www.timesofisrael.com
Open in
urlscan Pro
2606:4700:4400::ac40:9b06
Public Scan
URL:
https://www.timesofisrael.com/what-does-israel-need-to-do-to-comply-with-the-icj-genocide-decision/
Submission: On December 04 via api from US — Scanned from ES
Submission: On December 04 via api from US — Scanned from ES
Form analysis
14 forms found in the DOMGET /search/
<form class="new-search-form" method="get" target="_self" action="/search/">
<button class="submit" type="submit" name="submit"><span>search</span></button>
<div class="new-wrap-input">
<label for="search-input"><span class="v-hidden">Input search</span></label>
<input type="text" autocomplete="off" name="q" placeholder="Search" id="search-input" value="" class="search-input">
<button type="button" class="clear-text" title="Clear search input"><span class="v-hidden">Clear search input</span></button>
</div>
</form>
<form>
<div class="ml-form-inner">
<input autocomplete="off" type="text" name="email" class="email-address" value="" placeholder="Your email">
<button type="submit" class="submit"><span>submit</span></button>
</div>
<div class="newsletter-error"></div>
</form>
GET /search/
<form class="search-form" method="get" action="/search/">
<div class="wrap-input">
<label for="search-input"><span class="v-hidden">Input search</span></label>
<input type="text" autocomplete="off" name="q" placeholder="Type here to search" id="search-input" value="" class="search-input">
<button type="button" class="clear-text"><span class="v-hidden">Clear search input</span></button>
</div>
<input type="submit" name="submit" class="submit" value="Search">
</form>
<form class="newsletter-article-form">
<label for="newsletter-email-address" class="screen-reader-text">Newsletter email address</label>
<input id="newsletter-email-address" type="text" name="email" class="newsletter-article-input email-address" value="" placeholder="Your email">
<button type="submit" class="submit newsletter-article-input"><span>Get it</span></button>
</form>
<form>
<label>
<span class="toi-crm-popup-label">Email address <span class="asterisk">*</span></span>
<input id="emailForCheck" name="user_email" type="email" autocomplete="off">
</label>
<div class="toi-crm-popup-form-message"><span class="toi-crm-popup-form-message-text">Please use the following structure: example@domain.com</span></div>
<button id="checkEmail-button" class="toi-crm-popup-form-submit" type="submit"><span class="toi-crm-popup-form-submit-text">Continue</span></button>
</form>
<form>
<label>
<span class="toi-crm-popup-label">Email address <span class="asterisk">*</span></span>
<input id="emailForMode0" disabled="" class="checked-email" name="user_email" type="email" autocomplete="off" value="">
<button type="button" class="change-email-button back-button">Change</button>
</label>
<div class="toi-crm-popup-captcha-wrapper">
<div id="grecaptcha-crm" class="toi-crm-popup-captcha"></div>
</div>
<!-- <div class="toi-crm-popup-form-message"><span class="toi-crm-popup-form-message-text">error text</span></div> -->
<button id="authMode0-button" class="toi-crm-popup-form-submit" type="submit"><span class="toi-crm-popup-form-submit-text">REGISTER</span></button>
</form>
<form>
<label>
<span class="toi-crm-popup-label">Email address <span class="asterisk">*</span></span>
<input id="emailForMode1" disabled="" class="checked-email" name="user_email" type="email" autocomplete="off" value="">
</label>
<div style="display: none;" id="messageMode1" class="tac toi-crm-popup-form-message"><span class="toi-crm-popup-form-message-text">Something went wrong. <br> Please try again in a few minutes..</span></div>
<button id="authMode1-button" class="toi-crm-popup-form-submit" type="button"><span class="toi-crm-popup-form-submit-text">Continue</span></button>
</form>
<form autocomplete="off">
<label>
<span class="toi-crm-popup-label">Email address <span class="asterisk hid">*</span></span>
<input id="emailForMode2" class="checked-email" disabled="" name="user_email" type="email" autocomplete="off" value="">
</label>
<label>
<span class="toi-crm-popup-label">Password <span class="asterisk">*</span></span>
<input id="passwordForMode2" name="user_password" type="password" value="">
</label>
<div style="display: none;" id="messageMode2" class="toi-crm-popup-form-message error-pass"><span id="messageMode2Text" class="toi-crm-popup-form-message-text">Incorrect password. Please try again or choose an option below.</span></div>
<button id="authMode2-button" class="toi-crm-popup-form-submit" type="submit"><span class="toi-crm-popup-form-submit-text">Continue</span></button>
<div class="toi-crm-popup-form-links">
<a class="toi-crm-popup-form-links-item owsSendForgotPasswordLink" href="#">I forgot my password</a>
<span class="toi-crm-popup-form-links-slash"> / </span>
<a class="toi-crm-popup-form-links-item owsSendMagicLink" href="#">Send me a sign in link</a>
</div>
</form>
<form>
<input type="email" name="email" class="email-address" value="" placeholder="Email address" autocorrect="off" autocapitalize="off" autocomplete="off">
<input name="subscribe" value="Subscribe" class="submit" type="submit">
</form>
<form>
<div class="text">subscribe to the daily edition</div>
<label for="email-address" class="v-hidden"><span>Enter your email address</span></label>
<input type="text" name="email" class="email-address" id="email-address" value="" placeholder="e-mail address" aria-describedby="newsletter-error">
<button type="submit" class="submit"><span>submit</span></button>
<div role="alert" class="newsletter-error" id="newsletter-error" aria-live="polite"></div>
</form>
<form>
<label>
<span class="toi-crm-popup-label">Email address</span>
<input id="emailForCheck-regwall" name="user_email" type="email" autocomplete="off">
</label>
<div class="toi-crm-popup-form-message"><span class="toi-crm-popup-form-message-text">Please use the following structure: example@domain.com</span></div>
<button id="checkEmail-button-regwall" class="toi-crm-popup-form-submit" type="submit"><span class="toi-crm-popup-form-submit-text">REGISTER OR SIGN IN</span></button>
</form>
<form>
<label>
<span class="toi-crm-popup-label">Email address</span>
<input id="emailForMode0-regwall" disabled="" class="checked-email" name="user_email" type="email" autocomplete="off" value="">
<button type="button" class="change-email-button back-button">Change</button>
</label>
<div class="toi-crm-popup-captcha-wrapper">
<div id="grecaptcha-crm-regwall" class="toi-crm-popup-captcha"></div>
</div>
<!-- <div class="toi-crm-popup-form-message"><span class="toi-crm-popup-form-message-text">error text</span></div> -->
<button id="authMode0-button-regwall" class="toi-crm-popup-form-submit" type="submit"><span class="toi-crm-popup-form-submit-text">REGISTER</span></button>
