www.bbc.com Open in urlscan Pro
151.101.0.81  Public Scan

Form analysis
0 forms found in the DOM

Text Content

BBC Homepage
 * Skip to content
 * Accessibility Help

 * Sign in


 * Home
 * News
 * Sport
 * Reel
 * Worklife
 * Travel
 * Future
 * More menu

More menu
Search BBC
 * Home
 * News
 * Sport
 * Reel
 * Worklife
 * Travel
 * Future
 * Culture
 * Music
 * TV
 * Weather
 * Sounds

Close menu
BBC News
Menu
 * Home
 * War in Ukraine
 * Coronavirus
 * Climate
 * Video
 * World
 * US & Canada
 * UK
 * Business
 * Tech
 * Science

More
 * Stories
 * Entertainment & Arts
 * Health
 * In Pictures
 * Reality Check
 * World News TV
 * Newsbeat
 * Long Reads

 * Tech


META BOARD HEARS OVER A MILLION APPEALS OVER REMOVED POSTS

By Zoe Kleinman
Technology editor

Published4 days ago
Share
close
Share page
Copy link
About sharing
Image source, Getty Images

Meta's independent system of appeals against its decisions to remove content on
Facebook and Instagram had about 1.1 million cases in its first year.

The disputed posts, most of which originated in the US, Canada or Europe, had
largely been removed for either violence, hate speech or bullying.

Of the 20 cases about which The Oversight Board published decisions, it ruled
against Meta 14 times.

One case was about removed images of female breasts in a breast cancer post.

Others featured an image of a dead child alongside text about whether
retaliation was justified against China for its treatment of Uighur Muslims, and
the decision to ban Donald Trump following the Capitol Hill riots.

The board overturned Meta's decision to remove the first two examples, but
supported its decision to ban Mr Trump - although it criticised the "indefinite"
time frame.




It had initially shortlisted 130 cases to investigate, but Meta agreed up front
that it had been wrong on 51 of those occasions.

Board director Thomas Hughes said it looked for "emblematic" cases with
"problematic elements" to take on.

He added that the categories of hate speech, violence and bullying were
"difficult-to-judge issues" - especially for automated systems.

"Also in many of those cases, context is extremely important," he said.


RESTORE REQUESTS

The board has just released its first annual report, covering the period October
2020 to December 2021.

Anybody - including Meta itself - can appeal to it if they disagree with a
decision to remove content. Of the 1.1 million cases received during the
14-month period, only 47 came from the firm.



About 2,600 cases per day were reported on average.

However, Facebook alone has more than two billion users around the world, making
this a relatively tiny percentage of its vast content. It was also noticeable
that relatively few complainants were from outside Western countries.

Of all the cases submitted to the board:

 * 1% related to Instagram posts and the rest were about Facebook content
 * 94% were requests to restore content - only 6% wanted it removed - but most
   were about people's own posts rather than somebody else's
 * only 1.7% came from sub-Saharan Africa and 2.7% from central and south Asia
 * 49.4% came from the US and Canada

The Oversight Board is known as a kind of "supreme court" and was formed by Meta
boss Mark Zuckerberg. It operates as an independent entity, although its wages
and other costs are covered by Meta. It consists of journalists, human rights
activists, lawyers and academics.

Mr Hughes described the relationship between the board and Meta as "constructive
but critical".

It has made 86 additional recommendations to the tech giant, including
translating its policies into more languages and being more specific when
explaining why content has been removed on the grounds of hate speech.




MORE ON THIS STORY

 * Facebook 'supreme court' orders takedowns restored
   
   28 January 2021
   

 * BBC finds upskirt footage shared in Facebook groups
   
   5 days ago
   

 * Facebook unveils its plan for oversight board
   
   17 September 2019


RELATED TOPICS

 * Social media
 * Meta
 * Instagram
 * Facebook





TOP STORIES

 * Live. 
   
   G7 leaders pledge to help Ukraine 'for as long as it takes'

 * What US abortion ruling means for mid-terms
   
   Published23 hours ago

 * The church in Texas helping women get an abortion
   
   Published15 hours ago




FEATURES

 * Tracking Russia’s route for stolen grain
   
   

 * Forced to Beg: Tanzania’s Trafficked Kids. VideoForced to Beg: Tanzania’s
   Trafficked Kids
   
   

 * BBC journalist returns to bombed home. VideoBBC journalist returns to bombed
   home
   
   
 * 

 * What Severodonetsk's fall means for the war
   
   

 * 'There are aftershocks every day’
   
   

 * What sanctions are being imposed on Russia?
   
   

 * Chaotic scenes as Taser drawn at US abortion protest. VideoChaotic scenes as
   Taser drawn at US abortion protest
   
   

 * Helping families locate the missing in Ukraine war
   
   

 * 'Show them our pecs' - G7 leaders mock Putin. Video'Show them our pecs' - G7
   leaders mock Putin
   
   




ELSEWHERE ON THE BBC

 * Why top chefs are leaving Paris
   
   "It started before Covid, but it was discreet"
   
   

 * The films bringing sex work to life
   
   Has cinema perpetuated damaging stereotypes?
   
   

 * Has human progress peaked?
   
   A growing and influential intellectual movement aims to understand why human
   progress happens – and how to speed it up
   
   




MOST READ

 1.  1Pictures provide evidence of Russian grain theft
 2.  2What US abortion ruling means for mid-terms
 3.  3South Africa tries to unravel tavern deaths mystery
 4.  4Nato plans huge upgrade in rapid reaction force
 5.  5Japan urges 37 million people to switch off lights
 6.  6The church in Texas helping women get an abortion
 7.  7Charles cash donation reports checked by watchdog
 8.  8Russia in debt default as payment deadline passes
 9.  9Queen in Edinburgh for annual trip to Scotland
 10. 10Belarus plane arrest student appeals for pardon







BBC NEWS SERVICES

 * On your mobile
 * On smart speakers
 * Get news alerts
 * Contact BBC News

 * Home
 * News
 * Sport
 * Reel
 * Worklife
 * Travel
 * Future
 * Culture
 * Music
 * TV
 * Weather
 * Sounds

 * Terms of Use
 * About the BBC
 * Privacy Policy
 * Cookies
 * Accessibility Help
 * Parental Guidance
 * Contact the BBC
 * Get Personalised Newsletters
 * Why you can trust the BBC
 * Advertise with us
 * AdChoices / Do Not Sell My Info

© 2022 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read
about our approach to external linking.