jalopnik.com Open in urlscan Pro
151.101.2.166  Public Scan

Form analysis
0 forms found in the DOM

Text Content

 * The A.V. Club
 * Deadspin
 * Gizmodo
 * Jalopnik
 * Jezebel
 * Kotaku
 * Lifehacker
 * The Root
 * The Takeout
 * 
 * The Onion
 * 
 * The Inventory


ShopSubscribe

HomeLatestUnpavedRacingCar BuyingTechCar CultureTruck YeahWrenchingBeyond Cars



 * Home
 * Latest
 * Unpaved
 * Racing
 * Car Buying
 * Tech
 * Car Culture
 * Truck Yeah
 * Wrenching
 * Beyond Cars

AboutJalopnik AdvisorJalopnik Store
Explore our other sites
 * 
 * 
 * 
 * 
 * 
 * 
 * 
 * 
 * 
 * 
 * 

AdvertisingPrivacyJobsTerms of Use
 * 
 * 
 * 
 * 
 * 

© 2022 G/O Media

HomeLatestUnpavedRacingCar BuyingTechCar CultureTruck YeahWrenchingBeyond Cars




Planelopnik


AIR FRANCE FLIGHT BRIEFLY LOST CONTROL WHEN BOTH PILOTS TRIED TO FLY AT ONCE


FLIGHT AF011 HAD TO ABORT A LANDING ATTEMPT AFTER BOTH PILOTS PUSHED THE
CONTROLS IN OPPOSITE DIRECTIONS, INVESTIGATORS SAY.

By
Mercedes Streeter

Today 11:30AM

Comments (44)
Alerts



Photo: Air France


Earlier this month, pilots of an Air France Boeing 777 reported that their
aircraft had lost control after it failed to respond to control inputs during
landing. Investigators looking over the data have found that both pilots were
pulling on the controls in opposite directions, causing their own observations.

Advertisement




On April 5, Air France flight AF011 was on its final approach to Charles de
Gaulle Airport in Paris from New York’s John F. Kennedy International Airport.
During the approach, the Boeing 777-300ER (registration F-GSQJ) veered left.
Inside of the flight deck, the pilots could be heard on air traffic control
audio shouting “Stop! Stop!” and struggling while warning chimes blared in the
background.

Thankfully, the pilots were able to perform a go-around, then line up for a
second attempt at landing. The second try went off without a hitch.





The question of what happened that day has been up in the air, and France’s
Bureau d’Enquêtes et d’Analyses pour la Sécurité de l’Aviation (BEA) seeks to
find an answer. Investigators have released a preliminary report, and the
evidence thus far suggests that there wasn’t anything wrong with the plane, but
confusion in the cockpit. For context, “PF” in BEA’s statement below means
“Pilot Flying.”



> On final, the aeroplane was established on the localizer and glideslope ILS
> beams. At 07:49, the crew were cleared to land. They configured the aeroplane
> for landing, the selected speed was 140 kt. The crew then carried out the
> “Landing” checklist. At 07:50:20, when the aeroplane was at an altitude of
> 1,670 ft5 , the PF continued the approach in manual flight: he disconnected
> the autopilot (AP), leaving the auto throttle (AT) and the flight directors
> (FD) activated. He then made inputs on the controls for around 15 seconds. The
> aeroplane followed the movement of the controls and stayed on the ILS path,
> the left and right roll being less than 2°. In the subsequent ten seconds,
> there were less inputs on the wheel. The co-pilot than made inputs on the
> control column and wheel with a greater frequency, the amplitude was still
> small, the aeroplane followed the commands, the left and right roll being less
> than 3°. At 07:51:06, the co-pilot expressed his astonishment with respect to
> the aeroplane’s bank angle. The roll inputs were amplified and the average
> position of the wheel was at around 6° to the left. The aeroplane turned left
> with a small bank angle.

Sponsored LinksSponsored Links
Promoted LinksPromoted Links

Forge Of Empires
Advertisement


Forge Of EmpiresWenn du gerne spielst, ist dieses Städteaufbauspiel ein Muss.
Keine Werbung, kein Install.


Undo

JalopnikSkydiving Pilots Try to Swap Planes In Mid-Air, Causing Crash And An FAA
Investigation


Undo

Forge Of Empires - Free Online Game

Forge Of Empires - Free Online GameWenn du Zeit am Computer totschlagen musst,
ist dieses Städteaufbauspiel ein Muss. Kein Install.


