nymag.com
Open in
urlscan Pro
151.101.1.91
Public Scan
Submitted URL: http://nymag.com/intelligencer/article/gabriel-benedetti-the-long-alliance-book-excerpt.html
Effective URL: https://nymag.com/intelligencer/article/gabriel-benedetti-the-long-alliance-book-excerpt.html
Submission: On September 01 via manual from US — Scanned from DE
Effective URL: https://nymag.com/intelligencer/article/gabriel-benedetti-the-long-alliance-book-excerpt.html
Submission: On September 01 via manual from US — Scanned from DE
Form analysis 34 forms found in the DOM
Name: search — GET https://nymag.com/search.html
<form class="nav-search-form" name="search" method="get" action="https://nymag.com/search.html">
<input aria-label="Search" type="text" name="q" class="search-input" placeholder="Search">
</form>Name: search — GET https://nymag.com/search.html
<form class="nav-search-form" name="search" method="get" action="https://nymag.com/search.html">
<input aria-label="Search" type="text" name="q" class="search-input" placeholder="Search">
</form><form data-recaptcha-public-key="6LcQmfoUAAAAAHL2UQnKmKFkIgzXmLeJs0YET0Ps" class="form" data-post="/api/newsletter/users" data-success-msg="" data-success-title-msg="Thanks, you're all set!"
data-success-description-msg="You'll receive the next newsletter in your inbox." data-error-msg="*Please enter a valid email" data-display-after-sign-up="false">
<input class="newsletterId" type="hidden" value="great-story" name="newsletterId">
<input class="source" type="hidden" name="source">
<label for="columnSubscribeEmail-777" class="email-label">Email</label>
<input id="columnSubscribeEmail-777" type="email" class="email" placeholder="Enter your email" name="email" required="">
<input type="submit" class="submit" value="Sign up">
<div>
<span class="return-message" aria-live="assertive" tabindex="-1"></span>
</div>
</form>GET /newsletter/subscribe/new/
<form method="get" action="/newsletter/subscribe/new/" class="form">
<input type="hidden" value="" name="newsletterId" class="input">
<input type="hidden" value="" name="source" class="input">
<label for="newsletterEmail" class="label-email"> Email </label>
<input id="newsletterEmail" class="input email" type="email" placeholder="Enter your email" name="email" required="">
<input type="submit" class="input submit" value="Submit">
<span class="message success" role="alert" aria-live="assertive" aria-hidden="true" tabindex="-1"> You\'ll receive the next newsletter in your inbox. </span>
<span class="message error" role="alert" aria-live="assertive" aria-hidden="true" tabindex="-1"> *Sorry, there was a problem signing you up. </span>
</form>GET /api/newsletter/users
<form method="get" class="form" action="/api/newsletter/users">
<input type="hidden" value="" name="newsletterId" class="input newsletterId">
<input id="newsletterEmail" class="input email" type="email" placeholder="Enter your email" name="email" required="">
<input type="submit" class="input submit" value="">
</form><form class="sign-in-form">
<input id="username" type="text" name="email" value="pizza" autocomplete="username email" style="display: none;">
<label for="password" class="password-label sign-up">Choose a password to create an account:</label>
<label for="password" class="password-label sign-in">Enter your password or<button class="account-step-back-text" type="button">sign in with a different email</button></label>
<input class="password-field-input sign-in" name="password" id="sign-in-password" type="password" placeholder="Password" autocomplete="current-password">
<input class="password-field-input sign-up" name="password" id="sign-up-password" type="password" placeholder="Password" autocomplete="new-password">
</form><form class="newsletter-checkbox-form"></form><form class="sign-in-form">
<input id="username" type="text" name="email" value="pizza" autocomplete="username email" style="display: none;">
<label for="password" class="password-label sign-up">Choose a password to create an account:</label>
<label for="password" class="password-label sign-in">Enter your password or<button class="account-step-back-text" type="button">sign in with a different email</button></label>
<input class="password-field-input sign-in" name="password" id="sign-in-password" type="password" placeholder="Password" autocomplete="current-password">
<input class="password-field-input sign-up" name="password" id="sign-up-password" type="password" placeholder="Password" autocomplete="new-password">
</form><form class="newsletter-checkbox-form"></form>GET /newsletter/subscribe/new/
<form method="get" action="/newsletter/subscribe/new/" class="form">
<input type="hidden" value="" name="newsletterId" class="input">
<input type="hidden" value="" name="source" class="input">
<label for="newsletterEmail" class="label-email"> Email </label>
<input id="newsletterEmail" class="input email" type="email" placeholder="Enter your email" name="email" required="">
<input type="submit" class="input submit" value="Submit">
<span class="message success" role="alert" aria-live="assertive" aria-hidden="true" tabindex="-1"> You\'ll receive the next newsletter in your inbox. </span>
<span class="message error" role="alert" aria-live="assertive" aria-hidden="true" tabindex="-1"> *Sorry, there was a problem signing you up. </span>
</form>GET /api/newsletter/users
<form method="get" class="form" action="/api/newsletter/users">
<input type="hidden" value="" name="newsletterId" class="input newsletterId">
<input id="newsletterEmail" class="input email" type="email" placeholder="Enter your email" name="email" required="">
<input type="submit" class="input submit" value="">
</form><form class="sign-in-form">
<input id="username" type="text" name="email" value="pizza" autocomplete="username email" style="display: none;">
<label for="password" class="password-label sign-up">Choose a password to create an account:</label>
<label for="password" class="password-label sign-in">Enter your password or<button class="account-step-back-text" type="button">sign in with a different email</button></label>
<input class="password-field-input sign-in" name="password" id="sign-in-password" type="password" placeholder="Password" autocomplete="current-password">
<input class="password-field-input sign-up" name="password" id="sign-up-password" type="password" placeholder="Password" autocomplete="new-password">
</form><form class="newsletter-checkbox-form"></form><form class="sign-in-form">
<input id="username" type="text" name="email" value="pizza" autocomplete="username email" style="display: none;">
<label for="password" class="password-label sign-up">Choose a password to create an account:</label>
<label for="password" class="password-label sign-in">Enter your password or<button class="account-step-back-text" type="button">sign in with a different email</button></label>
<input class="password-field-input sign-in" name="password" id="sign-in-password" type="password" placeholder="Password" autocomplete="current-password">
<input class="password-field-input sign-up" name="password" id="sign-up-password" type="password" placeholder="Password" autocomplete="new-password">
</form><form class="newsletter-checkbox-form"></form>GET /newsletter/subscribe/new/
<form method="get" action="/newsletter/subscribe/new/" class="form">
<input type="hidden" value="" name="newsletterId" class="input">
<input type="hidden" value="" name="source" class="input">
<label for="newsletterEmail" class="label-email"> Email </label>
<input id="newsletterEmail" class="input email" type="email" placeholder="Enter your email" name="email" required="">
<input type="submit" class="input submit" value="Submit">
<span class="message success" role="alert" aria-live="assertive" aria-hidden="true" tabindex="-1"> You\'ll receive the next newsletter in your inbox. </span>
<span class="message error" role="alert" aria-live="assertive" aria-hidden="true" tabindex="-1"> *Sorry, there was a problem signing you up. </span>
</form>GET /api/newsletter/users
<form method="get" class="form" action="/api/newsletter/users">
<input type="hidden" value="" name="newsletterId" class="input newsletterId">
<input id="newsletterEmail" class="input email" type="email" placeholder="Enter your email" name="email" required="">
<input type="submit" class="input submit" value="">
</form><form class="sign-in-form">
<input id="username" type="text" name="email" value="pizza" autocomplete="username email" style="display: none;">
<label for="password" class="password-label sign-up">Choose a password to create an account:</label>
<label for="password" class="password-label sign-in">Enter your password or<button class="account-step-back-text" type="button">sign in with a different email</button></label>
<input class="password-field-input sign-in" name="password" id="sign-in-password" type="password" placeholder="Password" autocomplete="current-password">
<input class="password-field-input sign-up" name="password" id="sign-up-password" type="password" placeholder="Password" autocomplete="new-password">
</form><form class="newsletter-checkbox-form"></form><form class="sign-in-form">
<input id="username" type="text" name="email" value="pizza" autocomplete="username email" style="display: none;">
