www.washingtonpost.com
Open in
urlscan Pro
23.73.245.87
Public Scan
URL:
https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2023/06/27/desantis-immigration-border-plan-trump-maga/
Submission: On June 27 via manual from US — Scanned from US
Submission: On June 27 via manual from US — Scanned from US
Form analysis 1 forms found in the DOM
<form class="mt-sm mb-md" autocomplete="off">
<div class="relative flex"><input class="pl-sm pr-sm font--subhead font-xxs h-md light brad-2 b form-input-valid bg-white gray-darkest flex-grow-1 w-50-ns ma-0 border-box" id="paywall__input-field" type="email" autocomplete="email"
data-private="true" value="" style="transition: padding 200ms linear 200ms; border-top-right-radius: 0px; border-bottom-right-radius: 0px;"><label for="paywall__input-field" class="absolute"
style="transition: all 200ms ease-in-out 0s; transform: translate3d(16px, -50%, 0px); transform-origin: left top; top: 50%; color: rgb(90, 90, 90); pointer-events: none;">Enter email address</label></div>
<div class="dn">
<div class="db mt-xs mb-xs ease-in-out duration-400 left mt-xs"><span class="db font-xxxs gray-darker pt-xxs pb-xxs gray-dark" style="padding-top: 1px;"><span data-testid="tosCheckboxText">By creating your account, you agree to The Washington
Post's <a target="_blank" style="color:inherit;" class="underline" href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/terms-of-service/2011/11/18/gIQAldiYiN_story.html">Terms of Service</a> and
<a target="_blank" style="color:inherit;" class="underline" href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/privacy-policy/2011/11/18/gIQASIiaiN_story.html">Privacy Policy</a>.</span></span></div>
</div><button id="CTA_BUTTON_TEXT_CTA_WRAPPER" role="button" class="btn db dib-ns mt-sm btn-disabled ma-0 pointer dib btn subs-theme bg-blue" type="submit" disabled=""
style="white-space: normal; box-sizing: border-box; border-radius: 31px; padding: 7px 32px; width: 270px; border: initial;"><span id="CTA_BUTTON_TEXT" data-public="true">Create free account</span></button>
</form>Text Content
Accessibility statementSkip to main content Democracy Dies in Darkness SubscribeSign in Close The Washington PostDemocracy Dies in Darkness OpinionsEditorials Columns Guest opinions Cartoons Submit a guest opinion Today's Opinions newsletter OpinionsEditorials Columns Guest opinions Cartoons Submit a guest opinion Today's Opinions newsletter OPINION DESANTIS’S LATEST APPEAL TO MAGA TOPS TRUMP IN PERFORMATIVE CRUELTY By Greg Sargent Columnist|AddFollow June 27, 2023 at 12:00 p.m. EDT Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis. (Brandon Bell/Getty Images) Listen 5 min Share this article Share Comment on this storyComment As president, Donald Trump separated migrant families, forced asylum seekers back into Mexico and built hundreds of miles of border barriers. The border remained chaotic and the migrants kept coming, yet MAGA ideology continues to hold that the “crisis” can be solved with just the right mix of cruel deterrence, tough enforcement and — of course — more walls. WpGet the full experience.Choose your planArrowRight That disconnect helps explain Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis’s radical new plan to secure the border, which he rolled out Monday. The plan is meant to propel him to Trump’s right on a leading MAGA issue. But DeSantis’s blueprint contains a bunch of warmed-over ideas — mass deportations, draconian efforts to limit asylum-seeking and legal immigration, even an end to birthright citizenship — that Trump already tried to execute, yet could not. The fundamental promise of DeSantis’s GOP presidential primary campaign is that he’d execute the MAGA agenda far more competently than Trump. But there’s a reason Trump largely failed in controlling the border, and it has little do with competence or “toughness.” Advertisement Story continues below advertisement Rather, it’s that presidents lack the authority to close down legal immigration in any substantial way, and however harsh their enforcement gets, it simply doesn’t dissuade migrants from coming, including illegally, and settling here successfully. Follow this authorGreg Sargent's opinions Follow “No excuses: Stop the invasion,” blares DeSantis’s immigration blueprint. Unveiling his plan in Texas, DeSantis accused Trump of failing to deliver, saying the unthinkable: “Obama’s first four years had more deportations than Trump’s term, which is incredible.” Catherine Rampell | Earth to politicians: The U.S. has too few immigrants — not too many It’s true that President Barack Obama, to his discredit, deported more migrants in his first term than Trump did. But that’s because of many underlying factors: Under Obama, arrests at the border had begun to plummet, leaving more resources for deportations from the interior. There were also far fewer sanctuary localities denying cooperation with federal law enforcement then than now. Advertisement Story continues below advertisement Putting aside how wretched it is to cast mass deportations as a positive — we should legalize undocumented people, not deport them — DeSantis probably wouldn’t be able to do much better than Trump. What’s at issue is how much Congress is willing to spend on removals. “It would require an immense escalation of resources, which the Congress has to date shown little interest in providing,” Doris Meissner, a senior fellow at the Migration Policy Institute, told me. Deportation levels have nothing to do with some mystical quality of presidential toughness. But DeSantis’s move does constitute a genuine statement of priorities. Whereas President Biden deprioritizes the removal of undocumented immigrants who don’t pose a serious threat — which the Supreme Court upheld last