www.dallasnews.com
Open in
urlscan Pro
2600:1400:d::17db:5cb1
Public Scan
Submitted URL: http://www.dallasnews.com/opinion/commentary/2023/01/21/texas-is-giving-away-revenue-and-taking-new-mexicos-waste/
Effective URL: https://www.dallasnews.com/opinion/commentary/2023/01/21/texas-is-giving-away-revenue-and-taking-new-mexicos-waste/
Submission: On January 25 via api from CA — Scanned from CA
Effective URL: https://www.dallasnews.com/opinion/commentary/2023/01/21/texas-is-giving-away-revenue-and-taking-new-mexicos-waste/
Submission: On January 25 via api from CA — Scanned from CA
Form analysis 1 forms found in the DOM
<form class="dmnc_features-cta-newsletter-cta-newsletter-module__B4BKV flex flex-nowrap"><label for="subscribeEmail" class="accessibly-hidden">Enter email to subscribe</label><input type="text" id="subscribeEmail"
class="dmnc_features-cta-newsletter-cta-newsletter-module__59ohJ py-4 pl-4 pr-9 w-full border rounded-sm" placeholder="Email Address" inputid="subscribeEmail" value="" style="border-width: 1px; border-color: rgb(187, 193, 196);"><button
class="dmnc_features-cta-newsletter-cta-newsletter-module__ByBSk -ml-9" disabled=""><svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="24" height="24" viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="none" stroke="currentColor" stroke-width="2" stroke-linecap="round"
stroke-linejoin="round" class="feather feather-arrow-right" title="subscribe">
<path d="M5 12h14M12 5l7 7-7 7"></path>
</svg></button></form>Text Content
NEWS
*
*
*
*
*
* Collin County
* Coronavirus
* Courts
* Crime
* Education
* Elections
* Environment
* Healthy Living
* Immigration
* Inspired
* Investigations
* National
* News Commentary
* Obituaries
* Politics
* Public Health
* Public Safety
* Texas
* Transportation
* Watchdog
* Weather
* World
BUSINESS
* Airlines
* Autos
* Banking
* Business Commentary
* Economy
* Energy
* Entrepreneurs
* Health Care
* Jobs
* Local Companies
* Personal Finance
* Philanthropy
* Real Estate
* Retail
* Technology
* Top 100
SPORTS
*
*
*
* Baylor Bears
* College Sports
* Cowboys
* FC Dallas
* Golf
* Mavericks
* North Texas
* Oklahoma Sooners
* Other Schools
* Other Sports
* Rangers
* SMU Mustangs
* Stars
* TCU Horned Frogs
* Texas A&M Aggies
* Texas Longhorns
* Texas Tech Red Raiders
* TV Radio Listings
* Wings
HIGH SCHOOL SPORTS
* Baseball
* Basketball
* Football
* Other Sports
* Soccer
* Softball
* Volleyball
ARTS & ENTERTAINMENT
*
* Architecture
* Books
* Holidays
* Lifestyle
* Movies
* Performing Arts
* Pop Culture
* Pop Music
* State Fair
* Travel
* TV
* Visual Arts
FOOD
* Restaurant News
* Recipes
* Farm-to-Table
* Restaurant Reviews
* Drinks
* Cooking
GO SEE DFW
* Editor's Picks Events
* Free Events
* Pop Music Events
* Museums and Sculptures
* Holiday Events
OPINION
* Commentary
* Editorials
* Letters to the Editor
* Submit a Letter to the Editor
* Texan of the Year
* The American Middle
* We Recommend
SPONSORED CONTENT
*
* Branded Content
* North Texas Giving Guide
* Sponsored Content | Spanish
* Timeless in Texas
MORE
* Classifieds
* Obituaries
* Celebrations
GUIDES
* Voter Guide
* School Guide
* Assisted Living Guide
* Parents' Guide to Summer
* Parks Guide
AL DÍA
TODAY'S EPAPER
TODAY'S ARTICLES IN PRINT
Sections
Search
TDMN
* News
* Business
* Sports
* High School Sports
* Arts & Entertainment
* Food
* Go See DFW
* Opinion
Sign In
* Manage Account
* ePaper
Subscribe now
$1 for 3 months
Featured:
* Top 100 Places to Work
* Public Notices
* Podcasts
* ePaper
* Obituaries
* Content Removal Review
43°F
43°35°
More from Homepage
THE DALLAS COWBOYS’ BIGGEST PROBLEM IS AN UNFIXABLE JERRY JONES ONE
DALLAS ZOO’S START TO 2023 INCLUDES AN UNUSUAL DEATH, A MISSING ANIMAL AND TORN
ENCLOSURES
IMPRESSIVE 15 RESTAURANTS AND CHEFS IN DALLAS-FORT WORTH NAMED JAMES BEARD
SEMIFINALISTS
TONY HAWK URGES GARLAND TO NAME SKATE PARK AFTER HOMETOWN SKATING LEGEND
CONJOINED TWINS SUCCESSFULLY SEPARATED AT COOK CHILDREN’S IN FORT WORTH
