blog.hubspot.com Open in urlscan Pro
2606:4700:4400::6812:2194  Public Scan

Form analysis
3 forms found in the DOM

<form class="blog-nav-inline-site-search-form" data-nav-search-form="">
  <div class="blog-nav-inline-site-search-form-field">
    <label class="visually-hidden" for="blog-nav-inline-site-search"> Search... </label>
    <input id="blog-nav-inline-site-search" type="text" name="search-term" placeholder="Search...">
    <svg class="cl-icon" aria-hidden="true">
      <use href="#cl-icon-search"></use>
    </svg>
  </div>
</form>

<form class="blog-nav-site-search-form" data-nav-search-form="">
  <div class="blog-nav-site-search-form-field">
    <svg class="cl-icon cl-search -search" role="presentation">
      <use href="#cl-icon-search"></use>
    </svg>
    <label class="blog-search__form-input-label cl-input -light">
      <div class="blog-site-search-input-wrapper cl-input-wrapper">
        <input placeholder="Search..." name="search-term" type="search" aria-label="Search...">
      </div>
    </label>
  </div>
</form>

<form class="msf" data-theme="light" data-form-id="45afae4b-f2a7-4d63-b4bf-d8a4418bbcc1" data-response-type="redirect" data-redirect-url="https://offers.hubspot.com/thank-you/using-chatgpt-at-work?hubs_post-cta=on-page-redirect&amp;hubs_post=blog.hubspot.com/ai/decoding-copyright
" data-followup-email-id="" data-display-option="sticky" data-step="1" data-modal-id="">
</form>

Text Content

×close

We use cookies to improve HubSpot’s site. Some cookies are necessary for our
website and services to function properly. Other cookies are optional and help
personalize your experience, including advertising and analytics. You can
consent to all cookies, decline all optional cookies, or manage optional
cookies. Without a selection, our default cookie settings will apply. You can
change your preferences at any time. To learn more, check out our Cookie Policy.



Accept allDecline all
Manage cookies

Skip to content
 * English : Select a language
   * 日本語
   * Deutsch
   * English
   * Español
   * Português
   * Français
 * High Contrast

 * Log in
 * Start free or get a demo

Menu
Search...
Menu

 * BLOGS
   
   
   BLOGS
   
   Trusted by business builders worldwide, the HubSpot Blogs are your number-one
   source for education and inspiration.
   
    * MARKETING
      
      Resources and ideas to put modern marketers ahead of the curve
      
      
   
    * SALES
      
      Strategies to help you elevate your sales efforts
      
      
   
    * SERVICE
      
      Everything you need to deliver top-notch customer service
      
      
   
    * WEBSITE
      
      Tutorials and how-tos to help you build better websites
      
      
   
    * NEXT IN AI
      
      Your essential daily read on all things AI and business.
      
      
   
   See all blogs
    * Explore by topic
    * Instagram Marketing
      
      INSTAGRAM MARKETING
      
      
    * Customer Retention
      
      CUSTOMER RETENTION
      
      
    * Email Marketing
      
      EMAIL MARKETING
      
      
    * SEO
      
      SEO
      
      
    * Sales Prospecting
      
      SALES PROSPECTING
      
      

 * NEWSLETTERS
   
   
   NEWSLETTERS
   
   All of HubSpot's handcrafted email newsletters, tucked in one place.
   
    * THE HUSTLE
      
      Irreverent and insightful takes on business and tech, delivered to your
      inbox.
   
    * TRENDS
      
      Data-backed business trends, research insights, and industry analyses for
      business builders, delivered weekly.
      
      
   
    * MASTERS IN MARKETING
      
      Exclusive interviews with industry leaders, and curated resources, to help
      you become a better marketer.
      
      
   
    * THE PIPELINE
      
      Tips, tactics, and strategies from experienced sales reps to help you make
      President's Club.
      
      
   
   

 * VIDEOS
   
   
   VIDEOS
   
   Browse our collection of educational shows and videos on YouTube.
   
    * THE HUSTLE
      
      Our unrivaled storytelling, in video format. Subscribe for little
      revelations across business and tech
   
    * MARKETING WITH HUBSPOT
      
      Learn marketing strategies and skills straight from the HubSpot experts
   
    * MY FIRST MILLION
      
      When it comes to brainstorming business ideas, Sam and Shaan are legends
      of the game
   
    * MARKETING AGAINST THE GRAIN
      
      Watch two cerebral CMOs tackle strategy, tactics, and trends
   
    * HUBSPOT
      
      Everything you need to know about building your business on HubSpot
   
   See all videos

 * PODCASTS
   
   
   PODCASTS
   
   HubSpot Podcast Network is the destination for business professionals who
   seek the best education on how to grow a business.
   
