www.deccanherald.com Open in urlscan Pro
13.32.99.18 Public Scan

Back to summary

URL:
https://www.deccanherald.com/national/nuclear-power-must-be-bigger-part-of-the-mix-for-india-to-meet-emission-commitments-jai...
Submission: On September 30 via api (September 30th 2022, 11:04:28 am UTC) from FR — Scanned from FR

Form analysis
3 forms found in the DOM

GET /search

<form action="/search" method="get" class="text-center search-result--main parent-relative"> <input class="search-result__input search-result--main-search sanspro-semib" name="term" type="text" placeholder="What are you looking for?" value=""> <input
    class="search-result__submit search-result--main-submit sanspro-b" type="submit" value="Search"></form>

<form id="newsletters_manage-firstm-1046564" class="needs-validation optin_newsletter" novalidate="">
  <div id="agree_container_3_0"></div>
  <div class="input-group">
    <div id="agree_container_3_0"></div><input type="email" name="email" placeholder="Email Address" class="form-control" id="optin_email" pattern="[a-z0-9._%+-]+@[a-z0-9.-]+\.[a-z]{2,4}$" required=""><span class="input-group-btn"><button
        data-lid="63" class="btn" id="optin_btn" value="validate">Sign Up</button></span>
    <div class="errs inline"></div>
    <div class="valid-feedback feedback-pos"> A verification email has been sent to your inbox. Please verify to complete the subscription.</div>
    <div class="invalid-feedback feedback-pos"> Please enter a valid email address</div>
  </div>
</form>

<form id="newsletters_manage-first-1046564" class="needs-validation optin_newsletter" novalidate="">
  <div id="agree_container_3_0"></div>
  <div class="input-group"> <input type="email" name="email" placeholder="Email Address" class="form-control" id="optin_email" pattern="[a-z0-9._%+-]+@[a-z0-9.-]+\.[a-z]{2,4}$" required=""> <span class="input-group-btn"> <button data-lid="63"
        class="btn" id="optin_btn" value="validate">Sign Up</button> </span>
    <div class="errs"></div>
    <div class="valid-feedback feedback-pos"> A verification email has been sent to your inbox. Please verify to complete the subscription.</div>
    <div class="invalid-feedback feedback-pos"> Please enter a valid email address</div>
  </div>
</form>

Text Content

* Home
* Bengaluru
* Top Stories
* Crime
* Politics
* Infrastructure
* Life in the City
* Bengaluru 2040
* Karnataka
* Top Stories
* Politics
* Districts
* 22in22
* National
* Politics
* Coronavirus
* North and Central
* East and Northeast
* South
* West
* Sports
* Cricket
* Formula 1 with DH
* Football
* Tennis
* Sportscene
* Other Sports
* Business
* Business News
* Family Finance
* Technology
* DH Wheels
* Budget 2022
* Opinion
* DH Views
* Editorials
* Panorama
* Comment
* In Perspective
* Right in the Middle
* Features
* Metrolife
* Entertainment
* Travel
* Spectrum
* Sunday Herald
* Living
* DH Education
* Videos
* Latest Videos
* Bengaluru
* Karnataka
* People
* Popular
* Specials
* Insight
* Point Blank
* Sunday Spotlight
* Brandspot

Subscribe
To Epaper
NEW Newsletters

* Friday 30 Sep 2022
* updated: 4:33 pm IST
* E-Paper
* Classifieds

* BLR 24 ° C Clouds
* Sensex: 57426.92+1016.96
* Nifty: 17094.35+276.25

* Home
* DH Cup 2022
* Bengaluru
* Top Stories
* Crime
* Politics
* Infrastructure
* Life in the City
* Bengaluru 2040
* Karnataka
* Top Stories
* Politics
* Districts
* 22in22
* National
* Politics
* Coronavirus
* North and Central
* East and Northeast
* South
* West
* India@75
* Sports
* DH Cup 2022
* Cricket
* Formula 1
* Football
* Tennis
* Sportscene
* Other Sports
* Business
* Business News
* Family Finance
* Technology
* DH Wheels
* Budget 2022
* World
* Opinion
* DH Views
* Editorials
* Panorama
* Comment
* In Perspective
* Right in the Middle
* Metrolife
* Your Bond With Bengaluru
* Cityscape
* On The Move
* Lifestyle
* Entertainment
* Entertainment News
* DH Showtime
* DH Talkies
* Arts, Books & Culture
* Videos
* Latest Videos
* Bengaluru
* Karnataka
* People
* Popular
* Specials
* Insight
* Point Blank
* Sunday Spotlight
* Travel
* Spectrum
* Top Stories
* Statescan
* Living
* Front Page
* Health 'n' Well-Being
* Fashion Folio
* Food Fiesta
* Sunday Herald
* SH Top Stories
* Entertainment
* Articulations
* Art & Culture
* Melange
* Books
* Photos
* Pics of the Day
* DH Galleries
* 70 Years of DH
* My Take
* Your Space
* DH Education
* E-Paper

