legacy.aintitcool.com Open in urlscan Pro
99.84.108.23  Public Scan

Submitted URL: http://www.aintitcool.com//node//32743
Effective URL: https://legacy.aintitcool.com/node/32743
Submission: On July 13 via api from US — Scanned from US

Form analysis 0 forms found in the DOM

Text Content

Ain't It Cool News

Ain't It Cool News (www.aintitcool.com)
 * Home
 * Cool News
 * Coaxial
 * Reviews
 * Comics
 * Contact
 * Search


Movie News


AICN EXCLUSIVE! SO WHAT’S GOING ON WITH WATCHMEN CASTING?!

Published at: May 21, 2007, 3:30 p.m. CST by Moriarty




A LONGTIME SOURCE REARED HIS HEAD TODAY AND PASSED ON A FEW TIPS ABOUT FACES
WE’RE LIKELY TO SEE IN WATCHMEN WHEN ZACK SNYDER’S FILM VERSION OF THE
LONG-IN-DEVELOPMENT GRAPHIC NOVEL ADAPTATION FINALLY MAKES ITS WAY TO THE SCREEN
IN 2008, AND SOME OF IT’S SURPRISING, WHILE SOME OF IT ISN’T AT ALL. RIGHT NOW,
THERE ARE OFFERS OUT TO THREE PEOPLE TO JOIN THE CAST. IF THE STUDIO’S GOTTEN TO
THE POINT WHERE THEY’RE OFFICIALLY MAKING AN OFFER, YOU CAN EXPECT THAT THESE
PEOPLE WILL MOST LIKELY MAKE IT INTO THE FILM. SO THAT MEANS WE’LL SEE THE PROM
KING, PATRICK WILSON, SUIT UP AS NIGHT OWL. I THINK HE’S A GREAT CHOICE FOR DAN,
AND ALL YOU NEED TO DO IS LOOK AT THE WORK HE DID IN LITTLE CHILDREN AS AN
EXAMPLE OF THE SORT OF QUIET SADNESS HE’LL BRING TO THE ROLE. DR. MANHATTAN IS A
TRICKY PART, AND THERE’S SOMETHING ALIEN AND OTHERWORLDLY ABOUT HIM. KEANU
REEVES ALWAYS SEEMS TO ME TO BE ON A DIFFERENT WAVELENGTH THAN ANYONE ELSE ON
THE PLANET, SO WHEN HE STEPS INTO THE PART AS THE BIG BLUE SUPERBEING, IT MIGHT
BE A NICE FIT. AND IN THE BIGGEST “DUH” OF THE YEAR, JUDE LAW HAS BEEN OFFERED
THE ROLE OF ADRIEN VEIDT, AKA OZYMANDIAS. PERFECT CHOICE, AND LAW’S BEEN SAYING
FOR YEARS THAT HE IS A HUGE FAN OF THE MATERIAL. IF ANYONE OUT THERE IS MORE
RIGHT FOR THE ROLE, I DON’T KNOW WHO IT IS. HOPEFULLY WE’LL HAVE MORE WATCHMEN
NEWS FOR YOU AS IT DEVELOPS, AND MY THANKS TO THE ALWAYS-WATCHFUL BOSS HOGG FOR
THE HEADS UP.

DREW MCWEENY, LOS ANGELES

Follow drewathitfix
 * Share on Facebook
 * Share on Twitter



Readers Talkback

Please enable JavaScript to view the comments powered by Disqus.
   + Expand All
   

 * May 21, 2007 3:33 PM CST
   
   BOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
   
   by Punch Man
   
   at Jude Law Tom Cruise would have been perfect

 * May 21, 2007 3:34 PM CST
   
   YAAAY!
   
   by foreverguardian
   
   so looking forward to this

 * May 21, 2007 3:35 PM CST
   
   MARK HAMIL AS RORSCHACH
   
   by CarbonGhost
   
   wouldn't that be cool?

 * May 21, 2007 3:35 PM CST
   
   WILLIAM H. MACY...
   
   by Neil Peart
   
   ...should play Rorschach.

 * May 21, 2007 3:35 PM CST
   
   NOT KEANU
   
   by KinoEye
   
   please... please no

 * May 21, 2007 3:35 PM CST
   
   IS THIS SKEWING KINDA YOUNG?
   
   by Wed Vid Guy
   
   For some reason I thought of a more middle aged cast. Still not a bad line-up

 * May 21, 2007 3:35 PM CST
   
   KEANU AS DR. MANHATTAN?!?!
   
   by GiggityGoo
   
   I can understand your reasoning, Moriarty, but... that role requires someone
   who can pull off the sadness required towards the end of the story, and not a
   one-note mannequin.
   
   I guess I need to wait to reserve judgment, but... I was hoping for someone
   with better acting chops.

 * May 21, 2007 3:36 PM CST
   
   DR. MANHATTAN'S REACTION TO CREATING A CRYSTAL PALACE..
   
   by Aquatarkusman
   
   .. on Mars: "Whoa"

 * May 21, 2007 3:36 PM CST
   
   JUDE IS PERFECT CASTING, I'D
   
   by csssgl
   
   Jude is perfect casting, I'd say Wilson would have to put on a few pounds to
   make it perfect... looks good so far... 'cept Keanu... I'll have to see what
   they do with him and how they do it, but I'm open to the idea. Dr. Manhattan
   looks like it'd be hard to do.

 * May 21, 2007 3:37 PM CST
   
   SOUNDS LIKE SHIT TO ME
   
   by Rat Fink
   
   this will be terrible

 * May 21, 2007 3:39 PM CST
   
   KEANU AS DR. MANHATTAN?!?! (ECHO IN HERE)
   
   by chrth
   
   Whilst I worship at the throne of Keanu, I do NOT see that.

 * May 21, 2007 3:39 PM CST
   
   JOHN C MCGINLEY FOR RORSCHACH
   
   by Unbirthday
   
   Dr Cox as Rorschach. Nuff said.

 * May 21, 2007 3:39 PM CST
   
   SHIA LABEOUF HAS BEEN CAST AS SILK SPECTRE!!!
   
   by Err
   
   Phenomenal casting!

 * May 21, 2007 3:40 PM CST
   
   CIVILIAN
   
   by Spaz_Monkey
   
   Jude Law as Ozymandias? Perfect. Soon as I heard that, i couldn't picture
   anyone else but him in the role. I agree that Hammill would be AWESOME as
   Rorschach. MH has been impressing the fanboys for over 15 years with his
   voiceover work, but he needs a good movie role to break him out of the "Luke
   Skywalker" mindset everyone has of him, and this would be it. I can't quite
   see anyone as the Silk Spectre. Nobody currently has the 'it' factor needed
   to play her. Probably better off getting an unknown or indie actress to take
   on that role.

 * May 21, 2007 3:40 PM CST
   
   JUDE FECKIN LAW! FECK NO!!!
   
   by sillypig
   
   I've no feckin idea why that sissy bum is getting jobs! He can't act and
   nobody likes the fooker. Also too fraggin short. Jood hasn't cannot pull off
   the role of the brainiest man on Earth. On the otherhand if he muscles up and
   they ugly-fi the guy he would be ok as Rawshark but that only if they force
   Jood down our throats.

 * May 21, 2007 3:40 PM CST
   
   WHOA
   
   by DaleTremont
   
   Dr. Manhattan: Whoa.

 * May 21, 2007 3:41 PM CST
   
   WED VID GUY
   
   by slfricky
   
   They also have to be able to play the younger versions in the flashbacks, so
   it probably makes more sense to get younger actors who can get some minimal
   makeup to age them, than to get middle aged actors and expect them to
   convincingly portray 20 something versions of the characters as well.

 * May 21, 2007 3:42 PM CST
   
   WILL DR. MANHATTAN SEEK OUT THE ORACLE FOR GUIDANCE?
   
   by Err
   
   I hope so.

 * May 21, 2007 3:42 PM CST
   
   LIFETIME ORIGINALS VERSION
   
   by epitone
   
   Matthew Modine as Night Owl, Billy Campbell as Dr. Manhattan, Dan Futterman
   as Ozymandias.

 * May 21, 2007 3:42 PM CST
   
   I WISH THEY HAD GONE A LITTLE OLDER WITH THE CASTING.
   
   by herow/1000faces
   
   Think John Cusack as Nite Owl. (I actually always pictured William Hurt as
   Nite Owl - even older casting.) As it stands - I vote for Paul Bettany for
   Rorschach.

 * May 21, 2007 3:42 PM CST
   
   KEANU NOT MANHATTAN! MANHATTAN = NEAL MCDONOUGH...
   
   by stlfilmwire
   
   Remember that actor from Boomtown and Band of Brothers? HE'S Dr. Manhattan.
   Keanu? Please don't cast him!

 * May 21, 2007 3:43 PM CST
   
   KEANU REEVES
   
   by WISEBLOOD
   
   Will fuck this film up. HE IS WORTHLESS. I still dont get why he has any kind
   of career outside of TED. My boner just went down for this film.

 * May 21, 2007 3:43 PM CST
   
   UM, EW.
   
   by caltsoudas
   
   Okay Jude Law IS agood choice in my opinion for Ozymandias, but the other two
   are definately all wrong. Keanu shouldn't be let anywhere near something like
   Watchmen and Wilson is WAY too fit and good looking. I imagined someone older
   and out of shape for that part, like Paul Giamatti or something. As for Dr.
   Manhattan, I pictured someone like Djimon Hounsou playing him, whom I think
   would be perfect.

 * May 21, 2007 3:43 PM CST
   
   JUDE LAW SHOULD BE DOC MANHATTAN!!!
   
   by Forestal
   
   Keanu Reeves????? That doesn't make sense....

 * May 21, 2007 3:45 PM CST
   
   NOT SKEWING YOUNG...
   
   by jimmy_009
   
   They will have to flashback to younger versions of them. My guess is it's
   easier to make a young person look older than an older person look young
   again. Hence, get younger actors.

 * May 21, 2007 3:45 PM CST
   
   RORSCHACH IS EITHER WILLIAM H MACY, JACKIE EARLE HALEY
   
   by stlfilmwire
   
   or uhh... David Caruso.

 * May 21, 2007 3:45 PM CST
   
   I NEVER READ WATCHMEN...
   
   by DerLanghaarige
   
   ...but I'm not sure if Keanu Reeves and Jude Law be considered as great
   casting for anything.

 * May 21, 2007 3:45 PM CST
   
   I NEVER READ WATCHMEN...
   
   by DerLanghaarige
   
   ...but I'm not sure if Keanu Reeves and Jude Law can be considered as great
   casting for anything.

 * May 21, 2007 3:45 PM CST
   
   DOUG JONES AS DR MANHATTAN
   
   by DOGSOUP
   
   You know you want it. Ron Pearlman as The Comedian!

 * May 21, 2007 3:46 PM CST
   
   ERIC STOLTZ AS RORSCHACH
   
   by csssgl
   
   or Sam Rockwell.

 * May 21, 2007 3:46 PM CST
   
   WOW THIS MOVIE IS STILL MOVING FORWARD?
   
   by IAmLegolas
   
   Good luck with that...

 * May 21, 2007 3:46 PM CST
   
   ANDY SERKIS FOR RORSCHACH.
   
   by AnchorpersonOnTV
   
   Take that.

 * May 21, 2007 3:47 PM CST
   
   GOOD CASTING CHOICE FOR NIGHT OWL
   
   by vinceklortho
   
   in a smart, handsome, nerdy type of guy. A couple questions in regards to the
   story of Watchmen, which I'm sure have already been discussed. So, I'm sorry.
   BUT, will this take place in the 80's alternate universe NYC with Nixon as
   President and have flashbacks to the forties, sixties when explaining the
   origins of the groups? Plus, how are they going to do the parallel cannibal
   story that that kid reads at the newstand. Not to mention the totally in
   depth history of most of the characters. If you skimp on this stuff, you
   basically have a generic superhero whodunit story. It's the details and
   history which makes the book great.

 * May 21, 2007 3:47 PM CST
   
   WHAT IS THIS WATCHMEN YOU SPEAK OF? IS IT LIKE X-MEN
   
   by purplemonkeydw
   
   annoying geeky fanboy explosion in 3...2...1

 * May 21, 2007 3:47 PM CST
   
   YOU CAN MAKE YOUNG ACTORS LOOK OLDER EASILY
   
   by Multiplex
   
   but making old actors look younger (for the Minutemen flashbacks) is a lot
   harder. X-Men 3 did it well (it's about the only thing that shitfest did
   well), but it also cost some money -- money Watchmen could be spending
   elsewhere. And, caltsoudas, Wilson can eat some sandwiches to fatten up.
   Christ, why is it that fanboys have no imagination whatsoever?

 * May 21, 2007 3:48 PM CST
   
   DOUG HUTCHINSON FOR RORSHACH
   
   by Err
   
   Do it! Do it! Do it! Do it! Do it! Do it! Do it! Do it! Do it! Do it! Do it!
   Do it! Do it! Do it! Do it! Do it! Do it! Do it! Do it! Do it! Do it! Do it!
   Do it! Do it! Do it! Do it! Do it! Do it! Do it! Do it! Do it! Do it! Do it!
   Do it! Do it! Do it! Do it! Do it! Do it! Do it! Do it! Do it! Do it! Do it!
   Do it! Do it! Do it! Do it! Do it! Do it! Do it! Do it! Do it! Do it! Do it!
   Do it! Do it! Do it! Do it! Do it!

