www.amny.com Open in urlscan Pro
192.0.66.202  Public Scan

Form analysis
3 forms found in the DOM

GET /

<form role="search" method="get" class="search-form" action="/">
  <label>
    <span class="screen-reader-text">Search:</span>
    <input type="search" class="search-field" placeholder="Search" value="" name="s">
  </label>
  <button type="submit" class="basic-button bkg-main search-submit icon-search-basic" value="Search"><i class="fa fa-search" aria-hidden="true" aria-label="Search"></i></button>
</form>

GET /

<form role="search" method="get" class="search-form" action="/">
  <label>
    <span class="screen-reader-text">Search:</span>
    <input type="search" class="search-field" placeholder="Search" value="" name="s">
  </label>
  <button type="submit" class="basic-button bkg-main search-submit icon-search-basic" value="Search"><i class="fa fa-search" aria-hidden="true" aria-label="Search"></i></button>
</form>

POST #

<form method="post" action="#" class="sailthru-add-subscriber-form" id="sailthru-subscribe-id--1">
  <div class="sailthru-add-subscriber-errors"></div>
  <div class="sailthru_form_input form-group">
    <label class="sailthru-widget-label">Email</label>
    <input type="text" name="email" placeholder="Email" value="" class="form-control sailthru_email">
  </div>
  <input type="hidden" name="sailthru_nonce" value="fe9af6c7e9">
  <input type="hidden" name="sailthru_email_list" value="amNY Breaking News,amNY Dedicated,amNY Evening Daily RSS Newsletter,amNY Morning Daily RSS Newsletter">
  <input type="hidden" name="action" value="add_subscriber">
  <input type="hidden" name="source" value="sidebar-widget">
  <input type="hidden" name="lo_event_name" value="">
  <input type="hidden" name="reset_optout_status" value="">
  <input type="hidden" name="hide_title_status" value="">
  <input type="hidden" name="site_key" value="" id="siteKey">
  <input type="hidden" name="captcha_token" value="" id="sailthruToken">
  <span class="input-group-btn">
    <button class="basic-button bkg-main btn btn-reverse" type="submit"> Subscribe </button>
  </span>
</form>

Text Content

FLIP THROUGH
TODAY’S PAPERS



AMNY NEWSLETTER

Tackle the city, with our help.

Subscribe

AMNY NEWSLETTER

Manage your settings.

Manage

 * amNY Shops
 * News
   * All
   * By Neighborhood
   * Business
   * Coronavirus
   * Police & Fire
   * Eat & Drink
   * Education
   * Entertainment
   * Finance
   * Opinion
   * Politics
   * Real Estate
   * Sports
   * Transit
 * Things to Do
   * Events in Manhattan
   * Events in Brooklyn
   * Events in Queens
   * Events in The Bronx
   * Events on Staten Island
   * Things to do with kids
   * Post an Event
   * Entertainment Guides
   * Business Events
   * Webinars
 * Boroughs
   * Manhattan
   * Brooklyn
   * The Bronx
   * Queens
   * Staten Island
 * Sports
   * All
   * Mets
   * Yankees
   * Giants
   * Jets
   * Knicks
   * Nets
   * Islanders
   * Rangers
   * Soccer
   * Tennis
   * Olympics
   * NY Sports Betting Apps
   * DraftKings Sportsbook NY
   * Caesars NY
   * FanDuel Sportsbook NY
 * Casinos
   * Real Money Online Casino Apps
   * NJ Online Casinos
   * NJ Online Casino Bonuses
   * New NJ Online Casinos
   * Bet365 Casino
 * Contact Us
 * More from amNY
   * What is New York
   * Home Pros
   * Jobs
   * Games
   * Digital Editions
   * Podcasts
   * Brand Content

Search:

 * Search:

 * News
 * All
 * By Neighborhood
 * Business
 * Coronavirus
 * Police & Fire
 * Eat & Drink
 * Education

 *  
 * Entertainment
 * Finance
 * Opinion
 * Politics
 * Real Estate
 * Sports
 * Transit

 * Things to Do
 * Events in Manhattan
 * Events in Brooklyn
 * Events in Queens
 * Events in The Bronx
 * Events on Staten Island

 *  
 * Things to do with kids
 * Post an Event
 * Entertainment Guides
 * Business Events
 * Webinars

 * Boroughs
 * Manhattan
 * Brooklyn
 * The Bronx
 * Queens
 * Staten Island

 * Sports
 * All
 * Mets
 * Yankees
 * Giants
 * Jets
 * Knicks
 * Nets
 * Islanders

 *  
 * Rangers
 * Soccer
 * Tennis
 * Olympics
 * NY Sports Betting Apps
 * DraftKings Sportsbook NY
 * Caesars NY
 * FanDuel Sportsbook NY

 * Casinos
 * Real Money Online Casino Apps
 * NJ Online Casinos
 * NJ Online Casino Bonuses
 * New NJ Online Casinos
 * Bet365 Casino

 * More from amNY
 * What is New York
 * Home Pros
 * Jobs
 * Games
 * Digital Editions
 * Podcasts
 * Brand Content

 * amNY Shops
 * Contact Us
    * 

Op-Ed


OP-ED | NYC CAN PROTECT CHILDREN WITHOUT DEVASTATING FAMILIES

By Eve Stotland Posted on March 13, 2024
Photo via Getty Images

Sign up for our amNewYork email newsletter to get news, updates, and local
insights delivered straight to your inbox!
FacebookTwitterShare

Imagine a family sound asleep in the south Bronx in the middle of the night.
Suddenly, they are awakened by a knock at the front door.

