nautil.us
Open in
urlscan Pro
151.101.3.52
Public Scan
URL:
https://nautil.us/how-teacups-and-demons-help-demystify-physics-797444/?_sp=fbc76f9d-7c5c-4f2c-b4e7-19b9077bafa8.1...
Submission: On August 29 via manual from DE — Scanned from US
Submission: On August 29 via manual from DE — Scanned from US
Form analysis 6 forms found in the DOM
GET https://nautil.us/
<form role="search" method="get" class="search-inp-wrap responsive-search" action="https://nautil.us/">
<label>
<span class="screen-reader-text"></span>
<input type="search" class="form-control" placeholder="Search Nautilus..." value="" name="s">
</label>
<button type="submit" class="search-submit" value="Search">
<img src="https://nautil.us/wp-content/themes/nautilus-block-theme/images/icons/search-dark.svg" class="icon-search" alt="search icon" width="28" height="28">
</button>
</form>GET https://nautil.us/
<form role="search" method="get" class="search-form" action="https://nautil.us/">
<label>
<span class="screen-reader-text">Search for:</span>
<input type="search" class="search-field" placeholder="Search …" value="" name="s">
</label>
<input type="submit" class="search-submit" value="Search">
</form>POST
<form enctype="multipart/form-data" method="post" class="frm-show-form frm_js_validate frm_ajax_submit frm_pro_form " id="form_speedbump-block-default-form" data-token="522b2f11bba8907fab4474d0f27eb7bd" style="overflow-x: visible;">
<div class="frm_form_fields ">
<fieldset>
<legend class="frm_screen_reader">NL – Article speedbump</legend>
<div class="frm_fields_container">
<input type="hidden" name="frm_action" value="create">
<input type="hidden" name="form_id" value="86">
<input type="hidden" name="frm_hide_fields_86" id="frm_hide_fields_86" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="form_key" value="speedbump-block-default-form">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[0]" value="">
<input type="hidden" id="frm_submit_entry_86" name="frm_submit_entry_86" value="b61a648fab"><input type="hidden" name="_wp_http_referer" value="/how-teacups-and-demons-help-demystify-physics-797444/"><input type="hidden" name="item_meta[750]"
id="field_js_utm_id86" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[751]" id="field_js_utm_source1" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[753]" id="field_js_utm_medium1" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[752]" id="field_js_utm_campaign1" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[754]" id="field_js_utm_term1" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[755]" id="field_js_utm_content1" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[757]" id="field_nl_lp_rid86" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[758]" id="field_ucvvj" value="16:17:03" data-frmval="16:17:03">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[759]" id="field_7xafb" value="714" data-frmval="714">
<div id="frm_field_742_container" class="frm_form_field form-field frm_required_field frm_none_container frm_two_thirds">
<label for="field_y56x4" id="field_y56x4_label" class="frm_primary_label">Email <span class="frm_required" aria-hidden="true">*</span>
</label>
<input type="email" id="field_y56x4" name="item_meta[742]" value="" autocomplete="email" placeholder="Enter your email" data-reqmsg="Email cannot be blank." aria-required="true" data-invmsg="Email is invalid" aria-invalid="false">
</div>
<div id="frm_field_743_container" class="frm_form_field form-field frm_third">
<div class="frm_submit frm_third">
<button class="frm_button_submit frm_final_submit" type="submit" formnovalidate="formnovalidate">Sign up for free</button>
</div>
</div>
<input type="hidden" name="item_key" value="">
<div class="frm__655bb6eca1eeb">
<label for="frm_email_86"> If you are human, leave this field blank. </label>
<input id="frm_email_86" type="text" class="frm_verify" name="frm__655bb6eca1eeb" value="" autocomplete="off">
</div>
<input name="frm_state" type="hidden" value="KlvCIRs9PrcBc/SyV6Q92x7cbTuR381lh96IrhWulMb6XXBX6wl+oa1lxeu/bsk/lFT36iN86waAkSC6QSrpwzzc26VYYXSksY4ForBkgidZAYlj5W8xdGzVexfVj27aUCaQ0QgcowTrKUXzMxpk5tZwcxO3dhMqg7Fxh6OQmKV+R6bEbfJUsyoJm2JFd5lO">
</div>
</fieldset>
</div>
</form>POST
<form enctype="multipart/form-data" method="post" class="frm-show-form frm_js_validate frm_ajax_submit frm_pro_form " id="form_newsletter-signup-in-page-mobile" data-token="522b2f11bba8907fab4474d0f27eb7bd" style="overflow-x: visible;">
<div class="frm_form_fields ">
<fieldset>
<legend class="frm_screen_reader">NL – In Page Mobile</legend>
<div class="frm_fields_container">
<input type="hidden" name="frm_action" value="create">
<input type="hidden" name="form_id" value="60">
