www.timesofisrael.com
Open in
urlscan Pro
172.64.155.6
Public Scan
Submitted URL: https://links.timesofisrael.com/ss/c/u001.KlS5WRz1VMVrsQCW0LCZxgb7uoXvgShnByz-7Pj6_x6gZk4xx48AoXE5XIFT0R1X5vh3udtR0DIW0cuS12wAZc...
Effective URL: https://www.timesofisrael.com/toxic-and-polarizing-oxford-union-debate-on-israel-genocide-still-roils/?utm_source=The+Daily+Ed...
Submission: On December 17 via api from UA — Scanned from PL
Effective URL: https://www.timesofisrael.com/toxic-and-polarizing-oxford-union-debate-on-israel-genocide-still-roils/?utm_source=The+Daily+Ed...
Submission: On December 17 via api from UA — Scanned from PL
Form analysis
14 forms found in the DOMGET /search/
<form class="new-search-form" method="get" target="_self" action="/search/">
<button class="submit" type="submit" name="submit"><span>search</span></button>
<div class="new-wrap-input">
<label for="search-input"><span class="v-hidden">Input search</span></label>
<input type="text" autocomplete="off" name="q" placeholder="Search" id="search-input" value="" class="search-input">
<button type="button" class="clear-text" title="Clear search input"><span class="v-hidden">Clear search input</span></button>
</div>
</form>
<form>
<div class="ml-form-inner">
<input autocomplete="off" type="text" name="email" class="email-address" value="" placeholder="Your email">
<button type="submit" class="submit"><span>submit</span></button>
</div>
<div class="newsletter-error"></div>
</form>
GET /search/
<form class="search-form" method="get" action="/search/">
<div class="wrap-input">
<label for="search-input"><span class="v-hidden">Input search</span></label>
<input type="text" autocomplete="off" name="q" placeholder="Type here to search" id="search-input" value="" class="search-input">
<button type="button" class="clear-text"><span class="v-hidden">Clear search input</span></button>
</div>
<input type="submit" name="submit" class="submit" value="Search">
</form>
<form class="newsletter-article-form">
<label for="newsletter-email-address" class="screen-reader-text">Newsletter email address</label>
<input id="newsletter-email-address" type="text" name="email" class="newsletter-article-input email-address" value="" placeholder="Your email">
<button type="submit" class="submit newsletter-article-input"><span>Get it</span></button>
</form>
<form>
<label>
<span class="toi-crm-popup-label">Email address <span class="asterisk">*</span></span>
<input id="emailForCheck" name="user_email" type="email" autocomplete="off">
</label>
<div class="toi-crm-popup-form-message"><span class="toi-crm-popup-form-message-text">Please use the following structure: example@domain.com</span></div>
<button id="checkEmail-button" class="toi-crm-popup-form-submit" type="submit"><span class="toi-crm-popup-form-submit-text">Continue</span></button>
</form>
<form>
<label>
<span class="toi-crm-popup-label">Email address <span class="asterisk">*</span></span>
<input id="emailForMode0" disabled="" class="checked-email" name="user_email" type="email" autocomplete="off" value="">
<button type="button" class="change-email-button back-button">Change</button>
</label>
<div class="toi-crm-popup-captcha-wrapper">
<div id="grecaptcha-crm" class="toi-crm-popup-captcha"></div>
</div>
<!-- <div class="toi-crm-popup-form-message"><span class="toi-crm-popup-form-message-text">error text</span></div> -->
<button id="authMode0-button" class="toi-crm-popup-form-submit" type="submit"><span class="toi-crm-popup-form-submit-text">REGISTER</span></button>
</form>
<form>
<label>
<span class="toi-crm-popup-label">Email address <span class="asterisk">*</span></span>
<input id="emailForMode1" disabled="" class="checked-email" name="user_email" type="email" autocomplete="off" value="">
</label>
<div style="display: none;" id="messageMode1" class="tac toi-crm-popup-form-message"><span class="toi-crm-popup-form-message-text">Something went wrong. <br> Please try again in a few minutes..</span></div>
<button id="authMode1-button" class="toi-crm-popup-form-submit" type="button"><span class="toi-crm-popup-form-submit-text">Continue</span></button>
</form>
<form autocomplete="off">
<label>
<span class="toi-crm-popup-label">Email address <span class="asterisk hid">*</span></span>
<input id="emailForMode2" class="checked-email" disabled="" name="user_email" type="email" autocomplete="off" value="">
</label>
<label>
<span class="toi-crm-popup-label">Password <span class="asterisk">*</span></span>
<input id="passwordForMode2" name="user_password" type="password" value="">
</label>
<div style="display: none;" id="messageMode2" class="toi-crm-popup-form-message error-pass"><span id="messageMode2Text" class="toi-crm-popup-form-message-text">Incorrect password. Please try again or choose an option below.</span></div>
<button id="authMode2-button" class="toi-crm-popup-form-submit" type="submit"><span class="toi-crm-popup-form-submit-text">Continue</span></button>
<div class="toi-crm-popup-form-links">
<a class="toi-crm-popup-form-links-item owsSendForgotPasswordLink" href="#">I forgot my password</a>
<span class="toi-crm-popup-form-links-slash"> / </span>
<a class="toi-crm-popup-form-links-item owsSendMagicLink" href="#">Send me a sign in link</a>
</div>
</form>
<form>
<input type="email" name="email" class="email-address" value="" placeholder="Email address" autocorrect="off" autocapitalize="off" autocomplete="off">
<input name="subscribe" value="Subscribe" class="submit" type="submit">
</form>
<form>
<div class="text">Get the Daily Edition</div>
<label for="email-address" class="v-hidden"><span>Enter your email address</span></label>
<input type="text" name="email" class="email-address" id="email-address" value="" placeholder="Your email" aria-describedby="newsletter-error">
<button type="submit" class="submit"><span>submit</span></button>
<div role="alert" class="newsletter-error" id="newsletter-error" aria-live="polite"></div>
</form>
<form>
<label>
<span class="toi-crm-popup-label">Email address</span>
<input id="emailForCheck-regwall" name="user_email" type="email" autocomplete="off">
</label>
<div class="toi-crm-popup-form-message"><span class="toi-crm-popup-form-message-text">Please use the following structure: example@domain.com</span></div>
<button id="checkEmail-button-regwall" class="toi-crm-popup-form-submit" type="submit"><span class="toi-crm-popup-form-submit-text">REGISTER OR SIGN IN</span></button>
</form>
<form>
<label>
<span class="toi-crm-popup-label">Email address</span>
