nautil.us
Open in
urlscan Pro
151.101.131.52
Public Scan
URL:
https://nautil.us/consciousness-has-a-psychology-problem-1164162/?_sp=fbc76f9d-7c5c-4f2c-b4e7-19b9077bafa8.1732777...
Submission: On November 28 via manual from DE — Scanned from US
Submission: On November 28 via manual from DE — Scanned from US
Form analysis 6 forms found in the DOM
GET https://nautil.us/
<form role="search" method="get" class="search-inp-wrap responsive-search" action="https://nautil.us/">
<label>
<span class="screen-reader-text"></span>
<input type="search" class="form-control aa-input" placeholder="Search Nautilus..." value="" name="s" autocomplete="off" spellcheck="false" role="combobox" aria-autocomplete="list" aria-expanded="false" aria-owns="algolia-autocomplete-listbox-0"
dir="auto" style="">
<pre aria-hidden="true"
style="position: absolute; visibility: hidden; white-space: pre; font-family: "FreightSans Pro Book", Helvetica, Arial, sans-serif; font-size: 22px; font-style: normal; font-variant: normal; font-weight: 400; word-spacing: 0px; letter-spacing: normal; text-indent: 0px; text-rendering: auto; text-transform: none;"></pre>
</label>
<button type="submit" class="search-submit" value="Search">
<img src="https://nautil.us/wp-content/themes/nautilus-block-theme/images/icons/search-dark.svg" class="icon-search" alt="search icon" width="28" height="28">
</button>
</form>GET https://nautil.us/
<form role="search" method="get" class="search-form" action="https://nautil.us/">
<label>
<span class="screen-reader-text">Search for:</span>
<input type="search" class="search-field aa-input" placeholder="Search …" value="" name="s" autocomplete="off" spellcheck="false" role="combobox" aria-autocomplete="list" aria-expanded="false" aria-owns="algolia-autocomplete-listbox-2" dir="auto"
style="">
<pre aria-hidden="true"
style="position: absolute; visibility: hidden; white-space: pre; font-family: "FreightSans Pro Book", Helvetica, Arial, sans-serif; font-size: 16px; font-style: normal; font-variant: normal; font-weight: 400; word-spacing: 0px; letter-spacing: normal; text-indent: 0px; text-rendering: auto; text-transform: none;"></pre>
</label>
<input type="submit" class="search-submit" value="Search">
</form>POST
<form enctype="multipart/form-data" method="post" class="frm-show-form frm_js_validate frm_ajax_submit frm_pro_form " id="form_speedbump-block-default-form" data-token="c5ac6459d355e28da96b069717f25df8" style="overflow-x: visible;">
<div class="frm_form_fields ">
<fieldset>
<legend class="frm_screen_reader">NL – Article speedbump</legend>
<div class="frm_fields_container">
<input type="hidden" name="frm_action" value="create">
<input type="hidden" name="form_id" value="86">
<input type="hidden" name="frm_hide_fields_86" id="frm_hide_fields_86" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="form_key" value="speedbump-block-default-form">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[0]" value="">
<input type="hidden" id="frm_submit_entry_86" name="frm_submit_entry_86" value="4fe93c175b"><input type="hidden" name="_wp_http_referer" value="/consciousness-has-a-psychology-problem-1164162/"><input type="hidden" name="item_meta[750]"
id="field_js_utm_id86" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[751]" id="field_js_utm_source1" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[753]" id="field_js_utm_medium1" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[752]" id="field_js_utm_campaign1" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[754]" id="field_js_utm_term1" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[755]" id="field_js_utm_content1" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[757]" id="field_nl_lp_rid86" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[758]" id="field_ucvvj" value="15:35:44" data-frmval="15:35:44">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[759]" id="field_7xafb" value="7374" data-frmval="7374">
<div id="frm_field_810_container" class="frm_form_field form-field frm_none_container">
<label for="g-recaptcha-response" id="field_ra8px_label" class="frm_primary_label">Captcha <span class="frm_required" aria-hidden="true"></span>
</label>
<div id="field_ra8px" class="frm-g-recaptcha" data-sitekey="6LcIGuUpAAAAABhqlni-ytDG0olfnt-0G0s_5u09" data-size="invisible" data-theme="light" data-rid="0">
<div class="grecaptcha-badge" data-style="bottomright"
style="width: 256px; height: 60px; display: block; transition: right 0.3s; position: fixed; bottom: 14px; right: -186px; box-shadow: gray 0px 0px 5px; border-radius: 2px; overflow: hidden;">
<div class="grecaptcha-logo"><iframe title="reCAPTCHA" width="256" height="60" role="presentation" name="a-c5qi1w4v8wjr" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"
sandbox="allow-forms allow-popups allow-same-origin allow-scripts allow-top-navigation allow-modals allow-popups-to-escape-sandbox allow-storage-access-by-user-activation"
src="https://www.google.com/recaptcha/api2/anchor?ar=1&k=6LcIGuUpAAAAABhqlni-ytDG0olfnt-0G0s_5u09&co=aHR0cHM6Ly9uYXV0aWwudXM6NDQz&hl=en&v=pPK749sccDmVW_9DSeTMVvh2&theme=light&size=invisible&cb=wurmuzyxz9ea"></iframe>
</div>
<div class="grecaptcha-error"></div><textarea id="g-recaptcha-response" name="g-recaptcha-response" class="g-recaptcha-response"