<label for="password" class="password-label sign-up">Choose a password to create an account:</label>
<label for="password" class="password-label sign-in">Enter your password or<button class="account-step-back-text" type="button">sign in with a different email</button></label>
<input class="password-field-input sign-in" name="password" id="sign-in-password" type="password" placeholder="Password" autocomplete="current-password">
<input class="password-field-input sign-up" name="password" id="sign-up-password" type="password" placeholder="Password" autocomplete="new-password">
</form><form class="newsletter-checkbox-form"></form>GET /newsletter/subscribe/new/
<form method="get" action="/newsletter/subscribe/new/" class="form">
<input type="hidden" value="" name="newsletterId" class="input">
<input type="hidden" value="" name="source" class="input">
<label for="newsletterEmail" class="label-email"> Email </label>
<input id="newsletterEmail" class="input email" type="email" placeholder="Enter your email" name="email" required="">
<input type="submit" class="input submit" value="Submit">
<span class="message success" role="alert" aria-live="assertive" aria-hidden="true" tabindex="-1"> You\'ll receive the next newsletter in your inbox. </span>
<span class="message error" role="alert" aria-live="assertive" aria-hidden="true" tabindex="-1"> *Sorry, there was a problem signing you up. </span>
</form>GET /api/newsletter/users
<form method="get" class="form" action="/api/newsletter/users">
<input type="hidden" value="" name="newsletterId" class="input newsletterId">
<input id="newsletterEmail" class="input email" type="email" placeholder="Enter your email" name="email" required="">
<input type="submit" class="input submit" value="">
</form><form class="sign-in-form">
<input id="username" type="text" name="email" value="pizza" autocomplete="username email" style="display: none;">
<label for="password" class="password-label sign-up">Choose a password to create an account:</label>
<label for="password" class="password-label sign-in">Enter your password or<button class="account-step-back-text" type="button">sign in with a different email</button></label>
<input class="password-field-input sign-in" name="password" id="sign-in-password" type="password" placeholder="Password" autocomplete="current-password">
<input class="password-field-input sign-up" name="password" id="sign-up-password" type="password" placeholder="Password" autocomplete="new-password">
</form><form class="newsletter-checkbox-form"></form><form class="sign-in-form">
<input id="username" type="text" name="email" value="pizza" autocomplete="username email" style="display: none;">
<label for="password" class="password-label sign-up">Choose a password to create an account:</label>
<label for="password" class="password-label sign-in">Enter your password or<button class="account-step-back-text" type="button">sign in with a different email</button></label>
<input class="password-field-input sign-in" name="password" id="sign-in-password" type="password" placeholder="Password" autocomplete="current-password">
<input class="password-field-input sign-up" name="password" id="sign-up-password" type="password" placeholder="Password" autocomplete="new-password">
</form><form class="newsletter-checkbox-form"></form>GET /newsletter/subscribe/new/
<form method="get" action="/newsletter/subscribe/new/" class="form">
<input type="hidden" value="" name="newsletterId" class="input">
<input type="hidden" value="" name="source" class="input">
<label for="newsletterEmail" class="label-email"> Email </label>
<input id="newsletterEmail" class="input email" type="email" placeholder="Enter your email" name="email" required="">
<input type="submit" class="input submit" value="Submit">
<span class="message success" role="alert" aria-live="assertive" aria-hidden="true" tabindex="-1"> You\'ll receive the next newsletter in your inbox. </span>
<span class="message error" role="alert" aria-live="assertive" aria-hidden="true" tabindex="-1"> *Sorry, there was a problem signing you up. </span>
</form>GET /api/newsletter/users
<form method="get" class="form" action="/api/newsletter/users">
<input type="hidden" value="" name="newsletterId" class="input newsletterId">
<input id="newsletterEmail" class="input email" type="email" placeholder="Enter your email" name="email" required="">
<input type="submit" class="input submit" value="">
</form><form class="sign-in-form">
<input id="username" type="text" name="email" value="pizza" autocomplete="username email" style="display: none;">
<label for="password" class="password-label sign-up">Choose a password to create an account:</label>
<label for="password" class="password-label sign-in">Enter your password or<button class="account-step-back-text" type="button">sign in with a different email</button></label>
<input class="password-field-input sign-in" name="password" id="sign-in-password" type="password" placeholder="Password" autocomplete="current-password">
<input class="password-field-input sign-up" name="password" id="sign-up-password" type="password" placeholder="Password" autocomplete="new-password">
</form><form class="newsletter-checkbox-form"></form><form class="sign-in-form">
<input id="username" type="text" name="email" value="pizza" autocomplete="username email" style="display: none;">
<label for="password" class="password-label sign-up">Choose a password to create an account:</label>
<label for="password" class="password-label sign-in">Enter your password or<button class="account-step-back-text" type="button">sign in with a different email</button></label>
<input class="password-field-input sign-in" name="password" id="sign-in-password" type="password" placeholder="Password" autocomplete="current-password">
<input class="password-field-input sign-up" name="password" id="sign-up-password" type="password" placeholder="Password" autocomplete="new-password">
</form><form class="newsletter-checkbox-form"></form>GET https://tr.snapchat.com/cm/i
<form method="GET" action="https://tr.snapchat.com/cm/i" target="snap046472915612918153" accept-charset="utf-8" style="display: none;"><iframe id="snap046472915612918153" name="snap046472915612918153"></iframe><input name="pid"><input
name="u_scsid"><input name="u_sclid"></form>Text Content
* Intelligencer
* The Cut
* Vulture
* The Strategist
*
* Curbed
* Grub Street
* Magazine
Subscribe to the Magazine Give a Gift Subscription Buy Back Issues Current
Issue Contents
* Subscribe
* Sign In
* Account
Profile
Sign Out
Menu Menu Close Close
* Politics
* Business
* Technology
* Ideas
* Newsletters
Like Us Follow Us
* NYMag.com
* New York Magazine
* Intelligencer
* Vulture
* The Cut
* The Strategist
* Grub Street
* Curbed
SEARCH
Search Close
Subscribe Give A Gift
Menu Menu Close Close
* Politics
* Business
* Technology
* Ideas
* Newsletters
Like Us Follow Us
* NYMag.com
* New York Magazine
* Intelligencer
* Vulture
* The Cut
* The Strategist
* Grub Street
* Curbed
politics
Who’s the Change Agent Now?
* Share
* Tweet
* Pin It
48Comments 48 Leave a Comment
SEARCH
Search Close
Things you buy through our links may earn New York a commission.
politics Aug. 31, 2022
WHO’S THE CHANGE AGENT NOW?
JOE BIDEN IS DELIVERING BREAKTHROUGHS THAT LONG ELUDED BARACK OBAMA. WHO
UNDERSTANDS THE PRESIDENCY BEST?
By Gabriel Debenedetti
Senator and senator in 2005. Photo: Mark Wilson/Getty Images
Senator and senator in 2005. Photo: Mark Wilson/Getty Images
Senator and senator in 2005. Photo: Mark Wilson/Getty Images
This article was featured in One Great Story, New York’s reading recommendation
newsletter. Sign up here to get it nightly.
Barack Obama has kept a vanishingly small circle of trust in his
post-presidency, and for much of this summer, any visitors who got a moment with
him and dared to ask about Joe Biden’s tanking administration tended to get no
substantive answer. Ever since leaving the White House in 2017, Obama has been
cautious to the point of introversion about wading into daily politics, but
through June and deep into July, he was noticeably cagey even with buddies —
wary that a leak about any level of concern on his part would create a hellish
news cycle. Content to watch from afar on Martha’s Vineyard, where he and former
First Lady Michelle have a 29-acre home and a personal chef, Obama followed the
news closely as Biden’s agenda stalled out, then was ground down by inflation
and gas prices and an unconvincing response to the demise of Roe v. Wade.
From his perch on an island 500 miles north of the White House, Obama spoke with
Biden sporadically. As always, their calls were private and no aides listened
in. But as the summer wore on, Obama’s small group of confidants gathered that
Biden was impatient with his dismal approval numbers, which rivaled Donald
Trump’s. They thought Biden seemed sensitive about the fact that among
Democratic candidates running for office in November, the 44th president will be
a far more coveted surrogate than the 46th. (One private party poll in the
battleground state of Arizona showed Biden’s favorability at a putrid 26
percent.) And it seemed to them that the president was annoyed with some members
of his own party, especially regarding what he saw as their fatalistic attitude
about the midterms. (The White House disputes these impressions.)
