www.politico.eu Open in urlscan Pro
172.67.23.192  Public Scan

Form analysis
1 forms found in the DOM

GET https://www.politico.eu/

<form role="search" id="searchform" class="search-form" method="get" action="https://www.politico.eu/">
  <meta itemprop="target" content="https://www.politico.eu/?s={s}">
  <label for="search-field" class="screen-reader-text"> Search for: </label>
  <span class="algolia-autocomplete" style="position: relative; display: inline-block; direction: ltr;"><input itemprop="query-input" type="search" value="" class="aa-hint" readonly="" aria-hidden="true" autocomplete="off" spellcheck="false"
      tabindex="-1"
      style="position: absolute; top: 0px; left: 0px; border-color: transparent; box-shadow: none; opacity: 1; background: url(&quot;https://www.politico.eu/wp-content/themes/politico/dist/svg/icons/search.svg&quot;) 10.5px 50% / 16.8px no-repeat scroll padding-box border-box rgb(255, 255, 255);"><input
      itemprop="query-input" type="search" id="search-field" value="" placeholder="Search …" name="s" class="aa-input" autocomplete="off" spellcheck="false" role="combobox" aria-autocomplete="list" aria-expanded="false"
      aria-owns="algolia-autocomplete-listbox-0" dir="auto" style="position: relative; vertical-align: top; background-color: transparent;">
    <pre aria-hidden="true"
      style="position: absolute; visibility: hidden; white-space: pre; font-family: Sohne, &quot;Sohne fallback&quot;, sans-serif; font-size: 14px; font-style: normal; font-variant: normal; font-weight: 400; word-spacing: 0px; letter-spacing: normal; text-indent: 0px; text-rendering: auto; text-transform: none;"></pre>
  </span>
  <button type="submit" class="is-button is-style-primary has-size-default search-form__submit">
    <span class="button__label"> Submit </span>
  </button>
</form>

Text Content

Skip to main content
Advertisement


Menu
Search for:



Submit

Edition: Europe
 * Europe
 * UK
 * France
 * Germany
 * US

 * * Policy areas
     * Agriculture and Food
     * Central Banker
     * Competition and Industrial Policy
     * Cybersecurity and Data Protection
     * Defense
     * Energy and Climate
     * Energy and Climate UK
     * Energie et Climat France
     * Financial Services
     * Financial Services UK
     * Health Care
     * Mobility
     * Paris Influence
     * Sustainability
     * Technology
     * Technology UK
     * Trade
     * Trade UK
 * * Newsletters
     * Berlin Bulletin
     * Berlin Playbook
     * Brussels Playbook
     * China Watcher
     * Digital Bridge
     * Dimanchissime
     * EU Election Playbook
     * EU Influence
     * Global Playbook
     * Global Policy Lab: Living Cities
     * London Influence
     * London Playbook
     * Playbook Paris
     * POLITICO Confidential
     * Sunday Crunch
 * * Podcasts
     * EU Confidential
     * Politics at Jack and Sam's
     * Power Play
     * Westminster Insider
   * Opinion
     * All Opinion
     * Beyond the Bubble
     * Club Med
     * Declassified
     * From Across the Pond
     * Unpacked
 * * Featured Series
     * Bots and ballots
     * COP28
     * Living Cities
     * POLITICO 28
     * Qatargate files
   * Poll of polls
     * Elections in Europe
     * European Parliament election
   * Politico Live
     * See All Future Events
     * About our events
 * * Apps
     * Apple Store
     * Google Play Store
   * More Info
     * About Us
     * Media Solutions
     * POLITICO Studio
     * Press
     * Print Edition
     * Contact Us
     * Jobs
     * Careers at POLITICO

POLITICO Pro
Europe
 * Europe
 * UK
 * France
 * Germany
 * US

Log In POLITICO Pro
 * Home
 * Latest news
 * EU election
 * War in Ukraine
 * Israel-Hamas war
 * Farmers' protests
 * Newsletters
 * Podcasts
 * Poll of Polls
 * Policy news
 * Events


 1. News
 2. Politics


BRITAIN OFFLOADS ITS REFUGEE CRISIS TO IRELAND. DUBLIN IS AGHAST.

To Irish eyes, post-Brexit Britain’s toughening message to asylum seekers looks
like “To Rwanda — or to Ireland.”