COWBOYS’ MICAH PARSONS NAMED FINALIST FOR AP DEFENSIVE PLAYER OF THE YEAR
LAS VEGAS SANDS CONTRIBUTES MILLIONS, HIRES DOZENS OF LOBBYISTS AHEAD OF
GAMBLING PUSH
A DOWNTOWN DALLAS 7-ELEVEN THAT AVERAGED ONE POLICE CALL A DAY HAS CLOSED
TWO ELDERLY SCAM VICTIMS IN DALLAS DEMAND CHASE RECOVER $55,000 IN STOLEN FUNDS
DALLAS JUDGE WHO OVERSEES DWI COURT BLAMES HER DRUNK DRIVING CASE ON CAR, COP
AND AILMENT
This is member-exclusive content
icon/ui/info filled
Opinion
TEXAS IS GIVING AWAY REVENUE AND TAKING NEW MEXICO’S WASTE
IN WEST TEXAS, THERE’S A TOLL-FREE SUPERHIGHWAY FOR “PRODUCED WATER.”
Enable Midstream operates 14,000 miles of natural gas, crude oil, condensate and
produced water gathering pipelines.(Enable Midstream)
Take a drive on U.S. Highway 285 southeast from Carlsbad, N.M., heading to Pecos
in West Texas and you’ll be driving atop a portion of the largest proven oil
reserves in the United States. Along the drive, much of the scenery will look
the same. Drilling rigs are numerous and tower high above thinly rooted desert
shrubs. Above-ground pipeline and power line easements follow the road on either
side. Look too long and drift from the lane and the sound of rumble strips will
draw your attention back to the road ahead. Trailer trucks, pickups and
construction vehicles, all branded with corporate logos, pass in both
directions. Ahead in the distance you will see a light gray haze on the horizon
that fades into bright blue skies and stratus clouds. Roll down the window and
you will smell diesel exhaust and an unmistakable whiff of sulfur. This is the
Delaware Basin.
You would hardly know the point where you crossed into Texas as no noticeable
demarcation exists. However, a well-trained eye might start to notice saltwater
disposal (SWD) facilities appearing on both sides of the road with increasing
regularity. Facility signs mark the entrances, advertising to passing
water-hauling trucks looking to unload their tankers. When you start seeing an
overabundance of SWD facilities, congested along the border like state-line
liquor stores, that is when you know you are on Texas soil.
A fundamental characteristic of oil production is the conterminous production of
water. The Delaware Basin generates the largest volume of oil in the nation.
Accordingly, it also produces the largest volume of “produced water.” Produced
water contains high concentrations of salt, heavy metals and other toxic
substances. Thus, careful disposition is required. SWDs are wells that are
drilled expressly for the purpose of reinjecting the produced water into the
ground as a means of disposal.
Why the disproportionality between Texas and New Mexico? The explanation is
simple: regulation. Permitting SWDs in Texas is easy and quick compared with in
New Mexico. This is one of the reasons why each day an estimated 1.8 million
barrels (75.6 million gallons) of New Mexico produced water is sent to any one
of the numerous SWDs across the Texas state line. The volume is growing daily.
It would be correct to assume that longer transportation distances equate to
higher costs for oil and gas operators. So why not dispose of produced water
nearer to the origination point? The answer lies in a curious rule passed by the
New Mexico Oil Conservation Division (OCD) in 2016.
The New Mexico OCD, the regulating body for SWDs in the state, enacted a rule
prohibiting new shallow SWDs in the majority of the New Mexico Delaware Basin.
The ruling outlawed new SWDs in the Delaware Mountain Group formation, which is
the primary subsurface disposal zone in the basin. The basis for the 2016 rule
was research showing that shallow produced water injection was interfering with
producing oil wells in proximal formations. The ruling was viewed by many as
draconian and the Delaware Mountain Group Restricted Area as arbitrary.
The Texas Railroad Commission, by contrast, has no prohibition on new shallow
SWDs, and the time required to obtain an injection permit is markedly faster.
