www.fastcompany.com Open in urlscan Pro
151.101.1.54  Public Scan

Form analysis
0 forms found in the DOM

Text Content

FAST COMPANY

Follow
 * 
 * 
 * 
 * 
 * 

Login
 * Co.Design
 * Tech
 * Work Life
 * News
 * Impact
 * Podcasts
 * Video
 * Innovation Festival 360IF360
 * Subscribe
 * 
 * FastCo Works
    * AWS
    * Genpact
    * IBM


 * HOMEPAGE


 * CO.DESIGN


 * TECH


 * WORK LIFE


 * NEWS


 * IMPACT


 * PODCASTS


 * VIDEO


 * INNOVATION FESTIVAL 360


 * SUBSCRIBE

Help Center
fastco works


 * AWS


 * DELOITTE


 * DEPT


 * ELEVATE PRIZE


 * EY


 * IBM


 * KLARNA


 * VISA


 * FASTCO WORKS
   
   An award-winning team of journalists, designers, and videographers who tell
   brand stories through Fast Company's distinctive lens

FC Executive Board
collections


 * FAST GOVERNMENT
   
   The future of innovation and technology in government for the greater good


 * MOST INNOVATIVE COMPANIES
   
   Fast Company's annual ranking of businesses that are making an outsize impact


 * MOST CREATIVE PEOPLE
   
   Leaders who are shaping the future of business in creative ways


 * WORLD CHANGING IDEAS
   
   New workplaces, new food sources, new medicine--even an entirely new economic
   system


 * INNOVATION BY DESIGN
   
   Celebrating the best ideas in business

Newsletter
Events


 * INNOVATION FESTIVAL

Courses and LearningAdvertiseCurrent Issue
SUBSCRIBE
Follow us:

advertisement

 * 10-07-22


‘TEAR THE PAPER CEILING’: A NEW CAMPAIGN WANTS COMPANIES TO DITCH 4-YEAR DEGREE
REQUIREMENTS


JOB APPLICANTS WITHOUT A COLLEGE DEGREE HAVE A MUCH HARDER TIME GETTING
HIRED—PARTICULARLY IN JOBS WITH UPWARD MOBILITY. OPPORTUNITY@WORK IS TRYING TO
CHANGE THAT.

[Photo: Getty]
 * 
 * 
 * 
 * 

More Like This
Denver spent $4.1 million to get more people on e-bikes. It worked
Everybody poops, but not everybody’s poop gets spontaneously combusted under
water
For decades, these power plants ran on coal. Now, they’re converting to clean
energy
By Talib Visram5 minute Read

Justin Hutchinson was working at a smoothie shop in his native Baton Rouge,
trying to save money for his tuition to Louisiana State University, which he was
struggling to pay after the death of his father. Hutchinson was a popular
employee: He’d memorize customers’ orders and even their cars so he could start
blending their smoothies as they pulled up. One regular, a marketing CEO,
recognized his “people skills,” and offered him an internship at his marketing
agency, ThreeSixtyEight. On that new path, Hutchinson made the tough decision to
leave school to avoid continuing to rack up debt, still nervous it could impact
his career. But five years later, Hutchinson is now the agency’s business
development director.




While deserved, Hutchinson’s success story is relatively rare for people without
a four-year college degree. Opportunities have long been slimmer for job seekers
without degrees, but companies are increasing the practice of screening them
out. That means groups that have been a valuable part of the workforce for
decades now see their prospects shrinking even further. A new PSA campaign aims
to create a cultural shift, demonstrating to employers that a lack of a
bachelor’s degree doesn’t mean applicants aren’t qualified; that these
individuals can be trained through other routes and that it makes business sense
to hire them. The efforts are already seeing traction: 15 companies have signed
on to make a commitment to ease pathways for candidates without a four-year
degree.

Individuals “skilled through alternative routes,” dubbed STARs, are those 25
years and older in the labor force without a bachelor’s degree, but who instead 
have an associate’s degree, some community college courses, on-the-job training,
certificate programs, or military service. The term was coined in 2019 by the
organization Opportunity@Work to “emphasize their skills and pivot away from
pedigree and credentials,” says Will Villota, vice president of marketing and
communications. It’s not a negligible number: there are 70 million STARs, the
group says, who account for half the U.S. workforce. 

