
on Zindashti earlier this year, saying that he had conducted “assassinations and
kidnappings under the direction of the MOIS across multiple continents.”

Even while taking advantage of Zindashti’s international reach, Iran has
diversified.



A gunman who showed up at the Brooklyn doorstep of Iranian American journalist
Masih Alinejad in July 2022 was a member of a sprawling criminal organization
known as Thieves in Law. The phrase refers to a mafia-style honor code that
sworn members are bound to follow.

The assailant, Khalid Mehdiyev, was arrested after being pulled over for a
traffic violation near Alinejad’s residence. Police found an AK-47, 66 rounds of
ammunition and a ski mask in his vehicle, according to a U.S. indictment.

Charges have also been filed against two other suspected Thieves in Law members
alleged to have given Mehdiyev his orders. One was based in Iran but apprehended
in Uzbekistan and turned over to the United States in 2023, officials said. The
other was also extradited earlier this year after being arrested in the Czech
Republic.

The assassination attempt marked at least the third plot targeting Alinejad, a
prominent advocate for women’s rights in Iran. One centered on an elaborate
scheme to abduct her, escape New York by boat and board a flight to Iran from
Venezuela, according to details released by the U.S. Treasury Department when it
imposed sanctions on security operatives in Iran.

Alinejad said she has spent time in more than a dozen safe houses and that
Iran’s use of criminals has deepened her concern for her safety. “There are a
lot of people in Eastern Europe and other places and it’s very easy for them to
get a visa and come here to do the job,” she said.


‘WE’RE COMING FOR YOU’

Iran has used that template repeatedly against Iran International, the satellite
station whose journalists have been targets of at least five lethal plots.

Launched in 2017, the network has built gleaming studios in a London business
park and hired hundreds of employees, including prominent broadcasters from BBC
Persian and other platforms.

Despite negligible advertising revenue, the station spends lavishly on
facilities and salaries, reporting losses totaling $569 million between 2017 and
2022, the latest year for which figures are available. Executives declined to
provide details on the station’s funding except to acknowledge that much of it
comes from sources in Saudi Arabia — one of Iran’s primary adversaries.

Viewership has surged, fueled by around-the-clock coverage of internal protests.
During the 2022 uprisings that followed the death of Mahsa Amini, a 22-year-old
woman beaten by police for alleged violations of the country’s religious dress
code, the network aired coverage of the violent internal crackdown, showing
videos of police beatings and other abuses submitted by activists and ordinary
citizens.



As protests grew, IRGC commander Hossein Salami issued a thinly veiled threat to
the network. “We warn those who manage these systems of spreading news and
spreading lies for chaos inside our country to stop these behaviors,” he said.
“You’ve tried us before. Watch out because we’re coming for you.”

A month later, in November 2022, the station issued a news release saying it had
been warned of bomb and death threats against two of its senior managers. Other
plots followed, aimed at on-air broadcasters Fardad Farahzad and Sima Sabet.

In February 2023, police arrested a suspected associate of the Thieves in Law
who had arrived in London on a flight from Vienna, went straight to Iran
International’s headquarters and begun taking videos of its perimeter security.
That same month, the channel moved its production operations to an existing Iran
International studio in Washington, considered safer because of the distance
from Tehran and the capabilities of U.S. intelligence agencies.

The Metropolitan Police released a video showing a man arrested outside Iran
International's office in London on Feb. 11, 2023, under the state's terrorism
act. (Video: Met Police via PA Media)

The Thieves in Law suspect, Magomed-Husejn Dovtaev, a 31-year-old native of
Chechnya, was convicted in December of conducting surveillance for an act of
terrorism and given a three-and-a-half-year prison sentence.

Three months later, a trio of alleged assailants arrived in London much as
Dovtaev had — on flights from European countries that allow easy entry to
Britain.

Zeraati considers himself more partisan commentator than impartial journalist,
and the editorial tone of his weekly “Last Word” program may have made him a
priority target.

Several weeks before the stabbing, he had aired an interview with Israeli Prime
Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, who used the appearance to denounce the IRGC as a
“self-designated” terrorist organization.

Iran’s Fars News Agency responded by applying the same label to Iran
International, calling it a “terrorist” channel that had “offered its antenna to
the prime minister, murderer of children in Gaza.”

Advertisement

Story continues below advertisement



Despite efforts to protect Zeraati, the attack exposed security lapses. Police
had removed monitoring devices from his home a year earlier and though London is
saturated with police surveillance cameras, none had been installed on Zeraati’s
street.