Listen
Share
 * Share options
 * Copy Link
 * EMail
 * Twitter
 * WhatsApp
 * Linkedin

Ireland is experiencing an unprecedented surge in migration from Britain. | Paul
Faith/AFP via Getty Images
May 3, 2024 4:00 am CET
By Shawn Pogatchnik

DUBLIN – As Britain ramps up efforts to deter asylum seekers, one politically
explosive repercussion is that across the Irish Sea, parts of Dublin are being
turned into foul-smelling refugee camps.

It’s a problem linked to Brexit, and it’s likely to worsen as potentially tens
of thousands flee the U.K.’s increasingly tough asylum policies by re-entering
the EU through its open Irish back door.

Since immigration first became a feature of Irish life amid the Celtic Tiger
boom three decades ago, asylum seekers have typically arrived only after
spending months or even years attempting to settle in neighboring Britain. For
those fleeing war, famine or poverty, the main air links and trafficking routes
have always made it easier to reach Britain than Ireland.

Advertisement

Advertisement


Now, with the U.K.’s tough new immigration laws having finally cleared
Parliament and Prime Minister Rishi Sunak promising to start deporting asylum
seekers within weeks, Ireland is experiencing an unprecedented surge in
migration from Britain.

As asylum seekers flee the Sunak government’s threat to ship them to the East
African nation of Rwanda, with limited rights to appeal, many are leaving
Britain and entering the Republic of Ireland by crossing the checks-free border
with its U.K. neighbor, Northern Ireland.

Spend time chatting with any of the hundreds of single men arriving weekly to
Ireland’s International Protection Office and you’ll learn — from Arabs,
Africans, Afghans and Indians who sometimes speak with unmistakable touches of
regional English accents — that they see Ireland as their last-chance saloon to
stay in Europe, now that Britain has withdrawn the welcome mat.

“I don’t want to go back to Nigeria, and I don’t want to go to Rwanda either,”
said Christian, a 25-year-old Nigerian who has spent the past five years living
in Liverpool and Manchester in the north of England after overstaying a student
visa. He worked his way through the full gamut of the British asylum and appeals
process and is now looking for an alternative place to build a life. “I wanted
to be in Britain. I didn’t know anything about Ireland besides Guinness, but I’m
finding out.”

Like an estimated 80 percent of this year’s approximately 7,000 arrivals in
Ireland, Christian entered the Republic of Ireland by road from the North, the
only corner of the U.K. that shares a land border with an EU member. He says he
paid a taxi driver £2,400 to drive him and two other Nigerians the 102 miles
from Northern Ireland’s capital of Belfast across the border to Dublin — only to
learn that others in the asylum queue had made the same trip by public bus for
£17.


OPEN BORDERS

Keeping the Irish border barrier-free despite Brexit has been crucial for
Ireland’s economy and the hundreds of thousands of Irish citizens who live in
Northern Ireland. But it also makes it exceptionally easy for asylum seekers to
shift without hindrance from the U.K. to Ireland.

Advertisement


Other routes by sea and air aren’t as simple. Although Britain and Ireland have
maintained a Common Travel Area for the past century that gives British and
Irish citizens freedom to live and work in each other’s countries,
police-operated passport controls still operate on the Irish end of U.K. flights
to check the right of non-European Economic Area nationals to enter. Crossing by
vehicle or train from Northern Ireland has grown increasingly popular once Irish
authorities started tightening rules on letting U.K. asylum seekers on to
Ireland-bound aircraft.

Over the past year, Ireland’s Department of Integration and the International
Protection Office have struggled to source enough shelter for 100,000 Ukrainian
war refugees and at least 30,000 asylum seekers already here, amid a national
crisis in housing supply and affordability. A string of derelict properties
earmarked for development as asylum centers have been burned down in suspected
arson attacks by irate locals. Civil servants toiling to manage the fallout
expect pressures to keep building, perhaps to breaking point.

“It’s a madhouse,” said an International Protection Office worker, taking a
smoke break outside the office on Mount Street in the Georgian heart of Dublin.
Nearby, two groups of men — mostly Somalis to the left, Nigerians to the right —
loitered beside rows of tents on sidewalks that had been their home for weeks.
“We’ve nowhere to put them all and more keep coming. There’s no end to it.”

Illustrating the disproportionate nature of the challenge, the approximately
7,000 asylum seekers who have already arrived this year in Ireland mirror the
nearly 7,000 who have crossed over the same period by small boat from France to
England — a country 12 times the population of Ireland. | Paul Faith/AFP via
Getty Images

Starting a year ago, a tent city had been allowed to take root outside the
International Protection Office, snaking along footpaths and alleys down Mount
Street. The shantytown eventually spread past the headquarters of a government
party, Fianna Fáil, and was growing ever closer to the local European Commission
office and the Government Buildings base of Simon Harris, Ireland’s new prime
minister.

