gaycitynews.com Open in urlscan Pro
141.193.213.20  Public Scan

Form analysis
3 forms found in the DOM

GET /

<form role="search" method="get" class="search-form" action="/">
  <label>
    <span class="screen-reader-text">Search:</span>
    <input type="search" class="search-field" placeholder="Search" value="" name="s">
  </label>
  <button type="submit" class="basic-button bkg-main search-submit icon-search-basic" value="Search"><i class="fa fa-search" aria-hidden="true" aria-label="Search"></i></button>
</form>

GET /

<form role="search" method="get" class="search-form" action="/">
  <label>
    <span class="screen-reader-text">Search:</span>
    <input type="search" class="search-field" placeholder="Search" value="" name="s">
  </label>
  <button type="submit" class="basic-button bkg-main search-submit icon-search-basic" value="Search"><i class="fa fa-search" aria-hidden="true" aria-label="Search"></i></button>
</form>

Name: mc-embedded-subscribe-form — POST https://brooklynpaper.us7.list-manage.com/subscribe/post?u=1b2948b7c6ab19db3239219c9&id=01275da059

<form action="https://brooklynpaper.us7.list-manage.com/subscribe/post?u=1b2948b7c6ab19db3239219c9&amp;id=01275da059" method="post" id="mc-embedded-subscribe-form" name="mc-embedded-subscribe-form" class="validate" target="_blank"
  novalidate="novalidate">
  <div id="mce-responses" class="clear">
    <div class="response" id="mce-error-response" style="display:none"></div>
    <div class="response" id="mce-success-response" style="display:none"></div>
  </div>
  <div id="mc_embed_signup_scroll">
    <input type="email" value="" name="EMAIL" class="required email" id="mce-EMAIL" placeholder="Enter Email" aria-required="true">
    <input type="text" value="" name="MMERGE11" class="" id="mce-MMERGE11" placeholder="Zip">
    <!-- real people should not fill this in and expect good things - do not remove this or risk form bot signups-->
    <div style="position: absolute; left: -5000px;" aria-hidden="true"><input type="text" name="b_1b2948b7c6ab19db3239219c9_173f3d1250" tabindex="-1" value=""></div>
    <input type="submit" value="Subscribe" name="subscribe" id="mc-embedded-subscribe" class="button basic-button bkg-main">
  </div>
</form>

Text Content

 * Jobs
 * News
   * All
   * Arts
   * Crime
   * Politics
   * Perspectives
 * Things to Do
   * Local Events
   * Post an Event
   * Business Events
   * Games
 * Contact Us
 * Digital Editions
 * Webinars
 * Podcasts

Search:

 * Search:

 * News
 * All
 * Arts
 * Crime
 * Politics
 * Perspectives

 * Things to Do
 * Local Events
 * Post an Event
 * Business Events
 * Games

 * Jobs
 * Contact Us
 * Digital Editions
 * Webinars
 * Podcasts
    * 

Guest Perspective


WE NEED TO WALK AWAY FROM THE “PROGRESS” PROFIT FLAG

By Matt Foreman

comments
Posted on September 20, 2022
A Progress Pride Flag on display in Washington, DC.
Ted Eytan/Wikimedia Commons

Sign up for our amNY Sports email newsletter to get insights and game coverage
for your favorite teams
FacebookTwitterShare

Over the last two years, there has been a push to adopt the Progress Pride Flag
as “the” flag for the LGBTQIA+ community, supplanting the iconic rainbow flag.
(This flag put a wedge of the Trans Flag colors of light blue, pink, and white
and black on brown stripes in the rainbow flag.) The impulse to do that is
understandable: we are going through a long-overdue period of reckoning over
racism in our nation and our community, and there is an obvious need to elevate
our support for trans people as they are under attack as never before.



Sadly, what I have learned about the shady and unknown backstory of the
“Progress” Pride Flag requires all of us to stop using or promoting it until its
creator makes amends for its flagrant pride profiteering. And, even if the
goddess prevails and that happens, I do not believe this flag should be imposed
on us as the new symbol for all of us.



It’s Profiteering, Period.

Most people do not know about this flag’s origins. Its creator appropriated
Gilbert Baker’s 1978 rainbow flag and the light blue, pink, and white stripes
from the 1999 trans pride flag created by Monica Helms (without even a call to
her), and the black and brown stripes from the 2017 More Colors More Pride Flag
designed in partnership with Philadelphia’s Office of LGBT Affairs
and then proceeded to LICENSE THE DESIGN FOR PROFIT.

To the best of anyone’s knowledge, none of the creators of the now more than
90+(!) Pride Flags are imposing a fee to reproduce their designs. This proud
tradition goes back to 1979, when now-legendary LGBTQ rights lawyer Matt Coles
helped Gilbert Baker prevent the San Francisco pride organization from
copyrighting the rainbow flag.

But NOT the Profiteer-“Progress” Flag. 

