news.yahoo.com Open in urlscan Pro
2001:4998:124:1507::a000  Public Scan

Submitted URL: https://news.yahoo.com/amphtml/one-dobbs-california-abortion-privacy-110000041.html
Effective URL: https://news.yahoo.com/one-dobbs-california-abortion-privacy-110000041.html
Submission: On June 29 via manual from US — Scanned from US

Form analysis 1 forms found in the DOM

Name: ybar_mod_searchbox_sGET https://search.yahoo.com/search

<form class="_yb_2fvsw  _yb_1h4bc  _yb_1wg9j   ybar-voice-search " method="get" name="ybar_mod_searchbox_s" id="ybar-sf" role="search" action="https://search.yahoo.com/search" accept-charset="utf-8" data-appid="news" data-pubid=""
  data-sacrumb="hWO8PONfFKS" data-sabcrumb="GPIdOOpQIYa" data-sabase="https://search.yahoo.com/sugg/gossip/gossip-us-ura/" data-fastbreak="https://search.yahoo.com/sugg/gossip/gossip-us-fastbreak/" data-saenabled="true" data-saversion="1"
  data-textshown="new suggestions shown" data-textclosed="Suggestion box closed"> <label for="ybar-sbq" class="_yb_19bj4">Search query</label><input type="text" class="_yb_8vhmz " id="ybar-sbq" name="p" style="" value="" autocomplete="off"
    required="" placeholder="" autofocus="" role="combobox" aria-autocomplete="both" aria-expanded="false" data-rapid_p="14" data-v9y="1">
  <div class="_yb_1fwae">
    <div class="_yb_1atlj _yb_1wu62"></div>
  </div>
  <div class="_yb_1ytfr"><button id="ybar-sbq-x" type="button" aria-label="Clear Search" class="_yb_1dx1m _yb_lynlz" data-ylk="sec:yb_search;subsec:assist;slk:clear;itc:1;" data-rapid_p="15" data-v9y="0"> <span class="_yb_e903x"><svg width="16"
          height="16" fill="none" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" transform="translate(0 4)">
          <path d="M8 7.059 4.468 3.527a.667.667 0 0 0-.941.941L7.058 8l-3.531 3.531a.667.667 0 0 0 .94.942L8 8.94l3.532 3.532a.666.666 0 0 0 .94-.942L8.941 8l3.531-3.532a.666.666 0 0 0-.94-.941L8 7.059z" fill="#232A31"></path>
        </svg></span> </button><button id="ybar-sbq-voice" type="button" aria-label="Search with voice" class="_yb_1dx1m _yb_60jdq" data-ylk="sec:ybar;slk:websrch;subsec:searchbox;elm:search;elmt:voice;itc:0;" data-fr="uh3_news_vert_gs"
      data-fr2="p:news,m:voice-search" data-rapid_p="16" data-v9y="0" style="visibility: visible;"><span class="_yb_c8vzc"> <svg class="_yb_1w0ef" width="20" height="20" viewBox="0 0 20 20" version="1.1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg"
          xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink">
          <path fill="#188FFF"
            d="M6.25 9.167a3.75 3.75 0 1 0 7.5 0v-5a3.75 3.75 0 1 0-7.5 0v5zM10 2.083c1.15 0 2.084.933 2.084 2.084v5a2.083 2.083 0 0 1-4.167 0v-5c0-1.151.933-2.084 2.083-2.084zm3.334 15.834a.834.834 0 0 1 0 1.666H6.667a.834.834 0 0 1 0-1.666h6.667zM2.917 9.167a7.083 7.083 0 1 0 14.167 0v-.834a.834.834 0 0 0-1.667 0v.834a5.417 5.417 0 1 1-10.833 0v-.834a.834.834 0 0 0-1.667 0v.834z">
          </path>
        </svg><svg class="_yb_14kwr" width="20" height="20" viewBox="0 0 12 16" fill="none" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg">
          <path fill-rule="evenodd" clip-rule="evenodd"
            d="M5.99999 0.333496C4.71133 0.333496 3.66666 1.37816 3.66666 2.66683V7.66683C3.66666 8.9555 4.71133 10.0002 5.99999 10.0002C7.28866 10.0002 8.33333 8.9555 8.33333 7.66683V2.66683C8.33333 1.37816 7.28866 0.333496 5.99999 0.333496ZM8.66666 14.3335C9.03466 14.3335 9.33333 14.6322 9.33333 15.0002C9.33333 15.3682 9.03466 15.6668 8.66666 15.6668H3.33333C2.96533 15.6668 2.66666 15.3682 2.66666 15.0002C2.66666 14.6322 2.96533 14.3335 3.33333 14.3335H8.66666ZM0.333328 7.3335C0.333328 10.4632 2.87033 13.0002 6 13.0002C9.12966 13.0002 11.6667 10.4632 11.6667 7.3335V6.66683C11.6667 6.29883 11.368 6.00016 11 6.00016C10.632 6.00016 10.3333 6.29883 10.3333 6.66683V7.3335C10.3333 9.72683 8.39333 11.6668 6 11.6668C3.60666 11.6668 1.66666 9.72683 1.66666 7.3335V6.66683C1.66666 6.29883 1.36799 6.00016 0.999995 6.00016C0.631995 6.00016 0.333328 6.29883 0.333328 6.66683V7.3335Z"
            fill="#0063EB"></path>
        </svg> </span></button> <button type="submit" id="ybar-search" class="rapid-noclick-resp _yb_17sfr" aria-label="Search" value="Search" data-ylk="slk:websrch;elm:search;elmt:icon;sec:ybar;subsec:searchbox;itc:0;tar:search.yahoo.com;"
      data-rapid_p="17" data-v9y="1"></button> </div> <input type="hidden" name="fr" value="uh3_news_web" data-rapid_p="18" data-v9y="0"> <input type="hidden" name="fr2" value="p:news,m:sb" data-savalue="p:news,m:sa"
    data-modalsb="p:news,m:sb,v:modal" data-modalsa="p:news,m:sa,v:modal" data-rapid_p="19" data-v9y="0">
</form>

