m.independent.ie Open in urlscan Pro
2606:4700:4400::ac40:9b4c  Public Scan

URL: https://m.independent.ie/opinion/editorial/editorial-public-tolerance-of-immigration-is-waning/a44120254.html
Submission: On May 05 via manual from US — Scanned from US

Form analysis 1 forms found in the DOM

/search

<form class="indo-118f5aad_displayblock indo-4bb60769_marginbottom5 indo-4bb60769_marginleft5 indo-4bb60769_marginright5 indo-4bb60769_margintop5" data-testid="mobile-search-form" action="/search">
  <div>
    <div class="indo-702a40c0_root indo-118f5aad_displayinlineflex indo-6acd8451_wfull indo-23b4ab44_root indo-4bb60769_marginbottom3 indo-48c9407e_hidden" style="--align-items:center"><label
        class="indo-958a0785_root indo-958a0785_heading6 indo-da27be32_system indo-140c7d04_medium indo-d44a08fb_root" for="icon-left" id="icon-left-label"><span class="indo-4bb60769_marginright1">Search for articles</span></label></div>
    <div class="indo-34011dce_root"><input type="text" aria-labelledby="icon-left-label" aria-invalid="false" aria-required="true" class="indo-34011dce_field indo-34011dce_fieldiconleft" id="icon-left" name="keyword" required=""
        placeholder="Enter your search item" value=""><svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" viewBox="0 0 24 24" class="indo-8ef7b9d3_root indo-8ef7b9d3_medium indo-34011dce_icon indo-34011dce_iconleftcontainer" style="flex:0 0 auto">
        <path d="M15.657 4.343A8 8 0 114.343 15.657 8 8 0 0115.657 4.343zm-.707.707a7 7 0 10-9.9 9.9 7 7 0 009.9-9.9zm6.9 16.1a.491.491 0 010 .7.491.491 0 01-.7 0l-5.847-5.84.707-.707 5.84 5.847z"></path>
      </svg></div>
  </div>
</form>

Text Content

account arrow-left arrow-long-left arrow-right-long arrow-right blockquote
bookmark-circle-saved bookmark-circle bookmark-outline
bookmark-savedbookmarkcamera-new camera caret checkmark chevron-down
chevron-upclock close cog external facebook-brand MGL-f filter font-size
geargears-animated instagram iphone Page-1 lock logoff mail mijnzone-account
Slice 1Created with Sketch. nav-hamburger nieuws noresults ntm paco-arrow
personalization-add personalization-closepersonalization-remove quote refresh
regio remove reorder search selection star-outline star support-briefcase
support-customer support-message support-question support-truck switch tag-add
tag-remove tagaction-addtagaction-checktaglabeltransfer twitter unibetuser video
whatsapp

COOKIES AND DATA PROCESSING ON THE IRISH INDEPENDENT


Mediahuis (‘we’) and partners use technologies such as cookies to store and
access (personal) data – online identifiers (e.g., IP address, sign-in ID),
non-precise location and information about your browser, operating system,
device as well as insights into your use of this domain – on your device for the
following purposes:

 * Advertising and content measurement, audience insights and product
   development;
 * Personalised content;
 * Personalised ads; and
 * Social media.



If you allow such use, click "Agree and close". If you do not want to allow all
purposes, select "Learn More". You can change your preferences at any time in
your privacy settings. We will share your privacy preferences – for which
purposes and partners you provided consent - with our partners.

Would you like more explanation about our use of your data? Read our privacy
policy and cookie policy. More information on the use of your data by our
partners you find here.