Given the hit Biden took after the abortion ruling, some of Obama’s close allies
were baffled by Biden’s similarly uninspiring reaction to the July 4 mass
shooting in Highland Park, Illinois, that left seven people dead and dozens
wounded. As a handful of ambitious Democrats made micromoves that could position
them to run in Biden’s stead in 2024, Obama said nothing, either publicly or
through back channels. He stayed mum when Illinois governor J. B. Pritzker
visited the early-voting state of New Hampshire, and he didn’t reach out to
bring Gavin Newsom in line after the California governor rather conspicuously
began buying airtime in Florida and newspaper ads in Texas. Much of Obama’s
reluctance to engage was tactical; he didn’t want to overshadow the sitting
president or get dragged into a new role as Biden’s enforcer, and he’d already
determined that he would be most effective as an advocate for the party if he
lay low until just before the midterms. Still, coming from the most popular
Democrat, Obama’s distancing had the effect of heightening Biden’s isolation, as
an idea began to take hold in the public imagination that one of them knew how
to be a successful president and the other didn’t.
And then, as if out of nowhere, came a very Washington version of deliverance.
An agreement between Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer and the fickle West
Virginia senator Joe Manchin to make world-historic climate investments and
deflate drug prices headlined a run of nearly miraculous news for Biden’s White
House. It was the kind of concerted environmental effort Democrats had dreamed
of for years, if not decades, and even progressives who wanted more conceded it
would make for a genuine sea change in the government’s approach to the
existential threat of climate change. The deal came on the heels of the
bipartisan passage of a semiconductor-chip-manufacturing bill, and it cast in a
better light a June compromise to enact limited gun-control measures, alongside
other legislation of substance. (It didn’t hurt that in this stretch Biden had
ordered the drone killing of Al Qaeda’s leader and gas prices fell by more than
a dollar.) “There is no way to get around the fact the last month or so has been
stellar for the administration,” Charles M. Blow declared in the New York Times.
“Joe Biden’s Presidency Is Suddenly Back From the Dead,” Jonathan Chait wrote in
this magazine. Bob Shrum compared him to Lyndon Johnson.
Nobody was under any illusion that Biden had personally crafted the climate deal
or artfully twisted the right arms to get it done. More accurately, it fell into
his lap — months after he’d last tried to cut a compromise on his Build Back
Better plan with Manchin. If Biden could have made it happen sooner, he would
have. But just as presidents can fall victim to external disasters over which
they have little control (see gas prices), history remembers even indirect
victories as their own, too. What Biden did was leave the door open to a
bargain, recognizing the awkward reality that Schumer and Manchin had more space
to maneuver without his voice in the mix complicating the politics that faced
the prickly moderate from coal country. Biden and Schumer had also allowed
Republican Senate leader Mitch McConnell to believe the administration’s climate
ambitions were toast; the prevailing theory in Washington is that the Kentuckian
agreed to the chips bill only because he trusted that the big-ticket ones were
dead.
If Biden’s abrupt turnaround can be attributed to a style of governance that is
still emerging, that style is decidedly un-Obaman. The crown-jewel victory — the
Inflation Reduction Act, containing the climate provisions — was painstakingly
lashed together in secret by a crew of senators, including longtime denizens of
Biden’s old stomping ground. The president’s own hand was nowhere to be seen in
public until it was on the verge of passage, an echo of how the maximally
precarious gun bill had moved through Congress a few weeks earlier. Whether
because of changing times and opposition or recognition of their fundamentally
distinct political strengths, Biden has veered far from the Obama model to get
things done. It’s been months since he mounted a concerted effort to galvanize
public opinion with the presidential bully pulpit, and he has never attempted to
use an academic style of persuasion, as Obama often did.
Obama was elated to learn of the climate agreement. But as the ex- and current
president celebrated, a telling gap began to open. Biden’s West Wing sold the
Inflation Reduction Act as the largest climate investment ever, period.
Publicly, Obama agreed, calling the law a “BFD” — a nod for nostalgists to
Biden’s famous appraisal of Obamacare. Privately, however, Obama saw the
legislation as a step forward — a bend in the long arc of history he often cites
— and not a transformative leap. It was possible to read this as sour grapes, or
at least wry analysis, from a retired president whose own grandest ambitions had
been thwarted at almost every turn. Yet no one on earth understood what Biden
was facing better than the man who’d held the job for eight years. The two
simply saw change-making differently. Obama, in fact, had been getting updates
from Schumer all summer and had been quietly musing that a climate plan might be
revivable, fashioned from the surviving shreds of Biden’s Build Back Better
platform. He just hadn’t necessarily seen the idea as an epochal one — more like
a pragmatic concession that Biden’s original ambitions couldn’t work in this
version of Washington. The difference in perspective speaks to one of the oldest
lines of tension in Obama and Biden’s relationship and a question that is now
more pressing than ever: What is the right way to be a Democratic president?
Neither man’s approach has been static, especially as Republican opposition has
escalated from obstruction to nakedly anti-democratic sabotage. Obama entered
office in 2009 with large partisan majorities, confident in his rhetorical
abilities to unite the country and persuade voters to enact sweeping change, but
GOP intransigence hardened his view of what was achievable and left him
increasingly reliant on the unilateral powers of his office. He still used his
megaphone to urge the electorate toward pluralism in moments of need, but by
2016, he was giving exit interviews about the difficulty of turning ocean liners
more than a few degrees at a time. Biden observed all that from a closer vantage
point than anyone, and in 2021, he took the oath of office with an altogether
different strategy in mind. Although he had only a minuscule edge in Congress,
he was convinced that his long decades in the Senate made deal-making possible
again — both with members of his own party and with a small, theoretical group
of Republicans eager to get some things done after the embarrassments and
incompetence of the Trump years. Finding little success in trying to be the
country’s protagonist or pastor, Biden settled into a significantly quieter and
less confrontationally progressive posture even as he kept his faith in the
legislative process to eventually deliver him big wins. Though his achievements
were often overshadowed by a generalized perception of feebleness and
unrelenting demonization from Republicans, he began to rack up major policy
victories.
Seismic as it is, the climate law hardly rescues Biden from his doldrums. The
presidency is about much more than legislation, and early polling suggests his
approval rating has rebounded only modestly. Yet to a degree that would have
been unthinkable in the depths of summer, when Biden seemed all but dead
politically, it is now possible to debate whether his first two years or Obama’s
were more substantively successful.
Vice-president and president in 2012. Photo: Christopher Morris/VII/Redux
Today’s Obama-Biden dynamic would be unrecognizable to a voter from 2008, back
when Obama was the change-maker and Biden his elder realist and fixer. Their
roles haven’t exactly reversed, but it’s striking that Obama is now more
identified with piecemeal progress and Biden with a process that can be ugly and
lurching but does occasionally deliver dramatic breakthroughs. Back at the start
of his presidency, Obama sought to enact the most dramatic reform of the
American health-care system in history, and he overruled the advisers who told
him that he was being unrealistic about the political window — none of them
resisting so loudly as Biden. Universal access to medical insurance was a
priority for the left, but the vice-president argued that voters would give
Obama “a pass on this one” if he focused on the economy, which was still
teetering on the brink of ruin in early 2009. Over a few weeks of meetings in
the Roosevelt Room, Biden told Obama with increasing agitation that forcing a
health-care overhaul could kneecap his presidency from the start. Insisting on
this kind of historical loser — reforms had failed numerous times over the
decades — in year one would swamp the rest of his agenda, Biden said. But Obama
was unimpressed by Biden’s advice that he ought to focus on middle-class
pocketbooks above all else. He figured, We’re already doing everything we know
how to do for the economy, so all you’re proposing is giving up on health care.
That was status quo D.C. thinking.
It was their first serious disagreement about how to surmount roadblocks to
progress. Biden was joined by Obama’s chief of staff, Rahm Emanuel, and his lead
strategist, David Axelrod, who both tried to steer Obama to other priorities.
But the president grew increasingly impatient with the arguments. “What are we
supposed to do? Put our approval rating on the shelf and admire it for eight
years?” he asked. “Or draw down on it and do things of lasting value?” On this
much, Biden agreed; he just thought Obama should do health care in phases, not
all at once. At one planning meeting, Biden listened to a procession of experts
brief the president on a swath of policy changes, and eventually Biden tore into
them for five excruciating minutes. This will never pass, we’ll get bogged down
on it, and it will distract from everything else, he said, amazed that the room
still couldn’t see what seemed obvious to him: They’d end up getting drubbed in
the midterms with little or nothing to show for it. Obama shifted in his chair,
his discomfort and impatience more obvious by the moment, as Biden’s voice rose
to a yell. The president had already made his decision, and this wasn’t the
cerebral way he wanted his policies determined.
