www.npr.org Open in urlscan Pro
2a02:26f0:ea:490::1155  Public Scan

Form analysis
0 forms found in the DOM

Text Content

Accessibility links
 * Skip to main content
 * Keyboard shortcuts for audio player

 * Open Navigation Menu
 * 
 * 
 * 
 * NPR Shop
 * 

> Close Navigation Menu
 * Home
 * News Expand/collapse submenu for News
   * National
   * World
   * Politics
   * Business
   * Health
   * Science
   * Climate
   * Race
 * Culture Expand/collapse submenu for Culture
   * Books
   * Movies
   * Television
   * Pop Culture
   * Food
   * Art & Design
   * Performing Arts
   * Life Kit
 * Music Expand/collapse submenu for Music
   * Tiny Desk
   * #NowPlaying
   * All Songs Considered
   * Music Features
   * Live Sessions
 * Podcasts & Shows Expand/collapse submenu for Podcasts & Shows
   Daily
    * Morning Edition
    * Weekend Edition Saturday
    * Weekend Edition Sunday
    * All Things Considered
    * Fresh Air
    * Up First
   
   Featured
    * Planet Money
    * Rough Translation
    * Life Kit
    * NPR's Book of the Day
   
    * More Podcasts & Shows

 * Search
 * 
 * NPR Shop

 * 
 * Tiny Desk
 * #NowPlaying
 * All Songs Considered
 * Music Features
 * Live Sessions

 * About NPR
 * Diversity
 * Organization
 * Support
 * Careers
 * Connect
 * Press
 * Ethics

Inside the rise of 'stealerships' and the shady economics of car buying : Planet
Money Car dealerships deploy tricks and traps to make as much money as they can
from you. Here's what I learned when trying to buy a new car.


PLANET MONEY

The Economy Explained
 * Planet Money Podcast
 * The Indicator Podcast
 * Planet Money Newsletter Archive
 * About


 * Twitter
 * Facebook

   
   
   NPR
 * subscribe to Planet Money podcast
 *  * NPR One
    * Apple Podcasts
    * Spotify
    * Google Podcasts
    * RSS link

PERSPECTIVE


NEWSLETTER


INSIDE THE RISE OF 'STEALERSHIPS' AND THE SHADY ECONOMICS OF CAR BUYING

   
   
   NPR
 * subscribe to Planet Money podcast
 *  * NPR One
    * Apple Podcasts
    * Spotify
    * Google Podcasts
    * RSS link

 * Facebook
 * Twitter
 * Flipboard
 * Email

August 30, 20226:30 AM ET

Greg Rosalsky

Enlarge this image

Creative Commons

Creative Commons

Recently, my truck was stolen, forcing me to get some new wheels. And, for the
first time in my life, I've been looking to buy a new car. The process has
involved hours of searching. Painful haggling. And encounters with many
dealerships that, quite frankly, have been downright duplicitous. The whole
thing has been kind of a nightmare.

Cars are, of course, expensive, especially with the supply chain fiasco creating
shortages. But it's more than that. Shopping for cars is not like shopping for
most other products. Unlike, say, computers or refrigerators, cars are typically
not sold for one standard price. Ten people could go into a dealership and each
pay a wildly different amount to buy the same exact vehicle.

Economists call this sort of pricing strategy "price discrimination." That's
when, instead of charging everyone the same price, sellers charge people
different prices based on their willingness to pay. In simpler terms, it means
that the seller milks as much money as they can out of you. Not all dealerships
engage in this pricing strategy, but many do it aggressively, often with snake
oil-style salesmanship, deceptive marketing tactics, hidden fees, and overpriced
add-ons, like floor mats, alarm systems, or anti-rust undercoating. Some
consumers call the outfits that employ these tactics "stealerships."



The tricky pricing strategy used by dealerships can be maddening for consumers,
and I've personally found haggling over the price of a new truck with slick,
commission-seeking salespeople to be exhausting (Fortunately, my partner has
proved herself to be a talented haggler).

A slew of economic studies has found patterns in who bears the brunt of this
pricing strategy. It's not pretty. For example, a number of studies find that
dealerships tend to charge people of color more than white folks. Another study
finds that older people tend to be charged higher prices than younger people,
and that older women tend to be charged the highest price of all.

