www.bridgemi.com Open in urlscan Pro
2600:9000:23cb:5000:2:751f:ccc0:93a1  Public Scan

Form analysis
1 forms found in the DOM

/search

<form action="/search" target="_top" class="form-item form-type-textfield search-form form-item-search-block-form"><label class="visually-hidden" for="search-block-form">Search</label><input title="Enter the terms you wish to search for."
    placeholder="Search" type="text" id="search-block-form" name="keywords" value="" size="15" maxlength="128" class="form-text">
  <div class="form-actions form-wrapper" id="edit-actions"> <input type="submit" id="edit-submit" name="op" value="Search" class="form-submit"></div>
</form>

Text Content

Skip to main content


MAIN NAVIGATION

 * Popular
   Popular
    * Most Popular Article
      
      
      AN ARREST, MORE PROTESTS AT UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN GRADUATION EVENTS
      
      May 4, 2024 | Isabel Lohman in 
      Talent & Education
      
    * Most Popular, #2–7
      2024 Michigan elections: Whitmer, Thanedar take heat over Israel-Hamas war
      May 6, 2024
      Michigan ‘fake elector’ takes on top Democrat in bid for state House
      May 3, 2024
      U-M seeks to bring jobs to Detroit with a $250M innovation center
      May 3, 2024
      Lawsuit accuses EPA of failing to prevent harmful algal blooms in Lake
      Erie
      May 2, 2024
      COVID Tracker | Cases increase; Bridge discontinuing tracker
      April 30, 2024
      New Airbnb tax plan hits snag as summer tourism comes to Michigan
      May 1, 2024

 * Topics
   Topics
    * Talent & Education
    * Government
    * Health
    * Children & Families
    * Business
    * Urban Affairs
    * Quality of Life
    * Environment
    * Guest Commentary

 * Archive
 * About
   About
    * About
    * Staff
    * Funders
    * Individual Membership
    * Business & Nonprofit Membership
    * Power Circle Membership
    * Sponsorship
    * Jobs
    * The Center for Michigan
    * Corrections Policy
    * (Empty item)

 * Events
 * Sign Up
 * Contact
 * Search
   
   Close menu


Michigan’s nonpartisan, nonprofit news source
Menu
Please further the work we do with a donation
DONATE TODAY
Dismiss



Journalism protects democracy





Trustworthy, nonpartisan local news like ours spurs growth, fosters
relationships, and helps to ensure that everyone is informed. This is essential
to a healthy democracy. Will you support the nonprofit, nonpartisan news that
makes Michigan a better place this election year?

Make your tax-deductible contribution today.



Pay with VISA Pay with MasterCard Pay with American Express Pay with PayPal
Donate


TRENDING:

 * Coronavirus Michigan
 * Michigan K-12 schools
 * Gov. Gretchen Whitmer
 * Michigan colleges and universities
 * Rural Michigan

Topic: Talent & Education


WHITMER SEEKS $670M FOR MICHIGAN SCHOOLS. CRITICS CALL IT A ‘RAID’

Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer is facing GOP opposition as she seeks to redirect
teacher retirement fund contributions. (State of Michigan)
May 2, 2024
Isabel Lohman (Email)
Talent & Education
Michigan K-12 schools, Gov. Gretchen Whitmer

Share This:

Share this article on Twitter
Share this article on Facebook
Share this article on LinkedIn
Share this article via email
Print this article

Talent & Education
Whitmer seeks $670M for Michigan schools. Critics call it a ‘raid’

Share This:

Share this article on Twitter
Share this article on Facebook
Share this article on LinkedIn
Share this article via email
Print this article
Donate

 * Michigan Democrats proposing to boost school budgets by reducing teacher
   retirement fund contributions
 * Gov. Whitmer and allies contend it’s safe to redirect payments to the fully
   funded health care system back into classrooms
 * Republicans call it a ‘raid’ on teacher pension system that could jeopardize
   promises to retirees

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

With federal pandemic funding running dry, Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer is
seeking savings from the state's teacher retirement system in order to avoid
cuts and support other priorities for K-12 schools.  

The Democratic governor's budget plan would reduce state contributions to the
shared retirement system, which would free up $670 million that her office says
could be "invested into classrooms to help children learn."

While health care obligations are fully funded on paper, Republicans have
blasted the proposal as a “raid” on the teacher pension system, which remains
underfunded by nearly $30 billion.

Sponsor


They warn the governor’s plan could jeopardize long-promised benefits for
retired educators. 