    * MY FIRST MILLION
      
      Each week, hosts Sam Parr and Shaan Puri explore new business ideas based
      on trends and opportunities in the market
      
      
   
    * GOAL DIGGER
      
      Redefining what success means and how you can find more joy, ease, and
      peace in the pursuit of your goals
      
      
   
    * THE HUSTLE DAILY SHOW
      
      A daily dose of irreverent, offbeat, and informative takes on business and
      tech news
      
      
   
    * ANOTHER BITE
      
      Each week, Another Bite breaks down the latest and greatest pitches from
      Shark Tank
      
      
   
    * BUSINESS MADE SIMPLE
      
      Build your business for far and fast success
      
      
   
    * MARKETING AGAINST THE GRAIN
      
      HubSpot CMO Kipp Bodnar and Zapier CMO Kieran Flanagan share what's
      happening now in marketing and what's ahead
      
      
   
    * Online Marketing Made Easy
      
      ONLINE MARKETING MADE EASY
      
      
    * The Product Boss
      
      THE PRODUCT BOSS
      
      
    * Nudge
      
      NUDGE
      
      
    * Side Hustle Pro
      
      SIDE HUSTLE PRO
      
      
    * Outbound Squad
      
      OUTBOUND SQUAD
      
      
   
   See all podcasts

 * RESOURCES
   
   
   RESOURCES
   
   Expand your knowledge and take control of your career with our in-depth
   guides, lessons, and tools.
   
    * ACADEMY
      
      Learn and get certified in the latest business trends from leading experts
      
      
   
    * TEMPLATES
      
      Interactive documents and spreadsheets to customize for your business's
      needs
      
      
   
    * EBOOKS
      
      In-depth guides on dozens of topics pertaining to the marketing, sales,
      and customer service industries
      
      
   
    * KITS
      
      Multi-use content bundled into one download to inform and empower you and
      your team
      
      
   
    * TOOLS
      
      Customized assets for better branding, strategy, and insights
      
      
   
   
 * Search...

 * HUBSPOT PRODUCTS
   
   
   THE HUBSPOT CUSTOMER PLATFORM
   
   All of HubSpot's marketing, sales, customer service, CMS, operations, and
   commerce software on one platform. See pricing
   
    * FREE HUBSPOT CRM
      
      
   
    * OVERVIEW OF ALL PRODUCTS
      
      
   
    * MARKETING HUB
      
      Marketing automation software. Free and premium plans
      
      
   
    * SALES HUB
      
      Sales CRM software. Free and premium plans
      
      
   
    * SERVICE HUB
      
      Customer service software. Free and premium plans
      
      
   
    * CONTENT HUB
      
      Content marketing software. Free and premium plans
      
      
   
    * OPERATIONS HUB
      
      Operations software. Free and premium plans
      
      
   
    * COMMERCE HUB
      
      B2B commerce software. Free and premium plans
      
      
   
    * About HubSpot
    * Contact Us
    * Customer Support
   
   Start free or get a demo Contact Sales
   
    * ABOUT HUBSPOT
      
      
   
    * CONTACT US
      
      
   
    * CUSTOMER SUPPORT
      
      
   
    * LOG IN
      
      

 * Start free or get a demo

 * English : Select a language
   
    * 日本語
      
      
   
    * DEUTSCH
      
      
   
    * ENGLISH
      
      
   
    * ESPAÑOL
      
      
   
    * PORTUGUÊS
      
      
   
    * FRANÇAIS
      
      

 * High Contrast
 * Log in


 * Hubspot Blog
 * HubSpot.com

Loading

OH NO! WE COULDN'T FIND ANYTHING LIKE THAT.

Try another search, and we'll give it our best shot.

Load More Results



 * Home
 * Ai
 * Decoding Copyright: Who Owns Your AI-Generated Marketing Imagery?


DECODING COPYRIGHT: WHO OWNS YOUR AI-GENERATED MARKETING IMAGERY?

Download Now: 100 Free ChatGPT Prompts
Eleanor Hecks

Published: October 29, 2024

Who holds the rights to marketing imagery generated by artificial intelligence?
Can you sue people who reproduce your AI-generated marketing materials without
permission?



Surprisingly, courts have already made their stance on copyright protections for
non-human creations clear.


DOWNLOAD NOW: 100 CHATGPT PROMPTS FOR MARKETERS
[FREE GUIDE]


COPYRIGHT LAWS FOR AI CONTENT 

The United States Copyright Office is a government body that registers copyright
claims. In 2024, it released an AI initiative outlining how unauthorized digital
replicas — content that has been digitally created or manipulated to depict an
individual — must be quickly regulated.