style="width: 250px; height: 40px; border: 1px solid rgb(193, 193, 193); margin: 10px 25px; padding: 0px; resize: none; display: none;"></textarea>
</div>
</div>
</div>
<div id="frm_field_742_container" class="frm_form_field form-field frm_required_field frm_none_container frm_two_thirds">
<label for="field_y56x4" id="field_y56x4_label" class="frm_primary_label">Email <span class="frm_required" aria-hidden="true">*</span>
</label>
<input type="email" id="field_y56x4" name="item_meta[742]" value="" autocomplete="email" placeholder="Enter your email" data-reqmsg="Email cannot be blank." aria-required="true" data-invmsg="Email is invalid" aria-invalid="false">
</div>
<div id="frm_field_743_container" class="frm_form_field form-field frm_third">
<div class="frm_submit frm_third">
<button class="frm_button_submit frm_final_submit" type="submit" formnovalidate="formnovalidate">Sign up for free</button>
</div>
</div>
<input type="hidden" name="item_key" value="">
<input name="frm_state" type="hidden" value="KlvCIRs9PrcBc/SyV6Q92wBHgHSF88Z2Pq1UgxSsFjrpztNzlFh2zGzpETDVQuna08Sp0S/arsFJP3I4fNQitLHEqsYgIfgAOuG+pi3sk4D+xOki1CRkTpyzuPENynLLIZVAaXkkOSLX/hLnp5Gnc0VlNbF9Z2+/1rL96CH5Ou/WRsPwxCaI4VmlQXwtl6DY">
</div>
</fieldset>
</div>
</form>POST
<form enctype="multipart/form-data" method="post" class="frm-show-form frm_js_validate frm_ajax_submit frm_pro_form " id="form_newsletter-signup-in-page-mobile" data-token="c5ac6459d355e28da96b069717f25df8" style="overflow-x: visible;">
<div class="frm_form_fields ">
<fieldset>
<legend class="frm_screen_reader">NL – In Page Mobile</legend>
<div class="frm_fields_container">
<input type="hidden" name="frm_action" value="create">
<input type="hidden" name="form_id" value="60">
<input type="hidden" name="frm_hide_fields_60" id="frm_hide_fields_60" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="form_key" value="newsletter-signup-in-page-mobile">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[0]" value="">
<input type="hidden" id="frm_submit_entry_60" name="frm_submit_entry_60" value="4fe93c175b"><input type="hidden" name="_wp_http_referer" value="/consciousness-has-a-psychology-problem-1164162/">
<div id="frm_field_463_container" class="frm_form_field form-field frm_required_field frm_top_container">
<label for="field_email2" id="field_email2_label" class="frm_primary_label">Email: <span class="frm_required">*</span>
</label>
<input type="email" id="field_email2" name="item_meta[463]" value="" placeholder="Enter your email address" data-reqmsg="Email: cannot be blank." aria-required="true" data-invmsg="This is not a valid email." aria-invalid="false">
</div>
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[465]" id="field_js_utm_id3" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[466]" id="field_js_utm_source3" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[467]" id="field_js_utm_medium3" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[468]" id="field_js_utm_campaign3" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[469]" id="field_js_utm_term3" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[470]" id="field_js_utm_content3" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[471]" id="field_nl_lp_rid2" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[531]" id="field_xyc35" value="15:35:44" data-frmval="15:35:44">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[537]" id="field_yntmy" value="3414" data-frmval="3414">
<div id="frm_field_808_container" class="frm_form_field form-field frm_none_container">
<label for="g-recaptcha-response" id="field_gnmab_label" class="frm_primary_label">Captcha <span class="frm_required" aria-hidden="true"></span>
</label>
<div id="field_gnmab" class="frm-g-recaptcha" data-sitekey="6LcIGuUpAAAAABhqlni-ytDG0olfnt-0G0s_5u09" data-size="invisible" data-theme="light" data-rid="1">
<div class="grecaptcha-badge" data-style="none" style="width: 256px; height: 60px; position: fixed; visibility: hidden;">
<div class="grecaptcha-logo"><iframe title="reCAPTCHA" width="256" height="60" role="presentation" name="a-yxpvedmqf309" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"
sandbox="allow-forms allow-popups allow-same-origin allow-scripts allow-top-navigation allow-modals allow-popups-to-escape-sandbox allow-storage-access-by-user-activation"
src="https://www.google.com/recaptcha/api2/anchor?ar=1&k=6LcIGuUpAAAAABhqlni-ytDG0olfnt-0G0s_5u09&co=aHR0cHM6Ly9uYXV0aWwudXM6NDQz&hl=en&v=pPK749sccDmVW_9DSeTMVvh2&theme=light&size=invisible&cb=vec7dlclgrql"></iframe>
</div>
<div class="grecaptcha-error"></div><textarea id="g-recaptcha-response-1" name="g-recaptcha-response" class="g-recaptcha-response"
style="width: 250px; height: 40px; border: 1px solid rgb(193, 193, 193); margin: 10px 25px; padding: 0px; resize: none; display: none;"></textarea>
</div>
</div>
</div>
<div id="frm_field_782_container" class="frm_form_field form-field ">
<div class="frm_submit">
<button class="frm_button_submit frm_final_submit" type="submit" formnovalidate="formnovalidate">Sign up for free</button>
</div>
</div>
<input type="hidden" name="item_key" value="">
<input name="frm_state" type="hidden" value="KlvCIRs9PrcBc/SyV6Q92wBHgHSF88Z2Pq1UgxSsFjrpztNzlFh2zGzpETDVQuna08Sp0S/arsFJP3I4fNQitLHEqsYgIfgAOuG+pi3sk4D+xOki1CRkTpyzuPENynLLIZVAaXkkOSLX/hLnp5Gnc0VlNbF9Z2+/1rL96CH5Ou/WRsPwxCaI4VmlQXwtl6DY">