Both Obama and Biden recognized the precariousness of the moment, but where the
younger man saw opportunity for dramatic change that might yet shift the cynical
culture of Washington and, more important, help Americans, the other feared his
boss was missing a dire political reality. Biden came around once he saw that
Obama wouldn’t be dissuaded. As the health-care push began in earnest, Obama
took charge of the public-facing, political-slash-moral campaign and delegated
vote wrangling to Emanuel, Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, and House Speaker
Nancy Pelosi. Even as some conservative Democrats began to voice skepticism
about the cause and whether they could support it, Obama mostly left them alone;
he didn’t want to spend all his time schlepping to the Capitol or inviting
thirsty lawmakers to the White House residence to hang out. And he was sure that
when it came time to vote, the holdouts would come through for their party. He
was unwilling to be the one to woo or strong-arm them so early, figuring his
political influence should be held in reserve until it was absolutely needed.
Biden watched all of this with curiosity. His style of negotiation was
different: Not only did he want a lot more face time with counterparties than
Obama, but he also liked to start at a point of basic agreement and build,
adding pieces that each side wanted. Obama, in contrast, usually started from
his ideal spot and negotiated down to a place of mutual acceptance, and he
didn’t much like doing it. Biden was starting to suspect that Obama didn’t enjoy
negotiating — or members of Congress — at all. He wasn’t hanging around with
guests at White House receptions, and he rarely had his former Senate colleagues
over for strategy sessions. It was all stuff that Biden would’ve loved to do as
president but that Obama thought was superfluous and, often, bullshit.
That summer of 2009, neither Obama nor Biden knew quite how to deal with the
wave of organized conservative fury that arose in opposition to the health-care
effort, as epitomized by Sarah Palin’s ludicrous but effective claims about
“death panels.” The GOP pollster Frank Luntz had circulated a 28-page memo
coaching the party’s representatives to describe the health-care plan as a
“Washington takeover,” since “takeovers are like coups — they both lead to
dictators and a loss of freedom. What Americans fear most is that Washington
politicians will dictate what kind of care they can receive.” At one of their
regular private lunches that year, Obama asked Biden how and why Republicans
suddenly seemed to be in perfect lockstep against him. Biden gave an assessment
that in time would become the conventional wisdom but then felt fresh: The
sickness had begun with Newt Gingrich and his acolytes, who viewed comity with
Democrats as per se unacceptable, and things had been worsened by reforms to the
earmarking process and an explosion of outside money in politics. Obama listened
and considered it all quietly. This was why he’d chosen Biden. But the
explanation didn’t much alter his tactics.
As Washington got colder and negotiations with Capitol Hill dragged on, the
senior White House staff gathered for strategy sessions and carefully went
through a list of senators to make sure they knew where each one stood. Whenever
they worried that one was wavering, they would turn to the front of the room and
gauge Obama’s interest in engaging him or her. Quickly, they figured out that
this wasn’t his preferred way to spend his time but that Biden was eager to be
dispatched and he and Reid could coordinate an effective approach for his
ex-colleagues. Biden managed to keep several wobbly centrists in the fold,
calling them regularly to say he understood their political incentives.
Obama rarely drank in office, and Biden didn’t drink at all, but after the bill
passed, the president gathered his VP and a small group of senior aides to
celebrate over martinis in late March 2010. Obama was exhausted, and his outlook
on the condition of Washington was calcifying, but that night his confidence was
radiating and his glee was evident. Biden was downright impressed it had
actually worked. This was the massive overhaul for millions of Americans that
Democrats had been chasing since he was a baby. After Obama signed the bill into
law at a public event, the pair walked off side by side, clasping each other’s
backs, like nothing could separate them.
Ex-president and president in 2022. Photo: Adam Schultz/White House Photo/Alamy
Stock Photo
If reality and opposition have a way of ambushing presidents, it’s up to them
whether to adapt or bulldoze — or whether to learn any lessons at all. Fresh off
his reelection in 2012, Obama put aside his planned remarks at a Cabinet meeting
and began to riff. He predicted that they were entering a new era. If the vote
had shown anything, it was that the politics of obstruction had failed, Obama
said, and Americans wanted to see Washington drop pure partisanship and tackle
important issues. He’d told donors that he thought “the fever may break” once he
won again “because there’s a tradition in the Republican Party of more common
sense than that.” Now, he continued, it was time for his Cabinet to think big.
Obama didn’t know that he was about to embark on a five-month slide that would
turn his hope into the purest cynicism anyone had ever seen from him. Obama
usually hid his anger or expressed it in sarcasm, but after the Sandy Hook
massacre that December, and the failure to pass gun-control legislation the
following April, he seethed. If the murder of 20 little kids wasn’t going to jar
GOP lawmakers into cooperation, they were never going to get serious and work
with him on anything, were they? No, he concluded. Nothing had changed.
This was the great inflection point for Obama: He saw the political earth as
salted. For Biden, however, it was instructive but not decisive. He saw that
even the Republicans he considered reasonable were drifting away faster than
he’d realized, but he still thought he could get more done across the aisle if
given slightly more time and room to maneuver. In his eyes, there was no choice.
Even before that December’s horror, Biden’s faith on this point had begun to
irritate many of his fellow Democrats, some of whom suspected that the
Washington lifer was more interested in process than substance. Reid, for one,
had spent the first term privately dismissing the idea that Biden was Obama’s
true Senate whisperer. Reid and Biden were friendly but had never been
especially close, and Reid considered Biden both overly talkative and overly
self-assured. He sometimes told friends about the time he and Biden had faced
each other on a plane from Dallas to D.C. Looking at a clock above Biden’s head,
Reid timed him speaking for three hours and 18 minutes of the
three-hour-and-20-minute flight.
McConnell had a comically similar story about Biden. (The main differences were
that the flight had two legs and landed in Raleigh.) But he at least could stand
Biden, whereas he plainly disdained Obama, describing his negotiation sessions
with the president as visits to the principal where he’d get a condescending
lecture about how wrong he was before he could say a word. The dislike went both
ways. Obama understood, correctly, that McConnell would never negotiate in good
faith. There was little Obama hated more than the common D.C.-insider-crowd
insistence that he’d get more done legislatively if only he’d socialize more in
town. As he put it at 2013’s White House Correspondents’ Association Dinner,
“Some folks still don’t think I spend enough time with Congress. ‘Why don’t you
get a drink with Mitch McConnell?’ they ask. Really? Why don’t you get a drink
with Mitch McConnell?”
Biden didn’t like that joke. In the long list of Bidenisms, one of his favorites
was his promise never to question his colleagues’ motives. He considered
maintaining a good working relationship with McConnell an important part of his
job. They disagreed on almost everything but thought they understood each
other’s politics, even if Biden thought McConnell was overhyped as a tactician
and McConnell considered Biden a bit buffoonish. The relationship rarely bore
fruit, but it suited Biden and McConnell both; in 2011, Biden had even visited
the McConnell Center in Louisville to give a speech about bipartisanship. To
some in Obama’s inner circle, this was the whole problem. Biden fashioned
himself too much of a conciliator, they thought, and McConnell — who in 2010
admitted his goal was to make Obama “a one-term president” — was playing him.
This conviction was hardly diluted by Biden’s insistence that the White House
was always one deal away from breaking the obstruction. Yet in his negotiations,
Biden was always clear that he wasn’t the final decision-maker — Obama was.
That’s why he, too, was often frustrated: It was common to hear Biden gripe to
his aides that Obama was missing opportunities on the Hill by refusing to talk
to his former colleagues. “It’s like Obama is at a dinner table he’s never been
at before and doesn’t know it’s appropriate to ask them to pass the salt,” he’d
say in moments of candor. “There are just things he could do that he isn’t doing
that are offending people. Obama’s view is they’re never going to move. But
they’re people! They can be influenced!”
And in the final hours of 2012, it was Biden’s time to prove his point. The
so-called fiscal cliff was looming — an ugly combination of painful slashes to
government programs and tax increases that would automatically go into effect if
the Obama administration and Republicans in Congress couldn’t agree on a fix.
