www.independent.co.uk
Open in
urlscan Pro
2a04:4e42:200::347
Public Scan
Submitted URL: https://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/gadgets-and-tech/solarwinds-hack-how-russia-us-government-b1776034.html
Effective URL: https://www.independent.co.uk/tech/solarwinds-hack-how-russia-us-government-b1776034.html
Submission: On May 01 via api from CA — Scanned from CA
Effective URL: https://www.independent.co.uk/tech/solarwinds-hack-how-russia-us-government-b1776034.html
Submission: On May 01 via api from CA — Scanned from CA
Form analysis
5 forms found in the DOM<form class="gsc-search-box gsc-search-box-tools" accept-charset="utf-8">
<table cellspacing="0" cellpadding="0" role="presentation" class="gsc-search-box">
<tbody>
<tr>
<td class="gsc-input">
<div class="gsc-input-box" id="gsc-iw-id1">
<table cellspacing="0" cellpadding="0" role="presentation" id="gs_id50" class="gstl_50 gsc-input" style="width: 100%; padding: 0px;">
<tbody>
<tr>
<td id="gs_tti50" class="gsib_a"><input autocomplete="off" type="text" size="10" class="gsc-input" name="search" title="search" aria-label="search" id="gsc-i-id1" dir="ltr" spellcheck="false"
style="width: 100%; padding: 0px; border: none; margin: 0px; height: auto; background: url("https://www.google.com/cse/static/images/1x/en/branding.png") left center no-repeat rgb(255, 255, 255); outline: none;"></td>
<td class="gsib_b">
<div class="gsst_b" id="gs_st50" dir="ltr"><a class="gsst_a" href="javascript:void(0)" title="Clear search box" role="button" style="display: none;"><span class="gscb_a" id="gs_cb50" aria-hidden="true">×</span></a></div>
</td>
</tr>
</tbody>
</table>
</div>
</td>
<td class="gsc-search-button"><button class="gsc-search-button gsc-search-button-v2"><svg width="13" height="13" viewBox="0 0 13 13">
<title>search</title>
<path
d="m4.8495 7.8226c0.82666 0 1.5262-0.29146 2.0985-0.87438 0.57232-0.58292 0.86378-1.2877 0.87438-2.1144 0.010599-0.82666-0.28086-1.5262-0.87438-2.0985-0.59352-0.57232-1.293-0.86378-2.0985-0.87438-0.8055-0.010599-1.5103 0.28086-2.1144 0.87438-0.60414 0.59352-0.8956 1.293-0.87438 2.0985 0.021197 0.8055 0.31266 1.5103 0.87438 2.1144 0.56172 0.60414 1.2665 0.8956 2.1144 0.87438zm4.4695 0.2115 3.681 3.6819-1.259 1.284-3.6817-3.7 0.0019784-0.69479-0.090043-0.098846c-0.87973 0.76087-1.92 1.1413-3.1207 1.1413-1.3553 0-2.5025-0.46363-3.4417-1.3909s-1.4088-2.0686-1.4088-3.4239c0-1.3553 0.4696-2.4966 1.4088-3.4239 0.9392-0.92727 2.0864-1.3969 3.4417-1.4088 1.3553-0.011889 2.4906 0.45771 3.406 1.4088 0.9154 0.95107 1.379 2.0924 1.3909 3.4239 0 1.2126-0.38043 2.2588-1.1413 3.1385l0.098834 0.090049z">
</path>
</svg></button></td>
<td class="gsc-clear-button">
<div class="gsc-clear-button" title="clear results"> </div>
</td>
</tr>
</tbody>
</table>
</form>
POST
<form id="reg-lite-form" class="reg-form i-amphtml-form" target="_top" method="post" action-xhr="/internal-api/newsletter-component/submit/lite" verify-xhr="/internal-api/newsletter-component/verify" custom-validation-reporting="interact-and-submit"
on="valid:AMP.setState({liteRegValid: true});invalid:AMP.setState({liteRegValid: false});submit-success:AMP.setState({ success: true })" novalidate="">
<div [hidden]="success">
<div class="sc-mwbru6-1 iAuvyH"><input class="newsletter-key" name="newsletters" type="hidden" readonly="" value="receiveIndyBreakingNews"><input name="regSourceNewsletter" type="hidden" readonly="" value="IND_Breaking_Newsletter"><input
name="regSourceSection" type="hidden" readonly="" value="Tech"><input name="regSourceMethod" type="hidden" readonly="" value="Article%2BSignpost">