</div>
</fieldset>
</div>
</form>POST
<form enctype="multipart/form-data" method="post" class="frm-show-form frm_js_validate frm_ajax_submit frm_pro_form " id="form_newsletter-signup-footer" data-token="c5ac6459d355e28da96b069717f25df8" style="overflow-x: visible;">
<div class="frm_form_fields ">
<fieldset>
<legend class="frm_screen_reader">NL – Footer</legend>
<div class="frm_fields_container">
<input type="hidden" name="frm_action" value="create">
<input type="hidden" name="form_id" value="61">
<input type="hidden" name="frm_hide_fields_61" id="frm_hide_fields_61" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="form_key" value="newsletter-signup-footer">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[0]" value="">
<input type="hidden" id="frm_submit_entry_61" name="frm_submit_entry_61" value="4fe93c175b"><input type="hidden" name="_wp_http_referer" value="/consciousness-has-a-psychology-problem-1164162/">
<div id="frm_field_472_container" class="frm_form_field form-field frm_required_field frm_top_container">
<label for="field_email3" id="field_email3_label" class="frm_primary_label">Email: <span class="frm_required">*</span>
</label>
<input type="email" id="field_email3" name="item_meta[472]" value="" placeholder="Enter your email address" data-reqmsg="Email: cannot be blank." aria-required="true" data-invmsg="This is not a valid email." aria-invalid="false">
</div>
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[474]" id="field_js_utm_id4" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[475]" id="field_js_utm_source4" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[476]" id="field_js_utm_medium4" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[477]" id="field_js_utm_campaign4" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[478]" id="field_js_utm_term4" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[479]" id="field_js_utm_content4" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[480]" id="field_nl_lp_rid3" value="">
<div id="frm_field_671_container" class="frm_form_field form-field frm_top_container">
<div id="field_6tsy5_label" class="frm_primary_label">Name <span class="frm_required" aria-hidden="true"></span>
</div>
<fieldset aria-labelledby="field_6tsy5_label">
<legend class="frm_screen_reader frm_hidden"> Name </legend>
<div class="frm_combo_inputs_container" id="frm_combo_inputs_container_671" data-name-layout="first_last">
<div id="frm_field_671-first_container" class="frm_form_field form-field frm_form_subfield-first frm6" data-sub-field-name="first">
<label for="field_6tsy5_first" class="frm_screen_reader frm_hidden"> First </label>
<input type="text" id="field_6tsy5_first" value="" name="item_meta[671][first]" data-invmsg="Name is invalid" aria-invalid="false">
<div class="frm_description" id="frm_field_671_first_desc">First</div>
</div>
<div id="frm_field_671-last_container" class="frm_form_field form-field frm_form_subfield-last frm6" data-sub-field-name="last">
<label for="field_6tsy5_last" class="frm_screen_reader frm_hidden"> Last </label>
<input type="text" id="field_6tsy5_last" value="" name="item_meta[671][last]" data-invmsg="Name is invalid" aria-invalid="false">
<div class="frm_description" id="frm_field_671_last_desc">Last</div>
</div>
</div>
</fieldset>
</div>
<div id="frm_field_804_container" class="frm_form_field form-field frm_none_container">
<label for="g-recaptcha-response" id="field_iwpu3_label" class="frm_primary_label">Captcha <span class="frm_required" aria-hidden="true"></span>
</label>
<div id="field_iwpu3" class="frm-g-recaptcha" data-sitekey="6LcIGuUpAAAAABhqlni-ytDG0olfnt-0G0s_5u09" data-size="invisible" data-theme="light" data-rid="2">
<div class="grecaptcha-badge" data-style="none" style="width: 256px; height: 60px; position: fixed; visibility: hidden;">
<div class="grecaptcha-logo"><iframe title="reCAPTCHA" width="256" height="60" role="presentation" name="a-cf7i59hzrtgu" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"
sandbox="allow-forms allow-popups allow-same-origin allow-scripts allow-top-navigation allow-modals allow-popups-to-escape-sandbox allow-storage-access-by-user-activation"
src="https://www.google.com/recaptcha/api2/anchor?ar=1&k=6LcIGuUpAAAAABhqlni-ytDG0olfnt-0G0s_5u09&co=aHR0cHM6Ly9uYXV0aWwudXM6NDQz&hl=en&v=pPK749sccDmVW_9DSeTMVvh2&theme=light&size=invisible&cb=owtw94q5xhpu"></iframe>
</div>
<div class="grecaptcha-error"></div><textarea id="g-recaptcha-response-2" name="g-recaptcha-response" class="g-recaptcha-response"
style="width: 250px; height: 40px; border: 1px solid rgb(193, 193, 193); margin: 10px 25px; padding: 0px; resize: none; display: none;"></textarea>
</div>
</div>
</div>
<div id="frm_field_741_container" class="frm_form_field form-field ">
<div class="frm_submit">
<button class="frm_button_submit frm_final_submit" type="submit" formnovalidate="formnovalidate">Sign up for free</button>
</div>
</div>
<input type="hidden" name="item_key" value="">
<div class="frm__655bb6eca1eeb">
<label for="frm_email_61"> If you are human, leave this field blank. </label>
<input id="frm_email_61" type="text" class="frm_verify" name="frm__655bb6eca1eeb" value="" autocomplete="off">