</form>
<form>
<label>
<span class="toi-crm-popup-label">Email address</span>
<input id="emailForMode1-regwall" disabled="" class="checked-email" name="user_email" type="email" autocomplete="off" value="">
</label>
<div style="display: none;" id="messageMode1-regwall" class="tac toi-crm-popup-form-message"><span class="toi-crm-popup-form-message-text">Something went wrong. <br> Please try again in a few minutes..</span></div>
<button id="authMode1-button-regwall" class="toi-crm-popup-form-submit" type="button"><span class="toi-crm-popup-form-submit-text">Continue</span></button>
</form>
<form autocomplete="off">
<label>
<span class="toi-crm-popup-label">Email address <span class="asterisk hid">*</span></span>
<input id="emailForMode2-regwall" class="checked-email" disabled="" name="user_email" type="email" autocomplete="off" value="">
</label>
<label>
<span class="toi-crm-popup-label">Password <span class="asterisk">*</span></span>
<input id="passwordForMode2-regwall" name="user_password" type="password" value="">
</label>
<div style="display: none;" id="messageMode2-regwall" class="toi-crm-popup-form-message error-pass"><span id="messageMode2Text-regwall" class="toi-crm-popup-form-message-text">Incorrect password. Please try again or choose an option below.</span>
</div>
<button id="authMode2-button-regwall" class="toi-crm-popup-form-submit" type="submit"><span class="toi-crm-popup-form-submit-text">Continue</span></button>
<div class="toi-crm-popup-form-links">
<a class="toi-crm-popup-form-links-item rgwllSendForgotPasswordLink" href="#">I forgot my password</a>
<span class="toi-crm-popup-form-links-slash"> / </span>
<a class="toi-crm-popup-form-links-item rgwllSendMagicLink" href="#">Send me a sign in link</a>
</div>
</form>
Text Content
SU PRIVACIDAD ES IMPORTANTE PARA NOSOTROS Nosotros y nuestros 1457 socios almacenamos y/o accedemos a información en un dispositivo, como cookies, y procesamos datos personales, como identificadores únicos e información estándar enviada por un dispositivo para publicidad y contenido personalizado, medición de publicidad y contenido, investigación de audiencia y desarrollo de servicios. Con su permiso, nosotros y nuestros socios podemos utilizar datos de localización geográfica precisa e identificación mediante las características de dispositivos. Puede hacer clic para otorgarnos su consentimiento a nosotros y a nuestros 1457 socios para que llevemos a cabo el procesamiento previamente descrito. De forma alternativa, puede acceder a información más detallada y cambiar sus preferencias antes de otorgar o negar su consentimiento. Tenga en cuenta que algún procesamiento de sus datos personales puede no requerir de su consentimiento, pero usted tiene el derecho de rechazar tal procesamiento. Sus preferencias se aplicarán solo a este sitio web. Puede cambiar sus preferencias o retirar su consentimiento en cualquier momento volviendo a este sitio y haciendo clic en el botón "Privacidad" en la parte inferior de la página web. Tenga también en cuenta que este sitio web/aplicación utiliza uno o más servicios de Google y podría recopilar y almacenar información, incluida, entre otras cosas, su visita o comportamiento de uso. Puede hacer clic para otorgar o denegar el consentimiento a Google y sus etiquetas de terceros para utilizar sus datos para los fines especificados a continuación en la sección de consentimiento de Google. MÁS OPCIONESAgree Skip to main content Toggle Menu Join our Community Support ToI and remove all ads Learn more * English * العربية * Français * فارسی * עברית * Get The Daily Edition * Account * Sign In ISRAEL AT WAR - DAY 425 Open Search form search Input search Clear search input * Israel & the Region * Jewish Times * Israel Inside * Tech Israel * Real Estate Israel * The Blogs * Podcasts * Video * Newsletters * The Daily Edition What Matters Most Today * Tech Israel Updates from Silicon Wadi * Real Estate Israel Weekly Update * The Weekend Edition The Best Reads of the Week * Weekly Highlights Choice Voices From The Blogs * Partners * Atlanta Atlanta Jewish Times * North New Jersey The Jewish Standard * Pittsburgh Jewish Chronicle * United Kingdom The Jewish News * Australia The Australian Jewish News * For Publishers Become a Partner * Community * Join our community * Sign in * * About The Times of Israel * Advertise on The Times of Israel * Contact us * Get the Daily Edition submit * Follow us Facebook Twitter * © 2024 The Times of Israel , All Rights Reserved Terms and conditions Privacy policy * Open Search form Input search Clear search input Advertisement Homepage Explainer WHAT DOES ISRAEL NEED TO DO TO COMPLY WITH THE ICJ GENOCIDE DECISION? PROVISIONAL MEASURES ORDERED BY THE COURT THAT ISRAEL ALLEVIATE THE HUMANITARIAN SITUATION IN GAZA AND PREVENT INCITEMENT TO GENOCIDE WILL BE KEY TO DEMONSTRATING COMPLIANCE By Jeremy Sharon Follow NEW! Get email alerts when this author publishes a new article You will receive email alerts from this author. Manage alert preferences on your profile page You will no longer receive email alerts from this author. Manage alert preferences on your profile page 1 February 2024, 1:23 pm * Facebook * Twitter * email * Print * 27 Jeremy Sharon is The Times of Israel’s legal affairs and settlements reporter * * * File: The International Court of Justice, the principal judicial organ of the UN, delivers its order South Africa's request for provisional measures against Israel over its actions in the Gaza Strip, January 26, 2024. (International Court of Justice) The International Court of Justice’s decision on Friday finding that it is at least plausible that Israel violated some of the terms of the Genocide Convention during its war against Hamas in Gaza was something of a mixed bag for Jerusalem. On the one hand, the very nature of that finding does severe reputational damage to Israel and further weakens its international standing. On the other, the provisional measures the court ordered were also relatively mild. The ICJ said very generally and vaguely that Israel must do everything in its power to “prevent” acts of genocide, but since it did not tell Israel to “desist” from such acts or even to halt its military campaign in Gaza, there is little Israel needs to do to demonstrate compliance with that particular order. The court did, however, issue several other measures that will require more active steps by Israel in order to comply with the ICJ’s orders. MEASURES TO BE ADOPTED In total, the court issued six specific “provisional measures” Israel needs to comply with. Get The Times of Israel's Daily Edition by email and never miss our top stories Newsletter