The agency used its initiative to propose new federal laws regulating the
creation, reproduction and distribution of digital replicas. This move is
unsurprising, given it has previously denied or overturned copyright
applications for AI-generated images.

Marketers may be surprised to learn they cannot copyright materials created by a
generative model. This is because the U.S. Copyright Office does not recognize
AI-generated works as copyrightable — it only accepts human-created content.


WHO OWNS THE RIGHTS TO AN AI-GENERATED IMAGE?

The Copyright Act grants “the exclusive right” to “original works of authorship”
for a limited time to “authors,” meaning people can protect the imagery they
create.

While it does not explicitly define what an author is, the U.S. Copyright Office
has consistently said they must be human.

Some disagree but have had no luck changing the law.

For instance, a computer scientist named Stephen Thaler said his generative
system autonomously created artwork. The Copyright Office rejected his
application, stating works must have a human author to be copyrightable.

Thaler then asked the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit
to reverse the decision, arguing the word “author” in the Copyright Act can
represent a corporation or machine. The appeal likely won’t succeed since courts
have long agreed the authors must be human.

Years ago, a monkey took a camera from a British nature photographer and snapped
a selfie.

In 2014, courts denied copyright protections for the animal, stating that a
non-human creator cannot hold copyright under U.S. law. Instead, it ruled those
works become part of the public domain.

To recap, a marketer’s AI can’t copyright marketing materials because it isn’t
human. However, courts have consistently ruled they can’t hold the rights since
they weren’t the original creator. If they don’t own them, who does?

The answer is no one does — for now, at least.

Marketing materials generated by machines are non-copyrightable. The only people
who may have a claim to the rights are the creators who unknowingly supplied
their original works to train algorithms.


CAN OTHERS COPYRIGHT YOUR AI-GENERATED IMAGERY?

Since a generative model can’t create copyrightable works, any marketing
material you produce with one isn’t protected under copyright law.

Although your decision to use AI may not be evident, the lack of a disclaimer or
notice may entice people to use your content.

That said, most people will likely overlook your use of AI. Only 11% of people
believe they can always distinguish between a photo and an algorithm-generated
image. If they mistakenly believe your marketing material is protected, they
won’t attempt to use it.

Can you take legal action if someone reproduces or distributes your AI-generated
material as their own? Under current laws, you can’t file a lawsuit since you
don’t hold the rights to the work. The good news is that no one can copyright
that imagery.


HOW COPYRIGHT LAWS AFFECT MARKETERS USING AI

Marketers using generative models to create marketing materials should be
careful of the legal and ethical gray areas currently surrounding copyright law:

 * Reliability: According to one recent survey, 29% of respondents observed
   their employees lacked trust in AI. Are claims made by an algorithm less
   credible? Does non-copyrighted work seem less reliable?
 * Competition: What stops a company’s competitors from stealing its
   AI-generated marketing materials? What happens when a competitive coworker
   takes credit for an idea since replicating it is as easy as typing a prompt?
 * Infringement: AI tools may promote plagiarism, which can damage brand
   reputation and lead to legal issues relating to copyright infringement.
   Training datasets often contain works that were gathered without the owner’s
   permission.

While using generative technology isn’t inherently risky, it may expose
companies to copyright infringement. Also, it does not provide intellectual
property protections.


CONSIDERATIONS FOR USING AI TOOLS IN MARKETING

Marketing professionals still use generative technology despite copyright law's
uncertainty because it is effective. Around 85% of marketing professionals agree
that AI-generated content performs just as well — or even outperforms —
human-created alternatives.

Automation has also been a game-changer for many companies. It saves marketing
professionals 2.5 hours daily on average, freeing up over 30% of their work
week. This change isn’t surprising, given that content creation is incredibly
time-consuming.

No matter what industry marketing professionals are in, they can use a
generative model to produce imagery. This technology’s versatility is one of its
greatest strengths — it can accommodate almost every request.

While leveraging AI tools in marketing can save time and money, professionals
should carefully consider the potential risks. Even if they use a reputable
service provider, they may inadvertently be guilty of copyright infringement.

Such lawsuits have happened before. Getty Images — a stock photo provider —
recently sued Stability AI Inc. for allegedly misusing over 12 million
copyrighted photos to train its image generation system. There are also multiple
cases of artists suing AI companies.

No credible lawsuits have been directed at end users, so marketing professionals
shouldn’t worry too much. However, they should still be careful when selecting a
service provider to ensure they don’t face unintentional copyright infringement.