<input id="emailForMode0-regwall" disabled="" class="checked-email" name="user_email" type="email" autocomplete="off" value="">
<button type="button" class="change-email-button back-button">Change</button>
</label>
<div class="toi-crm-popup-captcha-wrapper">
<div id="grecaptcha-crm-regwall" class="toi-crm-popup-captcha"></div>
</div>
<!-- <div class="toi-crm-popup-form-message"><span class="toi-crm-popup-form-message-text">error text</span></div> -->
<button id="authMode0-button-regwall" class="toi-crm-popup-form-submit" type="submit"><span class="toi-crm-popup-form-submit-text">REGISTER</span></button>
</form>
<form>
<label>
<span class="toi-crm-popup-label">Email address</span>
<input id="emailForMode1-regwall" disabled="" class="checked-email" name="user_email" type="email" autocomplete="off" value="">
</label>
<div style="display: none;" id="messageMode1-regwall" class="tac toi-crm-popup-form-message"><span class="toi-crm-popup-form-message-text">Something went wrong. <br> Please try again in a few minutes..</span></div>
<button id="authMode1-button-regwall" class="toi-crm-popup-form-submit" type="button"><span class="toi-crm-popup-form-submit-text">Continue</span></button>
</form>
<form autocomplete="off">
<label>
<span class="toi-crm-popup-label">Email address <span class="asterisk hid">*</span></span>
<input id="emailForMode2-regwall" class="checked-email" disabled="" name="user_email" type="email" autocomplete="off" value="">
</label>
<label>
<span class="toi-crm-popup-label">Password <span class="asterisk">*</span></span>
<input id="passwordForMode2-regwall" name="user_password" type="password" value="">
</label>
<div style="display: none;" id="messageMode2-regwall" class="toi-crm-popup-form-message error-pass"><span id="messageMode2Text-regwall" class="toi-crm-popup-form-message-text">Incorrect password. Please try again or choose an option below.</span>
</div>
<button id="authMode2-button-regwall" class="toi-crm-popup-form-submit" type="submit"><span class="toi-crm-popup-form-submit-text">Continue</span></button>
<div class="toi-crm-popup-form-links">
<a class="toi-crm-popup-form-links-item rgwllSendForgotPasswordLink" href="#">I forgot my password</a>
<span class="toi-crm-popup-form-links-slash"> / </span>
<a class="toi-crm-popup-form-links-item rgwllSendMagicLink" href="#">Send me a sign in link</a>
</div>
</form>
Text Content
SZANUJEMY TWOJĄ PRYWATNOŚĆ Razem z naszymi 1463 partnerami przechowujemy na urządzeniu informacje, takie jak pliki cookie, i uzyskujemy do nich dostęp, a także przetwarzamy dane osobowe, takie jak niepowtarzalne identyfikatory i standardowe informacje wysyłane przez urządzenie, w celu zapewniania spersonalizowanych reklam i treści, pomiaru reklam i treści oraz zbierania opinii odbiorców, a także rozwijania i ulepszania produktów. Za Twoją zgodą my i nasi partnerzy możemy wykorzystywać precyzyjne dane geolokalizacyjne i identyfikację przez skanowanie urządzeń. Możesz kliknąć, aby wyrazić zgodę na przetwarzanie danych przez nas i naszych partnerów zgodnie z opisem powyżej. Możesz też uzyskać dostęp do bardziej szczegółowych informacji i zmienić swoje preferencje przed wyrażeniem zgody lub odmówić jej wyrażenia. Pamiętaj, że niektóre rodzaje przetwarzania danych osobowych mogą nie wymagać Twojej zgody, ale masz prawo sprzeciwić się takiemu przetwarzaniu. Twoje preferencje będą mieć zastosowanie tylko do tej witryny. Możesz w dowolnym momencie zmienić swoje preferencje lub wycofać zgodę, wracając na tę stronę i klikając przycisk "Prywatność" na dole strony. Należy również pamiętać, że ta strona internetowa/aplikacja korzysta z 1 lub więcej usług Google i może gromadzić i przechowywać dane, w tym informacje o odwiedzinach lub sposobie użytkowania. Użytkownik poprzez kliknięcie może udzielić lub odmówić zgody firmie Google i jej tagom stron trzecich na wykorzystywanie jego danych do celów określonych poniżej w sekcji dotyczącej zgody Google. WIĘCEJ OPCJIAgree Skip to main content Toggle Menu Join our Community Support ToI and remove all ads Learn more * English * العربية * Français * فارسی * עברית * Get The Daily Edition * Account * Sign In ISRAEL AT WAR - DAY 438 Open Search form search Input search Clear search input * Israel & the Region * Jewish Times * Israel Inside * Tech Israel * Real Estate Israel * The Blogs * Podcasts * Video * Newsletters * The Daily Edition What Matters Most Today * Tech Israel Updates from Silicon Wadi * Real Estate Israel Weekly Update * The Weekend Edition The Best Reads of the Week * Weekly Highlights Choice Voices From The Blogs * Partners * Atlanta Atlanta Jewish Times * North New Jersey The Jewish Standard * Pittsburgh Jewish Chronicle * United Kingdom The Jewish News * Australia The Australian Jewish News * For Publishers Become a Partner * Community * Join our community * Sign in * * About The Times of Israel * Advertise on The Times of Israel * Contact us * Get the Daily Edition submit * Follow us * © 2024 The Times of Israel , All Rights Reserved Terms and conditions Privacy policy * Open Search form Input search Clear search input Advertisement Homepage Inside Story ‘TOXIC AND POLARIZING’: OXFORD UNION DEBATE ON ISRAEL GENOCIDE STILL ROILS AS COUNTERTERROR POLICE INVESTIGATE AN ANTI-ISRAEL SPEAKER’S STATEMENTS AT THE NOVEMBER 28 EVENT, JEWISH STUDENTS AND PANELISTS DECRY ITS CONTRIBUTION TO CLIMATE OF JEW-HATRED By Robert Philpot Follow NEW! Get email alerts when this author publishes a new article You will receive email alerts from this author. Manage alert preferences on your profile page You will no longer receive email alerts from this author. Manage alert preferences on your profile page Today, 4:06 pm * Facebook * Twitter * email * Print * 11 Robert Philpot is a writer and journalist. He is the former editor of Progress magazine and the author of “Margaret Thatcher: The Honorary Jew.” * Illustrative: Then-US secretary of state John Kerry, speaking at the Oxford Union at Oxford University, England, May 11, 2016. (Peter Nicholls/Pool Photo via AP) LONDON — If the aim of students at the Oxford Union was to stir controversy with their motion accusing Israel of being “an apartheid state responsible for genocide,” the members of the elite debating society at one of Britain’s most prestigious universities succeeded in spades. Almost three weeks after the November 28 debate, the fallout continues, with reports that counterterrorism police are investigating complaints about remarks made by a pro-Palestinian speaker, accusations of antisemitism, and calls from one of Britain’s top academics for the government to