www.independent.co.uk Open in urlscan Pro
2a04:4e42:400::347 Public Scan

Back to summary

URL:
https://www.independent.co.uk/climate-change/news/whales-in-love-like-humans-their-brains-are-wired-for-romance-427863.html
Submission: On July 12 via api (July 12th 2024, 7:08:10 am UTC) from BE — Scanned from DE

Form analysis
2 forms found in the DOM

POST

<form id="reg-lite-form" class="reg-form i-amphtml-form" target="_top" method="post" action-xhr="/internal-api/newsletter-component/submit/lite" verify-xhr="/internal-api/newsletter-component/verify" custom-validation-reporting="interact-and-submit"
  on="valid:AMP.setState({liteRegValid: true});invalid:AMP.setState({liteRegValid: false});submit-success:AMP.setState({ success: true })" novalidate="">
  <div [hidden]="success">
    <div class="sc-1vqdyfr-1 jAyzHi"><input class="newsletter-key" name="newsletters" type="hidden" readonly="" value="receiveClimate"><input name="regSourceNewsletter" type="hidden" readonly="" value="IND_Climate_Newsletter"><input
        name="regSourceSection" type="hidden" readonly="" value="News"><input name="regSourceMethod" type="hidden" readonly="" value="Article%2BSignpost">
      <div class="sc-lqqm6o-0 krmMMK"><input type="text" id="reg-lite--form-email" name="_" class="not-logged-input is-pristine is-untouched"
          pattern="^(?=(.{1,64}@.{1,255}))([!#$%&amp;amp;'*+\-\/=?\^_`{|}~a-zA-Z0-9}]{1,64}(\.[!#$%&amp;amp;'*+\-\/=?\^_`{|}~a-zA-Z0-9]{0,}){0,})@((\[(25[0-5]|2[0-4][0-9]|[01]?[0-9][0-9]?)(\.(25[0-5]|2[0-4][0-9]|[01]?[0-9][0-9]?)){3}\])|([a-zA-Z0-9-]{1,63}(\.[a-zA-Z0-9-]{2,63}){1,}))$"
          required="" aria-controls="reg-lite--form-email-helper-text" aria-describedby="reg-lite--form-email-helper-text" placeholder="Email" value=""><label for="reg-lite--form-email"></label>
        <div class="error-text" visible-when-invalid="valueMissing" validation-for="reg-lite--form-email">Please enter a valid email address</div>
        <div class="error-text" visible-when-invalid="patternMismatch" validation-for="reg-lite--form-email">Please enter a valid email address</div>
        <div class="error-text" visible-when-invalid="customError" validation-for="reg-lite--form-email"></div>
      </div>
      <div class="sc-hav996-0 jPzgBY sc-hav996-3 sc-1vqdyfr-2 bZfIGi cHpRmL signup-btn lite-registration-submit form-submit"><button class="sc-1aus1tj-0 jZyLMC sc-hav996-2 eABVhl form-submit" name="submitBtn" disabled="" type="submit"
          [disabled]="!liteRegValid"><span class="btn-text">SIGN UP</span><span class="sc-hav996-1 iLCLMH btn-loader"></span></button></div>
    </div>
    <div class="sc-76suco-1 eMUmFm newsletter__checkbox sc-1vqdyfr-3 jKDOQS" data-nosnippet=""><input type="checkbox" id="newsletter-checkbox" name="newsletters" value="receiveIndyOffers"><label for="newsletter-checkbox"
        class="sc-76suco-0 flARGb checkmark">I would like to be emailed about offers, events and updates from The Independent. Read our&nbsp;<a target="_blank" rel="noreferrer" href="/service/privacy-policy-a6184181.html">privacy policy</a></label>
    </div>
  </div><input type="hidden" name="^" data-action="signUpNewsletters">
  <div submit-success="true"><template type="amp-mustache">
      <div class="sc-1i5cmds-0 hIzuKk">
        <h2 data-nosnippet="" class="sc-1i5cmds-1 bbHAxp">Thanks for signing up to the<br> <!-- -->Independent Climate<!-- --> email</h2>
      </div>
    </template></div>
  <div submit-error="true" data-nosnippet=""><template type="amp-mustache">
      <div class="sc-19svp5f-0 gRDDFW">{{ #verifyErrors }}<!-- -->{{ message }}<!-- -->{{ /verifyErrors }}<!-- -->{{ ^verifyErrors }}<!-- -->Something went wrong. Please try again later<!-- -->{{ /verifyErrors }}</div>
    </template></div>
</form>