email address Get it By signing up, you agree to the terms The first order instructs Israel to “take all measures within its power to prevent the commission” of genocidal acts, and the second states that Israel must “ensure with immediate effect” that the army isn’t carrying out genocidal acts. President of the International Court of Justice Judge Joan E. Donoghue delivers the court’s order on the request for the indication of provisional measures submitted by South Africa against Israel over its actions in the Gaza Strip, January 26, 2024. (Courtesy International Court of Justice) Since Israel already insists that it is not carrying out genocidal acts against the Palestinians in Gaza, and explained this position at length both in oral arguments in The Hague and in material submitted to the court, there is little it can practically do to show further compliance with these orders. Dr. Ziv Bohrer, a senior lecturer for international law at the Bar Ilan University Faculty of Law and a researcher at the Begin Sadat Center for Strategic Studies, said, however, that the IDF could reemphasize to soldiers and commanders that they must abide by the laws of armed conflict, and include details of these instructions in the report the ICJ ordered it to submit on the measures it has taken to comply with the provisional measures. Advertisement The fifth order instructs Israel “to prevent the destruction and ensure the preservation of evidence” pertaining to allegations of genocide, which will also not require much practically of Israel, and the sixth tells Israel to file a report to the court one month from the ruling detailing the measures it has taken. It is the third and fourth orders where Israel will need to demonstrate that it has taken real action to comply with the court. The third order instructs Israel to do everything it can to “prevent and punish the direct and public incitement to commit genocide,” while the fourth order tells Israel to take immediate steps to “enable the provision of urgently needed basic services and humanitarian assistance to address the adverse conditions of life faced by Palestinians in the Gaza Strip.” ‘…THE ADVERSE CONDITIONS OF LIFE FACED BY PALESTINIANS IN THE GAZA STRIP’ Bohrer said that the fourth order likely implies that Israel would need to show it is doing more than it currently is to enable the entry of humanitarian aid into Gaza. In theory, this is a measure that should be relatively straightforward to comply with. Trucks of humanitarian aid have been entering Gaza since October 21, first through the Rafah crossing between Egypt and Gaza and subsequently through the Kerem Shalom crossing between Israel and Gaza since December 17. Advertisement Trucks with aid arrive at the Gazan side of the Kerem Shalom border crossing, in the southern Gaza Strip, on January 17, 2024. (Abed Rahim Khatib/Flash90) An average of 149 trucks of humanitarian aid have entered the territory every day over the last four weeks up to January 25, according to the UN’s Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (compared to 500 a day before the war began). It appears that since the ICJ’s decision on Friday, significantly higher numbers of trucks are already passing into Gaza, with 186 trucks passing through the crossings this Sunday and Monday alone, OCHA has said. According to the Defense Ministry’s Coordinator of Government Affairs in the Territories (COGAT), 197 trucks entered Gaza on Tuesday. Another issue is not only the entry of food, medicine and other humanitarian supplies into the Strip but also its effective distribution amid the ongoing hostilities, which has been a problem for UN agencies and aid groups on the ground. The IDF already institutes daily pauses in combat operations to allow humanitarian aid to be distributed, and has done so from the beginning of the conflict. The significance of the ICJ’s concern regarding the level of humanitarian aid going into Gaza should not be underestimated. The court did not call on Israel to desist from acts of genocide but did cite numerous officials from UN agencies and humanitarian organizations who have commented on the dire humanitarian situation in Gaza and the severe effect it is having, and may yet have, on the welfare of Palestinian civilians in the territory. It is possible, therefore, that the ICJ’s principal concern with Israel’s actions in terms of the Genocide Convention is Article 2c of the treaty, which prohibits “Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part.” Advertisement The court quoted the World Health Organization and UN agencies regarding what they said was the extreme level of hunger in the territory and the potential for the spread of infectious disease, which could lead to massive loss of life. Ordering Israel to alleviate the humanitarian situation in the Gaza Strip is therefore likely intended to ensure that Israel does not violate Article 2c, and compliance with that provisional measure is therefore of critical concern for Israel. Displaced Palestinians flee from Khan Younis in the southern Gaza Strip on January 30, 2024. (Mahmud Hams/AFP) Speaking during a session of the UN Security Council on Wednesday called to review the ICJ’s provisional ruling, Brett Jonathan Miller, Israel’s deputy permanent representative to the UN, insisted that “Israel remains committed to mitigating civilian harm and to facilitating access to humanitarian aid according to the law, despite all the challenges,” noting that Hamas theft of such consignments is widespread. Hebrew media has reported that assessments given to Benny Gantz, a war cabinet minister, and Gadi Eisenkot, a war cabinet observer, have estimated that as much as 60 percent of aid trucks entering Gaza are being hijacked by Hamas. INCITEMENT TO GENOCIDE The third order, to prevent and punish incitement to genocide, will potentially be more difficult. Article 3c of the Genocide Convention states: “Direct and public incitement to commit genocide” is a punishable act, so here again it is crucial that Israel comply with this provisional measure. The ICJ’s decision cited the comments of three senior Israeli officials in relation to the allegations made by South Africa that Israel has failed to prevent and publish incitement to genocide. Advertisement In particular, it quoted comments by Defense Minister Yoav Gallant, President Isaac Herzog, and Foreign Minister Israel Katz (at the time energy minister). The ICJ decision quoted Gallant as saying “I have released all restraints . . . You saw what we are fighting against. We are fighting human animals. This is the ISIS of Gaza. This is what we are fighting against . . . Gaza won’t return to what it was before. There