After weeks of wrangling, McConnell had walked away from Obama and Reid and —
with barely a day before the deadline — asked for Biden. The VP was thrilled to
oblige at this late hour, coming up with a plan with McConnell to maintain
Bush-era cuts for people earning under $400,000 and to impose a small tax hike
on the wealthiest Americans.
To many in the party, it was yet another handout to the rich and not worth
pursuing if the alternative — going off the cliff — might make the public
realize just how extreme the Republicans’ tactics had become. On Capitol Hill,
liberals were incensed and some moderates struggled to understand why they
shouldn’t hold out, figuring that McConnell had rolled Biden and that the
Democratic Party would lose its leverage on pocketbook issues. Reid warned the
caucus to treat Biden with respect but said he wouldn’t pressure them to go
along with the VP. The measure passed — Obama wanted it to, and no one wanted to
be blamed for yet another economic crisis — but Reid in particular struggled to
move on.
Later that year, he listened, aghast, as Biden spoke up at an Oval Office
negotiation that was intended to avert a government shutdown being forced by
Senator Ted Cruz. “We don’t want you to lose; we want you to win,” the
vice-president said to McConnell. He’d meant he wanted it all to be resolved in
a way that was acceptable to the part of the GOP he could still deal with, but
Reid called Obama after the session for some blunt talk. He still liked Biden,
he said, but Obama needed to bar him from this negotiation. Reid knew he could
call Republicans’ bluff and make the shutdown more politically painful for them
than for Obama. The president listened as Reid continued: We can’t have Biden
swooping in to make some deal with McConnell to reopen the government and let
Republicans declare victory.
Biden thought this perspective misread their mandate. When they needed GOP
cooperation to pass anything, or even to keep the government open, he had to
engage his hyperactive deal-making mode. It would be a different conversation if
Democrats had unified control of Washington with enough of a margin to pass
whatever they liked, but they no longer did and he was skeptical of Obama’s
faith in the power of public campaigning to create enough political pressure on
the opposition to do much of anything. The real work had to happen between
handshakes.
Obama agreed with Reid but stayed antsy and asked for regular updates. It took
16 days for the right-wingers to cave. Reid never let any of his aides disparage
Biden in front of Obama. But the message he gave the president was the polite
version of a refrain among some advisers in his office and some of the VP’s
critics within the White House, too: “Biden’s too horny for a deal.”
It was impossible to miss how much space Obama took up in Biden’s mind as he
began his own term as president. Biden was irritated by the idea, occasionally
shared on cable and especially in some corners of the conservative press, that
Obama had somehow carried him to electoral victory, that he was still pulling
the strings, or that Biden would simply be Obama 2.0. Yet when he gathered aides
for meetings in the Oval Office, Biden pointedly sat in the exact same spot
Obama had for eight years, and for a while he referred to his predecessor’s
accomplishments and remembered White House procedures as “the way we did it” in
“our administration.” For his first few months in office, he spoke openly of
learning the hard lessons of that tenure and leveraging them to far greater
effect.
At the same time, he occasionally vented to allies that he was floored to learn
how much of the Obama years’ progress had been unwound by Trump. He found
himself occupied with the question of how to first restore it, then how to
cement his own accomplishments to ensure they couldn’t be rolled back by the
next Republican president. As a result, one of his most frequent contentions was
that his administration had to be far more intentional about selling the stuff
he was passing to keep it popular, a point he’d tried making to Obama about
their first big bill back in 2009 — a stimulus to get the country out of the
subprime-mortgage and financial crises, which they opted not to brag about as
other crises arose.
He excitedly viewed the American Rescue Plan Act — his nearly $2 trillion
COVID-targeted relief bill — as an opportunity to test the proposition. Biden
welcomed the obvious comparisons to Obama’s stimulus, and he made sure the
legislation was packed with purposely easy-to-understand and popular provisions
designed to make an immediate impact. Shortly after it passed the House in late
February 2021, he appeared virtually for a gathering of congressional Democrats
and promised them that he wouldn’t repeat Obama’s error. “We didn’t adequately
explain what we had done. Barack was so modest he didn’t want to take, as he
said, a ‘victory lap.’ I kept saying, ‘Tell people what we did.’ He said, ‘We
don’t have time. I’m not going to take a victory lap.’ And we paid a price for
it, ironically, for that humility,” Biden recalled.
The American Rescue Plan’s passage was an almost ostentatious rapid-fire display
of lessons learned. With the excruciatingly drawn-out Obamacare experience of
2009 and 2010 in mind, Biden took one meeting with Senate Republicans, listened
to their proposal to cleave the plan to about a third of its size, and rejected
it. One immense advantage Biden enjoys is that parliamentary norms have changed.
Obama entered office in an era that demanded 60 votes in the Senate, but by now
simple-majority legislating — the use of the once-obscure process known as
reconciliation — is so common on major bills as to be unremarkable. Biden had
embraced some progressive-policy aggression during the campaign, and he was
unwilling to let Republican foot-dragging get in the way of progress if he
didn’t need GOP votes in the first place. He also advocated for fitting as many
programs as possible into this one bill. Biden was under no illusions that he
could return to the drawing board for a second round of funding legislation if
he needed to — another mistaken assumption more than a decade earlier. When the
bill briefly appeared to be imperiled by last-minute hesitancy from Manchin,
Biden called him directly and worked with Schumer to address his concerns,
managing to keep all 50 Democratic senators onside.
It looked like Biden had cracked the governing code, improbably delivering the
kind of widely celebrated change he’d campaigned on. But Biden’s bliss soon
crashed. His chaotic exit from Afghanistan dovetailed with a resurgent COVID
variant and ever more fevered Republican recalcitrance, and by late summer 2021,
hardly anyone remembered the specifics of the relief bill Biden put so much
stock into selling. The follow-up social-spending bill he proposed had a
forbiddingly long road to being taken seriously by many lawmakers, let alone
passing.
The parallels to Obama’s most frustrating moments were inescapable. Biden once
liked to point out that McConnell had given a tribute to him on the Senate floor
about their mutual trust and had even named a cancer-research-funding provision
of a bill after Biden’s deceased son, Beau. Four months into Biden’s presidency,
though, McConnell said that “100 percent of our focus is on stopping this new
administration,” an echo of his 2010 pledge to ensure Obama served a single
term. No one was too surprised a few weeks later when the third-ranking GOP
senator, John Barrasso, raised the bar by arguing that Biden should be “a
one-half-term president.”
At the same time, Biden was distracted by infighting on his own side with
Democratic centrists threatening combat against progressives who wanted him to
pursue even more massive social investments. For months, Biden seemed like both
a victim of his own floridly set expectations of a new FDR-inspired era — an
idea that blossomed back when he’d expected a more heavily Democratic Senate —
and a man who could learn only so many new tricks as he approached the sixth
decade of his life in elected office. Even among his supporters, it was possible
to read Biden’s first 12 months as either a loose microcosm of the Obama years
or, more likely, as their frustrating natural next step in the face of
unrelenting right-wing attacks on the legitimacy of the democratic system
itself.
Many around Biden didn’t know exactly how to feel this spring when Obama showed
up at the White House for the first time since handing Trump the keys five years
earlier. Biden understood that he simply wouldn’t be the center of anyone’s
attention that Tuesday afternoon, and he settled into a familiar posture, half a
step behind his former boss. When Obama stood at the microphones and promptly
called the commander-in-chief “Vice-President Biden,” the sitting president
waited half a beat before laughing rowdily, as if to signal to the cameras that
he was in on the joke. Obama’s appearance was meant to be a mood booster, but
not everyone in Biden’s immediate orbit found the gag all that funny, and some
light grumbling about respect ensued within earshot of the White House press
corps. Still, even the most fervent Biden loyalists seemed eager to soak in
Obama’s nearly wistful glow for an afternoon to distract themselves from the
president’s own sinking ratings and frustrations.
That was the context in which Obama watched his partner and successor on
Martha’s Vineyard as the summer of 2022 began. They never spoke about what
should come next — they still haven’t discussed 2024, as has been inaccurately
reported. (Obama, though, is making initial plans to back candidates for
governor and state-level offices that will administer that election.) But both
have taken time to consider their joint and individual legacies, which sit at
the edge of an anti-democratic abyss; each has privately admitted to feeling the
weight of the moment as Trump acolytes amass primary wins and threaten the
future of free elections.