The “Progress” Pride Flag license is not a free-use, public domain license. It
requires that anyone reproducing the flag or its design commercially (meaning
virtually any manufacturer) to get permission and pay a fee to its creator.
Those fees are passed on to anyone who purchases a “Progress” Pride Flag online
or at a retail outlet. Every time anyone buys a “Progress” Pride Flag or pin, or
sticker, etc., money is going into the pocket of its creator.

The “Progress” Pride Flag creator is quite open about this, saying on their
website, “We want you to be able to use the design in your work, but we also
want to make sure that it is used properly, that it still supports the message
of the flag, and supports the creator of the work.” The designer even charges
a tiered fee based on the size the entity requesting permission to duplicate it.

Appropriating the creative work of others without consent and for profit is
wrong.

The profit in this adventure is significant.

Other 2’X3’ hand-sewn nylon pride flags at Cliff’s Hardware in San Francisco,
for example, run from $28 (the Rainbow and Bi Pride Flags) to $40 (Leather and
Bear Flags, which have more complicated designs). Anyone wanting a licensed,
sewn “Progress” Pride Flag must fork over $125! Even a cheaply printed-on-fabric
“Progress” Pride Flag costs $55 at the creator’s online store. (If you’ve been
able to get it less expensively, you got a “bootleg” version, most likely from
abroad.) The San Francisco International Airport recently paid $179.95 for a
single 5’X8’ “Progress” flag — 150% more than the Rainbow Flag. Come on!

Here’s the truth:

If this were about elevating and supporting queer people of color and trans
people then 100% of the profits would be donated to people of color and trans
organizations! The creator is no longer reporting on how much is being donated
back to the community, but the last time they did it was around $8,000.
Pathetic.

All of this spits in the face of the artists/activists who have created Pride
Flags over the years and given their designs freely for all to use. Almost all
of these creators live on the financial edge, including Gilbert Baker, who
struggled with being poor his entire life.

To me, this means we all need to reject the “Progress” Pride Flag until its
creator (a) drops the license; (b) apologizes to the artists from whom they
appropriated their work; (c) opens their books to provide a full accounting of
the licensing fee profits to date; and (d) donates 100% of those profits to
organizations serving trans and queer people of color.

When the “Progress” Pride Flag creator does this, and if this flag speaks to
your heart, then, by all means, fly it proudly! There is plenty of room in the
sky for all our community’s non-profiteering flags.

In reality, as a symbol of inclusion the “Progress” flag is a cop out.

Even if these conditions are met, however, I do not think we can allow the
“Progress” flag to be imposed on us as “the” flag for the entire LGBTQIA+
community. Why?

Beyond its simplicity and the millennial-old reverence for the rainbow, the
reason the rainbow flag has been embraced by queer people around the world is
because it does not purport to represent specific races, sexual orientations,
gender identities, or nationalities. Rather, Gilbert Baker and their co-creators
made it for “all genders, all races, all ages, the rainbow of humanity.” The
colors for the flag represent “universal elements in all of us” not identities.

It is precisely because it embraces all of us, the rainbow flag has been
adopted worldwide. Queer people from Uganda to Poland to Indonesia to Ukraine to
Cuba to Saudi Arabia have and are using it to unite and fight, often knowing
that under its banner they risk being beaten, imprisoned, or even executed.

On the other hand, I believe the “Progress” Pride flag’s inclusion of trans and
brown/black queer people — undeniably, marginalized and suffering communities —
but not others is inherently divisive and exclusionary.

Bisexual people make up more than half of all LGBTQIA+ people and are
disproportionately impacted by discrimination, violence, and health disparities.
Where are the colors of their flag? What about Indigenous Two-Spirit people, who
by any measure suffer greater rates of suicide, poverty, and discrimination than
other queer people in the US? Where are the two feathers from their Pride Flag?
What about Asian Pacific Islanders in our community, who are now suffering an
explosion in hate violence? Where are the represented in the “Progress” Pride
Flag? Any thinking queer person can see the success of recent efforts to erase
lesbian history and make our sisters invisible. Yet, four of the five colors on
the most recognized Lesbian Pride Flag are missing from the “Progress” Pride
Flag. Why?

For me, the “Progress” flag as a symbol of inclusion is an ultimate cop out. It
allows people, queer organizations, and businesses a way to pretend they are
“inclusive” of trans and Brown/Black people without putting any capital on the
line. If they actually wanted to show their support for trans people, they
should fly Monica’s Trans Pride Flag, period. (What, worried about being seen as
trans?)  If they want to take a stand for queer Black people, they should have
the guts to fly the Black Pride or the Black Lives Matter Flag. (What, too in
your face?) You get my point.

Please, let’s all take a stand against the particularly egregious example of
pride profiteering embodied by the “Progress” Pride Flag until it makes amends,
support all the queer people that have freely given our community its vibrant
diversity of pride flags, and rejoice in the reality that the rainbow embraces
each one of us, no matter our race, gender identity/expression, sexual
orientation, nationality, ethnicity, or any other identity you hold in your
heart!