<div class="sc-lqqm6o-0 dFOSsy"><input type="text" id="reg-lite--form-email" name="_" class="not-logged-input is-pristine is-untouched"
pattern="^(?=(.{1,64}@.{1,255}))([!#$%&amp;'*+\-\/=?\^_`{|}~a-zA-Z0-9}]{1,64}(\.[!#$%&amp;'*+\-\/=?\^_`{|}~a-zA-Z0-9]{0,}){0,})@((\[(25[0-5]|2[0-4][0-9]|[01]?[0-9][0-9]?)(\.(25[0-5]|2[0-4][0-9]|[01]?[0-9][0-9]?)){3}\])|([a-zA-Z0-9-]{1,63}(\.[a-zA-Z0-9-]{2,63}){1,}))$"
required="" aria-controls="reg-lite--form-email-helper-text" aria-describedby="reg-lite--form-email-helper-text" placeholder="Email" value=""><label for="reg-lite--form-email"></label>
<div class="error-text" visible-when-invalid="valueMissing" validation-for="reg-lite--form-email">Please enter a valid email address</div>
<div class="error-text" visible-when-invalid="patternMismatch" validation-for="reg-lite--form-email">Please enter a valid email address</div>
<div class="error-text" visible-when-invalid="customError" validation-for="reg-lite--form-email"></div>
</div>
<div class="sc-hav996-0 jMewHy sc-hav996-3 sc-mwbru6-2 iiKWbw cwDwew signup-btn lite-registration-submit form-submit"><button class="sc-hav996-2 eHaSMs form-submit" name="submitBtn" type="submit" disabled="" [disabled]="!liteRegValid"><span
class="btn-text">SIGN UP</span><span class="sc-hav996-1 ctQBbf btn-loader"></span></button></div>
</div>
<div class="sc-76suco-1 gcsYYJ newsletter__checkbox sc-mwbru6-3 kYLOIy" data-nosnippet=""><input type="checkbox" id="newsletter-checkbox" name="newsletters" value="receiveIndyOffers"><label for="newsletter-checkbox"
class="sc-76suco-0 OxRKM checkmark">I would like to be emailed about offers, events and updates from The Independent. Read our <a target="_blank" rel="noreferrer" href="/service/privacy-policy-a6184181.html">privacy notice</a></label>
</div>
</div><input type="hidden" name="^" data-action="signUpNewsletters">
<div submit-success="true"><template type="amp-mustache">
<div class="sc-z5n1ia-0 iHRfbq">
<h2 data-nosnippet="" class="sc-z5n1ia-1 dnHnev">Thanks for signing up to the<br> <!-- -->Breaking News<!-- --> email</h2>
</div>
</template></div>
<div submit-error="true" data-nosnippet=""><template type="amp-mustache">
<div class="sc-1sk658j-0 dVQBYa">{{ #verifyErrors }}<!-- -->{{ message }}<!-- -->{{ /verifyErrors }}<!-- -->{{ ^verifyErrors }}<!-- -->Something went wrong. Please try again later<!-- -->{{ /verifyErrors }}</div>
</template></div>
</form>
<form class="gsc-search-box gsc-search-box-tools" accept-charset="utf-8">
<table cellspacing="0" cellpadding="0" role="presentation" class="gsc-search-box">
<tbody>
<tr>
<td class="gsc-input">
<div class="gsc-input-box" id="gsc-iw-id2">
<table cellspacing="0" cellpadding="0" role="presentation" id="gs_id51" class="gstl_51 gsc-input" style="width: 100%; padding: 0px;">
<tbody>
<tr>
<td id="gs_tti51" class="gsib_a"><input autocomplete="off" type="text" size="10" class="gsc-input" name="search" title="search" aria-label="search" id="gsc-i-id2" dir="ltr" spellcheck="false"
style="width: 100%; padding: 0px; border: none; margin: 0px; height: auto; background: url("https://www.google.com/cse/static/images/1x/en/branding.png") left center no-repeat rgb(255, 255, 255); outline: none;"></td>
<td class="gsib_b">
<div class="gsst_b" id="gs_st51" dir="ltr"><a class="gsst_a" href="javascript:void(0)" title="Clear search box" role="button" style="display: none;"><span class="gscb_a" id="gs_cb51" aria-hidden="true">×</span></a></div>
</td>
</tr>
</tbody>
</table>
</div>
</td>
<td class="gsc-search-button"><button class="gsc-search-button gsc-search-button-v2"><svg width="13" height="13" viewBox="0 0 13 13">
<title>search</title>
<path
