www.cnet.com Open in urlscan Pro
2a04:4e42:4c::666  Public Scan

Form analysis
1 forms found in the DOM

GET /roadshow/search/

<form class="smartSearch_form" method="get" action="/roadshow/search/" data-component="autoSuggest"
  data-auto-suggest-options="{&quot;selectorSuggestions&quot;:&quot;.searchResults_linkResults a, .searchResults_imgResults a&quot;,&quot;url&quot;:&quot;\/roadshow\/smart-search\/xhr\/&quot;,&quot;selectorMenu&quot;:&quot;.searchResults&quot;}">
  <input data-search-input="null" class="smartSearch_formInput" name="query" type="search" placeholder="Search" autocomplete="off"><button class="smartSearch_button" type="submit">
    <div class="button button_type_secondary button_size_large "><span data-item="buttonText">Go</span></div>
  </button>
</form>

Text Content

Ford F-150 Lightning to Tesla Cybertruck: Electric truck roundup 2022 Honda
Civic 2021 Ford Mustang Mach-E GT 2022 Hyundai Tucson GMC Hummer EV 2021 Ford
Bronco Best car insurance
Car Finder
By make and model
Make
Acura Alfa Romeo Aston Martin Audi Bentley BMW Buick Cadillac Chevrolet Chrysler
Dodge Ferrari Fiat Ford Genesis GMC Honda Hyundai Infiniti Jaguar Jeep Kia
Lamborghini Land Rover Lexus Lincoln Lotus Maserati Mazda McLaren Mercedes-Benz
Mini Mitsubishi Nissan Polestar Porsche Ram Rolls-Royce Smart Subaru Tesla
Toyota Volkswagen Volvo
Model

Go
By style See all cars
 * Coupes
 * Sedans
 * SUVs/Crossovers
 * Trucks
 * Electric
 * Hybrids
 * Luxury
 * Sports Cars

Reviews
All auto reviews
2020 Chevy Silverado 2500 2020 Ford F-Series Super Duty 2020 Mazda CX-9 2020
Hyundai Sonata 2020 Toyota 4Runner Tesla Model 3
Best Cars
All the best cars
Best Affordable Cars Best Crossovers Best Electric Cars Best Family Cars Best
Fuel-Efficient Cars Best Hybrids Best Sedans Best SUVs
News
All auto news
Recalls Electric Cars Concept Cars SUVs Sports Cars
Prices
More
Photos
The 2020 Toyota Highlander gets a new platform... 2020 Hyundai Sonata brings
arresting style... Tesla Model Y SUV unveiled
Videos
AutoComplete Carfection Cooley On Cars
Advice & Tools
Does your car have a recall? Guide to certified preowned cars Ride sharing guide
Search
Go
Hi,
Settings
My Profile Sign Out
Join / Sign In



HOW MUCH RANGE YOU REALLY NEED IN AN ELECTRIC CAR

Stop trying to re-create your gas engine car from electricity and the answer
will become clear.

Brian Cooley

Feb. 27, 2022 1:02 p.m. PT

Brian Cooley

Editor at Large

Brian Cooley is CNET's Editor at large, following the big trends in car tech,
smart home , healthcare, the future of food, digital entertainment and more.
He's known for his affable and informed take on technologies that fly or flop.
Born and raised in Silicon Valley, he remembers when Apple's headquarters was
mostly apricots.

See full bio
 * * 
   * 
   * 
   * 

If you're considering an electric vehicle, don't make the mistake of buying one
with too much range. Unlike combustion engine cars with virtually unlimited
range, electric cars make the most sense when they have the right amount of
range, not a surfeit of it.

There are several reasons to temper your instinct to get the most range
possible.


COST

Range costs a lot of money. For example, a Nissan Leaf with 226 miles of range
costs $6,600 more than the same trim level with 149 miles of range.

There is no real parallel with combustion cars as their cost of range is in the
price and consumption rate of fuel, not the vehicle's MSRP. You can argue that
an EV earns back its overall cost premium in per-mile energy savings, but a
long-range electric car will need many more of those low-cost miles -- and
probably years of covering them to do so. 

The cost of EV range can make buyers recoil from one without knowing that their
perception of sufficient range, not cost, is the real problem.

Is a lower range EV, like a 149-mile-range Nissan Leaf, the right car for your
real driving needs?

Nissan


WEIGHT

Longer range versions of a given electric car have larger, heavier batteries.
Unlike a tank of gas that weighs about 100 pounds and gets lighter as it's used,
an EV battery can easily weigh 1,000 pounds and stays just as heavy as it is
"emptied," increasingly becoming dead weight the remaining amount of charge must
lug around.

