news.liverpool.ac.uk
Open in
urlscan Pro
138.253.13.33
Public Scan
URL:
https://news.liverpool.ac.uk/2024/01/15/south-africa-challenges-israel-at-the-international-court-of-justice/
Submission: On November 30 via api from US — Scanned from GB
Submission: On November 30 via api from US — Scanned from GB
Form analysis 8 forms found in the DOM
Name: courses-search — GET https://www.liverpool.ac.uk/search/
<form class="" name="courses-search" id="merged-search-mobile" method="get" action="https://www.liverpool.ac.uk/search/">
<h2><label for="coursequery-mobile">Search</label></h2>
<input type="hidden" name="course-search-location" value="main-top">
<span id="includes-radios"><input id="coursequery-mobile" class="search-query clearable ui-autocomplete-input" name="query" type="search" placeholder="e.g. Open days, accommodation, sports" autocomplete="off">
<div class="mobile-radios">
<span class="mobile-radio-group active">
<input type="radio" id="global-search-all-mobile" name="search-choose-mobile" value="all" data-href="https://www.liverpool.ac.uk/search/" checked="">
<label class="form__label" for="global-search-all-mobile">All</label>
</span>
<span class="mobile-radio-group">
<input type="radio" id="global-search-ug-mobile" name="search-choose-mobile" value="courses" data-href="https://www.liverpool.ac.uk/courses/search">
<label class="form__label" for="global-search-ug-mobile">Courses</label>
</span>
</div>
</span>
<input name="submit" id="submitbuttonmobile" type="image" value="Search" src="//www.liverpool.ac.uk/files/images/icons/search-white.svg" alt="submit">
</form>Name: courses-search — GET https://www.liverpool.ac.uk/course-search-results/?collection=new-main-collection
<form class="clearfix" name="courses-search" id="mobile-study-menu-course-search" method="get" action="https://www.liverpool.ac.uk/course-search-results/?collection=new-main-collection">
<div class="course-key-word">
<label for="query-mobile-course">
<h2>Find a course</h2>
</label>
<input type="hidden" name="collection" value="new-main-collection">
<input id="query-mobile-course" name="query" type="text" placeholder="Choose a subject">
</div>
<div class="course-type">
<input type="hidden" name="start_rank" value="1">
<input type="hidden" name="page" value="1">
<input type="hidden" name="f.IsCourse|Z" value="yes">
<input type="hidden" name="course-search-location" value="study-menu">
<label for="course-search-mobile-1" aria-label="Choose a course type">
<h2>Select type</h2>
<select id="course-search-mobile-1" name="f.IsCourse|Y">
<option selected="selected" value="">Any level</option>
<option value="undergraduate">Undergraduate</option>
<option value="postgraduate taught">Postgraduate Taught Courses</option>
<option value="postgraduate research">Postgraduate Research Degrees</option>
</select>
</label>
</div>
<div class="common-menu-course-search-button">
<input type="submit" name="submit" value="Search">
</div>
</form><form><input type="submit" id="continue-button" class="continue-button-gtm" value="Accept"></form>Name: courses-search — GET https://www.liverpool.ac.uk/course-search-results/
<form class="clearfix" name="courses-search" id="study-menu-course-search" method="get" action="https://www.liverpool.ac.uk/course-search-results/">
<div class="course-key-word">
<h2>Find a course</h2>
<p><a href="https://www.liverpool.ac.uk/study/subjects/">
Browse courses by subject area
</a></p>
<label for="query-study">
<h2>Search courses</h2>
</label>
<input type="hidden" name="collection" value="new-main-collection">
<input id="query-study" name="query" type="text" placeholder="Choose a subject">
</div>
<div class="course-type">
<input type="hidden" name="start_rank" value="1">