That disparity created business opportunities for hungry companies with an
appetite for interstate produced water logistics. Deep disposal is not
restricted in New Mexico but formations with suitable geology are so deep this
option is typically viewed as risky and uneconomic.
And so, each day more produced water finds its way to Texas. An estimated 34% of
New Mexico Delaware Basin produced water is sent out of state for disposal. This
is the status quo in the Delaware Basin. Without this escape route, some New
Mexico Permian oil production would grind to a halt. Water moves freely across
the border, untaxed, loosely regulated and inconspicuously reported.
An increase in the magnitude and frequency of earthquakes, with causal links to
injection, has prompted action by regulators on both sides of the border.
Disposal curtailments on both shallow and deep injection have reduced allowable
daily injection rates. This disproportionately affects Texas operators who have
to compete for space already occupied by New Mexico produced water. This
compounds pressure challenges that Texas operators are facing when drilling
through shallow injection zones. Meanwhile, New Mexico operators reap the
benefits of lower pressured shallow reservoirs and comparably lower seismic risk
by shipping their waste to Texas.
hidden ad unit
{"unitName":"dfpPosition2","display":"mobile","keyValues":{"breakpoint":"desktop"}}
The state of New Mexico continues to receive tax revenue from continued
hydrocarbon development. This is made possible only by Texas and its
laissez-faire attitude regarding shallow disposal. In return, Texas asks for
nothing.
Texas water midstream companies profit from New Mexico water, and this brings
its own suite of benefits to the state. But that is not enough. Seismicity
linked to injection is increasing, and the recent 5.4 magnitude quake in the
Delaware Basin (the third largest recorded event in Texas) has already triggered
new curtailments and restrictions. Once again, Texas operators will feel the
pinch.
Solutions do exist. New Mexico could revisit the Delaware Mountain Group
Restricted Area and allow shallow injection in specified areas. That alone will
not change the situation. SWDs are drilled, pipeline built and businesses
established under the existing condition. Furthermore, the New Mexico permitting
process is onerous, and getting a permit approved quickly is difficult due to
resource constraints at the New Mexico Oil Conservation Division. There is no
quick fix.
hidden ad unit
{"unitName":"teads-article","display":"mobile","keyValues":{"breakpoint":"desktop"}}
Accordingly, Texas should impose an import tax on New Mexico produced water.
This is not uncommon in the industry. In Ohio, out-of-state produced water
disposal is taxed at a hefty 20 cents per barrel, much higher than the
5-cent-per-barrel duty for water originating in-state, according to an Ohio
Department of Natural Resources fact sheet.
In the Delaware Basin alone, imposing a 20-cent-per-barrel tax on interstate
water could generate more than $140 million annually in tax revenue for Texas.
Given that interstate water transport and disposal is occurring in other parts
of the state (most notably from Louisiana to East Texas in the Haynesville
Bossier play), actual tax revenue could be much higher.
In the Delaware Basin, a tax would undoubtedly drive operators to pressure New
Mexico into lifting the arbitrary Delaware Mountain Group Restricted Area and
allow for shallow injection in certain parts of the basin. It might also tip
economic scales and drive more operators to invest in pipeline projects or
increase adoption of recycled produced water.
hidden ad unit
{"unitName":"dfpPosition_1","display":"mobile","keyValues":{"breakpoint":"desktop"}}
If Texas had implemented this tax starting in 2017, the state would have
generated more than $400 million thus far. The volume of produced water sent to
Texas is growing daily. Horizontal production on both sides of the border will
continue for the foreseeable future. Seismic events are increasing in magnitude
and frequency.
What is clearly visible is the disconnect between state regulatory bodies. Texas
operators bear the consequences while New Mexico operators reap the reward. A
Texas state tax on out-of-state produced water seems reasonable in any case.
Patrick Patton is a product manager at B3 Insight with more than a decade of
experience in oil and gas. He wrote this for The Dallas Morning News.
hidden ad unit
{"unitName":"dfpPosition_2","display":"mobile","keyValues":{"breakpoint":"desktop"}}
We welcome your thoughts in a letter to the editor. See the guidelines and
submit your letter here.
