www.bloomberg.com Open in urlscan Pro
151.101.65.73  Public Scan

Form analysis
0 forms found in the DOM

Text Content

Skip to content



Skip to content
Bloomberg the Company & Its ProductsThe Company & its ProductsBloomberg Terminal
Demo RequestBloomberg Anywhere Remote LoginBloomberg Anywhere LoginBloomberg
Customer SupportCustomer Support

Bloomberg Webinars: Access a broad range of analysis, research, insight & ideas.

MenuSearch
Bloomberg Businessweek
Sign InSign OutSubscribe



 * HOME


 * MARKETS


 * TECHNOLOGY


 * POLITICS


 * WEALTH


 * PURSUITS


 * OPINION


 * BUSINESSWEEK


 * NEW ECONOMY


 * EQUALITY


 * GREEN


 * CITYLAB

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------


 * QUICKTAKE


 * BLOOMBERG TV+


 * PODCASTS


 * RADIO


 * BLOOMBERG LIVE

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------


 * NEWSLETTERS


 * WATCHLIST


 * SUBSCRIBE


 * SIGN IN

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------


 * SUBMIT A TIP


 * HELP CENTER


 * LICENSE

Read
 * Bloomberg New Economy
 * Future Finance
 * Wealth
 * Next China
 * Crypto
 * Checkout
 * Hyperdrive
 * Well Spent
 * Prognosis
 * Good Business
 * Billionaires
 * Graphics
 * Sponsored Content
 * Screentime

Watch
 * The David Rubenstein Show
 * The David Rubenstein Wealth Show
 * Art + Technology
 * Future GO

Special Reports
 * Covid-19 Vaccine Tracker
 * What Wall Street Expects for 2021
 * Where to Invest $10,000
 * 50 Companies to Watch
 * Where to Invest $1 Million

Follow
 * Facebook
 * Twitter
 * Instagram
 * LinkedIn


Read
 * Economics
 * Deals
 * Odd Lots
 * The FIX | Fixed Income
 * ETFs
 * FX
 * Factor Investing
 * Alternative Investing
 * Markets Magazine

Watch
 * Daybreak
 * Surveillance
 * Markets
 * What'd You Miss
 * Real Yield
 * Charting Futures
 * Futures in Focus

Follow
 * Twitter
 * Facebook

Data
 * Stocks
 * Currencies
 * Commodities
 * Rates & Bonds
 * Sectors
 * Economic Calendar

SUBSCRIBE
 * Five Things: U.S.
 * Five Things: Europe
 * Five Things: Asia
 * Evening Briefing

Listen
 * What Goes Up
 * Stephanomics
 * Odd Lots
 * Surveillance
 * P&L
 * Trillions


Read
 * Work Shifting
 * Code Wars
 * 5G Network

Special Reports
 * The Elon Musk Tracker
 * Tesla Model 3 Tracker

Watch
 * Bloomberg Technology TV
 * Studio 1.0

Subscribe
 * Fully Charged
 * Power On
 * Game On

Listen
 * Decrypted

Follow
 * Twitter
 * Facebook


Read
 * Election 2020
 * Global Trade Tracker

Listen
 * Sound On
 * Bloomberg Law

Watch
 * Balance of Power

Subscribe
 * Balance of Power

Follow
 * Twitter
 * Facebook


Read
 * Investing
 * Living
 * Opinion & Advice
 * Savings & Retirement
 * Taxes
 * Reinvention

Watch
 * Good Money
 * The David Rubenstein Wealth Show

Listen
 * The Paycheck

Follow
 * Twitter
 * Facebook
 * Instagram


Read
 * Travel
 * Autos
 * Homes
 * Living
 * Culture
 * Style

Special Reports
 * Where to Go in 2021
 * London Property Prices
 * New York Property Prices

Watch
 * Made
 * Traveler
 * Invitation Only

Follow
 * Twitter
 * Facebook
 * Instagram


Read
 * Editorials
 * Letters

Follow
 * Twitter
 * Facebook
 * Instagram

Listen
 * Masters in Business

Subscribe
 * Bloomberg Opinion Today
 * Money Stuff
 * Ritholtz's Reads
 * Early Returns
 * Sparklines


