www.aljazeera.com Open in urlscan Pro
2a02:26f0:480:99c::2392  Public Scan

Form analysis
1 forms found in the DOM

POST

<form id="sib-form-general" method="POST" data-type="subscription">
  <div class="sib-newsletter-form-fields-container"><span class="newsletter-description-line" aria-hidden="false"><span>The latest news from around the world. Timely. Accurate. Fair.</span></span>
    <div class="sib-newsletter-form-fields" aria-hidden="false"><input class="sib-newsletter-form-input" type="email" id="email" name="email" autocomplete="email" placeholder="E-mail address" data-required="true" aria-label="E-mail address"
        tabindex="0" value=""><button class="sib-form-submit " form="sib-form-general" type="submit" aria-label="signup for Weekly Newsletter" tabindex="0">Subscribe</button></div>
    <div class="error-message" aria-hidden="true" role="alert" aria-atomic="true" aria-live="error"><img src="/static/media/error-icon.c8fb9e1b.svg" aria-hidden="true"><span>Your subscription failed. Please try again.</span></div>
    <div class="success-message" aria-hidden="true"><img src="/static/media/right-mark-icon.3a446adc.svg" aria-hidden="true"><span tabindex="-1">Please check your email to confirm your subscription</span></div>
  </div>
  <div class="sib-newsletter-privacy-policy"><span aria-hidden="true">By signing up, you agree to our </span><a href="https://privacy.aljazeera.net" aria-label="By signing up, you agree to our Privacy Policy.">Privacy Policy</a></div>
</form>

Text Content

Advertisement

Skip linksSkip to Content

play
Live
Close navigation menu
Navigation menu
 * NewsShow more news sections
    * Middle East
    * Africa
    * Asia
    * US & Canada
    * Latin America
    * Europe
    * Asia Pacific

 * War on Gaza
 * Trump 2.0
 * Opinion
 * Sport
 * Video
 * MoreShow more sections
    * Features
    * Ukraine war
    * Economy
    * Climate Crisis
    * Investigations
    * Interactives
    * In Pictures
    * Science & Technology
    * Podcasts

play
Live
Click here to searchsearch
Sign upEnrich your Al Jazeera experience by signing in or creating an
account.Close Tooltip

Navigation menucaret-left
 * Israel-Palestine conflict
 * Live updates
 * Why has Abbas nominated a successor?
 * Gaza waits for a ceasefire of its own
 * Which countries recognise Palestine?
 * The Palestinian medics in Israeli jails
 * Is Netanyahu immune from arrest?
 * The war in maps and charts

caret-right
EXPLAINER
News|Israel-Palestine conflict


WHAT WILL THE ICJ ANNOUNCE ON ISRAEL’S GAZA WAR? THE POSSIBLE SCENARIOS

The World Court’s interim measures could being relief for Israel, vindication
for Palestinians or offer a bit of both.

play videoplay video

Video Duration 08 minutes 53 seconds 08:53

ICJ's decision holds potential to shape not only legal outcomes but also public
opinion: Bishara

Published On 25 Jan 202425 Jan 2024

Save articles to read later and create your own reading list.

Close Tooltip



facebooktwitterwhatsappcopylink

On Friday, the International Court of Justice (ICJ) will announce its decision
on emergency or provisional measures against Israel in an interim verdict after
South Africa filed a case against Israel accusing it of committing genocide in
Gaza.

Here is what we know about the possible rulings that the ICJ could deliver, and
what they might mean for Israel, Palestine, and their respective allies.


RECOMMENDED STORIES

list of 4 items
list 1 of 4


‘SIGNIFICANT CENSORSHIP’ OF PALESTINE ON SOCIAL MEDIA SPARKS OUTCRY

list 2 of 4


THE POGROM IN AMSTERDAM THAT WASN’T

list 3 of 4


AMSTERDAM POLICE ARREST PRO-PALESTINE DEMONSTRATORS FOR DEFYING PROTEST BAN

list 4 of 4


EU MEMBER STATES MUST ENACT ICC ARREST WARRANTS, SAYS FOREIGN POLICY CHIEF

end of list


WHAT IS SOUTH AFRICA’S CASE AGAINST ISRAEL?