<input type="hidden" name="frm_hide_fields_60" id="frm_hide_fields_60" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="form_key" value="newsletter-signup-in-page-mobile">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[0]" value="">
<input type="hidden" id="frm_submit_entry_60" name="frm_submit_entry_60" value="b61a648fab"><input type="hidden" name="_wp_http_referer" value="/how-teacups-and-demons-help-demystify-physics-797444/">
<div id="frm_field_463_container" class="frm_form_field form-field frm_required_field frm_top_container">
<label for="field_email2" id="field_email2_label" class="frm_primary_label">Email: <span class="frm_required">*</span>
</label>
<input type="email" id="field_email2" name="item_meta[463]" value="" placeholder="Enter your email address" data-reqmsg="Email: cannot be blank." aria-required="true" data-invmsg="This is not a valid email." aria-invalid="false">
</div>
<div id="frm_field_464_container" class="frm_form_field form-field frm_none_container">
<label for="g-recaptcha-response" id="field_f02yo2_label" class="frm_primary_label">Captcha <span class="frm_required" aria-hidden="true"></span>
</label>
<div id="field_f02yo2" class="frm-g-recaptcha" data-sitekey="6LcIGuUpAAAAABhqlni-ytDG0olfnt-0G0s_5u09" data-size="invisible" data-theme="light" data-rid="0">
<div class="grecaptcha-badge" data-style="bottomright"
style="width: 256px; height: 60px; display: block; transition: right 0.3s; position: fixed; bottom: 14px; right: -186px; box-shadow: gray 0px 0px 5px; border-radius: 2px; overflow: hidden;">
<div class="grecaptcha-logo"><iframe title="reCAPTCHA" width="256" height="60" role="presentation" name="a-2k5fe63immpz" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"
sandbox="allow-forms allow-popups allow-same-origin allow-scripts allow-top-navigation allow-modals allow-popups-to-escape-sandbox allow-storage-access-by-user-activation"
src="https://www.google.com/recaptcha/api2/anchor?ar=1&k=6LcIGuUpAAAAABhqlni-ytDG0olfnt-0G0s_5u09&co=aHR0cHM6Ly9uYXV0aWwudXM6NDQz&hl=en&v=i7X0JrnYWy9Y_5EYdoFM79kV&theme=light&size=invisible&cb=j6apmtke5ir4"></iframe>
</div>
<div class="grecaptcha-error"></div><textarea id="g-recaptcha-response" name="g-recaptcha-response" class="g-recaptcha-response"
style="width: 250px; height: 40px; border: 1px solid rgb(193, 193, 193); margin: 10px 25px; padding: 0px; resize: none; display: none;"></textarea>
</div>
</div>
</div>
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[465]" id="field_js_utm_id3" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[466]" id="field_js_utm_source3" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[467]" id="field_js_utm_medium3" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[468]" id="field_js_utm_campaign3" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[469]" id="field_js_utm_term3" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[470]" id="field_js_utm_content3" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[471]" id="field_nl_lp_rid2" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[531]" id="field_xyc35" value="16:17:03" data-frmval="16:17:03">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[537]" id="field_yntmy" value="2698" data-frmval="2698">
<input type="hidden" name="item_key" value="">
<div class="frm__655bb6eca1eeb">
<label for="frm_email_60"> If you are human, leave this field blank. </label>
<input id="frm_email_60" type="text" class="frm_verify" name="frm__655bb6eca1eeb" value="" autocomplete="off">
</div>
<input name="frm_state" type="hidden" value="KlvCIRs9PrcBc/SyV6Q92x7cbTuR381lh96IrhWulMb6XXBX6wl+oa1lxeu/bsk/lFT36iN86waAkSC6QSrpwzzc26VYYXSksY4ForBkgidZAYlj5W8xdGzVexfVj27aUCaQ0QgcowTrKUXzMxpk5tZwcxO3dhMqg7Fxh6OQmKV+R6bEbfJUsyoJm2JFd5lO">
<div class="frm_submit">
<button class="frm_button_submit frm_final_submit" type="submit" formnovalidate="formnovalidate">Sign up for free</button>
</div>
</div>
</fieldset>
</div>
</form>POST
<form enctype="multipart/form-data" method="post" class="frm-show-form frm_js_validate frm_ajax_submit frm_pro_form " id="form_newsletter-signup-footer" data-token="522b2f11bba8907fab4474d0f27eb7bd" style="overflow-x: visible;">
<div class="frm_form_fields ">
<fieldset>
<legend class="frm_screen_reader">NL – Footer</legend>
<div class="frm_fields_container">
<input type="hidden" name="frm_action" value="create">
<input type="hidden" name="form_id" value="61">
<input type="hidden" name="frm_hide_fields_61" id="frm_hide_fields_61" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="form_key" value="newsletter-signup-footer">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[0]" value="">
<input type="hidden" id="frm_submit_entry_61" name="frm_submit_entry_61" value="b61a648fab"><input type="hidden" name="_wp_http_referer" value="/how-teacups-and-demons-help-demystify-physics-797444/">