Special Reports
 * Business of Equality
 * The Bloomberg 50
 * Best B-Schools
 * Small Business Survival Guide
 * Working From Home
 * 50 Companies to Watch

The Magazine
 * Subscribe
 * Manage

Follow
 * Twitter
 * Facebook
 * Instagram


Watch
 * New Economy Conversation Series
 * 2020 Digital Program Highlights

Subscribe
 * Turning Points

Listen
 * Stephanomics

Follow
 * Twitter
 * Facebook
 * LinkedIn
 * WeChat


Read
 * Corporate Leadership
 * Capital
 * Society
 * Solutions

Follow
 * Twitter
 * Instagram


Read
 * Science & Energy
 * Climate Adaptation
 * Finance
 * Politics
 * Culture & Design

Special Reports
 * Data Dash

Subscribe
 * Green Daily

Follow
 * Twitter
 * Facebook
 * Instagram


Read
 * Design
 * Culture
 * Transportation
 * Economy
 * Environment
 * Housing
 * Justice
 * Government

Subscribe
 * CityLab Daily
 * MapLab
 * Most Popular

Follow
 * Twitter
 * Facebook
 * Instagram
 * LinkedIn


Live
 * Watch Live TV

Original Series
 * Storylines
 * Moonshot
 * Hello World
 * Good Money
 * Game Changers
 * CityLab Solutions
 * Accelerate
 * See all series...

News Shows
 * Take Charge
 * Take a Break
 * Take the Lead
 * Geo

Follow
 * YouTube
 * Twitter
 * Instagram
 * Facebook


Watch Live TV
 * US
 * Europe
 * Asia
 * Australia
 * Schedule+Shows

Shows
 * Surveillance
 * Daybreak
 * Markets
 * Balance of Power
 * Bloomberg Technology
 * The David Rubenstein Show
 * What'd You Miss?
 * All Shows...

Follow
 * YouTube
 * Twitter
 * Facebook


Listen
 * What Goes Up
 * Stephanomics
 * Odd Lots
 * Foundering
 * Masters in Business
 * Surveillance
 * The Tape
 * Businessweek
 * The Pay Check
 * Prognosis
 * Travel Genius
 * Works for Me
 * Trillions
 * All Podcasts…
 * All Radio Shows…



Cut through the chaos with real time updates on the news affecting the global
economy. Enable Notifications.
Enable Later


Businessweek
Feature


PELOTON GOT TRAPPED IN ITS TRILLION-DOLLAR FANTASY

Fueled by manic demand during the early days of Covid, the company spent the
next two years chasing a dream of fitness dominance.

By

Drake Bennett and

Mark Gurman

+Follow
March 10, 2022, 10:00 AM GMTUpdated onMarch 10, 2022, 9:51 PM GMT

Illustration: Max Guther for Bloomberg Businessweek


SHARE THIS ARTICLE






Copied

Up until a few years ago, it was safe to assume that someone using the word
“peloton” was talking about either competitive bicycle racing (the term refers
to the main pack of riders) or a French-speaking country’s military (it means
“platoon”).

That assumption no longer holds. Peloton Interactive Inc. has ascended into the
pantheon of companies that have eclipsed their names, sitting alongside Facebook
(Harvard’s freshman directory), Starbucks (the first mate in Moby-Dick), and
Google (a very big number spelled “googol”). Six and a half million people use
its exercise bikes and treadmills and take its online classes. Its cultural
footprint is even larger: Those classes are plot points in television dramas and
are parodied on Saturday Night Live. Peloton’s instructors are celebrities, with
wellness consultancies and clothing lines. President Joe Biden fought with his
security staff to bring his Peloton bike to the White House. The name has become
a verb and a Rorschach blot: for the possibilities of digital communities, for
the lifestyle changes wrought by Covid-19, for the cultishness of curated
high-intensity exercise, and for the prospect of the rich and fit getting even
fitter from the comfort of their pool houses.



Peloton has also, however, become a test case for the brittle link between
attention and financial success. For a few months during the pandemic, there was
a sense that the company might represent the future of fitness: In December 2020
its share price peaked at $160. Today, as life begins to return to something
resembling pre-Covid, the stock hovers around $23 a share, and demand for
Peloton’s machines and content has dropped. On Feb. 8, co-founder John Foley
stepped down as chief executive officer, and the company announced it was laying
off 2,800 employees, or one-fifth of its workforce, amid other severe
cost-cutting measures.

