www.news.com.au Open in urlscan Pro
104.116.108.143  Public Scan

URL: https://www.news.com.au/technology/online/social/mark-lathams-vulgar-tweets-about-mp-alex-greenwich-not-defamatory-court...
Submission: On May 26 via api from US — Scanned from AU

Form analysis 2 forms found in the DOM

<form id="weather-widget_enter-location" class="weather-widget_enter-location">
  <input type="text" id="weather-widget_location" placeholder="Enter your postcode" pattern="[0-9]{4}">
  <input type="submit" value="Ok" id="weather-widget_submit">
  <label class="weather-widget_error"></label>
</form>

<form class="navigation_search"><input class="navigation_search-input g_font-body-s" placeholder="Search" aria-label="Search" title="Search" type="text"><button class="navigation_search-btn" type="submit" name="Search" aria-label="Search">
    <div class="icon-sprite-item" style="width: 16px; height: 16px"><svg>
        <use xlink:href="#magnifier"></use>
      </svg></div>
  </button></form>

Text Content

Deals of the Week
5:53PM Sunday, May 26th, 2024
In the know quiz
Sydney
Today

10 °/ 21 °


SET YOUR LOCAL WEATHER


Sign Up

Log In
 * My account
   
 * Sign Out


 * National
   
   
    * BREAKING NEWS
   
   
    * POLITICS
   
   
    * CRIME
   
   
    * COURTS & LAW
   
   
    * NSW & ACT
      
      * Politics
      * Crime
      * Courts & Law
   
   
    * QUEENSLAND
      
      * Politics
      * Crime
      * Courts & Law
   
   
    * VICTORIA
      
      * Politics
      * Crime
      * Courts & Law
   
   
    * SOUTH AUSTRALIA
   
   
    * WESTERN AUSTRALIA
   
   
    * NORTHERN TERRITORY
   
   
    * TASMANIA
   
   
    * WEATHER

 * World
   
   
    * BREAKING NEWS
   
   
    * PACIFIC
   
   
    * ASIA
   
   
    * NORTH AMERICA
      
      * US Politics
   
   
    * SOUTH AMERICA
   
   
    * AFRICA
   
   
    * MIDDLE EAST
   
   
    * EUROPE
      
      * UK Politics

 * Lifestyle
   
   
    * HEALTH
      
      * Health Problems
      * Mental Health
      * Wellbeing
      * Diet
   
   
    * FITNESS
      
      * Inspiration
      * Weight Loss
      * Exercise
   
   
    * PARENTING
      
      * Pregnancy
      * Babies
      * Kids
      * Teens
      * School Life
   
   
    * FOOD
      
      * Eat
      * Drink
      * Restaurants & Bars
      * Food Warnings
   
   
    * RELATIONSHIPS
      
      * Dating
      * Sex
      * The Sealed Section
      * Marriage
      * Family & Friends
   
   
    * FASHION
      
      * Fashion Shows
      * Designers
      * Fashion Trends
      * Celebrity
   
   
    * BEAUTY
      
      * Face & Body
      * Cosmetic Surgery
   
   
    * HOME
      
      * Interiors
      * Outdoors
      * DIY
      * Pets
   
   
    * REAL LIFE
      
      * True Stories
      * Good News
      * News Life
   
   
    * LIFESTYLE VIDEOS
   
   
    * HOROSCOPES

 * Travel
   
   
    * TRAVEL IDEAS
      
      * Cruises
      * Luxury
      * Adventure
      * Short Breaks
      * Ski & Snow
      * Road Trips
      * Food & Drinks
   
   
    * DESTINATIONS
      
      * Pacific
      * Asia
      * North America
      * Europe
      * New Zealand
      * Africa
      * Middle East
      * Central America
      * South America
   
   
    * TRAVEL ADVICE
      
      * Tips & Tricks
      * Flights
      * Accommodation
      * Money
      * Airports
   
   
    * AUSTRALIAN HOLIDAYS
      
      * NSW & ACT
      * Northern Territory
      * Queensland
      * South Australia
      * Tasmania
      * Victoria
      * Western Australia
   