Related:

 * Democrats ditching Whitmer plans for Michigan trash fee hike, EV rebates
 * U-M expert probes psychological effect of active-shooter drills in schools
 * Michigan gun plan would make schools share safe storage law with parents

Whitmer, however, compares her proposal to a homeowner paying off a mortgage
early. After years of helping districts make payments, she contends it is safe
for the state to scale back and redirect retirement contributions.

Fellow Democrats, who have narrow majorities in the state House and Senate,
appear to generally be on board with the governor’s plan but are crafting their
own budgets ahead of final negotiations in coming months.

Because a massive influx of federal and state surplus funding has run out,
Whitmer’s school aid proposal is $849 million smaller than the version she
signed last year. 

That means her plan to free up $670 million by reducing retirement contributions
could be especially important for funding local schools already facing a
so-called COVID cliff that could force spending cuts. 

The governor also wants to expand free preschool access to all families,
regardless of their income, and create a tuition-free community college
guarantee for Michigan high school graduates, among other things. 


WHAT IS MPSERS? 

The Michigan Public School Employees’ Retirement System (MPSERS) is designed to
centralize management of retirement income and health care benefit programs for
educators across the state. 

Members include employees in more than 600 traditional public, intermediate and
charter school districts, along with 28 community colleges, some libraries and
some universities.

As of last year, there were about 226,087 retirees and beneficiaries receiving
benefits and 154,688 active employees in the system.

While Michigan offers both 401k- and hybrid-style plans, nearly half of all
active employees are part of a "member investment" pension plan that requires
them to contribute 7% of the costs.


IS MPSERS UNDERFUNDED? 

The health care portion of the teacher retirement system is fully funded, but
the pension portion remains roughly $29.9 billion underfunded, meaning long-term
cost projections exceed current funding levels. 

Michigan caps the amount that local school districts have to pay to fund the
system. 

Because the health portion is fully funded, Whitmer contends the state is no
longer obligated to pay additional costs mandated under a 2017 law.

“We will pay down more debt early, freeing up hundreds of millions of dollars
for students now while shoring up the retirements of our educators,” Whitmer
said earlier this year when unveiling her budget plan. 

But MPSERS is “one promise” with “two parts,” said Jase Bolger, policy advisor
at the West Michigan Policy Forum and a Republican former Speaker of the
Michigan House. 

“The two parts are retiree healthcare and pension,” he said, arguing the state
government should not treat the two separately. “And so it is massively
underfunded. We're making progress, but now is no time to stop.” 

The state is in a “unique situation,” added James Hohman, director of fiscal
policy at the Mackinac Center for Public Policy, a free market think tank. 

“The state only began pre-funding retiree healthcare benefits in 2012 and
surprisingly they were able to catch up on what they owed within 15 years,” he
said.


WHY ARE REPUBLICANS OBJECTING TO THE WHITMER PLAN? 

Bolger contends it’s the legally and morally correct thing to do to put any
funds the state would have been putting toward healthcare benefits toward the
remaining pension debt.

“They both want to rob from teachers’ pensions, which will gamble with their
future retirement, so that they can spend the money today,” Bolger said. 

Michigan law prohibits the state from reducing funding to the retirement system
debt until it is fully funded. But Whitmer’s plan is built around the assumption
of separate funding “floors” for health care and pensions.

State Sen. Thomas Albert, R-Lowell, who sponsored a 2018 law that amended the
state pension system, said that is incorrect. He argues that the $670 million
isn’t even savings, it’s money that must be put in the larger retirement
system. 

Albert has requested the Office of Retirement Services to explain its rationale
for dividing the debts into two parts. 

“We have to make sure our teachers that have earned this benefit get it,” Albert
told Bridge. “...If we're not responsible, we're going to continue to take money
out of the classroom, which is not going to help us in making sure our kids have
the opportunities that they need.”


WHAT DO DEMOCRAT LAWMAKERS WANT TO DO?

Both the Senate and House budget proposals agree with the governor’s proposal to
spend the money elsewhere.

But the House’s proposal would use $290.8 million to lower how much school
districts have to pay into the system and $51.6 million to help districts
reimburse employees for their portion of healthcare contributions.

That’s more than Whitmer’s proposal, which would use $94.3 million to lower how
much school districts have to pay into the system. 

State Rep. Regina Weiss, D-Oak Park, chair of the House appropriations
subcommittee on School Aid and Education, said reducing districts’ contributions
is important because it equates to more funds districts can use directly in
classrooms. 