Despite these workers’ alternative qualifications, in the past 40 years there
has been a drop in their workforce participation because employers have been
increasingly less eager to hire workers without degrees, in what the Harvard
Business Review called “degree inflation.” Starting in the 1980s, increasing
globalization and automation sent more jobs abroad and replaced middle-skill
workers with machines, reducing the number of  jobs available for manual and
routine office work. Employers became pickier for the positions left, and the
Great Recession further thinned opportunities, compounding the problem.

advertisement



According to an Opportunity@Work report, in 2000, STARs held 54% of jobs with
chances for upward mobility; now, that number is 46%. They filled only 1.8
million of 17.2 million jobs of this caliber that have been added to the market
in the past two decades. Most recently, the rise of digital applications and
algorithms can automatically eliminate applicants without four-year degrees as a
way to shrink short lists, Villota says. The organization has identified 30
industries with the most displaced workers due to increased degree requirements,
including registered nurses and computer programmers, fields also experiencing
worker shortages.



To fight those generalizations, the Ad Council created a PSA campaign with
Opportunity@Work and Ogilvy to show the capacity to excel that these workers
have. The campaign, which will be promoted across all platforms, centers around
“tearing the paper ceiling” (in which the paper represents a degree). The phrase
“gives us a vocabulary where we can really talk about the inequities that are
holding back so many people in the workforce,” says Michelle Hillman, the Ad
Council’s chief campaign development officer. “We’re trying to change the
narrative around the workforce.”

Even when they’re hired, these employees earn significantly less than their
college-educated counterparts, taking 30 years to earn the same salary as a
graduate right out of college. “As a society, we’re equating 30 years of work
experience with four years of college,” Villota says, “and that just doesn’t
pass the smell test.” Today, they’re also earning less on average than they did
in 1976.



The problem particularly affects certain demographic group: 61% of Black workers
are STARs, as are 55% of Latinos, 61% of veterans, and 66% of rural residents.
“Suddenly, you realize that’s half the workforce,” Villota says. They become a
massive talent pool as businesses seek to fill roles, particularly, he adds, as
a strategy for meeting company diversity goals. The campaign calls for employers
to simply remove any degree requirements where possible, and to identify these
employees already in the organization and provide them with a path forward.
“What a crime it is if you’ve already got STARs, and you don’t give them a
pathway to mobility,” Villota says. “They end up having to find that elsewhere.”

Various companies are already championing the campaign. Some have their own
in-house training, like Accenture’s Apprenticeship Program and IBM’s free
SkillsBuild program; IBM also has pledged to remove the four-year degree
requirement for half of their U.S. job listings. Businesses could probably
afford to eliminate requirements for even more jobs, Villota says. “But it does
mean that they’re committed to raising awareness of this issue.”

Google is also supporting the campaign, chiefly through Google Career
Certificate, an online program started in 2018 that trains individuals in five
different digital-job areas, including UX, data analytics, and e-commerce. These
were chosen because they’re high paying, high growth, and high demand, says Lisa
Gevelber, founder and head of Grow with Google, the company’s $1 billion
commitment to create more equitable economic opportunity, currently featuring
1.5 million available jobs. “Lots of companies just can’t even find the talent
they need that’s trained up for these jobs,” she says. The program, which has
graduated 300,000 people, is available on Coursera for $39 a month; Gevelber
says most people complete it in three to six months.



These certificates can set people up for jobs at Google (although Gevelber says
the company doesn’t require degrees for most of their positions), and they’re
also recognized by 150 other companies. For instance, Deloitte added some
elements to the data analytics course to include mastery of SQL and R, two
programming languages that the company requires of candidates. “We built it
right into the certificate,” Gevelber says. “And now, we’re a preferred hiring
credential for Deloitte.”