d="m4.8495 7.8226c0.82666 0 1.5262-0.29146 2.0985-0.87438 0.57232-0.58292 0.86378-1.2877 0.87438-2.1144 0.010599-0.82666-0.28086-1.5262-0.87438-2.0985-0.59352-0.57232-1.293-0.86378-2.0985-0.87438-0.8055-0.010599-1.5103 0.28086-2.1144 0.87438-0.60414 0.59352-0.8956 1.293-0.87438 2.0985 0.021197 0.8055 0.31266 1.5103 0.87438 2.1144 0.56172 0.60414 1.2665 0.8956 2.1144 0.87438zm4.4695 0.2115 3.681 3.6819-1.259 1.284-3.6817-3.7 0.0019784-0.69479-0.090043-0.098846c-0.87973 0.76087-1.92 1.1413-3.1207 1.1413-1.3553 0-2.5025-0.46363-3.4417-1.3909s-1.4088-2.0686-1.4088-3.4239c0-1.3553 0.4696-2.4966 1.4088-3.4239 0.9392-0.92727 2.0864-1.3969 3.4417-1.4088 1.3553-0.011889 2.4906 0.45771 3.406 1.4088 0.9154 0.95107 1.379 2.0924 1.3909 3.4239 0 1.2126-0.38043 2.2588-1.1413 3.1385l0.098834 0.090049z">
</path>
</svg></button></td>
<td class="gsc-clear-button">
<div class="gsc-clear-button" title="clear results"> </div>
</td>
</tr>
</tbody>
</table>
</form>
POST
<form id="login-form" class="login-form i-amphtml-form" method="post" target="_top" action-xhr="/internal-api/user/login/commenting/submit" verify-xhr="/internal-api/user/login/verify" custom-validation-reporting="interact-and-submit"
on="valid:AMP.setState({loginDisabled: false});invalid:AMP.setState({loginDisabled: true})" novalidate=""><input type="hidden" name="returnUrl" value="/tech/solarwinds-hack-how-russia-us-government-b1776034.html">
<p class="sc-1wvnxd-5 kUUKtZ">Log in</p>
<div class="sc-1wvnxd-13 gymEKt">
<div class="sc-lqqm6o-0 dFOSsy"><input type="text" id="login-form-email" name="-" class="is-pristine is-untouched" required="" aria-controls="login-form-email-helper-text" aria-describedby="login-form-email-helper-text"
placeholder="Enter your email"><label for="login-form-email">Email address</label>
<div class="error-text" visible-when-invalid="customError" validation-for="login-form-email"></div>
</div>
</div>
<div class="sc-1wvnxd-13 gymEKt">
<div class="sc-lqqm6o-0 dFOSsy"><input type="password" id="login-form-password" name="password" class="sc-1wvnxd-8 fZOIWQ input-password js-hideshowpassword is-pristine is-untouched" required="" aria-controls="login-form-password-helper-text"
aria-describedby="login-form-password-helper-text" placeholder="Enter your password"><label for="login-form-password">Password</label>
<div class="error-text" visible-when-invalid="customError" validation-for="login-form-password"></div>
<a style="cursor: pointer; height: 24px; position: absolute; display: inline-block; right: 13px; top: 15px; width: 24px;"><svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" width="24" height="24"><defs><path id="a-0" d="M12 4.5C7 4.5 2.73 7.61 1 12c1.73 4.39 6 7.5 11 7.5s9.27-3.11 11-7.5c-1.73-4.39-6-7.5-11-7.5zM12 17c-2.76 0-5-2.24-5-5s2.24-5 5-5 5 2.24 5 5-2.24 5-5 5zm0-8c-1.66 0-3 1.34-3 3s1.34 3 3 3 3-1.34 3-3-1.34-3-3-3z"></path></defs><use fill="#7A7A7A" xlink:href="#a-0" fill-rule="evenodd"></use></svg></a>
</div>
</div>
<div class="form-errors" submit-error="true">Email and password don't match</div>
<div class="sc-hav996-0 jMewHy sc-hav996-3 sc-1wvnxd-10 iiKWbw kcbJBI"><button class="sc-hav996-2 eHaSMs form-submit" name="submitBtn" type="submit" disabled="" [disabled]="loginDisabled"><span class="btn-text">Submit</span><span
class="sc-hav996-1 ctQBbf btn-loader"></span></button></div>
<div class="sc-1wvnxd-2 hWMQLV"><a href="/forgotten-password" class="sc-1wvnxd-3 gtyiXp">Forgotten your password?</a></div>
<div class="sc-1wvnxd-11 fUpArD"></div>
<p class="sc-1wvnxd-6 bYHOzM">New to The Independent?</p><a id="registerLink" href="/register" class="sc-1wvnxd-9 RTsZS">Register</a>
</form>