The focus on additional funding sources comes as school districts are seeing the
end of their federal pandemic relief funds, Weiss acknowledged. 

She said the House proposal provides savings for districts and employees while
also freeing up money for other Democratic priorities, including free school
meals, student transportation and efforts to address declining enrollment.


WHAT ARE MICHIGAN SCHOOL GROUPS SAYING? 

Despite GOP warnings that Whitmer’s plan amounts to a “raid” on teacher
pensions, education leaders appear open to the debate but want to ensure that
they benefit from any savings realized by the state. 

In particular, school groups have praised the state House proposal, which would
use some of the savings Whitmer anticipates to cut retiree contributions for
schools.

Doug Pratt, director of communications and public engagement at the Michigan
Education Association union, said “taking that money and spending it on current
needs as opposed to overfunding that system makes sense.” 

But, he said, the state should share some of the savings with employees who have
been paying into the system and the spending should not be used as a bandage to
solve a larger revenue program.

“This can’t be another reason why the School Aid Fund gets used to fix revenue
problems that have to be addressed in the long term,” Pratt said. 

Bob McCann, executive director of The K-12 Alliance of Michigan, which
represents 123 Southeast Michigan school districts, said the state has a “once
in a generation” opportunity to pay down debt and ultimately, “schools would
have more money to spend on students.”

He would like to see the state put the money it is expected to save directly
into the remaining pension debt.

Sponsor


“The debt load on schools was meant to be brought down to zero,” McCann said.
“That's how it was supposed to go forward. And that's all we're asking them to
do.”


WHAT IS NEXT?

The full House and Senate will vote on their appropriation bills as early as
next week. Then, representatives from the governor’s office and both legislative
chambers will negotiate a final budget deal. 

It is not yet clear whether Democrats will need any Republican votes for
passage. 

“I think it's important just to remember, you know, in the end, this is all one
big negotiation,” said Pratt, with the MEA union. “...There's a revenue side.
There's an asset side. There's an expense side.”

Related Articles:


MARIJUANA EDIBLES, VAPE PENS IN MICHIGAN SCHOOLS PROMPT CALLS FOR REFORM

May 6, 2024 | Isabel Lohman in 
Talent & Education



U-M EXPERT PROBES PSYCHOLOGICAL EFFECT OF ACTIVE-SHOOTER DRILLS IN SCHOOLS

April 26, 2024 | Robin Erb in 
Michigan Health Watch



OPINION | MICHIGAN STUDENTS NEED HELP. BUT NOT ALL TUTORING IS CREATED EQUAL

April 26, 2024 | Holly Windram in 
Guest Commentary



HOW IMPACTFUL WAS THIS ARTICLE FOR YOU?

 * Rate1/5
 * Rate2/5
 * Rate3/5
 * Rate4/5
 * Rate5/5

Share the article you just read on Twitter
Share the article you just read on Facebook
Share the article you just read via email


MOST READ


AN ARREST, MORE PROTESTS AT UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN GRADUATION EVENTS






2024 MICHIGAN ELECTIONS: WHITMER, THANEDAR TAKE HEAT OVER ISRAEL-HAMAS WAR






MICHIGAN ‘FAKE ELECTOR’ TAKES ON TOP DEMOCRAT IN BID FOR STATE HOUSE






EDITOR’S CHOICE


INVEST IN BRIDGE MICHIGAN, INVEST IN HEALTHY DEMOCRACY






BRIDGE LUNCH BREAK TO DISCUSS FAFSA CHANGES, IMPACT ON MICHIGAN STUDENTS





Only donate if we've informed you about important Michigan issues





See what new members are saying about why they donated to Bridge Michigan:

 * “In order for this information to be accurate and unbiased it must be
   underwritten by its readers, not by special interests.” - Larry S.
 * “Not many other media sources report on the topics Bridge does.” - Susan B.
 * “Your journalism is outstanding and rare these days.” - Mark S.

If you want to ensure the future of nonpartisan, nonprofit Michigan journalism,
please become a member today. You, too, will be asked why you donated and maybe
we'll feature your quote next time!



Pay with VISA Pay with MasterCard Pay with American Express Pay with PayPal
Donate Now
Like Bridge Michigan on Facebook
Follow Bridge Michigan on Twitter
Follow Bridge Michigan on Instagram
Subscribe to Bridge Michigan’s RSS feed



QUICK LINKS

 * Home
 * Popular
 * Topics
 * Special Reports
 * Archive
 * About
 * Subscribe
 * Contact

©2024 Bridge Michigan. All rights reserved.

Website by Gravity Works