If Peloton’s story thus far were a Peloton class, it would be a high-intensity
one, perhaps even a Tabata ride. Everyone would pedal as fast as they could,
recover for not long enough, then do it again, as a charismatic figure on the
screen urged them on with promises of transformational personal growth and of
the massiveness of the total addressable market of subscription fitness. Midway
through, the instructor would announce that the 20-minute class would actually
go for an hour. Here and there, riders would injure themselves. There would be
technical issues with the machines. At the end, right after recommending a
five-minute post-ride stretching class and intoning his mantra—“We’re not a
stationary bike company, we’re not a treadmill company, we are an innovation
company that is at the nexus of fitness, technology, and media!”—the instructor
would announce his transition to a new role at the company. It would be
exhilarating and entertaining, but perhaps not a ride you’d want to do every
day.

The idea for Peloton came from an expensive habit. John Foley was a peripatetic
tech executive who had helped Barnes & Noble Inc. develop the Nook e-reader. He
was also a devotee of immersive, branded exercise classes, whose studios began
to appear in upscale enclaves all over the U.S. in the mid-2000s. The best-known
of them was probably SoulCycle, which took the concept of a spin
class—stationary bikes, propulsive music, an enthusiastic instructor announcing
how fast to pedal and where to set the resistance on the wheel—and infused it
with a New Age identity. There was also Barry’s Bootcamp, which wedded treadmill
workouts and weights, replacing the psychological brutality of an actual
military boot camp with a more affirming ethos; Pure Barre, which drew on
ballet; and Orangetheory Fitness, which has something to do with heart rate
zones. Foley and his wife were the kind of fitness-focused urban professionals
who structured their life around these classes, spending their ample disposable
income (classes run almost $40 per session) and scarce leisure time on them.

But after John and Jill had their two kids, it was harder to find time for the
classes and harder to get into the ones with the most popular instructors. What
if we didn’t have to leave the house to go to the classes, Foley wondered, and
what if the classroom could be infinitely large? As he would describe it years
later, at the TechCrunch Disrupt conference in 2018, “I knew from going to the
boutique instructor-led group fitness classes [that] there’s something magical
that happens in this room, with the instructor, and the other people, and the
energy, and the music, and the motivation—the whole program that is a class.”
Why not digitize that and bring it home, the way Netflix Inc. did with other
kinds of programming? (Foley declined to comment for this story.) From his time
creating the Nook, and from a job he’d had during and after college running the
assembly line at a candy factory (he oversaw Skittles and Starburst production
for all of North America), he felt as if he knew enough about manufacturing to
develop a high-end bike.



The idea’s promise wasn’t immediately evident to the investors Foley pitched
after starting his company in 2012. They were dubious of the size of the market
and about Foley’s dream of producing not only the classes but the bikes. Many of
them also told him, as Foley would later reminisce, that if he ever actually did
manage to manufacture a bike, they’d love one for their own home gym. He funded
the first prototypes on Kickstarter.

It didn’t take long for the company to find a committed user base. By 2017,
108,000 households were paying $39 monthly for Peloton’s connected fitness
subscriptions. Two years later, it was half a million. Over the same period,
total revenue rose from $219 million to $915 million. In the prospectus for its
2019 initial public offering, Peloton pointed to its 12-month retention rate of
95% as evidence that its product was “engaging-to-the-point-of-addictive.” Foley
predicted that Peloton would be a trillion-dollar company.

For those outside the pack, however, the appeal could be befuddling. This was a
$2,200 stationary bike—10 times what a decent alternative would cost—whose
content cost another $500 a year. The company tried to address this, cutting the
price of its bike over time to $1,500, teaming with the financing company Affirm
Inc. to provide an installment plan, and offering digital subscriptions that
don’t require the purchase of the bike at all.