View our 200 partners
ManageAccept

Consent


Subscribe

Search for articles

 * 
   News
   * 
     Overview
   * 
     Irish News
     * 
       Overview
     * 
       Politics
     * 
       Education
     * 
       Health
     * 
       Courts
     * 
       Crime
     * 
       Environment
     * 
       Seachtain
   * 
     Dublin
   * 
     Local News
     * 
       Overview
     * 
       Select your county
     * 
       Local ePapers
   * 
     World
     * 
       Overview
     * 
       Europe
     * 
       Britain
     * 
       North America
     * 
       Latin America
     * 
       Middle East
     * 
       Asia-Pacific
     * 
       Australasia
     * 
       Africa
   * 
     Farming
     * 
       Overview
     * 
       News
     * 
       Agri-business
     * 
       Dairy
     * 
       Tillage
     * 
       Beef
     * 
       Sheep
     * 
       Farm Property
     * 
       Machinery
     * 
       Legal Advice
     * 
       Comment
     * 
       Rural Life
     * 
       Schemes
     * 
       Finance
   * 
     Latest News
   * 
     Subscriber Exclusives
   * 
     Podcasts
     * 
       Overview
     * 
       The Indo Daily
     * 
       The Left Wing
     * 
       The Big Tech Show
     * 
       Real Health Podcast
     * 
       The Throw-In
     * 
       Seachtain Podcast
 * 
   Opinion
   * 
     Overview
   * 
     Letters
   * 
     Editorial
   * 
     Analysis
   * 
     Comment
 * 
   Business
   * 
     Overview
   * 
     Irish
   * 
     World
   * 
     Technology
   * 
     Personal Finance
   * 
     Small Business
   * 
     Jobs
   * 
     Commercial Property
   * 
     In The Workplace
 * 
   Sport
   * 
     Overview
   * 
     Rugby
     * 
       Overview
     * 
       The Left Wing
     * 
       Champions Cup
     * 
       United Rugby Championship
     * 
       Six Nations
     * 
       Leinster Rugby
     * 
       Munster Rugby
     * 
       Ulster Rugby
     * 
       Connacht Rugby
   * 
     GAA
     * 
       Overview
     * 
       Gaelic Football
     * 
       Hurling
     * 
       The Throw In
     * 
       U-20 Gaelic Football
     * 
       U-20 Hurling
     * 
       Camogie
     * 
       Ladies Football
   * 
     Soccer
     * 
       Overview
     * 
       Premier League
     * 
       International Soccer
     * 
       Champions League
     * 
       League of Ireland
     * 
       Other Soccer
   * 
     Olympics
   * 
     The Left Wing
   * 
     Women's Sport
   * 
     Golf
   * 
     Horse Racing
   * 
     Other Sports
     * 
       Overview
     * 
       Cricket
     * 
       Cycling
     * 
       Hockey
     * 
       Athletics
     * 
       Boxing
     * 
       Equestrian
     * 
       Motor Sport
     * 
       Snooker
     * 
       Swimming
     * 
       Tennis
 * 
   Life
   * 
     Overview
   * 
     Health & Wellbeing
     * 
       Overview
     * 
       Health Features
     * 
       Healthy Eating
     * 
       Fitness
     * 
       Mental Health
     * 
       Baby Loss
   * 
     Home & Garden
     * 
       Overview
     * 
       Homes
     * 
       New Homes
     * 
       Gardens
     * 
       Interiors
   * 
     Family
     * 
       Overview
     * 
       Family Features
     * 
       Learning
     * 
       Parenting
     * 
       Mothers & Babies
   * 
     Parenting
   * 
     Food & Drink
     * 
       Overview
     * 
       Recipes
     * 
       Food News
     * 
       Food Reviews
     * 
       Wine
   * 
     Motoring
     * 
       Overview
     * 
       News
     * 
       Reviews
     * 
       Car Talk
 * 
   Style
   * 
     Overview
   * 
     Celebrity
     * 
       Overview
     * 
       Celebrity News
     * 
       Celebrity Features
   * 
     Fashion
     * 
       Overview
     * 
       Fashion News
     * 
       Fashion Fix
     * 
       Style Talk
   * 
     Beauty
     * 
       Overview
     * 
       Body
     * 
       Hair
     * 
       Makeup
   * 
     Sex & Relationships
 * 
   Entertainment
   * 
     Overview
   * 
     Movies
     * 
       Overview
     * 
       Movie News
     * 
       Movie Reviews
   * 
     Television
     * 
       Overview
     * 
       TV News
     * 
       TV Reviews
   * 
     Music
     * 
       Overview
     * 
       Music News
     * 
       Music Reviews
   * 
     Radio
   * 
     Books
     * 
       Overview
     * 
       Book News
     * 
       Book Reviews
   * 
     Theatre & Arts
   * 
     Games
   * 
     Festivals
   * 
     Puzzles
   * 
     Competitions
 * 
   Travel
   * 
     Overview
   * 
     Reader Travel Awards
   * 
     Travel News
   * 
     Staycations
   * 
     Ireland
   * 
     Reviews
   * 
     Walks
   * 
     Europe
   * 
     World/USA
   * 
     Cruise
   * 
     Ski
 * 
   Video

Extra
 * 
   ePaper
 * 
   Puzzles
 * 
   Our Journalism
 * 
   Our Story
 * 
   Contact Us
 * 
   Subscribe

 1. Editorial


EDITORIAL: PUBLIC TOLERANCE OF IMMIGRATION IS WANING

Workers remove 'tent city' in Mount Street, Dublin, last week. Photo: Steve
Humphreys

Editorial
Today at 15:30
 * 
 * 
 * 
 * 



At the end of an extraordinary week that saw Ireland and Britain embroiled in an
unseemly political and diplomatic argument over rising levels of immigration,
both governments would be well advised to tone down the rhetoric and reset
relations to something approximating normality. Today’s Sunday
Independent/Ireland Thinks opinion poll lays bare the impact of last week’s row
on the attitude of voters here — and it shows those attitudes to have hardened
considerably in relation to immigration.