Text Content

 * HOME
   
 * MAIL
   
 * NEWS
   
 * FINANCE
   
 * SPORTS
   
 * ENTERTAINMENT
   
 * LIFE
   
 * SEARCH
   
 * SHOPPING
   
 * YAHOO PLUS
   
 * MORE...
   
 * 
 * Download the Yahoo News app
   




YAHOO NEWS

Yahoo News
Search query


Sign in
Mail
Sign in to view your mail
 * News
 * US
 * Politics
 * World
 * COVID-19
 * Climate Change
 * Health
 * Science
 * Originals
    * The 360
    * Skullduggery Podcast
    * Conspiracyland

 * Contact Us

…



Close this content

Gizmodo


ONE YEAR AFTER DOBBS, A CALIFORNIA ABORTION PRIVACY BILL IS UNDER ATTACK FROM
LAW ENFORCEMENT

Read full article
10
Thomas Germain
Fri, June 23, 2023 at 7:00 AM EDT·6 min read

The California flag in front of the state capital.

A coalition of law enforcement groups and prosecutors are holding up a
California bill with bipartisan support meant to protect people seeking
reproductive and gender affirming health care and fighting to weaken its
provisions.

The bill, AB 793, would prohibit so-called “reverse demands,” requests to tech
companies such as geofence or keyword search warrants, which typically pull in
data about masses of people who may not even be suspected of a crime. Law
enforcement and prosecutors say these are critical tools for public safety that
need to be maintained, but civil liberties advocates argue that law
enforcement’s recent lobbying efforts will narrow the bill to the point that it
leaves people unprotected.


Read more



 * These Are the Best Desktop Apps for Gmail

 * 9 of the Best Flops on Display at the Museum of Failure

 * From Disney+ to Max, Here Are the Best Streaming Services

“The intent of the bill was to ensure that these general warrants could not be
used against people seeking sensitive services in the state of California,” said
Assemblymember Mia Bonta, a state representative for Oakland, CA who introduced
the bill.