On December 29, South Africa filed an 84-page legal case at the ICJ accusing
Israel of violating the 1984 Genocide Convention during its near-four-month
bombardment of Gaza.

Israel has dismissed the genocide allegations as “grossly distorted” and deemed
them “blood libel”, saying it was acting in self-defence and targeting Hamas,
not Palestinian civilians.

On January 11 and 12, the ICJ conducted hearings during which South Africa
presented its case and, then, Israel defended itself.

[Al Jazeera]


WILL THE COURT DETERMINE WHETHER ISRAEL IS COMMITTING GENOCIDE?

Advertisement


The ICJ will not deal with the core question of whether Israel is committing
genocide on Friday. For now, it will only announce, at 1pm local time (12:00
GMT) whether it can order provisional or emergency measures in Gaza and what
those measures will be, while it deliberates the case for genocide.


SIGN UP FOR AL JAZEERA

WEEKLY NEWSLETTER

The latest news from around the world. Timely. Accurate. Fair.
Subscribe
Your subscription failed. Please try again.
Please check your email to confirm your subscription
By signing up, you agree to our Privacy Policy
protected by reCAPTCHA

Experts have said a ruling on the overall case, which will determine whether or
not Israel is committing genocide, could take as long as three or four years.

Here are the possible scenarios for what the court could announce on Friday:


COULD THE COURT THROW OUT THE CASE?

Israel argued in its response to South Africa’s ICJ allegations that the global
court does not have jurisdiction over the case.

It argued that South Africa had not communicated with Israel adequately about
the case before filing the application to the court, as is required by the
court’s own rules.

The Israeli representative claimed South Africa had given it only a few days to
respond to a notification that it was committing genocide. He said that Tel Aviv
had been open to the idea of a dialogue, but that South Africa had first
rejected a written request due to a holiday, and then had replied that there was
“no point” in having a discussion.

The ICJ’s rules require the petitioning nation to show that a dispute exists
with the country it is accusing, and that they have tried to address it before
approaching the court.

If the ICJ announces Friday that it does not have jurisdiction in the case, the
specific requests made by South Africa become immaterial.

Advertisement



WHAT EMERGENCY MEASURES HAS SOUTH AFRICA REQUESTED?

When it filed the case, South Africa asked the ICJ to order a series of
provisional measures to cease violence in Gaza until the court makes its ruling
on the case – a process which experts say may take years.

Some of South Africa’s demands are that:

 * Israel suspend military operations in and against Gaza.
 * Israel’s military organisations not escalate military operations any further.
 * Israel allow access to adequate food, water, fuel, shelter, hygiene and
   sanitation.
 * Israel prevent the destruction of Palestinian life in Gaza.
 * Israel not destroy evidence relevant to South Africa’s genocide allegations
   against it, nor deny international organisations such as fact-finding
   missions access to Gaza to help preserve this evidence.




WHAT EMERGENCY MEASURES IS THE ICJ LIKELY TO ORDER?

If the court does announce provisional measures, Neve Gordon, an international
law professor at Queen Mary University of London, told Al Jazeera that these
could cover some or all of South Africa’s requests – or it could order entirely
different provisional measures determined by the court itself.

Some commentators believe that the court may fall short of ordering a full
ceasefire. It could, instead, order access to adequate humanitarian relief,
Gordon said, adding that this would be a win for Israel.

In such a case, Israel could easily avoid international ramifications by saying
it would allow more aid in, then not actually doing much to facilitate it.
Additionally, aid agencies have said previously that the arrival of adequate
humanitarian aid in Gaza without a ceasefire is unrealistic, as aid trucks have
been unable to reach parts of Gaza, such as the north, due to obstacles created
by Israel’s siege and violence in the enclave.

Advertisement


While it is unclear whether and what interim measures the court might order,
experts have said that, under international law, it ought to order a ceasefire.
“If you look at what is happening on-ground in the Gaza Strip, then I think the
court should order a ceasefire,” Gordon said.

However, he added that “the decision made by the court in my opinion is an
entanglement between a legal argument and a political argument”. This is because
the panel of 17 judges come from different countries and it is unclear what
impact, if any, the interests of their countries could have on their legal
judgements.

“‘How politicised is the decision?’ is a question that needs to be asked,” he
said.