<form class="gsc-search-box gsc-search-box-tools" accept-charset="utf-8">
<table cellspacing="0" cellpadding="0" role="presentation" class="gsc-search-box">
<tbody>
<tr>
<td class="gsc-input">
<div class="gsc-input-box" id="gsc-iw-id1">
<table cellspacing="0" cellpadding="0" role="presentation" id="gs_id50" class="gstl_50 gsc-input" style="width: 100%; padding: 0px;">
<tbody>
<tr>
<td id="gs_tti50" class="gsib_a"><input autocomplete="off" type="text" size="10" class="gsc-input" name="search" title="search" aria-label="search" id="gsc-i-id1" dir="ltr" spellcheck="false"
style="width: 100%; padding: 0px; border: none; margin: 0px; height: auto; background: url("https://www.google.com/cse/static/images/1x/en/branding.png") left center no-repeat rgb(255, 255, 255); outline: none;"></td>
<td class="gsib_b">
<div class="gsst_b" id="gs_st50" dir="ltr"><a class="gsst_a" href="javascript:void(0)" title="Clear search box" role="button" style="display: none;"><span class="gscb_a" id="gs_cb50" aria-hidden="true">×</span></a></div>
</td>
</tr>
</tbody>
</table>
</div>
</td>
<td class="gsc-search-button"><button class="gsc-search-button gsc-search-button-v2"><svg width="13" height="13" viewBox="0 0 13 13">
<title>search</title>
<path
d="m4.8495 7.8226c0.82666 0 1.5262-0.29146 2.0985-0.87438 0.57232-0.58292 0.86378-1.2877 0.87438-2.1144 0.010599-0.82666-0.28086-1.5262-0.87438-2.0985-0.59352-0.57232-1.293-0.86378-2.0985-0.87438-0.8055-0.010599-1.5103 0.28086-2.1144 0.87438-0.60414 0.59352-0.8956 1.293-0.87438 2.0985 0.021197 0.8055 0.31266 1.5103 0.87438 2.1144 0.56172 0.60414 1.2665 0.8956 2.1144 0.87438zm4.4695 0.2115 3.681 3.6819-1.259 1.284-3.6817-3.7 0.0019784-0.69479-0.090043-0.098846c-0.87973 0.76087-1.92 1.1413-3.1207 1.1413-1.3553 0-2.5025-0.46363-3.4417-1.3909s-1.4088-2.0686-1.4088-3.4239c0-1.3553 0.4696-2.4966 1.4088-3.4239 0.9392-0.92727 2.0864-1.3969 3.4417-1.4088 1.3553-0.011889 2.4906 0.45771 3.406 1.4088 0.9154 0.95107 1.379 2.0924 1.3909 3.4239 0 1.2126-0.38043 2.2588-1.1413 3.1385l0.098834 0.090049z">
</path>
</svg></button></td>
<td class="gsc-clear-button">
<div class="gsc-clear-button" title="clear results"> </div>
</td>
</tr>
</tbody>
</table>
</form>
Text Content
Jump to content UK EDITIONCHANGE US EditionAsia EditionEdición en Español Sign up to our newslettersSubscribe {{indy.truncatedName}} Log in / Register The CoronationBuxton Rise Up SubscribeMenu × search Custom Search Sort by: Relevance Relevance Date * NewsNews * News * UK * US * World * UK Politics * Brexit * Health * Business * Science * Space * News Videos * SportSport * Sport * Football * Formula 1 * Rugby Union * Cricket * Tennis * Boxing * UFC * Cycling * Golf * Sport Videos * VoicesVoices * Voices * Editorials * Letters * Tom Peck * John Rentoul * Mary Dejevsky * Andrew Grice * Marie Le Conte * Sean O’Grady * CultureCulture * Culture * Film * TV & Radio * Music * Games * Books * Art * Photography * Theatre & Dance * Culture Videos * LifestyleLifestyle * Lifestyle * Shopping * Tech * Money * Food & Drink * Fashion * Love & Sex * Women * Health & Families * Royal Family * Motoring * Electric Vehicles * Lifestyle Videos * TravelTravel * Travel * UK Hotel Reviews * News & Advice * Simon Calder * UK * Europe * North America * Asia * Inspiration * City Guides * Sustainable Travel * PremiumPremium * Premium * Editorials * Voices * Long Reads * Politics Explained * News Analysis * Today’s Edition More More Best * Advisor * Home & Garden * Tech * Fashion & Beauty * Food & Drink * Kids * Books * Travel & Outdoors * Sports & Fitness * Deals Climate * News * Voices * Sustainable Living * Explained * Climate Videos * Electric Vehicles * SGI