POST

<form id="login-form" class="login-form i-amphtml-form" method="post" target="_top" action-xhr="/internal-api/user/login/commenting/submit" verify-xhr="/internal-api/user/login/verify" custom-validation-reporting="interact-and-submit"
  on="valid:AMP.setState({loginDisabled: false});invalid:AMP.setState({loginDisabled: true})" novalidate=""><input type="hidden" name="returnUrl" value="/climate-change/news/whales-in-love-like-humans-their-brains-are-wired-for-romance-427863.html">
  <p class="sc-1wvnxd-5 lhvkiY">Log in</p>
  <div class="sc-1wvnxd-11 eaWGiN">
    <div class="sc-lqqm6o-0 krmMMK"><input type="text" id="login-form-email" name="-" class="is-pristine is-untouched" required="" aria-controls="login-form-email-helper-text" aria-describedby="login-form-email-helper-text"
        placeholder="Enter your email"><label for="login-form-email">Email address</label>
      <div class="error-text" visible-when-invalid="customError" validation-for="login-form-email"></div>
    </div>
  </div>
  <div class="sc-1wvnxd-11 eaWGiN">
    <div class="sc-lqqm6o-0 krmMMK"><input type="password" id="login-form-password" name="password" class="sc-1wvnxd-7 eYLrQp input-password is-pristine is-untouched" required="" aria-controls="login-form-password-helper-text"
        aria-describedby="login-form-password-helper-text" placeholder="Enter your password"><label for="login-form-password">Password</label>
      <div class="error-text" visible-when-invalid="customError" validation-for="login-form-password"></div>
    </div>
  </div>
  <div class="form-errors" submit-error="true">Email and password don't match</div>
  <div class="sc-hav996-0 jPzgBY sc-hav996-3 sc-1wvnxd-8 bZfIGi emBJUF"><button class="sc-1aus1tj-0 jZyLMC sc-hav996-2 eABVhl form-submit" name="submitBtn" disabled="" type="submit" [disabled]="loginDisabled"><span class="btn-text">Submit</span><span
        class="sc-hav996-1 iLCLMH btn-loader"></span></button></div>
  <div class="sc-1wvnxd-2 cRUFMT"><a href="/forgotten-password" class="sc-1wvnxd-3 jTwWIO">Forgotten your password?</a></div>
  <div class="sc-1wvnxd-9 cHxqYM"></div>
  <p class="sc-1wvnxd-6 eSZEci">New to The Independent?</p><a id="registerLink" href="/register" class="sc-1aus1tj-0 fJwhAZ">Register</a>
</form>

Text Content

Jump to content

UK EDITIONCHANGE

US EditionAsia EditionEdición en Español
Sign up to our newslettersSubscribe now
{{indy.truncatedName}}
Log in / Register
Independent
General electionIndyBest
SubscribeMenu

 * News
   * News
   * UK
   * US
   * World
   * UK Politics
   * Brexit
   * Health
   * Business
   * Science
   * Space
   * News Videos
 * Sport
   * Sport
   * Football
   * Paris 2024 Olympics
   * Formula 1
   * Rugby Union
   * Cricket
   * Tennis
   * Boxing
   * UFC
   * Cycling
   * Golf
   * Betting
   * Sport Videos
 * Voices
   * Voices
   * Editorials
   * Letters
   * John Rentoul
   * Mary Dejevsky
   * Andrew Grice
   * Sean O’Grady
 * Culture
   * Culture
   * Film
   * TV & Radio
   * Music
   * Games
   * Books
   * Art
   * Photography
   * Theatre & Dance
   * Culture Videos
 * Lifestyle
   * Lifestyle
   * Shopping
   * Beauty
   * Fitness & Wellbeing
   * Tech
   * Money
   * Food & Drink
   * Fashion
   * Love & Sex
   * Women
   * Health & Families
   * Royal Family
   * Motoring
   * Electric Vehicles
   * Car Insurance Deals
   * Lifestyle Videos
 * Travel
   * Travel
   * UK Hotel Reviews
   * News & Advice
   * Simon Calder
   * Cruises
   * UK
   * Europe
   * USA
   * Asia
   * Australia & New Zealand
   * South America
   * C. America & Caribbean
   * Middle East
 * Premium
   * Premium
   * Politics Explained
   * Editorials
   * Voices
   * Long Reads
   * News Analysis
   * Today’s Edition

More
Best
 * Advisor
 * Home & Garden
 * Tech
 * Broadband deals
 * Fashion & Beauty
 * Deals
 * Food & Drink
 * Kids
 * Books
 * Travel & Outdoors
 * Sports & Fitness

Climate
 * News
 * Electric Vehicles
 * Voices
 * Sustainable Living
 * Explained
 * Climate Videos
 * Solar Panels
 * SGI

