www.theguardian.com Open in urlscan Pro
2a04:4e42:600::367  Public Scan

Form analysis
1 forms found in the DOM

https://www.google.co.uk/search

<form action="https://www.google.co.uk/search" class="dcr-g8v7m4"><label for="src-component-9501" class="dcr-0">
    <div class="dcr-16c0nhc">Search input </div>
  </label><input type="text" id="src-component-9501" aria-required="true" aria-invalid="false" aria-describedby="" required="" name="q" placeholder="Search" data-link-name="nav2 : search" tabindex="-1" class="selectableMenuItem dcr-1ea5ded"><label
    class="dcr-0">
    <div class="dcr-16c0nhc">google-search </div>
    <div class="dcr-190ztmi"><svg width="30" viewBox="-3 -3 30 30" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" aria-hidden="true">
        <path fill-rule="evenodd" clip-rule="evenodd"
          d="M9.273 2c4.023 0 7.25 3.295 7.25 7.273a7.226 7.226 0 0 1-7.25 7.25C5.25 16.523 2 13.296 2 9.273 2 5.295 5.25 2 9.273 2Zm0 1.84A5.403 5.403 0 0 0 3.84 9.274c0 3 2.409 5.454 5.432 5.454 3 0 5.454-2.454 5.454-5.454 0-3.023-2.454-5.432-5.454-5.432Zm7.295 10.887L22 20.16 20.16 22l-5.433-5.432v-.932l.91-.909h.931Z">
        </path>
      </svg><span class="dcr-1p0hins">Search</span></div>
  </label><button type="submit" aria-live="polite" aria-label="Search with Google" data-link-name="nav2 : search : submit" tabindex="-1" class="dcr-v4dfgf">
    <div class="src-button-space"></div><svg width="30" viewBox="-3 -3 30 30" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" aria-hidden="true">
      <path fill-rule="evenodd" clip-rule="evenodd" d="M1 12.956h18.274l-7.167 8.575.932.932L23 12.478v-.956l-9.96-9.985-.932.932 7.166 8.575H1v1.912Z"></path>
    </svg>
  </button><input type="hidden" name="as_sitesearch" value="www.theguardian.com"></form>

Text Content

Skip to main contentSkip to navigation
Close dialogue1/1Next imagePrevious imageToggle caption
Skip to navigation
Print subscriptions
Sign in
Search jobs
Search
Europe edition
 * Europe edition
 * UK edition
 * US edition
 * Australia edition
 * International edition

The Guardian - Back to homeThe Guardian


SUPPORT THE GUARDIAN

Fund independent journalism with €10 per month
Support us

Support us
 * News
 * Opinion
 * Sport
 * Culture
 * Lifestyle

ShowMoreShow More
 * News
   * View all News
   * World news
   * UK news
   * Climate crisis
   * Ukraine
   * Environment
   * Science
   * Global development
   * Football
   * Tech
   * Business
   * Obituaries
   
 * Opinion
   * View all Opinion
   * The Guardian view
   * Columnists
   * Cartoons
   * Opinion videos
   * Letters
   
 * Sport
   * View all Sport
   * Football
   * Cricket
   * Rugby union
   * Tennis
   * Cycling
   * F1
   * Golf
   * US sports
   
 * Culture
   * View all Culture
   * Books
   * Music
   * TV & radio
   * Art & design
   * Film
   * Games
   * Classical
   * Stage
   
 * Lifestyle
   * View all Lifestyle
   * Fashion
   * Food
   * Recipes
   * Love & sex
   * Health & fitness
   * Home & garden
   * Women
   * Men
   * Family
   * Travel
   * Money
 * Search input
   google-search
   Search
   
   
    * Support us
    * Print subscriptions

   Europe edition
   * UK edition
   * US edition
   * Australia edition
   * International edition
   
 * * Search jobs
   * Holidays
   * Digital Archive
   * Guardian Licensing
   * About Us
   * The Guardian app
   * Video
   * Podcasts
   * Pictures
   * Newsletters
   * Today's paper
   * Inside the Guardian
   * The Observer
   * Guardian Weekly
   * Crosswords
   * Wordiply
   * Corrections
 * * Search jobs
   * Holidays
   * Digital Archive
   * Guardian Licensing
   * About Us

 * World
 * Europe
 * US
 * Americas
 * Asia
 * Australia
 * Middle East
 * Africa
 * Inequality
 * Global development



A knife attack at the Assyrian Christ The Good Shepherd church in Sydney was
quickly designated as a terror incident, while a similar attack at Bondi
Junction two days earlier was not. Photograph: Jaimi Joy/Reuters
View image in fullscreen
A knife attack at the Assyrian Christ The Good Shepherd church in Sydney was
quickly designated as a terror incident, while a similar attack at Bondi
Junction two days earlier was not. Photograph: Jaimi Joy/Reuters
Australian police and policing

Explainer


SYDNEY IS REELING FROM TWO HIGH-PROFILE STABBING ATTACKS – WHY WAS ONLY ONE
DEEMED A TERROR INCIDENT?