</div>
<input name="frm_state" type="hidden" value="KlvCIRs9PrcBc/SyV6Q92wBHgHSF88Z2Pq1UgxSsFjrpztNzlFh2zGzpETDVQuna08Sp0S/arsFJP3I4fNQitLHEqsYgIfgAOuG+pi3sk4D+xOki1CRkTpyzuPENynLLIZVAaXkkOSLX/hLnp5Gnc0VlNbF9Z2+/1rL96CH5Ou/WRsPwxCaI4VmlQXwtl6DY">
</div>
</fieldset>
</div>
</form>POST
<form enctype="multipart/form-data" method="post" class="frm-show-form frm_js_validate frm_ajax_submit frm_pro_form " id="form_newsletter-signup-emailgate" data-token="c5ac6459d355e28da96b069717f25df8" style="overflow-x: visible;">
<div class="frm_form_fields ">
<fieldset>
<legend class="frm_screen_reader">NL – Emailgate</legend>
<div class="frm_fields_container">
<input type="hidden" name="frm_action" value="create">
<input type="hidden" name="form_id" value="74">
<input type="hidden" name="frm_hide_fields_74" id="frm_hide_fields_74" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="form_key" value="newsletter-signup-emailgate">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[0]" value="">
<input type="hidden" id="frm_submit_entry_74" name="frm_submit_entry_74" value="4fe93c175b"><input type="hidden" name="_wp_http_referer" value="/consciousness-has-a-psychology-problem-1164162/">
<div id="frm_field_602_container" class="frm_form_field form-field frm_required_field frm_none_container">
<label for="field_email6" id="field_email6_label" class="frm_primary_label">
<span class="frm_required">*</span>
</label>
<input type="email" id="field_email6" name="item_meta[602]" value="" style="width:302px" placeholder="Enter your email address" data-reqmsg="This field cannot be blank." aria-required="true" data-invmsg="This is not a valid email."
class="auto_width" aria-invalid="false">
</div>
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[604]" id="field_js_utm_id9" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[605]" id="field_js_utm_source9" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[606]" id="field_js_utm_medium9" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[607]" id="field_js_utm_campaign9" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[608]" id="field_js_utm_term9" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[609]" id="field_js_utm_content9" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[610]" id="field_nl_lp_rid6" value="">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[611]" id="field_2926n3" value="15:35:44" data-frmval="15:35:44">
<input type="hidden" name="item_meta[612]" id="field_md9f43" value="5455" data-frmval="5455">
<div id="frm_field_802_container" class="frm_form_field form-field frm_none_container">
<label for="g-recaptcha-response" id="field_kqr7t_label" class="frm_primary_label">Captcha <span class="frm_required" aria-hidden="true"></span>
</label>
<div id="field_kqr7t" class="frm-g-recaptcha" data-sitekey="6LcIGuUpAAAAABhqlni-ytDG0olfnt-0G0s_5u09" data-size="invisible" data-theme="light" data-rid="3">
<div class="grecaptcha-badge" data-style="none" style="width: 256px; height: 60px; position: fixed; visibility: hidden;">
<div class="grecaptcha-logo"><iframe title="reCAPTCHA" width="256" height="60" role="presentation" name="a-ig78b5qpbe6i" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"
sandbox="allow-forms allow-popups allow-same-origin allow-scripts allow-top-navigation allow-modals allow-popups-to-escape-sandbox allow-storage-access-by-user-activation"
src="https://www.google.com/recaptcha/api2/anchor?ar=1&k=6LcIGuUpAAAAABhqlni-ytDG0olfnt-0G0s_5u09&co=aHR0cHM6Ly9uYXV0aWwudXM6NDQz&hl=en&v=pPK749sccDmVW_9DSeTMVvh2&theme=light&size=invisible&cb=ast5h9gzm4c5"></iframe>
</div>
<div class="grecaptcha-error"></div><textarea id="g-recaptcha-response-3" name="g-recaptcha-response" class="g-recaptcha-response"
style="width: 250px; height: 40px; border: 1px solid rgb(193, 193, 193); margin: 10px 25px; padding: 0px; resize: none; display: none;"></textarea>
</div><iframe style="display: none;"></iframe>
</div>
</div>
<div id="frm_field_756_container" class="frm_form_field form-field ">
<div class="frm_submit">
<button class="frm_button_submit frm_final_submit" type="submit" formnovalidate="formnovalidate">Sign up for free</button>
</div>
</div>
<input type="hidden" name="item_key" value="">
<input name="frm_state" type="hidden" value="KlvCIRs9PrcBc/SyV6Q92wBHgHSF88Z2Pq1UgxSsFjrpztNzlFh2zGzpETDVQuna08Sp0S/arsFJP3I4fNQitLHEqsYgIfgAOuG+pi3sk4D+xOki1CRkTpyzuPENynLLIZVAaXkkOSLX/hLnp5Gnc0VlNbF9Z2+/1rL96CH5Ou/WRsPwxCaI4VmlQXwtl6DY">
</div>
</fieldset>
</div>
</form>Text Content
*
*
*
* Channels
* Topics
* About
* Contact us
* Newsletter
* Become a member
* Shop
Channels
Art+Science
Biology + Beyond
Cosmos
Culture
Earth
Life
Mind
Ocean
One Question
Quanta Abstractions
Rewilding
Science at the Ballot Box
Science Philanthropy Alliance
Spark of Science
The Porthole
The Reality Issue
The Rebel Issue
Women in Science & Engineering
Topics
* Anthropology
* Arts
* Astronomy
* Communication
* Economics
* Environment
* Evolution
* General
* Genetics
* Geoscience
* Health
* History
* Math
* Microbiology
* Neuroscience
* Paleontology
* Philosophy
* Physics
* Psychology
* Sociology
* Technology
* Zoology
ALREADY A MEMBER? LOG IN
*
*
* Join
Close
Search for:
Log in Join
Evolution
Motion Made Minds
Psychology
When Do We Have Free Choice?