 * May 21, 2007 3:49 PM CST
   
   NICE CALL STLFILMWIRE.
   
   by herow/1000faces
   
   Jackie Earle Haley is a great choice for Rorschach. Also, I agree with
   caltsoudas...Patrick Wilson seems a better fit for Dr. Manhattan then Nite
   Owl. If they were going a little older with casting I'd say John Corbett
   might make a good Osterman/Manhattan.

 * May 21, 2007 3:49 PM CST
   
   IF TOM CRUISE HAD GET THE OZY ROLE...
   
   by slfricky
   
   You know they wouldn't get to use the line from when Rorschach is writing
   about his meeting with him: "Possibly homosexual? Must investigate further".
   And Manhattan is meant to be a cold, emotionless being for most of the film.
   Who better for emotionless performances than Keanu!

 * May 21, 2007 3:50 PM CST
   
   VINCEKLORTHO
   
   by Err
   
   From what I heard...
   
   Yes to the 80s timesetting. It's supposed to take place in the 80s. As for
   the Pirate story, rumors circulated that for time constraints, they might
   have to cut the Black Freighter parallel storyline.

 * May 21, 2007 3:50 PM CST
   
   PLUS I ACTUALLY PICTURED
   
   by caltsoudas
   
   Plus I actually pictured Jennifer Aniston as being a good Silk Spectre. Just
   because she seems so jaded and cranky all the time. Aniston is good at doing
   bitchy without coming off as a bitch and she's got that not too young/not too
   old/but still easy on the eyes thing going on.

 * May 21, 2007 3:51 PM CST
   
   FIRST?
   
   by Romoehlio
   
   no way...still: WHERES RATCHET??

 * May 21, 2007 3:52 PM CST
   
   JUDE LAW -WRONG CHOICE.
   
   by Punch Man
   
   I don't care if he has a Watchmen tattoo on his face, he's wrong for Ozy. He
   looks too young and will probably come off as too arrogant, AV was supposed
   to be likable. Keanu I'm Ok with for now until i see the make-up. It would
   have been better to get an unknown though.

 * May 21, 2007 3:53 PM CST
   
   DR. MANHATTAN
   
   by Mr_X
   
   from what i remember from the books (read about 20 years ago, manhattan was a
   huge muscular blue guy. I cant see keanu playing that. although they can do
   anything with cgi aka tasg in the 300.Djimon Hounsou would be good but his
   accent would fark it up. needs someone who can act like brent spiner, like a
   emotionaless andriod. hold on.. keanus perfect!

 * May 21, 2007 3:56 PM CST
   
   STLFILMWIRE: NEAL MCDONOUGH?
   
   by refrigerator
   
   I think you meant casting him as Ozymandias perhaps?

 * May 21, 2007 3:57 PM CST
   
   ARENT THESE GUYS SUPPOSED TO BE IN THEIR 40'S AT LEAST?
   
   by BEARison Ford
   
   Interesting, although as others have said, it's easier to age rather than
   de-age. Dunno about Keanu, we'll see.

 * May 21, 2007 3:59 PM CST
   
   STLFILMWIRE: NEAL MCDONOUGH PERFECT FOR...
   
   by Calico Pete
   
   Captain America!

 * May 21, 2007 3:59 PM CST
   
   YOU DON'T NEED TO AGE KEANU
   
   by chrth
   
   Remember, Doc Manhattan doesn't age anymore.

 * May 21, 2007 4:00 PM CST
   
   LEE EVANS = RORSHACH
   
   by ducki3x
   
   I have been convinced for years that Lee Evans would make the perfect
   Rorshach. He has the mix of physicality and runty-scrawnyness that the role
   needs...

 * May 21, 2007 4:02 PM CST
   
   CLIVE OWEN AS THE COMEDIAN
   
   by Calico Pete
   
   or else Russell Crowe? Kurt Russell? Edward James Olmos?

 * May 21, 2007 4:05 PM CST
   
   DR. MANHATTAN WAS ANNOYING...
   
   by Aznbuddy
   
   Seriously, he was annoying to his first wife, his second wife and to the
   readers because he was too self-involved. Aloof. Keanu would be perfect for
   that! I admit I didn't like his casting in Constantine, but after watching
   it, I was totally fine with it. If they cast him, he'll do fine. And so will
   Jude Law and the other guy.
   
   It's the casting of Silk Spectre, Laurie, that we should all be worried
   about. If they Alba-fy this casting, it'll be horrible. You cannot make a
   Watchmen 2 to make up for it. You fuck up Laurie Juspeczyk, you fuck up the
   Watchmen.

 * May 21, 2007 4:07 PM CST
   
   TOM CRUISE AS OZYMANDIAS
   
   by godoffireinhell
   
   Would have been perfect, considering where Ozymandias ends up. It would have
   been a brave choice and pretty much the only Tom Cruise project I'd have
   looked forward to.

 * May 21, 2007 4:07 PM CST
   
   HEROES-WATCHMEN
   
   by Punch Man
   
   I don't think it's such a big problem, don't you think that the audience of
   Heroes are comprised mostly of comic book fans who know Watchmen already ?

 * May 21, 2007 4:08 PM CST
   
   RORSHACH = DAVID CARUSO
   
   by Skinny White Lad
   
   Freckled, Red Headed, and Calm Intensity. Clearly the obvious choice.

 * May 21, 2007 4:09 PM CST
   
   SNYDER IS GOING TO BUTCHER THIS ADAPTATION
   
   by Dannychico
   
   He is a horrible choice for Watchmen. Yes, he can direct the hell out of an
   action scene, and he can turn a stylized graphic novel into a beautiful
   on-screen vision. Unfortunately, Watchmen isn't really stylized at all, and
   there are basically ZERO action scenes. Nothing in Snyder's ouevre shows he
   can handle the depth that this material demands.

 * May 21, 2007 4:10 PM CST
   
   OFF THE TOP OF MY HEAD
   
   by Mr_X
   
   John Billingsley as night owl, tom selleck as the comedian.Jeffrey Combs as
   Rorschach and Aaron Eckhart as Ozymandias

 * May 21, 2007 4:12 PM CST
   
   YUL BRYNNER FOR DR. MANHATTAN!
   
   by ShaunTheEdifice
   
   Who is with me?

 * May 21, 2007 4:12 PM CST
   
   SEHR INTERESSANT, JA?
   
   by evil mystical ninja
   
   Doc Manhattan always came across as a tall dude in the novel, and I don't
   associate Ted with tall. I know CGI allows lotsa stuff to happen but it just
   wouldn't look right, or at least in my head it doesn't.
   
   I agree wholeheartedly with the peeps that said Doug Jones should get it -
   and I add that I think he should get to do the voice work as well because
   that dude CAN NOT catch a break, and it sucks!
   
   The Dr Cox for Rorschach made me go "hmmmmm" for a second but I changed my
   mind after that minute.
   
   I've never seen Mr Wilson (except that old guy in Dennis) so no comment on
   him... But agree with the "expected someone fatter/out of shape."
   
   Perlman as The Comedian would be fuckin awesome... Doug Jones for Doc...
   would be cool if they found a "nobody" who was perfect for Rorschach... The
   chicks would be quite difficult actually - as long as it's not Jessica Alba
   for Silk Spectre II im happy. Ozymandias, I've got a friend who looks exactly
   like the character in the comic, but he can;t act.

 * May 21, 2007 4:14 PM CST
   
   THIS SHIT JUST GOT REAL
   
   by Saluki
   
   I'm not seeing the Manhattan - Keanu connection, but SOMEONE has to play him,
   so it at least should be someone who is going to bring some attention and
   devotation to the role. He gets too much shit from fanboys, so I'm just going
   to wait until I go all yay or nay.

 * May 21, 2007 4:15 PM CST
   
   RORSCHACH CASTING
   
   by MrSpeed
   
   I think William H. Macy would be a fine choice for the character, as would
   Eric Stoltz, but after seeing Shawn of the Dead and Hot Fuzz, Simon Pegg has
   my vote.

 * May 21, 2007 4:15 PM CST
   
   DAMIAN LEWIS FOR RORSCHACH
   
   by CeeBeeUK
   
   The guy from Band of Brothers, red head, tough, good actor... What more could
   you ask for?

 * May 21, 2007 4:17 PM CST
   
   THIS YEAR'S LITTLE MISS HEROES!!!
   
   by Pennsy
   
   It took 63 posts for somebody to say that? ;)

 * May 21, 2007 4:18 PM CST
   
   INTERESTING SO FAR
   
   by one9deuce
   
   I can see Keanu as Dr. Manhattan, but not as the scientist who becomes Dr.
   Manhattan. If that makes sense. Patrick Wilson is a good choice for Nite Owl
   2, I like that casting. Jude Law is a great choice for Ozymandius. He is an
   exceptional actor and a great looking and charismatic guy. He will own that
   part.
   
   Rorschach is the pivotal role though. Jackie Earle Haley is a very
   interesting choice. And anyone saying John C. McGinley should be Rorschach,
   please go actually read WATCHMEN.

 * May 21, 2007 4:18 PM CST
   
   ALWAYS ON THE BALL
   
   by Khrono
   
   Great post as always Moriarty, Looking forward to more Watchmen news as I am
   a fan of the material also.

 * May 21, 2007 4:22 PM CST
   
   JUDE LAW MAKES A GREAT ME
   
   by AdrianVeidt
   
   I've always said that if anyone should play me it should be Jude Law.
   However, I'm not a dumb ass and would not cheat on someone as effing hot as
   Sienna Miller. Idiot.

 * May 21, 2007 4:24 PM CST
   
   HEROES WILL BEAT IT TO THE PUNCH
   
   by CallerFromLA
   
   By the time Watchmen comes out, the whole story will have been told by Heroes
   on NBC. They are closely following the Watchmen concept and storyline. It's
   just not a giant squid thingy, it's a man gone nuclear, which is even more
   dramatic. It would be nice if the Heroes writers acknowledged this parallel
   in some episode.

 * May 21, 2007 4:25 PM CST
   
   NO DOUG JONES FOR MANHATTAN...
   
   by Aznbuddy
   
   Because then we'd have a Blue Silver Surfer. Who wasn't silver. And just as
   nekkid.

 * May 21, 2007 4:25 PM CST
   
   YOU FUCK UP LAURIE JUSPECZYK, YOU FUCK UP THE WATCHMEN.
   
   by Canada's King
   
   Aznbuddy's post a few up top is on the mark about Silk Spectre. She's the
   generational glue that holds the two eras of Watchmen together, as well as
   connecting all the other characters. In a strange way, the actress who plays
   her is gonna have to face some challenging acting, too, considering half her
   scenes take place with a radioactive blue guy. To again echo what Aznbuddy
   said, Snyder & Co. CANNOT Alba-fy this casting.

 * May 21, 2007 4:25 PM CST
   
   SMELLS LIKE
   
   by mrsinister7381
   
   bullshit to me. There is a world of difference between offered parts,
   auditions, etc and actual casting. Fucking Nick Nolte auditioned for Han
   Solo, doesn't mean shit.

 * May 21, 2007 4:26 PM CST
   
   ON THE OTHER HAND...
   
   by mrsinister7381
   
   Jude Law IS perfect as Ozy.

 * May 21, 2007 4:27 PM CST
   
   SIN...
   
   by drew mcweeny
   
   ... I didn't say anything about "auditions." These are offers. The studio has
   put money on the table and negotiations are underway. It's a very specific
   part of the casting process, and once it gets here, it's pretty much done.

 * May 21, 2007 4:27 PM CST
   
   KEANU AS MANHATTAN
   
   by Mullah Omar
   
   I think this is perfect casting. I've seen a dozen names that would make for
   a good Rorschach (Mark Hamill, Daniel Craig, William Macy, etc), but I
   haven't seen any other decent suggestions for an actor that rivals Keanu for
   his emotionless, wooden style. William Hurt would have been a solid candidate
   back when "Watchmen" came out, but the guy is probably too old now.

 * May 21, 2007 4:27 PM CST
   
   IN ALL SERIOUSNESS, THOUGH...
   
   by AdrianVeidt
   
   I really like these casting ideas. I'm a little iffy on Keanu. I think he'd
   be great at it, sure, especially after a performance like A Scanner Darkly,
   but he just doesn't seem to have the right LOOK about him. I've been wrong
   before, though...

 * May 21, 2007 4:28 PM CST
   
   SPECTRES
   
   by Skinny White Lad
   
   I really like the idea of Jennifer Connelly as II... and how cool would it be
   to have Lynda Carter as I? You might have to age her a little bit, but you
   can still tell that she was/is a beautiful woman, and it'd be a great way to
   bring in a kind of vibe that the graphic novel has as a commentary on
   superhero stories.

 * May 21, 2007 4:31 PM CST
   
   NBC ANCHOR BRIAN WILLIAMS FOR DR. MANHATTAN'S VOICE
   
   by Canada's King
   
   When I hear Dr. Manhattan's voice when I read the novel, it sounds like I'm
   listening to what a God would sound like. Yeah, sounds corny, but Dr.
   Manhattan seems like he'd have a voice that is ageless and accentless. Almost
   like a news anchors. Calm, but commanding. Keanu can do calm, but can he do
   commanding?