cut funding to universities that fail to protect their Jewish students. Founded over two centuries ago, the Oxford Union is the political finishing school in which future prime ministers, cabinet ministers, and journalists hone their skills and cut their teeth. Although not formally part of the university itself, almost all of its members and officers are Oxford students, and two academics sit on its governing committee. As well as attracting top-shelf speakers, including former US presidents, Hollywood actors, and leading cultural figures, the Union is renowned for hitting the headlines. Appearances by Oswald Mosley, head of the UK’s pre-World War II fascist Blackshirts, David Irving, the discredited Holocaust-denying historian, and Nick Griffin, the former leader of the far-right British National party, have long led to accusations that the Union is overstepping the boundaries of free speech. Last month’s debate on Israel is likely to join this catalog of infamy. The result of the debate — a predictable 59 to 278 thrashing against the pro-Israel speakers — is likely to be forgotten long before the content of some of the speeches and what has been described as a “toxic and polarizing” atmosphere in the storied debating chamber. Get The Times of Israel's Daily Edition by email and never miss our top stories Newsletter email address Get it By signing up, you agree to the terms According to the Sunday Telegraph, Miko Peled, a pro-Palestinian Israeli-American activist and author, is now under investigation by specialist counterterror police following complaints about remarks he made during the debate. “What we saw on October 7 was not terrorism,” Peled argued. “These were acts of heroism of a people who have been oppressed.” Thousands of Hamas-led terrorism invaded southern Israel on October 7, 2023, slaughtering 1,200 men, women, and children, and kidnapping 251 to the Gaza Strip, amid acts of horrific brutality including sexual assault. Jonathan Turner, executive director of UK Lawyers for Israel, says he believes Peled’s remarks breach section 12 of the Terrorism Act 2000. Advertisement “In saying this, he expressed an opinion or belief supportive of Hamas, a proscribed terrorist organization,” Turner told The Times of Israel. “Moreover, given the cheers he had already received, he was reckless as to whether members of the audience would be encouraged by his words to support Hamas.” Turner suspects Peled has now left the UK and returned to the US. British police are unlikely to seek his extradition, due to the costly process and possible refusal on the grounds of freedom of speech. “However, if Peled returns to the UK, he should be arrested and tried,” Turner said. An open letter, organized by the Pinsker Center, a campus-based foreign policy think tank, and signed by over 300 academics, has similarly raised concerns about law-breaking at the event. “We unequivocally condemn the incendiary remarks made by some speakers in support of Hamas and terrorist violence. Such statements are not only morally reprehensible, but also in clear violation of the law,” said the letter, whose signatories included Baroness Ruth Deech, Prof. Sir Vernon Bogdanor, acting principal of Oxford’s Brasenose College, and University of Haifa history professor Dr. Fania Oz-Salzberger. “Glorifying acts of violence under the guise of advocating for Palestinian rights serves neither justice nor peace.” The academics also targeted the tenor of the debate. “While discussing issues like the Israeli-Palestinian conflict is vital, dangerous rhetoric, provocative behavior, and acts of intimidation have no place in such forums,” they wrote. “Reports that Jewish students felt threatened or intimidated during and after the debate are deeply disturbing. The university and the Union have a duty to ensure that Jewish students — and all minority groups — feel safe, respected, and protected from hate and harassment.” A pro-Palestinian, anti-Israel camp outside the Pitt Rivers Museum at the University of Oxford, in England, May 9, 2024. (AP Photo/Kin Cheung) Both pro-Israel speakers and Jewish students at the debate have since reported they felt anything but. “It was terrifying being Jewish in that room. I don’t think any of them would have actually attacked us, but it certainly felt like that in the moment. None of us [Jewish students] left alone,” Boruch Epstein, a postgraduate student, told the Sunday Telegraph last weekend. “I have been a member of the Oxford Union for three years,” he added. “I have never witnessed a debate like this.” ‘HIDEOUS, SINISTER AND SUFFUSED WITH TENSION’ Writer and broadcaster Jonathan Sacerdoti, one of the four pro-Israeli speakers opposing the motion that Israel is an apartheid state promoting genocide, likewise said that “the atmosphere in the chamber was hideous, sinister, and suffused with tension.” Advertisement “Jews who might have attended were clearly too afraid to show up: many had written to me privately to tell me of their fears,” he wrote in The Spectator magazine. “From the moment the debate began, the crowd displayed its unbridled hatred towards us.” During his speech, Sacerdoti was interrupted by a young woman screaming: “Liar! F– you, the genocidal motherf–er!” And Hassan Yousef, the son of a Hamas co-founder who renounced the terror group and became a pro-Israel activist, was labeled a “traitor” and a “prostitute” (in Arabic). When he asked the audience to raise their hands if they would have reported Hamas’s plans to the Israeli authorities if they had prior knowledge of the October 7 massacre, few did so. > The chamber of the Oxford Union has been breached by the forces of bigotry, > hatred, and mob rule Advertisement “The chamber of the Oxford Union,” Sacerdoti wrote, “has been breached by the forces of bigotry, hatred, and mob rule.” In a statement, the Oxford Union has strongly defended itself against critics. “As a Union, we are unwavering in our commitment to free speech. This means difficult or controversial views can be expressed and challenged,” it said. “The Oxford Union has a proud tradition of hosting debates on the most challenging issues of the day, and it is this commitment to open discourse that sets us apart. The Union does not endorse the views expressed by any of the speakers.” Mosab Hassan Yousef addresses an American Friends of Magen David Adom event in Florida, December 2018. (Courtesy) Saceredoti has accused the Union of withholding and editing video of the debate to remove abusive heckling of