Matt Foreman has been actively involved in the LGBTQ movement for more 40 years.
He is a co-founder of Heritage of Pride (the organizers of New York City pride
events) and a former commissioner of the New York Commission on Human Rights. He
has served as executive director of the NYC Gay & Lesbian Anti-Violence Project
(1990-1996), the Empire State Pride Agenda (1996-2003), and the National LGBTQ
Task Force (2003-2008). He is most proud of winning the title of First-Runner Up
Miss Kanawha Valley (WV) in 1976.



FacebookTwitterShare


ABOUT THE AUTHOR




JOBS IN NEW YORK

ADD YOUR JOB

 * MDG Design & Construction LLCSection 3 Work Opportunity
 * Law Office-Brooklyn Boro ParkParalegal/Secretary
 * SANT AMBROEUS SOUTH HAMPTONSeasonal Floor Manager

VIEW ALL JOBS…




LGBTQ+ EVENTS IN NYC

Post an Event

Tomorrow, 7 pm


LEGACY OF PRIDE MONTH @ YANKEE STADIUM
YANKEE STADIUM

June 23, 6 pm


FAMILY PRIDE NIGHT
LONG ISLAND CHILDREN’S MUSEUM

June 24, 11 am


FAMILY PRIDE FEST
PRIMARK STAGE

June 24, 1 pm


3RD ANNUAL FAMILY PRIDE IN THE PARK
PUGSLEY PARK

June 24, 1 pm


MOMA PRIDE FAMILY DAY!
THE MUSEUM OF MODERN ART

June 25, 9:30 am


JOY IN RESILIENCE: MARBLE COMMUNITY GOSPEL CHOIR SET TO RAISE THE ROOF AT PRIDE
CELEBRATION
MARBLE COLLEGIATE CHURCH

View All Events…




ARTS

 * Suzy Wong serves fish sauce realness
 * Anti-trans film nixed after facing backlash
 * In midtown, glamorous Lammy Awards return to a sense of normalcy
 * Tribeca Film Festival highlights LGBTQ features and documentary films
 * Q&A with ‘Nobody’s Hero’ director Alain Guiraudie




POLITICS

 * Assemblymember voices anti-LGBTQ remarks at community board meeting
 * New York State lawmakers pass LGBTQ and HIV long-term care residents’ bill of
   rights
 * New York State and City move to become safe haven for trans youth and
   families
 * City Council bill would establish protections for sex workers
 * Biden condemns wave of state legislation restricting LGBTQ+ rights, says
   ‘these are our kids’


CRIME

 * Yet again, vandals attack Stonewall National Monument
 * Vandals target Rainbow Flags at Stonewall National Monument 
 * City invites New Yorkers to submit requests to re-evaluate LGBTQ cold cases
 * Woman who torched Rainbow Flag placed in custody of health department
 * Teen arrested in death of trans woman in Atlanta


PERSPECTIVES

 * Get fully vaccinated against mpox to protect yourself and our community
 * Time to recognize the YU Pride Alliance
 * Celebrate International Transgender Day of Visibility by protecting trans
   kids
 * Why I cover and march in St. Patrick’s Day Parades
 * Fighting food insecurity in LGBTQ community requires multi-faceted approach




RELATED ARTICLES

 * Art Exhibit Honors Different LGBTQ Flags
 * A Second Rainbow Flag at Stonewall Monument — This One Clearly Over Federal
   Land
 * Trump to Gays: Not My Rainbow Flag
 * Why Isn’t the Rainbow Flag Flying at the Stonewall National Monument?




LGBTQ+ EVENTS IN NYC

Full calendar


NEW YORK’S JOB BOARD

Search Jobs


MORE FROM AROUND NYC

Brooklyn Paper


TWO BROOKLYN ARTISTS REDESIGN SKITTLES’S WRAPPER TO CELEBRATE PRIDE

Bronx Times


INDICATIVE OF A NATIONAL TREND, SISTERS SERVANTS OF MARY CONVENT IN COUNTRY CLUB
TO CLOSE DUE TO SCARCITY OF SISTERS

Caribbean Life


FLORIDA WOMAN JUSTIFIES SHOOTING BLACK WOMAN WITH ‘STAND YOUR GROUND’ PLEA

AMNY


FRANCES TIAFOE MAKES HISTORY WITH TOP 10 RANKING


GET THE GAY CITY NEWSLETTER

Sign up for our regular & breaking news updates.


 * About
 * Contact Us
 * Networking Events
 * Advertise
 * 

 * © Gay City News 2023. Schneps Media
 * Privacy Policy
 * Terms of Use


✓
Thanks for sharing!
AddToAny
More…


 * Sections
 * Jobs
 * Games
 * Events
 * Contact