 * May 21, 2007 4:32 PM CST
   
   RORSACH NEEDS TO BE AN UNKNOWN
   
   by wackedfuck
   
   Think about it. In the graphic novel, the guy with the billboard is just sort
   of there. You don't really notice him that much. Hell, I had to go back just
   to see who he was when they took R's mask off. That's what is needed. Someone
   who's not immediately recognizable. You put someone that people are familiar
   with in the role, they'll already know he's important to the story when they
   first see him, which is not a good thing. Sure, it won't make much of a
   difference to those of us who have read the story, but think of those who
   haven't. They need to be surprised during the reveal and only an unknown
   actor can provide that.

 * May 21, 2007 4:33 PM CST
   
   KEANU IS NOT A GOOD CHOICE
   
   by Lance Rock
   
   .

 * May 21, 2007 4:37 PM CST
   
   RORSCHAC AND WILSON
   
   by Blueberry
   
   I was watching "Little children" last week, thinking that James Earl Haley
   who was rumored to be in the run for Rorschach, was a very good choice. And
   strangely enough I was also thinking that Patrick Wilson could have been a
   good Manhattan. To me, the perfect NiteOwl would have been Norton. Wilson is
   a bit too cute for the part.

 * May 21, 2007 4:37 PM CST
   
   UNBIRTHDAY - JOHN C. MCGINLEY
   
   by spud mcspud
   
   Definitely John C. McGinley for Rorscach. Fantastic casting! I actually think
   he was pretty menacing in NOTHING TO LOSE, but as that was a Martin Lawrence
   movie, I reckon virtually no-one else in this talkback will have seen it.
   Dammit.
   
   And if Doc Cox WAS to be Rorscach, imagine the scene at the end of the novel,
   Rorscach and Dr Manhattan facing each other in the snow:
   
   RORSCACH: Yes, your attitude bothers me, yes this whole goddamn case bothers
   me, and yes, YOU! BOTHER ME!!!
   
   DR MANHATTAN: Caught my first tube this morning. Sir. Whoa.
   
   This is gonna be fucking hilarious. At least Jude Law got the right gig.

 * May 21, 2007 4:38 PM CST
   
   WHAT DID BAY DO TO MEGATRON'S FACE??
   
   by finky089
   
   Oh, wrong bitchfest, sorry.
   
   Good rumors. Hope they pan out.

 * May 21, 2007 4:38 PM CST
   
   DOUG JONES AS RORSCHACH!
   
   by The_Comedian
   
   It just makes sense people.

 * May 21, 2007 4:38 PM CST
   
   BUTLER
   
   by Blueberry
   
   If Keanu is Manhattan, that also means that Gerard Butler will be the
   Comedian.

 * May 21, 2007 4:39 PM CST
   
   LUIZ GUZMAN FOR THE VOICE OF DR. MANHATTAN
   
   by finky089
   
   You know you want it.

 * May 21, 2007 4:39 PM CST
   
   PAINT THE SILVER SURFER BLUE FOR DR MANATTAN
   
   by badboymason
   
   seriously, a CGI Doc with Doug Jones, Larry Fishburne or James Earl Jones
   doing his voice...

 * May 21, 2007 4:39 PM CST
   
   REGINALD VEL JOHNSON FOR RORSHACH!
   
   by finky089
   
   he could pull it off for two twinkies and a fruit pie.

 * May 21, 2007 4:40 PM CST
   
   BILLY ZANE FOR DOC MANHATTAN
   
   by Skinny White Lad
   
   Listen to your friend Billy Zane. He's a cool guy.

 * May 21, 2007 4:40 PM CST
   
   DON CHEADLE FOR INDY'S BABY MAMA!
   
   by finky089
   
   oh, I give up.

 * May 21, 2007 4:40 PM CST
   
   WELL, IT'S OVER BEFORE IT BEGAN...
   
   by superhero
   
   If I needed proof that they'd fuck it up here it is. Oh, well, I'll probably
   see it on cable. Sad.

 * May 21, 2007 4:41 PM CST
   
   I THOUGH JOHN CUSAK WOULD BE THE PERFECT NITE OWL
   
   by BGDAWES
   
   But I actually like Patrick Wilson in the role more. Let's not be surprised
   if we find King Leonidas casted as The Comedian though, for some reason I
   have a feeling that might happen. I hope I'm wrong.

 * May 21, 2007 4:44 PM CST
   
   JUDE LAW WILL GIVE RORSHACH AN EXTRA POWER
   
   by emeraldboy
   
   the power of Nanny seduction.

 * May 21, 2007 4:45 PM CST
   
   EXCUSE ME..."CAST"
   
   by BGDAWES
   
   Casted isn't a word. You're a dumbass BGDAWES.

 * May 21, 2007 4:45 PM CST
   
   PATRICK WILSON AS A HUNKY NITE OWL?
   
   by Rupee88
   
   You've got to be kidding me...Nite Owl was a middle aged pudgy guy in the
   book and Patrick Wilson is a super studly muscular guy. But Snyder nailed
   300, so I'm going to give him the benefit of the doubt. It didn't work out
   with Singer and Superman, but maybe this will be different.

 * May 21, 2007 4:45 PM CST
   
   JUST WENT BACK....
   
   by evil mystical ninja
   
   And had a look at Rorschach in chapter 10, and Damian Lewis could work
   appearance wise for sure. He's probably a good enough actor to capture all
   the weird aspects of Rorschach's character, in and out of costume so who
   knows!
   
   I think Snarf, with a little help from the CGI department would be perfect
   for Bubastis... Definitely!
   
   William H Macy for Moloch. I just decided. lol

 * May 21, 2007 4:47 PM CST
   
   SIMMER DOWN NOW, MASTERCLASS FANBOY DORKGOONS
   
   by Cider Mouse Rules
   
   This casting is fine. Sure, Keanu as Doc Manhattan is maybe a bit
   disappointing sounding... but by the time you paint Keanu blue, shave his
   head, and CGI him so he's 30 feet tall you are going to have an image of a
   character that has no context in Keanu's previous films. The question is, can
   Keanu act vacant, meditative, spiritual, and angry? The answer is "of course
   he can". Jude Law as Ozy is a good fit. I'd prefer a more interesting and
   exciting choice, but the character is in Jude's range. Patrick Wilson as Nite
   Owl is inspired casting. William H. Macy or John Cussack would have been too
   obvious. Wilson was the best part of Little Children. He's an immensely
   talented actor. I was fortunate enough to speak with Snyder when he and Frank
   Miller were pimping out 20 minutes of 300 to various media outlets based in
   LA. My friends and I spoke with him for about five minutes about The
   Watchmen. After hearing him talk about it, I can say he definitely knows what
   he was doing. Dawn of the Dead was an absolute blast and 300 is a kickass
   work of art. You really have to give the benefit of the doubt here.

 * May 21, 2007 4:47 PM CST
   
   KEANU AS DR. MANHATTAN
   
   by Rupee88
   
   I would have never thought of this, but I can see what you are saying that it
   may work. He does seem kind of "out there".. I hope they still make him blue,
   but we'll see.

 * May 21, 2007 4:48 PM CST
   
   NO MORE KEANU
   
   by hobomoviezapper
   
   I could only hope that they wouldn't dare cast keanu reeves.

 * May 21, 2007 4:49 PM CST
   
   I READ WATCHMEN...IT SUCKED
   
   by Holodigm
   
   it was lame rip-off of Heroes

 * May 21, 2007 4:49 PM CST
   
   RORSCHACH - SPOILER! (IF YOU HAVEN'T READ THE COMIC)
   
   by bralli
   
   An unknown actor needs to be cast as Rorschach. Remember, the whole point of
   his character is that he is revealed to be a short crazy bum who we have
   already seen in the background throughout the book. If you cast a known actor
   like Eric Stoltz as the "crazy guy holding the end of the world sign", it
   will ruin the big reveal.

 * May 21, 2007 4:50 PM CST
   
   WHAT I HEARD...
   
   by Blueberry
   
   is that Rorschac mask will have lips.

 * May 21, 2007 4:50 PM CST
   
   THE COMEDIAN
   
   by bralli
   
   Has to be...Ian McShane.

 * May 21, 2007 4:51 PM CST
   
   KEANU PUTS ASSES IN SEATS
   
   by Rupee88
   
   Yeah, there are 1000 actors who would be better in the part, but there are
   100,000 who would be worse, so I'm willing to accept this choice...it is not
   quite as bad as Jessica Alba in Sin City and that almost worked, so I think
   this will too.

 * May 21, 2007 4:52 PM CST
   
   SOME OF YOU ARE IDIOTS...
   
   by jrbarker
   
   Just because an actor has red hair DOESN'T automatically make him "perfect"
   for Rorschach. Or someone with a bald head makes him "perfect" for Dr.
   Manhattan.

 * May 21, 2007 4:53 PM CST
   
   HOLODIGM
   
   by Rupee88
   
   lol...you are joking, but many people will not when Watchmen is released.

 * May 21, 2007 4:55 PM CST
   
   ROSIE O DONNEL
   
   by evil mystical ninja
   
   For the Lesbian Taxi Driver at the news stand... oh ja.
   
   I would actually really like to see Jeff Bridges as Dreiberg/Nite Owl 2. MEGA
   SPOILER !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! - Dan Dreiberg Cant get it up unless
   he's wearing his costume, yup, you heard it here first people.

 * May 21, 2007 4:57 PM CST
   
   OLDER CASTING
   
   by Rupee88
   
   Teens don't like to see old farts in movies. And teens are what drive the box
   office business. There will some major compromises with the source material,
   but many of these are probably necessary to get a decent budget. Again, it
   was a sellout that Nancy wasn't naked in Sin City, but we dealt with it
   because of the greater good. I'm usually a purist, but I've learned by now
   that Hollywood is very impure and maybe Snyder can tow the line and make it
   work.

 * May 21, 2007 5:00 PM CST
   
   BRUCE WILLIS
   
   by KneelBeforeZod
   
   Harry, use your pull. Get Bruce to read the script. He should be the
   Comedian.

 * May 21, 2007 5:00 PM CST
   
   I THINK IT'S GOING TO SUCK, TOO...
   
   by BrooseTheScharuk
   
   Snyder is all about making "kickass" movies that kick your ass until it's not
   even an ass worth kicking anymore. Fine. That is not Watchmen. Watchmen
   should be directed by Unfrozen David Lean. It should take its time, and feel
   like it was made for adults, by adults, and is about adults. It can still
   kick some ass, but with some sense of relevance and resonance, rather than
   just "is this cool or what?". Some time spent with characters where we're not
   going "whoa, it almost looks like they're not on a greenscreen stage, but
   actually in a real place! wicked backgrounds! wicked tunes!" It should be a
   drama, but with amazing action and effects sequences that support the story
   content. Snyder is all about "coolness". You can tell by how young he seems
   to be looking for a cast, if this scoop is any indication. That's why it will
   suck. As far as my dream casting ideas go, off the top of my head: Rorschach-
   Paddy Considine, Dr. Manhattan- Billy Zane, The Comedian- Ron Perlman, Night
   Owl- John Cuzack, Ozymandias- Tom Cruise...I also like the sound of the
   Connelly/Carter Spectres thing.

 * May 21, 2007 5:00 PM CST
   
   HUH...
   
   by solitaire
   
   My cast was always as follows: Nite-Owl: Jeff Bridges, Rorschach: David
   Caruso (voice and mannerisims seem dead on, as are his looks with a forrest
   gump haircut)Ozymandias: Val Kilmer, Dr. Manhatten: William Hurt, Silk
   Specter 1: Sigourney Weaver, Silk Specter 2: Diane Lane, Comedian: Ron
   Pearlman (gotta admit...never considered that before, but he beats Berringer,
   my original choice) Mystic villian of Rorschach who's name begins with an "M"
   that escapes me right now: Ron Rifkin. Thing with this movie is, the source
   material has become so much more than a graphic novel, it is a universally
   respected work of literature that gets the gold standard in ivy league
   english classes, and rightfully so. Every one of us who has read this over
   and over has our own vision of it, the best we can hope for is that there is
   respect given. After 300, I'm willing to give this the benefit of the doubt,
   and I don't see keanu getting cast as set in stone at this point.

 * May 21, 2007 5:03 PM CST
   
   THATS 2 FOR JEFF BRIDGES
   
   by evil mystical ninja
   
   Woop Woop.... Moloch is the villain you're thinking of btw ^^

 * May 21, 2007 5:04 PM CST
   
   SORRY MOREY, BUT THOSE ARE SOME BAD CHOICES.
   
   by Boneyard
   
   I prefer these: Night Owl - John Cusack Doc Manhattan - David Hyde Pyrce (DHP
   for before accident, CG w/voice for after) Rorscharch - David Caruso Comedian
   - Kurt Russell Jude Law - Ozymandias

 * May 21, 2007 5:05 PM CST
   
   EVIL MYSTICAL NINJA
   
   by solitaire
   
   I bow to you sir, thanks ;-)

 * May 21, 2007 5:08 PM CST
   
   KEANU???!!!! NO FUCKING WAY
   
   by Evil Hobbit
   
   Terrible actor who's marked as NEO for the rest of his life.