TV * Behind The Headlines * On The Ground * Decomplicated * You Ask The Questions * Binge Or Bin * Millennial Love * Watch on your TV * Today’s Edition * Crosswords & Puzzles * Most Commented * Newsletters * Ask Me Anything * Virtual Events * Courses * Vouchers * Compare * Indy100 THANK YOU FOR REGISTERING Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in Tech SOLARWINDS HACK: HOW SUNBURST HACKERS INFILTRATED HIGHEST LEVELS OF US GOVERNMENT CYBER ATTACK WENT UNDETECTED FOR MONTHS, MEANING IT MAY HAVE SINCE MORPHED INTO FAR MORE INSIDIOUS MALWARE STILL LURKING ON VICTIMS’ COMPUTERS Anthony Cuthbertson Friday 18 December 2020 14:27 Comments ARTICLE BOOKMARKED Find your bookmarks in your Independent Premium section, under my profile Don't show me this message again ✕ Software from SolarWinds compromised around 18,000 organisations (Getty Images) FOR FREE REAL TIME BREAKING NEWS ALERTS SENT STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX SIGN UP TO OUR BREAKING NEWS EMAILS SIGN UP TO OUR FREE BREAKING NEWS EMAILS Please enter a valid email address Please enter a valid email address SIGN UP I would like to be emailed about offers, events and updates from The Independent. Read our privacy notice THANKS FOR SIGNING UP TO THE BREAKING NEWS EMAIL {{ #verifyErrors }}{{ message }}{{ /verifyErrors }}{{ ^verifyErrors }}Something went wrong. Please try again later{{ /verifyErrors }} The largest hack of a Western government in recent memory appears to have stemmed from an innocuous-looking pop-up message. In March, IT staff at up to 18,000 companies and organisations using SolarWinds software clicked on a link to download the latest version of a product called Orion. SolarWinds makes technology that allows organisations – including US federal agencies and some of the world’s biggest companies – to manage their computer systems and networks, and so updated of this kind arrive regularly. What neither SolarWinds nor the IT workers knew was that the new version of the software was laced with a malicious form of malware that would grant hackers “God-view” access to any infected networks. So how did hackers manage to infiltrate the highest levels of the US government and go unnoticed for so long? The hack, known as Sunburst, may have happened in the spring but the groundwork for the attack most likely began much earlier. In order to booby-trap the pop-up, the hackers first needed to gain access to SolarWinds’ computer systems. Once inside the US firm, the hackers were able to secretly insert the malware into a standard security update, which would have looked identical to numerous other updates issued by the popular IT management software. RECOMMENDED * ‘Quantum apocalypse’: How super computers could cripple governments SolarWinds counts all five branches of the US military, the Pentagon, the State Department and the Office of the President of the United States among its 300,000 global customers. All were advised to update their software immediately in order to address the security vulnerability, though for many it will already be too late. Treasury Department Hacked (Copyright 2019 The Associated Press. All rights reserved.) In a security advisory published this week, SolarWinds described it as a “very sophisticated” attack that “could potentially allow an attacker to compromise the server” of the victims, meaning sensitive information would have already been exposed. Not only that, the fact the hackers had a nine month headstart before being discovered means they could have already developed new and much harder to detect methods of lurking within victims’ computer systems. As