But at his weekly Cabinet meeting Tuesday, Harris authorized an operation to
remove the Mount Street refugees, chiefly to a commandeered conference center on
the city’s outskirts, and to a more remote army-style campground featuring
12-man tents.

At dawn Wednesday, a fleet of buses and taxis took nearly 300 men to those
emergency facilities while sanitation staff in hazmat suits cleansed pavements
of months of public urination and piled-up garbage. Police erected barriers of
1,000-kilogram concrete blocks where the tents had stood and told refugees
they’d face immediate arrest if they tried camping on Mount Street again.

Advertisement


But according to the protection office’s own accounts, that barely dented the
problem. The organization’s staff still can’t source shelter for more than 1,500
asylum seekers sleeping rough. Refugee tents remain scattered all over Dublin in
parks, shop fronts, alleyways and along the River Liffey that cuts the city in
two.

Aggravating the situation, dozens of the Mount Street evacuees have already
abandoned their state-supplied communal tents to board buses and return to the
city center. And more than 100 newly arrived applicants Thursday were told the
state had no available beds anywhere to offer, ensuring that new tents will
sprout up in new locations.


SEND THEM BACK?

It’s all proving too much for Ireland, which wants Britain to take back those
with active cases in the U.K.’s own asylum system. Otherwise, officials here
warn, cases chiefly inherited from Britain will top 20,000 in Ireland this year
alone.

Illustrating the disproportionate nature of the challenge, the approximately
7,000 asylum seekers who have already arrived this year in Ireland mirror the
nearly 7,000 who have crossed over the same period by small boat from France to
England — a country 12 times the population of Ireland.

Yet Sunak cites France as the reason England should have no sympathy for the
Irish. He has ruled out accepting any returnees from Ireland unless France
agrees to take back refugees who crossed the English Channel in the first place.

Neither appears likely, even as Harris and his justice minister, Helen McEntee,
publicly argue that an unpublished 2020 Brexit-linked memorandum of
understanding binds Britain to accept refugees back into its system from
Ireland. Britain characterizes that agreement as toothless and non-binding.

Advertisement


Privately, officials in the Department of Justice and prime minister’s office
say they don’t expect a single deportation to Britain unless and until Sunak
loses the next U.K. general election and Labour, opposed to the Rwanda policy,
comes to power.

They note that not a single asylum seeker has been returned to Britain since
December 2020, when Britain left the EU on a wave of anti-immigrant sentiment.

Before that, when Ireland and Britain both were bound to the same EU asylum
rules, such transfers made next to no practical difference for either nation:
from 2015 to 2020, Ireland sent 162 migrants back to Britain, while the British
dispatched 156 in the other direction.





UK NATIONAL PARLIAMENT ELECTION POLL OF POLLS

All 3 Years 2 Years 1 Year 6 Months Smooth Kalman
May 03, 2024Con23 %Lab43 %Lib Dems10 %UKIP1 %Greens6 %SNP2 %Reform12
%ChangeUKPlaid1 %JunJulAugSepOctNovDec2024FebMarAprMay0 %5 %10 %15 %20 %25 %30
%35 %40 %45 %50 %

For more polling data from across Europe visit POLITICO Poll of Polls.

“There is no realistic prospect of the United Kingdom agreeing to help us given
their current political disposition,” said a government official, granted
anonymity to discuss plans yet to be signed off by Cabinet.

“If we’re going to get a handle on this situation before it becomes
overwhelming, we’ll need to deploy maximum resources into processing cases
ourselves as quickly as possible and remove inadmissible cases back to their own
countries wherever possible,” the official said.


NIGERIA TOP OF THE LIST

Private charter aircraft have already been provisionally booked to carry failed
applicants under police guard, the official said, with arrivals from Nigeria a
top priority for deportation. While Nigeria is not on Ireland’s official list of
“safe” countries, meaning arrivals can be returned to their place of origin, it
could be by the end of the year when the flights are earmarked to start, the
official said.

Advertisement


Nigerians are the largest single group currently coming from the U.K,
representing a third of all asylum seekers arriving this year in Ireland. The
department plans to reassign up to 100 police currently handling asylum claims
and refocus them on overseeing deportations once an accelerated legal process
permits this.

Immigrant law experts doubt Ireland will be able to return asylum seekers to the
U.K. as long as the Rwanda provision remains, since human rights lawyers argue
it violates basic elements of the EU’s conventions on refugee rights.

Some government lawmakers in Dublin blame Sunak for treating Ireland’s
difficulty as England’s opportunity.

