www.nationalreview.com Open in urlscan Pro
2a04:fa87:fffd::c000:42b8  Public Scan

Form analysis
3 forms found in the DOM

GET /search/

<form action="/search/" method="GET" id="site-header-search">
  <div class="site-header__search-input"><label aria-hidden="true" class="screen-reader-text" for="searchInput">Search Text</label><input placeholder="SEARCH" type="text" id="searchInput" name="s" class="site-header__search-form"><button
      class="site-header__search-submit" type="submit" name="search-submit">GO</button></div>
</form>

<form><input placeholder="Enter your email" type="email"><button type="submit" class="button" style="background-color: rgb(233, 33, 49); color: rgb(255, 255, 255);"><span class="button-text">Subscribe</span></button></form>

<form class="form-newsletter">
  <div class="site-footer__newsletter-tools">
    <div class="site-footer__newsletter-select"><input id="morning-jolt-footer" type="checkbox" value="morning-jolt"><label for="morning-jolt-footer" class="newsletter-label">Morning Jolt (M-F)</label></div>
    <div class="site-footer__newsletter-select"><input type="checkbox" id="nr-footer"><label for="nr-footer" class="newsletter-label">NR Daily (M-Sa)</label></div>
    <div class="site-footer__newsletter-select"><input type="checkbox" id="breaking-news-footer"><label for="breaking-news-footer" class="newsletter-label">Breaking News (M-Su)</label></div>
  </div>
  <div class="site-footer__newsletter-signup"><input class="newsletter-input" id="footer-signup" name="email" placeholder="Email" required="" type="email"><label for="footer-signup" class="footer-label">Email</label><input type="submit"
      name="footer-button" class="footer-signup-button" value="Submit"></div>
</form>

Text Content

Primary Menu

National Review

Representative Maxine Waters Calls for Political Violence
 * Donate
 * Corner
 * Magazine
 * Login
 * Subscribe

Search National Review
Search TextGO


ARTICLE BROWSER

Is Xi Jinping Dumb?

How Sam Bankman-Fried Conquered Washington

What Is the World Cup’s Purpose?

At Disney, Woke Strikes Back

What You Need to Know about the Colossal Mess of FTX

Nov. 29, 2022
 * Subscribe
 * Login


The Morning JoltPolitics & Policy


REPRESENTATIVE MAXINE WATERS CALLS FOR POLITICAL VIOLENCE

Waters walks in a Fourth of July parade in Los Angeles in 2013. (Reuters photo:
Jonathan Alcorn)
Share
 * 
 * 
 * 
 * 
 * 
 * 
 * 
 * 32

By Jim Geraghty
 * About Jim Geraghty
 * Follow Jim Geraghty on Twitter

June 25, 2018 9:10 AM
Listen to article


ALL OUR OPINION IN YOUR INBOX

NR Daily is delivered right to you every afternoon. No charge.

Subscribe

Making the click-through worthwhile: Maxine Waters advocates mob politics;
examining Gavin Newsom’s particular brand California progressivism; and a look
at Derek Hunter’s new book.




TOP STORIES

DISNEY FILM FEATURING GAY MAIN CHARACTER BOMBS AT BOX OFFICE

Ari Blaff

TWO CHEERS FOR ELON MUSK’S TWITTER

Michael Brendan Dougherty
NRPLUS

NEW YORK’S SURPRISE WINS DELIVERED THE HOUSE

John Fund
NRPLUS

Does She Know Where This Leads?

Democratic congresswoman Maxine Waters, calling for attacks on the Trump
administration at a rally in Los Angeles Saturday: “If you see anybody from that
Cabinet in a restaurant, in a department store, at a gasoline station, you get
out and you create a crowd and you push back on them, and you tell them they’re
not welcome anymore, anywhere.”

How exactly does Maxine Waters think this is going to shake out?

Does she think this tactic will be used only by leftist protesters, only against
Trump cabinet officials, and that in no circumstance will “pushing back at them”
lead to violence against those targeted individuals? Does she think that there
is no possible scenario where the security details assigned to protect cabinet
officials from harm respond to threatening behavior with force? Does she think
that there’s a scenario where the cabinet officials, the president, and his
supporters in general decide that because so many leftists are angry, they had
better change their minds and their policies?



Does she envision a near-future where Trump and the Right in general avoid
policy proposals that offend or anger Leftists, out of a fear of being targeted
for “pushback” that will make them unwelcome anywhere?