will be no Hamas. We will eliminate everything. If it doesn’t take one day, it will take a week, it will take weeks or even months, we will reach all places.” This citation appears to mostly rely on the incomplete quotes cited by the South African application. Defense Minister Yoav Gallant speaks to troops near the Gaza border, October 19, 2023. (Ariel Hermoni/ Defense Ministry) The remarks in question were made by Gallant on October 10, but he was not fully quoted either by the South Africans or by the ICJ. During those comments to soldiers at an IDF base in the Gaza border region, Gallant made clear on several occasions that his bellicose remarks were directed toward Hamas and combatants. Parts of Gallant’s speech not included by South Africa or the ICJ include “we will eliminate Hamas,” “we will kill everyone who fought us,” and “Gaza will not return to what it was. Hamas won’t exist.” Herzog was quoted by the ICJ as saying, “It is an entire nation out there that is responsible. It is not true this rhetoric about civilians not aware, not involved. It is absolutely not true,” and that “when a nation protects its home it fights, and we will fight until we’ll break their backbone.” He made these remarks during a press conference on October 12, but also repeated on three occasions during that event that Israel was operating and would operate according to international law, only one of which was cited by the ICJ. The court also cited a post on X by Katz, who wrote on October 13: “We will fight the terrorist organization Hamas and destroy it. All the civilian population in gaza [sic] is ordered to leave immediately. We will win. They will not receive a drop of water or a single battery until they leave the world.” The South African application included numerous other inflammatory comments made both by cabinet ministers and MKs, as well as musicians, journalists, former MKs, and former senior IDF officials, among others. To comply with the ICJ order, it would appear that Attorney General Gali Baharav-Miara would have to open investigations and potentially prosecute those deemed to have engaged in incitement to genocide. The court noted that just days before the hearings in The Hague, the Attorney General’s Office issued a statement saying that several incidents of possible incitement to harm civilians were being examined by her office. Attorney General Gali Baharav-Miara attends a conference of the Israeli chapter of the Association of Corporate Counsel (ACC) in Tel Aviv, July 5, 2022. (Avshalom Sassoni/Flash90) Dr. Assaf Shapira of the Israel Democracy Institute said he did not believe that any of the comments by government ministers made since October 7 actually amounted to calls for genocide. But another complication is that sitting MKs and cabinet ministers enjoy “substantive immunity” from prosecution for committing a criminal offense if it was committed as part of their job, including criminal speech, which could make efforts to prosecute them for incitement more difficult Shapira said, however, that an express call for the murder of civilians would be a criminal offense that would not be covered by substantive immunity. But Bar-Ilan’s Bohrer noted that although even incitement to genocide is not protected speech, “where the line passes between incitement and free speech is not always clear.” Baharav-Miara would also likely face a firestorm of criticism from the government if she opened an investigation into a cabinet minister, which might once again spark the kind of tensions seen between her, the judiciary and the government before the October 7 atrocities and the outbreak of war. Still, she is entirely independent in terms of the discretion she has to open criminal investigations of elected officials. Dr. Gal Levertov, a former director of the international division of the State Attorney’s Office, said it would be easier for the attorney general to prosecute public personalities who expressed potentially genocidal rhetoric than elected officials. These could include comments such as those of former MK Moshe Feiglin, who posted on X that Israel should “flatten Gaza,” or journalist David Mizrahy Verthaim who said, also on X, that Israel should “turn the entire Strip into a slaughterhouse,” both of which were cited by the South African application. But Levertov said that to prosecute only those who do not have immunity while failing to prosecute elected officials because of their parliamentary immunity could be seen as especially unjust and problematic in terms of public legitimacy. Bohrer noted that there are also other ways to mitigate the damage done by intemperate comments. The Attorney General’s Office could, for example, ask those who have made such a remark to either clarify that they did not mean to imply that they were advocating genocide or, in a case where the remarks cannot be understood in any other way, to fully retract them. President Isaac Herzog speaks to foreign journalists at his residence in Jerusalem on October 12, 2023. (Amy Spiro/Times of Israel) Following the publication of the ICJ orders on Friday, Herzog did issue some clarifying comments, although he also denounced the court and said he was “disgusted by the way they twisted my words, using very, very partial and fragmented quotes.” Herzog went on to say in his clarification that “there are also innocent Palestinians in Gaza,” and explained that his comments about broader responsibility by Palestinians related to “the involvement of many residents of Gaza in the slaughter, in the looting, and in the riots of October 7,” and “how the crowds in Gaza cheered at the sight of Israelis being slaughtered and their bodies mutilated.” Levertov says that in order to be in compliance by the deadline for the report that the ICJ has requested, it would be sufficient for the attorney general to demonstrate that she has merely opened investigations into possible incidents of incitement to genocide. Further down the line, if the court requests further reports, the attorney general would likely have to detail the nature of the investigations and either point to any indictments arising from them as evidence that Israel is seeking to prevent and punish incitement to genocide, or if cases are closed without indictments demonstrate there was no room for prosecution. During the UN Security Council meeting on Wednesday, Miller insisted that Israel “makes rigorous efforts to draw the line between permissible statements, even those that express pain and outrage in times of crisis, and those which go beyond the limits of free speech.” He also pointed to the Attorney General office’s statement that calling for intentional harm to civilians may amount to