Undo

Jalopnik2023 Acura Integra Starts at $30,800, Arrives In June


Undo

Homeday - Faire Provision

Homeday - Faire ProvisionWie viel Ihr Haus tatsächlich wert ist, entscheidet die
Postleitzahl


Undo



G/O Media may get a commission
20% Off
Fire TV Stick 4K

Streamin' USA
Allows you to use a bunch of streaming services in one place, grants access to
live TV thanks to things like YouTube TV, and can be controlled using your
voice.

Buy for $40 at Amazon


In short, the autopilot was disconnected, and the aircraft was following the
inputs entered. The pilot flying was apparently surprised with the aircraft
deviating from its path.

When the aircraft was at an altitude of 1,115 feet, the pilots decided to
perform the go-around. At that time, the aircraft was banked seven degrees to
the left with the control wheel pointed 16 degrees to the left. BEA notes that
the aircraft was still in a stabilized approach and could have landed safely.

Advertisement




The confusion would only be amplified during the go-around. According to the
preliminary report, both pilots began pulling on their control columns in
opposite directions. The Captain was making nose-down inputs while the First
Officer was making nose-up inputs. The control wheels were also calling for even
more bank.

At this time, the BEA investigation has found nothing wrong with the aircraft
itself.

Advertisement



Screenshot: BEA

Normally, one pilot is in control of the aircraft (Pilot Flying) while the other
handles communications and monitors what the plane is doing (Pilot Monitoring).
When pilots exchange duties, it’s practice for the pilot taking control to call
out, “I have control.” In this case, the data suggests that both pilots were
trying to fly the plane, and because they both were inputting opposite inputs,
they were creating the assumed loss of control that they reported.

Advertisement




As for the warning chimes going off? BEA explains that the push-to-talk and
autopilot switches were being hit a number of times, causing audible warnings to
sound over and over.

The Boeing 777 is fly-by-wire, but its control columns are mechanically linked,
which can allow for a situation like this to occur. This link is maintained with
a torque tube breakout mechanism. When enough opposing force is applied, the
link breaks. It’s designed so that the plane can remain under control if one of
the columns gets jammed.

Advertisement




The BEA will continue its investigation. It will continue to validate the data
and attempt to replicate what happened in the cockpit that day to gain a better
understanding of the forces that were applied to the controls to the movements
of the controls.

Subscribe to our newsletter!
While you're driving by, subscribe to our newsletter so you don't miss out on
more of our 100% correct and undeniably true car takes.
Enter your emailSign Me Up
By subscribing you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.




Beyond CarsPlanelopnik




Featured Videos
Video Player is loading.
Play Video
Play
Unmute

Current Time 0:00
/
Duration 1:51
Loaded: 5.39%



Stream Type LIVE
Seek to live, currently playing liveLIVE
Remaining Time -1:51
 
Playback Rate

1x
Chapters
 * Chapters

Descriptions
 * descriptions off, selected

Captions
 * captions off, selected

 * Quality
 * 240p
 * 480p
 * 720p
 * 1080p
 * Auto, selected

Audio Track
 * default, selected

Fullscreen

This is a modal window.



What Car Should You Buy?
GM announces hybrid + electric Corvettes
Monday 6:30PM
The Most Important Cars at the 2022 New York Auto Show
4/19/22 6:15PM
Find A Car
Fun
Utility
Off Road
EVs and Hybrids
Sports Cars
Pickup Trucks
See More
Make

Model

Year

See Full Specs

You may also like
Jezebel
The ACLU Says It Wrote Amber Heard's Domestic Violence Op-Ed and Timed It to Her
Film Release

Yesterday 3:19PM
Gizmodo
A Fully Aligned Webb Space Telescope Sees a Field of Stars

Today 12:40PM
Kotaku
Ubisoft's Six-Year Development Hell Pirate Game Leaks In New Footage

Today 11:05AM


Recommended from G/O Media
11 burning questions before Ozark’s finale
4/27/2022, 5:00 AM

19 Food Network Stars’ Personal Websites, Ranked
4/27/2022, 4:00 PM

The 7 Deadly Sins of Dog Ownership
4/20/2022, 3:00 PM