www.forbes.com Open in urlscan Pro
151.101.1.55  Public Scan

Form analysis
2 forms found in the DOM

<form class="search-modal__form"><input class="search-modal__input" type="text" placeholder="Search" autofocus=""><button class="search-modal__submit" role="button" tabindex="0" title="Submit"><svg class="fs-icon fs-icon--arrow-right"
      xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" viewBox="0 0 24 24">
      <path d="M12.6 6.4l4.6 4.6H3v2h14.2l-4.6 4.6L14 19l7-7-7-7z"></path>
    </svg></button></form>

<form id="zephr-registration-form-M-l1TsBw" class="zephr-registration-form" style="--zephr-color-text-main:#000000;
--zephr-color-text-tinted:#333333;
--zephr-color-background-main:#FFFFFF;
--zephr-color-background-tinted:#cccccc;
--zephr-color-accent-main:#DCF1FB;
--zephr-color-accent-tinted:#81cdf1;
--zephr-color-action-main:#006EDB;
--zephr-color-action-tinted:#0f87ff;
--zephr-color-warning-main:#D90B00;
--zephr-color-warning-tinted:#ff190d;
--zephr-typography-title-font:Roboto;
--zephr-typography-title-fallbackFont:sans-serif;
--zephr-typography-body-font:Roboto;
--zephr-typography-body-fallbackFont:sans-serif;
--zephr-button-fontWeight:normal;
--zephr-button-fontSize:16;
--zephr-button-borderWidth:0;
--zephr-button-borderRadius:9;
--zephr-button-height:50;
--zephr-input-borderColor:#333333;
--zephr-input-borderWidth:1;
--zephr-input-borderRadius:5;
--zephr-input-height:50;
">
  <div class="zephr-registration-form-text svelte-i1fi5">
    <h4>Sign in or create your account</h4>
  </div><label class="zephr-registration-form-input-label svelte-1ok5fdj" for="zephr-registration-form-identifier-M-l1TsBw" style=""><span class="svelte-1ok5fdj">Email</span> </label>
  <div class="zephr-registration-form-relative-container"><input id="zephr-registration-form-identifier-M-l1TsBw" name="email" required="" type="email" placeholder="Enter your email"
      class="zephr-registration-form-input zephr-registration-form-input-email svelte-blfh8x" autocomplete="username"> </div><button class="zephr-registration-form-button svelte-17g75t9" type="submit" disabled="">Sign In Or Register</button>
  <div class=" svelte-1wyy3bx" id="zephr-recaptcha-badge-M-l1TsBw"></div>
  <div class="zephr-registration-form-divider-container svelte-mk4m8o">
    <div class="zephr-registration-form-divider-line svelte-mk4m8o"></div> <span class="zephr-registration-form-divider-text svelte-mk4m8o">OR USE</span>
    <div class="zephr-registration-form-divider-line svelte-mk4m8o"></div>
  </div>
  <div class="social-sign-in-flex-container">
    <div class="zephr-registration-form-button zephr-registration-form-social-sign-in-button svelte-gp4ky7">
      <div class="zephr-registration-form-flex-container zephr-registration-form-social-sign-in svelte-gp4ky7">
        <div class="zephr-registration-form-social-sign-in-icon svelte-gp4ky7"><svg class="zephr-registration-form-social-sign-in-icon zephr-registration-form-google-icon svelte-1jnblvg" viewBox="0 0 533.5 544.3" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg">
            <path d="M533.5 278.4c0-18.5-1.5-37.1-4.7-55.3H272.1v104.8h147c-6.1 33.8-25.7 63.7-54.4 82.7v68h87.7c51.5-47.4 81.1-117.4 81.1-200.2z" fill="#4285f4"></path>
            <path d="M272.1 544.3c73.4 0 135.3-24.1 180.4-65.7l-87.7-68c-24.4 16.6-55.9 26-92.6 26-71 0-131.2-47.9-152.8-112.3H28.9v70.1c46.2 91.9 140.3 149.9 243.2 149.9z" fill="#34a853"></path>
            <path d="M119.3 324.3c-11.4-33.8-11.4-70.4 0-104.2V150H28.9c-38.6 76.9-38.6 167.5 0 244.4l90.4-70.1z" fill="#fbbc04"></path>
            <path d="M272.1 107.7c38.8-.6 76.3 14 104.4 40.8l77.7-77.7C405 24.6 339.7-.8 272.1 0 169.2 0 75.1 58 28.9 150l90.4 70.1c21.5-64.5 81.8-112.4 152.8-112.4z" fill="#ea4335"></path>
          </svg></div> Continue with Google
      </div>
    </div>
    <div class="zephr-registration-form-button zephr-registration-form-social-sign-in-button svelte-gp4ky7">
      <div class="zephr-registration-form-flex-container zephr-registration-form-social-sign-in svelte-gp4ky7">
        <div class="zephr-registration-form-social-sign-in-icon svelte-gp4ky7"><svg id="" class="svelte-fa svelte-1cj2gr0" style="height:1em;line-height:.75em;font-size:1.33333em;vertical-align:-.225em;transform-origin:center;overflow:visible"
            viewBox="0 0 512 512" aria-hidden="true" role="img" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg">
            <g transform="translate(256 256)" transform-origin="128 0">
              <g transform="translate(0,0) scale(1,1)">
                <path
                  d="M504 256C504 119 393 8 256 8S8 119 8 256c0 123.78 90.69 226.38 209.25 245V327.69h-63V256h63v-54.64c0-62.15 37-96.48 93.67-96.48 27.14 0 55.52 4.84 55.52 4.84v61h-31.28c-30.8 0-40.41 19.12-40.41 38.73V256h68.78l-11 71.69h-57.78V501C413.31 482.38 504 379.78 504 256z"
                  fill="#1877f2" transform="translate(-256 -256)"></path>
              </g>
            </g>
          </svg></div> Continue with Facebook
      </div>
    </div>
  </div>
</form>