“His immigration policy seems to be ‘To Rwanda or to Ireland.’ That’s not going
to bode well for future relations,” said Lisa Chambers, a Fianna Fáil senator.

Jim O’Callaghan, another Fianna Fáil legislator whose Dublin constituency
includes the refugee center, offers a different view. He doubts that the Rwanda
threat represents anything more than short-term “optics” for the Tories to win
votes at the British general election expected this fall.

But if U.K. policies of deterrence do become effective and migrant boats do stop
crossing the Channel, O’Callaghan said, this could ultimately benefit Ireland —
because most refugees won’t get farther than France.

“In order to get to Ireland, they’ve got to get into Britain,” O’Callaghan said.
“If people are going to be deterred from going to the U.K., the likelihood is
that they probably then won’t leave the continent.”

Advertisement

Related Tags
Asylum Borders Brexit British politics Elections Elections in Europe Immigration
Migration Refugees Rights U.K. election 2024
Related Countries
England France Ireland Nigeria Northern Ireland Rwanda United Kingdom
Related People
Helen McEntee Rishi Sunak Simon Harris


OUR READERS READ NEXT


HOW MEPS MAKE MILLIONS ON THE SIDE: LEGAL ADVICE, SPEECHES AND COVID CURES

21 HRS ago 4 mins read


NORTH MACEDONIA’S EU ASPIRATIONS FACE BUMPY RIDE AFTER ELECTIONS

23 HRS ago 6 mins read


TEENAGER TURNS HIMSELF IN FOR ASSAULT ON GERMAN LAWMAKER

May 5 2 mins read


SOCIALISTS TO URSULA VON DER LEYEN’S CONSERVATIVES: DON’T WORK WITH FAR RIGHT

May 4 2 mins read


MORE FROM SHAWN POGATCHNIK


AFTER JEFFREY DONALDSON’S BOMBSHELL EXIT, WHAT NEXT FOR NORTHERN IRELAND’S DUP?

As party reels, new leader Gavin Robinson faces a U.K. election that could cost
him his seat.

Apr 5 7 mins read


JEFFREY DONALDSON QUITS AS DUP CHIEF IN BOMBSHELL FOR NORTHERN IRELAND

Unionist party said Donaldson was out “with immediate effect” after being
charged by police.

Mar 29 5 mins read


MEET SIMON HARRIS, IRELAND’S FIRST TIKTOK PRIME MINISTER

New PM built his base on a novel mix of high-energy effort and social media
savvy.

Mar 26 7 mins read


AS LEO VARADKAR DEPARTS, WHO IN THE IRISH GOVERNMENT WILL HOLD OFF SINN FÉIN?

Mainstream parties Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil are seeking to stabilize their
first-time partnership and strand Sinn Féin in opposition.

Mar 22 6 mins read
 * * Facebook
   * Twitter
   * YouTube
 * App Store
 * Play Store

 * * Policy
     * Agriculture and Food
     * Central Banker
     * Competition and Industrial Policy
     * Cybersecurity and Data Protection
     * Defense
     * Energy and Climate
     * Energy and Climate UK
     * Energie et Climat France
     * Financial Services
     * Financial Services UK
     * Health Care
     * Mobility
     * Paris Influence
     * Sustainability
     * Technology
     * Technology UK
     * Trade
     * Trade UK
 * * Newsletters
     * Berlin Bulletin
     * Berlin Playbook
     * Brussels Playbook
     * China Watcher
     * Digital Bridge
     * Dimanchissime
     * EU Election Playbook
     * EU Influence
     * Global Playbook
     * Global Policy Lab: Living Cities
     * London Influence
     * London Playbook
     * Playbook Paris
     * POLITICO Confidential
     * Sunday Crunch
 * * Podcasts
     * EU Confidential
     * Politics at Jack and Sam's
     * Power Play
     * Westminster Insider
   * Opinion
     * All Opinion
     * Beyond the Bubble
     * Club Med
     * Declassified
     * From Across the Pond
     * Unpacked
 * * Featured Series
     * Bots and ballots
     * COP28
     * Living Cities
     * POLITICO 28
     * Qatargate files
   * Subscriptions
     * POLITICO Pro
     * Print Edition
     * Research and analysis division

 * About us
 * Contact us
 * Privacy Policy
 * Cookie Policy
 * Media Solutions
 * Research and Analysis Division
 * Press
 * Print Edition
 * Jobs
 * Careers at POLITICO
 * Ts&Cs
 * FAQs
 * Manage Privacy Settings