HOW TO USE GENERATIVE AI WITHOUT COPYRIGHT ISSUES

If you still want to use generative AI for marketing purposes, there are several
ways you can incorporate it into operations without significantly raising your
risk of legal issues:

 * Brainstorming: You can use generative AI in places other than content
   creation. Use it to take notes, analyze demographic data or get tips on how
   to use your other tools.
 * Fair use: Fair use allows you to use copyrighted works without the owner’s
   permission. Prevent infringement by making your commercial imagery
   transformative.
 * Derivative works: To be copyrightable, a derivative work must be based on
   work your company has already copyrighted. It must also meaningfully differ
   from the original.
 * Drafting: If you use AI to generate ideas but create the final product
   yourself, the work may be entitled to copyright protections.

While these methods don’t guarantee the U.S. Copyright Office will accept your
claim, they help.

More importantly, they reduce your risk of infringement, preserving your
company’s reputation.



Topics: Artificial Intelligence


DON'T FORGET TO SHARE THIS POST!




RELATED ARTICLES

prev next


 * WHICH LLM SHOULD YOU USE FOR YOUR BUSINESS? [PROS AND CONS]
   
   Nov 05, 2024


 * HOW AI CAN HELP PROTECT YOUR BUSINESS FROM PHISHING SCAMS
   
   Oct 29, 2024


 * 6 MYTHS WE GOT WRONG ABOUT AI (AND WHAT’S THE REALITY)
   
   Oct 22, 2024


 * NOTEBOOKLM GETS AN UPGRADE: AUDIO PROMPTS, BACKGROUND LISTENING, AND MORE
   
   Oct 22, 2024


 * SMART AI TRENDS I SEE ENTREPRENEURS LEVERAGING TODAY
   
   Oct 08, 2024


 * MONTHLY AI ROUNDUP: THE BIGGEST AI HEADLINES IN SEPTEMBER
   
   Oct 01, 2024


 * REAL OR AI-GENERATED: YOU GUESS [ROUND 2]
   
   Sep 26, 2024


 * HOW TO BOOST YOUR SEARCH RANKING, ACCORDING TO GREG ISENBERG
   
   Sep 24, 2024


 * 3 AI BUSINESS IDEAS FOR ENTREPRENEURS TO PURSUE IN 2024
   
   Sep 17, 2024


 * IS LOCALIZATION EASIER WITH LLMS OR DO LEGACY SYSTEMS STILL HAVE THE EDGE?
   EXPERTS WEIGH IN
   
   Sep 10, 2024

 * 
 * 
 * 
 * 
 * 
 * 
 * 
 * 


Pop up for DOWNLOAD NOW: 100 FREE CHATGPT PROMPTS FREE CHATGPT GUIDE


Discover the key to unlocking unparalleled productivity with this ultimate guide
to revolutionizing your workflow.

DOWNLOAD NOW DOWNLOAD NOW

Pop up for FREE MARKETING SOFTWARE FREE MARKETING SOFTWARE


Marketing software that helps you drive revenue, save time and resources, and
measure and optimize your investments — all on one easy-to-use platform

START FREE OR GET A DEMO
BACK


POPULAR FEATURES

 * All Products and Features
 * Free Meeting Scheduler App
 * Breeze AI Tools
 * Email Tracking Software
 * AI Content Writer
 * AI Website Generator
 * Email Marketing Software
 * Lead Management Software
 * AI Email Writer
 * Free Website Builder
 * Sales Email Templates
 * Free Online Form Builder
 * Free Chatbot Builder
 * Free Live Chat Software
 * Marketing Analytics
 * Free Landing Page Builder
 * Free Web Hosting


FREE TOOLS

 * See All Free Business Tools
 * AI Search Grader
 * Clip Creator
 * Website Grader
 * Make My Persona
 * Email Signature Generator
 * Brand Kit Generator
 * Blog Ideas Generator
 * Invoice Generator
 * Free Business Templates
 * Guide Creator
 * Software Comparisons Library
 * Template Marketplace
 * Campaign Assistant
 * Landing Page Creator


COMPANY

 * About Us
 * Careers
 * Management Team
 * Board of Directors
 * Investor Relations
 * Blog
 * Contact Us


CUSTOMERS

 * Customer Support
 * Join a Local User Group


PARTNERS

 * All Partner Programs
 * Solutions Partner Program
 * App Partner Program
 * HubSpot for Startups
 * Affiliate Program

 * Facebook
 * Instagram
 * Youtube
 * Twitter
 * Linkedin
 * Medium
 * Tiktok

Copyright © 2024 HubSpot, Inc.

 * Legal Stuff
 * Privacy Policy
 * Security
 * Website Accessibility
 * Manage Cookies