The campaign’s focus on employers is an effort to relieve the burden on workers
to advocate forcefully for themselves, considering the bulk of power is in
employers’ hands. And there are success stories: According to Opportunity@Work,
about 4 million of the 70 million have torn through the paper ceiling, landing
themselves in high-wage jobs. But those opportunities are still relatively
infrequent and, as in Hutchinson’s case, involve some luck. “If we can start
screening in STARs rather than screening them out,” Villota says, “it’ll shift
from happenstance to more intentional and more normative practices.”




Recommended for you


IOS 16 RELEASE TIME: HERE’S WHEN YOU CAN DOWNLOAD THE IPHONE’S NEW OPERATING
SYSTEM WORLDWIDE TODAY


THIS INDIAN HEALTH CLINIC WAS DESIGNED USING AI


3 STRATEGIES ANY LEADER CAN USE TO SPOT AND MOVE PAST GROUPTHINK

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

@talibvisram

More

advertisement



FEATURED VIDEO

Ocean spray asks are you a jiggler or a wiggler?
We’re a little more than a month away from that most glorious of gastronomic
holidays, Thanksgiving, and Ocean Spray decided to remind you that a lil’ jiggly
canned cranberry is way better than having to stir a hot pot of homemade fruit
jelly for meat. This is Fast Company’s Brand Hit or Miss of the Week.
More Videos


0 seconds of 3 minutes, 10 secondsVolume 0%

Press shift question mark to access a list of keyboard shortcuts
Keyboard ShortcutsEnabledDisabled
Play/PauseSPACE
Increase Volume↑
Decrease Volume↓
Seek Forward→
Seek Backward←
Captions On/Offc
Fullscreen/Exit Fullscreenf
Mute/Unmutem
Seek %0-9
Next Up
How Brian Chesky put the breakfast in Airbnb
02:41
Settings
OffBrand Hit And Miss 102122 Igtv V1 Aq
Font Color
White

Font Opacity
100%

Font Size
100%

Font Family
Arial

Character Edge
None

Background Color
Black

Background Opacity
50%

Window Color
Black

Window Opacity
0%

Reset
WhiteBlackRedGreenBlueYellowMagentaCyan
100%75%50%25%
200%175%150%125%100%75%50%
ArialCourierGeorgiaImpactLucida ConsoleTahomaTimes New RomanTrebuchet MSVerdana
NoneRaisedDepressedUniformDrop Shadow
WhiteBlackRedGreenBlueYellowMagentaCyan
100%75%50%25%0%
WhiteBlackRedGreenBlueYellowMagentaCyan
100%75%50%25%0%
facebook twitter Email
Linkhttps://www.fastcompany.com/video/ocean-spray-asks-are-you-a-jiggler-or-a-wiggler/G9X3sOC5
Copied
Auto180p1080p720p406p270p180p
Live
00:00
03:10
03:10








 


OCEAN SPRAY ASKS ARE YOU A JIGGLER OR A WIGGLER?

advertisement


Today's Top Stories:
01

co-design
Exclusive: YouTube’s new redesign is built to feel more like TV
02

news
These 6 brands are growing by letting fans pursue their passions
03

co-design
Why designers keep trying to kill the logo
04

technology
Unity CEO John Riccitiello describes the realities—and distractions—of the
metaverse
05

co-design
Mark Zuckerberg might have already doomed his metaverse, but Neal Stephenson’s
vision is very much alive
More Top Stories:
PLAY Fast Company Top Articles: Video Settings Full Screen About Connatix
V193450 Read More Read More Read More Read More Read More Read More
Uber releases new driver safety features, including video recording test
READ MORE
Uber releases new driver safety features, including video recording test 1/1
Skip Ad Continue watching after the ad Visit Advertiser websiteGO TO PAGE




