www.forbes.com Open in urlscan Pro
151.101.1.55  Public Scan

URL: https://www.forbes.com/sites/antoniopequenoiv/2023/06/29/heres-what-happened-after-affirmative-action-ended-in-these-4-...
Submission: On June 29 via manual from US — Scanned from US

Form analysis 0 forms found in the DOM

Text Content

...
Sign In
Subscribe
Subscribe
 * Account
 * Profile
 * Contact Settings
 * Newsletters
 * Following
 * Help

SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTERS



SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTERS



BILLIONAIRES

View All Billionaires
 * World's Billionaires
 * Forbes 400
 * America's Richest Self-Made Women
 * China's Richest
 * India's Richest
 * Indonesia's Richest
 * Korea's Richest
 * Thailand's Richest
 * Japan's Richest
 * Australia's Richest
 * Taiwan's Richest
 * Singapore's Richest
 * Philippines' Richest
 * Hong Kong's Richest
 * Malaysia's Richest
 * Money & Politics
 * 2020 Money

INNOVATION

View All Innovation
 * 5G
 * AI
 * Big Data
 * Cloud
 * Cloud 100
 * Consumer Tech
 * Cybersecurity
 * Enterprise Tech
 * Future Of Work
 * Games
 * Guild BrandVoice | Paid Program
 * Healthcare
 * Innovation Rules
 * Magnit BrandVoice | Paid Program
 * SAP BrandVoice | Paid Program
 * Science
 * Social Media
 * Sustainability
 * Transportation
 * Venture Capital

LEADERSHIP

View All Leadership
 * Careers
 * CEO Network
 * CFO Network
 * CHRO Network
 * CIO Network
 * CMO Network
 * CxO
 * Dell Technologies BrandVoice | Paid Program
 * Diversity, Equity & Inclusion
 * Education
 * Forbes EQ | Paid Program
 * ForbesBLK
 * ForbesWomen
 * Leadership Strategy
 * Under 30
 * Working Remote
 * Over 50

MONEY

View All Money
 * Banking & Insurance
 * CME Group BrandVoice | Paid Program
 * ETFs & Mutual Funds
 * Fintech
 * Hedge Funds & Private Equity
 * Investing
 * Investing Basics | Q.ai
 * Markets
 * Personal Finance
 * Premium Investing Newsletters
 * Retirement
 * Taxes
 * Top Advisor | SHOOK
 * Wealth Management

FORBES DIGITAL ASSETS

View All Forbes Digital Assets
 * Home
 * Crypto Prices
 * Research

 * LEARN
   
    * Crypto Basics
    * BTC
    * DeFi
    * Web3 Education
    * NFTs
    * Crypto Investments

 * Events
 * Crypto Portfolios

INVESTMENT NEWSLETTERS

BUSINESS

View All Business
 * Aerospace & Defense
 * Energy
 * Food & Drink
 * Hollywood & Entertainment
 * Manufacturing
 * Media
 * Policy
 * Retail
 * SportsMoney

SMALL BUSINESS

View All Small Business
 * Entrepreneurs
 * Franchises
 * Small Business Strategy

LIFESTYLE

View All Lifestyle
 * Arts
 * Boats & Planes
 * Cars & Bikes
 * Dining
 * ForbesLife
 * Forbes Travel Guide
 * Spirits
 * Style & Beauty
 * Travel
 * Vices
 * Watches

REAL ESTATE

View All Real Estate
 * Commercial Real Estate
 * Forbes Global Properties
 * Residential Real Estate

FORBES STORE

View All Forbes Store
 * U30 Collection
 * ForbesWomen Collection
 * Core Collection

VETTED

View All Vetted
 * Gear
 * Health & Wellness
 * Home & Kitchen
 * Style
 * Tech & Electronics

 * TRAVEL
   
    * Hotels & Lodging

COUPONS

View All Coupons
 * Dell
 * Lululemon
 * Purple
 * Verizon
 * Lowe's
 * Zenni
 * Home Depot
 * Walmart
 * Samsung
 * QVC
 * Walgreens
 * Sephora
 * Hotels.com

ADVISOR

View All Advisor
 * Best Credit Cards Of 2023
 * Balance Transfer Credit Cards
 * Cash Back Credit Cards
 * Travel Credit Cards
 * Business Credit Cards

 * MORTGAGES & LOANS
   
    * Best Mortgage Lenders
    * Today's Mortgage Rates
    * Today's Refinance Rates
    * Best Personal Loans
    * Compare Loans
    * Loans For Bad Credit
    * Best Debt Consolidation Loans
    * Best Student Loan Lenders
    * Best Student Loan Refinance Lenders
    * Business Loans

 * BANKING
   
    * Best Online Banks
    * CD Rates
    * Best Savings Accounts
    * High-Yield Savings Accounts