The only counter-evidence for these scenarios is the entirety of human existence
and the complete history of angry mobs. Angry mobs are not discerning or
careful. They do not distinguish between their initial target and anyone who
happens to be in the wrong place at the wrong time. Charles Murray described how
an angry mob at Middlebury College attacked political-science professor Allison
Stanger as she attempted to walk him to his car after a disrupted speech event:

> I didn’t see it happen, but someone grabbed Allison’s hair just as someone
> else shoved her from another direction, damaging muscles, tendons, and fascia
> in her neck. I was stumbling because of the shoving. If it hadn’t been for
> Allison and Bill keeping hold of me and the security guards pulling people off
> me, I would have been pushed to the ground. That much is sure. What would have
> happened after that I don’t know, but I do recall thinking that being on the
> ground was a really bad idea, and I should try really hard to avoid that.
> Unlike Allison, I wasn’t actually hurt at all.

Stanger disagrees with Murray politically — but the mob didn’t care; she was
next to him and for that she got a concussion.

Angry mobs are not good for deterring a particular unwanted behavior. They are
good for instilling fear and giving a lot of people an excuse to let out all of
their antisocial or violent impulses with a thin patina of moral righteousness.
“I’m not harassing and assaulting another human being, I’m standing up for human
rights!” No doubt the man who tried to kill as many GOP congressmen as he could
at the baseball field in Alexandria, Va., believed he was standing up for good
causes and doing the right thing.



Harassment of public figures on the right is only going to lead to harassment of
public figures on the left. No doubt everyone remembers their own favorite
example of a breach of decorum and proper behavior: the guy in the Miami
cheesecake factory, Joe Wilson shouting out “you lie!” at an Obama address to
Congress, the man who dumped a beer on a lawmaker in a bar, the guy who
harangued Ivanka Trump on a flight. The fake blood thrown at the private home of
an NRA lobbyist. The guy who threw water at Tomi Lahren in a restaurant in New
York. The audience disruptions at Julius Ceasar and Robert De Niro’s A Bronx
Tale.

Some no doubt would argue that the president himself threw gasoline on this
fire. At a rally in Cedar Rapids, Iowa, in February 2016, Trump said, “If you
see somebody getting ready to throw a tomato, knock the crap out of them, would
you? Seriously, okay. Just knock the hell — I promise you I will pay for the
legal fees, I promise.” And then in Saint Louis a month later, Trump lamented
that no one sufficiently hurts protesters at his speeches: “Nobody wants to hurt
each other anymore, right? And they’re being politically correct the way they
take them out, so it takes a little bit longer. And honestly, protesters, they
realize it. They realize that there are no consequences to protesting anymore.”



This is a genie that does not go back into the bottle easily. A lot of people in
politics remember the examples of their side being attacked and conclude this is
how the entirety of the opposition wants to play the game. The rallying cry on
the Right on Twitter these days is “you’re going to hate the new rules” —
basically conservatives cheerfully announcing they or their brethren will adopt
any tactic used by the Left. Turnabout is fair play; what’s good for the goose
is good for the gander. (Lord knows I’ve long lamented the glaring double
standard and the need for one bipartisan set of rules for public debate.)

The problem is that this cycle of tit-for-tat leads more and more people
conclude that the opposition only understands the language of force and that
they cannot be negotiated with, persuaded, or even tolerated in a form of
coexistence.

We could steer away from this path, if there was a broad, across-the-spectrum
denunciation of comments like the one from Waters, reemphasizing that in the
United States, we settle our differences through debate and discourse and the
ballot box and in the courtroom — not by stirring up an angry crowd and implying
(or maybe more than implying) a threat of physical violence against the
political opposition. But that’s too much to ask in this polarized — Balkanized?
— environment, isn’t it?



A Look into California’s Likely Future

Comedian Dennis Miller used to joke that Ted Kennedy was “the distilled essence
of liberalism — emphasis on distilled.” Gavin Newsom — the former San Francisco
mayor, current lieutenant governor of California, and likely the next governor —
could be similarly characterized as the distilled essence of his state’s unique
brand of liberalism — except that could be interpreted as an unfair shot at
Newsom’s 2007 statement about a “problem with alcohol.”