Text Content

Subscribe To Newsletters

Subscribe
Sign In























BETA
This is a BETA experience. You may opt-out by clicking here
Edit Story
ForbesInnovationCybersecurity
Editors' Pick


THE FBI FORCED A SUSPECT TO UNLOCK AMAZON’S ENCRYPTED APP WICKR WITH THEIR FACE

Thomas Brewster
Forbes Staff
Senior writer at Forbes covering cybercrime, privacy and surveillance.
FollowingFollow

Click to save this article.
You'll be asked to sign into your Forbes account.
Got it

0
Jul 19, 2022,12:30pm EDT
 * Share to Facebook
 * Share to Twitter
 * Share to Linkedin



A warrant allowed FBI agents in Tennessee to force a suspect to unlock his
encrypted Amazon messaging app, Wickr, with his face. It's an unprecedented move
by the feds.

getty


THE FEDS ARE USING AN UNPRECEDENTED TYPE OF SEARCH WARRANT TO OBTAIN ENCRYPTED
COMMUNICATIONS THAT THE AGENCY SAYS ARE NEARLY IMPOSSIBLE TO ACCESS OTHERWISE.



--------------------------------------------------------------------------------



In November last year, an undercover agent with the FBI was inside a group on
Amazon-owned messaging app Wickr, with a name referencing young girls. The group
was devoted to sharing child sexual abuse material (CSAM) within the protection
of the encrypted app, which is also used by the U.S. government, journalists and
activists for private communications. Encryption makes it almost impossible for
law enforcement to intercept messages sent over Wickr, but this agent had found
a way to infiltrate the chat, where they could start piecing together who was
sharing the material.



As part of the investigation into the members of this Wickr group, the FBI used
a previously unreported search warrant method to force one member to unlock the
encrypted messaging app using his face. The FBI has previously forced users to
unlock an iPhone with Face ID, but this search warrant, obtained by Forbes,
represents the first known public record of a U.S. law enforcement agency
getting a judge’s permission to unlock an encrypted messaging app with someone’s
biometrics.



According to the warrant, the FBI first tracked down the suspect by sending a
request for information, via an unnamed foreign law enforcement partner, to the
cloud storage provider hosting the illegal images. That gave them the Gmail
address the FBI said belonged to Christopher Terry, a 53-year-old Knoxville,
Tennessee resident, who had prior convictions for possession of child
exploitation material. It also provided IP addresses used to create the links to
the CSAM. From there, investigators asked Google and Comcast via administrative
subpoenas (data requests that don’t have the same level of legal requirements as
search warrants) for more identifying information that helped them track down
Terry and raid his home.