The unexpected and unscheduled visitors are representatives of New York City’s
Administration for Children’s Services (ACS), the local child welfare agency.
Without permission from the parents, the investigators enter the home, search
the premises, and rouse the children.  



The experience is nothing short of traumatizing for the children and families
involved — a disproportionate number of whom are Black or Latinx and living in
low-income neighborhoods.







We believe these practices are not only terrifying but a violation of families’
civil rights.

As advocates’ repeated attempts to negotiate an end to these harmful practices
have proven unsuccessful, The New York Community Trust, our region’s community
foundation, is providing financial support for a federal class-action lawsuit
filed Tuesday by the Family Justice Law Center, a nonprofit that uses strategic
litigation to challenge potentially unconstitutional practices by child welfare
agencies.



The Center seeks financial remedies for families who have been harmed as well as
system-wide policy changes that will protect all New Yorkers from the specter of
unconstitutional searches.

We are confident that the case The Center has built is a strong one.

According to the nonprofit The Bronx Defenders, a never-released racial equity
audit conducted by ACS in 2020 revealed “that ACS’s own leadership encourages
employees to target Black and brown families, reflexively use family separation,
and rely on damaging racial stereotypes without telling parents their rights.”

Further, the Family Justice Law Center alleges that investigators conducting
these late-night visits incorrectly tell families they have the right to enter
the family home, inspect the premises, and unclothe and search the children for
physical harm–all without a warrant and in non-emergency situations. In
instances in which families hesitate to invite them in, investigators threaten
to return with the police or to remove the children on the spot. 



Tragic deaths of children by their caregivers demand our attention. However, the
majority of investigations do not involve any allegations of physical
mistreatment, and the government must balance the risk of harm from maltreatment
with the very real harm caused to children and families when they are
unnecessarily threatened with separation. We decided to fund this lawsuit after
it became apparent that litigation was necessary to bring about systemic change
to respect parents’ rights. 

The unreleased audit obtained by The Bronx Defenders surveyed child protective
workers who overwhelmingly stated that Black and Latinx families are subject to
more scrutiny than white families.

The report concluded that “white parents are presumed to be innocent and are
repeatedly given opportunities to fail and try again, while Black and brown
parents are treated at every juncture as if they are not capable of providing
acceptable care to their children.” 



The City has defended these inspections by describing them as voluntary, but
consent provided in the face of threats and misinformation can hardly be
characterized as voluntary. 

We believe that ACS can fulfill its mission to protect children from
maltreatment without violating parents’ rights. The remedy is clear: ACS should
comply with existing laws by obtaining a judicial warrant or consent that is not
coerced to search parents’ homes, except in the rare instances where ACS has
sufficient evidence that children are being harmed and that there is no time to
request a warrant. 

Eve Stotland is a senior program officer at The New York Community Trust.

FacebookTwitterShare


ABOUT THE AUTHOR


THINGS TO DO IN NYC

Post an Event

March 16, 2 pm


REMEMBER THE FIRST WAVE: A PANDEMIC DISCUSSION AND FILM SCREENING
ELMHURST LIBRARY

March 17, 11 am


PURIM CARNIVAL
JOAN & ALAN BERNIKOW JCC

March 24, 2 pm


LOU’S HELPING HAND: 2ND ANNUAL EASTER EGG HUNT
ANNADALE PARK

March 30, 10 am


EASTER AT THE MOUNT
MOUNT LORETTO

May 3, 6 pm


SESAME STREET LIVE! SAY HELLO
KINGS THEATRE

May 25, 11 am


BLUEY’S BIG PLAY
KINGS THEATRE

View All Events…




JOBS IN NEW YORK

ADD YOUR JOB

 * YNH LogisticsTruck driver
 * Publishers Circulation Fulfillment, IncNewspaper Delivery Driver- Early
   mornings – PT
 * DIABETIC FOOT CARE SERVICES Receptionist

VIEW ALL JOBS…


TACKLE THE CITY, WITH OUR HELP.

Close
Thank you for subscribing!
Email
Subscribe



HOME PROS

Find a pro





RELATED ARTICLES

 * Op-Ed | Bearing witness to the aftermath of the October 7th attacks
 * Op-Ed | Building a city of opportunity
 * Op-Ed | Governor Hochul, don’t leave NYC children behind in early
   intervention funding
 * Op-ed | Support care and hope during MS Awareness Week


THINGS TO DO IN NYC

Full calendar


HOME PROS

Find a pro


MORE FROM AROUND NYC

Bronx Times


AOC ANNOUNCES MORE THAN $7.5 MILLION IN FUNDING FOR FUTURE BRONX RENOVATIONS AND
PLANS

QNS


FROM COMMUNITY CENTERS TO DNA TESTING, CONGRESSWOMAN MENG SECURES $13M FOR
QUEENS INITIATIVES

Brooklyn Paper


BROOKLYN’S OWN ‘IRON MAN’ OFFERS TO SMOOTH GREENPOINT’S RUMPLED CLOTHING FOR
FREE

Gay City News


FLORIDA TEACHERS CAN DISCUSS SEXUAL ORIENTATION AND GENDER IDENTITY UNDER ‘DON’T
SAY GAY’ BILL SETTLEMENT

 * Contact Us
 * Jobs
 * Home Pros
 * Advertise
 * Newsletter
 * 

 * © amNY 2024 Schneps Media
 * Privacy Policy
 * Terms of Use

✓
Thanks for sharing!
AddToAny
More…


 * Sections
 * amNY Shops
 * News
 * Things to Do
 * Contact