As Biden’s polling sank on a Jimmy Carter–esque trajectory, it might have been
reasonable to chalk up his initial legislative feats to a smart use of early but
limited political capital — especially considering how quickly the Democratic
coalition on the Hill then started to crack — and conclude all the other
responsibilities of the Oval Office and the vectors of 2022’s unforgiving
politics were simply swamping him. Yet that’s also why the climate-focused deal
represented a genuine breakthrough for the 79-year-old president, who’d begun
facing calls from some elected Democrats in Washington to retire. It appeared to
reaffirm Biden’s essential approach to politics and his oft-contested theory of
change: Dealmongering isn’t dead after all, no matter the president’s age or his
political shortcomings and even if he isn’t the one directly negotiating the
lines of legislative text. Presidents set the context.
Biden could well continue to suffer low approval ratings and the abandonment of
factions of his party, even as he continues to deliver prizes of staggering
scale. In late August, he said he would forgive hundreds of billions in student
loans. Progressives complained loudly that he could have been even more
generous; moderates expressed skepticism about the move’s political wisdom. It’s
tempting to imagine what might have gone through Biden’s head after eight years
at Obama’s side and now two on his own: Do you think the last Democrat would’ve
done any better?
The Long Alliance: The Imperfect Union of Joe Biden and Barack Obama, by Gabriel
Debenedetti
$29
$29
Buy at Amazon
Buy
$30 at Macmillan
Buy
Thank you for subscribing and supporting our journalism. If you prefer to read
in print, you can also find this article in the August 29, 2022, issue of New
York Magazine.
Want more stories like this one? Subscribe now to support our journalism and get
unlimited access to our coverage. If you prefer to read in print, you can also
find this article in the August 29, 2022, issue of New York Magazine.
ONE GREAT STORY: A NIGHTLY NEWSLETTER FOR THE BEST OF NEW YORK
The one story you shouldn’t miss today, selected by New York’s editors.
Email
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of
Service apply.
Vox Media, LLC Terms and Privacy Notice
By submitting your email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Notice and to
receive email correspondence from us.
TAGS:
* politics
* joe biden
* barack obama
* the white house
* book excerpt
* new york magazine
* one great story
* More
48Comments 48 Leave a Comment
Who’s the Change Agent Now?
Things you buy through our links may earn New York a commission.
MOST VIEWED STORIES
1. Who’s the Change Agent Now?
2. Trump’s Document Lies Have Been Exposed. All He Has Left Are Threats.
3. The Last, Lonely Days of Ivana Trump
4. Mehmet Oz Recently Flip-Flopped to an Extreme Abortion Stance
5. Trump’s Gossip on Macron’s Sex Life Can’t Be That Good
1. Who’s the Change Agent Now?
2. The Last, Lonely Days of Ivana Trump
3. Trump’s Document Lies Have Been Exposed. All He Has Left Are Threats.
4. The Infamous FBI Informant Behind a 20-Fatality Limo Crash
5. Mehmet Oz Recently Flip-Flopped to an Extreme Abortion Stance
EDITOR’S PICKS
* encounter
I Hate How Much I Don’t Hate Nick Viall’s Dating Advice I Hate How Much I
Don’t Hate Nick Viall’s Dating Advice
* the speech wars
The Marketing Veterans Leading a New Campaign to Defund the Right Marketing
Veterans Lead a New Campaign to Defund the Right
* the year i ate new york
Pretending to Vacation in Bushwick Pretending to Vacation in Bushwick
MOST VIEWED STORIES
1. Who’s the Change Agent Now?
2. Trump’s Document Lies Have Been Exposed. All He Has Left Are Threats.
3. The Last, Lonely Days of Ivana Trump
4. Mehmet Oz Recently Flip-Flopped to an Extreme Abortion Stance
5. Trump’s Gossip on Macron’s Sex Life Can’t Be That Good
1. Who’s the Change Agent Now?
2. The Last, Lonely Days of Ivana Trump
3. Trump’s Document Lies Have Been Exposed. All He Has Left Are Threats.
4. The Infamous FBI Informant Behind a 20-Fatality Limo Crash
5. Mehmet Oz Recently Flip-Flopped to an Extreme Abortion Stance
EDITOR’S PICKS
* encounter
I Hate How Much I Don’t Hate Nick Viall’s Dating Advice I Hate How Much I
Don’t Hate Nick Viall’s Dating Advice
* the speech wars
The Marketing Veterans Leading a New Campaign to Defund the Right Marketing
Veterans Lead a New Campaign to Defund the Right
* the year i ate new york
Pretending to Vacation in Bushwick Pretending to Vacation in Bushwick
MOST VIEWED STORIES
1. Who’s the Change Agent Now?
2. Trump’s Document Lies Have Been Exposed. All He Has Left Are Threats.
3. The Last, Lonely Days of Ivana Trump
4. Mehmet Oz Recently Flip-Flopped to an Extreme Abortion Stance
5. Trump’s Gossip on Macron’s Sex Life Can’t Be That Good
1. Who’s the Change Agent Now?
2. The Last, Lonely Days of Ivana Trump
3. Trump’s Document Lies Have Been Exposed. All He Has Left Are Threats.
4. The Infamous FBI Informant Behind a 20-Fatality Limo Crash
5. Mehmet Oz Recently Flip-Flopped to an Extreme Abortion Stance
EDITOR’S PICKS
* encounter
I Hate How Much I Don’t Hate Nick Viall’s Dating Advice I Hate How Much I
Don’t Hate Nick Viall’s Dating Advice
* the speech wars
The Marketing Veterans Leading a New Campaign to Defund the Right Marketing
Veterans Lead a New Campaign to Defund the Right
* the year i ate new york
Pretending to Vacation in Bushwick Pretending to Vacation in Bushwick
MOST VIEWED STORIES
1. Who’s the Change Agent Now?
2. Trump’s Document Lies Have Been Exposed. All He Has Left Are Threats.
3. The Last, Lonely Days of Ivana Trump
4. Mehmet Oz Recently Flip-Flopped to an Extreme Abortion Stance
5. Trump’s Gossip on Macron’s Sex Life Can’t Be That Good
1. Who’s the Change Agent Now?
2. The Last, Lonely Days of Ivana Trump
3. Trump’s Document Lies Have Been Exposed. All He Has Left Are Threats.
4. The Infamous FBI Informant Behind a 20-Fatality Limo Crash
5. Mehmet Oz Recently Flip-Flopped to an Extreme Abortion Stance
PLAY Top Articles Video Settings Full Screen About Connatix V179619 Read More
Read More Read More Read More Read More Read More Did Republicans Pick Trump
Because Democrats Were Mean to Romney? 1/1 Skip Ad Continue watching after the
ad Visit Advertiser websiteGO TO PAGE
THE FEED
12:11 p.m.
the national interest
the national interest
Did Republicans Pick Trump Because Democrats Were Mean to Romney?
By Jonathan Chait
No. No, they didn’t.
10:52 a.m.
early and often
early and often
Sarah Palin’s Comeback Fails, Sending Democrat Mary Peltola to Congress
By Ed Kilgore
Republican divisions and voters’ distaste for Palin helped give Peltola, an
Alaska Native, a narrow win in Alaska’s special election.
10:35 a.m.
extremely online
extremely online
Twitter’s Edit Button Is for Cowards
By Sarah Jones
This website sucks. Somehow, it’s going to get worse.
MOST POPULAR
1. Who’s the Change Agent Now?
By Gabriel Debenedetti
2. Trump’s Document Lies Have Been Exposed. All He Has Left Are Threats.
By Jonathan Chait
3. The Last, Lonely Days of Ivana Trump
By Nina Burleigh
4. Mehmet Oz Recently Flip-Flopped to an Extreme Abortion Stance
By Ed Kilgore
5. Trump’s Gossip on Macron’s Sex Life Can’t Be That Good
By Margaret Hartmann
1. Who’s the Change Agent Now?
By Gabriel Debenedetti
2. The Last, Lonely Days of Ivana Trump
By Nina Burleigh
3. Trump’s Document Lies Have Been Exposed. All He Has Left Are Threats.
By Jonathan Chait
4. The Infamous FBI Informant Behind a 20-Fatality Limo Crash
By Ben Ryder Howe
5. Mehmet Oz Recently Flip-Flopped to an Extreme Abortion Stance
By Ed Kilgore
8:00 a.m.
the speech wars
the speech wars
The Marketing Veterans Leading a New Campaign to Defund the Right
By Colin Moynihan
A Sleeping Giants veteran and her partner pioneered a new way to fight
disinformation. Is it accountability or censorship?