pro-Israel speakers, including himself, and statements supporting the October 7 Hamas atrocities by anti-Israel speaker Miko Peled. The Union said that not publishing and editing video was consistent with its existing practices. Lord William Hague, a former Conservative Foreign Secretary who was last month elected Chancellor of Oxford University, has indicated his unhappiness about the debate. “I have seen the open letter and, from what I have heard of last week’s debate … share the concerns of the signatories,” he told The Times. “When I take office as chancellor … I will do my utmost to encourage a culture of debate that will at times be fierce and strongly felt but should always be respectful and never intimidating.” William Hague in 2010. (By Rob Hunt / Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office, OGL 3) But Hague’s role is largely symbolic and Jewish students at the university suggest the Oxford Union debate was not an isolated incident. “For over a year, Jewish students at Oxford have faced a torrent of hatred on our campus,” the Oxford Jewish Society and the Union of Jewish Students said in a joint statement after the debate. They cited slogans such as “Globalize the intifada,” “There is only one solution — intifada revolution,” and “Zionists are not welcome at Oxford,” and attacked the Oxford Union’s debate. “Inflammatory speakers were invited not in the spirit of free speech, but instead to spark division, alienating Jewish — and all — students.” A FIRE HOSE OF HATRED An open letter sent to the university authorities in May cataloged over 100 antisemitic and anti-Israel incidents that had occurred at the university in the previous six months. One instance concerned an Israeli student, whose family members were murdered, with one taken hostage, on October 7. They shared their experiences with their college welfare officer a few days later and were told: “Oxford is often not a nice place for Israelis and Jews, and there is nothing we can do about it.” The open letter said that displays for the hostages and vigils for the massacre’s victims were constantly “vandalized by both individual students and some university groups,” while those who organized events for the hostages often had “derogatory and violent comments” shouted at them. > Oxford is often not a nice place for Israelis and Jews, and there is nothing > we can do about it Other incidents included: an Israeli fellow told by a colleague that “Jews run all the banks in the world”; an Israeli student was told by a number of students from their college, “You guys control the American government”; and a Jewish student told by another student that they “wouldn’t date a Jew.” A Jewish student who told their director of studies about the hostile environment at the university was told to “get over antisemitism.” New figures from the Community Security Trust, which monitors antisemitism and protects Jewish institutions in the UK, released this week show the experience of Jewish and Israeli students at Oxford is not unique. In the 2023/24 campus year, there were 272 university-related antisemitic incidents recorded by CST — the highest total ever recorded for a single academic year and a jump of 117 percent on the 2020-22 reporting period. “This can primarily be attributed to the wave of anti-Jewish hatred following the October 7 Hamas terror attack in Israel and the subsequent ongoing war in the Middle East that has led to a sharp rise in antisemitic incidents nationwide,” said the CST. Anti-far-right demonstrators protest as Nick Griffin of the British National Party and Holocaust-denying historian David Irving attend a debate on free speech at the Oxford Union in Oxford, November 26, 2007. (Jon ENOCH / AFP) Mark Gardner, the chief executive of the CST, called for university authorities, the government and the police to confront extremists who are “permitted to harass, intimidate and disrupt on campus.” Writing in response to the Oxford Union debate, Bogdanor, a highly respected constitutional scholar and historian, has called on Oxford to adopt specific guidelines on antisemitism, arguing that those on racism are “too generalized.” But he has also said it is time for the government to step in and take a tougher approach. The prime minister, Keir Starmer, should meet university vice-chancellors and tell them to take “personal responsibility” for the safety and well-being of Jewish students, the academic said. The prime minister should warn too that universities that fail to meet their obligations under the UK’s Equality Act, which protects ethnic and religious minorities from discrimination, should face cuts in government funding. “In America, Donald Trump is informing college presidents that, unless they confront antisemitism, they will lose federal funding,” Bogdanor pointedly noted. “A Labour government must not show itself less sensitive to racism than Donald Trump.” > A Labour government must not show itself less sensitive to racism than Donald > Trump Turner backs the calls to penalize universities that fail to tackle antisemitism and urges increased support for students to challenge it. “There are very serious problems of antisemitism on British campuses. I agree with cutting both public and private funding from universities that fail to take adequate action to tackle this problem,” he said. Turner also believes that Jewish students and “other fair-minded students” need to be helped and encouraged to “stand up against the hatred,” and provided with “the true facts relating to Israel and correct explanations of the legal issues.” “Funds withheld from unsatisfactory universities could helpfully be redeployed to support such learning,” he said. Watch Docu Nation Season 2: Resilience when you join the ToI Community Support The Times of Israel's independent journalism and receive access to our documentary series, Docu Nation: Resilience, premiering December 12. In this season of Docu Nation, you can stream eight outstanding Israeli documentaries with English subtitles and then join a live online discussion with the filmmakers. The selected films show how resilience, hope, and growth can emerge from crisis. When you watch Docu Nation, you’re also supporting Israeli creators at a time when it’s increasingly difficult for them to share their work globally. To learn more about Docu Nation: Resilience, click here. Support ToI and get Docu Nation Support ToI and get Docu Nation Already a member? Sign in to stop seeing this You're a dedicated reader We’re