TV
 * Behind The Headlines
 * On The Ground
 * Decomplicated
 * You Ask The Questions
 * Binge Watch
 * Music Box
 * Love Lives
 * Travel Smart
 * Watch on your TV

 * Today’s Edition
 * Crosswords & Puzzles
 * Most Commented
 * Newsletters
 * Ask Me Anything
 * Virtual Events
 * Betting Sites
 * Online Casinos
 * Wine Offers
 * Vouchers
 * Indy100


THANK YOU FOR REGISTERING

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be
automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in


ClimateNews


WHALES IN LOVE: LIKE HUMANS, THEIR BRAINS ARE WIRED FOR ROMANCE


THEY ARE THE TOUCHY-FEELIES OF THE DEEP, WITH A CAPACITY TO EXPERIENCE LOVE AND
ATTACHMENT, THANKS TO SOME TINY CELLS, NEW RESEARCH SHOWS

Renee Knight
Sunday 10 December 2006 01:00 GMT
Comments

ARTICLE BOOKMARKED

Find your bookmarks in your Independent Premium section, under my profile

Don't show me this message again
✕


SIGN UP TO THE INDEPENDENT CLIMATE EMAIL FOR THE LATEST ADVICE ON SAVING THE
PLANET


GET OUR FREE CLIMATE EMAIL


Please enter a valid email address
Please enter a valid email address

SIGN UP
I would like to be emailed about offers, events and updates from The
Independent. Read our privacy policy


THANKS FOR SIGNING UP TO THE
INDEPENDENT CLIMATE EMAIL

{{ #verifyErrors }}{{ message }}{{ /verifyErrors }}{{ ^verifyErrors }}Something
went wrong. Please try again later{{ /verifyErrors }}

We know that they sing, sending musical waves through the deep as they travel in
complex family units. We know that they appear stricken with grief when one of
them dies. And now we know that the great whales of the world are capable of
loving.

A remarkable new study will reveal that whales - hunted for centuries by man,
and lauded in ancient literature for their mystical qualities - have the ability
to experience love and also deep-rooted emotional suffering.




Two scientists - Patrick Hof and Estel Van Der Gucht, of the New York Consortium
in Evolutionary Primatology - made the breakthrough after spending 15 years
studying the brains of the biggest mammals on the planet.



They did not expect to find anything unusual when they set out to study the
inner workings of the large whale brain. But the scientists were determined that
humans should know more about the minds of these mysterious creatures.



They discovered something that could change the way the world views whales,
which are still hunted by Japan and Norway for "scientific purposes". As they
studied a brain, they came across a spindle cell - a cell originally thought to
live only in humans and great apes, and which allows humans to experience love
and emotions.

Professor Hof told The Independent on Sunday: "I really wasn't expecting this. I
stumbled on one by chance and I said, this looks like a spindle cell. Then I saw
them everywhere, and I immediately realised that we had something big."



The spindle cells were found in humpback whales, fin whales, killer whales and
sperm whales - all the whales that have large brains as well as large bodies.
The discovery not only means that humans and apes aren't the only ones who have
these distinguishing spindle cells, but that primates were not the first to have
them.

It appears that large whales have been evolving these cells for 30 million years
- twice as long as humans, according to an article in New Scientist ahead of
publication of the scientists' findings.



Whales also have more of these emotion-controlling cells, and early research
indicates that they may have up to three times as many spindle cells as humans.
In humans, these cells help process emotions and encourage the development of
social interaction.

But even though the cells allow humans to feel love, more work will be needed to
judge whether love is the same for humans as it is for whales, Professor Hof,
the vice-chairman of the department of neuroscience, said from his office at the
Mount Sinai School of Medicine in New York.



"I don't know about love or emotion," he added. "I don't know the nature of such
feelings in these animals. Whales are isolated and we cannot just apply what we
see in great apes or ourselves in that type of animal. It's very difficult to
know. Many people would like to say that, of course."

But these spindle cells were found in the same area of the brain that regulates
emotional functions such as social organisation, empathy, speech, intuition, and
rapid gut reactions in humans - the anterior cingulate cortex and frontoinsular
cortex. Large whales do show some of these characteristics, making the findings
even more significant to the academic. Cells were also found in other areas of
the whale's brain, but Professor Hof doesn't know the significance of these
finds.



He said: "What is fascinating about the species these cells were found in, is
that you have the capacity for frequency and specificity. They can communicate
in an intelligible manner. Hunting parties are very well co-ordinated. You can
see killer whales teaching hunting techniques to their offspring. It's quite
striking."

Professor Hof is still investigating exactly how spindle cells function in
whales, but for now he believes that long, high-speed connections fast track
information to and from other parts of the cortex. The quick connection allows
for instant processing and appropriate emotional cues for given situations.