IN BRIEF:

* Sharjeel Imam gets bail
* Cong polls: Tharoor vs Kharge
* Kabul: Suicide blast kills 19
* RBI hikes repo rate by 50 bps
* Pilot's priority for Rajasthan
* A battle of wills

* Home
* National
* 'India needs nuclear power to meet emission commitment'

'India needs nuclear power to meet emission commitment'

NUCLEAR POWER MUST BE BIGGER PART OF THE MIX FOR INDIA TO MEET EMISSION
COMMITMENTS: JAIRAM RAMESH

'MY EXPECTATION FROM GLASGOW IS THAT THE RULE BOOK FOR IMPLEMENTING THE PARIS
AGREEMENT SHOULD BE CLINCHED BEFORE WE GET INTO ALL THESE MEANINGLESS DEBATES ON
NET ZERO', SAYS RAMESH

*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*

Shemin Joy, DHNS, New Delhi,
* Nov 02 2021, 08:01 ist
* updated: Nov 02 2021, 08:35 ist

Senior Congress MP Jairam Ramesh was an influential voice at the Copenhagen and
Cancun editions of the UN Climate Change Conference in 2009 and 2010. As yet
another edition of the Conference of Parties (COP) gets underway in Glasgow,
Ramesh spoke to DH’s Shemin Joy, charging the Narendra Modi government with
diluting forest and environmental laws and rules at home while making the right
noises outside India. The former Union environment minister says that nuclear
power has to be a bigger part of the mix for India to be able to make emissions
commitments.

World leaders have converged in Glasgow for COP26. What outcome do you expect
from the summit?

I have very modest expectations. It's been six years since the Paris agreement.
That was based on the foundations of (climate summits of) Copenhagen in 2009 and
Cancun in 2010. It took five years after Cancun to arrive at the agreement.

We are now six years after the Paris (summit), we still do not have the rule
book for implementing the Paris agreement. In Glasgow, there will be a lot of
rhetoric, there will be a lot of moralising, there will be a lot of
grandstanding. But I don't expect any great breakthrough. Fundamental
non-negotiable output of Glasgow should be the finalisation of the rule book.
Countries made pledges in Paris. How are they going to hold themselves
internationally accountable? It is not enough to be domestically accountable.
You have to be internationally accountable. This is a global agreement. So that
is still not done. It is still going round and round for six years.

Read | Six charts show how hard it is for India to hit net zero

My expectation from Glasgow is that the rule book for implementing the Paris
agreement should be clinched before we get into all these meaningless debates on
net zero and so on, which is completely fraudulent in my view. I mean in 2050,
all the people who are going to make the commitments are not going to be around
to be held accountable. It is an aspirational goal to have net zero. But the
question is what are you doing in the 2020s, in the 2030s? That is more
important. Net Zero becomes an excuse, it is a clock for failure to do something
meaningful in the 5-10-15 year horizon. Entire COP architecture in my view is
fundamentally flawed.

I have been saying this ever since I was a Minister that the COP architecture is
a COP-out architecture. This is COP26. Can you imagine for 26 years, we have
been meeting year after year. It is like the objective of the COP25 is to figure
out where to have COP26, when you have COP26, you have to figure out where to
hold COP27. This is completely dysfunctional architecture. For dealing with the
problem which you know have day-to-day ramifications, climate change actions
should not have to be something you announce in the form of a dramatic headline
during two weeks of November. It is something which is a day-to-day activity.
You make commitments, you improve on the commitments, you make new commitments,
increase your level of ambition. So this is an architecture where you sleep
throughout the year and suddenly you wake up and then you want to make a
dramatic gesture.

I think this whole thing, I am not terribly excited by it. To be meaningful, it
must deliver on the Paris agreement, it must close the Paris agreement, which
was signed by so many Heads of governments and heads of States. We do not have
finality on how the Paris agreement pledges are going to be monitored, reported,
verified, then what are we talking about.

Do you think the Modi government is walking the talk on environment, climate
change?