 * May 21, 2007 5:09 PM CST
   
   JEFF BRIDGES
   
   by Blueberry
   
   Would have been a great NiteOwl, 12 years ago. And he has a couple of
   projects already lined up for the next months.

 * May 21, 2007 5:11 PM CST
   
   PHYSICAL APPEARANCE
   
   by Skinny White Lad
   
   Given, Red Hair does not a Rorschach make. Nor does Baldness make a Manhattan
   (btw were it the 1950s Yul WOULD be an awesome Doc M). But the comic is a
   visual medium, and I think it's clear that the appearance of each character
   was carefully crafted in the novel. That's not to say that Snyder has to
   stick with that, or that tweaking what characters look like would detract
   from the film. But it IS to say that if you don't have to movie magic an
   actor into a look it might be advantageous. And I'd love to see a Rorschach
   that stepped out of those square panels as much as a Drieberg or a Comedian.
   And I think the ideal casting is going to combine both the look of the
   character as well as the acting chops that are required to bring that
   character to life. Talk them both up!

 * May 21, 2007 5:12 PM CST
   
   PATRICK WILSON OR KIP PARDUE???
   
   by rutgerman
   
   I cannot for the life of me tell them apart!

 * May 21, 2007 5:13 PM CST
   
   PATRICK WILSON WOULD BE GREAT FOR ANY SUPERHERO
   
   by CherryValance
   
   I'm not sure if he's a good fit for this role since I only read the book
   once. So I'd have to go back and check but I definitely remember Dr.
   Manhattan and can't think of why Keanu wouldn't be great. But Ozymandias,
   wasn't he cooler than Jude Law? Like an all American rich kid type, like JFK,
   Jr.?

 * May 21, 2007 5:16 PM CST
   
   DR. MANHATTEN SHOULD BE CGI
   
   by V'Shael
   
   and voiced by computer speech synthesiser. Not the 80's crappy one that
   Stephen Hawking uses. A modern one.

 * May 21, 2007 5:17 PM CST
   
   FAMKE JANSSEN FOR LAURIE
   
   by Evil Hobbit
   
   She is perfect for the part.

 * May 21, 2007 5:20 PM CST
   
   THIS IS A COOL TALKBACK
   
   by Rupee88
   
   "Watchmen" is my "Transformers"

 * May 21, 2007 5:23 PM CST
   
   DR. MANHATTAN SHOULD BE...
   
   by Aznbuddy
   
   ...voiced by Bob Dole!!! Dig it!

 * May 21, 2007 5:23 PM CST
   
   JIM THIRLWELL
   
   by robertdee
   
   Perfect Casting for Rorschach. He's a musician but he's been embodying that
   kind of persona for years and he looks the part. Checkout the pictures on
   foetus.org

 * May 21, 2007 5:24 PM CST
   
   RORSCHACH IS LIKE THE DUDE IN V FOR VENDETTA
   
   by Rupee88
   
   He is behind the mask 99% of the time, so it doesn't matter how he looks
   really. I mean he takes off the mask at the end, but that's the only time
   (except for maybe some flashbacks). I just hope that Snyder doesn't pull a
   "Raimi" and keep Rorschach maskless the whole movie becuase he thinks we can
   relate to him better. That woudl be really bad.

 * May 21, 2007 5:28 PM CST
   
   DR MANHATTAN WOULD SUCK IF HE WAS CGI
   
   by Rupee88
   
   I don't know if you've noticed by it's not possible to do realistic CGI
   humans yet. And it won't be possible in our lifetimes. You saw how much
   people hated The Hulk (who I thought was fine). But you essentially end up
   with a real person acting with a puppet and that never works...maybe with
   mosters (Gollum) or animals (King Kong), but not with humans. We are
   incredibly discerning when it comes to a human face and human movement, and
   anything that doesn't look perfect will be too distracting. You can mo-cap
   the movement and get clsoe, but the face is always going to be off even if
   you mo-cap that. It just won't work and would eat up too much budget to even
   get remotely close.

 * May 21, 2007 5:30 PM CST
   
   RORSCHACH
   
   by Marwood 1974
   
   From my recollection of the book, isn't Rorschach supposed to be 'somewhat'
   threatening? Now I'm not claiming to be a tough guy, but... I could twat
   Simon Pegg from here to Peking. And back. Paddy Considine or Doug Hutchison.
   End. Of. Fucking. Story.

 * May 21, 2007 5:32 PM CST
   
   DR. MANHATTEN'S VOICE....
   
   by vinceklortho
   
   I'm a little worried with Keanu talking. Everything else, shaved head, all
   blue, you won't be able to tell it's him. I can tell you that he will have
   the perfect stale and wooden mannerisms for the Dr. I always imagined the
   Dr., through the pics in the novel, of some buff blond guy, much like a
   Arnold Mr. Freeze type thing. Hey, settle down nerds! Just picture it!

 * May 21, 2007 5:32 PM CST
   
   UH, THIS MOVIE IS SLATED TO COME OUT NEXT SUMMER...
   
   by Canada's King
   
   So unless Warner Bros. pushes Watchmen back for the winter (which they
   should), there just isn't enough time to CGI Dr. Manhattan and do it justice.

 * May 21, 2007 5:33 PM CST
   
   HAPPY WITH WILSON AND LAW...MEH ON REEVES
   
   by DannyOcean01
   
   I always heard Fishburne's voice. Unless Reeves is just playing Osterman
   which could work.

 * May 21, 2007 5:36 PM CST
   
   PATRICK WILSON IS WAAAAAY TO YOUNG
   
   by Evil Hobbit
   
   Dan is supposed to be a man in his midlifecrisis. Frankly the whole cast
   seems a bit young.

 * May 21, 2007 5:36 PM CST
   
   JUDE LAW IS CINEMATIC CANCER.
   
   by jenkis
   
   That is all.

 * May 21, 2007 5:38 PM CST
   
   KEANU? MAYBE HE CAN PULL THE CGI DOC PART..
   
   by Wonderboys
   
   but I can't see it as the melancholic watchmaker Jon Osterman... I thought
   Gerard Butler was a lock for that part... Jude Law I can see why are they
   going for him, but he seems too nice to be Veidt.. I always rooted for Sean
   Bean for that part. For Rorschach, I've always thought that William Fichtner
   would be an awesome Rorschach... For the Comedian, some years ago Mel Gibson
   was dead on... Ron Perlman its too obvious, and I can imagine him playing it
   a bit like his characther of Blade II or Alien Resurrection... better not,
   thanks... In a bit of stunt casting I choose Jason Statham, thats a though
   sonofabitch.. (ok, I now he has no hair... and is way too young)...

 * May 21, 2007 5:38 PM CST
   
   DOCTOR MANHATTAN WON'T BE CGI
   
   by Blueberry
   
   And there's no reason for it. He's just a blue guy and maybe you should read
   again the report that Moriarty made last year when Greengrass was still
   supposed to direct. He saw a test for a DocM where they used a special body
   paint that when properly lit looks like a sparkling blue.

 * May 21, 2007 5:38 PM CST
   
   MIDDLE AGED CAST
   
   by kafka07
   
   I expected more middle aged casting too, but you can't make everyone old; I'm
   sure they want to cover enough demographics. Patrick Wilson, not my first
   choice for Night Owl, but a good one. William H Macy would be a good middle
   aged Night Owl. Jude Law as a snobby genius billionare fits, I think. Keanu
   Reeves too for the blue Manhattan guy. I didn't add anything new to the
   discussion but I'm excited they're making this! Best graphic novel EVER.

 * May 21, 2007 5:41 PM CST
   
   OH, AND FUCK WILLIAM H MACY...
   
   by Wonderboys
   
   either for Rorschach or for Dan Dreiberg... he looks too comedic to pull
   either part off.

 * May 21, 2007 5:42 PM CST
   
   CGI MOCAP FOR DR MANHATTAN
   
   by Happyfat73
   
   They've got the technology to pull it off magnificently - it will allow them
   to do "Otherworldly" way better than shaving Neo and painting him blue.
   
   I've always maintained that I'd love to see John Cusack as Nite Owl and John
   C. McGinley as Rorschach (or Paddy Considine since seeing Dead Man's Shoes).
   
   
   
   I think Jude Law isn't comanding enough to be Adrian Veidt - I'm thinking Val
   Kilmer would be the man.
   
   
   
   

 * May 21, 2007 5:42 PM CST
   
   I HAVE NO PROBLEM WITH THIS CASTING SO FAR
   
   by oisin5199
   
   these characters are only partially about a "look" which is easy to achieve
   with makeup, wardrobe and cg (if necessary). It's all about how you play
   them. Is Snyder an actor's director? Not from what I've seen, but maybe he'll
   surprise us. Yes, Keanu's range is limited, but he can do some great things.
   How he played the role in Scanner Darkly was spot on. Anyway, to me, these
   are the three easiest roles to cast in the film. It's the others that will
   make or break it.
   
   And to whoever said it, I do NOT think that most Heroes fans know Watchmen.
   Many Heroes fans have never even picked up a comic book. I think it's the
   very vocal minority who have been screaming 'Watchmen ripoff.'

 * May 21, 2007 5:47 PM CST
   
   THIS IS ME TALKING ABOUT WATCHMEN CASTING...
   
   by Brians Life
   
   Could it be better? Sure. Here's how I break it down....JUDE LAW looks alot
   like Ozymandias and I believe he's quite a good actor. He's young, but than
   Ozymandias was sort of a character that defied age in a way. PATRICK WILSON I
   think will do quite fine if he gains some wieght for the scenes where OwlMan
   is older, also quite a good actor. As for KEANU...I think if you're EVER
   thinking about casting Keanu Reeves it's GOTTA be for a part in which he
   plays detached,naive, and a little "duh"...THAT is Doctor Manhattan. Yes,
   he's incredibly brilliant but his entire struggle is that he's a God among
   men not because of his knowledge but because he no longer understands men.
   I'm a fan of this casting. As for RORSACH I'd love if they cast two
   completely different people for his masked and unmasked roles. Those who are
   saying William H. Macy are thinking too literal...honestly think that Simon
   Pegg wouldn't be bad. Jeez, some of the casting specs you guys make...I
   actually saw a post with some one suggesting VIN DIESEL as Dr.
   Manhattan....REALLY?!?!

 * May 21, 2007 5:47 PM CST
   
   MARK HAMIL AS ROCHSACH CARBON GHOST?
   
   by blindambition238
   
   Holy shit, I wish I came up with that... too bad hell will freeze over before
   that happens...

 * May 21, 2007 5:50 PM CST
   
   STACY KEACH = THE COMEDIAN
   
   by TORTURE PWN
   
   Make it so.

 * May 21, 2007 5:52 PM CST
   
   KEANU???
   
   by OGREISHERE
   
   I just need to focus on the Matrix Keanu and not the Johnny Nemonic Keanu.

 * May 21, 2007 5:53 PM CST
   
   RORSCHACH - DANIEL DAY LEWIS
   
   by dirkadirkadirka
   
   In a perfect world, Daniel Day Lewis would act the shit out of this character
   and carry this project to the place we all want. Andy Sirkis is a good
   call...I've thought about him as well. Roarschach is all about the eyes, that
   blank stare, and I could see Serkis pulling that off. Third choice, how about
   Gary Sinese, I haven't seen him mentioned yet. He's a great actor when given
   the parts and the material.

 * May 21, 2007 5:54 PM CST
   
   BRIANS LIFE
   
   by Wonderboys
   
   You seem to have a very good knowledge of the graphic novel... "Owlman"?
   "Rorsach"? Simon Pegg? have you actually read Watchmen?

 * May 21, 2007 5:56 PM CST
   
   RUPEE YOU DUMBASS
   
   by DannyOcean01
   
   One of the major parts of the novel is when Rorschach's actual face is
   revealed. Everyone thinks he's this macho, badass, but it's revealed he's
   this short, ugly 'nothing'. For me that's one of the main reasons Rorschach's
   skin becomes his only face. Of course it fucking matters what he looks like.
   Did you skim read the bloody thing?

 * May 21, 2007 5:57 PM CST
   
   DANIEL DAY LEWIS FOR MANHATTAN
   
   by DannyOcean01
   
   Could work better than Rorschach.

 * May 21, 2007 6:01 PM CST
   
   MEL GIBSON AS COMEDIAN...
   
   by Evil Hobbit
   
   Spot on Wonderboys, and still possible today.

 * May 21, 2007 6:02 PM CST
   
   GOLDBLUM!
   
   by Bass Ackwards
   
   The only actor for Manhattan!