<input type="hidden" name="page" value="1">
<input type="hidden" name="f.IsCourse|Z" value="yes">
<input type="hidden" name="course-search-location" value="study-menu">
<label for="course-search-desktop" aria-label="Choose a course type">
<h2>Select type</h2>
<select id="course-search-desktop" name="f.IsCourse|Y">
<option selected="selected" value="">Any level</option>
<option value="undergraduate">Undergraduate</option>
<option value="postgraduate taught">Postgraduate Taught Courses</option>
<option value="postgraduate research">Postgraduate Research Degrees</option>
</select>
</label>
</div>
<div class="common-menu-course-search-button">
<input type="submit" name="submit" value="Search">
</div>
</form>Name: courses-search — GET https://www.liverpool.ac.uk/search/
<form class="" name="courses-search" id="merged-search" method="get" action="https://www.liverpool.ac.uk/search/">
<h2><label for="coursequery-desktop">Search</label></h2>
<input type="hidden" name="course-search-location" value="main-top">
<div id="includes-radios">
<input id="coursequery-desktop" class="search-query clearable ui-autocomplete-input" name="query" type="search" autocomplete="off" placeholder="e.g. Open days, accommodation, sports">
<div class="radio-group active">
<input type="radio" id="global-search-all-desktop-all" name="search-choose" value="all" data-href="https://www.liverpool.ac.uk/search/" checked="">
<label class="form__label" for="global-search-all-desktop-all">All</label>
</div>
<div class="radio-group">
<input type="radio" id="global-search-ug-desktop-courses" name="search-choose" value="courses" data-href="https://www.liverpool.ac.uk/courses/search">
<label class="form__label" for="global-search-ug-desktop-courses">Courses</label>
</div>
<script>
$(function() {
var whichchecked = $("input[name=search-choose]:checked").val();
if (whichchecked == "courses") {
$('input#global-search-all-desktop-all').parent().removeClass('active'); // replace former active with not-active
$('input#global-search-ug-desktop-courses').parent().removeClass('not-active').addClass('active'); // add class active to
}
$('.radio-group').click(function() { // when a .myDiv is clicked
$('.radio-group.active').removeClass('active').addClass('not-active'); // replace former active with not-active
$(this).removeClass('not-active').addClass('active'); // add class active to current element instead of class not-active
})
})
</script>
</div>
<input name="submit" id="submitbutton" type="image" value="Search" src="//www.liverpool.ac.uk/files/images/icons/search-white.svg" alt="submit">
</form>Name: courses-search — GET https://www.liverpool.ac.uk/search/?collection=new-main-collection
<form class="clearfix" name="courses-search" id="course-search" method="get" action="https://www.liverpool.ac.uk/search/?collection=new-main-collection">
<fieldset class="course-key-word">
<label for="query-news">
<h2 data-gtm-vis-recent-on-screen480562_746="275" data-gtm-vis-first-on-screen480562_746="275" data-gtm-vis-total-visible-time480562_746="100" data-gtm-vis-has-fired480562_746="1">Search for news</h2>
</label>
<input type="hidden" name="collection" value="new-main-collection">
<input id="query-news" name="query" type="text" placeholder="Find University of Liverpool news stories by keyword">
<input type="hidden" name="f.IsNews|R" value="yes">
</fieldset>
<fieldset class="common-menu-course-search-button">
<input type="submit" name="submit" value="Search">
</fieldset>
</form>Name: courses-search — GET https://www.liverpool.ac.uk/search/?collection=new-main-collection
<form class="clearfix" name="courses-search" id="course-search" method="get" action="https://www.liverpool.ac.uk/search/?collection=new-main-collection">