such, uncovering the malware and issuing an update is just the beginning of the process of routing out any malignant actors still probing the networks. It is not yet known, at least not publicly, whether any state secrets of highly classified information was breached, though US senators have called for a full list of any federal agency impacted by the attack. It is expected to take months to uncover the full extent of the attack, with forensic investigations aiming to figure out which emails, files and other data were accessed, and whether they were copied or transmitted to other systems. WHO WAS BEHIND THE SOLARWINDS HACK? The sophisticated nature of the hack points to a nation state, with US adversaries in the cyber domain most commonly being China, Iran, North Korea and Russia. “We’ve been advised that the nature of this attack indicates that it may have been conducted by an outside nation state, but SolarWinds has not verified the identity of the attacker,” SolarWinds explained in its advisory. Some security experts believe it has the hallmarks of a Russian hacking collective known as Cosy Bear, which has links to Russia’s Foreign Intelligence Service SVR. Former Homeland Security adviser Thomas Bossert said that “evidence in the SolarWinds attack points to the Russian intelligence agency known as the SVR, whose tradecraft is among the most advanced in the world.” Cyber security firm FireEye, which was the first to report the hack after falling victim to it, also said it was likely a Russian operation, using “top-tier operations tradecraft and resources”, though Russia has denied any involvement. “I reject these statements, these accusations,” said Vladimir Putin’s press secretary Dmitry Peskov. “Even if it is true there have been some attacks over many months and the Americans managed to do nothing about them, possibly it is wrong to groundlessly blame Russians right away. We have nothing to do with this.” MORE ABOUT hack JOIN OUR COMMENTING FORUM Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies Comments 1/2HOW SOLARWINDS HACKERS INFILTRATED HIGHEST LEVELS OF US GOVERNMENT HOW SOLARWINDS HACKERS INFILTRATED HIGHEST LEVELS OF US GOVERNMENT Treasury Department Hacked Copyright 2019 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. HOW SOLARWINDS HACKERS INFILTRATED HIGHEST LEVELS OF US GOVERNMENT Software from SolarWinds compromised around 18,000 organisations Getty Images Promoted stories Tips and Tricks Everyone laughed at him when he married her, 6 years later she shows her metamorphosis Tips and Tricks| SponsoredSponsored Undo Healthbay Buzzing In Ears? Do This ImmediatelyHealthbay| SponsoredSponsored Undo Her Life & Health Breakthrough "Skinny Pill" Takes Canada By StormHer Life & Health| SponsoredSponsored Undo ✕ SUBSCRIBE TO INDEPENDENT PREMIUM TO BOOKMARK THIS ARTICLE Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? Start your Independent Premium subscription today. Subscribe Already subscribed? Log in MOST POPULAR Stephen Stills: ‘David Crosby got out of here just in time’ Putin ‘punishes drunk soldiers by putting them in holes in the ground’ ‘Dead ends’ in manhunt for Texas gunman who killed five neighbors Russian troops suffer sickness after digging and fishing in Chernobyl Girl, 16, took own life at school after ‘hyper-fixating on detention’ POPULAR VIDEOS Tucker Carlson speaks after leaving Fox News in conspiracy-laced video The Body in the Woods | An Independent TV Original Documentary Armed Forces rehearse King Charles III’s coronation procession Kim Kardashian lookalike Christina Ashten Gourkani dies after botched “medical procedure" 