At first, Asm. Bonta said the bill sailed through committee with bipartisan
support. But AB 793 faced opposition late in the game as previously supportive
lawmakers changed their positions under pressure from lobbyists, prosecutors,
and law enforcement officials. The bill passed the Assembly by a single vote.
Its fate now lies in the Senate, where it may need significant cuts to its
protections if it has any hope of passing, Bonta said.

There’s a long list of people and groups opposing the bill. That includes the
California District Attorneys Association, the Peace Officers Research
Association of California, the California Police Chiefs Association, and
California State Sherriff’s Association, as well as a number of county sheriffs
and district attorneys.

“The bill was originally scaled to essentially eliminate these practices
altogether. This digital privacy issue is about fundamental rights. It’s in the
constitution. The ways our digital footprints are being used are the modern day
equivalent of some of the problems that caused the American Revolution,” Bonta
said.

Story continues

In general, law enforcement and prosecutors argue that those seeking
reproductive and gender affirming care should be protected, but they say losing
access to reverse demands would do more harm than good.


A representative for the Peace Officers Research Association of California
(PORAC) pointed to a letter the association wrote in opposition to the bill. AB
793 would prohibit using reverse location and keyword searches, essential
methods that investigators use to solve some of the most serious crimes,” the
letter reads. The other law enforcement groups, sheriffs, and district attorneys
mentioned in this story did not immediately answer requests for comment.

Like other groups, PORAC offers an alternative path forward. The organization
says it would consider withdrawing opposition if the bill was amended to limit
the ban on reserve demands to cases specifically involving reproductive rights
and access to gender-affirming care.

However, some civil liberties advocates argue that narrowing the bill in this
way would render it ineffective.

“It would mean we’re going to lose protections even for those exact communities
we’re trying to help, because there are are a lot of ways law enforcement could
use reverse demands to get their hands on this information without asking for it
specifically,” said Hayley Tsukayama, a Senior Legislative Activist at the
Electronic Frontier Foundation.

For example, law enforcement could create a geofence warrant for a gas station
across the street from a Planned Parenthood clinic, rather than the clinic
itself. Officials could ask for a keyword search warrant for search terms that
aren’t obviously related to issues surrounding the transgender community.

Moreover, Tsukayama said reverse demands are unconstitutional in the first
place. “In a densely populated city, these warrants can pull in information
about hundreds or thousands of people, people who aren’t suspects. There is no
probable cause to justify that kind of search,” Tsukayama said. “There are
plenty of other tools law enforcement has used for decades that are much more
protective of people’s rights, and there’s evidence these kinds of warrants
often don’t even help solve crimes. to more cases being closed.”

One recent example came after an investigation by the Kentucky Center for
Investigative Reporting found widespread use of geofence warrants by Louisville
Metro Police Department, but data showed these efforts weren’t leading to more
closed cases. “Law enforcement is arguing for tools with opaque benefits that
are difficult to see,” Tsukayama said.

One year ago this week, the Supreme Court’s Dobbs decision overturned Americans’
constitutional right to abortions. It sparked a new debate over the importance
of digital privacy. As states across the county work to criminalize once
accessible health care procedures, advocates worry that the trail of data we all
leave behind could be used to catch and prosecute marginalized individuals.

The fight to protect reproductive healthcare and the LGBTQ community is now tied
into older concerns about law enforcement surveillance. Normally, law
enforcement and prosecutors need to show probable cause and obtain a warrant or
a court order to get their hands on information about suspects. But in recent
years, a new practice has emerged that circumvents the Fourth Amendment’s
protection against unlawful searches and seizures. Rather than single out an
individual, officials ask a company like Google for a report on everyone who
searched for certain keywords, or a list of everyone whose location data shows
they were in a particular area, known as “geofencing.”

AB 793 isn’t the first attempt at protecting these sensitive healthcare
procedures. Immediately after the Supreme Court’s Dobbs decision, California
passed three laws that carve out exceptions for healthcare providers and state
officials, allowing them to ignore out-of-state subpoenas related to
reproductive and gender affirming care.

The data hoovered up by tech companies, however, is a gray area, one that AB 793
hopes to address. Google, Meta, and Amazon, three companies that receive the
lion’s share of geofence and keyword search warrants, did not immediately
respond to a request for comment.