 * May 21, 2007 6:02 PM CST
   
   YOU GOTTA BE FREAKIN' KIDDING ME!!!
   
   by dtwookieman
   
   Keanu "I couldn't act my wooden self out of a paper bag if my Oscar depended
   on it" Reeves as Dr. Midnite?? Um, NOOOOOO. ANd I think there should be only
   one actor to play Rorschach, and that's Ewan Bremner (Red from Pearl Harbor,
   he is also in Black Hawk Down, and AVP) When they unmask Rorschach in the
   comics, I could swear that Ewan Brennen is a spitting image of him, and he
   can pull off the psychotichness that Rorschach requires very well. Harry, if
   you are reading this, and if you have any influence on Zach Snyder's casting,
   tell him to cast Ewan Bremner. Just go to this link here and tell me you
   don't think he is a spitting image of Rorschach unmasked from the comics.
   http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0001971/

 * May 21, 2007 6:02 PM CST
   
   OH AND ONE MORE THING...
   
   by purplemonkeydw
   
   This guy just delievered the baddest ass comic movie ever in 300 (yeah I said
   it)...have a little faith, nerds. In response to your anticipated fanboy
   rage, I say: 'THIS...IS...SPARTA'...and kick you in a pit (slo mo of course).

 * May 21, 2007 6:03 PM CST
   
   NOT TERRIBLE CASTING
   
   by dirkadirkadirka
   
   I must admit I've never heard of Patrick Wilson and I've not seen any of his
   stuff, so I'll hold off judgement on that one. Jude Law is a good choice.
   He's actually perfect. Good actor, right look for the part, somewhat big name
   (but not too big). If Tom Cruise is cast then you just know that Ozy is going
   to play some big part towards the end. You need to forget about him and Law
   is forgettable. He's played some good suppoting roles in AI and Road to
   Perdition. I like the choice. Keanu is not the best choice, but I don't think
   the worst either. Snyder must be in some kind of struggle with the studio
   over casting. Lets hope that the 'studio' choices are Reeves and Law and
   we'll get some really bold choices for some of the other more important
   roles. Keanu certainly didn't ruin the original Martrix...in fact he was
   pretty good in it. So when given the right role he does a decent job.

 * May 21, 2007 6:07 PM CST
   
   JAMES SPADER FOR NIGHT OWL
   
   by Diotima
   
   He's got the perfect look for the older version, but making him look young
   enough for the flashbacks would be a challenge. Then again, did anyone think
   Uma Thurmam could do a college flashback in Kill Bill?

 * May 21, 2007 6:07 PM CST
   
   I AGREE WITH PURPLEMONKEY
   
   by dirkadirkadirka
   
   Lets give the guy a f'n chance. 300 was pretty damn awesome. Snyder won't f
   around. right????

 * May 21, 2007 6:10 PM CST
   
   KEANU AS SIDDHARTHA IN LITTLE BUDDHA = DR. MANHATTEN
   
   by Calico Pete
   
   If you haven't seen Little Buddha, the scenes w/Keanu as Siddhartha are
   beautiful, and show he can look otherworldly, meditative, etc. Youtube has a
   clip that shows him meditative (though not as otherworldly as he appears in
   the rest of the film). Check him out at 2:00, 2:30, 4:12-4:45 (could be
   taking place on mars!), and 5:50 onward. tinyurl.com/2x8egq
   
   Another look from the film: tinyurl.com/37yf35

 * May 21, 2007 6:12 PM CST
   
   THREE WAY BATTLE FOR THE COMEDIAN...
   
   by dirkadirkadirka
   
   The way I see it there are three damn solid choices out there for the role.
   1). Micky Rourke 2). Ron Pearlman 3). Kurt Russell Any of those would work
   for me.

 * May 21, 2007 6:13 PM CST
   
   NOW THAT YOU MENTION PADDY CONSIDINE
   
   by CherryValance
   
   wouldn't Gary Stretch be good for the Comedian?

 * May 21, 2007 6:15 PM CST
   
   MORE OF KEANU'S SIDDHARTHA LOOK
   
   by Calico Pete
   
   much clearer... use your imagination and you'll see Doc Manhatten:
   tinyurl.com/yompk6

 * May 21, 2007 6:15 PM CST
   
   THE COMEDIAN IS....
   
   by Err
   
   more than likely going to be Gerard Butler.

 * May 21, 2007 6:17 PM CST
   
   AGREE WITH CALICO PETE
   
   by DannyOcean01
   
   Reeve's Neo and Buddha roles must have played a part in this decision. If he
   is playing Manhattan and not just Osterman, it'll be down to the delivery and
   Snyder's going to have to direct the man. It's his job after all.

 * May 21, 2007 6:18 PM CST
   
   SNYDER IS NOT...
   
   by theseventhshore
   
   ...an actor's director. 'Dawn' was certainly cool, but the character arcs
   flattened out halfway through...and 300 was certainly gorgeous, but the
   performances were more 2D than the original graphic novel. Law will be
   fine...but I'm certainly vexed over the Keanu choice - sure, he IS a great
   physical actor (Matrix, Constantine, Point Break, and his Hamlet theatre run
   in Canada), but his emoting should be featured as part of a Ikea's discount
   furnishing line. Zach Snyder is NOT Paul Thomas Anderson here,
   kidlets...don't expect an 'Adam Sandler' surprise turn here...the chops
   simply aren't there on EITHER side :( (that said...my sources whisper that
   the budget hasn't even been APPROVED yet - casting pending - therefore, this
   could just be a calculated leak to gauge the degree of fan
   shock/approval/revulsion)

 * May 21, 2007 6:18 PM CST
   
   KID FROM "EVERYONE HATES CHRIS"...
   
   by Napoleon Park
   
   ...as kid at newsstand reading Pirate comic. *** David Caruso as Rorshach.
   *** Need a guy willing to do full frontal nudity for Dr. Manhatten, so
   obviously Harvey Kietel's your go to guy. *** Years ago someone dreamcast Dan
   Ackroyd as Nite Owl. Would have worked... then. *** Tom Cruise cameo as guy
   Rorshach shoots in the guts with a grappling hook, because we'd all pay to
   see that. *** Any actor under 35 being considered for a major role in this
   film for "get the fuck out of this movie, punk ass kid". Except for kid
   reading Pirate comic, of course.

 * May 21, 2007 6:20 PM CST
   
   THIS IS WHAT THE WATCHMEN CAST SHOULD BE...
   
   by bat-kyo
   
   Doctor Manhattan=gerard butler the Comedian=clive owen Ozymandias=jude law
   Nite Owl=anthony edwards Rorschach=mark hamill Captain Metropolis=val kilmer
   Silk Spectre=evangeline lilly

 * May 21, 2007 6:30 PM CST
   
   GIOVANNI RIBISI NEEDS TO BE RORSCHACH.
   
   by CHEWBLACCA
   
   Come on, Zack. You know that he'd be awesome.

 * May 21, 2007 6:33 PM CST
   
   DOG DOO DOO
   
   by reckni
   
   This can't really be serious. Whoa?

 * May 21, 2007 6:35 PM CST
   
   3 BULLET POINTS
   
   by HugePrawn
   
   BULLET POINT 1: The time is finally right for The Watchmen to hit the big
   screen. It's been 20 years since Alan Moores landmark comic changed the way
   the "every man" viewed comics and the impact they could have on mainstream
   media, as well as being fantastically written as anything on the shelves of
   your local bookstore.
   
   The comic took all the iconic superheroes and dropped them into the real
   world, into our world. Moore showed aging superheroes grasping for the good
   old times of yesteryear only to be faced with horrors that haunt the news
   daily, war, racism, gangs, murder - the same horrors that we still face today
   in 2007.
   
   Over the last several years comicbook heroes have burst out on the silver
   screen and have done extremely well: Spider man battling The Green Goblin,
   The X-men battle Magneto, Superman battling Lex Luther, Batman battling Ras a
   Ghoul, so on and so. And now, The Watchmen will come to a theater near you in
   2008 to deconstruct everything that has come before it.
   
   BULLET POINT 2: Zach Snyder has shown he knows comics. He knows action. He
   knows style. To me this is half the battle. Sure he is young, but so are the
   kids that will be going to see this film thinking it to be the next X-men.
   Much like I did back in 1987 when I picked up issue 1 of the comic thinking
   it was the next Outsiders or Justice League.
   
   BULLET POINT 3: I'm not concerned with who plays who in the film. They are
   all actors and get paid good money to act. If the director does his job well
   ANYONE can pull off the role of Dr. Manhattan, or Night Owl. Don't forget,
   the story of The Watchmen has already been told by Alan Moore. His story will
   always be THE story regardless if Keanu takes the role or not.
   
   I for one can't wait to sit back in a nice cool theater some summer day in
   2008 with a huge smile on my face and watch a story I love come to life.
   
   cheers

 * May 21, 2007 6:45 PM CST
   
   GREAT POINT WACKEDFUCK!
   
   by FilmZ0mbie
   
   If Macy is holding the billboard then that'll totally ruin in. I hope nyder
   is reading this.

 * May 21, 2007 6:48 PM CST
   
   HAS THERE EVER BEEN A MORE UNNECESSARY FILM?
   
   by rev_skarekroe
   
   Does Hollywood have to ruin EVERY Alan Moore series? Although I'm looking
   forward to them getting around to "Lost Girls".

 * May 21, 2007 6:52 PM CST
   
   REMEMBER...THERE WILL BE FLASHBACKS
   
   by jrbarker
   
   So it is easier to age a young actor than make an older actor look young.

 * May 21, 2007 6:53 PM CST
   
   JEBUS, PEOPLE...
   
   by omarthesnake
   
   has No One suggested Steve Buscemi for Rorschach yet? And Give the guy who
   suggested Stacy Keach as the Comedian a goddamn prize! woooo!

 * May 21, 2007 6:56 PM CST
   
   TIM ROBBINS
   
   by The_Comedian
   
   Would be the perfect Nite Owl IMO

 * May 21, 2007 7:02 PM CST
   
   SIMON PEGG IS RORSCHACH!
   
   by madmunky
   
   Totally agree with MrSpeed. Simon Pegg would be a perfect Rorschach!

 * May 21, 2007 7:04 PM CST
   
   JACKMAN AS THE COMEDIAN, PLEASE
   
   by PotSmokinAlien
   
   nuff said

 * May 21, 2007 7:04 PM CST
   
   ED NORTON AS RORSCHACH, PLEASE
   
   by PotSmokinAlien
   
   nuff said

 * May 21, 2007 7:07 PM CST
   
   JACK BLACK AS RORSCHACH!!!!
   
   by DOGSOUP
   
   Hehehe just kidding...

 * May 21, 2007 7:08 PM CST
   
   HOW IN THE HELL IS JUDE LAW PERFECT?
   
   by TELF
   
   Balding, sexually sinister man-waif plays all conquering Randian gymnast
   Ubermensch? Really?

 * May 21, 2007 7:14 PM CST
   
   EDWARD NORTON OR GUY PEARCE AS MOST ANYONE
   
   by Rupee88
   
   They both have a lot of range.

 * May 21, 2007 7:33 PM CST
   
   I DON'T LIKE THIS
   
   by Gwai Lo
   
   Jude Law should not be getting work. I hate that guy, he stinks in pretty
   much everything. The one thing I remember liking him in was the Talented Mr
   Ripley, but that was before I knew who he was, and before I knew he was just
   playing himself. He's a bad choice for Ozymandias, who needs to convey
   INTELLIGENCE and BRAWN. Jude Law is not exactly muscular or smart, and I
   can't recall a role where he convinced me he was either. Keanu Reeves is
   possibly the most obvious choice for Manhattan that anyone could come up
   with. It reminds me of the casting for Beast (Kelsey Grammar has played smart
   guys before! Let's cast him!) or of fanboys suggesting Crispin Glover for
   Joker. It's too damn obvious to put up with while you're watching the movie.
   If you ask me they can cast pretty much anyone for the flashbacks when he's
   Jon Osterman (it would help if they looked like Manhattan is drawn, acting
   isn't even really important they have about two scenes that they need to be
   in.) and then you just need a voice for what is inevitable going to be a
   motion capture performance. Howbout Peter Weller's voice over a Doug Jones
   (obvious, I know, but I can only think of two of these guys) performance? I
   haven't seen Little Children and don't know Patrick Wilson from anything. But
   it seems like he's probably too young and good looking for Nite Owl. They
   need someone like Tim Robbins, Bill Pullman, Michael Douglas, etc. Someone
   that maybe looks like they used to be a superhero but now they're kind of a
   schlub. As for Rorschach, I say go with an unknown or a character actor. No
   one more famous that Gary Sinise. Dylan Baker would be a good bet, so would
   Brad Dourif. The Comedian can be played by any badass around, you can
   literally name 200 actors that would be great in that role. I'm stuck on
   Ozymandias and Laurie, can't think of anyone. But I'd love to see Adam West
   as Nite Owl I, playing it serious of course.

 * May 21, 2007 7:36 PM CST
   
   STILL DOUBTFULL...
   
   by Billyeveryteen
   
   Fake alien invasion??
   
   Tough to pull off.

 * May 21, 2007 7:37 PM CST
   
   HEY THANKS EVERYONE...
   
   by jimmy_009
   
   ...for repeating what I posted about a young actor playing an old person and
   vice versa. Way to regurgitate.

 * May 21, 2007 7:42 PM CST
   
   KEANU AND JUDE NEEDS TO TAKE STEROIDS
   
   by pipergates
   
   too bad you dont like jude, alot of of people do.i dont care much for keanu
   but i guess he could be alright here.with some extra muscle.GEORGE BUSH FOR
   RORSCACH!