After discovering the spindle cells in whales, Professor Hof is to look at other
large animals. He is currently studying elephant brains, and said he expects to
find spindle cells.

This type of research was crucial, he said, and when it came to large whales,
more of it needed to be done. "They are difficult to track in the ocean, but
it's worth the effort. There's so much that humans just don't know about large
whales, and any information that comes out can only make it easier for people to
help protect and conserve these mysterious animals.



"They are certainly popular animals in general, but they are all threatened and
live in habitats frequently quite endangered. We just don't know enough about
their biology."

The scientists' report will appear in the January edition of The Anatomical
Record.




JOIN OUR COMMENTING FORUM

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see
their replies

Comments


1/0WHALES IN LOVE: LIKE HUMANS, THEIR BRAINS ARE WIRED FOR ROMANCE








✕


SUBSCRIBE TO INDEPENDENT PREMIUM TO BOOKMARK THIS ARTICLE

Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later?
Start your Independent Premium subscription today.

Subscribe
Already subscribed? Log in


MOST POPULAR

Tributes paid to ‘loveliest’ Hunt family after triple murder
Crossbow found as suspect remains in serious condition – latest
Gordon Ramsay’s wife says their four adult children moved back home
ITV News presenter quits channel after 21 years
Olympic swimmer issues swimwear safety warning to parents


POPULAR VIDEOS

Braverman describes buildings flying rainbow flags as ‘occupied’
Biden calls Zelensky ‘Putin’ while introducing him at NATO summit
Sarah Ferguson reveals she and Princess Diana got arrested on hen do

Who is Emio? Nintendo teases an uncharacteristically unsettling game - what we
know so far
Kris Jenner hints at future marriage to Corey Gamble
Woman appalled after passenger changes baby’s nappy right next to her on flight
‘Always something a bit different’ about Phil Foden, says youth football coach
A primary school maths question is leaving adults completely stumped




SPONSORED FEATURES

Tributes paid to ‘loveliest’ Hunt family after triple murder
Crossbow found as suspect remains in serious condition – latest
ITV News presenter quits channel after 21 years
Biden opens high-stakes press conference by calling Kamala ‘VP Trump’
Dark Knight star says he’s not allowed to talk about famous sister


 * Get in touch
   * Contact us
   * 
 * Our Products
   * Subscribe
   * Register
   * Newsletters
   * Donate
   * Today’s Edition
   * Install our app
   * Archive
 * Other publications
   * International editions
   * Independent en Español
   * Independent Arabia
   * Independent Turkish
   * Independent Persian
   * Independent Urdu
   * Evening Standard
 * Extras
   * Advisor
   * Puzzles
   * All topics
   * Betting Offers
   * Voucher codes
   * Competitions and offers
   * Independent Advertising
   * Independent Ignite
   * Syndication
   * Working at The Independent
 * Legal
   * Code of conduct and complaints
   * Contributors
   * Cookie policy
   * Donations Terms & Conditions
   * Privacy notice
   * 
   * User policies
   * Modern Slavery Act




THANK YOU FOR REGISTERING

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be
automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in

Close

UK EDITIONCHANGE

US EditionAsia EditionEdición en Español
Subscribe
{{indy.truncatedName}}
Log in / Register

General electionIndyBest
{{#items}}


{{#STAMPSMALL}}{{/STAMPSMALL}}{{#STAMPCLIMATE}}{{/STAMPCLIMATE}}{{#STAMPPREMIUM}}{{/STAMPPREMIUM}}{{TITLE}}{{#DESC}}{{DESC}}{{/DESC}}


   {{#children}}
 * {{title}}
   {{/children}}

{{/items}}

 * Today’s Edition
 * Crosswords & Puzzles
 * Most Commented
 * Newsletters
 * Ask Me Anything
 * Virtual Events
 * Betting Sites
 * Online Casinos
 * Wine Offers
 * Vouchers
 * Indy100


Close the sidebar
✕

Log in

Email address

Password

Email and password don't match
Submit
Forgotten your password?


New to The Independent?

Register

Or if you would prefer:

SIGN IN WITH GOOGLE

Want an ad-free experience?

View offers

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy notice and Terms of
service apply.

Hi {{indy.fullName}}

 * My Independent Premium
 * Account details
 * Help centre
 * Logout

Close the sidebar

www.independent.co.uk Open in urlscan Pro 2a04:4e42:400::347 Public Scan

Form analysis 2 forms found in the DOM

POST

POST

Text Content

www.independent.co.uk Open in urlscan Pro
2a04:4e42:400::347 Public Scan

Form analysis
2 forms found in the DOM