   
    * TRAVEL VIDEOS

 * Entertainment
   
   
    * CELEBRITY LIFE
      
      * Hook Ups & Break ups
      * Celebrity Photos
      * Celebrity Kids
      * Celebrity Deaths
      * Royals
   
   
    * CELEBRITY STYLE
      
      * Red Carpet
   
   
    * TV & RADIO
      
      * TV Shows
      * Reality TV
      * Streaming
      * Radio
      * Morning Shows
      * Current Affairs
      * Flashback
   
   
    * MOVIES
      
      * Upcoming Movies
      * New Movies
      * Movies Reviews
   
   
    * MUSIC
      
      * Music Festivals
      * Tours
   
   
    * BOOKS & MAGAZINES
      
      * Books
      * Magazines
   
   
    * AWARDS
      
      * Oscars
      * Golden Globes
      * Grammys
      * ARIAS
      * Logies
      * Emmys
   
   
    * ENTERTAINMENT VIDEOS

 * Technology
   
   
    * ONLINE
      
      * Social Media
      * Security
      * Internet
      * Hacking
   
   
    * GADGETS
      
      * Mobile Phones
      * Tablets
      * Cameras
      * Wearables
   
   
    * HOME ENTERTAINMENT
      
      * TV
      * Computers
      * Audio
   
   
    * GAMING
   
   
    * SCIENCE
      
      * Space
      * Archaeology
      * Human Body
      * Animals
   
   
    * ENVIRONMENT
      
      * Climate Change
      * Sustainability
      * Natural Wonders
   
   
    * INNOVATION
      
      * Inventions
      * Design
   
   
    * MOTORING
      
      * Motoring News
      * New Cars
      * Luxury
      * HiTech
      * Car Advice
      * On the Road
   
   
    * TECHNOLOGY VIDEOS

 * Finance
   
   
    * WORK
      
      * At Work
      * Careers
      * Leaders
   
   
    * BUSINESS
      
      * Breaking News
      * Technology
      * Banking
      * Travel
      * Retail
      * Manufacturing
      * Media
      * Other Industries
   
   
    * MONEY
      
      * Costs
      * Investing
      * Budgeting
      * Wealth
      * Tax
   
   
    * ECONOMY
      
      * Australian Economy
      * World Economy
      * Interest Rates
      * Federal Budget
   
   
    * REAL ESTATE
      
      * Selling
      * Buying
      * Renting
      * Sydney & NSW
      * Melbourne & VIC
      * Adelaide & SA
      * Perth & WA
   
   
    * MARKETS
      
      * Australian Markets
      * World Markets
      * Australian Dollar
   
   
    * SUPERANNUATION

 * Sport
   
   
    * AFL
   
   
    * NRL
   
   
    * CRICKET
      
      * Cricket Live Scores
   
   
    * TENNIS
   
   
    * MOTORSPORT
      
      * F1
      * V8 Supercars
      * Moto GP
   
   
    * SPORTS LIFE
      
      * Champions
      * History
   
   
    * AMERICAN SPORTS
      
      * NFL
   
   
    * OLYMPICS
   
   
    * FOOTBALL
      
      * A-League
      * EPL
   
   
    * BOXING
   
   
    * UFC
   
   
    * GOLF
   
   
    * BASKETBALL
      
      * NBA
   
   
    * RUGBY
      
      * Wallabies
   
   
    * HORSE RACING
      
      * Expert Opinion
      * Tips
      * NSW Racing
      * VIC Racing
      * SA Racing
      * QLD Racing
      * WA Racing
      * Punter's Life
   
   
    * CYCLING
   
   
    * MORE SPORTS
   
   
    * SPORT VIDEOS

 * Shopping
   
   
    * SALES & DEALS
   
   
    * TECH
   
   
    * FASHION & ACCESSORIES
   
   
    * BEAUTY
   
   
    * HOME & GARDEN
   
   
    * LIFE
   
   
    * HEALTH & WELLBEING
   
   
    * COUPONS & DEALS




 * Technology
 * Online
 * Social


MARK LATHAM ‘DEFENDED’ HIMSELF WITH HOMOPHOBIC TWEET ABOUT SYDNEY MP: COURT

Former NSW One Nation leader Mark Latham was responding to “an attack” from MP
Alex Greenwich when he sent a homophobic tweet, a court has been told.