When they apprehended Terry, the FBI obtained his unlocked phone as well. But
there was a problem: His Wickr account was locked with Apple’s Face ID facial
recognition security. “By the time it was made known to the FBI that facial
recognition was needed to access the locked application Wickr, Terry had asked
for an attorney,” the FBI noted in its warrant. “Therefore, the United States
seeks this additional search warrant seeking Terry’s biometric facial
recognition… to complete the search of Terry’s Apple iPhone 11.”



> “Most courts are going to find they can force you to use your face to unlock
> your phone because it's not compelling you to speak or incriminate
> yourself...”

After the FBI successfully forced Terry to use his face to unlock his Wickr
account, Terry was charged in a criminal complaint with distribution and
possession of CSAM, but has not yet offered a plea. His lawyer did not respond
to a request for comment at the time of publication.



Amazon’s Wickr hadn’t provided comment at time of publication. The FBI, Google
and Comcast did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

Forcing people to unlock encrypted messaging with their biometrics is
unprecedented — and controversial. That’s because of an illogical quirk in U.S.
law: Courts across the U.S. have not allowed investigators to compel people to
hand over a passcode for phones or apps, but they have allowed them to
repeatedly unlock phones using biometrics. That’s despite the obvious fact that
the result is the same.

Jerome Greco, a public defender in the Digital Forensics Unit of the Legal Aid
Society in New York City, says this is because American law hasn’t caught up
with the technology. Passcodes, unlike biometric information, are legally
considered “testimonial,” and citizens are not obliged to provide such testimony
because the Fifth Amendment protects you from self-incrimination. But body parts
are, by their nature, not as private as a person’s thoughts, Greco notes.

“Most courts are going to find they can force you to use your face to unlock
your phone because it's not compelling you to speak or incriminate yourself...
similar to fingerprints or DNA,” Greco says.

But he believes there will soon be enough diverging case law for the Supreme
Court to have to decide whether or not compelled facial recognition unlocks are
lawful. “We're trying to apply centuries-old constitutional law that no one
could have envisioned would have been an issue when the laws were written,” he
says. “I think the fight is coming.”

There has been some pushback over such biometric unlocks from judges in some
states. That includes two 2019 cases in California and Idaho, where the police
wanted to force open phones inside properties relevant to the investigations.
The judges in those cases declared biometric data was, in fact, testimonial, and
law enforcement couldn’t force the owners of those phones to use their faces to
unlock them.



But last year, Forbes revealed the Justice Department was continuing to carry
out such searches. It had also adopted new language in its warrants that said
suspects have a legal right to decline to tell law enforcement whether it’s your
face, your finger, or your eye that unlocks your phone. But even if you don’t
say what will unlock your phone, the DOJ said investigators could unlock your
device by simply holding it up to your face or pressing your finger to it.

The search also comes after years of campaigning by the FBI to have tech giants
provide more assistance in providing access to encrypted data. Since the 2015
San Bernardino terrorist attack, where the Justice Department demanded Apple
open the shooter’s iPhone, that debate has intensified. The warrant, however,
shows the government does have some techniques it can use to find criminals
using the likes of Wickr and its encrypted data.

For now, Greco says the best way a person can protect themselves from such
searches is to lock a device with a complex passcode rather than a face. It’s
possible to do the same with Wickr by disabling Touch ID or Face ID.

Follow me on Twitter. Check out my website. Send me a secure tip. 
Thomas Brewster
Follow



I'm a senior writer for Forbes, covering security, surveillance and privacy. I'm
also the editor of The Wiretap newsletter, which has exclusive stories on
real-world surveillance and all the

... Read More



 * Editorial Standards
 * Print
 * Reprints & Permissions








1 of 4 free articles
Subscribe to journalism that illuminates, informs and inspires.
Subscribe Now


SIGN IN OR CREATE YOUR ACCOUNT

Email

Sign In Or Register


OR USE


Continue with Google

Continue with Facebook









auto PREMIUM
Want to save more articles? Subscribe today.
You've reached your limit of articles you can save without a subscription.
Subscribe now to save as many articles as you want.

Premium Journalism, deeply reported stories and breaking news

Members-only events
Subscribe
Subscriptions renew automatically. You may cancel your subscription at any time.