The long range Tesla Model 3 (358 miles of range) weighs 172 pounds more than
the RWD version's still-generous 272-mile range, a weight difference equal to
the entire payload a car will most often carry: the driver. The difference is
even more pronounced when comparing a long range Model 3 to a comparable
conventional BMW 3 Series, which is about 475 pounds lighter. 

Beyond efficiency there's also a safety problem with excess vehicle weight. A
2014 paper by researchers at the University of California, Berkeley and
published in the Review of Economic Studies found that "being hit by a vehicle
that is 1000 pounds heavier generates a 40-50% increase in fatality risk" and by
itself generates a societal cost equivalent to a $0.97 per gallon gas tax.

Lotus Cars Founder Colin Chapman famously said "simplify then add lightness" for
a car that performs better all around, a maxim that's particularly apropos for
electric cars.


BATTERY LIFE CYCLE 

Like depreciation, this is a somewhat arcane factor that car buyers prefer to
ignore but larger, long range batteries scale the problems of resource
extraction, manufacturing emissions and battery recycling. In all three areas EV
batteries are largely a problem by the pound, not the unit. The recycling
problem looms large enough that it's garnered serious attention from Argonne
National Labs and former Tesla Co-Founder JB Straubel, among others. Smaller EV
batteries today can mean fewer environmental ironies.


KNOW YOUR NEEDS

Most EV buyers will reflexively seek future-proofing and edge case peace of mind
with long range electric vehicles. We've been spoiled by the virtually
effortless range of gas engine cars. But the US Bureau of Transportation
Statistics has long documented the average personal car clocks about 14,500
miles a year -- or under 40 miles a day in a combination of commute, shopping,
errands and pleasure trips. It may surprise many drivers to know that only 15%
of those trips are commutes, with a much larger 45% being shorter runs for
shopping and errands, and 27% for social trips or meeting friends.

A recent survey sponsored by Castrol found that a stout 319 miles of range is
the mental tipping point for many US consumers to consider an EV. Assuming an
average of 40 miles per day, that 319-mile range equates to needing a full
charge only every six days, even assuming the driver never depletes their car's
battery below 20%. For drivers who have access to home charging, this suggests a
desire for range that is more emotional than rational.

And while aggregate commute patterns are trending toward pre-pandemic levels,
all that matters is your commute pattern: If you've permanently shifted to a
work style that reduces your commute, you need to frame EV range in that reality
-- not in the aggregate of all commuters or in the driving pattern you were used
to before the pandemic.

On the other hand, there are good reasons for high EV range: You may drive long
distances as a matter of course, either due to the nature of your work or if you
live in a spread-out part of the US. It's little wonder that few EVs are
registered in long-legged states like Wyoming, Montana and North Dakota.

You may desire high battery capacity for emergencies like regional power outages
that disable the grid for an extended period or for disaster evacuation where
charging on the road may be impossible to forecast. But EVs of any range are,
frankly, hard to feel good about in those scenarios. The difficulty of making an
EV the complete equivalent of a conventional car is perhaps why 90% of US
households that have an EV also own a conventional gas-engine vehicle.

Finally, a less-considered option: Do you need a pure electric car or a plug-in
hybrid? A Toyota RAV4 Prime plug-in hybrid offers 42 miles of pure electric
range under most driving conditions, enough for most daily needs before a
4.5-hour Level II full charge that's easily accomplished overnight, every night.

Whether you're considering a pure EV or plug-in hybrid, don't let perfect become
the enemy of good. The conceptions and expectations formed by generations of
using combustion engine cars are important to reexamine.


Automobiles Climate Change
Notification on
Notification off
Cooley On Cars




Trending
Ford F-150 Lightning to Tesla Cybertruck: Electric truck roundup
2022 Honda Civic
2021 Ford Mustang Mach-E GT
2022 Hyundai Tucson
GMC Hummer EV
2021 Ford Bronco
About
About Roadshow
Newsletter
Sitemap
Careers
Help Center
Licensing
Policies
Privacy Policy
Terms of Use
Cookie Settings
Do Not Sell My Information
Follow

© 2022 CNET, A RED VENTURES COMPANY. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
Cookie Settings


We use cookies and similar technologies to understand how you use our services,
improve your experience and serve you personalized content and advertising. By
clicking "Accept All", you accept all cookies. By clicking "Reject All", you
reject all cookies except Strictly Necessary cookies. To manage your cookies and
learn more about our use of cookies click “Cookie Settings”.Learn more.

Cookie Settings Reject All Accept All