<div id="frm_field_472_container" class="frm_form_field form-field frm_required_field frm_top_container">
<label for="field_email3" id="field_email3_label" class="frm_primary_label">Email: <span class="frm_required">*</span>
</label>
<input type="email" id="field_email3" name="item_meta[472]" value="" placeholder="Enter your email address" data-reqmsg="Email: cannot be blank." aria-required="true" data-invmsg="This is not a valid email." aria-invalid="false">
</div>
<div id="frm_field_473_container" class="frm_form_field form-field frm_top_container">
<label for="g-recaptcha-response" id="field_f02yo3_label" class="frm_primary_label">Please check the box below to proceed. <span class="frm_required" aria-hidden="true"></span>
</label>
<div id="field_f02yo3" class="frm-g-recaptcha" data-sitekey="6LcIGuUpAAAAABhqlni-ytDG0olfnt-0G0s_5u09" data-size="invisible" data-theme="dark" data-rid="1">
<div class="grecaptcha-badge" data-style="none" style="width: 256px; height: 60px; position: fixed; visibility: hidden;">
<div class="grecaptcha-logo"><iframe title="reCAPTCHA" width="256" height="60" role="presentation" name="a-wnkezb3rpagd" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"
sandbox="allow-forms allow-popups allow-same-origin allow-scripts allow-top-navigation allow-modals allow-popups-to-escape-sandbox allow-storage-access-by-user-activation"
src="https://www.google.com/recaptcha/api2/anchor?ar=1&k=6LcIGuUpAAAAABhqlni-ytDG0olfnt-0G0s_5u09&co=aHR0cHM6Ly9uYXV0aWwudXM6NDQz&hl=en&v=i7X0JrnYWy9Y_5EYdoFM79kV&theme=dark&size=invisible&cb=8vfmrv5llt0v"></iframe>
</div>
<div class="grecaptcha-error"></div><textarea id="g-recaptcha-response-1" name="g-recaptcha-response" class="g-recaptcha-response"
style="width: 250px; height: 40px; border: 1px solid rgb(193, 193, 193); margin: 10px 25px; padding: 0px; resize: none; display: none;"></textarea>
</div>
</div>
</div>
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[474]" id="field_js_utm_id4" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[475]" id="field_js_utm_source4" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[476]" id="field_js_utm_medium4" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[477]" id="field_js_utm_campaign4" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[478]" id="field_js_utm_term4" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[479]" id="field_js_utm_content4" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[480]" id="field_nl_lp_rid3" value="">
<div id="frm_field_741_container" class="frm_form_field form-field ">
<div class="frm_submit">
<button class="frm_button_submit frm_final_submit" type="submit" formnovalidate="formnovalidate">Sign up for free</button>
</div>
</div>
<input type="hidden" name="item_key" value="">
<div class="frm__655bb6eca1eeb">
<label for="frm_email_61"> If you are human, leave this field blank. </label>
<input id="frm_email_61" type="text" class="frm_verify" name="frm__655bb6eca1eeb" value="" autocomplete="off">
</div>
<input name="frm_state" type="hidden" value="KlvCIRs9PrcBc/SyV6Q92x7cbTuR381lh96IrhWulMb6XXBX6wl+oa1lxeu/bsk/lFT36iN86waAkSC6QSrpwzzc26VYYXSksY4ForBkgidZAYlj5W8xdGzVexfVj27aUCaQ0QgcowTrKUXzMxpk5tZwcxO3dhMqg7Fxh6OQmKV+R6bEbfJUsyoJm2JFd5lO">
</div>
</fieldset>
</div>
</form>POST
<form enctype="multipart/form-data" method="post" class="frm-show-form frm_js_validate frm_ajax_submit frm_pro_form " id="form_newsletter-signup-emailgate" data-token="522b2f11bba8907fab4474d0f27eb7bd" style="overflow-x: visible;">
<div class="frm_form_fields ">
<fieldset>
<legend class="frm_screen_reader">NL – Emailgate</legend>
<div class="frm_fields_container">
<input type="hidden" name="frm_action" value="create">
<input type="hidden" name="form_id" value="74">
<input type="hidden" name="frm_hide_fields_74" id="frm_hide_fields_74" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="form_key" value="newsletter-signup-emailgate">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[0]" value="">
<input type="hidden" id="frm_submit_entry_74" name="frm_submit_entry_74" value="b61a648fab"><input type="hidden" name="_wp_http_referer" value="/how-teacups-and-demons-help-demystify-physics-797444/">
<div id="frm_field_602_container" class="frm_form_field form-field frm_required_field frm_none_container">
<label for="field_email6" id="field_email6_label" class="frm_primary_label">
<span class="frm_required">*</span>
</label>
<input type="email" id="field_email6" name="item_meta[602]" value="" style="width:302px" placeholder="Enter your email address" data-reqmsg="This field cannot be blank." aria-required="true" data-invmsg="This is not a valid email."