Incidents at a Bondi Junction mall and at a Wakeley church have seen very
different responses from police

 * Get our morning and afternoon news emails, free app or daily news podcast


Josh Butler and Mostafa Rachwani
Wed 17 Apr 2024 11.20 CESTLast modified on Thu 18 Apr 2024 00.35 CEST
Share



Two high-profile knife attacks in three days have left many in Sydney and across
the country in a state of shock and alarm. The two separate incidents, at a
shopping centre in Bondi Junction and a church in Wakeley, have seen different
responses from police and politicians.

So why are police treating the Wakeley incident as a terror attack, while the
Bondi Junction attack – which killed six people – was quickly ruled out as such?


Sydney church stabbing: how an alleged attack on a firebrand preacher reignited
tensions
Read more

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------


WHY WAS THE CHURCH EVENT DESIGNATED AS TERRORISM?

New South Wales police on Tuesday declared the Wakeley stabbing, where Bishop
Mar Mari Emmanuel and several worshippers were injured at the Assyrian Christ
the Good Shepherd church, as a terror incident. A joint counterterror
investigation, Strike Force Petrina, was set up.

Saturday’s stabbing at Bondi Junction’s Westfield was ruled out as a terror
incident. The federal police commissioner, Reece Kershaw, on Saturday night said
agencies were “working together to make that assessment” but that at the time it
was “too early” to make that call.

The federal attorney general’s department defines a terrorist act as an act
which “intends to coerce or influence the public or any government by
intimidation to advance a political, religious or ideological cause”; and also
causes death, injury or danger to a person, damage to property, risk to public
health, or interference with critical infrastructure.

While both Sydney stabbings may have caused fear, initial information from
police suggests different goals, according to Prof Greg Barton, a terrorism
expert.

“It’s about motivation and whether someone wants to change the system; a broad
political view, rather than personal animus,” the Deakin University security
academic said.

In video of the alleged perpetrator of the Wakeley stabbing, he can be heard
saying: “If he [the bishop] didn’t get himself involved in my religion, if he
hadn’t spoken about my prophet, I wouldn’t have come here.”

Lydia Khalil, a research fellow and counter-terror expert at the Lowy Institute,
said classification as a terror incident “centres around motivation”.

“Since security agencies [allege they] have evidence of a motive, and it relates
to an ideological or religious or political objective, based on the
Australian legal definition, this is terrorism,” she said.

“It’s not only defined by how it impacts on the community as many types of
crimes can scare or terrorise.”

The NSW premier, Chris Minns, on Wednesday said declaring the Wakeley stabbing a
terrorist attack was “necessary” and not a “performative gesture”.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------


DOES THAT MEAN THE 16-YEAR-OLD WILL BE CHARGED WITH TERRORISM OFFENCES?

The NSW police commissioner, Karen Webb, said declaring a terrorist incident and
the potential for laying terrorism-related charges “shouldn’t be conflated”.

Webb said it would be “premature” to speculate on whether the alleged offender
had been radicalised online.

“The investigation will delve into his history, his background and that will
form part of what was on that individual’s mind,” she said.

 * Sign up for Guardian Australia’s free morning and afternoon email newsletters
   for your daily news roundup

Barton said the designation of a terror incident helped “unleash” certain
policing and investigative resources, but didn’t necessarily obligate laying of
terrorism charges.

“With a young person you might come to the conclusion that it was terrorism but
it’s someone who was manipulated or fell into the wrong company, so maybe the
best thing to do for their future is some other kind of sentencing,” he said,
speaking generally.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------


WHAT INVESTIGATIVE POWERS DOES A TERROR DESIGNATION UNLOCK?

Minns said Webb deemed it necessary to declare the incident a terrorist attack
in order to “unlock” special investigatory powers – a decision supported by
federal authorities.

Kershaw said the counterterror investigation would include the AFP, NSW police
and Asio, who would “investigate this incident from all angles.”

“Our job is also to look at individuals connected with the [alleged] attacker,
to assure ourselves that there is no one else in the community with similar
intent,” said Asio’s director general, Mike Burgess, adding there were currently
“no indications of that”.