Nathan Schmidt

@Nate_R_Schmidty

4 min read
May 23, 2024 - 5:18PM
NCA NewsWire

MP Alex Greenwich, left, is suing former NSW One Nation leader Mark Latham,
right.
More from Social Media

‘DYNAMIC STRAIN’: DIRE OUTLOOK FOR TELCOS

FAMOUS YOUTUBER FACES 25YRS IN JAIL

HOW MY LIFE HAS CHANGED AFTER QUITTING SOCIAL MEDIA

Former NSW One Nation leader Mark Latham was “defending” himself when he
published a “crass and vulgar” tweet targeting Sydney MP Alex Greenwich, a court
has heard.

The Sydney MP launched defamation proceedings against the controversial and
newly-independent Mr Latham in May last year following a graphic and homophobic
tweet.

In a statement of claim, Mr Greenwich alleged Mr Latham painted him as “not a
fit and proper person” to be in parliament because he “engages in disgusting
sexual activities”.

He further alleged Mr Latham portrayed him as “a disgusting human being who goes
to school to groom children to become homosexuals” in a subsequent media
interview.

Appearing before a second day of hearings at the Federal Court on Thursday, Mr
Latham’s barrister, Mr Kieran Smark SC, said the “primary tweet was a striking
publication”.


Alex Greenwich is suing over a graphic and homophobic tweet. Picture: NewsWire /
Christian Gilles

Mark Latham is expected to argue the tweet was his “honest opinion”. Picture:
NewsWire / Christian Gilles

Mr Smark told the court Mr Latham was responding to “an attack” by Mr Greenwich
in a media interview where he called him a “disgusting human being”.

“He (Mr Latham) is addressing how he can be called a ‘disgusting human being’
when … he’s saying he finds the conduct of LGBTQ+ people disgusting,” he said.

“Mr Latham had no basis to know what sort of sexual conduct Mr Greenwich himself
engaged in, or whether he engaged in sexual conduct at all.

“He was putting forward, by way of defence … the disgusting conduct that he
could see in all this was the fact that gay men engaged in the conduct
described.”



Mr Smark later added: “Although it’s a graphic response to vulgar response (by
Mr Latham), that doesn’t mean it’s a disproportionate response.

Mr Smark said a “reasonable person” would know Mr Latham’s was expressing his
own opinions, and that the imputation of his political ability was “tangential”.

He earlier described other tweets by Mr Latham about the same time as
“offensive, crass, and vulgar”, but stated that did not make them defamatory in
nature.

“What we say globally is that Mr Latham’s primary tweet may have wounded Mr
Greenwich, but it did not wound his reputation,” Mr Smark told the court.

He later added: “We can see a kind of almost universal – or not quite universal
– revulsion at the primary tweet, but that does not directly mark it is
defamatory”.

Mr Greenwich’s barrister Matt Collins KC said Mr Latham’s statements were
“pregnant with innuendo”.

“It is plainly not a tweet about homosexual sex. It’s a tweet about a particular
and unhygienic sex act,” Dr Collins said at the start of his closing address on
Thursday.

“To suggest that it is to be equated to being homosexual is something we would
not expect to hear in one of His Majesty’s courts in the third decade of the
21st century.

“People understood Mr Latham to be saying exactly what he said in the tweet:
that Mr Greenwich he engages in the particular disgusting and hygienic sexual
act.”

Mr Smark said the defamation action would have to prove the imputations, that
they were defamatory, and that there was serious harm or the likelihood of it.


Alex Greenwich with barrister Dr Matt Collins KC, left. Picture: NewsWire /
Christian Gilles

He told the court acceptance of LGBTQ+ people in Australia had been
revolutionary “due in part to work of people like the applicant”, referring to
Mr Greenwich.

He described vitriolic messages directed at the MP after the tweet as being from
people who were “vile filth”, and “drawing from a wellspring of prejudice”.

Nonetheless, he said their actions did not reflect a “change in their internal
perception of the reputation” of Mr Greenwich because of Mr Latham’s tweet.

“It’s not a trivial thing that happened and we’re not saying it was trivial in
its impact on Mr. Greenwich,” Mr Smark told Justice David O’Callaghan on
Thursday.