 * May 21, 2007 7:55 PM CST
   
   YES KEANU IS A CLONE.YES PERLEMAN IS THE COMEDIAN.
   
   by pipergates
   
   just cover keanu in a lot of blue paint so you cant see his lack of changing
   expression.hope we dont get to see his blue balls though.

 * May 21, 2007 7:55 PM CST
   
   I AGREE SIMON PEGG NEEDS TO PLAY RORSCHACH
   
   by OGREISHERE
   
   Hot Fuzz proved that to me.

 * May 21, 2007 7:58 PM CST
   
   WILL MANHATTAN BE CG?
   
   by Rindain
   
   ...or Keanu painted in blue or with a glowy aura?

 * May 21, 2007 8:05 PM CST
   
   I.
   
   by Mockingbuddha
   
   Hate.Keanu.Reeves.So.Much. He's the thinking man's Ben Affleck. I think Hugo
   Weaving would be a good Doc. Manhattan. Simon Pegg as Rorschach is genius.

 * May 21, 2007 8:09 PM CST
   
   DR. MANHATTAN SHOULD BE.....
   
   by VicSage
   
   Vincent D'Onofrio. Smart and detached.

 * May 21, 2007 8:09 PM CST
   
   IAN MCSHANE FOR THE COMEDIAN!!!
   
   by Bad_Lieutenant121
   
   He'll act that role better than any other cocksucker around!!!! And how about
   Guy Pierce for Ozymandias.. dye the hair and bulk him up a bit and you have
   Mr Veidt. Granted, I would have loved to see Cruise in the role but Pierce
   would be inspired...

 * May 21, 2007 8:21 PM CST
   
   A HUGE WATCHMAN WEIGHS IN (TO OTHER FANS ONLY).....
   
   by brassai2003
   
   Rorschach: Charles Fleischer http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0281486/ Night Owl:
   Randy Quaid Comedian: Stacy Keech Dr. Manhattan: Ozi: John Tesh (just
   kidding-but think about it)

 * May 21, 2007 8:40 PM CST
   
   FRED WARD AS THE COMEDIAN
   
   by ballyhoo
   
   He's freaking perfect.

 * May 21, 2007 8:47 PM CST
   
   JUDE LAW IS BOX OFFICE POISON
   
   by Domi'sInnerChild
   
   Was, is, and will continue to be his entire career.

 * May 21, 2007 9:08 PM CST
   
   THIS MOVIE SHOULDN'T BE MADE.
   
   by Mr Soze
   
   You can't capture this in film, I love movies but I think this is a bad move,
   it's too big. This material is untouchable. All us geeks would bitch and cry
   anyway if it was made.

 * May 21, 2007 11:20 PM CST
   
   BGDAWES HAS GOOD TASTE!!
   
   by Redbox
   
   John Cusack should be Nightowl!!!! This I thought was a no brainer!!!
   AHHHHH!!! Please!!!!! Oh, I guess not.. zzzzzzzzz

 * May 21, 2007 10:04 PM CST
   
   PRETTY AMAZING TIMES FOR COMIC&MOVIE FANS
   
   by pipergates
   
   nolan on Bats,300,Watchmen,Wanted,30 days off
   night,Tintin,Wolvie?,Magneto?,and the quality is improving too. Plus the
   pirated copies are soo cheap.

 * May 21, 2007 10:08 PM CST
   
   NO! I AM PERFECT CASTING FOR THE COMEDIAN AND DR M!
   
   by Laserbrain
   
   I can grow a moustache or shave my head and I am tall. I'm wating by the
   phone. No reasonable offer refused.

 * May 22, 2007 12:09 AM CST
   
   JOKER PHOTO UP ON SUPERHERO HYPE!!!!
   
   by Bob Cryptonight
   
   Whoa! He looks just like a guy from an asylum!!!

 * May 21, 2007 10:18 PM CST
   
   RON PERLMAN IS THE COMEDIAN!
   
   by BatPsycho
   
   come on people have some sense about this casting! He already wants to do it.
   he said so in an interview awhile back. Make it so!

 * May 21, 2007 10:37 PM CST
   
   IAN MCSHANE AND DEXTER FLETCHER.
   
   by Redfive!
   
   Those 2 should play The Comedian and Rorschach hands down,both looks exactly
   like those characters and I really hope Manhattans face is CGI'D becuase
   Keanu Reeves in blue paint doesnt seem right.

 * May 21, 2007 10:37 PM CST
   
   RODRIGUEZ TO DIRECT "BARBARELLA" !!!!!!!
   
   by pipergates
   
   Rodriguez is working with writers Neal Purvis and Robert Wade, who are
   developing an original adventure for Barbarella. Purvis and Wade co-wrote
   "Casino Royale" and recently finished work on the next installment in the
   James Bond franchise, which has a working title of "Bond 22." "Dino De
   Laurentiis came to me and said, 'Barbarella' is a world where you are
   completely free to unleash all your fantasies, creativity and imagination --
   where the possibilities are limitless,"' Rodriguez said. "I love this iconic
   character and all that she represents, and I'm truly excited by the challenge
   of inviting a new audience into her universe." "Barbarella is the ultimate
   science-fiction adventure heroine: smart, strong and sexy," said Dino De
   Laurentiis. "In our vision, the future is female, and I can't wait to
   introduce Barbarella to a new generation of moviegoers."

 * May 21, 2007 10:44 PM CST
   
   BETTER CASTING THAN I THOUGHT
   
   by #1 Zero
   
   The guy from Little Children is a good actor, he was in Angels in America as
   well I believe. But the owl was pretty fat and nerdy. This guy is pretty
   ripped and studly. But I think he can play it. I always thought Tom Selleck
   would be a good Comedian just on looks alone but that's not enough and
   wouldn't give the film credibility. Viggo Mortensen for Rorschach and why not
   Hugh Jackman for Dr. Manhattan. He was bald in the Fountain and has the
   physique.

 * May 21, 2007 10:53 PM CST
   
   IN SNYDER WE TRUST -- MY TWO CENTS:
   
   by _Lizarkeo
   
   The (Jude) Law is mandatory. A bald Keanu? Well, ok, "black hair and black
   coat" Constantine kind of worked. But the watchmaker (Sylar? cough cough),
   Jon Osterman, looks more like the other guy (which guy? ANY other guy!
   Hehehe). Gerard Butler as the Comedian? This is "comedian gold", man. Eddie
   Blake to Silkspectre2: "I AAAAAM YOUR FAAAAAAAATHEEER!!!!!". Ahem, actually,
   I dig the choice, the Comedian´s black eyemask will look just great on his
   MAD-AND-VERY-INTENSE eyes. About this Patrick fella, well, the sad fact is,
   all the other good choices are too old now. And THIS IS WHAT HAPPENS WHEN YOU
   FUCK A PROJECT SO MUCH TIME IN THE ASS, DUDE... Now, gotta update that old
   manip from five years ago, damn... http://tinyurl.com/ywbv9e

 * May 21, 2007 11:24 PM CST
   
   WHY NOT DO A ...
   
   by Antz
   
   ... Hellbazer adaptation and have Keanau play a blonde bastard ex-punk rocker
   British guy with a wicked sense of humor, it could be... oh... never mind.

 * May 21, 2007 11:29 PM CST
   
   ALFRED MOLINA AS NIGHT OWL
   
   by acebandg
   
   Patrick Wilson is in his 30's, bad choice for someone whose going through a
   middle age crisis. In fact, most (if not all) the heroes are in their are
   between their mid 40's and 50's (with exception for Laurie, who is likely to
   be in her 30's). To have young guns playing these beloved characters wouldn't
   be right in my opinion. anyways, Alfred Molina looks more like Night Owl and
   he would be a better actor for the part ta boot

 * May 21, 2007 11:31 PM CST
   
   BECAUSE I JUST FINISHED READING WATCHMEN LAST NIGHT
   
   by Bronx Cheer
   
   for the first time, it's very fresh. Wow, what a great work, by the way.
   
   Jude Law might work well, but he better get buff and they need to get his
   hair right.
   
   I don't know Patrick Wilson from Adam...checking IMDB...oh, yeah, he's
   perfect. Great choice.
   
   As for Keanu, it's funny, while I was reading the book, I had sort of cast
   each part, but I continual got stuck on Dr. Manhattan. I never once
   considered Reeves, but I think he's a very good choice. As Mori pointed out,
   he does have that "oddness" about him, and based on some key performances of
   his, especially as Siddhartha in "Little Buddha," I think he'll surprise a
   lot of the doubters. Good choice.
   
   I was thinking maybe Aaron Eckhart for Veidt. Rorschach--funny someone else
   said John C. McGinley, I thought either him or Woody Harrelson. Comedian is
   Bruce Willis or Kurt Russell. I don't know about the women. I think you can
   go any way with them, because they all seemed cut from the same cloth. Capt.
   Metropolis could be George Clooney or Eckhart or Hugh Jackman (because there
   is a law, just passed in the USA, that states that Hugh Jackman must be in
   every comic book film, or at least discussed for each one in development).
   
   Shirpa LeBoueffe can be Hollis at age 12, and I want Will Smith's kid as
   Bernard reading Tales of the Black Freighter.
   
   

 * May 21, 2007 11:33 PM CST
   
   TWO OUTTA THREE AIN'T BAD!
   
   by rickets419
   
   Patrick Wilson is an incredible actor, even though I think he's too young
   looking for Nite Owl, but I'm giving him the benefit of the doubt. Jude Law
   is also too you, but does fit well, so I'll go for that. Even though Tom
   Cruise (who sucks) really would have been a great social commentary casting.
   But Keanu?!?!?! Ominous?!?!?! All knowing?!?!? Not a chance!!! Billy Zane
   would have been creepier and cooler. These characters should be in their late
   forties- early fifties, with mel gibson as the comedian, (does anyone else
   see this???), ian holmes as moloch, Catherine Zeta-Jones or Jennifer Connelly
   as the Silk Spectre. Hope they cast an awesome unknown as Rorschach. This
   movie has to be incredible.

 * May 21, 2007 11:42 PM CST
   
   THE COMEDIAN
   
   by Patrick to the max
   
   should be none other than Ron Perlman. He'd be an awesome Comedian. Nuff
   said,

 * May 21, 2007 11:51 PM CST
   
   KEANU'S ALIEN OTHERWORLDLINESS...
   
   by TheGhostWhoLurks
   
   Is called marijuana, 'round these parts. See also: Mary-Jane, pot, weed,
   ganja and Gramma Betty's secret ingredient.

 * May 22, 2007 12:04 AM CST
   
   HEROES VS. WATCHMEN
   
   by Gislef_crow
   
   Keep in mind that Watchmen's ending was basically taken from an old Outer
   Limits episode. Which they at least acknowledged in Issue #12, but it's not
   like they invented it... For Rorschach, Debra Winger. Check her out in "Made
   in Heaven" (1987).

 * May 22, 2007 12:09 AM CST
   
   DOUG HUTCHISON MUST BE WALTER KOVACS
   
   by ZeroCorpse
   
   Rorshach will only be done justice by Doug Hutchison. I led the charge years
   ago, and others have picked up the ball and run with it, and Doug was brought
   into this and is actively pursuing the role, last I heard. He's perfect. This
   is his role. I want to see this happen.

 * May 22, 2007 12:14 AM CST
   
   THANK GOD 300 BROKE THE PROVERBIAL BANK
   
   by IndustryKiller!
   
   Because now this film just might get the budget it needs. Even know I
   certainly didn't think 300 was anywhere near where the hype placed it, it's
   for the greater good.

 * May 22, 2007 12:34 AM CST
   
   RORSCHACH MUST BE AN UNKNOWN ACTOR
   
   by darwinmayflower
   
   end of story.

 * May 22, 2007 12:59 AM CST
   
   GOTTA SAY, LAW IS KIND OF BORING.
   
   by superninja
   
   Keanu is not mature enough as an actor to play Manhattan - he always comes
   across as a near void. Get someone with gravitas who seems intelligent.
   Kilmer would actually probably be extremely interesting although I prefer
   Kilmer for Ozy. They don't all have to come across as a bunch of pretty boys,
   either. Cast some men, now.

 * May 22, 2007 1:16 AM CST
   
   I LIKE CRUISE AS OZY. SPOILER ALERT!
   
   by quentintarantado
   
   I thought Tom Cruise as Ozymandias, though unlikely, would be interesting. He
   certainly has the ego. To WIN in the end would be doubly, satisfyingly
   frustrating to the viewer.

 * May 22, 2007 4:05 AM CST
   
   JUST GOT OFF THE PHONE WITH ZACK SNYDER
   
   by Motoko Kusanagi
   
   and told him that he is a movie god.

 * May 22, 2007 2:19 AM CST
   
   WAIT, DOES THIS MEAN KEANU'S PENIS JUST GOT CAST?
   
   by Alonzo Mosely
   
   Painted blue and waved around for 100 minutes...

 * May 22, 2007 2:27 AM CST
   
   DAVID MORSE FOR RORSCHACH...
   
   by Sledge Hammer
   
   The guy has sheer presence when he needs it, and can also be believable as a
   scary dude who could fuck you up when he plays it up. But at the same time he
   can easily pull off the near-anonymous "everyman" and blend into the crowd,
   and while relatively well known he's not famous enough so as to be completely
   obvious to first timers if he's just kind of there milling in the background.
   