While I was on vacation last week, NR ran the profile I wrote about Newsom. A
few details that got trimmed out:

 * The connections between powerful California political families are
   fascinating. (Gavin Newsom’s aunt, Barbara, was married for almost two
   decades to Ron Pelosi, the brother-in-law of House Minority Leader Nancy
   Pelosi.)
 * As the Sacramento Bee summarized, “Newsom opened [his] wine shop in 1992 with
   the financial backing of family friend and oil fortune heir Gordon Getty.
   Newsom’s father, a classmate and close adviser of Getty, urged another
   prominent friend, John Burton, to recommend then-Mayor Willie Brown to
   appoint him to a vacant seat on the Board of Supervisors.” It’s not often you
   read sentences like, ‘[Gordon and Ann Getty] paid about $233,000 toward his
   first wedding reception.”
 * Newsom is now married to Jennifer Siebel, a feminist documentary filmmaker
   whose works include Miss Representation and The Mask You Live In. On October
   6, after the revelations about Hollywood mogul Harvey Weinstein, Seibel
   wrote, “Based on my years in the industry and unfortunately, my own personal
   experience with Harvey Weinstein, I can tell you that I believe every single
   word that was written.”
 * Siebel did not specify when Weinstein’s “aggressive advances” toward her
   occurred. But she said that the world needed more powerful men like “my very
   own husband Gavin Newsom who understand their place of privilege in the
   public eye and use it to defend and protect those who need defending.”
   Unfortunately, Weinstein had donated $5,000 to Newsom’s gubernatorial
   campaign in 2009. On October 13, Newsom donated an equivalent amount to a
   nonprofit organization — an awkward announcement that he was effectively
   returning a donation from a creep who had harassed his own wife.
 * There’s little reason to think that as governor, Gavin Newsom would deviate
   much from the current Democratic status quo. He pledges “guaranteed health
   care for all,” which would probably require at least another $100 billion in
   taxes, to “alert immigrants of ICE activity,” to put the state on the path to
   “100 percent renewable energy,” which would require changing about 70 percent
   of the current suppliers, to eliminate all diesel pollution by 2030, and to
   create a state-level technology-research institution like the Defense
   Advanced Research Projects Agency. It’s all as ambitious as his pledge to end
   long-term homelessness in ten years.

Good luck, California.



The Flaws of Modern Journalism Do Not Make the Mission Any Less Important

An important conclusion from Derek Hunter’s newly-released Outrage, Inc: How the
Liberal Mob Ruined Science, Journalism, and Hollywood:

> For all the problems I have with modern journalism, journalism itself is
> incredibly important. Or at least it should be. And you won’t find many people
> who love movies more than I do or are a bigger supporter of the pursuit of
> truth.
> 
> That last part, the pursuit of truth, permeates everything else. Without it,
> nothing has meaning, nothing matters. If the truth is Play-Doh, it can be
> molded and bastardized to fit whatever the holder of it wants it to. . . .
> 
> The United States, or any other free people, needs access to accurate,
> truthful information. Without it we’re serfs making decisions based on lies
> told by those in power. When you make decisions based on lies, you are under
> the control of those feeding you the lies. . . .
> 
> The American people have never been more misinformed by the media, but they’ve
> also never had more access to more information. The house of cards that is the
> mainstream media will either fall or be forced to change completely. Until
> that happens, it’s up to you not only be informed but to inform others.

ADDENDA: If you haven’t already, check out NRPLUS, National Review’s new
membership undertaking offering lots of benefits — including a Facebook group
where editors and writers (including yours truly) pop in regularly and chat with
readers. Get complete information here.

The best news of the morning: While she’s still got a difficult road ahead, GOP
congressional candidate Katie Arrington is expected to make a full recovery from
a serious car accident that occurred Friday night. She is expected to continue
her campaign and could be walking around in a few days. God bless her.

Next JoltThe New Democratic Party
Back to The Morning Jolt

Jim Geraghty is the senior political correspondent of National Review.
@jimgeraghty
32Comments



RECOMMENDED


JOE BIDEN IS THE PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES, HE IS NOT AN INNOCENT BYSTANDER

Apparently, Biden’s world is one in which he and his party are paragons of
virtue, moderation, and calm, and everyone who disagrees with him is an
extremist.

Charles C. W. Cooke


A ‘PANDEMIC AMNESTY’? HELL, NO

‘Forget everything, learn nothing’ is a bad way to ensure accountability for our
institutions.

Michael Brendan Dougherty


IS ABRAMS DRAGGING DOWN WARNOCK IN GEORGIA?

Democrats were warned about Stacey Abrams’s flaws as a candidate; they just
didn’t want to listen.

Jim Geraghty


MUSK DISBANDS TWITTER BOARD, APPOINTS HIMSELF ‘SOLE DIRECTOR’

Immediately after completing his $44 billion acquisition of Twitter, Musk fired
several senior executives, including CEO Parag Agrawal.