[Al Jazeera]


WHAT HAPPENS IF THE ICJ ORDERS NO PROVISIONAL MEASURES?

Gordon said he believes the court will order some measures rather than none at
all.

However, the ICJ can choose not to order interim measures. This would not mean
the end of the legal case, however. The overall case for genocide will still be
considered.

If provisional measures are not ordered, South Africa and the countries that
have backed it in its complaint against Israel will have to try avenues for
stopping violence other than international legal fora, since the ICJ is the
highest world court and the supreme legal authority, Gordon explained. This
could include taking the issue up with the UN Security Council or placing legal
pressure on countries providing Israel with weapons.

Alternatively, if they believe the violence is persisting and escalating,
another country, or even South Africa again, can file a new, separate case with
the ICJ.

Advertisement









COULD AN ICJ RULING MAKE ANY DIFFERENCE FOR GAZA?

The ICJ’s rulings are legally binding and cannot be appealed. However, the court
has no way of enforcing them and the enforcement is left to the international
community.

“Whether Israel takes the measures into account or not is a different story,”
said Gordon.

“Israel cannot appeal the court’s ruling, and it will have to decide whether it
abides by the court’s decision or not,” he added.

If it does not abide by the ruling, a member state of the UN Security Council
(UNSC) can escalate this before the Council, which will then vote to require
Israel to abide by the provisional measures.

The US could possibly cast a veto in this vote, a move the permanent member has
repeatedly made in the past to obviate accountability for its close ally Israel.

However, Gordon pointed out that a resolution drafted by a Security Council
member state might hold different weight compared with a decision made by the
highest court in the world. If the US vetoes a Security Council resolution based
on the ICJ decision “it will expose the duplicity of the US like no other veto
before”.

In a scenario in which the US does not veto and the UNSC passes the resolution,
it would have the power to take punitive action against Israel. Past examples of
UNSC action have included economic or trade sanctions, arms embargoes and travel
bans.

The UN charter also allows the Council to go a step further and intervene with
force. An example of this happened in 1991 when a US-led military alliance was
created to reverse the invasion of Kuwait by the Iraqi leader, Saddam Hussein.

Advertisement


An ICJ ruling on the provisional measures in Gaza could possibly be actionable,
therefore. However, it would be up to the international community to enforce it.

Source: Al Jazeera

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Sponsored Content


Advertisement


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

 * AboutShow more
    * About Us
    * Code of Ethics
    * Terms and Conditions
    * EU/EEA Regulatory Notice
    * Privacy Policy
    * Cookie Policy
    * Cookie PreferencesManage preferences
    * Sitemap
    * Work for us

 * ConnectShow more
    * Contact Us
    * User Accounts Help
    * Advertise with us
    * Apps
    * Newsletters
    * Channel Finder
    * TV Schedule
    * Podcasts
    * Submit a Tip

 * Our ChannelsShow more
    * Al Jazeera Arabic
    * Al Jazeera English
    * Al Jazeera Investigative Unit
    * Al Jazeera Mubasher
    * Al Jazeera Documentary
    * Al Jazeera Balkans
    * AJ+

 * Our NetworkShow more
    * Al Jazeera Centre for Studies
    * Al Jazeera Media Institute
    * Learn Arabic
    * Al Jazeera Centre for Public Liberties & Human Rights
    * Al Jazeera Forum
    * Al Jazeera Hotel Partners

Follow Al Jazeera English:

 * facebook
 * twitter
 * youtube
 * instagram-colored-outline
 * rss


© 2024 Al Jazeera Media Network










YOU RELY ON AL JAZEERA FOR TRUTH AND TRANSPARENCY

We and our 865 partners store and access information on your device, such as
unique IDs in cookies to process personal data. You may accept and manage your
choices at any time by clicking `Manage Preferences`, including your right to
object where legitimate interest is relied upon. Your choices will be signaled
to our partners and will not affect your browsing.To learn more, please view our
Cookie Policy.


WE AND OUR PARTNERS PROCESS DATA TO PROVIDE:

Use precise geolocation data. Actively scan device characteristics for
identification. Store and/or access information on a device. Personalised
advertising and content, advertising and content measurement, audience research
and services development. List of Partners (vendors)

Allow all Reject all Manage preferences