www.todayonline.com Open in urlscan Pro
104.109.94.227  Public Scan

Form analysis
1 forms found in the DOM

POST /singapore/express-train-service-cross-island-line-table-khaw-boon-wan

<form class="subscription-form-1" data-drupal-selector="subscription-form-1" action="/singapore/express-train-service-cross-island-line-table-khaw-boon-wan" method="post" id="subscription-form-1" accept-charset="UTF-8">
  <input data-drupal-selector="edit-newsletter-shortcode" type="hidden" name="newsletter_shortcode" value="TDY_Partners" class="form-item__textfield">
  <div class="subscribe-form-wrapper">
    <div class="js-form-item form-item">
      <input placeholder="Enter your email address" data-drupal-selector="edit-email" type="text" id="edit-email" name="email" value="" size="60" maxlength="128" class="form-text form-item__textfield">
    </div>
    <input data-drupal-selector="edit-subscription-div-identifier" type="hidden" name="subscription_div_identifier" value="subscription_form__3341" class="form-item__textfield">
    <input autocomplete="off" data-drupal-selector="form-yugn0eeabvg43wgx-w3ipeyhvvr-yd387r39sjrq-as" type="hidden" name="form_build_id" value="form-yUgN0EeABvG43WGX-w3ipeyhVvr_yd387R39SJrq_as" class="form-item__textfield">
    <input data-drupal-selector="edit-subscription-form-1" type="hidden" name="form_id" value="subscription_form_1" class="form-item__textfield">
    <div class="submit-wrapper"><input data-drupal-selector="edit-submit" data-disable-refocus="true" type="submit" id="edit-submit" name="op" value="Subscribe" class="button js-form-submit form-submit form-item__textfield" data-once="drupal-ajax">
    </div>
  </div>
  <div id="form-error-subscription_form__3341" class="inline-error"></div>
</form>

Text Content

Skip to main content
 * Sign In
 * My Account
 * Search

Hamburger Menu Close
 * Singapore
   
 * World
   
 * Big Read
   
 * Adulting 101
   
 * Gen Y Speaks
   
 * Gen Z Speaks
   
 * Voices
   
 * Commentary
   
 * 8 Days
   
 * More
   
   * Health
     
   * Watch
     
   * Brand Spotlight
     

Singapore

EXPRESS TRAIN SERVICE ON CROSS ISLAND LINE OFF THE TABLE: KHAW BOON WAN

Bookmark Bookmark Share
WhatsApp Telegram Facebook Twitter Email LinkedIn


ADVERTISEMENT










ADVERTISEMENT










EXPRESS TRAIN SERVICE ON CROSS ISLAND LINE OFF THE TABLE: KHAW BOON WAN

SINGAPORE — An express MRT train service that would get commuters more quickly
from one end of the future Cross Island Line (CRL) to the other will not
materialise after all. This is after the authorities projected that just less
than 5 per cent of the rail line's users would see time savings of at least 15
minutes.

TODAY file photo

Site investigation works for the future Cross Island Line being carried out at
the Central Catchment Nature Reserve.

Follow us on Instagram and Tiktok, and join our Telegram channel for the latest
updates.
By

JANICE LIM

@janicelimtoday
By Janice Lim
Published November 19, 2018
Updated November 20, 2018
Bookmark Bookmark Share
WhatsApp Telegram Facebook Twitter Email LinkedIn


SINGAPORE — An express MRT train service that would get commuters more quickly
from one end of the future Cross Island Line (CRL) to the other will not
materialise after all.

This is after the authorities projected that just less than 5 per cent of the
rail line's users would see time savings of at least 15 minutes. 


ADVERTISEMENT





In a written reply to a parliamentary question by Mr Ong Teng Koon, Member of
Parliament for Marsiling-Yew Tee Group Representation Constituency, Transport
Minister Khaw Boon Wan also said on Monday (Nov 19) that the benefits of
significant time savings do not outweigh the cost.

Based on the CRL’s daily ridership estimate of 600,000 commuters, fewer than
30,000 people would benefit from this service.

“Viewed against the much higher cost and land take needed to build two
additional tunnels for the express service, we did not pursue the option,” he
added.

Mr Khaw explained that while express services can reduce travel time, they
require a separate set of tracks and additional signalling systems.

“This will mean greater land take, pose operational complexities, and cost
taxpayers and commuters significantly more,” he said.


ADVERTISEMENT





An express service on the CRL was first mooted in 2014, when the Land Transport
Authority (LTA) called for an engineering feasibility study for running both
regular and express trains on the new line, which will be ready in 2030.

The 50km MRT line will start from Changi in the eastern part of Singapore, and
end at Jurong in the west, passing through Loyang, Pasir Ris, Hougang, Ang Mo
Kio, Bukit Timah, Clementi and West Coast.

Transport analysts told TODAY that they were not surprised by the Government’s
decision.

Transport economist Walter Theseira from Singapore University of Social Sciences
(SUSS) pointed out that express train services usually need twice the amount of
trackage.