<fieldset class="course-key-word">
<label for="query-news-mobile">
<h2>Search for news</h2>
</label>
<input type="hidden" name="collection" value="new-main-collection">
<input id="query-news-mobile" name="query" type="text" placeholder="Find University of Liverpool news stories by keyword">
<input type="hidden" name="f.IsNews|R" value="yes">
</fieldset>
<fieldset class="common-menu-course-search-button">
<input type="submit" name="submit" value="Search">
</fieldset>
</form>Name: courses-search — GET https://www.liverpool.ac.uk/search/?collection=new-main-collection
<form class="clearfix" name="courses-search" id="course-search" method="get" action="https://www.liverpool.ac.uk/search/?collection=new-main-collection">
<fieldset class="course-key-word">
<label for="query">
<h2>Search for news</h2>
</label>
<input type="hidden" name="collection" value="new-main-collection">
<input id="query" name="query" type="text" placeholder="Find University of Liverpool news stories by keyword">
<input type="hidden" name="f.IsNews|uol.news=yes">
</fieldset>
<fieldset class="common-menu-course-search-button">
<input type="submit" name="submit" value="Search">
</fieldset>
<input type="hidden" name="as_sfid" value="AAAAAAV_G3918Z9pPWs5i_4d29IgG0-c-5blILxBofZXECCrzamzv-zdGtGtVJf0up5-_LYLdSjkpAcgvwlbSLiIcj0OSWNfnvQJ59l1LLEOer69XQ=="><input type="hidden" name="as_fid" value="rjOKv9il1M2b-0UIP_8W">
</form>Text Content
Menu
* SEARCH
All Courses
* Open submenu (Study with Liverpool)Study with Liverpool
* Open submenu (Our Research)Our Research
* Open submenu (About Us)About Us
* * Sign in
* Staff
* Students
* A-Z
Back to main menuStudy with Liverpool
STUDY WITH LIVERPOOL
* FIND A COURSE
SELECT TYPE
Any level Undergraduate Postgraduate Taught Courses Postgraduate Research
Degrees
OUR COURSES
* All courses
* Undergraduate
* Postgraduate taught
* Postgraduate research
* Continuing education
* Continuing professional development
* International students
* XJTLU mobility
* Online courses
* Paying for your studies
WHY CHOOSE LIVERPOOL?
IT’S AN IMPORTANT QUESTION. AND THERE ARE THOUSANDS OF ANSWERS.
Back to main menuOur Research
OUR RESEARCH
RESEARCH
* Research themes
* A-Z of research groups
* REF 2021
POSTGRADUATE RESEARCH
* PhD degrees
RESEARCH AND BUSINESS COLLABORATION
* Collaborate with us
* Our successes
* Facilities and equipment
RESEARCH WITH REAL WORLD IMPACT
Back to main menuAbout Us
ABOUT US
OUR STORY
* About the University
* Key people
* Accounts and main documents
* Liverpool 2031: Our strategic ambition
* Equality, Diversity and Inclusion
* Sustainability
KEY INFORMATION
* News
* Events
* Departments
* Library
* Alumni
* Sports
* Conferences
* Jobs
* Accommodation
OUR LOCATIONS
* Maps
* Contact us
ADVANCING KNOWLEDGE TO TRANSFORM LIVES
facebooktwitteryoutubeinstagramlinkedin
Skip navigation
COOKIES ON THE UNIVERSITY OF LIVERPOOL WEBSITE
We use cookies to improve your online experience and track performance of our
website. If you continue, we’ll assume that you are happy to receive all
cookies. You can change cookie settings in your browser at any time.
*
* Change cookie settings
* About cookies
Toggle mobile navigation
* Study with Liverpool
WHY CHOOSE LIVERPOOL?
IT’S AN IMPORTANT QUESTION. AND THERE ARE THOUSANDS OF ANSWERS.
STUDY WITH LIVERPOOL
FIND A COURSE
Browse courses by subject area
SEARCH COURSES
SELECT TYPE
Any level Undergraduate Postgraduate Taught Courses Postgraduate Research
Degrees
OUR COURSES
All courses
Undergraduate Postgraduate taught Postgraduate research Continuing education
Continuing professional development International students
XJTLU mobility Online courses Paying for your studies
ABOUT STUDYING WITH US
* Why choose Liverpool?