   If you want to go with a smaller guy, then how about John Glover? Though he
   might be just a touch old. Mind you Mark Hamill and the oft mentioned David
   Caruso would be solid choices too, and I quite like the idea of John C
   McGinley (playaing against type somewhat) in the role, which could work quite
   well. Fact is, there's quite a few actors out there that could make
   interesting Rorschachs, some of the other roles, not so much.
   
   As for the above casting, frankly Law worries me far more than Reeves,
   because I know that Reeves will a) put the effort in, b) take it seriously,
   and c) be open to being guided by the director, whereas Law has always seemed
   more manipulative and less dedicated in his choices to me. Plus he just
   doesn't sell threatening or the weight of power in my mind very convincingly.
   Maybe Law could pull the role off, but it's hard to be convinced by the fact
   at this stage. As for NightOwl, I still think Cusack would have been perfect.
   Oh, and Kurt Russell should be The Comedian.

 * May 22, 2007 4:34 AM CST
   
   KEANU AS DR MANHATTAN=FLAMES ON OPTIMUS
   
   by stones_throw
   
   Dream Casting - Alec Baldwin-Nite Owl II, Paddy Considine-Rorschach, Julianne
   Moore-Silk Spectre, Bruce Willis-Comedian, Paul Newman-Nite Owl I,
   Ozymandias-Val Kilmer, Dr Manhattan-Guy Pearce

 * May 22, 2007 4:58 AM CST
   
   HARVEY DENT AS OZYMANDIAS
   
   by pipergates
   
   much as i like Jude he is a bit young, soft, skinny and jaw-lacking for this
   role. i like Pegg for Rorschach too, since George Bush probably wont do it.

 * May 22, 2007 5:07 AM CST
   
   POWERS BOOTH AS THE COMEDIAN!
   
   by Datascream
   
   I can kinda see it....am I alone on this? hello?

 * May 22, 2007 5:12 AM CST
   
   I HATE JUDE LAW
   
   by angrykirby.tk
   
   he sucks in everything

 * May 22, 2007 3:19 AM CST
   
   KEANU IS GOING TO ROCK AS DR MANHATTAN!
   
   by Jon E Cin
   
   People shouldnt hate on Keanu. He's a solid actor and gives his all in every
   role. I have full confidence he'll do his best in this role. I like that Jude
   Law is cast as well. Very cool news.

 * May 22, 2007 3:26 AM CST
   
   OH YEAH MORI..
   
   by Jon E Cin
   
   didnt I email you this info about 3 weeks ago?????????

 * May 22, 2007 4:13 AM CST
   
   KEANU ROCKS!
   
   by kiddae
   
   That's awesome. Jude Law works, but Neo Manhattan is really cool. Nite Owl
   needs to be older and fatter. Alec Baldwin or Jeff Bridges. And I cannot
   fathom anyone wanting a name for Rorschach, he absolutely MUST be an unknown,
   with no picture of him unmasked released before the movie opens. Fans of the
   comic will be able to spot him straight away, but it'd still be awesome to
   just have him as the anonymous bum/doomsayer.

 * May 22, 2007 4:28 AM CST
   
   ANDY SERKIS FOR RORSCHACH
   
   by 11dayempire
   
   You know it makes sense. He does bug-eyed creepiness well, his face isn't
   *that* familiar to casual moviegoers (so it wouldn't spoil the surprise of
   his secret identity), and he's used to working under a spandex mask. What's
   not to like?

 * May 22, 2007 6:32 AM CST
   
   BRUCE CAMPBELL SHOULD PLAY DR MANHATTAN...
   
   by Edward_nygma
   
   ...he can so do this part.

 * May 22, 2007 5:35 AM CST
   
   KEANU'S BLUE SCROTUM
   
   by pipergates
   
   that would be a neat subtitle for the film.

 * May 22, 2007 6:18 AM CST
   
   MR MONKEY I AM IN AGREEMENT
   
   by PotSmokinAlien
   
   seriously, keanu makes me suspicious but that's something that *might* work.
   jude law as ozi is wroooooong wrong wrong. i think snyder is gonna fuck this
   thing up huge like.

 * May 22, 2007 8:44 AM CST
   
   KEANU REEVES AS AN INFINATELY SMART SUPERBEING? WHY
   
   by lilgorgor
   
   why why why

 * May 22, 2007 8:50 AM CST
   
   RORSHCNACH
   
   by WillPfilm
   
   Paddy Considine as Rorschnach.. No-one else comes close

 * May 22, 2007 7:32 AM CST
   
   CAST EDDIE MURPHY AND MIKE MYERS IN ALL THE ROLES.
   
   by Mosquito March
   
   That would make a shitload of dough.

 * May 22, 2007 7:53 AM CST
   
   A YOUNG BRUCE BOXLEITNER MIGHT HAVE BEEN GOOD AS...
   
   by The Ape Giggins
   
   Ozymandias, but too late now!

 * May 22, 2007 10:08 AM CST
   
   I NEVER THOUGHT....
   
   by jpdisco
   
   That 2 words could completely put me off ever seeing this movie. Jude Law,
   you're more powerful than I thought.

 * May 22, 2007 8:53 AM CST
   
   MESSI,
   
   by Motoko Kusanagi
   
   SHUT THE HELL UP

 * May 22, 2007 11:03 AM CST
   
   MATTHEW PERRY AS NIGHT OWL
   
   by syoreed
   
   Though Dan Dreiberg may exhibit a certain amount of "quiet sadness," I see
   him a bit more clumsy and, I'll say it, pudgier than Raoul. I think Perry's
   time on STUDIO 60 proves that he can be both sad, funny and clumsy,
   especially around the women folk. Plus, Perry looks older than Wilson (who
   looks far too young to be a middle-aged "adventurer"). And I thought that
   Snyder said Gerard Butler was going to be in this one? Is that still
   happening?

 * May 22, 2007 9:29 AM CST
   
   ADAM WEST AS HOLLIS MASON
   
   by Fuck The Napkin
   
   The best casting suggestion I've ever read on here. It would be PERFECT!

 * May 22, 2007 11:39 AM CST
   
   GARY STRETCH-COMEDIAN
   
   by Spartacus Hughs
   
   .

 * May 22, 2007 11:40 AM CST
   
   PADDY CONSIDINE-RORSCHACH
   
   by Spartacus Hughs
   
   ..

 * May 22, 2007 11:41 AM CST
   
   VIGGO MORTENSON-DR MANHATTAN
   
   by Spartacus Hughs
   
   ...

 * May 22, 2007 11:42 AM CST
   
   JAKE WEBBER-NITE OWL
   
   by Spartacus Hughs
   
   ....

 * May 22, 2007 11:48 AM CST
   
   ERIC BANA-OZYMANDIAS
   
   by Spartacus Hughs
   
   .....

 * May 22, 2007 10:03 AM CST
   
   JUST AS LONG AS IT'S
   
   by Blood T Cat
   
   chock full of shots of people stepping in puddles and match cuts. Lots of
   match cuts. More puddles! Buckets of thinly veiled Iraq War metaphors! And
   Hugh Laurie! And somebody drip some Clooney in there somewhere. And don't
   forget that story within a story that was so captivating!

 * May 22, 2007 10:04 AM CST
   
   PARKER POSEY FOR SS.
   
   by jalfredprufrock
   
   You know it would be 8 kinds of great. Rorschach has to be an unknown. It
   needs to be at least a bit of a shock when they rip his mask off mid
   beat-down. This Keanu thing has me a bit down, but hopefully Snyder can pull
   something good out of it.

 * May 22, 2007 10:08 AM CST
   
   OH -AND WHOEVER SAID ADAM WEST FOR HOLLIS
   
   by jalfredprufrock
   
   is a fucking casting genius.

 * May 22, 2007 10:14 AM CST
   
   THE MOST IMPORTANT BIT OF CASTING IS...
   
   by adrock303
   
   ...Rorschach, and we don't even know who it's gonna be yet. The good news is
   it's obviously gonna be someone good. The casting is great so far, and that
   includes Gerard Butler who I think we can pencil in as the Comedian. I have
   it on good authority that Rorschach carries this movie. Maybe Brad Pitt will
   join the cast after all?

 * May 22, 2007 10:35 AM CST
   
   WHAT ABOUT BRAD DOURIF AS RORSCHACH?
   
   by dirkadirkadirka
   
   Wormtongue, Doc Cochrane, Chucky...he could pull it off.

 * May 22, 2007 12:37 PM CST
   
   BRUCE CAMPBELL FOR THE COMEDIAN.
   
   by Darksider
   
   I'm not even fucking joking. He's even got his own robe. Gerard Butler for
   Rorschach. Don't like Keanu for Dr. Manhattan. Jude Law seems like a good
   choice. You need someone who in real life would be likeable and good looking.
   The last person you would suspect. Not too familiar with Patrick Wilson, so I
   don't know.

 * May 22, 2007 10:45 AM CST
   
   JOHN CUSACK! ETC.
   
   by zombiezeus
   
   Night Owl (Dan)= John Cusack (PERFECT--he can be physically imposing, but
   NAILS that unsure-of-himself-but-ultimately-capable characteristic that
   defines Night Owl. Also we can believe he's smart enough to make all those
   gadgets, down-to-earth enough to be appealing, AND he looks like him!) The
   Comedian= Mel Gibson (Tough as nails? Crass? Unpopular political views and
   not afraid to share his opinion no matter what? Dark, haunted past? BINGO.)
   Ozymandias= Jude Law (I'm sorry, he's just perfect in every way for this
   role.) Doctor Manhattan= Russell Crowe (originally I considered him for The
   Comedian, but picture him as Doc Manhattan--ok so the face is not close at
   all, but cold? Detached? Obsessed? Supersmart? It also gives him a chance to
   play against type for once) Rorschach= Simon Pegg (looks the part, a really
   good actor, and you will find NO ONE more committed to the role) Silk Specter
   (Sally)= Ashley Judd (beautiful, complicated, and able to be a super hero.
   Absolutely.) Silk Specter (Laurie)= Diane Lane (could be Ashley's mom, sexy
   older woman, and she'd probably love to stretch as a frumpy used-to-be
   sexpot) Night Owl (Hollis)= Rutger Hauer (he was a scrapper back in the
   day--but they'd have to 'young him up' a little for the flashbacks) At LEAST
   John Cusack as Night Owl, though. He is PERFECT.

 * May 22, 2007 10:47 AM CST
   
   SO, HOW PISSED OFF ARE YOU GOING TO BE WHEN.......
   
   by lost.rules
   
   this movie sucks. Just reading who there offering parts to is frightening.

 * May 22, 2007 10:49 AM CST
   
   WHO'S GONNA WATCH THE WATCHMEN?
   
   by Blood T Cat
   
   Seriously. Your average moviegoer has no idea what the hell the Watchmen is.
   The story is talky and slow and not fun at all. Sure it was fresh twenty
   years ago but now the book seems pretentious and obvious.

 * May 22, 2007 10:51 AM CST
   
   SIMON PEGG AS RORSHACH
   
   by Shigeru
   
   that's all

 * May 22, 2007 11:25 AM CST
   
   JACKIE EARL HALEY = RORSCHACH
   
   by TORTURE PWN
   
   Aaron Eckhart= Ozymandias,& again,STACY KEACH= THE COMEDIAN.

 * May 22, 2007 11:32 AM CST
   
   I'M NOT BUYING KEANU AS A GENIUS.
   
   by ZeroCorpse
   
   I'm sorry, but Dr. Manhattan was a genius BEFORE his accident. I simply can't
   buy Keanu Reeves as a genius scientist. No way. No how.
   
   Doc Manhattan needs to be a lot more brainy and plain. Keanu is always Keanu,
   no matter who he's playing, it's always shades of Ted "Theodore" Logan.

 * May 22, 2007 12:16 PM CST
   
   RORSCHACH...
   
   by Kid Z
   
   ...=Steve Buscemi! The Comedian... Christopher Walken, bulk him up a little
   and have him grow a sleazy 70's porn star 'stache.

 * May 22, 2007 12:37 PM CST
   
   I FEEL...
   
   by CutAndPaste
   
   ...Bruce Campbell should play every role. Even the women. I've never even
   read Watchmen, but I don't see how this could possibly fail.

 * May 22, 2007 12:44 PM CST
   
   DARKSIDER
   
   by BGDAWES
   
   Holy shit, I think you're right! Bruce would be great as the comedian. For
   some reason I also think DeNiro, Keitel, or maybe even Michael Madsen might
   do well too.

 * May 22, 2007 1:11 PM CST
   
   RORSHACH LOOKS LIKE A KID WHEN THEY TAKE
   
   by superninja
   
   his mask off. Why is everyone trying to cast someone older unless they don't
   want the voice to match the actor? Personally, it would work best if it was a
   somewhat famous actor who could change their voice to sound older. That would
   throw people off - casting an unknown will not shock anyone.

 * May 22, 2007 1:14 PM CST
   
   JUDE LAW IS SHORT AND NOTEABLE FOR PLAYING GIGOLOS
   
   by superninja
   
   not the kind of person who would inspire the confidence of the entire world.
   It needs someone else, it just makes me think they don't get the character
   except for superficially. Same with the Keanu casting. Looks over ability to
   channel the character's main traits.