While it is possible to intermix the tracks for the express and regular train
service, it is “more dangerous”, and may slow down both services as one train
will have to stop to let the other pass, he said. Mr Khaw also pointed this out
in his written reply, stating that this will have a “significant adverse impact”
for commuters on the regular train services, as they would have to be held back
at certain stations for the express trains to pass.


ADVERTISEMENT





Dr Theseira added that there must be a pattern demand to justify the huge
expense of running an express service — such as having many commuters getting on
and off at both ends of the services, or only alighting at major interchanges
located in the Central Business District.

SUSS' urban transport expert Park Byung-Joon said that building an extra line
for an express service would “cost a lot of money”.

While he could not give an estimate of the total cost of running such an express
service on the CRL, Dr Park said that 1km of track would typically cost more
than S$1 million, with expenditure going up in Singapore because the tracks
would be underground.

While South Korea and Japan’s transport systems have express services, he said
that the costs to build those tracks are “a lot cheaper” because they are
situated at ground level.

Dr Park added: “It’s really a cost-benefit analysis — how much money to put in
extra to have time savings. If the time savings is an extra 15 minutes, it’s not
a wise way of spending money.”


ADVERTISEMENT





There was talk previously that an express service on the CRL would entice
residents in southern Malaysia to fly out of Singapore instead of
Malaysia's capital Kuala Lumpur, as the CRL would be linked to the Kuala
Lumpur-Singapore High-Speed Rail (HSR) at the Jurong terminus. In September, the
multi-billion-dollar HSR project was formally postponed by almost two years.

The Singapore Government is now deciding between two alignment options for the
CRL — one that runs directly beneath the Central Catchment Nature Reserve, and
another slightly longer route which skirts around the nature reserve that would
cost S$2 billion and increase travel time by four minutes.

The first option had drawn opposition from environmentalists and
conservationists, who said that such a move would seriously damage the reserve
and its ecosystem. The authorities have assured the public that a decision would
not be made without a full range of studies, which include a “robust” two-phase
environmental impact assessment.

Site investigations, which took place from May 2016 to September last year, were
conducted after the first phase of the environmental study.

Read more of the latest in

Singapore Explore now


ADVERTISEMENT






POPULAR

CHEERS EMPLOYEE WHO FILMED HIS ARGUMENT WITH POLICE OFFICERS DISMISSED FROM JOB

14 MONTHS' JAIL FOR WOMAN WHO STABBED 15-YEAR-OLD DAUGHTER IN THIGH TO 'PREVENT
HER FROM GOING OUT'

65-YEAR-OLD MAN ARRESTED FOR ALLEGED ATTEMPTED MURDER OF MAN, 37, FOUND WITH
BURN WOUNDS

#TRENDING: CHEERS CONVENIENCE STORE EMPLOYEE CRITICISED FOR UNCOOPERATIVE
BEHAVIOUR IN VIRAL VIDEOS SHOWING ARGUMENT WITH POLICE

Recommended by

AD
Hear Clear Kaufen Sie keine Hörgeräte bevor Sie das gelesen haben

AD
healthyedibles4-you Two Drops Before Bed Can Treat Years of Joint Pain &
Arthritis
Deliveryman admits following woman, molesting her twice near her home while
under probe for similar offence

AD
getmrjoint.com Bone on Bone Knee Pain? Try this, says Top Doc!



ADVERTISEMENT






STAY IN THE KNOW. ANYTIME. ANYWHERE.

Subscribe to get daily news updates, insights and must reads delivered straight
to your inbox.

By clicking subscribe, I agree for my personal data to be used to send me TODAY
newsletters, promotional offers and for research and analysis.


READ THE FULL STORY

Fetching more news

RECENT SEARCHES



 * Singapore
   
 * Commentary
   
 * World
   
 * Voices
   
 * Big Read
   
 * Watch
   
 * Gen Y Speaks
   
 * Brand Spotlight
   
 * Adulting 101
   
 * 8 Days
   

 * About TODAY
   
 * Coupons
   
 * Journalists
   
 * Advertise With Us
   
 * About Mediacorp
   
 * Contact Us
   
 * Mediacorp Digital Network
   
 * Privacy Policy
   
 * Mediacorp Terms and Conditions of Use
   

CONNECT WITH US

 * Facebook
 * Twitter
 * Youtube
 * LinkedIn
 * Instagram
 * Telegram
 * TickTok

DOWNLOAD OUR APP

 * Google Play
 * App Store
 * App Gallery

Copyright 2023 © Mediacorp Pte Ltd. All rights reserved.

Official Domain | Terms & Conditions | Privacy Policy








THIS BROWSER IS NO LONGER SUPPORTED

We know it's a hassle to switch browsers but we want your experience with TODAY
to be fast, secure and the best it can possibly be.

To continue, upgrade to a supported browser or, for the finest experience,
download the mobile app.



Upgraded but still having issues? Contact us


✓
Thanks for sharing!
AddToAny
More…