One study found that dealerships tend to treat a buyer's decision to trade in
their used car like a neon sign on their foreheads, flashing, "Charge me more!"
That's because trading in your used car, while easier than selling it directly,
also fetches less money. Dealerships apparently see this as an indicator that
you're either unsavvy or willing to burn cash — so they jack up the price of the
car they sell to you. The type of car you trade in also offers a wealth of
information on how much they can charge.



In normal times, when supply is ample and dealerships are more worried about
getting cars off the lot, it's common for them to charge less than the
Manufacturer Suggested Retail Price (MSRP). But with supply-chain problems
creating shortages of new vehicles recently, many dealerships have been charging
much more than MSRP. Meanwhile, the dealerships that don't add markups to MSRP
are seeing their inventory depleted quickly, and often have wait times of months
or even years for coveted vehicles.

Michelle Krebs is a longtime automotive researcher who serves as the executive
analyst of Cox Automotive, which owns brands like Kelley Blue Book and
Autotrader. "This is the first time in my career — and it's a long career — that
I've seen most dealerships charging at list price or over," she says. "And it's
simply because there's high demand, low inventory, and they can do it." Krebs
says she's seen some cases where dealerships have charged buyers literally tens
of thousands of dollars over MSRP.


AUTOMAKERS VS. DEALERSHIPS

Dealerships are usually independent franchises of their affiliated automaker,
which means they are autonomous businesses that can basically do what they want
when it comes to setting prices. But many automakers are not happy with their
franchises charging crazy high markups. A recent study from the consumer group
Growth for Knowledge suggests that excessive price gouging sours consumers on
not just a particular dealership, but the car brand as a whole.

At least some automakers know this. Earlier this year, Hyundai Motor Company
sent a letter to its dealerships urging them to end deceptive practices, such as
advertising a low price online and then charging a much higher price when
customers go into the store. The company complained that sky-high markups were
"damaging our brands' long-term ability to capture new customers and retain
loyal ones."

Likewise, Ford Motor Company urged its dealers to cut down on markups and
threatened to cut back on sending them Ford's most coveted vehicles if they
didn't. And yet the new Ford F-150 Lightning electric pickup truck and the Ford
Bronco are some of the most marked-up vehicles on the market, regularly being
priced at much higher levels than what Ford has said they should be sold for.
The problem for Ford: dealerships are independent and the Manufacturer Suggested
Retail Price is just that, suggested.

Newer automakers like Tesla and Rivian have been trying to build distribution
and service networks that jettison the use of independent dealerships. They are
building a direct-to-consumer retail model in which consumers custom-design
their vehicles on the internet and receive them directly from the manufacturer —
without dealership middlemen and exhausting haggling over price with
commission-seeking salespeople. For in-person needs, these automakers provide
their own dealerships and service centers.

However, there are state franchise laws across the country that protect
independent dealerships — and these laws have made it difficult to disrupt the
dealership system and offer consumers potentially a better way of buying a
vehicle.


A V8 POLITICAL ENGINE

To be fair to dealerships, they do provide important services. They offer a
distribution and service network, which is vital to both manufacturers and car
buyers. They offer buyers the ability to check out, test drive, and learn about
cars at their facilities, which really do cost a lot when it comes to real
estate, inventory, and manpower. If the manufacturer recalls something, there
are thousands of local dealerships across the nation there to fix the problem.
They also, of course, create tons of jobs in local communities.

But, while having a sprawling network of local dealerships may be valuable, this
geographic reach also gives them outsized political power. Spread out all over
the place, local dealerships are important constituents for a whole slew of
federal, state, and local politicians. That — together with the fact that
they're a trillion-dollar-plus industry — makes them an effective lobbying
force. And opponents argue that the protective franchise laws they've worked to
erect and maintain thwart entrepreneurs' ability to create new, more efficient
business models that better serve consumers.

We reached out to the National Automobile Dealers Association (NADA), which
represents more than 16,000 dealerships across America, and they provided a
statement. "State legislatures passed franchise laws — and continue to
overwhelmingly support franchise laws — to separate car sales from
manufacturing, prevent monopoly pricing by factories, promote competition in
auto sales and service, and keep jobs and investment local," says NADA Vice
President of Communications Jared Allen. "The franchise system delivers these
tremendous benefits better than anyone."