a criminal offense and that several cases are currently being examined by Israel’s law enforcement authorities. The report, which is due by February 26, will likely be written by the Justice Ministry, and include input from the International Law Department of the Military Advocate General Corps in the IDF, along with the Foreign Ministry and the defense team that represented Israel in the ICJ. On Giving Tuesday, support quality journalism Is the fast, fair and free journalism of The Times of Israel important to you? If so, today - Giving Tuesday - is the right time to join The Times of Israel Community. For as little as $6/month, you will support our independent journalism, enjoy an AD-FREE experience and unlock exclusive content available only for members of The Times of Israel Community. Join Our Community Join Our Community Already a member? Sign in to stop seeing this You're a dedicated reader We’re really pleased that you’ve read X Times of Israel articles in the past month. That’s why we started the Times of Israel eleven years ago - to provide discerning readers like you with must-read coverage of Israel and the Jewish world. So now we have a request. Unlike other news outlets, we haven’t put up a paywall. But as the journalism we do is costly, we invite readers for whom The Times of Israel has become important to help support our work by joining The Times of Israel Community. For as little as $6 a month you can help support our quality journalism while enjoying The Times of Israel AD-FREE, as well as accessing exclusive content available only to Times of Israel Community members. Thank you, David Horovitz, Founding Editor of The Times of Israel Join Our Community Join Our Community Already a member? Sign in to stop seeing this Most Popular * 1 Trump warns there will be ‘all hell to pay’ if hostages aren’t released by Jan. 20 * 2 In a watery Golan cave, Herod’s great-grandson entertained in the Roman imperial style * 3 IDF says US-Israeli hostage Cpt. Omer Neutra killed on Oct. 7 and his body held in Gaza * 4 Who are the rebels battering Syria’s regime, and do they pose a risk to Israel? * 5 IDF launches wave of strikes in Lebanon after Hezbollah mortar attack * 6 As Iran sends forces to Syria, IDF warns it not to smuggle arms to Hezbollah * 7 Digging in, IDF builds dozens of bases in and around expanded Netzarim Corridor – NYT * 8 Israeli researchers discover gene mutation in Ashkenazi Jews that can cause autism Advertisement Skip Ads by read more: * Israel & the Region * Israel genocide case at ICJ * ICJ International Court of Justice * The Hague * October 7 Hamas atrocities * 2023-2024 Israel-Hamas war * genocide * Genocide Convention close popup Sign in or Register Email address * Please use the following structure: example@domain.com Continue Or Continue with By registering you agree to the terms and conditions Send me The Times of Israel Daily Edition back close popup Register to continue Email address * Change REGISTER Or Continue with back close popup Log in to continue Email address * Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.. Continue back close popup Sign in or Register Email address * Password * Incorrect password. Please try again or choose an option below. Continue I forgot my password / Send me a sign in link Or Continue with close popup Check your email We sent an email to you at . It has a link that will sign you in. Click the link in that email to complete registration so you can comment. Advertisement Advertisement Recommended Stories No more boring Zoom lessons. Learn Hebrew differently! Citizen Café Tel Aviv | Sponsored Amazon Founder Jeff Bezos Recommends: 5 Books For Turning Your Life Around Blinkist: Jeff Bezos' Reading List | Sponsored Increíble, el decodificador de TV del que todos hablan: ¿Acceso a todos los canales? Smart TV | Sponsored Shop Now Thousands of Men Love These Simple Men's Jeans Dudlle Dad Jeans | Sponsored 77 consejos de jubilación para carteras superiores a 500.000 € Fisher Investments España | Sponsored Urologist: 87% of Men with E.D. Don't Know About This Easy Solution (Try Tonight!) staminasparkstation.com | Sponsored Upgrade Your Home Security This 2024 Holiday Season with Smart Locks TodayAINews | Sponsored Nuevo salvaescaleras 2024: sin instalación Anuncios buscados | Sponsored Advertisement December 4, 2024 Current Top Stories Slain Israeli-American hostage remembered as ‘hero of Israel’ at NY memorial service By AP, Jacob Magid and Jessica Steinberg Hundreds pack synagogue where Omer Neutra had bar mitzvah to pay respects; brother Daniel vows to work for release of all captives in his honor; grandmother speaks at Tel Aviv event Trump warns there will be ‘all hell to pay’ if hostages aren’t released by Jan. 20 By Jacob Magid IDF says US-Israeli hostage Cpt. Omer Neutra killed on Oct. 7 and his body held in Gaza By Emanuel Fabian ‘Dad won’t be able to say goodbye’: Mother of Hamas hostage Keith Siegel dies By ToI Staff Live Norway wealth fund divests from Bezeq for providing services to West Bank settlements By ToI Staff Trump said considering replacing Hegseth with Florida’s DeSantis as Pentagon pick * Pentagon says US forces in eastern Syria struck rocket launchers, tank posing ‘imminent threat’ * 11min ago Settlers set fire to Palestinian buildings after troops demolish structures in West Bank outpost * 42min ago US House honors slain Israeli-American hostage Omer Neutra: 'Young man of extraordinary courage' * 50min ago IDF says it returned bodies of 2 Jordanian terrorists who infiltrated near Dead Sea in October * 1hr ago UN seeks $47 billion for aid in 2025, warning 'world on fire' MKs file bill to enable police probes against AG amid growing campaign to oust her By ToI Staff Likud minister reveals list of 13 cabinet members who have signed letter demanding firing of Gali Baharav-Miara, with Ben Gvir reportedly lobbying other ministers to sign on Top West Bank cop revealed as suspect in shadowy case linked to Ben Gvir By ToI Staff Prison service chief detained for questioning; Ben Gvir accuses AG of ‘attempted coup’ By ToI Staff Judge orders Netanyahu aide Feldstein to house arrest, gives state till Wed. to appeal By ToI Staff Court finds dearth of evidence that spokesman intended to harm state security when he leaked secret document to press, but does believe he knew leaking the material was illegal Live updates (closed)Dec. 3: Reports say Feldstein told Netanyahu about top-secret document before leak to Bild By Michael Bachner and ToI Staff Judges okay moving Netanyahu testimony to Tel Aviv amid concerns for his security By ToI Staff Netanyahu: High Court has no right to order state commission of inquiry into Oct. 7 By ToI Staff