8/31/2022
covid
covid
America’s COVID Testing Regime Is Somehow Still a Travesty
By Ross Barkan
Tests remain way too expensive, and nobody in power really seems to care.
8/31/2022
early and often
early and often
Mehmet Oz Recently Flip-Flopped to an Extreme Abortion Stance
By Ed Kilgore
And now the GOP Senate candidate may need to flip right back as he struggles to
catch up with Democratic opponent John Fetterman.
8/31/2022
life after roe
life after roe
Vulnerable Anti-abortion House Republicans Set a Trap for Themselves
By Ed Kilgore
Pre-Dobbs, at-risk House Republicans bent the knee to the anti-abortion movement
by backing a federal “personhood” statute. Now it actually matters.
8/31/2022
what we know
what we know
Top-Secret Documents at Trump’s Mar-a-Lago: What We Know
By Intelligencer Staff
In a scathing court filing, the Justice Department says it found evidence that
Trump and his team hid classified papers and misled investigators.
8/31/2022
the national interest
the national interest
Trump’s Document Lies Have Been Exposed. All He Has Left Are Threats.
By Jonathan Chait
The Justice Department strips bare the former president’s defense.
8/30/2022
infrastructure
infrastructure
Mississippi’s Largest City Doesn’t Have Enough Water
By Chas Danner
Jackson’s long-plagued water system has effectively collapsed, leaving the more
than 150,000 residents of the majority Black city in crisis.
8/30/2022
tremendous content
tremendous content
Trump’s Gossip on Macron’s Sex Life Can’t Be That Good
By Margaret Hartmann
One of the papers seized in the Mar-a-Lago raid contains “info re: President of
France.” But could Trump really keep “tawdry” Macron dirt to himself?
8/30/2022
He tore down the Iron Curtain
Mikhail S. Gorbachev, whose rise to power in the Soviet Union set in motion a
series of revolutionary changes that transformed the map of Europe and ended the
Cold War that had threatened the world with nuclear annihilation, has died in
Moscow. He was 91. His death was announced on Tuesday by Russia’s state news
agencies, citing the city’s central clinical hospital. The reports said he had
died after an unspecified “long and grave illness.”
Mikhail S. Gorbachev, Reformist Soviet Leader, Is Dead at 91
—The New York Times
8/30/2022
2022 midterms
2022 midterms
Blake Masters Has a Lot of Thoughts About Black People
By Matt Stieb
He says Kamala Harris is not qualified to be vice-president, diversity hurts the
economy, and the gun scourge is the fault of “Black people, frankly.”
8/30/2022
tennis
tennis
Don’t Sleep on Tommy Paul
By Caira Conner
The former phenom is now 25, a little bit wiser, and finally making good on his
early potential.
8/30/2022
early and often
early and often
Impeaching Biden Will Be Job One If Republicans Win the House
By Ed Kilgore
Speaker McCarthy will face intense pressure from the party’s MAGA wing to
impeach Biden, setting up a performative Senate trial heading into 2024.
8/30/2022
court appearances
court appearances
Elon Musk’s Got a New Plan to Not Buy Twitter
By Kevin T. Dugan
In order to get out of buying Twitter, it appears the Tesla CEO is abandoning
his old legal arguments about spambots. Now he’s alleging fraud.
8/30/2022
q&a
q&a
Why Effective Altruists Fear the AI Apocalypse
By Eric Levitz
A conversation with the philosopher William MacAskill.
8/30/2022
business
business
Milk Money: The Start-Ups Racing to Shake Up the Baby Formula Industry
By Reeves Wiedeman
The national shortage that wreaked havoc for parents created an opening in the
$4 billion market.
8/29/2022
Biden wants some prime time
President Joe Biden plans to deliver a prime-time speech this week about how
America’s “rights and freedoms are still under attack,” returning to the core
message of his 2020 campaign as Americans are getting ready to vote in
the November midterm elections. A White House official said Thursday’s address
at Independence National Historical Park in Philadelphia would focus on “the
continued battle for the soul of the nation” and show how the president sees the
central argument of his 2020 candidacy remains as salient as ever with the
midterm elections coming into clearer focus.
Biden to give prime-time speech about 'soul of the nation' as voters prepare to
cast midterm ballots
—NBC News
8/29/2022
what we know
what we know
What Is Going On at Ukraine’s Zaporizhzhia Nuclear Power Plant?
By Chas Danner
The threat of catastrophic accident persists amid heavy fighting in the area. A
team from the International Atomic Energy Agency is en route.
8/29/2022
early and often
early and often
Trump Demands Unconstitutional Do-over of 2020 Election
By Ed Kilgore
After a dubious poll about Hunter Biden’s laptop, Trump is now blaming his loss
on an FBI conspiracy — and his supporters probably believe him.
8/29/2022
the national interest
the national interest
The Conservative Case for Letting Trump Obstruct Justice
By Jonathan Chait
A new legal doctrine emerges on the right.
8/29/2022
vision 2024
vision 2024
Please Shut Up About Liz Cheney or Larry Hogan in 2024
By Ed Kilgore
The media should quit indulging what is almost disinformation about their White
House aspirations.
8/29/2022
to the moon
to the moon
Long-Delayed Moonshot Delayed Yet Again
By Chas Danner
A last-minute engine issue forced NASA to postpone the big launch of its new
moon rocket.
8/29/2022
early and often
early and often
It’s Not Good to Mock the Payroll Protection Program
By Ross Barkan
Democrats have been delighting in Republican hypocrisy, mocking the GOP for
taking PPP loans while opposing student-debt reform — a risky argument.
8/29/2022
covid-19
covid-19
How to Order More Free Home COVID Tests From the Government
By Margaret Hartmann
U.S. residents who want to order the free tests must now do so before September
2, when the program will be suspended.
Sign In to Comment
Email You\'ll receive the next newsletter in your inbox. *Sorry, there was a
problem signing you up.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of
Service apply.
or
Already a subscriber? Sign In
WHAT IS YOUR EMAIL?
This email will be used to sign into all New York sites. By submitting your
email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy and to receive email
correspondence from us.
Enter your email: Please enter a valid email address.
Submit Email
or
Connect with Google Connect with Facebook
Sign in
|
Subscribe Today
SIGN IN TO CONTINUE READING
CREATE YOUR FREE ACCOUNT
edit email
Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Google
Choose a password to create an account: Enter your password orsign in with a
different email
Forgot Password?
Password must be at least 8 characters and contain:
* Lower case letters (a-z)
* Upper case letters (A-Z)
* Numbers (0-9)
* Special Characters (!@#$%^&*)
This password will be used to sign into all New York sites. By submitting your
email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy and to receive email
correspondence from us.
Sign In Create Account
YOU’RE IN!
As part of your account, you’ll receive occasional updates and offers from New
York, which you can opt out of anytime.
Continue Reading
or
Already a subscriber? Sign In
WHAT IS YOUR EMAIL?
This email will be used to sign into all New York sites. By submitting your
email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy and to receive email
correspondence from us.
Enter your email: Please enter a valid email address.
Submit Email
or
Connect with Google Connect with Facebook
Sign in
|
Subscribe Today
SIGN IN TO CONTINUE READING
CREATE YOUR FREE ACCOUNT
edit email
Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Google
Choose a password to create an account: Enter your password orsign in with a
different email
Forgot Password?
Password must be at least 8 characters and contain:
* Lower case letters (a-z)
* Upper case letters (A-Z)
* Numbers (0-9)
* Special Characters (!@#$%^&*)
This password will be used to sign into all New York sites. By submitting your
email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy and to receive email
correspondence from us.
Sign In Create Account
YOU’RE IN!
As part of your account, you’ll receive occasional updates and offers from New
York, which you can opt out of anytime.
Continue Reading
Already a subscriber? Sign In
View Account Log Out
Already a subscriber? Sign In
View Account Log Out
Email You\'ll receive the next newsletter in your inbox. *Sorry, there was a
problem signing you up.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of
Service apply.
or
Already a subscriber? Sign In
WHAT IS YOUR EMAIL?
This email will be used to sign into all New York sites. By submitting your
email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy and to receive email
correspondence from us.