“The fact that people felt motivated to make homophobic attacks on the applicant
… it doesn’t follow that they’re expressing the standards of the general
community.”

Much of his opening address, which will continue on Thursday, spoke to the legal
thresholds for proving defamation, including understanding the meaning of the
tweet.


Mark Latham was invited to speak about religious freedoms at the church in
Belfield. Picture: Facebook

Instead, the riot squad was called after more than 500 people turned up to
protest outside. Picture: Facebook

Mr Latham described Mr Greenwich as “disgusting” and made crude comments about
anal sex in the so-called primary tweet, which was removed after just 2.5 hours
online.

Taking the stand on Wednesday, Mr Greenwich told the court he took legal action
because he “wanted the hate and abuse to stop” and that he had considered
leaving public life.

He described the imputation of the comments as being a “justification of the
attack” on him and said the tweet, as in his statement of claim, had “saddened
me and angered me”.

Under cross examination, he defended calling Mr Latham a “disgusting human
being” who was “extremely hateful and dangerous” in an interview days before the
tweet.


Mark Latham, centre, with barrister Mr Kieran Smark SC, left. Picture: NewsWire
/ Christian Gilles

He denied accusations he expected a response from the comment and reiterated
claims he had felt unsafe in public and at his office because of abuse following
the tweet.

The first day of hearings otherwise largely focused on the events leading up to
the tweet, namely a protest by LGBTQ+ activists of a speaking event by Mr Latham
at a Sydney church.

Dr Collins told the court Mr Latham had, in statements after the riot, accused
Mr Greenwich of instigating the protest, which he said the Sydney MP was not
involved in.

He said Mr Latham had “got the facts hopelessly wrong” and had condemned in
later statements co-called “transgender radical left wing activists” for
sparking the riot.

The hearing continues on Friday.

 * 
 * 
 * 

Read related topics:One NationPauline HansonSydney
SPONSORED

Beauty and the Beast musical wows Qld
SPONSORED

From runway to reality: Dior's lip star


Read next

Skip
Ads by





More related stories

Politics

‘DYNAMIC STRAIN’: DIRE OUTLOOK FOR TELCOS

As Telstra swings the axe on thousands of jobs, a major warning has been issued
that Aussie telcos are under “dynamic strain” amid sliding margins in the
sector.


Read more

Social Media

FAMOUS YOUTUBER FACES 25YRS IN JAIL

A famous YouTuber who specialises in legal issues is reportedly facing 25 years
in prison after being arrested on multiple charges.


Read more

Social Media

HOW MY LIFE HAS CHANGED AFTER QUITTING SOCIAL MEDIA

Zakkarie Montgomery-Cole has managed to wipe all of his social media accounts
and his life is completely different. Here he reveals why and what’s changed.


Read more


 * 
 * 
 * 
 * 
 * 
 * 

 * Sign Up
 * 
   Log In

 * SIGN UP
   
   * Registration
   * Connect
   * In The Know Quiz
   * Newsletters
   * Competitions

 * ABOUT US
   
   * Welcome to news.com.au
   * The Team
   * Our Values
   * Code of Conduct
   * Shopping
   * Coupons

 * HELP AND SUPPORT
   
   * Contact us
   * FAQ
   * General Feedback
   * Advertise with us
   * Standards of Practice
   * Site Map
   * Licensing & Reprints

 * OUR NEWS NETWORK
   
   * Kids News
   * The Daily Telegraph
   * Herald Sun
   * The Courier Mail

 * OUR PARTNERS
   
   * Kidspot
   * Body+Soul
   * realestate.com.au
   * FoxSports
   * CODE Sports

Our Apps

 * 
 * 

A NOTE ABOUT RELEVANT ADVERTISING: We collect information about the content
(including ads) you use across this site and use it to make both advertising and
content more relevant to you on our network and other sites. Find out more about
our policy and your choices, including how to opt-out.Sometimes our articles
will try to help you find the right product at the right price. We may receive
payment from third parties for publishing this content or when you make a
purchase through the links on our sites.
 * Privacy policy
 * Relevant ads opt-out
 * Cookie policy
 * Terms of use

Nationwide News Pty Ltd © 2024. All times AEST (GMT +10). Powered by
WordPress.com VIP