Israel warns Lebanon to ensure Hezbollah adheres to truce or face attacks itself By Emanuel Fabian and Agencies Defense minister urges Lebanese to keep terror group within ceasefire terms; Hezbollah liaison with Syrian army killed in strike; US said to press Jerusalem, Beirut to uphold deal IDF launches wave of strikes in Lebanon after Hezbollah mortar attack By Emanuel Fabian, Lazar Berman, Jacob Magid and ToI Staff Iran’s ambassador to Lebanon reappears after being injured in September pager attack By ToI Staff and AP Op-ed: Day 424 of the war David Horovitz Why you should be worried for Israeli democracy The coalition is moving to centralize ever more authority in Netanyahu’s hands – at the expense of gatekeepers including the legal system, police, Shin Bet and free press South Korea’s President Yoon backs down after briefly declaring martial law By Jack Kim and Ju-min Park Outraged lawmakers had rejected the decree, sparking the country’s biggest political crisis in decades; protesters outside parliament shout and clap South Korean leader declares martial law, sparking chaos as lawmakers vote to block move By Agencies and ToI Staff Award-winning French film about Jewish radical shrouded in mystery makes US debut By Shira Li Bartov ‘The Goldman Case’ tells the story of Pierre Goldman, who was convicted of murdering two pharmacists in a robbery before a retrial cleared him of the charges Syrian rebel forces push toward Hama, intensifying pressure on Assad and his allies By Reuters and ToI Staff Iranian FM says Tehran will consider sending troops if Damascus asks; Israel said to fear chemical weapons could fall into wrong hands during takeover of regime military facilities Israel rejects claims it is restricting Gaza aid, says hundreds of trucks waiting By Emanuel Fabian and Agencies Foreign Ministry lashes UK, France and Germany for missive on shortages of supplies; evacuation warnings issued for parts of southern Gaza after rocket fired by Hamas from area Fatah, Hamas agree to form committee to run postwar Gaza By Agencies and ToI Staff Digging in, IDF builds dozens of bases in and around expanded Netzarim Corridor – NYT By ToI Staff UN watchdog to conduct probe into sexual misconduct allegations against ICC prosecutor By Agencies and ToI Staff Karim Khan’s wife previously worked with oversight body selected to investigate him, prompting human rights groups to express concerns over conflict of interest Pro-Palestinian group files war crimes complaint against new IDF attaché in Brussels By ToI Staff ICC top judge pans ‘appalling’ US threat to penalize court over Israel arrest warrants By AP and ToI Staff Israeli researchers discover gene mutation in Ashkenazi Jews that can cause autism By Diana Bletter One in 80 Ashkenazi Jews carry the TBCB gene; Israelis can now test for it as part of the Health Ministry national healthcare basket Franz Kafka’s papers metamorphose into National Library exhibit By Jessica Steinberg Wide-ranging exhibition ‘Kafka: Metamorphosis of an Author’ features the institution’s singular archives and marks 100 years since the Czech author’s death Israeli farmer who lost son to Hezbollah rocket tries to restore his orchard By Reuters and ToI Staff ‘I came and saw the worst thing possible to see,’ says Moshe Weinstein, who found his son, along with four Thai workers, lying dead in his apple orchard Andorra, where non-Catholic houses of worship are illegal, gets first full-time rabbi By PHILISSA CRAMER Chabad emissary Kuty Kalmenson to become first Jewish religious leader of tiny principality, where around 250 Jews live among a total population of around 80,000 Business leaders worry about government priorities to support war-battered economy By Sharon Wrobel Prominent entrepreneurs see the continued prioritization of political budget allocations, over economic ones, delaying recovery at a cost to the public ‘Zionism 2.0’: Former NBA player Omri Casspi raises $60m to invest in Israeli startups By Sharon Wrobel Nova’s lingering scars: PTSD and fear of suicides spark alarm By Deborah Danan Many of those who survived the Hamas massacre at the desert rave witnessed extreme violence by the terrorists, including rape and mutilation. Now, they are desperate for more support Those we have lost Eliyahu Berenshtein, 19: Oldest of 10 was ‘magical’ musical autodidact By ToI Staff Murdered by Hamas terrorists while trying to flee the Supernova music festival on October 7 Those we have lostDavid Newman, 25: Ex-Haredi dreamed of opening his own events hall By ToI Staff Those We Have LostSupt. Dan Ganot, 41: Cop spent time mentoring at-risk youth By ToI Staff More Headlines US deepens sanctions on Iranian oil as smuggling said to rake in billions for Tehran By Reuters IDF says 3 gunmen planning ‘imminent terror attack’ killed in West Bank drone strike By Emanuel Fabian and ToI Staff Israel prepares to honor Diaspora victims of antisemitic attacks By Zev Stub Three killed when two cars collide north of Tel Aviv, burst into flames By ToI Staff Bill giving justice minister power over Bar Association’s fees clears first reading By ToI Staff Google said worried contract with Israel could damage its reputation By ToI Staff 4 anti-government protesters charged with terror for firing flares at Netanyahu home By ToI Staff Shin Bet: Iran targeted senior Israeli figures with over 200 cyberattacks By Emanuel Fabian and ToI Staff In reversal, German court says 100-year-old Nazi guard may go on trial By AFP Intel CEO resigns before completing struggling chipmaker’s turnaround plan By Reuters and Sharon Wrobel Top Ops Debra Weiner-Solomont Words no army parent wants to hear: ‘Get to the hospital now’ My son has a hard road ahead, but his deep friendships and our new support network have already worked wonders toward healing Hussain Abdul-Hussain Gulf countries talk like Iran, act like Israel The GCC rhetoric on Israel masks its true aims to decouple Syria’s Assad and the Islamic Republic and declaw Hezbollah in Lebanon Ely Karmon Why I just subscribed to Haaretz The government’s multi-pronged assault on the independence of Israel’s news media takes a page out of the authoritarian playbook Yonatan Freeman No cause for alarm: ICC decisions won’t change Israel’s reality The world needs Israel in the fight against the radical forces (read: Iran) that threaten regional and global stability Nathan Lopes Cardozo Judaism without God Those without faith must learn and live the commandments as a revolution, as a protest to the commonplace, as an act of defiance Romi Sussman Intersecting paths at Har Herzl The grieving couple that happened to visit their son’s grave during another funeral seemed like strangers at first. And