'World's most expensive' eye cream company launches product that promises to fix eyes in 5 minutes How to do the 'eye color chart' TikTok trend 6 times everyone was totally fooled by AI in 2023 Every single person in Europe is a descendant of one man Sponsored LinksSponsored Links Promoted LinksPromoted Links Promoted stories ActiveBeat Montreal: Senior Living For $1000/MonthActiveBeatLearn More Undo Bleacher Breaker Movie Costume Mistakes Most Fans Never NoticedBleacher Breaker Undo PDFwonder 25 Most Unforgettable Swimsuit Moments In Film HistoryPDFwonder Undo Finance Wealth Post Gwen Stefani, 53, Takes Off Makeup, Leaves Us With No WordsFinance Wealth Post Undo Electric Cars | Search Ads Completely new small electric car for seniors - the price might surprise youElectric Cars | Search AdsSearch Now Undo Sizzlfy Police called after man buys storage unit with $7.5MSizzlfy Undo by Taboolaby Taboola SPONSORED FEATURES Seasalt Cornwall’s SS23 collection is blooming with perfect pieces for special occasions Find your perfect summer getaway from TUI: holiday deals from Turkey to Florida Abel & Cole is the sustainable and convenient online grocer to know Got a question? JustAnswer has the answer for every situation Upgrade to Dermatica’s affordable personalised skincare for your best skin yet SPONSORED FEATURES Russian troops suffer sickness after digging and fishing in Chernobyl Putin ‘punishes drunk soldiers by putting them in holes in the ground’ ‘Dead ends’ in manhunt for Texas gunman who killed five neighbors Girl, 16, took own life at school after ‘hyper-fixating on detention’ MTG claims lack of taxes during ice age proves climate change is fake Indy / Compare Compare UK Broadband DealsCompare broadband packages side by side to find the best deal for you Cheap Broadband Deals in 2023Compare cheap broadband deals from providers with fastest speed in your area Fibre Broadband Deals April 2023All you need to know about fibre broadband Best Apple iPhone Deals in the UK April 2023Compare iPhone contract deals and get the best offer this April Compare Mobile Phone DealsCompare the best mobile phone deals from the top networks and brands * Get in touch * Contact us * * Our Products * Subscribe * Register * Newsletters * Today’s Edition * Install our app * Archive * Other publications * International editions * Independent en Español * Independent Arabia * Independent Turkish * Independent Persian * Independent Urdu * Evening Standard * Novaya Gazeta * Extras * Advisor * Puzzles * All topics * Voucher codes * Compare * Independent Advertising * Syndication * Working at The Independent * Legal * Code of conduct and complaints * Contributors * Cookie policy * Privacy notice * User policies * Modern Slavery Act THANK YOU FOR REGISTERING Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in Close UK EDITIONCHANGE US EditionAsia EditionEdición en Español Subscribe {{indy.truncatedName}} Log in / Register × search Custom Search Sort by: Relevance Relevance Date The CoronationBuxton Rise Up {{#items}} {{#STAMPSMALL}}{{/STAMPSMALL}}{{#STAMPCLIMATE}}{{/STAMPCLIMATE}}{{#STAMPPREMIUM}}{{/STAMPPREMIUM}}{{TITLE}}{{#DESC}}{{DESC}}{{/DESC}} {{#children}} * {{title}} {{/children}} {{/items}} * Today’s Edition * Crosswords & Puzzles * Most Commented * Newsletters * Ask Me Anything * Virtual Events * Courses * Vouchers * Compare * Indy100 Close the sidebar ✕ Log in Email address Password Email and password don't match Submit Forgotten your password? New to The Independent? Register Or if you would prefer: SIGN IN WITH GOOGLE Want an ad-free experience? View offers