Asm. Bonta said the bill would still have teeth with the proposed amendments.
“It raises the bar for law enforcement requests. If we’re able to do this work
over the next several weeks, it’s going to be an incredibly big win around
issues of reproductive health and gender affirming care,” Asm. Bonta said.
“People are going to have an assurance that those actions will be protected,
even if they’re deemed criminal by their other states.”

It’s going to take compromise if the bill has any hope of passing. AB 793 faces
an uphill battle, as its proposals require a two thirds majority in the
legislature. But Asm. Bonta said that won’t get in the way of her efforts.

“We’re planting a flag, and I’m very hopeful that we’ll be able to get to a
place that is going to move the ball forward for digital privacy and its nexus
with law enforcement,” Asm. Bonta said.

More from Gizmodo

 * The Best Free AI Art Generators, Ranked

 * The Best Free TV and Movie Channels For Every Major Streaming Device

Sign up for Gizmodo's Newsletter. For the latest news, Facebook, Twitter and
Instagram.

Click here to read the full article.





RECOMMENDED STORIES

 * NBC News
   
   DESANTIS SAYS HE WOULD ELIMINATE FOUR FEDERAL AGENCIES IF ELECTED PRESIDENT
   
   
   Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis said in an interview that if elected he would seek
   to abolish the departments of education, commerce and energy, as well as the
   IRS.
   
   12h ago
   
 * HuffPost
   
   CHRIS CHRISTIE HAS ‘STUPID’ YET BELIEVABLE THEORY ON WHY TRUMP KEPT SECRET
   DOCS
   
   
   The former New Jersey governor suspects the real reason is extremely
   childish.
   
   4h ago
   
 * Ad•Guardio
    * Why this Ad?
    * I like this ad
    * I don't like this ad
    * Go ad-free*
   
   ADREMOVE MALWARE HIDING ON YOUR COMPUTER
   
   
   Most Chrome users don't know this one security tip. Run a Free Scan (Do it
   Now)
   
   
 * The Telegraph
   
   ‘PRESUMED HUMAN REMAINS’ RECOVERED FROM WRECKAGE OF TITAN SUB
   
   
   Presumed human remains have been recovered from the wreckage of the Titan
   submersible, the US Coast Guard has confirmed.
   
   15h ago
   
 * CNN
   
   JUSTICE THOMAS RENEWS ATTACKS ON LANDMARK FIRST AMENDMENT DECISION IN FIERY
   DISSENT
   
   
   Justice Clarence Thomas on Tuesday renewed his yearslong attack on a landmark
   First Amendment decision, with the conservative jurist again calling for the
   Supreme Court to revisit the “flawed” ruling in the 1964 case.
   
   2d ago
   
 * USA TODAY
   
   'FINAL ACT OF PUTIN'S REIGN': DETAILS OF CHAOTIC RUSSIAN COUP EMERGING. LIVE
   UPDATES
   
   
   Russian President Vladimir Putin is losing the war in Ukraine and has become
   "a bit of a pariah around the world," President Joe Biden said Wednesday.
   
   1d ago
   
 * Ad•Fios Home Internet
    * Why this Ad?
    * I like this ad
    * I don't like this ad
    * Go ad-free*
   
   ADCUT THE CABLE. SWITCH TO FIOS HOME INTERNET.
   
   
   For a limited time get a Stream TV Soundbar on us and transform your home
   entertainment experience. With a Fios 1 Gig plan. Add'l terms apply.
   
   
 * HuffPost
   
   CHRIS CHRISTIE SHREDS 'GRIFTING' TRUMP FAMILY, ESPECIALLY JARED KUSHNER
   
   
   “What was Jared Kushner doing in the Middle East?" asked Christie, one of
   Trump's 2024 rivals.
   
   8h ago
   
 * Associated Press
   
   CALIFORNIA BLACK REPARATIONS TASK FORCE CONCLUDES HISTORIC 2-YEAR WORK
   
   
   California's first-in-the-nation slavery reparations task force wraps up its
   historic work Thursday with the official submission of a report two years in
   the making, one that documents the state's role in perpetuating
   discrimination against Black residents and suggests dozens of ways to atone.
   The report heads to lawmakers who will be responsible for turning policy
   recommendations into legislation. Reparations will not happen until lawmakers
   and Gov. Gavin Newsom agree.
   