really pleased that you’ve read X Times of Israel articles in the past month. That’s why we started the Times of Israel eleven years ago - to provide discerning readers like you with must-read coverage of Israel and the Jewish world. So now we have a request. Unlike other news outlets, we haven’t put up a paywall. But as the journalism we do is costly, we invite readers for whom The Times of Israel has become important to help support our work by joining The Times of Israel Community. For as little as $6 a month you can help support our quality journalism while enjoying The Times of Israel AD-FREE, as well as accessing exclusive content available only to Times of Israel Community members. Thank you, David Horovitz, Founding Editor of The Times of Israel Join Our Community Join Our Community Already a member? Sign in to stop seeing this Most Popular * 1 As northern Israel comes back to life, Hezbollah strongholds over the border lie in ruins * 2 Heavy Israeli airstrikes reported on Syrian military sites in coastal Tartus region * 3 PM discusses hostages with Trump as Israeli officials say deal could be clinched in days * 4 Israel to close its embassy in Dublin due to Ireland’s ‘extreme anti-Israel policy’ * 5 Ben Gvir to ex-hostage: Even if captives being raped, deal will cause 10,000 future rapes * 6 Hamas fears Trump will allow Israel to resume Gaza war after 1st phase of hostage deal * 7 A claim that the earliest alphabet was found in Syria sparks a media maelstrom – finally * 8 Lebanese Druze politician says country should ‘permanently abandon’ war on Israel Advertisement Skip Ads by read more: * Jewish Times * University of Oxford * debate * anti-Israel academics * anti-Israel bias * anti-Israel sentiment * anti-Israel activity on campus * antisemitism on campus * campus protests * university campuses * British Jews close popup Sign in or Register Email address * Please use the following structure: example@domain.com Continue Or Continue with By registering you agree to the terms and conditions Send me The Times of Israel Daily Edition back close popup Register to continue Email address * Change REGISTER Or Continue with back close popup Log in to continue Email address * Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.. Continue back close popup Sign in or Register Email address * Password * Incorrect password. Please try again or choose an option below. Continue I forgot my password / Send me a sign in link Or Continue with close popup Check your email We sent an email to you at . It has a link that will sign you in. Click the link in that email to complete registration so you can comment. Advertisement Advertisement Recommended Stories Urologist: 87% of Men with E.D. Don't Know About This Easy Solution (Try Tonight!) staminasparkstation.com | Sponsored Eat 1 Teaspoon Every Night, See What Happens A Week Later [Video] nomorfat.com | Sponsored Probably the best fantasy game for the holiday season [no install] Elvenar | Sponsored Cheap Way to Get All the TV Channels - Is It Really Working? Smart TV | Sponsored Glaucoma and cataract can disappear! And vision can return quickly (Stop Doing This) visionntie.com | Sponsored Nowe Windy Schodowe Nie Wymagają Instalacji (Sprawdź Teraz) Schody Lift | Reklamy w wyszukiwarce | Sponsored Amazon Founder Jeff Bezos Recommends: 5 Books For Turning Your Life Around Blinkist: Jeff Bezos' Reading List | Sponsored Witaminy na wypadanie włosów: to nigdy nie było takie proste! Wypadanie włosów | Reklamy w wyszukiwarce | Sponsored Advertisement December 17, 2024 Current Top Stories Live Netanyahu’s office says PM was on Mount Hermon, denies report he’s heading to Cairo By Michael Bachner and ToI Staff Reuters reports Gaza ceasefire, hostage deal expected in coming days * Hamas: Deal possible if Israel ‘stops setting new conditions’ * 2 IDF troops killed in southern Gaza * 20min ago Egyptian media also denies Netanyahu traveling to Cairo * 23min ago White House believes Israel and Hamas getting closer to Gaza ceasefire, hostage deal * 25min ago Netanyahu was at Mount Hermon today for Syria briefing, PM's office says * 33min ago Netanyahu is not on his way to Cairo, PM's office says Inside story Jacob Magid Hamas fears Trump will allow Israel to resume Gaza war after 1st phase of hostage deal Sources familiar with talks say Hamas compromising on terms of IDF withdrawal but still insisting on permanent ceasefire, fearing deal made under Biden could collapse under Trump Katz said to tell MKs hostage-truce deal ‘closer than ever,’ echoing Hamas optimism By Gianluca Pacchiani and ToI Staff Trump says he’s ‘trying to help very strongly’ to bring hostages home By Jacob Magid Syrian rebel leader: Territory will not be used to launch attacks against Israel By AFP and ToI Staff Chief of Hayat Tahrir al-Sham, which ousted Assad regime, pledges commitment to 1974 buffer-zone agreement, says IDF activity in Syria ‘must end’ and Israel ‘has to pull back’ Syria’s new rulers step up engagement with world as nations urge humanitarian future By AFP Heavy Israeli airstrikes reported on Syrian military sites in coastal Tartus region By ToI Staff Otzma Yehudit votes against state budget, as coalition argues over bid to fire AG By Sam Sokol Bills pass first readings despite coalition infighting; Ben Gvir feuds with fellow far-right leader Smotrich, who says, ‘It’s a shame to undermine the coalition over nonsense’ Live updates (closed)Dec. 16: Likud sources say PM unlikely to fire Ben Gvir for voting against state budget By ToI Staff Netanyahu allies look to marshal support for ousting AG and reviving judicial overhaul By Sam Sokol and ToI Staff Levin threatens to revive divisive judicial overhaul: High Court ‘left us no choice’ By Sam Sokol Inside Story Robert Philpot ‘Toxic and polarizing’: Oxford Union debate on Israel genocide still roils As counterterror police investigate an anti-Israel speaker’s statements at the November 28 event, Jewish students and panelists decry its contribution to climate of Jew-hatred Jerusalem man accused of spying for Iran, planning terror attack By Emanuel Fabian Erdler Israel Amoyal, 23, allegedly carried out surveillance, vandalism tasks; searched internet for bomb-making instructions, proposed targeting Jerusalem light rail’s system ToI podcast Daily Briefing Dec. 17: Day 438 – Is Hamas softening stance on hostage-ceasefire deal? By Jessica Steinberg and David Horovitz ToI founding editor David Horovitz reviews the latest in the advanced negotiations for a Gaza deal, dissent