Enter your email: Please enter a valid email address.
Submit Email
or
Connect with Google Connect with Facebook
Sign in
|
Subscribe Today
SIGN IN TO CONTINUE READING
CREATE YOUR FREE ACCOUNT
edit email
Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Google
Choose a password to create an account: Enter your password orsign in with a
different email
Forgot Password?
Password must be at least 8 characters and contain:
* Lower case letters (a-z)
* Upper case letters (A-Z)
* Numbers (0-9)
* Special Characters (!@#$%^&*)
This password will be used to sign into all New York sites. By submitting your
email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy and to receive email
correspondence from us.
Sign In Create Account
YOU’RE IN!
As part of your account, you’ll receive occasional updates and offers from New
York, which you can opt out of anytime.
Continue Reading
or
Already a subscriber? Sign In
WHAT IS YOUR EMAIL?
This email will be used to sign into all New York sites. By submitting your
email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy and to receive email
correspondence from us.
Enter your email: Please enter a valid email address.
Submit Email
or
Connect with Google Connect with Facebook
Sign in
|
Subscribe Today
SIGN IN TO CONTINUE READING
CREATE YOUR FREE ACCOUNT
edit email
Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Google
Choose a password to create an account: Enter your password orsign in with a
different email
Forgot Password?
Password must be at least 8 characters and contain:
* Lower case letters (a-z)
* Upper case letters (A-Z)
* Numbers (0-9)
* Special Characters (!@#$%^&*)
This password will be used to sign into all New York sites. By submitting your
email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy and to receive email
correspondence from us.
Sign In Create Account
YOU’RE IN!
As part of your account, you’ll receive occasional updates and offers from New
York, which you can opt out of anytime.
Continue Reading
Already a subscriber? Sign In
View Account Log Out
Already a subscriber? Sign In
View Account Log Out
Email You\'ll receive the next newsletter in your inbox. *Sorry, there was a
problem signing you up.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of
Service apply.
or
Already a subscriber? Sign In
WHAT IS YOUR EMAIL?
This email will be used to sign into all New York sites. By submitting your
email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy and to receive email
correspondence from us.
Enter your email: Please enter a valid email address.
Submit Email
or
Connect with Google Connect with Facebook
Sign in
|
Subscribe Today
SIGN IN TO CONTINUE READING
CREATE YOUR FREE ACCOUNT
edit email
Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Google
Choose a password to create an account: Enter your password orsign in with a
different email
Forgot Password?
Password must be at least 8 characters and contain:
* Lower case letters (a-z)
* Upper case letters (A-Z)
* Numbers (0-9)
* Special Characters (!@#$%^&*)
This password will be used to sign into all New York sites. By submitting your
email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy and to receive email
correspondence from us.
Sign In Create Account
YOU’RE IN!
As part of your account, you’ll receive occasional updates and offers from New
York, which you can opt out of anytime.
Continue Reading
or
Already a subscriber? Sign In
WHAT IS YOUR EMAIL?
This email will be used to sign into all New York sites. By submitting your
email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy and to receive email
correspondence from us.
Enter your email: Please enter a valid email address.
Submit Email
or
Connect with Google Connect with Facebook
Sign in
|
Subscribe Today
SIGN IN TO CONTINUE READING
CREATE YOUR FREE ACCOUNT
edit email
Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Google
Choose a password to create an account: Enter your password orsign in with a
different email
Forgot Password?
Password must be at least 8 characters and contain:
* Lower case letters (a-z)
* Upper case letters (A-Z)
* Numbers (0-9)
* Special Characters (!@#$%^&*)
This password will be used to sign into all New York sites. By submitting your
email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy and to receive email
correspondence from us.
Sign In Create Account
YOU’RE IN!
As part of your account, you’ll receive occasional updates and offers from New
York, which you can opt out of anytime.
Continue Reading
Already a subscriber? Sign In
View Account Log Out
Already a subscriber? Sign In
View Account Log Out
Email You\'ll receive the next newsletter in your inbox. *Sorry, there was a
problem signing you up.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of
Service apply.
or
Already a subscriber? Sign In
WHAT IS YOUR EMAIL?
This email will be used to sign into all New York sites. By submitting your
email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy and to receive email
correspondence from us.
Enter your email: Please enter a valid email address.
Submit Email
or
Connect with Google Connect with Facebook
Sign in
|
Subscribe Today
SIGN IN TO CONTINUE READING
CREATE YOUR FREE ACCOUNT
edit email
Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Google
Choose a password to create an account: Enter your password orsign in with a
different email
Forgot Password?
Password must be at least 8 characters and contain:
* Lower case letters (a-z)
* Upper case letters (A-Z)
* Numbers (0-9)
* Special Characters (!@#$%^&*)
This password will be used to sign into all New York sites. By submitting your
email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy and to receive email
correspondence from us.
Sign In Create Account
YOU’RE IN!
As part of your account, you’ll receive occasional updates and offers from New
York, which you can opt out of anytime.
Continue Reading
or
Already a subscriber? Sign In
WHAT IS YOUR EMAIL?
This email will be used to sign into all New York sites. By submitting your
email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy and to receive email
correspondence from us.
Enter your email: Please enter a valid email address.
Submit Email
or
Connect with Google Connect with Facebook
Sign in
|
Subscribe Today
SIGN IN TO CONTINUE READING
CREATE YOUR FREE ACCOUNT
edit email
Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Google
Choose a password to create an account: Enter your password orsign in with a
different email
Forgot Password?
Password must be at least 8 characters and contain:
* Lower case letters (a-z)
* Upper case letters (A-Z)
* Numbers (0-9)
* Special Characters (!@#$%^&*)
This password will be used to sign into all New York sites. By submitting your
email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy and to receive email
correspondence from us.
Sign In Create Account
YOU’RE IN!
As part of your account, you’ll receive occasional updates and offers from New
York, which you can opt out of anytime.
Continue Reading
Already a subscriber? Sign In
View Account Log Out
Already a subscriber? Sign In
View Account Log Out
Email You\'ll receive the next newsletter in your inbox. *Sorry, there was a
problem signing you up.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of
Service apply.
or
Already a subscriber? Sign In
WHAT IS YOUR EMAIL?
This email will be used to sign into all New York sites. By submitting your
email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy and to receive email
correspondence from us.
Enter your email: Please enter a valid email address.
Submit Email
or
Connect with Google Connect with Facebook
Sign in
|
Subscribe Today
SIGN IN TO CONTINUE READING
CREATE YOUR FREE ACCOUNT
edit email
Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Google
Choose a password to create an account: Enter your password orsign in with a
different email
Forgot Password?
Password must be at least 8 characters and contain:
* Lower case letters (a-z)
* Upper case letters (A-Z)
* Numbers (0-9)
* Special Characters (!@#$%^&*)
This password will be used to sign into all New York sites. By submitting your
email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy and to receive email
correspondence from us.
Sign In Create Account
YOU’RE IN!
As part of your account, you’ll receive occasional updates and offers from New
York, which you can opt out of anytime.
Continue Reading
or
Already a subscriber? Sign In
WHAT IS YOUR EMAIL?
This email will be used to sign into all New York sites. By submitting your
email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy and to receive email
correspondence from us.
Enter your email: Please enter a valid email address.
Submit Email
or
Connect with Google Connect with Facebook
Sign in
|
Subscribe Today
SIGN IN TO CONTINUE READING
CREATE YOUR FREE ACCOUNT
edit email
Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Google
Choose a password to create an account: Enter your password orsign in with a
different email
Forgot Password?
Password must be at least 8 characters and contain:
* Lower case letters (a-z)
* Upper case letters (A-Z)
* Numbers (0-9)
* Special Characters (!@#$%^&*)
This password will be used to sign into all New York sites. By submitting your
email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy and to receive email
correspondence from us.
Sign In Create Account
YOU’RE IN!
As part of your account, you’ll receive occasional updates and offers from New
York, which you can opt out of anytime.
Continue Reading
Already a subscriber? Sign In
View Account Log Out
Already a subscriber? Sign In
View Account Log Out
Like Us Follow Us
* Newsletters
* About Us
* Help
* Contact
* Media Kit
* We’re Hiring
* Press
* Privacy
* Terms
* Ad Choices
* Do Not Sell My Info
* Accessibility
intelligencer is a Vox Media Network. © 2022 Vox Media, LLC. All rights
reserved.