then they weren’t Marc J. Rosenstein From the river to the sea Today’s apocalyptic vision of total victory must make way for hard decisions, arduous negotiations, and courageous leadership David Matlow Lessons of a 100–year-old postcard from an imaginary land Where in the world is West Refaim and why did it have its own stamp? Riddles from back when the Jewish imagination went postal Mijal Bitton If Esau could have met Rabbi Zvi Kogan z”l Jacob is the ’good guy’ in his family, but was his twin really such a villain? What if he had been educated with the love each child needs? (Toledot) David Sedley Internal strength Like reinforced concrete, law and justice are things we take for granted – that is, until things go terribly wrong (Toledot) Michael Oren Love and rage: A tale of two funerals Though traumatized by war, the thousands who came to lay Sgt. First Class Yona Brief to rest united in a display of unrestrained compassion Ali Rashid Al Nuaimi and Jonathan A. Greenblatt Those who murdered Rabbi Kogan have already failed Together, we declare: Terror has failed, peace will prevail. The UAE will continue to be a lighthouse of hope in the region Latest Articles * 3 hours ago Live updatesNorway wealth fund divests from Bezeq for providing services to West Bank settlements * 4 hours ago MKs file bill to enable police probes against AG amid growing campaign to oust her * 5 hours ago Syrian rebel forces push toward Hama, intensifying pressure on Assad and his allies * 7 hours ago Slain Israeli-American hostage remembered as ‘hero of Israel’ at NY memorial service * 8 hours ago Award-winning French film about Jewish radical shrouded in mystery makes US debut * 9 hours ago UN watchdog to conduct probe into sexual misconduct allegations against ICC prosecutor * 9 hours ago South Korea’s President Yoon backs down after briefly declaring martial law * 10 hours ago Pro-Palestinian group files war crimes complaint against new IDF attaché in Brussels * 10 hours ago IDF says 3 gunmen planning ‘imminent terror attack’ killed in West Bank drone strike * 10 hours ago Judges okay moving Netanyahu testimony to Tel Aviv amid concerns for his security * 11 hours ago Judge orders Netanyahu aide Feldstein to house arrest, gives state till Wed. to appeal * 12 hours ago Andorra, where non-Catholic houses of worship are illegal, gets first full-time rabbi * 13 hours ago South Korean leader declares martial law, sparking chaos as lawmakers vote to block move * 13 hours ago Business leaders worry about government priorities to support war-battered economy * 13 hours ago Google said worried contract with Israel could damage its reputation * 13 hours ago Israeli farmer who lost son to Hezbollah rocket tries to restore his orchard * 14 hours ago In reversal, German court says 100-year-old Nazi guard may go on trial * 14 hours ago US deepens sanctions on Iranian oil as smuggling said to rake in billions for Tehran * 15 hours ago Israeli researchers discover gene mutation in Ashkenazi Jews that can cause autism * 15 hours ago Israel rejects claims it is restricting Gaza aid, says hundreds of trucks waiting See All Latest Blogs * Vincent James Hooper NATO Membership for Ukraine: A Pa... * Kenneth Cohen Obstacles to Spirituality * Ethan Goldberg What’s Behind Mohammed bin Salm... * Jeffrey Levine From Jacob to Israel: Lies and Hate * Stanley M. Rosenblatt Antisemites Should Love the Jews * Michael Laitman The Parable of the Strong Wind St... * Berl Falbaum Shakespeare & Biden's Pardon ... * Carol Silver Elliott Truly Doing Good * Samir Hasanov North Caucasus: Rising Threat to ... * Gina Friedlander A Taste of Life in the Israeli Army See All Docu Nation Today's Daily Briefing Day 424 – Hezbollah mortar fire tests Lebanon ceasefire listen to the podcast Those We Have Lost Stories of the civilians and soldiers who have fallen since Oct. 7 Read Here Help Rebuild Their Lives Donate Sponsored TOI ORIGINAL VIDEO THE 8119TH RESERVE BATTALION Those We Are Missing The hostages and victims whose fate is still unknown Read Here PODCASTS Listen now & Wartime Diaries Voices and testimonies of these devastating times listen to the podcast The Times of Israel Daily Edition Free to Your Inbox The email is either missing or invalid. By signing up, you agree to our terms You hereby accept The Times of Israel Terms of Use and Privacy Policy, and you agree to receive the latest news & offers from The Times of Israel and its partners or ad sponsors. Full Coverage 2023-2024 Israel-Hamas war * Slain Israeli-American hostage remembered as ‘hero of Israel’ at NY memorial service By AP, Jacob Magid and Jessica Steinberg * Business leaders worry about government priorities to support war-battered economy By Sharon Wrobel * Google said worried contract with Israel could damage its reputation By ToI Staff See All Full Coverage What Matters Now * What Matters Now to combat medic Tuvia Book: Reserve duty for over a year By ToI Staff * What Matters Now to Haviv Rettig Gur: What’s left of the left? By ToI Staff * What Matters Now to Haviv Rettig Gur: Rising resentment as Haredi men refuse draft By ToI Staff See All Full Coverage Liveblog * Norway wealth fund divests from Bezeq for providing services to West Bank settlements By ToI Staff * Dec. 3: Reports say Feldstein told Netanyahu about top-secret document before leak to Bild By Michael Bachner and ToI Staff * Dec. 2: IDF issues evacuation orders after Gaza rocket fire; navy downs drone over Red Sea By Elana Kirsh and ToI Staff See All Full Coverage ToI Original Video * The 8119th Reserve Battalion * Hersh * Tel Aviv cafe brews up resilience See All Those we have lost Stories of the civilians and soldiers who have fallen in the Israel-Hamas war * Those we have lost Staff Sgt. Shlomo Reshetnikov, 20: Lone soldier from Russia By ToI Staff * Those we have lost Sgt. First Class Omer Bitan, 22: Reservist with big life plans By ToI Staff * Those we have lost Nadav Amikam, 39: Art teacher with a deep love of nature By ToI Staff * Those we have lost Aviya Genut, 22: Coffee addict was ‘a ray of sunshine’ By ToI Staff * Those We Have Lost Clemence Mtenga: Tanzanian student on 1st trip from home By ToI Staff * Those we have lost Hillel Zalmanovich, 60: Avid bike rider who loved to explore Israel By ToI Staff * Those we have lost Ch. Insp. Kim Dukarker, 22: Off-duty cop who wouldn’t leave her friend By ToI Staff * Those we have lost Sgt. Guy Bazak, 19: Golani, scout leader ‘destined for greatness’ By ToI Staff * Those we have lost Aviv Baram, 33: Kfar Aza defender, roadie for rockers & Hapoel fanatic By ToI Staff * Those we have lost Amit Lahav, 23: Adventurous free spirit who spread positivity By ToI Staff * Those we have lost