class="auto_width" aria-invalid="false">
</div>
<div id="frm_field_603_container" class="frm_form_field form-field frm_none_container">
<label for="g-recaptcha-response" id="field_f02yo6_label" class="frm_primary_label">Check the box below to proceed. <span class="frm_required" aria-hidden="true"></span>
</label>
<div id="field_f02yo6" class="frm-g-recaptcha" data-sitekey="6LcIGuUpAAAAABhqlni-ytDG0olfnt-0G0s_5u09" data-size="invisible" data-theme="dark" data-rid="2">
<div class="grecaptcha-badge" data-style="none" style="width: 256px; height: 60px; position: fixed; visibility: hidden;">
<div class="grecaptcha-logo"><iframe title="reCAPTCHA" width="256" height="60" role="presentation" name="a-drcupyoxrh2m" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"
sandbox="allow-forms allow-popups allow-same-origin allow-scripts allow-top-navigation allow-modals allow-popups-to-escape-sandbox allow-storage-access-by-user-activation"
src="https://www.google.com/recaptcha/api2/anchor?ar=1&k=6LcIGuUpAAAAABhqlni-ytDG0olfnt-0G0s_5u09&co=aHR0cHM6Ly9uYXV0aWwudXM6NDQz&hl=en&v=i7X0JrnYWy9Y_5EYdoFM79kV&theme=dark&size=invisible&cb=xy3y009tjuvx"></iframe>
</div>
<div class="grecaptcha-error"></div><textarea id="g-recaptcha-response-2" name="g-recaptcha-response" class="g-recaptcha-response"
style="width: 250px; height: 40px; border: 1px solid rgb(193, 193, 193); margin: 10px 25px; padding: 0px; resize: none; display: none;"></textarea>
</div><iframe style="display: none;"></iframe>
</div>
</div>
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[604]" id="field_js_utm_id9" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[605]" id="field_js_utm_source9" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[606]" id="field_js_utm_medium9" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[607]" id="field_js_utm_campaign9" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[608]" id="field_js_utm_term9" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[609]" id="field_js_utm_content9" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[610]" id="field_nl_lp_rid6" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[611]" id="field_2926n3" value="16:17:03" data-frmval="16:17:03">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[612]" id="field_md9f43" value="5455" data-frmval="5455">
<div id="frm_field_756_container" class="frm_form_field form-field ">
<div class="frm_submit">
<button class="frm_button_submit frm_final_submit" type="submit" formnovalidate="formnovalidate">Sign up for free</button>
</div>
</div>
<input type="hidden" name="item_key" value="">
<div class="frm__655bb6eca1eeb">
<label for="frm_email_74"> If you are human, leave this field blank. </label>
<input id="frm_email_74" type="text" class="frm_verify" name="frm__655bb6eca1eeb" value="" autocomplete="off">
</div>
<input name="frm_state" type="hidden" value="KlvCIRs9PrcBc/SyV6Q92x7cbTuR381lh96IrhWulMb6XXBX6wl+oa1lxeu/bsk/lFT36iN86waAkSC6QSrpwzzc26VYYXSksY4ForBkgidZAYlj5W8xdGzVexfVj27aUCaQ0QgcowTrKUXzMxpk5tZwcxO3dhMqg7Fxh6OQmKV+R6bEbfJUsyoJm2JFd5lO">
</div>
</fieldset>
</div>
</form>Text Content
*
*
*
* Channels
* Topics
* About
* Contact us
* Newsletter
* Become a member
* Shop
Channels
Art+Science
Biology + Beyond
Cosmos
Culture
Earth
Life
Mind
Ocean
One Question
Quanta Abstractions
Science Philanthropy Alliance
Spark of Science
The Porthole
The Reality Issue
The Rebel Issue
Women in Science & Engineering
Topics
* Anthropology
* Arts
* Astronomy
* Communication
* Economics
* Environment
* Evolution
* General
* Genetics
* Geoscience
* Health
* History
* Math
* Microbiology
* Neuroscience
* Paleontology
* Philosophy
* Physics
* Psychology
* Sociology
* Technology
* Zoology
ALREADY A MEMBER? LOG IN
*
*
* Join
Close
Search for:
Log in Join
Physics
When Reality Came Undone