Some of these claims — like the fact that local dealerships create jobs — are
undeniable. Others are highly debatable. First of all, there are more than a
dozen automakers in the United States, so no single carmaker comes close to
being a monopoly. And it's not clear how adding a middleman to the process
reduces prices for consumers, especially when you consider that this middleman
often resorts to a slew of tactics that tends to raise prices. Many of these
dealerships, by the way, are not mom-and-pop shops; the industry is seeing
growing consolidation, with multibillion-dollar corporations now owning hundreds
of dealerships across the nation.

For years, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), the agency tasked with looking
out for American consumers, has advocated relaxing state franchise laws so that
companies like Tesla or Rivian can create new, direct-to-consumer business
models. "States should allow consumers to choose not only the cars they buy, but
also how they buy them," FTC officials wrote in 2015. But franchise laws
continue to protect the dealership model and thwart innovation.

Earlier this summer, the FTC proposed new rules aimed at combating the graft and
skulduggery found at many dealerships. "As auto prices surge, the Commission is
seeking to eliminate the tricks and traps that make it hard or impossible to
comparison shop or leave consumers saddled with thousands of dollars in unwanted
junk charges," the FTC said.

The new rules the FTC proposes include a ban on deceptive advertising in which
dealerships market cars as way cheaper than they actually intend to sell them
for; a ban on "junk fees for fraudulent add-on products and services that
provide no benefit to the consumer"; and a requirement that dealerships disclose
upfront all costs and conditions for buying their vehicles.

NADA, not surprisingly, opposes these proposed rules. "The FTC's proposed rules
would cause great harm to consumers by significantly extending transaction
times, making the customer experience much more complex and inefficient, and
increasing prices, and NADA again urges the FTC to go back to the drawing board
before forcing implementation of a series of unstudied and untested mandates
that will have such significant negative impacts on customers," says NADA Vice
President of Communications Jared Allen.


BUYING A CAR IN THIS BONKERS MARKET

We asked Michelle Krebs, the longtime automobile industry analyst, if she had
any advice for me — and, more importantly, you, our cherished Planet Money
newsletter readers — about buying a car in this bonkers, supply-constrained
market. "I always say pack your patience and persistence," Krebs says. "You have
to keep looking, keep shopping. You have to be flexible on your choice. You may
not get the brand or car style you want. And, importantly, expand your
geographic search. Most people don't want to shop more than 25 miles away, but
you may need to go farther than that."

In trying to find my new truck, I spent hours searching online and corresponding
with dozens of dealerships located up and down the West Coast and farther
inland. I found some trucks that were literally priced $10,000-$15,000 over
MSRP, and I encountered many of the shady business practices that the FTC is now
trying to ban. I also found honest, "no haggle" dealerships willing to sell the
truck at MSRP. The catch: I'd be forced to wait at least six months for a truck
from them to arrive, and with the theft of my old truck leaving me without a
vehicle, I didn't have that kind of patience.

Luckily, my partner ended up finding the exact truck I wanted, located more than
400 miles away, in Southern California, near her parents' house. The dealership
initially wanted $5,000 over MSRP. But thanks to her fierce negotiations (she's
a lawyer), we were able to talk them down to only $2,000 over. In normal times,
that would be a rip-off. But these are not normal times.

Anyways, at least I have a truck again — and, unlike the last one, this one has
an immobilizer that might prevent it from being stolen.

 * dealership
 * FTC

 * Facebook
 * Twitter
 * Flipboard
 * Email







PLANET MONEY

The Economy Explained

READ & LISTEN

 * Home
 * News
 * Culture
 * Music
 * Podcasts & Shows

CONNECT

 * Newsletters
 * Facebook
 * Twitter
 * Instagram
 * Press
 * Contact & Help

ABOUT NPR

 * Overview
 * Diversity
 * Ethics
 * Finances
 * Public Editor
 * Corrections

GET INVOLVED

 * Support Public Radio
 * Sponsor NPR
 * NPR Careers
 * NPR Shop
 * NPR Events
 * NPR Extra

 * Terms of Use
 * Privacy
 * Your Privacy Choices
 * Text Only
 * 



Sponsor Message

Become an NPR sponsor




COOKIE CONSENT & SPONSORSHIP CHOICES

We and our partners store and access information on your device, such as unique
IDs in cookies to process personal data. You may accept and manage your choices
at any time by clicking `Manage Preferences`, including your right to object
where legitimate interest is relied upon. Your choices will be signaled to our
partners and will not affect your browsing.