* International students
* Study in China
* Our research
RESEARCH WITH REAL WORLD IMPACT
OUR RESEARCH
RESEARCH
* Research themes
* A-Z of research groups
* REF 2021
POSTGRADUATE RESEARCH
* PhD degrees
RESEARCH AND BUSINESS COLLABORATION
* Collaborate with us
* Our successes
* Facilities and equipment
* About us
ADVANCING KNOWLEDGE TO TRANSFORM LIVES
ABOUT US
OUR STORY
* About the University
* Key people
* Accounts and main documents
* Liverpool 2031: Our strategic ambition
* Equality, Diversity and Inclusion
* Sustainability
KEY INFORMATION
* News
* Events
* Departments
* Library
* Alumni
* Sports
* Conferences
* Jobs
* Accommodation
OUR LOCATIONS
* Maps
* Contact us
* Search
SEARCH
All
Courses
A-Z
Sign in: Staff/Students
NEWS
SATURDAY, 30 NOVEMBER
SEARCH FOR NEWS
BROWSE NEWS STORIES
* All news
* All opinion
News
menu
SEARCH FOR NEWS
BROWSE NEWS STORIES
* All news
* All opinion
* Published: January 15, 2024
SHARE THIS POST:
* Email
* Facebook
* Twitter
* LinkedIn
SOUTH AFRICA CHALLENGES ISRAEL AT THE INTERNATIONAL COURT OF JUSTICE
This article is written by Michelle Farrell, Professor of International Law in
the School of Law and Social Justice and Jasmin Johurun Nessa, Lecturer in
International Law at Edge Hill University, and a University Teacher at the
University of Liverpool School of Law.
On 29 December 2023, South Africa filed an application instituting proceedings
against Israel before the International Court of Justice (ICJ). South Africa
alleges that Israel’s conduct in Gaza violates its obligations under
the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide by
committing genocide against Palestinians in Gaza, failing to prevent genocide,
and failing to prevent or punish incitement to genocide.
The ICJ and Provisional Measures
The ICJ is the main judicial organ of the United Nations, established to settle
disputes between states. The Court can hear contentious cases – disputes between
two or more states. South Africa v Israel is such a case. It can also provide
advisory opinions, on any international legal question.
On 11 and 12 January, the ICJ held urgent public hearings on South Africa’s
application to the Court to indicate provisional measures. Provisional measures
are interim measures – for example, suspension of military action – that the
applicant state can request, if it considers that “the rights that form the
subject of the application are in immediate danger”. In this case, South Africa
requested that “Israel suspend its military operations in and against Gaza” and
desist from the commission of “genocidal acts” “as a matter of extreme urgency”
to protect Palestinians in Gaza against “further, severe and irreparable harm”.
To indicate provisional measures, the Court must first determine that it has
prima facie jurisdiction. This means the Court must determine that a dispute can
be said to exist between the two states under the Genocide Convention. The Court
must also then establish that at least some of the acts alleged by South Africa
fall within provisions of the Genocide Convention. Are some of the acts alleged
plausibly genocidal? Are the measures requested necessary to protect Palestinian
rights? Those are the kinds of questions now before the Court. These hearings
are a preliminary phase to determine whether provisional measures are warranted.
The Road to the ICJ and the International Reaction
South Africa’s charge of genocide did not come out of the blue. In mid-November,
UN experts called on the international community “to act quickly to prevent
genocide”. International legal experts also expected a state to apply to the ICJ
under the Genocide Convention, a judicial route that could offer some
protection.
The complete siege of Gaza – cutting off food, water, fuel – the evacuation
orders and the bombardment combined with the language of political and military
leaders prompted these fears of an unfolding genocide.
Under the Genocide Convention, states’ obligations are erga omnes, meaning they
are owed to the international community as a whole. It was only a matter of time
before a state would act upon its obligation to prevent genocide. In reaction,
however, Israeli spokesperson, Eylon Levy, decried South Africa’s application as
‘absurd blood libel’. The US, politically and materially supportive of Israel’s
war on Gaza, dismissed the application as meritless. The UK’s response was also
critical but confused. Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs, David Cameron,
said he did not think South Africa’s application was “helpful” nor did he agree
with it or think it was “right”. Cameron said words like genocide, should not be
“bandied” about, as it is for courts not states to define “genocide”.
Numerous states have explicitly welcomed South Africa’s application, including,
Jordan, Turkey, Pakistan and Brazil as well as the Organisation of Islamic
Cooperation (OIC).
What is genocide?
Genocide constitutes certain ‘acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or
in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group, as such’. South Africa
accuses Israel of killing Palestinians in Gaza, causing them serious bodily and
mental harm, inflicting on them conditions of life calculated to bring about
their physical destruction and imposing measures intended to prevent Palestinian
births.