Even so, a genre of online mockery developed to snark the company’s television
commercials, in which customers pedaled away in dedicated Peloton rooms with
million-dollar views. “You might ask why the windows in front of these Pelotons
are so small,” read one Twitter parody caption. “Unfortunately space on the
yacht is limited and the gym is near the waterline. We manage.” A 2019 holiday
TV ad that presented itself as a video made by a young mother to thank her
husband for the life-changing gift of her spin bike became the company’s first
public-relations debacle. The woman’s manic riding, while wearing a wide-eyed
expression somewhere between apprehension and terror, was interpreted by much of
social media not as a testament to her deep emotional bond with her connected
exercise device, but as the plea of a hostage to body-image expectations chained
to a high-tech hamster wheel.

In the six months after Peloton went public in September 2019, the stock price
bounced around, reflecting, in part, broader doubts about whether the success
would last. Peloton continued to add users, but it was paying dearly for them.
In the quarter ended Dec. 31, 2019, it spent $161 million, or a little more than
a third of its revenue, on sales and marketing. Like lots of buzzy tech
unicorns, it lost money.

With the pandemic, though, suddenly the choice for potential consumers wasn’t
between a Peloton and a gym membership; it was between a Peloton and nothing. By
the end of 2020, 1.7 million households had Peloton machines and were paying for
subscriptions. Over the next year, the company added a million more. The
pandemic, Foley insisted, wasn’t fueling a fad; it was giving people the chance
to see how much they had always needed to be members of a high-end virtual
fitness community. “When I hear Peloton being a Covid story in the press, it
annoys the crap out of me, because what we’re building is here to stay, and it’s
going to grow,” he said at the Goldman Sachs Builders + Innovators Summit on
Oct. 15, 2020. The recent growth, he declared, “is an acceleration of the
inevitable.” Inside the company, things felt heady. “There was a massive push to
hire very quickly, to grow and kick off new projects,” says a former executive
who spoke on the condition of anonymity to avoid jeopardizing future career
prospects. “It felt like there was nothing but tremendous growth ahead of us.”



It wasn’t a future Peloton was prepared to meet, especially as the global supply
chain convulsed. In December 2020 the company announced it was acquiring the
fitness-machine maker Precor Inc. to buttress its manufacturing capacity. In May
2021 it announced it was breaking ground on a $400 million factory in Ohio. Even
so, Peloton fell far behind on orders, and wait times lengthened. Foley pledged
$100 million to clear the logjam, in part by shipping bikes by air. A recent
article in FT Magazine revealed that when the company discovered that bikes were
arriving from its overseas plant with rust on them, staff were instructed to
spray the bikes with a chemical cover-up and ship them out. (The name for this
initiative was Project Tinman. The company said it had no impact on the
performance of the bikes.) Along the way, aging alpha males on not one but two
TV shows, HBO’s Sex and the City reboot and Showtime’s Billions, suffered
Peloton-induced heart attacks.

In the real world, problems were emerging about the safety of Peloton’s line of
treadmills, which it started selling in 2018. The U.S. Consumer Product Safety
Commission found that the touchscreen on the Peloton Tread could fall off,
potentially injuring the user. The company fixed the problem, and the machine
was soon back on the market. But on the higher-end Tread+, the risks were more
serious. In an April 2021 warning, after a 6-year-old was killed by a machine,
the CPSC wrote that the Tread+ posed “serious risks to children for abrasions,
fractures, and death.” The safety regulator eventually reported 72 injuries to
people and pets. Peloton called the bulletin “inaccurate and misleading” and
insisted there was no reason for anyone to stop using the Tread+ as long as they
followed directions and kept kids and animals away from it. But the following
month it agreed to a recall.

By the beginning of 2022, all the scrambling and expenditures and rust-covering
had seemingly paid off. Peloton was finally making enough bikes to meet
pandemic-era demand. The only problem was that pandemic-era demand was now gone.
In January, CNBC reported that the company had such a glut of inventory it was
pausing bike and treadmill manufacturing for several weeks. In a note on the
company website, Foley denied the report but conceded that Peloton was
“right-sizing our production.”

Peloton was still growing; it just wasn’t the wild growth Foley had aimed for.
If he hadn’t spent the previous two years chasing the dream that the pandemic
represented the company’s trillion-dollar future—if he hadn’t spent hundreds of
millions of dollars on marketing, built half a factory, and hired thousands of
people who now are being fired—Peloton would probably look like a success story.