Psychology
Can Ecstasy Save a Marriage?
Psychology
Reading Through Grief
Philosophy
What Counts as Consciousness
Technology
Consciousness, Creativity, and Godlike AI
Psychology
The Dark Side of Awe
Neuroscience
Why We Sense Somebody Who Isn’t There
Technology
When AI Hallucinates
Philosophy
Audio Feature: The Puzzle of Free Will
Neuroscience
Yes, We Have Free Will. No, We Absolutely Do Not
Psychology
The Happiest Man in the World
Evolution
Motion Made Minds
Psychology
When Do We Have Free Choice?
Psychology
Can Ecstasy Save a Marriage?
Psychology
Reading Through Grief
Philosophy
What Counts as Consciousness
Technology
Consciousness, Creativity, and Godlike AI
Psychology
The Dark Side of Awe
Neuroscience
Why We Sense Somebody Who Isn’t There
Technology
When AI Hallucinates
Philosophy
Audio Feature: The Puzzle of Free Will
Neuroscience
Yes, We Have Free Will. No, We Absolutely Do Not
Psychology
The Happiest Man in the World
Evolution
Motion Made Minds
Psychology
When Do We Have Free Choice?
Psychology
Can Ecstasy Save a Marriage?
Psychology
Reading Through Grief
Philosophy
What Counts as Consciousness
Technology
Consciousness, Creativity, and Godlike AI
Psychology
The Dark Side of Awe
Neuroscience
Why We Sense Somebody Who Isn’t There
Technology
When AI Hallucinates
Philosophy
Audio Feature: The Puzzle of Free Will
Neuroscience
Yes, We Have Free Will. No, We Absolutely Do Not
Psychology
The Happiest Man in the World
ADVERTISEMENT
Nautilus Members enjoy an ad-free experience. Log in or Join now .
* Psychology
CONSCIOUSNESS HAS A PSYCHOLOGY PROBLEM
The biases that shape our understanding of the mind.
* By Iris Berent
* November 27, 2024
* Add a comment
* Share
Facebook Twitter Pocket Reddit Email
Sign up for the free Nautilus newsletter:
science and culture for people who love beautiful writing.
NL – Article speedbump
Captcha
Email *
Sign up for free
Explore
Seeing the striking magenta of bougainvillea. Tasting a rich morning latte.
Feeling the sharp pain of a needle prick going into your arm. These subjective
experiences are the stuff of the mind. What is “doing the experiencing,” the
3-pound chunk of meat in our head, is a tangible object that works on
electrochemical signals—physics, essentially. How do the two—our mental
experiences and physical brains—interact?
Powered By
10
If We Could Listen to the Sun, What Sounds Would it Make?
Share
Next
Stay
Nautilus Members enjoy an ad-free experience. Log in or Join now .
The puzzle of consciousness seems to be giving science a run for its money. The
problem, to be clear, isn’t merely to pinpoint “where it all happens” in the
brain (although this, too, is far from trivial). The real mystery is how to
bridge the gap between the mental, first-person stuff of consciousness and the
physical lump of matter inside the cranium.
Some think the gap is unbreachable. The philosopher David Chalmers, for
instance, has argued that consciousness is something special and distinct from
the physical world. If so, it may never be possible to explain consciousness in
terms of physical brain processes. No matter how deeply scientists understand
the brain, for Chalmers, this would never explain how our neurons produce
consciousness. Why should a hunk of flesh, teeming with chemical signals and
electrical charges, experience a point of view? There seems to be no conceivable
reason why meaty matter would have this light of subjectivity “on the inside.”
Consciousness, then, is a “hard problem”—as Chalmers has labeled it—indeed.
> Can a person lack conscious experience, even if their body looks just like
> mine?
ADVERTISEMENT
Nautilus Members enjoy an ad-free experience. Log in or Join now .
The possibility that consciousness itself isn’t anything physical raises burning
questions about whether, for example, an AI can fall in love with its
programmer. And since consciousness is a natural phenomenon, much like gravity
or genes, these questions carry huge implications. Science explains the natural
world by physical principles only. So if it turns out that one natural
phenomenon transcends the laws of physics, then it is not only the science of
consciousness that is in trouble—our entire understanding of the natural world
would require serious revision.
But before we run off too fast and far, let us pause, take a breath, and
reconsider. The mind is hard to explain in physical terms—this much is obvious.
Why it is hard, however, is far from evident. In fact, this question is open to
two competing explanations. The first explanation puts the blame on what
consciousness is—that it is not physical, as Chalmers claims. Alternatively,
this impression (that consciousness isn’t physical) could arise from within, as
a result of human bias—a psychological delusion.
Psychological biases are relevant because philosophers and scientists heavily
rely on their intuitions as they try to explain what consciousness is. Is it
special—can it reveal more about the world than what I can infer from my reason
alone? Does my conscious experience seem physical? Can a person lack conscious
experience, even if their body looks and works just like mine?