Patrick Patton
Icona Post
Ryan Has Fans In Awe With Latest MovesIcona Post|
SponsoredSponsored
Undo
Daily Pulse
Lottery companies don't like this and that's why you should.Daily Pulse|
SponsoredSponsored
Undo
FreeSlot
Do you want to play free games? Click HereFreeSlot|
SponsoredSponsored
Undo
Finance Blog
This Is The Tip All Canadians Need To KnowFinance Blog|
SponsoredSponsored
Undo
Gundry MD Bio Complete 3 Supplement
Top Heart Surgeon: This Simple Trick Helps Empty Your Bowels Every MorningGundry
MD Bio Complete 3 Supplement|
SponsoredSponsored
Undo
Daily Pulse
Stop scanning your lottery ticket, do this insteadDaily Pulse|
SponsoredSponsored
Undo
Luxury Casino
Follow 2 Easy Steps to Win Big! 1) Spin Jurassic Park Slots Wheel! 2) Claim your
Winnings!Luxury Casino|
SponsoredSponsored
Undo
FreeManRealty
Her Amazing Discovery Is Helping PeopleFreeManRealty|
SponsoredSponsored
Undo
GI-Adv
Canadian seniors discover surprising benefitUnique life insurance coverage for
Canadian seniorsGI-Adv|
SponsoredSponsored
Learn More
Undo
Health Benefits
Urologist: Plenty of Men With An Enlarged Prostate Do Not Know About This Simple
SolutionHealth Benefits |
SponsoredSponsored
Undo
THE DALLAS COWBOYS’ BIGGEST PROBLEM IS AN UNFIXABLE JERRY JONES ONE
DALLAS ZOO’S START TO 2023 INCLUDES AN UNUSUAL DEATH, A MISSING ANIMAL AND TORN
ENCLOSURES
IMPRESSIVE 15 RESTAURANTS AND CHEFS IN DALLAS-FORT WORTH NAMED JAMES BEARD
SEMIFINALISTS
TONY HAWK URGES GARLAND TO NAME SKATE PARK AFTER HOMETOWN SKATING LEGEND
CONJOINED TWINS SUCCESSFULLY SEPARATED AT COOK CHILDREN’S IN FORT WORTH
MORE STORIES
A DOWNTOWN DALLAS 7-ELEVEN THAT AVERAGED ONE POLICE CALL A DAY HAS CLOSED
Member Exclusive
LAS VEGAS SANDS CONTRIBUTES MILLIONS, HIRES DOZENS OF LOBBYISTS AHEAD OF
GAMBLING PUSH
TWO ELDERLY SCAM VICTIMS IN DALLAS DEMAND CHASE RECOVER $55,000 IN STOLEN FUNDS
Member Exclusive
LOGISTICS COMPANY BRINGS SHIPPING HUB AND HUNDREDS OF JOBS TO MESQUITE
Member Exclusive
‘ECONOMY ON FIRE:’ TEXAS ADDS NATION-TOPPING 650,000 JOBS IN 2022
Member Exclusive
OPINION
Get smart opinions on the topics North Texans care about.
Enter email to subscribe
By signing up you agree to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy
REAL. LOCAL. JOURNALISM.
Stand with us in our mission to discover and uncover the story of North Texas
Become a Member >
THE LATEST
THE DALLAS COWBOYS’ BIGGEST PROBLEM IS AN UNFIXABLE JERRY JONES ONE
By Tim Cowlishaw
DALLAS ZOO’S START TO 2023 INCLUDES AN UNUSUAL DEATH, A MISSING ANIMAL AND TORN
ENCLOSURES
By Jamie Landers and Lana Ferguson
IMPRESSIVE 15 RESTAURANTS AND CHEFS IN DALLAS-FORT WORTH NAMED JAMES BEARD
SEMIFINALISTS
By Sarah Blaskovich
TONY HAWK URGES GARLAND TO NAME SKATE PARK AFTER HOMETOWN SKATING LEGEND
By Tommy Cummings
CONJOINED TWINS SUCCESSFULLY SEPARATED AT COOK CHILDREN’S IN FORT WORTH
By Marin Wolf
MOST POPULAR ON DALLASNEWS.COM
1
THE DALLAS COWBOYS’ BIGGEST PROBLEM IS AN UNFIXABLE JERRY JONES ONE
2
DALLAS SOUFFLÉ SHOP RISE WILL OPEN IN PLANO
3
DALLAS JUDGE WHO OVERSEES DWI COURT BLAMES HER DRUNK DRIVING CASE ON CAR, COP
AND AILMENT
4
TWO ELDERLY SCAM VICTIMS IN DALLAS DEMAND CHASE RECOVER $55,000 IN STOLEN FUNDS
5
A DOWNTOWN DALLAS 7-ELEVEN THAT AVERAGED ONE POLICE CALL A DAY HAS CLOSED
6
A POSSIBLE DAN QUINN DEPARTURE IS FIRST DOMINO IN SHAKE-UP OF COWBOYS’ DEFENSE
TDMNTexas' Leading News SourceEst. October 1, 1885
Subscribe
Company
* About The Dallas Morning News
* Contact us
* Careers
* FAQ
Advertise With Us
* Autos
* Celebrations
* Classifieds
* Jobs
* Obituaries
* Public Notices
Buy
* Purchase Today's Paper
* Photo reprints
* Archived articles
* Back copies
* Commercial reprints
* Licensing
Customer Support
* Help and feedback
* Manage your account
* Newspaper subscription
* ePaper
* ePaper (Al Día)
* Daily audio briefing
* Vacation hold/billing
* Newsletters
Website Support
* Terms of service
* Privacy policy
* Do Not Sell My Personal Information
* Content Removal Review
* Site Map
Copyright © 2023 The Dallas Morning News. All rights reserved.
