www.catholic.com Open in urlscan Pro
2606:4700:20::681a:b8b  Public Scan

Form analysis
0 forms found in the DOM

Text Content

Skip to main content Accessibility feedback
☰
✕
   Home
   Catholic Answers Live
   Podcasts
   Video
   Magazine
   Q&As
   Tracts
   News
   Events
   Encyclopedia
   Bible Navigator
 * 
   Donate
   SOCIETY 315
   Shop
   School of Apologetics
   Speakers
 * 
   About
   Careers
   Advertise



Find
About Shop Donate
article


LOVE JESUS MORE THAN JUSTICE


HOMILY FOR THE TWENTY-THIRD SUNDAY IN ORDINARY TIME, 2022

Fr. Samuel Keyes • 9/4/2022
Download Share
AddThis Sharing Buttons
Share to FacebookFacebookShare to TwitterTwitterShare to PrintPrintShare to
EmailEmailShare to MoreAddThis
Listen to the audio version of this content


> If anyone comes to me and does not hate his own father and mother and wife and
> children and brothers and sisters, yes, and even his own life, he cannot be my
> disciple (Luke 14:26).

What in the world is going on here? Most of us hear this passage and immediately
try to deconstruct it for what it must be really saying. Surely, we say, this
isn’t really about hate; it’s about priorities. So it’s not that we should hate
our fathers and mothers and so on, but that we should not love them too much.
And we can all think of examples where people (not us, obviously) do that.

To be fair, there does exist in Hebrew literary culture a tendency to hyperbole.
So maybe there’s a bit of rhetorical exaggeration here in Jesus’ comments. But
he still says what he says, and it’s still jarring, so it’s worth asking whether
he really wants us to jump straight to the easier message of “get your
priorities in order.”



I want to draw here from one of my old professors, Stanley Hauerwas, who is
famous for never passing up an opportunity to say something provocative. In a
piece called “Hating Mothers as the Way to Peace,” he points out how love is so
often at the heart of conflict:

> Our violence lies not in ourselves but in our loves. We think it crucial to
> protect those we love. Indeed, I suspect most of us go to war to protect our
> loves. Our families, our neighborhoods are what we care about when we go to
> war—nations are but symbols of those cares.

I’d guess this resonates with most of us. It is often the case that soldiers
fight less for some idea about the nation or about virtue than in simple defense
of those they love. Any father or mother, sister or brother gets this. And I
often say that fatherhood brought out depths of anger that I never knew I had!
I’m not just talking about the frustrations of children—I’m talking about this
deeply ingrained fighting instinct against those who might in any way hurt my
children.

We’re all familiar with that moment in the Garden of Gethsemane when Peter draws
a sword to defend his Lord. We all want to do that. Love demands it. But, Jesus
tells us, as he tells Peter there, this love has to be transformed.

Here’s Hauerwas again:

> We no longer need desperately try to ensure the survival of those we love, for
> we can now love them with the security and the conviction that God’s kingdom
> is surely here. In short, Jesus brought the end time so that we may have the
> time to love without that love becoming the source of our violence.

Let’s put it this way: Christianity isn’t in the first instance about protecting
the innocent. Yes, Catholic tradition is very strong in its recognition of and
witness to natural kinds of justice. But such witness has more to do with
authentic created human nature than it does with the gospel. In fact, the death
and resurrection of Jesus have given us a fundamentally new context for any
discussion of justice in the world. Our hope does not depend in any way on our
success in preserving the innocent from suffering, or on stopping all injustice,
or on protecting those we love.

After all, as a people we already done the worst thing we could possibly do. We
killed God.

Sometimes, showing a rather casual forgetfulness of this huge cosmic history,
modern Christians love to go around promoting causes. Sometimes they’re very
good causes that should be promoted, like the integrity of the natural human
family and the protection of children. But there is a danger here that we need
to acknowledge. The chief task of the Church isn’t just going around declaring
that this or that thing is bad. The chief task of the Church is to tell the
world that the ultimate source of all this evil is the world’s rejection of
Jesus. We can correct this or that injustice all day, but until we get to this
most basic reality our work will always be incomplete.

Which brings us to our epistle, which is an excerpt from St. Paul’s short letter
to Philemon. To refresh our memory, here’s the story. Philemon is a wealthy
Christian who was converted through Paul’s ministry. Onesimus was his slave.
Onesimus runs away, but while he is away he himself encounters Paul and becomes
a Christian. Paul sends him back to his former master with this letter, which
effectively says, Onesimus is now, like you, the slave of Christ. So treat him
as such.

When you study this letter in an academic context, pretty quickly the discussion
moves to the big question. Why doesn’t Paul just outright condemn slavery? It’s
pretty clear that he doesn’t envision Onesimus just going back to his former
life, but from a modern perspective it’s weird that Philemon isn’t called out
for owning slaves in the first place. Cue the modern critics who see this as yet
another example of how backward Christianity is.

But what if Paul understands that it’s not really sufficient for the Church
simply to condemn an evil practice? What if he understands that what is at stake
is not just something like getting our priorities in order or preventing
suffering, but a radical new form of the human family centered on our
incorporation into the resurrected Jesus? He who does not hate mother or father
or sister or brother or slave or master or even life itself for my sake cannot
be my disciple. The big picture matters. We can get our priorities in order, we
can avoid loving things too much, but without Jesus none of this will matter
very much. We can promote justice and make the world a better place, but without
Jesus the world will still choose darkness rather than light.

The only way to avoid hate is to love Jesus first and above all else. Because it
is only when we love people and things for his sake, and in his love, that those
loves can become the real love that can last through death.


RELATED


THE HARD SAYINGS OF JESUS (WITH THE WORD ON FIRE INSTITUTE)

In this interview with Word on Fire content director Matt...

AUDIO


WHY WE'RE CATHOLIC: OUR REASONS FOR FAITH, HOPE, AND LOVE

How can you believe all this stuff? This is the number-one...

SHOP


UNREASONABLE JESUS

It would seem as if some of Jesus’ teachings are...

ARTICLE


WHEN CONVERTING HURTS, DO IT ANYWAY

Once you’re convinced Catholicism is true, is converting...

ARTICLE


JESUS TRULY UNDERSTANDS OUR SUFFERING

Homily for the Fifth Sunday of Lent, 2021 Some Greeks who had...

ARTICLE


FAITH ALONE IS NOT ENOUGH

When I was Protestant, I knew just how I was going to respond...

ARTICLE


DID CHRIST DIE FOR ALL?

Protestants and Catholics share the belief that Jesus Christ...

ARTICLE


THE REAL PRESENCE: PART ONE

For millions of non-Catholic Christians, myself included when...

ARTICLE


JESUS PUTS MARY IN HER PLACE

There are two moments in the Gospels in which Jesus appears...

ARTICLE

‹ ›
Enjoying this content?  Please support our mission! Donate
Get Our Newsletter Donate


COMPANY

About Us
News
Profiles
Careers
Advertise

SITES

 * Shop
 * School
 * Conference
 * Cruises

PUBLISHING

 * Submissions
 * Permissions


Copyright © 1996-2022 Catholic Answers
Terms | Privacy | Contact Us
By continuing to use this site you agree to our Terms and that you have read our
Privacy Policy. All right