 * Life Insurance
 * Cheap Life Insurance
 * No Exam Life Insurance
 * Travel Insurance
 * Covid-19 Travel Insurance
 * Cheap Travel Insurance Companies
 * Best Car Insurance
 * Compare Car Insurance Quotes
 * Cost Of Car Insurance
 * Cheap Car Insurance
 * Pet Insurance
 * How Much Is Pet Insurance?
 * Cheap Pet Insurance

 * BUSINESS SERVICES
   
    * Best Password Managers
    * Best VPN
    * Best VOIP Service
    * Best Payroll Services
    * Best Project Management Software

 * HOME SERVICES
   
    * Solar Companies
    * Moving Companies
    * Home Warranty
    * Pest Control Companies
    * Internet Providers

 * Forbes Advisor UK

HEALTH

View All Health
 * Body
 * Best Diets
 * Healthy Aging
 * Best Medical Alert Systems
 * Medicare
 * Medicare Advantage Plans
 * Medicare Supplement Plans
 * Medicare Advantage By State
 * Health Insurance
 * Hearing Aids
 * Best Hearing Aids
 * Senior Living
 * Mind
 * Best Online Therapy
 * Family

LISTS

VIDEO

NEWSLETTERS

 * Crypto Confidential
 * Editorial Newsletters
 * Investing Digest
 * Premium Investing Newsletters

FRASE BY FORBES

FORBES MAGAZINE

View All Forbes Magazine
 * Forbes Asia
 * Free Issue of Forbes

LATEST

 * Coronavirus Coverage
 * Daily Cover Stories
 * Dark Capital
 * Editors' Picks
 * Visual Web Stories

FEATURED

 * 5 Black And Latino Leaders Working To Eliminate The Racial Wealth Gap
 * 30 Under 30 2022
 * America's Richest Self-Made Women 2023
 * Aviram Awards
 * Comarch BrandVoice | Paid Program
 * EY BrandVoice | Paid Program
 * EY Global Government & Infrastructure BrandVoice | Paid Program
 * EY Ripples: Collaborating for Impact | Paid Program
 * Fidelity Investments BrandVoice
 * Forbes Billionaires 2023: The Richest People In The World
 * Forbes Insights With J.P. Morgan Payments Commerce Solutions | Paid Program
 * Forbes Research: 2023 Small Business Survey
 * Forbes Insights with SAP Concur | Paid Program
 * How Tech And HR Are Coming Together In The New World Of Work
 * New Digital Tools To Create A Productive Employee Experience
 * Take Me Fishing BrandVoice | Paid Program
 * The Fintech 50 List 2023
 * The Forbes World's Most Influential CMOs List: 2023

Advertise with ForbesReport a Security IssueSite FeedbackContact UsCareers at
ForbesTipsCorrectionsPrivacyDo Not Sell My Personal
InformationTermsAdChoicesReprints & Permissions
© 2023 Forbes Media LLC. All Rights Reserved
Close the sidebarClose the sidebar
This site uses cookies
Continue to Site

To give you a great browsing experience free of charge, this site uses cookies.
Cookies help us personalize content and ads, provide social media features,
track your preferences, and analyze traffic. Forbes may share this information
with its advertising, analytics, and social media partners, who may use it with
information you have provided to them in connection with their services.

For more information: Privacy Statement

To consent and proceed, click "Continue to Site."


Breaking


Business


HERE’S WHAT HAPPENED AFTER AFFIRMATIVE ACTION ENDED IN THESE 4 STATES

Antonio Pequeño IV
Forbes Staff
I cover breaking news.
Jun 29, 2023,10:40am EDT|



TOPLINE

The effects of the Supreme Court’s decision to strike down affirmative action
will take time to materialize—but a 2013 Harvard study found that after
affirmative action ended in key states “sharp declines” in the workplace
followed for Asian women, Black women and Hispanic men.



Study found “significant loss” in workplace [+][-]
diversity when affirmative action was repealed by four states from 1996 to 2008.
Getty Images



KEY FACTS

The study, which ranged from 1990 to 2009, examined California, Michigan,
Nebraska and Washington after those states banned affirmative action.




Once affirmative action was repealed in the states, workforce participation from
Latino men decreased by 7%, Black women’s participation decreased 4% and Asian
women’s participation decreased 37%—the study notes that the last figure was
particularly large because few Asian women were in the workforce.




Black women’s decrease in participation continued to drop up until five years
after the ban, while Hispanic men’s decline continued through the third year and
Asian women’s decline was limited to the first year after the ban.



The study’s 19 year duration allowed the author to examine the share of
minorities and women that worked in state and local government before and after
affirmative action bans went into effect.