Warrant Officer Ziv Dado, 36: Career officer was ‘the first to help’ By ToI Staff * Those we have lost Sgt. Maj. Chen Nahmias, 43: Father of 4 was ‘definition of a hero’ By ToI Staff * Those We Have Lost Eliyahu Orgad, 72: Grandfather who was ‘a true intellectual’ By ToI Staff * Those We Have Lost Cpt. Shir Eilat, 20: Selfless observation soldiers commander By ToI Staff * Those We Have Lost Staff Sgt. Adi Tzur, 20: Quietly assertive ‘hero’ soldier By ToI Staff * Those We Have Lost Livnat Levi, 27: World-traveler partygoer was sixth of 10 siblings By ToI Staff * Those we have lost Matan Lior, 35: Festival sound man stayed to help others flee By ToI Staff * Those We Have Lost Sgt. First Class (res.) Yinon Fleishman, 31: Beloved educator By ToI Staff * Those we have lost Sgt. Yaron Zohar, 19: Promising soccer player who was ‘never angry’ By ToI Staff * Those we have lost Ben Mizrachi, 22: Former IDF medic killed while helping others By ToI Staff Those we are missing The hostages and victims whose fate is still unknown * Those we are missing Taken captive: Bar Kupershtein, last seen tied up by Hamas By ToI Staff * Those we are missing Taken captive: Eviatar David, IDed in a Hamas photo on Telegram By ToI Staff * Those we are missing Taken captive: Ziv Berman, from his home in Kfar Aza’s young generation neighborhood By ToI Staff * Those we are missing Taken captive: Yosef-Haim Ohana, helped injured at Supernova rave By ToI Staff * Those we are missing Taken captive: Segev Kalfon, last seen running across Highway 232 By ToI Staff * Those we are missing Taken captive: Tsahi Idan, terrorists promised daughter his safe return By ToI Staff * Those we are missing Taken captive: Nimrod Cohen, twin working to bring him home By ToI Staff * Those we are missing Taken captive: Ohad Yahalomi, shot in the leg by terrorists By ToI Staff * Those we are missing Taken captive: Liri Albag, seen in Hamas video being abducted By ToI Staff * Those we are missing Taken captive: Hamza Ziyadne, Rahat resident working in Kibbutz Holit By ToI Staff * Those we are missing Taken captive: Ohad Ben Ami, dual Israeli-German citizen By ToI Staff * Those who are missing Taken captive: Doron Steinbrecher, ‘They’ve arrived, they have me’ By ToI Staff * Those we are missing Taken captive: Alon Ohel, pianist’s family recorded song for him By ToI Staff * Those we are missing Taken captive: Omer Wenkert, suffers from autoimmune condition By ToI Staff * Those we are missing Taken captive: Devoted uncle and Nir Oz resident Yair Horn By ToI Staff * Those we are missing Taken captive: Maxim Herkin, was attending his first trance rave By ToI Staff * Those we are missing Taken captive: Omer Shem-Tov’s car was driven into Gaza By ToI Staff * Those we are missing Taken captive: Guy Gilboa-Dalal, took a selfie with his brother for mom By ToI Staff * Those we are missing Taken captive: Itzik Elgarat, shot in his hand by Hamas terrorists By ToI Staff * Those we are missing Taken captive: Tamir Nimrodi, walked by gunmen to base gate By ToI Staff Tales of the Times The quirky, improbable, infuriating and uplifting * Ming leftovers Mount Zion dig unearths 16th century Chinese porcelain bowl fragment By Gavriel Fiske * Historic move Jerusalem ancient citadel museum to host accessibility conference By Jessica Steinberg * Happy ending Former Hamas hostage Mia Schem engaged to childhood friend By ToI Staff * Tiny treasure Girl, 12, finds 3,500-year-old Egyptian amulet on hike in central Israel By Gavriel Fiske * Elon, watch your back? Meta CEO Zuckerberg dines with Trump at Mar-a-Lago By AFP * Year of discord October 7 reverberates at Israeli music awards By Jessica Steinberg * Sensory arts At Nalaga’at festival, the blind lead the public to food and fun in the dark By ToI Staff * Ultra-Orthodox LGBTQ+ Israel’s Nir Bergman wins director’s prize in Tallinn By Jessica Steinberg * Fiction meets reality 3rd season of ‘Tehran,’ featuring Hugh Laurie, returns to Kan By Jessica Steinberg * Her legacy lives on Murdered peace activist Vivian Silver remembered with new prize By Jessica Steinberg * 'Greatest gift to Israel' Warner Bros, Aaron Sorkin to tell story of ‘father’ of IAF By ToI Staff * 'We will dance again' Pop stars spotlight October 7 massacre at ADL concert against hate By ToI Staff * Counting sheep Israelis swiftly snatch up tickets for ‘The 16th Sheep’ shows By Jessica Steinberg * Feast of words Book offers guide to Israel’s ethnic groups through family restaurants By Jessica Steinberg * Fist of Jewry? Jake Paul brings a touch of Jewish heritage to boxing By JTA and ToI Staff * Identity crisis Boycott calls over Israeli cast as Mary in Netflix’s Jesus mom epic By Michael Horovitz * A royal reception Israeli action star Lior Raz meets King Charles at London premiere By ToI Staff * Old friends ‘I was a fool’: Art Garfunkel says he made amends with Paul Simon By ToI Staff * Welcome to LA Gal Gadot hosts Academy members for screening of Israel’s Oscars choice By Jessica Steinberg * Under the sea Jerusalem’s aquarium invites visitors to spend the night By Jessica Steinberg Scroll to view more * home * Israel & the Region * Jewish Times * Israel Inside * The Blogs * Tech Israel * Real Estate Israel * daily edition * terms and conditions * privacy policy * about us * advertise with us * Jobs at The Times of Israel * contact us * facebook * twitter subscribe to the daily edition Enter your email address submit Community * Join our community * Sign in © 2024 The Times of Israel, all rights reserved Concept, design & development by Powered by Never miss breaking news on Israel Get notifications to stay updated Stay updated No thanks You're subscribed close popup Register for free and continue reading Registering also lets you comment on articles and helps us improve your experience. It takes just a few seconds. Already registered? Enter your email to sign in. Email address Please use the following structure: example@domain.com REGISTER OR SIGN IN Or Continue with By registering you agree to the terms and conditions. Once registered, you’ll receive our Daily Edition email for free. Send me The Times of Israel Daily Edition back close popup Register to continue Email address Change REGISTER Or Continue with back close popup Log in to continue Email address Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.. Continue back close popup Sign in or Register Email address * Password * Incorrect password. Please try again or choose an option below. Continue I forgot my password / Send me a sign in link Or Continue with back close popup Check your email We sent an email to you at . It has a link that will sign you in. Click the link in that email to complete your registration.