in Netanyahu’s coalition, and remarks made by Syria’s rebel leader Katz envisions half of Haredi men eventually enlisting while rest stay in ‘Torah world’ By Sam Sokol Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee chair warns against coalition efforts to bypass his panel on ultra-Orthodox conscription issue; Lapid slams bill as ‘a complete sham’ Former chief rabbi says ultra-Orthodox must not serve in army, provoking outrage By ToI Staff Archaeology A claim that the earliest alphabet was found in Syria sparks a media maelstrom – finally By Gavriel Fiske A Johns Hopkins archaeologist recycles a 20-year-old hypothesis that small clay cylinders found in an ancient tomb reset the genesis of letters by 500 years. Why are people listening now? US says airstrike hit Houthi command and control facility in Yemen By Agencies and ToI Staff CENTCOM says Iran-backed rebels used targeted site to coordinate attacks on naval and merchant ships in Red Sea, Gulf of Aden; IDF said readying strike plans after missile launch Houthi ballistic missile triggers sirens in Tel Aviv and across central Israel By Emanuel Fabian Two charged over Iran-backed drone strike that killed 3 US troops in Jordan By Steve LeBlanc, Eric Tucker and TARA COPP Interview A female Shylock battles 1930s UK fascists in new adaptation of ‘The Merchant of Venice’ By Robert Philpot Skyrocketing UK antisemitism after Oct. 7 adds meaning and poignancy as acclaimed actress and playwright Tracy-Ann Oberman puts a new spin on a play she’s ‘always hated’ Hostage’s mother to minister: ‘I will take law into my hands’ if son doesn’t return alive By ToI Staff Einav Zangauker appears to threaten Ze’ev Elkin during Knesset committee hearing, saying ‘My son is alive but you are continuing to abandon him,’ demands deal to free all hostages Ben Gvir to ex-hostage: Even if captives being raped, deal will cause 10,000 future rapes By ToI Staff IAF says ‘hostage ribbons’ painted in the skies by planes on routine flight path By Emanuel Fabian Palestinians in Syria flock to cemetery ravaged and made off-limits under Assad By Maher Al Mounes Relatives strive to locate graves amid piles of rubble and smashed tombstones left in Yarmouk burial ground outside Damascus Breaking silence, Assad denies abandoning Syria despite his flight from rebels By Agencies and ToI Staff Iran awaiting ‘necessary conditions’ to reopen vandalized Syria embassy By AFP and ToI Staff Analysis Gianluca Pacchiani With a show of force in Jenin, the PA tries to prove it can rule Gaza. But can it? Ramallah is bent on regaining control of the northern West Bank and thereby improving its credentials to govern in postwar Gaza. But its legitimacy among Palestinians remains low Family of American activist killed in West Bank meets with Blinken, urges US inquiry By Jacob Magid and Reuters Settler leaders call for moving Palestinian population in West Bank ‘to combat terror’ By Jeremy Sharon Israel working via Russia to find Eli Cohen’s remains in Syria, Palestinian sources say By AFP Following Assad’s fall, Palestinian officials tell AFP that mediators also contacted them about locating body of a soldier who has been missing since 1982 battle Report: Syrian border villagers and rebels collecting weapons and handing them to IDF By ToI Staff Russia still has a military presence in post-Assad Syria — for now By ABBY SEWELL Netanyahu tells court he got ‘special hostility’ from Walla, ‘not special treatment’ By Jeremy Sharon Judges agree to cancel Tuesday’s hearing due to ‘special circumstances’; defense attorney attacks prosecution’s claim PM received favorable coverage from news site FM Sa’ar defends Dublin embassy closure, brands Irish premier an antisemite By Lazar Berman and Sam Sokol Top Israeli diplomat accuses Ireland of having ‘encouraged’ Jew hatred, slams it for backing ‘politicized proceedings’ against Israel at ICC More Headlines Russia’s top WMD general killed by bomb in Moscow in apparent Ukrainian operation By Agencies Israeli researchers decode mechanism of rare neurological disease By Diana Bletter Fish embryos decide when they want to be born, Israeli researchers find By Diana Bletter Australian state proposes ban on protests at places of worship amid antisemitism spike By AP and ToI Staff German Chancellor Scholz loses no-confidence vote, setting up early elections By Geir Moulson Leading US private school association apologizes for antisemitism at conference By Luke Tress Teacher, teenage student killed in shooting at Christian school in Wisconsin By Scott Bauer Grenade scare causes major traffic jam on Ayalon Highway By ToI Staff US private equity firm said to bid for Israeli spyware maker Paragon By Sharon Wrobel Rabbi Asher Deutsch, leader of hardline Jerusalem Faction, dies at 79 By ToI Staff Serbia used Israeli phone-hacking tool to enable spy campaign – Amnesty report By Reuters and ToI Staff Report: Police ID 20 rioters who broke into IDF bases, but isn’t investigating them By ToI Staff Top Ops Alon Tal The truth about life with a deceitful leader Netanyahu’s loose relationship with the truth leaves the public wondering whether to believe anything he says Gilles Darmon For the day after, injustice in Israel’s budgetary policies must end It is unacceptable to finance wartime efforts by reallocating resources in ways that devastate the most vulnerable populations Israel’s justice minister is creating a dictatorship in the judicial system A group of experts, including a former chief justice of the Supreme Court and two former IDF chiefs of staff, respond to claims made by Justice Minister Yariv Levin Rachelle Unreich In Melbourne, the Adass Synagogue is a wreck, but we are not Like so many others, my mother survived the Holocaust with nothing, but the Judaism she left me as an inheritance filled with small miracles Danny Maseng What my grandfather Rabbi Harry Davidowitz never told me A street newly named for him recognizes one of the many stories I never knew, his role in writing Israel’s Declaration of Independence Yossi Klein Halevi Is anti-Zionism antisemitism? It doesn’t matter It is time to shift gears and recognize that the delegitimization of Israel is the greatest threat facing the Jewish people today Alexander Seinfeld Notre Dame is wondrous, but is it moral? The celebrated restoration preserves the cathedral’s core mission and meaning, the triumph of Christianity over Judaism William Daroff Pass the Antisemitism Awareness Act Fighting antisemitism requires a formal definition. The US