Sociology
Placebo Science Is Rooted in Witch Hunts
Arts
The Harrowing and the Beautiful
Psychology
Out of Your Head
Neuroscience
When Reality Feels Unreal
Communication
The Reality Issue
Technology
In the Beginning, There Was Computation
Physics
Confessions of a Theoretical Physicist
Philosophy
A Hermit’s Reality
Physics
When Reality Came Undone
Sociology
Placebo Science Is Rooted in Witch Hunts
Arts
The Harrowing and the Beautiful
Psychology
Out of Your Head
Neuroscience
When Reality Feels Unreal
Communication
The Reality Issue
Technology
In the Beginning, There Was Computation
Physics
Confessions of a Theoretical Physicist
Philosophy
A Hermit’s Reality
Physics
When Reality Came Undone
Sociology
Placebo Science Is Rooted in Witch Hunts
Arts
The Harrowing and the Beautiful
Psychology
Out of Your Head
Neuroscience
When Reality Feels Unreal
Communication
The Reality Issue
Technology
In the Beginning, There Was Computation
Physics
Confessions of a Theoretical Physicist
Philosophy
A Hermit’s Reality
ADVERTISEMENT
Nautilus Members enjoy an ad-free experience. Log in or Join now .
* Physics
HOW TEACUPS AND DEMONS HELP DEMYSTIFY PHYSICS
The thought experiments illuminating black holes and other scientific problems.
* By Patricia Palacios
* August 26, 2024
* Add a comment
* Share
Facebook Twitter Pocket Reddit Email
Sign up for the free Nautilus newsletter:
science and culture for people who love beautiful writing.
NL – Article speedbump
Email *
Sign up for free
If you are human, leave this field blank.
Explore
In his 1967 short story “The Southern Thruway,” Argentine writer Julio Cortázar
conjures a catastrophic traffic jam just outside of Paris. The gridlock endures
for months, forcing motorists to build an entirely new society around their
immobile cars. It is a thought that has perhaps crossed many people’s minds as
they are stuck in seemingly interminable traffic: What might happen if …
Cortázar’s 20th-century fiction often played in the realm of the fantastical as
a way of probing the deeper truths about existence. In a series of lectures
delivered in 1980 at the University of California, Berkeley, Cortázar explained
that, in his work, “the fantastic is at the service of reality.” He continued:
Powered By
00:00/01:12
10
How Fast Does Hair Grow?
Share
Next
Stay
Nautilus Members enjoy an ad-free experience. Log in or Join now .
The fantasy, the fantastic, the imaginable that I love and with which I have
tried to make my own work is everything that ultimately serves to project more
clearly and with more strength the reality that surrounds us.
Dabbling in the fantastic might seem natural for a fiction writer—but at sharp
odds with science. It turns out, however, that fantasy may play a similarly
useful role in illuminating the darkest and most mysterious corners of science,
including seemingly inaccessible regions, such as the study of energy within
black holes.
ADVERTISEMENT
Nautilus Members enjoy an ad-free experience. Log in or Join now .
Such fantasies—like Cortázar’s epic traffic jam—are actually a very useful form
of thought experiment. What might happen if … In physics, thought experiments
have proven invaluable over the centuries for exposing weaknesses in existing
theories and generating new ideas.
Thought experiments, of course, are not like real experiments performed in the
lab. They usually consist of fictional—sometimes even fantastic—situations that
occur in the mind of the scientist: Demons, spirits, and giant teacups can all
be part of scientific thought experiments. How can it be that thought
experiments, mere exercises of the imagination, can teach us something about our
scientific theories—especially in today’s era of high-computation physics? This
question motivated me to open a new chapter in my own research.