After a week when the Irish Government eff­ected the removal of migrants from a
makeshift campsite on the pavements and alleys in and around Mount Street,
Dublin, and following Justice Minister Helen McEntee’s claim that around 80pc of
migrants are arriving here from Britain via Northern Ireland, the poll finds a
significant 15-point increase in public concern about this issue.

The consequences look set to become apparent when the public votes in local and
European elections that are predicted to result in a rightward swing to
candidates presenting a firm line on immigration here and throughout the
continent of Europe. Politics will probably look very different after the
elections on June 11 and 12. Foreign Affairs Minister Micheál Martin has
referred to work the Government has to do to explain the complexities of
immigration to the public. That is one of the failures of this administration,
which is struggling with the hugely difficult task of managing an ever-growing
crisis.

Today’s poll indicates the extent of the communications shortcomings, which can
be set alongside a shortage of accommodation for asylum-seekers and a lack of
early preparedness at the International Protection Office in Dublin to meet the
challenge.

Among other poll findings is overwhelming support to send immigrants back to the
UK, the setting up of checkpoints at the Border and the introduction here of a
“Rwanda-style” policy, similar to that in the UK, to deter immigrants from
coming here.

The Government has ruled out checkpoints, and Ireland and the EU are opposed to
a Rwanda-style policy, favouring instead Europe’s new migration and asylum pact,
but that is somewhat lost on the public, a growing number of whom are demanding
immediate and increasingly strident action. If anything, there is a high level
of confusion about the migration pact — ­another failure of government
communication.




The Common Travel Area, which ensures the free movement of people between the UK
and Ireland, is the arrangement by which both governments must resolve the
issues that have arisen; wider still, agreement will have to be reached between
the UK and the EU on immigration in which Ireland will have an important role to
play.

Whether such agreements can be reached before a general election in the UK this
autumn is unlikely; it may well fall to a future Labour government there to
negotiate an agreed solution with Ireland, either before or after a general
election here.

A resolution must be found, however, because as today’s poll shows, immigration
as an issue is increasing in intensity and is sure to have a significant impact
on the outcome of elections local, national and European over the next 12
months, almost certainly for the worse.



Join the Irish Independent WhatsApp channel

Stay up to date with all the latest news


 * 
 * 
 * 
 * 


RELATED TOPICS

 * Immigration
 * Helen McEntee
 * Northern Ireland
 * Micheál Martin
 * EU

Promoted Links
Recommended by






MORE EDITORIAL

 * Editorial
   
   EDITORIAL: PUBLIC TOLERANCE OF IMMIGRATION IS WANING
   
   
 * Editorial
   
   EDITORIAL: POLITICIANS AND MIGRANTS SHOULD BE ABLE TO LIVE WITHOUT FEAR
   
   
 * Editorial
   
   EDITORIAL: CONCERTED EFFORTS ARE NEEDED TO ADDRESS PROBLEMS AT UNIVERSITY
   HOSPITAL LIMERICK
   
   
 * Editorial
   
   EDITORIAL: ‘TENT CITY’ SHAMBLES A SHAMEFUL EXERCISE IN KICKING THE CAN DOWN
   THE ROAD ON IMMIGRATION
   
   
 * Editorial
   
   EDITORIAL: WITH LIVES AT STAKE, BRITISH PRIME MINISTER RISHI SUNAK CANNOT
   SLAM THE DOOR ON EU AMID MIGRATION CRISIS
   
   
 * Editorial
   
   EDITORIAL: DIALOGUE WITH BRITAIN IS THE BEST ROUTE TO SOLVING THE IMMIGRATION
   CHAOS THAT IRELAND IS NOW FACING
   
   
 * Editorial
   
   EDITORIAL: STATE MUST AGAIN FACE DOWN THREATS TO OUR DEMOCRACY
   
   
 * Editorial
   
   EDITORIAL: IMMIGRATION CRISIS IS GETTING HARDER TO MANAGE
   
   
 * Editorial
   
   EDITORIAL: POLITICAL FAILURES ON IMMIGRATION MUST BE SOLVED WITH COMPASSION
   
   
 * Editorial
   
   EDITORIAL: LACK OF ENFORCEMENT ON OUR ROADS MUST BE DEALT WITH BY MINISTERS
   
   


TOP STORIES

 * Politics
   
   EXCLUSIVE | SINN FÉIN SUPPORT RISES AS PARTY HARDENS STANCE ON IMMIGRATION

 * Irish News
   
   YOUNG WOMAN DIES AFTER FALLING AT THE CLIFFS OF MOHER
   
   
 * Leinster Rugby
   
   BRENDAN FANNING: LEINSTER’S LATE FRIGHT GIVES LEO CULLEN CONCERNS FOR FINAL
   TILT
   
   
 * Sex & Relationships
   
   ASKING FOR A FRIEND: I’M IN A SITUATIONSHIP WITH A GUY BUT I’VE CAUGHT
   FEELINGS AND WANT US TO BE EXCLUSIVE AND HE DOESN’T. WILL HE CHANGE HIS MIND?
   