By clicking “Accept All,” you agree to the use of cookies, similar tracking and
storage technologies, and information about your device to enhance your viewing,
listening and user experience, personalize content, personalize messages from
NPR’s sponsors, provide social media features, and analyze NPR’s traffic. This
information is shared with social media, sponsorship, analytics, and other
vendors or service providers.


WE AND OUR PARTNERS PROCESS DATA TO PROVIDE:

Actively scan device characteristics for identification. Store and/or access
information on a device. Personalised ads and content, ad and content
measurement, audience insights and product development. List of Partners
(service providers or vendors)

Accept All Reject All Manage Preferences



MANAGE PREFERENCES

We process your data to deliver content or advertisements and measure the
delivery of such content or advertisements to extract insights about our
website. We share this information with our partners on the basis of consent and
legitimate interest. You may exercise your right to consent or object to a
legitimate interest, based on a specific purpose below or at a partner level in
the link under each purpose. These choices will be signaled to our vendors
participating in the Transparency and Consent Framework.
Allow All


MANAGE CONSENT PREFERENCES

STRICTLY NECESSARY OR ESSENTIAL COOKIES

Always Active

These cookies are essential to provide you with services available through the
NPR Services and to enable you to use some of their features. These cookies are
necessary for the website to function and cannot be switched off in our systems.
They are usually set in response to actions made by you that amount to a request
for services, such as setting your privacy preferences, logging in, or filling
in forms. You can set your browser to block or alert you about these cookies,
but some parts of the site will not then work. Without these cookies, the
services that you have asked for cannot be provided, and we only use these
cookies to provide you with those services.

Cookies Details‎

PERFORMANCE AND ANALYTICS COOKIES

Performance and Analytics Cookies

These cookies are used to collect information about traffic to our Services and
how users interact with the NPR Services. The information collected includes the
number of visitors to the NPR Services, the websites that referred visitors to
the NPR Services, the pages that they visited on the NPR Services, what time of
day they visited the NPR Services, whether they have visited the NPR Services
before, and other similar information. We use this information to help operate
the NPR Services more efficiently, to gather broad demographic information and
to monitor the level of activity on the NPR Services. NPR's third-party service
providers that measure and analyze the use of the NPR Services for NPR also use
their own cookies. NPR's third-party analytics service providers use cookies
across multiple sites to collect visitor data (such as data related to age,
gender and visitor interests).

Cookies Details‎

TARGETING AND SPONSOR COOKIES

Targeting and Sponsor Cookies

These cookies track your browsing habits or other information, such as location,
to enable us to show sponsorship credits which are more likely to be of interest
to you. These cookies use information about your browsing history to group you
with other users who have similar interests. Based on that information, and with
our permission, we and our sponsors can place cookies to enable us or our
sponsors to show sponsorship credits and other messages that we think will be
relevant to your interests while you are using third-party services. NPR works
with third-party vendors that may serve sponsorship credits or other messages to
you on other websites after you visit the NPR Services. These third-party
vendors use their own cookies to recognize you as an NPR Services visitor and to
serve you sponsorship credits or other messages on other websites that they
believe you will find most relevant. If you do not allow these cookies, you may
still receive sponsorship or marketing messages, but they may not be targeted to
your interests.

Cookies Details‎

FUNCTIONAL COOKIES

Functional Cookies

These cookies allow NPR Services to remember choices you make when you use them,
such as remembering your Member station preferences and remembering your account
details. The purpose of these cookies is to provide you with a more personal
experience and to avoid you having to re-enter your preferences every time you
visit the NPR Services. They may be set by us or by third party providers whose
services we have added to our pages. If you do not allow these cookies then some
or all of these services may not function properly.