In these mini-thought experiments, intuitions are data. Since consciousness
generates intuitions, intuitions can speak to what consciousness is, at least in
principle. The problem is that the “psychology of psychology” is a tricky
business.
ADVERTISEMENT
Nautilus Members enjoy an ad-free experience. Log in or Join now .
Human cognition, as we know, is laced with biases—we can readily recognize these
distortions in visual illusions, auditory hallucinations, and logical fallacies.
So, if our perception of the external world is distorted, why assume our
internal perception is truthful? In fact, people are demonstrably plagued by
multiple biases that cloud their reasoning about how their own psyche works.
Intuitive dualism is one such psychological bias. It suggests to us that the
mind is ethereal, distinct from the body. My research suggests that intuitive
dualism arises in humans naturally and spontaneously—it emerges from the two
innate systems: One guides our understanding of the physical properties of
objects; another helps us “read” the minds of others. So it is not the product
of rationally analyzing what exists. It is a psychological delusion that arises
from within the human mind itself.
However, intuitive dualism has been shown to give rise to various prejudices,
ranging from the denial of human nature to our misguided fascination with
neuroscience and the tendency to stigmatize people with psychiatric disorders.
Our consciousness intuitions could arise from the same source as these biases.
So, if consciousness appears somehow distinct from physical reality, then this
conclusion could well arise not from what consciousness really is, but rather
from what our psyche is telling us, courtesy of intuitive dualism.
ADVERTISEMENT
Nautilus Members enjoy an ad-free experience. Log in or Join now .
How can we tell, then, whether or not our intuitions (that consciousness is not
physical) reflect what consciousness really is? It looks like we are at a
stalemate. And that’s a problem for the “hard problem.”
Recent research helps us move forward. To see how, suppose you inspect yourself
in the mirror: Your face has an unhealthy greenish hue. Before rushing to the
ER, you step outside and reexamine your image in natural light. The greenish
appearance changes, you are all clear; the strange color was likely an artifact
of the lighting. Shifting intuitions are diagnostic—they can help us identify
our own biases.
The same logic can help us sift consciousness fact from fiction. If our
intuitions about consciousness faithfully reflect what consciousness is, and if
the nature of consciousness is invariant—meaning it doesn’t change from being
physical to non-physical—then our intuitions about the nature of consciousness
should also not change. In other words, they should not vary by context. But if
consciousness intuitions shift, such that, in some situations, consciousness
seems ethereal, and in others, it seems physical, then it’s likely something
about our psyche that explains these intuitions, not consciousness itself.
When such shifts are detected, it’s a telltale sign of a psychological delusion,
just like the shifts of your greenish complexion above. And if we could further
explain how these shifts arise from within—by spelling out their psychological
causes, then our confidence in this psychological explanation would increase
further. Such shifts in consciousness intuitions, then, suggest that our
intuitions can’t be trusted to reveal reliable information about the nature of
our minds. This is precisely what psychological experiments probing our
intuitions about consciousness show.
ADVERTISEMENT
Nautilus Members enjoy an ad-free experience. Log in or Join now .
> Why should a hunk of flesh experience a point of view?
Sometimes this involves asking people to consider the idea of a philosophical
zombie. Philosophical zombies are hypothetical creatures that lack consciousness
yet everything else physical about them—including their biology and brain
chemistry—matches humans perfectly. The idea is that if someone believes
consciousness is distinct from physical matter, then that person should think
philosophical zombies could, in theory, exist. And if philosophical zombies are
conceivable, then perhaps the possession of an intact human body does not
guarantee consciousness. Consciousness, so the argument goes, is thus distinct
from the physical.
When philosophers are surveyed, most respond that, indeed, zombies are
conceivable. But what about most people—do they, too, share these intuitions?
In a 2021 paper published in the journal Cognition, researchers Eugen Fischer
and Justin Sytsma had participants think about whether the idea of a
“philosophical zombie” made sense. To find out, they asked people to rate
whether philosophical zombies would be capable of having conscious experiences,
feelings, and emotions. Responses hovered around the “neutral” midpoint of the
seven-point rating scale (4, “neither agree nor disagree”). Few participants, to
be sure, outright denied that zombies are conscious, and fewer yet denied that
zombies are conscious while affirming that they have a functional, humanlike
body (as the instructions to the experiment suggested). This last result could
either indicate that most people cannot fully conceive of philosophical zombies
or that participants are simply reluctant to respond “no” (e.g., No, zombies
aren’t conscious!).
ADVERTISEMENT
Nautilus Members enjoy an ad-free experience. Log in or Join now .
Indeed, in a 2022 study published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of
Sciences, my colleagues and I showed that when participants are forced to give a
binary response (instead of a seven-point rating scale that allows them to “sit
on the fence”), participants state that a perfect replica of a person’s body
will not maintain their mental states—thoughts and beliefs. Insofar as
consciousness is a mental state, this would imply that zombies do not seem
possible.
Either way, participants in Fischer and Sytsma’s study certainly did not ascribe
much conscious experience to zombies, even though the problem framing clearly
established that these creatures have a human body. Consciousness, for them,
seems to be at least partly distinct from the physical.
So far, then, it looks like most people intuit that consciousness is ethereal;
at least, that is what they say about philosophical zombies. It is therefore
tempting to conclude that what’s true for zombies could hold for the many other
scenarios that philosophers have used to probe our consciousness intuitions.