   
 * Irish News
   
   TRINITY STUDENT PRESIDENT: WHY I’M RISKING MY €20,000-A-YEAR EDUCATION TO
   PROTEST AS BOOK OF KELLS IS BARRICADED ‘INDEFINITELY’
   
   
 * Comment
   
   EILIS O’HANLON: BLAMING THE BRITS WON’T SOLVE OUR MIGRANT CRISIS
   
   
 * Books
   
   ‘AS A TEENAGER, I HAD A LOT OF LOVE TO GIVE TO THOSE KIDS’ – WHAT IT’S LIKE
   TO GROW UP WITH 50 FOSTER SIBLINGS
   
   
 * Irish News
   
   ‘I HAVE LOST TOO MANY PEOPLE...MY HEART IS FULL OF GRIEF’ – ZAK HANIA
   REUNITED WITH FAMILY IN DUBLIN AFTER RAFAH ESCAPE
   
   
 * Hurling
   
   DAVY FITZGERALD: ‘I DON’T BLAME THEM OR THE REFEREE, BUT WE SHOULD HAVE
   FINISHED THAT GAME. I AM EXTREMELY PROUD OF THE LADS’
   
   
 * Personal Finance
   
   TEACHING KIDS HOW TO MANAGE THEIR COMMUNION MONEY IS A KEY LIFE LESSON
   
   


LATEST NEWS

 * Comment
   
   MICHAEL MCNAMARA: HOW DID SEX OFFENDER SEEKING ASYLUM FLY UNDER THE RADAR?
   
   Today at 15:30
   
 * Editorial
   
   EDITORIAL: PUBLIC TOLERANCE OF IMMIGRATION IS WANING
   
   Today at 15:30
   
 * Business
   
   UK REVIEW OF WASTE-TO-ENERGY PLANTS A ‘SIGNIFICANT RISK’ TO SOLAR 21 PLAN
   VIABILITY, SAYS RENEWABLES FIRM
   
   Today at 15:30
   
 * Irish Business
   
   DRUMSHANBO DISTILLERY OWNER WARNS OF GLOBAL DRINK MARKET SLOWDOWN
   
   Today at 15:30
   
 * Opinion
   
   MÁIRÍA CAHILL: MATTIE MCGRATH HAS A DUTY TO REDUCE TENSION, NOT INFLAME IT
   
   Today at 15:30
   
 * Sport
   
   IRISH SPORTS MARKETING AGENCY SPORT ENDORSE TARGETS POTENTIALLY HIGHLY
   LUCRATIVE US COLLEGE ATHLETE BASE
   
   Today at 15:30
   
 * Politics
   
   REPORT QUERIES €4M PAID TO TOP-UP SALARIES OF 760 RTÉ STAFF
   
   Today at 15:30
   
 * Book News
   
   LUCY CALDWELL: ‘I LOVE THE COMFORT OF A GENERATIONAL SAGA – THEY TAKE ME BACK
   TO FAMILY HOLIDAYS DRIVING THROUGH IRELAND’
   
   Today at 15:30
   
 * Business
   
   HOW IRELAND BECAME A LEADER IN LIFE SCIENCES, AND HOW WE PLAN TO STAY IN
   FRONT
   
   Today at 15:30
   
 * Interiors
   
   MY FAVOURITE ROOM: “THE MAN WHO CAME TO PAINT THE KITCHEN SAID ‘IT’S AN
   ABSOLUTE SIN.’ I SAID ‘I WON’T BE GOING TO CONFESSION’ – THE TANNERY'S MÁIRE
   FLYNN
   
   Today at 15:30
   

Show more


🎧 THE INDO DAILY

 * THE INDO DAILY: MICHAEL STONE – THE LIFE AND CRIMES OF THE NOTORIOUS GUNMAN
   OF THE TROUBLES

More Episodes




Follow us:

 * Sitemap
 * Archive
 * Terms & conditions
 * Contact us
 * Privacy statement
 * Cookie Policy
 * Group Websites
 * Advertise with Us
 * Subscription Bundles
 * Subscription Rewards
 * Subscription Puzzles
 * FAQ's
 * ePapers
 * Newsletters