week — DeSantis would deport them en masse, no matter how deeply connected they are to communities here. Advertisement Story continues below advertisement DeSantis’s plan also vows to force untold numbers of asylum seekers to wait in Mexico for their hearings, just as Trump did. But Mexico flatly stated this year that it opposes restarting this policy. Would DeSantis follow Trump in threatening enormous tariffs against Mexico to force it to comply? DeSantis also promises to disregard legal limits on how long child migrants can be held in detention to facilitate detaining migrant families longer. Guess what? Trump tried that, too, but it was struck down in court as outside presidential authority. DeSantis would apparently mandate extended detention of all migrant families awaiting legal proceedings, but this would likely require Congress to fund a large expansion of our detention machinery. Good luck with that. The DeSantis plan would also end guaranteed citizenship for anyone born on U.S. soil. Trump proposed that as well, but it’s enshrined by the 14th Amendment. DeSantis insists this reading of the Constitution is wrong; the vast consensus among legal experts says otherwise. Advertisement Story continues below advertisement DeSantis also promises to end all of Biden’s parole programs, which admit at least 30,000 migrants per month who apply from abroad. That’s something DeSantis might be able to do as president, but no one should call it “securing the border.” In fact, widening legal channels for such migration arguably disincentivizes people from trying to enter via the border and straining infrastructure there. That helps process overall migration in a more orderly way. The rub is that DeSantis doesn’t want well-managed migration. He wants far less of it. Running the immigration system is profoundly challenging for any president regardless of his priorities. Biden has certainly struggled, and keeping arrivals at the border manageable has led to limitations on asylum-seeking that renege on our international commitments. Advertisement Story continues below advertisement But Biden understands that many complex factors throughout the Americas drive migration to the United States, and he sees letting more applicants in from abroad, while making border processing more humane wherever possible, as the way to manage it as a positive good for the country. By contrast, DeSantis would cut off those applicants entirely while rendering our immigration system more cruel, more inhumane and more destructive to our overall national interests. Even if DeSantis would struggle to implement his plan’s specifics, what’s appalling is the deliberate message it sends: He would seek to one-up Trump’s hyper-restrictionist agenda, despite all its abominations and the searing social conflict it unleashed. In short, DeSantis views Trump’s inability to implement his horrors at full scale as lamentable — as something that should be rectified, and even outdone. Comments Share More from Opinions HAND CURATED * Opinion|He has flown 23 million miles. Here are his travel secrets. June 23, 2023 Opinion|He has flown 23 million miles. Here are his travel secrets. June 23, 2023 * Opinion|We know what social media is doing to us. How do we reclaim our focus? June 22, 2023 Opinion|We know what social media is doing to us. How do we reclaim our focus? June 22, 2023 * Opinion|The Titan submersible met its end in a vast, dark world June 22, 2023 Opinion|The Titan submersible met its end in a vast, dark world June 22, 2023 View 3 more stories Loading... Subscribe to comment and get the full experience. Choose your plan → View more Advertisement TOP STORIES Technology Big Tech news and how to take control of your data and devices What’s your type? Try these tests to pick the perfect font for you. Meta’s new AI lets people make chatbots. They’re using it for sex. Review|Google Pixel Fold review: Competent, not captivating Refresh Try a different topic Sign in or create a free account to save your preferences Advertisement Advertisement Company * About The Post * Newsroom Policies & Standards * Diversity and Inclusion * Careers * Media & Community Relations * WP Creative Group * Accessibility Statement Get The Post * * Become a Subscriber * Gift Subscriptions * Mobile & Apps * Newsletters & Alerts * Washington Post Live * Reprints & Permissions * Post Store * Books & E-Books * Newspaper in Education * Print Archives (Subscribers Only) * Today’s Paper * Public Notices Contact Us * Contact the Newsroom * Contact Customer Care * Contact the Opinions team * Advertise * Licensing & Syndication * Request a Correction * Send a News Tip * Report a Vulnerability Terms of Use * Digital Products Terms of Sale * Print Products Terms of Sale * Terms of Service * Privacy Policy * Cookie Settings * Submissions & Discussion Policy * RSS Terms of Service * Ad Choices washingtonpost.com © 1996-2023 The Washington Post * washingtonpost.com * © 1996-2023 The Washington Post * About The Post * Contact the Newsroom * Contact Customer Care * Request a Correction * Send a News Tip * Report a Vulnerability * Download the Washington Post App * Policies & Standards * Terms of Service * Privacy Policy * Cookie Settings * Print Products Terms of Sale * Digital Products Terms of Sale * Submissions & Discussion Policy * RSS Terms of Service * Ad Choices 4.17.5 Already have an account? Sign in -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- FREE ACCESSENDS JUNE 29 READ ALL STORIES, ALL FOR FREE Create a free account to discover more of The Post, now through June 29. Enter email address By creating your account, you agree to The Washington Post's Terms of Service and Privacy Policy. Create free account No credit card. No obligation. Close