Bondi Junction mass stabbing attack: who are the six victims?
Read more

Barton said the declaration could see the activation of specific powers, such as
control or detention orders, or wider powers to stop and search suspects
depending on the jurisdiction. In NSW, police powers laws around terror offences
allow officers to stop and search a person, their possessions, vehicle or
premises without a warrant.

“To get through someone’s social media postings, you might need a team of 10
working 50 hours a week. When the switch is flicked, you can have those
resources.”

“If it’s just one person acting with animus, maybe the risk stops. But if it’s
terror, there might be social networks, international networks, so you’re better
off investing now to find it.”

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------


WHY WASN’T THE BONDI JUNCTION ATTACK DESIGNATED AS TERRORISM?

Asked about the two stabbing incidents, Asio’s Burgess explained why authorities
made different judgments.

“To call it a terrorist attack you need indications of information or evidence
that suggests actually the motivation was religiously motivated or ideologically
motivated,” he said.

“In the case of [Bondi Junction], that was not the case.”

Saturday’s stabbing attack, which left six dead and a dozen in hospital
including a baby, caused obvious terror in the community – but based on what we
know now, Khalil and Barton backed the decision to not classify it as terrorism.

“There’s the impression the attacker went after women. But this fact alone does
not make it a terror attack,” Khalil said.

Khalil said it was unclear at this stage how or why Joel Cauchi selected his
victims, but noted the man’s father described his son as “frustrated” that he
could not get a girlfriend.


Floral tributes at Westfield Bondi Junction shopping centre. Photograph: Steven
Saphore/AAP

“However, misogyny or grievances motivate all sorts of violence against women.
There is no evidence at this stage he was an ‘incel’ or had ideological views
around the role of women,” she said. “Unless authorities unearth such evidence,
we can’t label it as that [terror].”

Barton said indications were that Cauchi lived with mental health issues, while
also noting his father’s comments.

“The fact he’s deceased makes it harder to know what he was thinking on the day.
But they’ve found his identity, online posts, looked at any political
motivations. Sometimes [a terror offender] will post a manifesto or brief
statement – none of that was evident.”

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------


WHAT CRITICISMS ARE BEING MADE ABOUT THE DECISION TO DESIGNATE THE CHURCH ATTACK
AS A TERRORISM?

Dai Le, the local federal MP whose electorate includes Wakeley, warned the
terrorism declaration could heighten tensions.

“It’s just going to add to it … I hope that the premier and the police
commissioner know what they’re doing,” she told Today.

Rita Jabri Markwell, a spokesperson for the Australian Muslim Advocacy Network
(Aman), said labelling the church stabbing a terror incident had become an
inflammatory decision in the Muslim community.

The Islamic Council of NSW “found it bewildering” Saturday’s attack at Bondi
Junction was deemed to be “exclusively motivated by the mental health issues”
but the church stabbing “was designated as a terrorist act within hours.”

“The signal this sends to the Australian community is that terrorism is solely
reserved for Muslims.”

Khalil said she understood the concerns raised by some within the Muslim
community about impacts on social cohesion, but backed the terror declaration.

“If something is motivated by Islamic ideology we’re very quick to deem it a
terror attack in the media. In contrast, attacks by far-right actors have not
been as quick to be label[ed] as such. There’s a understandable concern about
stigmatisation from the community, but from a legal perspective, it’s pretty
straightforward,” she said.

Barton concurred.

“Police recognise once you attach ‘terrorism’ to something, it comes with stigma
and communities don’t like it … They’ve learned to not shoot from the hip, they
won’t talk about Islamic extremism until [they’re] absolutely sure and
necessary.”

Explore more on these topics
 * Australian police and policing
 * Sydney
 * New South Wales
 * Bondi Junction stabbings
 * explainers

Share

Reuse this content





MOST VIEWED


MOST VIEWED



 * World
 * Europe
 * US
 * Americas
 * Asia
 * Australia
 * Middle East
 * Africa
 * Inequality
 * Global development

 * News
 * Opinion
 * Sport
 * Culture
 * Lifestyle

Original reporting and incisive analysis, direct from the Guardian every morning
Sign up for our email

 * Help
 * Complaints & corrections
 * SecureDrop
 * Work for us
 *  
 * Privacy policy
 * Cookie policy
 * Terms & conditions
 * Contact us

 * All topics
 * All writers
 * Digital newspaper archive
 * Facebook
 * YouTube
 * Instagram
 * LinkedIn
 * Twitter
 * Newsletters

 * Advertise with us
 * Search UK jobs


Back to top
© 2024 Guardian News & Media Limited or its affiliated companies. All rights
reserved. (dcr)