Alicia Kearns, a member of British Parliament who was chairwoman of the Foreign
Affairs Committee at the time of the stabbing, said in an interview that she was
troubled that police had failed to stop the assailants before they could flee
the country.

“There are unfortunately going to be an increase in hostile states seeking to
silence those who speak against them,” she said. “The U.K. can’t be a beacon of
freedom and democracy if we can’t stop hostile states conducting acts of
terrorism on our soil.”

Zeraati has pressed on with his program but his life has been altered. After
additional stays in safe houses, he and his wife decided this summer to move
away from England. They now reside in Jerusalem, a city where they believed they
would be safer, close to the regional stories he covers and where the station
also has a studio.

He no longer walks with a noticeable limp, he said, but bears scars that “will
stay for a lifetime.”



About this story

Mekhennet and Brown reported from Washington. Amanda Coletta in Toronto and
Kareem Fahim and Beril Eski in Istanbul contributed to this report.

Design and development by Andrew Bradford. Illustration by Rob Dobi. Graphics by
Sam Granados and Cate Brown.

Photo editing by Olivier Laurent. Design editing by Joseph Moore.

Editing by Peter Finn. Project editing by Akilah Johnson. Copy editing by Feroze
Dhanoa.

Additional support from Jordan Melendrez, Nina Zafar, Grace Moon, Joe Snell,
Sarah Parnass and Sarah Murray.

Share
582 Comments

NewsletterAs news breaks
World News Alerts
Breaking news email alerts for major happenings around the world.
Sign up

Subscribe to comment and get the full experience. Choose your plan →



NewsletterAs news breaks
World News Alerts
Breaking news email alerts for major happenings around the world.
Sign up
Company
About The Post Newsroom Policies & Standards Diversity & Inclusion Careers Media
& Community Relations WP Creative Group Accessibility Statement Sitemap
Get The Post
Become a Subscriber Gift Subscriptions Mobile & Apps Newsletters & Alerts
Washington Post Live Reprints & Permissions Post Store Books & E-Books Today’s
Paper Public Notices
Contact Us
Contact the Newsroom Contact Customer Care Contact the Opinions Team Advertise
Licensing & Syndication Request a Correction Send a News Tip Report a
Vulnerability
Terms of Use
Digital Products Terms of Sale Print Products Terms of Sale Terms of Service
Privacy Policy Cookie Settings Submissions & Discussion Policy RSS Terms of
Service Ad Choices
washingtonpost.com © 1996-2024 The Washington Post
 * washingtonpost.com
 * © 1996-2024 The Washington Post
 * About The Post
 * Contact the Newsroom
 * Contact Customer Care
 * Request a Correction
 * Send a News Tip
 * Report a Vulnerability
 * Download the Washington Post App
 * Policies & Standards
 * Terms of Service
 * Privacy Policy
 * Cookie Settings
 * Print Products Terms of Sale
 * Digital Products Terms of Sale
 * Submissions & Discussion Policy
 * Sitemap
 * RSS Terms of Service
 * Ad Choices









COOKIE CHOICES FOR EU, SWISS & UK RESIDENTS

We and our 94 partners store and access personal data, like browsing data or
unique identifiers, on your device. Selecting "I Accept" enables tracking
technologies to support the purposes shown under "we and our partners process
data to provide," whereas selecting "Reject All" or withdrawing your consent
will disable them. If trackers are disabled, some content and ads you see may
not be as relevant to you. You can resurface this menu to change your choices or
withdraw consent at any time by clicking the ["privacy preferences"] link on the
bottom of the webpage [or the floating icon on the bottom-left of the webpage,
if applicable]. Your choices will have effect within our Website. For more
details, refer to our Privacy Policy.

If you click “I accept,” in addition to processing data using cookies and
similar technologies for the purposes to the right, you also agree we may
process the profile information you provide and your interactions with our
surveys and other interactive content for personalized advertising.

If you are an EU, Swiss, or UK resident and you do not accept, we will process
cookies and associated data for strictly necessary purposes and process
non-cookie data as set forth in our Privacy Policy (consistent with law and, if
applicable, other choices you have made).


WE AND OUR PARTNERS PROCESS COOKIE DATA TO PROVIDE:

Actively scan device characteristics for identification. Create profiles for
personalised advertising. Use profiles to select personalised advertising.
Create profiles to personalise content. Use profiles to select personalised
content. Measure advertising performance. Measure content performance.
Understand audiences through statistics or combinations of data from different
sources. Develop and improve services. Store and/or access information on a
device. Use limited data to select content. Use limited data to select
advertising. List of Partners (vendors)

I Accept Reject All Show Purposes