South Africa contextualises these acts within the “broader context of Israel’s
conduct towards Palestinians during its 75-year-long apartheid, its 56-yearlong
belligerent occupation of Palestinian territory and its 16-year-long blockade of
Gaza”. But the focus of this application is Israel’s specific intent, during the
current operation, “to destroy Palestinians in Gaza as a part of the broader
Palestinian national, racial and ethnical group”.
Much of the controversy surrounding South Africa’s application stems from the
weight of the crime of genocide. The Genocide Convention embodies the promise
“never again”, a commitment made as a direct result of the Holocaust. Irish
Taoiseach, Leo Varadkar, reflected the controversy of “accusing Israel, a
Jewish state, of genocide, given the fact that six million Jews – over half the
population of Jews in Europe – were killed”. Genocide, for Varadkar, must be
used carefully, when “absolutely convinced”. But this conflicts with the
obligation to prevent genocide.
South Africa acknowledged how fraught this “crime of crimes” is, observing, they
are “acutely aware of the particular weight of responsibility in initiating
proceedings against Israel for violations of the Genocide Convention”.
Law mirrors the sensitivity towards the crime of genocide; states deliberately
made genocide an extremely difficult crime to establish. The dolus specialis or
specific intent to destroy a group, in whole or in part, requires proving that
the perpetrator intended to target individuals precisely because of their group
membership. The ICJ has interpreted this requirement rigidly.
What’s next?
The significance of the current proceedings lie in their potential to bring some
immediate relief to the Palestinians in Gaza. Given the humanitarian situation,
the Court is likely to reach its decision quickly. Germany’s recent announcement
that it rejects the genocide accusation and will intervene as a third party in
the ICJ proceedings indicates a belief that provisional measures are pending. If
that is the case, political pressure will be crucial. Whilst states are legally
required to comply with the Court’s decision, non-compliance is common. Prime
Minister, Benjamin Netanyahu has already indicated non-compliance, in a thread
on X.
The ICJ is not yet tasked with determining whether Israel’s conduct in Gaza
violates the Genocide Convention. Assuming the case proceeds, Israel may raise
preliminary objections challenging the Court’s competence to decide on the
jurisdiction and substance of the case. If the case reaches the merits phase –
where issues of substance are decided – the Court will conduct public hearings
before ultimately determining whether Israel’s actions have violated the
Convention. That decision could take years.
Irrespective of what happens at the ICJ in the weeks and years to come,
political inaction to prevent further catastrophe in Gaza is unthinkable.
CATEGORY
* Comment
* Expert Opinion
TAGS
* Faculty of Humanities & Social Sciences
* Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences
* School of Law
* School of Law and Social Justice
CATEGORIES
* News
* Expert Opinion
* Comment
* The Conversation
* The Liverpool View
* Becoming an expert
* Postcard
* Staff News
FOR MEDIA
* Press Office Contacts
* Press release archive
LATEST NEWS
All recent news
Christmas comes to The Spine with four events this December
Liverpool and Manchester universities pledge closer ties to power the North West
economy
Captain Tom Foundation report is a welcome reminder that charity is supposed to
be solely for the public good
Government suspends implementation of HE Freedom of Speech Act
Liverpool’s dementia forum travels to Australia
SOCIAL MEDIA
* facebook Facebook
* Twitter Twitter
* youtube Youtube
* instagram Instagram
PRESS RELEASE ARCHIVE
* 2024
* 2023
* 2022
* 2021
* 2020
* 2019
* 2018
* 2017
* 2016
* 2015
SEARCH FOR NEWS
BROWSE NEWS STORIES
* All news
* All opinion
NEWSLETTER
* Sign up
The Original Red Brick
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
University of Liverpool
Liverpool
L69 3BX
* Liverpool city centre campus map
* Find us
* +44 (0)151 794 2000
* All contact details
* Call us
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
* University of Liverpool – a member of the Russell Group
* Terms and Conditions
* Modern slavery statement
* Accessibility
* Facebook
* Twitter
* Youtube
* Instagram
* Linkedin