Cookies Details‎

STORE AND/OR ACCESS INFORMATION ON A DEVICE

Store and/or access information on a device

Cookies, device identifiers, or other information can be stored or accessed on
your device for the purposes presented to you.

List of IAB Vendors‎ | View Full Legal Text Opens in a new Tab

PERSONALISED ADS AND CONTENT, AD AND CONTENT MEASUREMENT, AUDIENCE INSIGHTS AND
PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT

Personalised ads and content, ad and content measurement, audience insights and
product development

 * SELECT BASIC ADS
   
   Switch Label
   
   Ads can be shown to you based on the content you’re viewing, the app you’re
   using, your approximate location, or your device type.
   
   Object to Legitimate Interests Remove Objection

 * CREATE A PERSONALISED ADS PROFILE
   
   Switch Label
   
   A profile can be built about you and your interests to show you personalised
   ads that are relevant to you.
   
   Object to Legitimate Interests Remove Objection

 * SELECT PERSONALISED ADS
   
   Switch Label
   
   Personalised ads can be shown to you based on a profile about you.
   
   Object to Legitimate Interests Remove Objection

 * CREATE A PERSONALISED CONTENT PROFILE
   
   Switch Label
   
   A profile can be built about you and your interests to show you personalised
   content that is relevant to you.
   
   Object to Legitimate Interests Remove Objection

 * SELECT PERSONALISED CONTENT
   
   Switch Label
   
   Personalised content can be shown to you based on a profile about you.
   
   Object to Legitimate Interests Remove Objection

 * MEASURE AD PERFORMANCE
   
   Switch Label
   
   The performance and effectiveness of ads that you see or interact with can be
   measured.
   
   Object to Legitimate Interests Remove Objection

 * MEASURE CONTENT PERFORMANCE
   
   Switch Label
   
   The performance and effectiveness of content that you see or interact with
   can be measured.
   
   Object to Legitimate Interests Remove Objection

 * APPLY MARKET RESEARCH TO GENERATE AUDIENCE INSIGHTS
   
   Switch Label
   
   Market research can be used to learn more about the audiences who visit
   sites/apps and view ads.
   
   Object to Legitimate Interests Remove Objection

 * DEVELOP AND IMPROVE PRODUCTS
   
   Switch Label
   
   Your data can be used to improve existing systems and software, and to
   develop new products
   
   Object to Legitimate Interests Remove Objection

List of IAB Vendors‎ | View Full Legal Text Opens in a new Tab

ACTIVELY SCAN DEVICE CHARACTERISTICS FOR IDENTIFICATION

Actively scan device characteristics for identification

Your device can be identified based on a scan of your device's unique
combination of characteristics.

List of IAB Vendors‎ | View Full Legal Text Opens in a new Tab

ENSURE SECURITY, PREVENT FRAUD, AND DEBUG

Always Active

Your data can be used to monitor for and prevent fraudulent activity, and ensure
systems and processes work properly and securely.

List of IAB Vendors‎ | View Full Legal Text Opens in a new Tab

TECHNICALLY DELIVER ADS OR CONTENT

Always Active

Your device can receive and send information that allows you to see and interact
with ads and content.

List of IAB Vendors‎ | View Full Legal Text Opens in a new Tab

MATCH AND COMBINE OFFLINE DATA SOURCES

Always Active

Data from offline data sources can be combined with your online activity in
support of one or more purposes

List of IAB Vendors‎ | View Full Legal Text Opens in a new Tab

LINK DIFFERENT DEVICES

Always Active

Different devices can be determined as belonging to you or your household in
support of one or more of purposes.

List of IAB Vendors‎ | View Full Legal Text Opens in a new Tab

RECEIVE AND USE AUTOMATICALLY-SENT DEVICE CHARACTERISTICS FOR IDENTIFICATION

Always Active

Your device might be distinguished from other devices based on information it
automatically sends, such as IP address or browser type.

List of IAB Vendors‎ | View Full Legal Text Opens in a new Tab
Back Button


PERFORMANCE COOKIES



Search Icon
Filter Icon

Clear
checkbox label label
Apply Cancel
Consent Leg.Interest
checkbox label label
checkbox label label
checkbox label label

 * 
   
   View Cookies
   
    * Name
      cookie name

Reject All Confirm My Choices