Congress approved the bill — why has Chuck Schumer failed to bring a Senate vote? Garrett Shore That time an antisemite came after me The thing is, I’m not Jewish. But as I cased him for a knife or gun, I realized how little that matters Mijal Bitton Fighting back: Even in the face of Jew-hatred, we must not hide It is the moments of unflinching honesty about who we are, what we value, and who we stand with that define us (Vayishlach) Rifka Lebowitz The cost of war: Israel’s New Year’s VAT increase will hurt your pocket Nobody wants higher household, business, and real estate expenses, but budgeting carefully will get Israelis through it Khalil Ayoub My fellow Druze and I have so much more to give The dedication of Israeli Druze is evident in their military service, but pre-army programs will boost them into better positions in the IDF, education, and jobs Today's Daily Briefing Day 438 – Is Hamas softening stance on hostage-ceasefire deal? listen to the podcast Latest Articles * 17 minutes ago Pope Francis was target of attempted suicide attack on 2021 trip to Iraq, he says * 32 minutes ago Two IDF soldiers killed in southern Gaza building collapse, two injured * 50 minutes ago Jerusalem man accused of spying for Iran, planning terror attack * 1 hour ago Inside Story‘Toxic and polarizing’: Oxford Union debate on Israel genocide still roils * 2 hours ago Syria’s new rulers step up engagement with world as nations urge humanitarian future * 3 hours ago ToI podcastDaily Briefing Dec. 17: Day 438 – Is Hamas softening stance on hostage-ceasefire deal? * 4 hours ago Iran awaiting ‘necessary conditions’ to reopen vandalized Syria embassy * 4 hours ago Palestinians in Syria flock to cemetery ravaged and made off-limits under Assad * 4 hours ago On the menuAnu museum offers virtual culinary tours with foodie Gil Hovav * 5 hours ago The way we wereVirtual museum recreates Jewish enclaves in Iran and Morocco * 5 hours ago Russia’s top WMD general killed by bomb in Moscow in apparent Ukrainian operation * 6 hours ago Report: Syrian border villagers and rebels collecting weapons and handing them to IDF * 7 hours ago Syrian rebel leader: Territory will not be used to launch attacks against Israel * 7 hours ago InterviewA female Shylock battles 1930s UK fascists in new adaptation of ‘The Merchant of Venice’ * 8 hours ago Australian state proposes ban on protests at places of worship amid antisemitism spike * 8 hours ago Inside storyHamas fears Trump will allow Israel to resume Gaza war after 1st phase of hostage deal * 9 hours ago Two charged over Iran-backed drone strike that killed 3 US troops in Jordan * 11 hours ago US says airstrike hit Houthi command and control facility in Yemen * 12 hours ago FM Sa’ar defends Dublin embassy closure, brands Irish premier an antisemite * 13 hours ago ArchaeologyA claim that the earliest alphabet was found in Syria sparks a media maelstrom – finally See All Latest Blogs * Rolene Marks Handy tips for driving in Israel * Yoseph Janowski To Ireland’s leader * Will Moore Data Analytics When Buying Israel... * Gilles Darmon For the day after, injustice in I... * Gil Samsonov Trump Creates Era of the 'Preside... * Sandra Alfonsi Gilad Segev and the Project Heroe... * Vincent James Hooper Chabahar Port: A Nexus for Trade,... * J.J Gross Yosef, Yehudah, Tamar:The Making ... * Mitchell James Kaplan Islamophobia * Ruth Ben-Or Herzl, Moses, the Khameneis and M... See All Docu Nation Those We Have Lost Stories of the civilians and soldiers who have fallen since Oct. 7 Read Here Help Rebuild Their Lives Donate Sponsored TOI ORIGINAL VIDEO THE 8119TH RESERVE BATTALION Those We Are Missing The hostages and victims whose fate is still unknown Read Here PODCASTS Listen now & Wartime Diaries Voices and testimonies of these devastating times listen to the podcast Full Coverage fall of Assad regime * Iran awaiting ‘necessary conditions’ to reopen vandalized Syria embassy By AFP and ToI Staff * Report: Syrian border villagers and rebels collecting weapons and handing them to IDF By ToI Staff * Syrian rebel leader: Territory will not be used to launch attacks against Israel By AFP and ToI Staff See All The Times of Israel Daily Edition Free to Your Inbox The email is either missing or invalid. By signing up, you agree to our terms You hereby accept The Times of Israel Terms of Use and Privacy Policy, and you agree to receive the latest news & offers from The Times of Israel and its partners or ad sponsors. Full Coverage What Matters Now * What Matters Now to Ksenia Svetlova: Women are the canary in the Mideast coal mine By Amanda Borschel-Dan and Ksenia Svetlova * What Matters Now to Haviv Rettig Gur: Iran’s solution for the Jewish state problem By ToI Staff * What Matters Now to combat medic Tuvia Book: Reserve duty for over a year By ToI Staff See All Full Coverage Liveblog * Netanyahu’s office says PM was on Mount Hermon, denies report he’s heading to Cairo By Michael Bachner and ToI Staff * Dec. 16: Likud sources say PM unlikely to fire Ben Gvir for voting against state budget By ToI Staff * Dec. 15: US said to ask Israel to approve military aid for PA as it fights terrorists in Jenin By ToI Staff See All Full Coverage ToI Original Video * The 8119th Reserve Battalion * Hersh * Tel Aviv cafe brews up resilience See All Those we have lost Stories of the civilians and soldiers who have fallen in the Israel-Hamas war * Those we have lost Master Sgt. Gal Eisenkot, 25: Student was ‘a man of truth and justice’ By ToI Staff * Those we have lost Staff Sgt. Omri Peretz, 20: Squad commander ‘surrounded by friends’ By ToI Staff * Those we have lost Guy Illouz, 26: Soundman for Hayehudim with ‘a huge heart’ By ToI Staff * Those We Have Lost Adiel Twito, 32: Chef and reality TV star who ‘loved to feed people’ By ToI Staff * Those we have lost Sgt. First Class Mulugeta Gadif, 29: Police officer left behind newborn By ToI Staff * Those we have lost Orel Abohatzira, 25: Maccabi Haifa fan who never missed a game By ToI Staff * Those We Have Lost Staff Sgt. Shalev Dagan, 20: Golani soldier who left his twin behind By ToI Staff * Those we have lost Mayana and Noah Hershkovitz, 65 & 68: Couple shared a love of art By ToI Staff * Those we have lost Rami Katzir, 79: Mechanic who worked listening to classical music By ToI Staff * Those we have lost Elia Toledano, 28: Tel Aviv event planner who was ‘full of joy’ By ToI Staff * Those We Have Lost Noy Shosh, 36: Fought terrorists outside his front door By ToI Staff * Those we have lost Avi