hidden ad unit
{"unitName":"adhesion","display":"mobile","keyValues":{"breakpoint":"desktop"}}
search by queryly Advanced Search
Powered by the Parse.ly Publisher Platform (P3).
More stories to check out before you go
Keep on reading
Cowboys legend, Fox NFL analyst Troy Aikman says he’s at ‘an impasse’ with
networkIn January, Troy Aikman called his 20th consecutive NFC Championship game
with Fox Sports. The former Dallas Cowboys quarterback, Pro Football Hall of
Famer...Dallas Morning News
Group 3
Undo
Troy Aikman says ‘toughest call’ was telling Erin Andrews he was leaving Fox for
ESPNESPN made it official Monday when it introduced Troy Aikman and Joe Buck as
their new Monday Night Football announcing team in a conference call
with...Dallas Morning News
Group 3
Undo
One of Dallas’ best barbecue joints, Terry Black’s, to expand to Fort Worth‘We
want to go where barbecue is popular,’ says one of the co-owners.Dallas Morning
News
Group 3
Undo
Jerry Jones explains why Cowboys didn’t pursue Ndamukong SuhIt’s no secret that
the Cowboys’ run defense could stand to improve. However, when 12-year NFL
veteran Ndamukong Suh was on the free-agent market, Cowboys...Dallas Morning
News
Group 3
Undo
' ' '
' ' '
Former Dallas Cowboys running back Marion Barber found dead in Frisco
apartmentMarion Barber III, a punishing staple in the Dallas Cowboys backfield
for six seasons, was found dead Wednesday at his Frisco home. Frisco police
said...Dallas Morning News
Undo
Former Dallas Cowboys RB Marion Barber died of heat stroke, according to medical
examinerFormer Dallas Cowboys running back Marion Barber III died of an
accidental heat stroke, according to a report by the Collin County Medical
Examiner’s office....Dallas Morning News
Undo
Woman sues Dallas Cowboys owner Jerry Jones, says he is her father, court
documents sayA 25-year-old congressional aide who grew up in North Texas has
sued Dallas Cowboys owner Jerry Jones, alleging he is her biological father.
Attorneys for...Dallas Morning News
Undo
What we know about megachurch pastor Matt Chandler of The Village ChurchNorth
Texas megachurch pastor Matt Chandler announced Sunday he will step down from
preaching and teaching because of an in appropriate online relationship...Dallas
Morning News
Undo
Icona Post
Ryan Has Fans In Awe With Latest MovesIcona Post|
SponsoredSponsored
Undo
Daily Pulse
Lottery companies don't like this and that's why you should.Daily Pulse|
SponsoredSponsored
Undo
Cowboys’ Jerry Jones says Deion Sanders is ‘very capable’ of being a head coach
in the NFLDallas Morning News
Undo
Denton Ryan five-star linebacker Anthony Hill decommits from Texas A&MDallas
Morning News
Undo
FreeSlot
Do you want to play free games? Click HereFreeSlot|
SponsoredSponsored
Undo
Finance Blog
This Is The Tip All Canadians Need To KnowFinance Blog|
SponsoredSponsored
Undo
Pastor of D-FW megachurch steps aside, citing inappropriate online relationship
with womanProminent Southern Baptist pastor steps down from preaching after
inappropriate online relationshipDallas Morning News
Undo
Former Cowboys TE Gavin Escobar dies in rock climbing accidentFormer Cowboys
tight end Gavin Escobar was one of two rock climbers found dead on Wednesday
near Idyllwild, Calif., according to the Riverside (Calif.) County...Dallas
Morning News
Undo