Ari Blaff


JUSTICE THOMAS UNLOADS ON LAWYER DEFENDING AFFIRMATIVE ACTION: ‘DIVERSITY SEEMS
TO MEAN EVERYTHING FOR EVERYONE’

‘I’ve heard similar arguments in favor of segregation, too,’ said Justice
Thomas.

Brittany Bernstein


NBC RETRACTS REPORT THAT EXPOSED NEW DETAILS IN PELOSI-ATTACK INVESTIGATION

When police arrived, Pelosi ‘began walking several feet back towards the
assailant and away from police,’ NBC reported in the since-deleted segment.

Ari Blaff


THE LATEST


SENATE VOTES TO ADVANCE SAME-SEX MARRIAGE BILL

The revised legislation includes an amendment ensuring that nonprofit religious
organizations won’t be forced to facilitate same-sex marriage.

Brittany Bernstein


IRAN THREATENED FAMILIES OF NATIONAL SOCCER TEAM WITH ‘VIOLENCE AND TORTURE’:
REPORT

The captain of Iran’s national men’s soccer team spoke in support of the
anti-government protests last week. 

Brittany Bernstein


PELOSI: HOUSE WILL CONSIDER INTERVENING TO AVERT RAIL STRIKE

The window for the unions and major rail freight carriers to reach a deal before
the December 9 strike deadline is shrinking.

Brittany Bernstein


IRAN BREAKS SILENCE ON PROTESTS, ACKNOWLEDGES OVER 300 HAVE BEEN KILLED

The statement marks the first time an official casualty toll has been
publicized, but activist groups say the true number is more than 450.

Ari Blaff


WHY THE CHINESE PROTESTS CAME AS A SURPRISE

China’s zero-Covid policy has been an obvious disaster, but the timing of
uprisings in authoritarian societies can be impossible to predict.

Dominic Pino


THE PRESS DRAGS TRUMP’S EXPECTED 2024 RIVALS INTO THE CONVERSATION ABOUT HIS
VILE ANTISEMITE DINNER

The media is urging Pence and DeSantis to give Trump exactly what he wants after
the Mar-a-Lago dinner.

Isaac Schorr, Brittany Bernstein




MOST POPULAR

DISNEY FILM FEATURING GAY MAIN CHARACTER BOMBS AT BOX OFFICE

Ari Blaff

TWO CHEERS FOR ELON MUSK’S TWITTER

Michael Brendan Dougherty

NEW YORK’S SURPRISE WINS DELIVERED THE HOUSE

John Fund
View More
Loading...
 * Facebook
 * Twitter
 * Login

© 2022 National Review

 * Donate
 * Subscribe

 * Sections
   * The Corner
   * Capital Matters
   * Bench Memos
   * The Morning Jolt
   * News
   * Books, Arts & Manners
   * All Articles
   * All Authors
   * Podcasts
   * Photos
   * Games
   * Videos

 * Topics
   * Politics & Policy
   * Culture
   * White House
   * Film & TV
   * Woke Culture
   * U.S.
   * World
   * Immigration
   * Economy & Business
   * Elections

 * Magazine
   * Latest Issue
   * Archive
   * Subscribe
   * Give NR as a Gift
   * Customer Care
   * NRPLUS

 * About
   * Frequently Asked Questions
   * About Us
   * The Masthead
   * Contact Us
   * Careers
   * Privacy Policy
   * Terms of Service
   * NR Institute

 * More
   * Advertise
   * Donate
   * Search
   * E-mails & Alerts
   * Send a Tip
   * A percentage of affiliate-program purchases made on this site (e.g.,
     Bookshop.org) go to support NR’s quality conservative journalism.

Newsletters

Morning Jolt (M-F)
NR Daily (M-Sa)
Breaking News (M-Su)
Email

© 2022 National Review





word word word word word word word word word word word word word word word word
word word word word word word word word word word word word word word word word
word word word word word word word word word word word word word word word word
word word word word word word word word word word word word word word word word
word word word word word word word word word word word word word word word word
word word word word word word word word word word word word word word word word
word word word word word word word word word word word word word word word word
word word word word word word word word word word word word word word word word
word word word word word word word word word word word word word word word word
word word word word word word word word word word word word word word word word
word word word word word word word word word word word word word word word word
word word word word word word word word word word word word word word word word
word word word word word word word word

mmMwWLliI0fiflO&1
mmMwWLliI0fiflO&1
mmMwWLliI0fiflO&1
mmMwWLliI0fiflO&1
mmMwWLliI0fiflO&1
mmMwWLliI0fiflO&1
mmMwWLliI0fiflO&1
We’d like to send you notifications of our latest news and opinion. Unsubscribe
anytime.


AllowCancel