   10h ago
   
 * Business Insider
   
   RUSSIAN DIPLOMATS FLEW TO MALI AND SYRIA HOURS AFTER PRIGOZHIN ANNOUNCED HIS
   FAILED WAGNER REBELLION, ASSURING LEADERS THE KREMLIN WAS IN CHARGE
   
   
   Kremlin diplomats personally reassured Syrian president Bashar al-Assad that
   Wagner would continue operating in the country, but not independently.
   
   12h ago
   
 * Ad•Cooking4All
    * Why this Ad?
    * I like this ad
    * I don't like this ad
    * Go ad-free*
   
   ADED SULLIVAN WAS REPULSED BY THIS SINGER
   
   
   Ed Sullivan could make or break careers, here are all the behind the scenes
   feuds
   
   
 * HuffPost
   
   LAUREN BOEBERT'S MOST GLARING HYPOCRISY YET CALLED OUT ON TWITTER
   
   
   The far-right lawmaker's latest complaint backfired on social media.
   
   7h ago
   
 * HuffPost
   
   DESANTIS UNVEILS PLAN TO ELIMINATE 4 FEDERAL AGENCIES
   
   
   The 2024 GOP presidential candidate said he'd "use" the agencies for his
   anti-"woke" agenda if Congress won't go for wiping them out.
   
   7h ago
   
 * HuffPost
   
   ARI MELBER SHOWS WHY TRUMP SHOULD BE VERY WORRIED ABOUT RUDY GIULIANI
   
   
   The MSNBC host said new developments could be bad news for the former
   president.
   
   5h ago
   
 * Ad•Kerassentials
    * Why this Ad?
    * I like this ad
    * I don't like this ad
    * Go ad-free*
   
   ADDO THIS IF YOU SUFFER FROM TOENAIL FUNGUS
   
   
   Do This If You No Longer Want To Suffer From Toenail Fungus
   
   
 * Salon
   
   TRUMP HITS THE PANIC BUTTON: ANTISEMITIC ATTACKS ON SPECIAL COUNSEL JACK
   SMITH BETRAY DESPERATION
   
   
   When racism is the defense, Americans must prepare for potential violence
   
   1d ago
   
 * HuffPost
   
   JESSE WATTERS TRIES TO MOCK JOE BIDEN'S MISTAKE AND IT GOES LAUGHABLY WRONG
   
   
   Tucker Carlson's Fox News successor wanted to own the president for his
   gaffe, but made the same blunder.
   
   3h ago
   
 * Business Insider
   
   WAGNER'S CHAOTIC ATTEMPT AT ARMED REBELLION IS STARTING TO (KIND OF) MAKE
   SENSE
   
   
   New reporting suggests that Wagner leader Yevgeny Prigozhin probably had a
   better and more effective plan than the messy one he ended up with.
   
   1d ago
   
 * Ad•Explored Planet
    * Why this Ad?
    * I like this ad
    * I don't like this ad
    * Go ad-free*
   
   ADRARE PHOTOS OF LIFE ON HAWAII'S FORBIDDEN ISLAND
   
   
   Outside of the popular tourist destinations, there is an island in Hawaii
   that most people don’t even know exists.
   
   
 * Fort Worth Star-Telegram
   
   THERE’S ONE WORD FOR TEXAS LEADERS’ ASTONISHING FAILURE TO CUT PROPERTY TAXES
   | OPINION
   
   
   Here we go again, with another special session of the Legislature. | Opinion
   
   22h ago
   
 * USA TODAY
   
   DEPUTIES ACCUSED OF BEATING, SEXUALLY ABUSING BLACK MEN FIRED BY MISSISSIPPI
   SHERIFF
   
   
   Deputies accused of beating and sexually assaulting Michael Corey Jenkins and
   Eddie Terrell Parker before shooting one of them have been fired.
   