Instead, in the quarter ended September 2021, the company lost $376 million. It
lost $439 million over the next three months. Along with the layoffs, Peloton is
abandoning its Ohio expansion (“The Ohio factory and Precor acquisitions were
huge mistakes,” the former executive now says). Equally worrisome: Existing
members don’t seem to be getting on their bike as often as they were during the
lockdowns. The average number of workouts for each Peloton subscriber peaked in
early 2021 and has been dropping steadily ever since.



There’s more talent in the building than I expected,” says Barry McCarthy, the
new CEO. It’s a compliment, sort of, paid to Peloton’s remaining employees if
not their accomplishments. “Execution challenges have of course been
disappointing.” McCarthy makes clear that he believes the scramble to keep up
with pandemic demand hurt the company. Among other things, it took the focus
away from the product itself and on how to make it better.

Speaking by Zoom from Peloton’s Manhattan headquarters, McCarthy, who was chief
financial officer of Netflix and then of Spotify Technology SA, says he’s a
longtime user himself. Then he describes “an opportunity to quickly refocus
people on a process of experimentation and learning that will restore a sense of
momentum and progress.” The plan follows a well-worn Silicon Valley playbook.
McCarthy talks about making lots of small bets and failing fast, about A/B
testing to see what consumers actually want.


CEO McCarthy
Photographer: Michael Nagle/Bloomberg

New products are coming, of course. There’s the Guide, for lifting weights in
front of your TV, and a rowing machine. The company also continues to work with
regulators to get the Tread+ reapproved. All those devices will be necessary to
compete in an increasingly crowded landscape of connected fitness contraptions,
including new brands, like Mirror and Tonal, and older ones, like NordicTrack
and Bowflex. Another competitor, Zwift Inc., doesn’t bother to build machines at
all. It caters to serious cyclists who provide their own training bikes.

The bring-your-own-bike model holds evident appeal for McCarthy, who’s less
interested in the physical machines than in his company’s content. “The magic
happens in the tablet,” he says. He muses that perhaps the Peloton screen should
be an open platform where third-party programmers can place apps. Or maybe the
company could try the inkjet printer business model, offering machines for cheap
and making money through higher monthly subscription fees. At the moment, you
can ride your bike even if you’re not paying for classes. McCarthy plans to
experiment with making those payments mandatory. (On March 10, the company
announced such a test, saying it would create a monthly subscription that
combines the price of its hardware and content and lacks an upfront hardware
payment.)

In all of this, McCarthy says he’ll let the data be his instructor. It’s a
familiar narrative: Startup founder gives way to the bean counters and market
researchers. Peloton, more than perhaps any other company, trades on charisma—of
its instructors, of its corporate leadership, of its hardcore users cheerfully
touting the brand. But even cults need accountants.

Peloton says it’s not for sale, but anytime a company’s stock price drops as
much as its has, takeover rumors are inevitable. And McCarthy’s proposed
strategy of juicing subscriber numbers, outsourcing manufacturing, and opening
up the software platform could make the company appealing to a cash-rich tech
giant. Apple Inc. has been mentioned as a possible acquirer, but the company
already has its own fitness features and content. Amazon, on the other hand, is
always looking to add more material to Amazon Prime, and Peloton’s classes could
also make it tempting to Netflix or Walt Disney Co. Nike Inc. might see the
company as a way to reenter the market for digital hardware.

How long McCarthy will remain at Peloton is unclear. “You know, I kind of think
in three- or four-year increments,” he says. “I’m 68 now, and part of the answer
would depend on how I’m managing my health and stamina.” The CEO is pacing
himself, in other words, and he thinks the company should, too. —With Kristen V.
Brown



 

(Updates with information about a new pricing test in paragraph 21.)


SHARE THIS ARTICLE






Copied
Follow the authors
+ Get alerts forDrake Bennett
@markgurman
+ Get alerts forMark Gurman
Have a confidential tip for our reporters?
Get in touch
Before it's here, it's on the
Bloomberg Terminal
Learn more
Terms of Service Manage Cookies Trademarks Privacy Policy ©2022 Bloomberg L.P.
All Rights Reserved
Careers Made in NYC Advertise Ad Choices Help



Your monthly limit of free content is about to expire. Stay on top of historic
market volatility. Try 3 months for $8.75 $0.50 per week. Cancel anytime.
Claim This Offer
Sign In
Bloomberg Anywhere clients get free access