No. The Modi government is not walking the talk on environment. It is walking
the talk on the environment globally, but it is walking in a completely
different direction domestically. Yes, the Modi government has taken advantage
of the dramatic fall in solar prices. For example, when I took over as
Environment Minister in 2009, solar prices were Rs 15 per unit. Today, it is
less than Rs 3 per unit. Solar prices have fallen dramatically. India has taken
advantage of it, rightly so. In terms of renewable energy, we had a target of
20,000 MW. Modi increased it to 100,000 MW.

It was inevitable because the cost was declining so dramatically. But I don't
judge the Modi government by what the Prime Minister says in Glasgow. While he
speaks in Glasgow, there are proposals here to amend the Forest Conservation
Act. There are proposals to convert the Environment Protection Act into an
Environment Management Act. There are proposals for one overarching law to bring
everything under one law. These are completely ridiculous ideas. You are
diluting all the coastal regulations, the Coastal Regulation Zone (CRZ) Rules.
The draft Environment Impact Assessment (EIA) regulations that is coming out is
basically going to lead to making a mockery of the entire environment impact
assessment process. You have loosened pollution norms for thermal power plants.
I see Modi saying the right things but his actions are completely different.

What should be India's attitude, red-lines in Glasgow?

Modi will not go for red-lines or deadlines. He will only go for headlines. I
don't go by this notion of red-lines and deadlines. Frankly, as of today, we
cannot obviously announce that we are going to phase-out fossil fuels. We can
certainly announce a phase-down strategy. I will give you an example. I don't
see why we can't say that by 2045, which is a long enough period, India will not
have any petrol or diesel vehicles. That is a doable target.

Read | COP26: Failure is not an option

While we cannot announce economy-wide targets, we can certainly announce some
sectoral initiatives. Should we announce it in Glasgow and all, that is a
separate issue. I am not talking about it. Domestic actions count more than
global announcements. Whatever you announce globally, we really have to back it
up domestically. Everybody recognises India's developmental challenges. Our per
capita consumption of electricity is 1/8th of Europe, it is 1/15th in the US,
1/6th in China. Electricity consumption in India is bound to increase. We are
not running away from it. But we cannot certainly do it in the good-old
traditional manner. Today, nuclear power accounts for 3-3.4% of electricity
generation. It ought to have been at least double that contribution today. So
nuclear power in climate change point of view is a better option than coal.

Unfortunately what has happened in India is that the nuclear programme has not
expanded at the rate at which it ought to have expanded and therefore, the
pressure on coal has increased. But we must start thinking very seriously about
a phase-down, not a phase-out. There is a difference between phase-down and
phase-out. Now, if there is a dramatic decline in the cost of energy storage,
which I think will happen, then the pressure on India to expand the coal-based
power generation to provide the base load will be reduced substantially. As of
now, because of the intermittency of the renewable energy, you still require
base load capacity. That base load capacity comes either from gas or coal or
nuclear. We have difficult choices to make but we have to be very clear about
the path we are going.

The path should be a phase-down path. But we can certainly consider phase-outs
in specific areas, like phasing out petrol and diesel vehicles by 2040 or 2045
in India. Today, Tesla has become the sixth trillion dollar market cap company.
India made some commitments at Paris. We will fulfil two of the three
commitments -- those were commitments I had made in 2009 and I was criticised
bitterly by BJP's late Arun Jaitley and everybody else. In 2015, the Modi
government made it part of the Paris agreement. So in emission intensity,
undoubtedly we will meet the target.

On the commitment of 40% of electricity coming from non-fossil fuels, I am sure
we will exceed the target. But the commitment on forestry we have made is
completely bogus. We said that we will expand the contribution of our forests to
absorb the carbon as 'carbon sink'. That is not going to happen, particularly
when you are going to destroy natural forests and if you are not going to
regenerate forests. If you are going to liberalise all your forest conservation
laws, which is very much on the agenda, then I am afraid we are going up
completely the wrong track.

Commerce Minister Piyush Goyal has said that India needs to be in the Nuclear
Suppliers Group to quit coal power. What is your view?

Where I disagree with Piyush Goyal is that I have always believed and I have
said this in 2009 that India should have standardised on its own design of a
heavy water reactor. India should not depend on imported reactors. I have a
fundamental problem with that. Two standard 700 MW reactors are coming up in
Kakrapar in Gujarat and more elsewhere. India should standardise on those
reactors. We should build on those reactors. To think that imported reactors are
going to be the answer to India's nuclear capacity problems, I have never been
in agreement with this view. I have stated this in 2009 that India must
standardise on its own indigenous design, upgrade it. We went from 210 MW, then
we built 500 MW, then 700 MW. We can upgrade it to 1,000 MW.