advertisement

news
Jared Leto breaks into the beauty business
leadership
How To End The “Office Housework” Gender Bias
co-design
Why can’t Adidas quit Yeezy?
technology
The 3 education brands taking clever approaches to shaping minds of all ages
technology
How a stealth startup’s $100 genome could change how we treat and diagnose
diseases like cancer
leadership
These are the top 10 most passive-aggressive phrases you’re probably using in
email
leadership
This startup wants to reimagine egg donation
leadership
Why quitting on time is key to winning at work
magazine
Bored Ape Yacht Club tell all: The untold story of the $4 billion crypto startup
ideas
Automakers like Audi claim this new technology will keep bikers safe. It won’t
ideas
These 18 brands grew business with their communities—and the environment—in mind
technology
Meet the 13 brands elevating everyday tasks, from washing dishes to banking
technology
How these brands have built advocacy into their businesses
co-design
How automakers insidiously shaped our cities for cars
co-design
Watch How The U.S. Stole Land From Native Americans
advertisement

advertisement

co-design
The North Face is straddling a crevasse in branding, with a belay from Jimmy
Chin
news
The dramatic rise in employer ghosting is—we’ll just say it—scary
technology
This simple system will streamline your jumble of apps, tabs, and email to boost
productivity
news
6 trends shaping the global supply chain in 2023
co-design
Inside the fascinating world of “ham radio” QSL cards
co-design
Apple is losing its industrial design boss . . . again
news
The airline pilot shortage is dire. Here’s what major carriers are doing to fill
cockpits
ideas
These 19 brands are helping people sharpen their minds, look good, and improve
their health
co-design
UX design is more successful than ever, but its leaders are losing hope. Here’s
why
technology
Netflix profile transfer: Did you get the email? Here’s what to understand about
the controversial feature
technology
iPadOS 16, macOS Ventura release time: Here’s when you can download the new
operating systems worldwide today
technology
4 Google tricks to take your searches to the next level
technology
5 tips to give a second life to your old laptop
ideas
Protected bike lanes can help cities cut emissions. Bogota’s $130 million
investment proves it
advertisement



TECH

Presented By capital one


WHY HUMAN-CENTERED DESIGN IS SO IMPORTANT IN A POST-PANDEMIC WORLD

Tech


UBER RELEASES NEW DRIVER SAFETY FEATURES, INCLUDING VIDEO RECORDING TEST

Tech


THIS IS WHAT IT WILL TAKE TO BE SUCCESSFUL IN WEB3


NEWS

News


HOW WOODBURY COMMON IS LURING BACK CHINESE SHOPPERS, IN SPITE OF TRAVEL
RESTRICTIONS

News


TWITTER STOCK SUSPENSION: TWTR SHARES WON’T TRADE ON FRIDAY AS ELON MUSK’S
TAKEOVER NEARS

News


CLOROX JUST RECALLED THESE PINE-SOL CLEANING SUPPLIES OVER FEARS OF DANGEROUS
BACTERIA


CO.DESIGN

Co.Design


HERE’S WHY THE BALTIMORE RAVENS TOOK AMTRAK TO THEIR GAMES AGAINST NEW YORK’S
TEAMS

Co.Design


MEET THE FASHION TIKTOKER TURNING HOUSEHOLD OBJECTS INTO VIRAL OUTFITS

Co.Design


HOW MANIPULATING LIGHT HAS INSPIRED ARTISTS THROUGHOUT THE AGES


WORK LIFE

Work Life


I’M AN INTROVERT AND I’VE BUILT A CAREER AROUND PUBLIC SPEAKING

Work Life


IT’S TIME WE TALK HONESTLY ABOUT GRIEF IN THE WORKPLACE

Work Life


WHY CULTURAL INTELLIGENCE HELPS YOU UNDERSTAND PEOPLE BETTER

 * Advertise
 * Privacy Policy
 * Terms
 * Notice of Collection
 * Do Not Sell My Data
 * Permissions
 * Help Center
 * About Us
 * Site Map
 * Fast Company & Inc © 2022 Mansueto Ventures, LLC
 * 






search by queryly Advanced Search




WE USE COOKIES ON OUR WEBSITES TO SUPPORT TECHNICAL FEATURES THAT ENHANCE YOUR
USER EXPERIENCE AND HELP US IMPROVE OUR WEBSITE. BY CONTINUING TO USE THIS
WEBSITE YOU ACCEPT OUR PRIVACY POLICY AND TERMS OF USE.

Yes, I Accept