   21h ago
   
 * TheStreet.com
   
   WALT DISNEY GAINS UNLIKELY ALLY IN WAR WITH RON DESANTIS
   
   
   The right-wing Florida governor is trying to play to the Republican base, but
   he may be missing his mark, according to one major conservative figure.
   
   2d ago
   
 * Ad•MyDailyMagazine
    * Why this Ad?
    * I like this ad
    * I don't like this ad
    * Go ad-free*
   
   ADHIDDEN GEMS OF 'THE FIFTH ELEMENT' WE MISSED
   
   
   35 mind blowing details hidden in "The 5th Element"
   
   
 * HuffPost
   
   FOX NEWS HOST STEVE DOOCY SPOUTS DOOZY OF A THEORY ABOUT TRUMP AUDIO LEAK
   
   
   "Fox & Friends" co-hosts said Doocy's explanation about the Trump audio cited
   as evidence in his classified documents case made sense.
   
   1d ago
   
 * USA TODAY
   
   A POLICE OFFICER JAILED A 3-YEAR-OLD FOR POTTY TRAINING TROUBLE. HE'S UNDER
   INVESTIGATION.
   
   
   "He was crying. I was getting the response I expected from him," Lt. Michael
   Schoenbrod told a caseworker, body-cam footage shows.
   
   20h ago
   
 * Ukrayinska Pravda
   
   PRIGOZHIN'S JET FLIES FROM BELARUS TOWARD RUSSIA
   
   
   The business jet owned by Yevgeny Prigozhin, the founder of Wagner Private
   Military Company (PMC), has taken off from Belarus and is heading towards
   Russia. Source: Belaruski Hajun, an independent Belarusian military
   monitoring media outlet, citing Flight Radar data Quote: Prigozhin's business
   jet took off from Machulishchy.
   
   2d ago
   
   More Stories

TRENDING

 * SALVAGED DEBRIS FROM TITAN SUBMERSIBLE CONTAINS 'PRESUMED HUMAN REMAINS': US
   COAST GUARD
   
   
   ABC News·4 min read
   

 * ANALYSIS-WHERE ARE RUSSIA'S TOP GENERALS? RUMOURS SWIRL AFTER MERCENARY
   MUTINY
   
   
   Reuters·5 min read
   

 * THE MAN WHO SUED BUFFALO WILD WINGS OVER ITS 'BONELESS' WINGS IS NOW SUING A
   HOME-GOODS COMPANY OVER A $20 BLANKET
   
   
   Business Insider·3 min read
   

 * A DERMATOLOGIST APPROACHED A MAN ON A TRAIN AND TOLD HIM TO GET THE SPOT ON
   HIS FACE CHECKED OUT. IT TURNED OUT TO BE CANCER.
   
   
   INSIDER·4 min read
   

 * THE CBS REPORTER WHO RODE ON THE TITAN SUB IN 2022 DOESN'T THINK OCEANGATE
   CEO STOCKTON RUSH WAS A CON MAN: 'HE GENUINELY BELIEVED IN HIS DESIGN'
   
   
   INSIDER·2 min read
   


POPULAR

 * FEDERAL JUDGE BLOCKS PART OF TENNESSEE’S BAN ON GENDER-AFFIRMING CARE FOR
   MINORS
   
   
   CNN

 * ADDO THIS IF YOU SUFFER FROM TOENAIL FUNGUS
   
   
   Ad•Kerassentials
    * Why this Ad?
    * I like this ad
    * I don't like this ad
    * Go ad-free*
   
   

 * NORTH CAROLINA SENATE APPROVES BAN ON GENDER-AFFIRMING CARE FOR MINORS
   
   
   The Hill

 * DOBBS DECISION SPURS MORAL INJURY TO ABORTION PATIENTS, PROVIDERS ALIKE
   
   
   The Montgomery Advertiser

 * LAWMAKERS GIVE OK TO BAN GENDER-AFFIRMING CARE FOR TRANS CHILDREN
   
   
   WTVD – Raleigh/Durham




Display Advertisement


Waiting for permission
Allow microphone access to enable voice search

Try again.

Try saying