 * May 22, 2007 1:16 PM CST
   
   M.C. GAINEY FROM LOST WOULD BE GOOD AS THE COMEDIAN TOO
   
   by TORTURE PWN
   
   But come the fuck on...Stacy Keach IS The mother fucking Comedian.

 * May 22, 2007 1:21 PM CST
   
   CASTING DUMB
   
   by kylerayner
   
   Jude Law? WTF? Ozymandias is BIG, buff, and all-American looking. BLOND.
   Hello, casting clue phone... And Keanu? WHAT? And as some have said.
   Middle-aged is the very point. These are supposed to be heroes in decline.
   William Macy would be good as Rorschach or Dan. Stacy Keach as the Comedian
   is awesome. There should be NO pretty boys in this movie. Ozym. could be
   handsome, but not pretty. And every actor should be at least 40. I've no idea
   what these people are thinking. Another great property ruined. Does Moore
   have any control on this one? Probably not.

 * May 22, 2007 1:21 PM CST
   
   PITT IS A BETTER CHOICE FOR OZY. LIFE IMITATING ART.
   
   by superninja
   
   Maybe Eric Bana would be good for Manhattan? He has very soulful eyes and as
   we saw in Hulk can play a cold fish.
   
   What about Saffron Burrows for Silk Spectre? She is a great actress and very
   sexy. Her daughter can be played by Romola Garai who is an excellent actress
   as well.

 * May 22, 2007 1:23 PM CST
   
   SAFFRON BURROWS AND ROMOLA GARAI FOR THE SILK
   
   by superninja
   
   Spectres. Just seconding my previous nom. I am a genuis!

 * May 22, 2007 1:24 PM CST
   
   OKAY, MAYBE I'M NOT A GENUIS.
   
   by superninja
   
   But I am a genius! I don't have a problem with the guy they have playing Nite
   Owl. He is the one character who is better off being an unknown since he is
   the reluctant hero of the story.

 * May 22, 2007 1:29 PM CST
   
   THOMAS JANE WOULD BE A BETTER VEIDT THAN LAW
   
   by TORTURE PWN
   
   and again Jackie Earl Haley = RORSCHACH

 * May 22, 2007 1:35 PM CST
   
   THE COMEDIAN IS SOMEONE YOU KIND OF LIKE
   
   by superninja
   
   in spite of himself. They need to cast a well-liked actor and have him play a
   real @$$hole. Campbell is too old, but I don't think other than his looks
   he's strong enough to play the character. Could actually be a really good
   turn for Jackman to play against type.

 * May 22, 2007 1:41 PM CST
   
   ROMOLA GARAI WOULD ALSO MAKE A GREAT BLACK
   
   by superninja
   
   Canary for a Green Arrow film.

 * May 22, 2007 1:47 PM CST
   
   WOW...I'M SURPRISED NO ONE SAID THIS.
   
   by 7pointedstar
   
   I'd like to see Tim Roth play Rorschach. That would just be sweet. And, to
   me, Jude Law is a good pick for Ozymandias. He can certainly project an "I'm
   better than you...and the rest of the world" attitude.

 * May 22, 2007 2:12 PM CST
   
   OZYMANDIAS HAS TO INSPIRE THE ENTIRE WORLD TO
   
   by superninja
   
   follow him, not just have an air of superiority or elitism. He has to convey
   trust and authority generally and then turn suspicious and elitist when
   confronted. That Jude Law could do the first part which is the MAIN FUNCTION
   of the character is somewhat less believeable in my opinion - he comes across
   as a giggolo. Personally, I think Val Kilmer is ideal for this part as he can
   play both likeable/charming and psycho.

 * May 22, 2007 2:30 PM CST
   
   WERNER HERZOG AS RORSHACH!
   
   by JimmyLoneWolf
   
   Think about it...you know it could work...inspired casting. It will never
   happen of course, but he'd be brilliant.

 * May 22, 2007 2:41 PM CST
   
   JUDE LAW= BOX OFFICE POISON
   
   by TORTURE PWN
   
   You know it's true!

 * May 22, 2007 3:14 PM CST
   
   BEN FROM LOST ==> RORSHACH
   
   by Calico Pete
   
   Eddie Izzard ==> Nite Owl
   
   Anyone remember the super old rumor (maybe from back in the "Terry Gilliam
   directing Watchmen" day) that Schwarzeneggar was gonna be Dr. Manhatten?
   
   And speaking of Arnold, how about Arnold Vosloo (from the Mummy) as Dr.
   Manhatten? Yeah yeah, the roles've been cast. Still...

 * May 22, 2007 3:18 PM CST
   
   NO, I GOT IT...
   
   by Calico Pete
   
   Sam Jackson himself ==> Dr. Manhattan; or Shaq. Wait... what's that? They
   cast him already? As Rorshach you say? Oh, you mean they cast Dr Manhattan.
   Oh ok. Got it. I'll shut up now.

 * May 22, 2007 3:23 PM CST
   
   JUDE LAW: LEADER OF THE FREE WORLD.
   
   by superninja
   
   Sounds a bit ridiculous, kind of like Keanu Reeves: Physicist and Super
   Genius.

 * May 22, 2007 3:44 PM CST
   
   LINDSAY LOHAN: "I'M GONNA DO SOME COKE..."
   
   by Vitiumconatusimbibespermaequinus
   
   And fly to New York to fuck Ozymandias!"
   
   Now, if he'll just leave her to freeze to death in Antarctica...

 * May 22, 2007 3:55 PM CST
   
   BARRY PEPPER AS RORSCHACH & ERIC BANA AS DR. MANHATTAN
   
   by noctos
   
   I applaud Zack Snyder for choosing Jude Law. Patrick Wilson is a great actor
   as well. But I just don't understand how Keanu Reeves could do a convincing
   Dr. Manhattan. This is not the Matrix but a humanised version of Superheores,
   for which one would need good actors. I would propose Eric Bana as Dr.
   Manhattan (remember Chopper? Bana could puff such a transformation off). And
   Barry Pepper is obviously the best suited actor to play Rorschach.
   Furthermore: Michelle Monaghan as Silk Spectre, Ian Mcshane as the Comedian
   and Mark Ruffalo as Nite Owl. Anyway, more about my Watchmen dreamcast here:
   http://noctos.wordpress.com/2007/05/22/my-watchmen-dreamcast/

 * May 22, 2007 4:01 PM CST
   
   VITIUMCONATUSIMBIBESPERMAEQUINUS
   
   by Mr. Nice Gaius
   
   Worst. Talkbacker. Name. Ever.

 * May 22, 2007 4:02 PM CST
   
   IN FACT, ERIC BANA WOULD BE A GREAT NITE OWL...
   
   by Wonderboys
   
   Yep!

 * May 22, 2007 4:04 PM CST
   
   MICHAEL MADSEN AS THE COMEDIAN!!!
   
   by Chriscarlisle
   
   C'mon, no one does crazy psycho better than Michael Madsen! This is a no
   brainer casting choice.

 * May 22, 2007 4:07 PM CST
   
   AND I HOPE FOR YOU WATCHMEN FANS...
   
   by Mr. Nice Gaius
   
   ...that Snyder does this justice. Comparing what everyone expects from
   "Watchmen" against what he did with "300"...I'm just not feeling it. Of
   course, casting is always key and some of these names have promise. But I
   remain skeptical for the timebeing.

 * May 22, 2007 4:22 PM CST
   
   OH FUCK YES!!!!!!!
   
   by ImJustSaying
   
   Ok, fuck all ya'll Keanu is going to be the shit in this role. If you don't
   believe me go watch A Scanner Darkly again (his best acting to date). Perfect
   part for him, and I wouldn't have thought of it in a million years, so hats
   off to that outside the box creative casting. Jude's a slam dunk, and I'm so
   excited to see what Patrick does with this role (and I really do hope he puts
   on the pounds). With this calibre of actors almost on board, I really hope
   this film isn't trashy like Snyder's previous work (if you didn't think 300
   was kinda trashy, you're frankly rather dense). This is supposed to be an
   emotional story, and these look like the actors to pull that off. Oh, and
   someone mentioned Damion Lewis for Rorshach, and I have never agreed with
   anything in a talkback more!! I'm still kinda nervous about this one, but I
   hope it KICKS THE SHIT OUT OF HEROES.

 * May 22, 2007 4:25 PM CST
   
   BARRY PEPPER???? RORSCHACH??????
   
   by dirkadirkadirka
   
   He's a terrible choice. Gos, what a terrible actor. How about Vin Deisel as
   the comedian. Give me a freakin break. Madsens a good call though. He plays a
   quality bad ass.

 * May 22, 2007 5:36 PM CST
   
   YAY, IT'S THE CLOWN FROM SPAWN'S COUSIN.
   
   by superninja
   
   A scary horror clown: it's soooo original!

 * May 22, 2007 5:51 PM CST
   
   IT NEEDS A GIANT ROBOT OF DR. MANHATTAN.
   
   by superninja
   
   That would be more realistic.

 * May 22, 2007 6:14 PM CST
   
   CLINT HOWARD AS RORSCHACH!
   
   by WONKABAR
   
   anybody? anybody? Btw Reeves looks really freaky bald...

 * May 22, 2007 6:55 PM CST
   
   WARWICK DAVIS FOR RORSCHACH! IT'S THE ONLY WAY!!!
   
   by Err
   
   It's the only way this movie'll get made.

 * May 22, 2007 7:07 PM CST
   
   CARROT-TOP= TEH >RORSCHACH!
   
   by WONKABAR
   
   You know it to be true

 * May 22, 2007 7:17 PM CST
   
   THE NOVEL DOES HAVE PIRATES
   
   by krushjudgement
   
   Reading is good.

 * May 22, 2007 11:57 PM CST
   
   WINO
   
   by AICN Nazi
   
   Watchmen In Name Only!

 * May 23, 2007 12:32 AM CST
   
   ACTUALLY, MARK HAMILL AS RORSCHACH....
   
   by WONKABAR
   
   is a really great fucking idea...good call CarbonGhost! Seriously, that would
   be the most epic geek-casting ever...and Hamill would do a great job to boot.
   I'm sure he's a fan of the material as well. I hope someone somehow gets this
   idea to Snyder cuz that would be the shit right there.

 * May 23, 2007 4:41 AM CST
   
   PETER MACNICOL
   
   by GrandpaUlrira
   
   As Rorschach. Or in fact, anyone who can seem really benign and harmless
   until he gets going with the beating.

 * May 23, 2007 8:03 AM CST
   
   RORSCACH
   
   by hippy32
   
   Why should Rorscach be an unknown actor? never announce the casting of
   Rorscach. announce the casting of walter kovacs. the geek community will know
   who kovacs is, the non geek community wont. hell, i figure a lot of them will
   take (for arguments sake) David Caruso, the guy holding the sign and being
   near all the crime scenes as the murderer that Rorscach is hunting.

 * May 23, 2007 10:37 AM CST
   
   KEANU = PERFECT CASTING
   
   by Nachokoolaid
   
   Back when I first read Watchmen a couple of years ago, I remember wishing
   that Keanu would be Dr. Manhattan if they ever made a film. He does
   "detached" very well.

 * May 23, 2007 7:26 PM CST
   
   JOSH HARTNETT
   
   by Blueberry
   
   He could be a better Doc Manhattan than Keanu. And he has a far better body
   too.

 * May 23, 2007 7:41 PM CST
   
   MICHAEL BIEHN = COMEDIAN
   
   by Calico Pete
   
   you know i'm right.

 * May 24, 2007 10:21 PM CST
   
   RORSCHACH VICTIM: DUSTIN DIAMOND
   
   by Marvel1967
   
   I hope the guy in the bar who gets his fingers broken by Rorschach is played
   by Dustin Diamond, his fingers actually are broken, and he is uncredited in
   the film. And kicked in the balls. For real.

 * May 29, 2007 5:46 PM CST
   
   NIGHT WATCHMAN NAME BLUNDERS
   
   by Unruly
   
   Are we all just confused, here? Keanu Reeves is set to start filming in the
   "Night Watch" formerly named "The Night Watchman" which is based on novel by
   James Ellroy. The movie's name was changed "to probably to avoid confusion
   with Warner Brothers upcoming adaptation of the Alan Moore graphic novel,"
   according to Richard in Movies at The Movie Biz. However, "Night Watch" is
   also the first title in the series of Russian novels-turned-films rumored to
   be slated for an American remake - it’s also the title of at least one novel
   by Terry Pratchett novel as well as an Ewan McGregor horror-thriller, which
   was itself a remake of a Danish film also known by the same name. Thoroughly
   confused yet?

 * May 31, 2007 10:53 AM CST
   
   DUUUUUUUUUUDE...
   
   by Ned Pepper
   
   Keanu Reeks? A one-note actor playing the most complex being on the planet?
   I'm ready to go Rorschach on the casting director.

Trending
 * Marc Singer talks AGENT RECON
 * It May Only be July, but Here's a Trailer for THE BEST CHRISTMAS PAGEANT
   EVER!


Home | Cool News | Coaxial / TV | Picks & Peeks | Movie Reviews | Animation |
Comics | Search | Comics | The Zone Forums RSS | Privacy Policy | Contact AICN
This site is © 1996-2024 Ain't It Cool News.