Several years ago, I was on a ski tour in the Alps with a colleague of mine from
the University of Salzburg, the philosopher and historian of science Rawad El
Skaf. My poor level as a skier together with our enthusiasm for discussing big
ideas in physics led us to spend much of the day on the terrace of a very
charming Hütte (cottage), mulling over the role of thought experiments. We
arrived at the following conclusion, which we later described in a paper
together: Thought experiments in black hole physics help us reveal and resolve
tensions and, in some cases, inconsistencies between different theories—much as
they have throughout the history of physics, including in the revolutionary
theories of general relativity and quantum mechanics.
ADVERTISEMENT
Nautilus Members enjoy an ad-free experience. Log in or Join now .
More than a century ago, one of the most famous thought experiments in physics
helped rip a hole in one of its key laws. It involved imaginary gasses, a door,
and, perhaps fittingly, a demon.
In 1867, the second law of thermodynamics reigned. It declared that entropy
cannot decrease in an isolated system—whether that’s a closed chamber or a
universe—and that heat only flows spontaneously from hot to cold—and never the
other way around. One of the reasons why the second law was (and still is) so
important is that it has a series of implications at all levels. It predicts
that a cup of hot coffee will eventually cool down; that temperature differences
are very hard to maintain; and even that, as time passes, we will grow older and
not younger.
> Fantasy may play a useful role in illuminating the darkest and most mysterious
> corners of science.
But that year, Scottish physicist James Clerk Maxwell—a pioneer of statistical
physics—considered what could happen if there were a being who could play a game
with gas molecules? His conceptual experiment imagines a small being, called
later a “demon,” which can manipulate (without expending energy) the flow of gas
molecules in a container by controlling a door that divides the container into
two parts. We assume that when the gas molecules approach the door, the demon
can quickly select the molecules allowing only fast-moving molecules (which
produce hot temperatures) to pass from the left- to the right-hand side of the
container and allowing only slow-moving molecules (which produce cold
temperatures) to move from right to left.
ADVERTISEMENT
Nautilus Members enjoy an ad-free experience. Log in or Join now .
By doing this, the demon is able to make one part of the container colder as the
other gets hotter. Importantly, this implies that temperature differences could
be produced at the expense of no work—and that entropy can also decrease in the
process.
Maxwell’s fictional demon allowed him to “pick a hole” in one of the most
important physical laws of his era. He disputed not only the deterministic
character of the law, showing that it allows for exceptions, but also, and more
profoundly, he disputed the idea that the laws of nature always follow a simple,
regular path. The second law of thermodynamics, he concluded, is valid only
statistically.
Could we have seen those possible violations of the second law without invoking
demons? Perhaps, but these fantasies certainly helped scientists make these
problems with the second law more intuitive. As historian of science Jimena
Canales puts it in her book Bedeviled, “Scientific thinkers used demons to
explore problems, test the limits of what is possible, and better understand
nature.”
Aspects of nature can be vexingly hard to understand when we lack empirical
evidence about them. Such is the case with the relatively new field of black
hole thermodynamics. This discipline aims to ascribe thermodynamic properties,
such as temperature, to black holes, which are defined in astrophysics as
“regions of no escape.” It is a challenging intellectual space for even the
brightest minds. It’s hard to speculate what might be happening with energy and
entropy in a black hole when relevant information is as-yet essentially
undetectable. So, in areas like this, thought experiments appear to be at their
most essential.
ADVERTISEMENT
Nautilus Members enjoy an ad-free experience. Log in or Join now .
As Erik Curiel, a philosopher of physics working on the foundations of black
holes, has written: “Why assume a classical black hole has an entropy in the
first place? The best answer to this is implicit in the series of
thought-experiments.”
To better explain Curiel’s position, let us take a trip back in time to the
origins of black hole thermodynamics. At the beginning of the 1970s, John
Wheeler, an eminent physicist, wanted to challenge his graduate students at
Princeton University. So he suggested the following situation: Imagine holding a
cup of tea in the vicinity of a black hole. Instead of drinking the tea, what
might happen if you threw it into the black hole?
> Could we have seen possible violations of the second law without invoking
> demons?
He used this simple thought experiment to reveal a tension between the second
law of thermodynamics and the “no-hair theorem,” which is a conjecture in
general relativity. According to the no-hair theorem, a black hole is determined
only by well-known parameters—namely its mass, angular momentum, and electric
charge. Wheeler referred to this with the phrase that “black holes have no hair”
because it implies that all the information, for instance about the formation of
the black hole, would vanish behind the black hole’s boundaries (its event
horizon).