KEY BACKGROUND

The Supreme Court ruled in favor of/against two cases focused on the role of
students’ race in college admissions processes. With the Court’s rulings on the
lawsuits—Students for Fair Admissions (SFFA) v. University of North Carolina and
Students for Fair Admissions v. Harvard University—race will no longer be able
to be considered as a factor in college and university admissions decisions.
Such changes could significantly shift the composition of collegiate student
bodies across the country. A poll from the Associated Press-NORC Center for
Public Affairs Research found that most Americans believe race should have a
small role in college admissions as opposed to being outright banned, with 63%
of the poll’s respondents saying the Supreme Court should not block colleges
from considering race or ethnicity in admission decisions.




CONTRA

Critics have argued that in addition to White and Asian students being
discriminated against, affirmative action takes away from the achievements of
minority students in favor of satisfying quotas.


BIG NUMBER

74%. That’s the percentage of adults surveyed in a 2022 Pew Research Center
study who believed race should not be considered in college admissions
decisions.


TANGENT

Bans on affirmative action at universities, which greatly impacted minority
student populations, are not unprecedented. When the University of California
system eliminated affirmative action in 1995, the number of Black and Latino
students accepted by Berkeley and UCLA was cut by nearly half by 1998, the first
year affected by the ban. Black and Latino students made up for 32% of all
University of California admits in 2022, compared to the 15% of admits they
represented in 1998, according to system data.




FURTHER READING

Ending affirmative action programs significantly decreased diversity in the
workplace, disproportionately hurting Asian women, Black women, and Hispanic men
(Harvard Kennedy School)



The future of affirmative action: Experts explain the upcoming Supreme Court
cases (Temple University)



California banned affirmative action in 1996. Inside the UC struggle for
diversity (Los Angeles Times)


Get the best of Forbes to your inbox with the latest insights from experts
across the globe.
Follow me on Twitter or LinkedIn. Send me a secure tip.
Antonio Pequeño IV

Antonio Pequeño IV is a breaking news reporter based in Los Angeles. Prior to
joining Forbes, Antonio was a reporter with the San Fernando Valley Business
Journal and Los An…

Read More Read Less
Editorial StandardsCorrectionsReprints & Permissions


Loading ...



MORE FROM FORBES


SUPREME COURT PAVES WAY FOR MORE RELIGIOUS ACCOMMODATIONS AT WORK WITH POSTAL
WORKER RULING


SUPREME COURT GETS RID OF AFFIRMATIVE ACTION IN COLLEGE ADMISSIONS


POLICE KILLING OF TEENAGER TRIGGERS MASSIVE PROTESTS IN FRANCE—HERE’S WHAT YOU
NEED TO KNOW




WILDFIRE SMOKE RETURNS: AIR POLLUTION FROM CANADA FIRES ENGULFS NEW YORK TO
CHICAGO


CHINESE SPY BALLOON REPORTEDLY USED U.S.-MADE GEAR THAT COULD BE BOUGHT ONLINE


CANADA SUED BY IRAN AT THE INTERNATIONAL COURT OF JUSTICE




TRUMP IS REPORTEDLY MULLING A RETURN TO TWITTER AFTER TRUTH SOCIAL EXCLUSIVITY
DEAL EXPIRES


NVIDIA LEADS PREMARKET SLUMP IN CHIPMAKER SHARES—AS WHITE HOUSE REPORTEDLY MULLS
FRESH CURBS ON AI CHIPS


More Articles

{{^loggedIn}}
Already a subscriber?
Sign in here
{{/loggedIn}}
You've reached your limit of free articles.  Subscribe to continue reading.
Subscribe to continue reading.
✓Unlimited access to articles✓A better reading experience with fewer ads✓Cancel
anytime
Annual : Most Popular$49.99
Billed AnnuallySave 40%
Subscribe
Monthly$6.99Billed Monthly
Subscribe
Two Year$139.99
Billed Every Two YearsSave 17%
Subscribe
1 of 4free articles
Introducing the Forbes.com subscription.Unlimited content. Improved ad
experience.
Learn more
2 of 4free articles
Get unlimited access to the most trusted source for business news.
Subscribe
3 of 4free articles
Unlock your improved reading experience.Unlimited articles, fewer ads.
Subscribe
4 of 4free articles
Subscribe to get unlimited access and a better Forbes.com experience.
Get unlimited access
Share
EMAIL
FACEBOOK
TWITTER
LINKEDIN
REDDIT

© 2023 Forbes Media LLC. All Rights Reserved.
 * AdChoices
 * Privacy Statement
 * Do Not Sell My Personal Information
 * Digital Terms of Sale
 * Terms of Service
 * Contact Us
 * Report a Security Issue
 * Jobs At Forbes
 * Reprints & Permissions
 * Forbes Press Room
 * Advertise