Hindi, 37: Engineer and devoted father of three By ToI Staff * Those We Have Lost Arieh, Ruti & Or Akuni: 68, 67, 32: Parents, daughter slain at home By ToI Staff * Those We Have Lost Itay, Etti and Sagi Zak, 53, 50, 15: Family died in each other’s arms By ToI Staff * Those We Have Lost Staff Sgt. Itamar Bruchim, 20: Born leader lived fully in the moment By ToI Staff * Those We Have Lost Bilha Epstein, 81: Kibbutz elder was eager to meet a 1st great-grandchild By ToI Staff * Those we have lost Robert Shaulov, 70: Avid fisherman and beloved grandfather By ToI Staff * Those We Have Lost Amit Levy, 22: Had plans to travel the world with her twin sister By ToI Staff * Those We Have Lost Zur Saidi, 28: Had plans to propose to girlfriend, establish orchard By ToI Staff * Those We Have Lost Master Sgt. (res.) Naftali Gordon, 32: A man of ‘honesty and justice’ By ToI Staff Those we are missing The hostages and victims whose fate is still unknown * Those we are missing Taken captive: Naama Levy, Hands of Peace project alumnus By ToI Staff * Those we are missing Taken captive: Or Levy arrived at festival minutes before onslaught By AP * Those we are missing Taken captive: Gadi Moshe Mozes, expert potato farmer, ‘saba’ to all By ToI Staff * Those we are missing Taken captive: Eitan Mor, guard at rave who helped save others By ToI Staff * Those we are missing Taken captive: Ohad Yahalomi, shot in the leg by terrorists By ToI Staff * Those we are missing Taken captive: Surasak Lamnau, Thai worker abducted with employer By ToI Staff * Those we are missing Taken captive: Arbel Yehud, third generation on Kibbutz Nir Oz By ToI Staff * Those we are missing Taken captive: Ohad Ben Ami, dual Israeli-German citizen By ToI Staff * Those we are missing Taken captive: Karina Ariev, told parents ‘continue your lives’ By ToI Staff * Those we are missing Taken captive: Rom Braslavski, rave guard who saved others By ToI Staff * Those we are missing Taken captive: Shlomo Mansour, as his wife of 60 years escaped By ToI Staff * Those we are missing Taken captive: Amazon employee Sasha Trufanov By ToI Staff * Those we are missing Taken captive: Segev Kalfon, last seen running across Highway 232 By ToI Staff * Those we are missing Taken captive: Omer Shem-Tov’s car was driven into Gaza By ToI Staff * Those we are missing Taken captive: Edan Alexander, told mother he was safe By ToI Staff * Those we are missing Taken captive: Devoted uncle and Nir Oz resident Yair Horn By ToI Staff * Those we are missing Taken captive: Daniella Gilboa, identified by the shirt she wore By ToI Staff * Those we are missing Taken captive: US citizen Keith Siegel, driven to Gaza in his own car By ToI Staff * Those we are missing Taken captive: Agam Berger, seen being led to a car, still dressed in her pajamas By ToI Staff * Those we are missing Taken captive: Elkana Bohbot, young son asking, ‘Where’s Daddy?’ By ToI Staff Tales of the Times The quirky, improbable, infuriating and uplifting * On the menu Anu museum offers virtual culinary tours with foodie Gil Hovav By Jessica Steinberg * The way we were Virtual museum recreates Jewish enclaves in Iran and Morocco By Jessica Steinberg * Spoiler alert Mossad agent on the loose as Season 3 of ‘Tehran’ finally arrives By Jessica Steinberg * Peace vibes Local ‘Woodstock’ aims to unite Israelis, Palestinians for peace By Jessica Steinberg * Jewish camp Son of cantor, 11, makes Broadway debut in musical on drag queens By Steve North * Ace in the hole? Jewish pitcher Max Fried signs record-breaking deal with NY Yankees By jacob gurvis * Historic text Adam Schiff sworn into Senate on 1490 edition of Maimonides’ legal code By Ron Kampeas * Ballin' hard Innovation delivers an array of instant matzah ball options By Rachel Ringler * Extra challenges Jerusalem’s Sam Spiegel Film Lab launches 13th year By Jessica Steinberg * Real TV Actor Guri Alfi returns to the US for new episodes of ‘The New Jew’ By Jessica Steinberg * Ming leftovers Mount Zion dig unearths 16th century Chinese porcelain bowl fragment By Gavriel Fiske * Historic move Jerusalem ancient citadel museum to host accessibility conference By Jessica Steinberg * Happy ending Former Hamas hostage Mia Schem engaged to childhood friend By ToI Staff * Tiny treasure Girl, 12, finds 3,500-year-old Egyptian amulet on hike in central Israel By Gavriel Fiske * Elon, watch your back? Meta CEO Zuckerberg dines with Trump at Mar-a-Lago By AFP * Year of discord October 7 reverberates at Israeli music awards By Jessica Steinberg * Sensory arts At Nalaga’at festival, the blind lead the public to food and fun in the dark By ToI Staff * Ultra-Orthodox LGBTQ+ Israel’s Nir Bergman wins director’s prize in Tallinn By Jessica Steinberg * Fiction meets reality 3rd season of ‘Tehran,’ featuring Hugh Laurie, returns to Kan By Jessica Steinberg * Her legacy lives on Murdered peace activist Vivian Silver remembered with new prize By Jessica Steinberg Scroll to view more * Israel & the Region * Jewish Times * Israel Inside * Tech Israel * Real Estate Israel * The Blogs * podcast * video * terms and conditions * privacy policy * about us * advertise with us * Jobs at The Times of Israel * contact us Community * Join our community * Sign in Get the Daily Edition Enter your email address submit © 2024 The Times of Israel, all rights reserved Concept, design & development by Powered by Never miss breaking news on Israel Get notifications to stay updated Stay updated No thanks You're subscribed close popup Register for free and continue reading Registering also lets you comment on articles and helps us improve your experience. It takes just a few seconds. Already registered? Enter your email to sign in. Email address Please use the following structure: example@domain.com REGISTER OR SIGN IN Or Continue with By registering you agree to the terms and conditions. Once registered, you’ll receive our Daily Edition email for free. Send me The Times of Israel Daily Edition back close popup Register to continue Email address Change REGISTER Or Continue with back close popup Log in to continue Email address Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.. Continue back close popup Sign in or Register Email address * Password * Incorrect password. Please try again or choose an option below. Continue I forgot my password / Send me a sign in link Or Continue with back close popup Check your email We sent an email to you at . It has a link that will sign you in. Click the link in that email to complete your registration.