ADVERTISEMENT
Nautilus Members enjoy an ad-free experience. Log in or Join now .
The problem arises if we combine the no-hair theorem with the second law of
thermodynamics in scenarios such as the one proposed by Wheeler. If you were to
throw a cup of tea into a black hole, thermodynamics would predict that the
entropy in the exterior of the black hole decreases. However, given that the
no-hair theorem does not tell us anything about the entropy in the interior of
the black hole, one cannot exclude the possibility that the total entropy of the
universe may have decreased in the process. This is intriguing, because it means
that we cannot rule out the possibility that the second law might be violated
after all. Since the consequences are similar to Maxwell’s demon, some people
have called this thought experiment “Wheeler’s demon.”
Wheeler wanted to push his students by suggesting counterfactual situations in
which the second law would become observationally meaningless, or in his own
words “transcended.” Not all students were impressed by this challenge. Robert
Wald, for instance, another eminent physicist who was a student of Wheeler’s
during that period, admits: “The thought that flashed through my mind at the
time was ‘Boy, am I glad that I have some good problems to work on!’ ” A perhaps
slightly facetious take that seems perfectly reasonable for the time.
These thoughts about the possible “transcendence” of the second law were
motivated not by real experiments performed in the lab, but by those only in
“the laboratory of the mind” that could not happen in the real world. Of course
it is not physically possible to have a cup of tea in the vicinity of a black
hole—gravity would not allow it!
ADVERTISEMENT
Nautilus Members enjoy an ad-free experience. Log in or Join now .
So, why should we take thought experiments, with their preposterous tea parties
and wily minuscule demons seriously?
Jacob Bekenstein, another prominent physicist and student of Wheeler’s at that
time, taught us an important lesson. In contrast to Wald, he decided to take the
challenge proposed by Wheeler very seriously and looked into different ways that
the second law might be rescued.
To solve the conflict between the no-hair theorem and the second law of
thermodynamics, he conjectured that black holes have an entropy that is
proportional to the black hole area. This new definition of black hole entropy
was motivated by Stephen Hawking’s famous 1971 “area theorem,” which says that
the surface area of the event horizon of a black hole cannot decrease with time.
Bekenstein then used this definition to formulate the “generalized second law,”
which says that “common entropy plus black hole entropy cannot decrease.” So
throw a cup of tea in and the entropy of the black hole will increase to
compensate for the loss of entropy in its exterior. The second law—or rather a
generalized version of it—has been rescued!
Bekenstein’s findings were published soon after in his 1972 seminal paper “Black
Holes and the Second Law.” And the field of black hole thermodynamics—a now
well-established discipline in physics and a field that keeps many contemporary
physicists awake at night—was born.
ADVERTISEMENT
Nautilus Members enjoy an ad-free experience. Log in or Join now .
All motivated by a seemingly trivial setup about a cup of tea.
Not long after my heady ski trip conversations with El Skaf, I attended a
workshop on the foundations of thermodynamics, held in a beautiful
European-style home in the countryside of Minnesota, where Juan Maldacena, a
leading scientist in black hole physics at Princeton, presented his latest
results. In the talk he stressed the important role of thought experiments for
generating insights into this area that is so out of reach of physical
experimentation and even direct observation.
Afterward, I asked him directly: “How much do your results rely on thought
experiments?” He answered without hesitating: “Nearly 100 percent!”
But are thought experiments useful only in cases in which direct experimentation
is impossible in practice, like impenetrable black holes?
ADVERTISEMENT
Nautilus Members enjoy an ad-free experience. Log in or Join now .
There is a tendency among physicists to think that all the fantasies involved in
thought experiments should eventually be replaced by real, physical experiments.
This thought is probably inherited from the empiricist tradition, the
philosophical position that tells us we can only learn about the real world from
sensory experience and empirical evidence.
> What might happen if you threw a cup of tea into a black hole?
I agree that only real experiments can tell us, more conclusively, how to
resolve the contradictions that are first revealed by thought experiments. But I
also strongly believe that it is only due to the fantasies of thought
experiments that we can see in a clear and intuitive way the inconsistencies and
conflicts between different theories. They allow us—even before a laboratory
experiment could be conceived of—to wonder, what might happen if …
In the past few decades, more philosophers of science have started to stress the
important parallels between fictional literature and science. The philosopher
Roman Frigg, for instance, in his influential paper “Models and Fictions” argues
that scientific models share important aspects in common with literary fiction,
and that theories of fiction can therefore help us better understand how science
works. In science, fiction—and even fantasy—can be used as an instrument to
better understand our theories and the real world. This suggests that the
friction between science and fiction is less sharp than people tend to think.