After all, if we assume that these scenarios shed light on what consciousness
is—and for what we know, consciousness does not change—then what’s true in one
case ought to be true in all.
The physicality case, it would seem, is closed; our intuitions tell us that
consciousness isn’t physical. So strong is this tacit conviction that, to my
knowledge, no one has bothered to check whether this is really the case. But it
turns out that when most people are asked to consider a second famous case—the
problem of Mary in the black and white room—people tend to view consciousness as
squarely physical.
ADVERTISEMENT
Nautilus Members enjoy an ad-free experience. Log in or Join now .
Mary, the thought experiment goes, is a neuroscientist who is an expert on color
vision. Mary herself, however, has never seen color, as she lives in a black and
white room. Now, suppose that Mary steps out of that room and sees a red rose
for the first time. How significant is that conscious experience? Will it
register or “show up” in Mary’s brain?
A series of experiments from my lab at Northeastern University presented
participants with several versions of Mary’s case (a total of 180 people across
four different experiments). Their task was to rate not only the significance of
that new conscious experience (specifically, “How transformative is Mary’s
experience seeing the color red? How much has her grasp of ‘red’ changed by
seeing the red rose?”) but also its embodiment—whether it is likely to “show up”
in Mary’s brain.
The philosophical literature leads us to expect that Mary’s new conscious
experience is significant—it has utterly transformed her grasp of color, and
participants agreed. In fact, their ratings in response to the “transformative”
question (above) were significantly above the midpoint of the seven-point rating
scale, so clearly, participants did view this experience as quite significant.
But when asked whether Mary’s conscious experience will “show up” in a brain
scan (i.e., in Mary’s physical body), they said it will!
Participants further believed that Mary’s first conscious experience of red is
more likely to manifest in the brain scan than all of her “abstract” knowledge
about color vision. In fact, the more likely participants were to state the
“red” experience would “show up” in the brain, the more transformative it
seemed. Thus, not only did participants consider Mary’s conscious experience as
squarely embodied, but embodiment was also linked to the significance of this
experience.
ADVERTISEMENT
Nautilus Members enjoy an ad-free experience. Log in or Join now .
> Consciousness does not change—what’s true in one case ought to be true in all.
In another experiment (from the same study), participants were asked to assume
that Mary’s first encounter with the red rose happens in one of two conditions
(presented to Mary as part of a carefully controlled experiment). One condition
has Mary looking at the red rose in full view for several seconds; when asked to
report her experience, Mary confirms seeing it. In a second condition, the red
rose is presented for just a fraction of a second. When asked about what she
saw, Mary reports seeing nothing. Despite this, participants are told, seeing
the red rose for just a fraction of a second is likely to have registered in
Mary’s brain since research has shown that after such subliminal presentations,
the word “rose” comes to mind more readily.
The two conditions (the subliminal and conscious), then, are identical except
that one engenders consciousness and the other doesn’t. By comparing them, we
can directly examine intuitions about consciousness (as opposed to “seeing
color”). If responses to the two conditions differ, then, this difference will
shed light on how consciousness is perceived—whether it is transformative and
whether it is embodied in Mary’s brain.
Results showed that participants considered Mary’s conscious experience (in the
first condition) as more transformative than her subliminal experience (in the
second condition); this is only expected from the philosophical analysis. But,
contrary to what might be expected given the “hard problem,” participants also
considered the conscious experience to be more likely to “show up” in Mary’s
brain compared to the subliminal experience. And once again, “transformative”
ratings were positively linked with the brain registering the experience, such
that the stronger the intuitions that Mary’s conscious experience registered in
her brain, the more transformative it seemed.
ADVERTISEMENT
Nautilus Members enjoy an ad-free experience. Log in or Join now .
These outcomes are striking for two reasons. First, the results show that, when
people consider Mary’s case, consciousness seems to them squarely physical. This
flies in the face of the common wisdom that consciousness seems not physical.
Second, when compared with the zombie’s case, it appears that these
psychological intuitions shift.
In the zombie’s case, consciousness seems ethereal; in Mary’s case, it seems
physical. And if different thought experiments can produce such a radical shift
in intuitions about the nature of consciousness, then our intuitions about
subjective experience cannot possibly be trusted to reflect what consciousness
really is like. This means our intuitions about consciousness likely emerge
from within—from psychological biases.
Our intuitions about consciousness are shaped by two competing psychological
biases: intuitive dualism and essentialism.
A large body of literature suggests that people—adults and young children,
across various societies and cultures—consider the mind distinct from the body.
For intuitive dualists, philosophical zombies don’t seem so strange. Since
dualists see the mind as ethereal, distinct from the body, they can readily
imagine a creature that shares only our body, but not the inner light of
conscious experience. From the outside, the creature seems just like any real
person; but on the inside, there’s nobody home. They’re as conscious as a rock.
ADVERTISEMENT
Nautilus Members enjoy an ad-free experience. Log in or Join now .
Had our intuitions about consciousness stemmed only from intuitive dualism, then
consciousness should have always seemed ethereal, just as the case of zombies
suggests. But psychological biases, such as intuitive dualism, do not operate in
a vacuum; they often interact with conflicting biases. And when these
interactions occur, a bias that was previously silent can suddenly become
dominant. Critically, the “push and pull” dynamics between them can also be
shaped by context. When context shifts—when people consider different thought
experiments about consciousness—the role of dualism may be weakened.
Consequently, intuitions about the link between consciousness and the brain
shift, too.