This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy notice and Terms of service apply. Hi {{indy.fullName}} * My Independent Premium * Account details * Help centre * Logout Close the sidebar Jump to content UK EDITIONCHANGE US EditionAsia EditionEdición en Español Sign up to our newslettersSubscribe {{indy.truncatedName}} Log in / Register The CoronationBuxton Rise Up SubscribeMenu × search Custom Search Sort by: Relevance Relevance Date * NewsNews * News * UK * US * World * UK Politics * Brexit * Health * Business * Science * Space * News Videos * SportSport * Sport * Football * Formula 1 * Rugby Union * Cricket * Tennis * Boxing * UFC * Cycling * Golf * Sport Videos * VoicesVoices * Voices * Editorials * Letters * Tom Peck * John Rentoul * Mary Dejevsky * Andrew Grice * Marie Le Conte * Sean O’Grady * CultureCulture * Culture * Film * TV & Radio * Music * Games * Books * Art * Photography * Theatre & Dance * Culture Videos * LifestyleLifestyle * Lifestyle * Shopping * Tech * Money * Food & Drink * Fashion * Love & Sex * Women * Health & Families * Royal Family * Motoring * Electric Vehicles * Lifestyle Videos * TravelTravel * Travel * UK Hotel Reviews * News & Advice * Simon Calder * UK * Europe * North America * Asia * Inspiration * City Guides * Sustainable Travel * PremiumPremium * Premium * Editorials * Voices * Long Reads * Politics Explained * News Analysis * Today’s Edition More More Best * Advisor * Home & Garden * Tech * Fashion & Beauty * Food & Drink * Kids * Books * Travel & Outdoors * Sports & Fitness * Deals Climate * News * Voices * Sustainable Living * Explained * Climate Videos * Electric Vehicles * SGI TV * Behind The Headlines * On The Ground * Decomplicated * You Ask The Questions * Binge Or Bin * Millennial Love * Watch on your TV * Today’s Edition * Crosswords & Puzzles * Most Commented * Newsletters * Ask Me Anything * Virtual Events * Courses * Vouchers * Compare * Indy100 THANK YOU FOR REGISTERING Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in More stories to check out before you go Keep on reading Strange Russian spacecraft seems to be stalking US military satelliteUS satellite appears to have made its first jump to a higher orbit away from Russian spacecraftThe Independent Group 3 Undo Police hunt after woman sexually assaults man at train stationOfficers appeal for informationThe Independent Group 3 Undo What are the ‘dragon’s teeth’ defences being erected by Russia in Ukraine?Concrete anti-tank barricades constructed in anticipation of major counteroffensive by Kyiv’s forcesThe Independent Group 3 Undo Putin ‘orders drunk Russian soldiers to be kept in holes in the ground as punishment’Ukraine-Russia war: latest news and live updatesThe Independent Group 3 Undo ' ' ' ' ' ' The real reason James Corden is leaving The Late Late ShowIs James Corden leaving LA?The Independent Undo MTG claims the lack of tax raises during ice age proves climate change is a hoaxMs Greene has faced backlash recently for making offensive comments during congressional hearingsThe Independent Undo Tucker Carlson’s sexist comments about fans emerge as Fox News ratings plunge – liveTucker Carlson fired from Fox News: the latest news, reaction and live updatesThe Independent Undo ‘Traitor’ Ukraine police chief who defected to Russia killed in explosionMelitopol mayor calls slain police officer ‘traitor’ who defected to Russia after invasionThe Independent Undo Tips and Tricks Everyone laughed at him when he married her, 6 years later she shows her metamorphosis Tips and Tricks| SponsoredSponsored Undo Healthbay Buzzing In Ears? Do This ImmediatelyHealthbay| SponsoredSponsored Undo