Are you saying that one should not link the NSG membership with this?

No. I am just saying that we should not depend on imported reactors. After all,
we signed the nuclear deal in 2005. Have we got any imported reactors? We
haven't. India's nuclear strategy must be based on standardisation of its own
700 MW reactor. It cannot depend on imported reactors. Fundamental starting
point of Goyal's statement is that we will depend on imported reactors. He is
linking the import of reactors with the NSG. I am not talking about NSG
membership. India must be a member of the NSG. That I agree. We have been trying
that and we must pursue that. But I don't think imported reactors are the answer
to India's nuclear problems. India's nuclear programme is at cross roads.
Nuclear power accounts for 3-3.4% and we ought to have been 6%. We should by
2040 aim to have at least 10-15% of our electricity coming from nuclear power.

Another argument is about climate finance. Environment Minister Bhupender Yadav
has said in Glasgow that developed nations have not adhered to their commitment.
What is your response?

I agree. They have not. They made a promise of $100 billion. I think they are at
about $80 billion. That is a generous figure because they have re-classified
development assistance as climate finance. My view has always been -- this view
I have taken when I was a Minister -- that countries like India and China are
perfectly capable of raising the resources required for meeting their climate
objectives. This climate finance is largely for smaller countries -- African
countries, island States etc. It is also for countries like India. In fact, I
negotiated India's first climate loan for Himachal Pradesh from the World Bank.
It was one of the first World Bank projects on climate finance. But India's
capacity to generate resources, domestically and internationally, is very
strong. I don't think we should link what we do to the availability of finance.
I have never been sympathetic to this view.

Has the government reached out to the Opposition before going to Glasgow?

No. Zero. In 2009, I wrote to the Lok Sabha Speaker requesting to nominate MPs
for the Copenhagen summit. They were not selected by me but by the Speaker.
Murli Manohar Joshi, Bhartruhari Mahtab, Suresh Prabhu among others were there
in the delegation. There were four debates in Parliament before and after
Copenhagen. There were two debates each before and after Cancun. There was no
reach out this time.

Watch latest videos by DH here:

GET A ROUND-UP OF THE DAY'S TOP STORIES IN YOUR INBOX

A verification email has been sent to your inbox. Please verify to complete the
subscription.
Please enter a valid email address

Check out all newsletters

Deccan Herald News now on Telegram - Click here to subscribe

GET A ROUND-UP OF THE DAY'S TOP STORIES IN YOUR INBOX

A verification email has been sent to your inbox. Please verify to complete the
subscription.
Please enter a valid email address
Top News of the Day
Tune in to DH Radio
DH Video on Demand
Best of DH Opinion
DH Sportsletter
Best Of DH On Weekends
Political Theatre
Subscribe Now

India
COP26
Jairam Ramesh
Climate Change
global warming

by Taboolaby Taboola
Sponsored LinksSponsored Links
Promoted LinksPromoted Links
You May Like
Les Girandières

Vivre en résidence pour seniors, comment ça marche ?Les Girandières

Undo
Bitdefender

Votre antivirus est-il fiable ?Bitdefender

Undo
Lecomparateurassurance.com

Les retraités s’emballent pour cette mutuelle à
10,11€/moisLecomparateurassurance.com

Undo
Safe Life Tips

La plupart des Français qui utilisent Windows ne connaissent pas cette
astuceSafe Life TipsEn savoir plus

Undo
Forge Of Empires - Jeu en ligne

Le nouveau jeu de construction qui rend tout le monde accro. Pas
d'installationForge Of Empires - Jeu en ligne

Undo
Nutravya

Un docteur révèle : Un truc simple pour les problèmes de prostateNutravya

Undo
Aides panneaux solaires

Ces panneaux solaires sont financés dans la région Hauts-de-franceAides panneaux
solaires

Undo
Top 20 Gadget Deals

Here Are 20+ of the Coolest Gadgets for 2022Top 20 Gadget DealsShop Now

Undo
VisionaryProfit

Wall Street “Loser” Becomes the Trader For The Top 1%VisionaryProfit

Undo

www.deccanherald.com Open in urlscan Pro 13.32.99.18 Public Scan

Form analysis 3 forms found in the DOM

GET /search

Text Content

www.deccanherald.com Open in urlscan Pro
13.32.99.18 Public Scan

Form analysis
3 forms found in the DOM