Mary’s case invokes just that shift in intuitions. What’s different about Mary’s
case (relative to zombies) is that it invites us to evaluate a change to Mary
herself (her new experience with color), and as a result, we now focus on her
body, more than her mind. This attenuates the effect of intuitive dualism and
brings a second competing constraint into the forefront—intuitive essentialism.
Essentialism is the intuitive belief that living things are what they are
because they possess some innate, immutable essence that lies within their
bodies. Research has shown that when people evaluate a change to a protagonist,
they assess whether the change pertains to the protagonist’s essence. And since
that essence seems to lie within the body, it is the body that determines the
significance of that change.
For example, young children believe that a change to a dog’s insides (like
removing its blood and bones) amounts to changing the kind of thing that it is,
whereas external changes (like removing its fur) will not, presumably because it
is within the “insides” that the animal’s hidden essence lies.
ADVERTISEMENT
Nautilus Members enjoy an ad-free experience. Log in or Join now .
Like the dog example, Mary’s case also features a change. So for an intuitive
essentialist, Mary’s newly gained consciousness of the redness of the color red
ought to be significant or transformative only if this change pertains to her
bodily essence. It follows that, to engender a significant change, a new
conscious experience must affect Mary’s body. Seeing color fits the bill,
because “seeing” intuitively feels like an embodied affair that involves the
eyes. Accordingly, participants viewed Mary’s conscious experience as
“transformative.”
Moreover, seeing color is significant precisely because intuitively, this
experience seems physically embodied. The results also showed that the more
“embodied” Mary’s experience seemed, the more transformative it was. This link
between “embodiment” and “transformativeness” is exactly what intuitive
essentialism predicts.
Together, intuitive dualism and essentialism can both capture our conscious
intuitions. The crucial point, however, isn’t just why and how consciousness
intuitions shift. Rather, it is the fact a shift occurs that is critical. And
since it does, you know you could be in trouble—your intuitions could well arise
from your internal psychological biases. So, resist the temptation and do not
blindly follow their delusional voice. Don’t trust your consciousness to tell
you what consciousness really is.
Lead image: everything bagel / Shutterstock
ADVERTISEMENT
Nautilus Members enjoy an ad-free experience. Log in or Join now .
* IRIS BERENT
Posted on November 27, 2024
Iris Berent is a professor of psychology at Northeastern University and the
author of The Blind Storyteller: How We Reason About Human Nature.
GET THE NAUTILUS NEWSLETTER
Cutting-edge science, unraveled by the very brightest living thinkers.
NL – In Page Mobile
Email: *
Captcha
Sign up for free
Environment
The New Climate Math on Hurricanes
Zoology
A Stolen Egg
Math
When Work Is Play
ADVERTISEMENT
View / Add Comments
*
Explore
MOTION MADE MINDS
* By Viviane Callier
* October 25, 2024
* Evolution
The origins of consciousness according to Peter Godfrey-Smith.
*
Explore
WHEN DO WE HAVE FREE CHOICE?
* By Corey Cusimano & Tania Lombrozo
* October 21, 2024
* Psychology
Two psychologists explain how we think about freedom.
*
Explore
CAN ECSTASY SAVE A MARRIAGE?
* By Ben Seal
* October 10, 2024
* Psychology
A new wave of experimental therapy is enlisting MDMA in relationship
counseling.
*
Explore
READING THROUGH GRIEF
* By Cody Delistraty
* June 25, 2024
* Psychology
Trying to turn the page on my mom’s death.
*
Explore
WHAT COUNTS AS CONSCIOUSNESS
* By Dan Falk
* May 6, 2024
* Philosophy
Neuroscientist Christof Koch on human minds, AI, and bacteria.
NAUTILUS: SCIENCE CONNECTED
Nautilus is a different kind of science magazine. Our stories take you into the
depths of science and spotlight its ripples in our lives and cultures.
GET THE NAUTILUS NEWSLETTER
Cutting-edge science, unraveled by the very brightest living thinkers.
NL – Footer
Email: *
Name
Name
First
First
Last
Last
Captcha
Sign up for free
If you are human, leave this field blank.
QUICK LINKS
* Home
* About Us
* Contact
* FAQ
* Prime
* Ebook
* Shop
* Donate
* Awards and Press
* Privacy Policy
* Terms of Service
* RSS
* Jobs
* Newsletter
* Ethics Policy
SOCIAL
*
*
*
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
© 2024 NautilusNext Inc., All rights reserved.
Enjoy unlimited Nautilus articles, ad-free, for less than $5/month. Join now
! THERE IS NOT AN ACTIVE SUBSCRIPTION ASSOCIATED WITH THAT EMAIL ADDRESS.
ALREADY A MEMBER? LOG IN
JOIN TO CONTINUE READING.
You’ve read your 2 free articles this month. Access unlimited ad-free stories,
including this one, by becoming a Nautilus member — 25% off for a limited time
during our seasonal sale.
Join for 25% off
! THERE IS NOT AN ACTIVE SUBSCRIPTION ASSOCIATED WITH THAT EMAIL ADDRESS.
ALREADY A MEMBER? LOG IN
THIS IS YOUR LAST FREE ARTICLE.
Don’t limit your curiosity. Access unlimited ad-free stories like this one, and
support independent journalism, by becoming a Nautilus member — 25% off for a
limited time during our seasonal sale.
Join for 25% off
Literary and always interesting.
To read this story, sign up for the free Nautilus newsletter: science and
culture for people who love beautiful writing.
NL – Emailgate
*
Captcha
Sign up for free