Nautilus Members enjoy an ad-free experience. Log in or Join now .
Interestingly, this is not far from what Cortázar himself proposed about the two
disciplines. In Literature Class, the book distilled from his Berkeley lectures,
he noted—according to my translation of his Spanish text—that, “it has seemed to
us that literature is a kind of combinatorial art in which fantasy, imagination,
truth, lies, any postulate, any theory” are welcome. Scientists, on the other
hand, he said, it has often seemed, occupied a very different world—one of
certainty, confidence. “But when I read about Heisenberg’s uncertainty
principle, I said ‘damn, they’re like us.’ ”
Lead image by Tasnuva Elahi; with images by Triff and urfin / Shutterstock
* PATRICIA PALACIOS
Posted on August 26, 2024
Patricia Palacios is a philosopher of science at the University of Salzburg
in Austria and an external member of the Munich Center for Mathematical
Philosophy. Her work extends from the thermodynamics of black holes and the
relationship between scientific theories to challenges in the application of
physics to economics and biology.
GET THE NAUTILUS NEWSLETTER
Cutting-edge science, unraveled by the very brightest living thinkers.
NL – In Page Mobile
Email: *
Captcha
If you are human, leave this field blank.
Sign up for free
Zoology
Crows Are Even Smarter Than We Thought
Physics
When Reality Came Undone
Sociology
Placebo Science Is Rooted in Witch Hunts
ADVERTISEMENT
View / Add Comments
*
Explore
WHEN REALITY CAME UNDONE
* By Philip Ball
* August 28, 2024
* Physics
100 years ago, a circle of physicists shook the foundation of science. It’s
still trembling.
*
Explore
PLACEBO SCIENCE IS ROOTED IN WITCH HUNTS
* By Kristen French
* August 27, 2024
* Sociology
How we learned to sort true from false in medicine.
*
Explore
THE HARROWING AND THE BEAUTIFUL
* By Michael Hersch
* August 23, 2024
* Arts
In the darkest reality, this celebrated composer finds his voice.
*
Explore
OUT OF YOUR HEAD
* By Steve Paulson
* August 22, 2024
* Psychology
Exploring psychedelic experiences that seem wider than the brain.
*
Explore
WHEN REALITY FEELS UNREAL
* By Katherine Harmon Courage
* August 21, 2024
* Neuroscience
Why your life sometimes feels alien to you.
NAUTILUS: SCIENCE CONNECTED
Nautilus is a different kind of science magazine. Our stories take you into the
depths of science and spotlight its ripples in our lives and cultures.
GET THE NAUTILUS NEWSLETTER
Cutting-edge science, unraveled by the very brightest living thinkers.
NL – Footer
Email: *
Please check the box below to proceed.
Sign up for free
If you are human, leave this field blank.
QUICK LINKS
* Home
* About Us
* Contact
* FAQ
* Prime
* Ebook
* Shop
* Donate
* Awards and Press
* Privacy Policy
* Terms of Service
* RSS
* Jobs
* Newsletter
* Ethics Policy
SOCIAL
*
*
*
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
© 2024 NautilusNext Inc., All rights reserved.
Enjoy unlimited Nautilus articles, ad-free, for less than $5/month. Join now
! THERE IS NOT AN ACTIVE SUBSCRIPTION ASSOCIATED WITH THAT EMAIL ADDRESS.
ALREADY A MEMBER? LOG IN
JOIN TO CONTINUE READING.
You’ve read your 2 free articles this month. Access unlimited ad-free stories,
including this one, by becoming a Nautilus member.
Join now
! THERE IS NOT AN ACTIVE SUBSCRIPTION ASSOCIATED WITH THAT EMAIL ADDRESS.
ALREADY A MEMBER? LOG IN
THIS IS YOUR LAST FREE ARTICLE.
Don’t limit your curiosity. Access unlimited ad-free stories like this one, and
support independent journalism, by becoming a Nautilus member.
Join now
Literary and always interesting.
To read this story, sign up for the free Nautilus newsletter: science and
culture for people who love beautiful writing.
NL – Emailgate
*
Check the box below to proceed.
Sign up for free
If you are human, leave this field blank.
Notifications