storeys.com Open in urlscan Pro
151.101.193.91  Public Scan

Form analysis
2 forms found in the DOM

/search/

<form action="/search/"><button type="submit" class="menu-global__submit fa fa-search" value="" aria-label="Submit"></button><input name="q" class="menu-global__text-input" type="text" placeholder="Search..." aria-label="Search"></form>

/search/

<form action="/search/" role="search"><input name="q" class="js-search-input search-widget__input" type="text" placeholder="" aria-label="Search"><button type="submit" class="js-search-submit search-widget__submit fa fa-search" value=""
    aria-label="Submit"></button></form>

Text Content

Real Estate News
Affordable HousingAppointment NoticesConstructionDevelopment
ProjectsIndustryPolicyRenting
Commercial
IndustrialMultifamilyOfficeRetail
Cities
TorontoOttawaMississaugaVancouverBurnabySurreyCoquitlamCalgaryEdmontonHamiltonOakvilleVaughan
Listings
ListedListed LuxeListed CommercialListed CountrySold
Cottage Country
CollingwoodGeorgian BayHaliburtonKawarthasMuskoka
Insiders
Dock TalkHume with a ViewMeet the AgentOpinionProfilesReal InsightsThe Kinsman
ReportThe Proptech ReviewUrbanity Fair
Finance
EconomyFirst Time BuyersMortgagesPersonal FinanceRenovationsTaxes
Urban Living
EntertainmentParksTransportation
Newsletter
NEWSLETTER

IN THE KNOW: Buyer Found For Vandyk-Backyard Humberside Property


 1. Home>
 2. Real Estate News>
 3. Construction>
 4. How The Ontario Developer Coalition Pledging To Reduce Prices Came Together>

ConstructionBreaking NewsReal Estate NewsOther (Canada)Featured
True
(Elton Law, Shutterstock)
Construction


HOW THE ONTARIO DEVELOPER COALITION PLEDGING TO REDUCE PRICES CAME TOGETHER


THE GROUP IS CALLING ITSELF THE COALITION AGAINST NEW-HOME TAXES (CANT) AND
INCLUDES REPUBLIC, ALTERRA, DEVRON, AND FORUM, AMONG MANY OTHERS.


Howard Chai

August 01, 2024

03:59 PM

A group of Ontario developers have signed a pledge to cut the prices of the
homes they build, putting their money where their mouth is in an attempt to make
a real impact on housing affordability.

The catch: they are asking municipal, provincial governments, and the federal
government to reduce or eliminate the various development charges that
essentially serve as a tax on housing, adding to the costs of building that
developers pass on to buyers.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------



"For every dollar of tax eliminated by any level of government from the cost of
delivering new housing, we will immediately reduce the price of all homes we
sell by the amount saved, dollar for dollar," the coalition says.

The group is calling itself the Coalition Against New-Home Taxes (CANT) and
includes Republic Developments, Alterra, Altree Developments, Devron, and Forum
Asset Management, among many others.


THE COALITION

The birth of the coalition can be traced back to January and Republic
Developments President & CEO Matt Young.

"It kind of started with myself and a consultant that I work with having a chat
early in January," Young tells STOREYS. "We were just kind of talking about the
market and what we were seeing and how unaffordable pricing has gotten. We had
started doing a bunch of research on why it got so expensive, and I told him
that 'You know, taxes have gone up more than any other cost in the proforma of a
project.' So, we thought trying to do something to target governments [and get
them] to pay attention to those taxes, look at reforms around those taxes, would
be an interesting idea."







Young then started reaching out to various homebuilder colleagues, many of them
liked the idea, and the ball got rolling from there. Although he declined to
identify them, Young says that some developers would not commit to joining the
coalition and signing the pledge.

"I think we have an incredible group and since the story has come out, more
developers have reached out to me saying they'd love to be a part of the pledge,
so we're going to have more and more homebuilders signing on to the pledge, and
it sends a message. These are people who are leading the charge. These are
people who care about housing affordability. The ones who don't sign the pledge
maybe are the ones that care less about that."

As for the idea of the pledge, Young says it was a direct response to the
current market environment, where numerous condo projects across the Greater
Toronto and Hamilton Area are not selling or being put on hold.







"The concept of the pledge came up because we were talking about the fact that I
don't think any developer or homebuilder wants to make more money right now,"
says Young. "I think what they all want to do is build housing and get shovels
in the ground. So, we thought this idea of doing a pledge, kind of like the
giving pledge, would sort of send the message to the public that we are on their
side and we actually do want to build housing that is affordable. But we can
only build housing at a price relative to the cost to build, and right now taxes
account for 30% of a home, so if you want lower pricing, taxes was the lowest
hanging fruit to do that."


THE COSTS

In their pledge letter, dated July 31 and addressed to the heads of three levels
of government and others, the coalition included a sample proforma for a
hypothetical 321-unit high-rise condo project in a mid-market location in
Toronto. According to their provided proforma, this project would have a total
cost of $264,054,168.







On a project level, government costs account for $77,173,414 of that total,
which represents 29.2% of the total budget. On a per unit basis, government
costs account for $240,416 in the price of each home, with the biggest line
items coming from the HST and development charges.

A sample project proforma, including a breakdown of government costs.(Coalition
Against New-Home Taxes)

"It's actually not just the taxes," adds Young. "We also include in that the
interest saved on those taxes, because for a number of these taxes, we actually
pay upfront, before the home is completed and closed. And when we pay them
upfront, we have to finance those costs, which means we're paying interest on
those costs. We're actually including that interest as part of the price that we
would reduce."

On the other side of these development charges, however, are the governments,
which typically use these charges to fund things like infrastructure. The
coalition's letter does not provide a solution to address how governments would
be able to make up for this funding gap, saying only that "there are better
tools to fund these infrastructure costs which are more sustainable." Young
recognizes this, but also points out that not all infrastructure is paid for by
governments.







"We, as a builder, if we're building a project in an area that doesn't have
sufficient capacity or requires a new road or sewers, we actually have to build
those," he points out. "We build them and we pay for them. The development
charge is a double dip — it's tax on top of the cost we already have to build.
We can't actually use our development charges on the projects [and the new
infrastructure that's required]."

Young also points to the concept that's behind this — the concept of "growth
paying for growth," a topic that was at the centre of a debate in British
Columbia last year after the Metro Vancouver Regional District proposed to raise
its development cost charges, which was later pushed through despite a warning
from Sean Fraser.

"Everybody always talks about development charges funding infrastructure," he
says. "A lot of that infrastructure that gets funded are used by everybody in
the city. In Toronto, the number one line item is for transit. That
infrastructure benefits everybody in the city, not just the 20,000 to 30,000 new
homeowners that buy every year. I think we need to look at how that's funded and
everybody needs to pay their fair share, so we're not burdening first-time
homebuyers, young people, and new immigrants."








THE ASK

In their letter to the various levels of government, CANT is asking for three
things. The first is that the government eliminate the HST on all new housing,
similar to last year's move to eliminate the GST on new rental construction.
"Reforms have been implemented with rental housing and should now be extended to
all new ownership housing as well," the coalition says.

The second ask is for governments to eliminate the land transfer taxes on new
construction, which buyers pay upon closing. In Toronto, Young points out, there
is both a municipal and provincial land transfer tax, and the coalition is
asking for the introduction of a one-time credit on these taxes, which would be
direct savings for buyers.

Last, but not least, is municipal development charges, which the coalition
points out have gone up over 600% since 2009, rising from $36,000 per unit to
$240,000 per unit. The coalition is asking the City of Toronto to "reduce
development charges on new housing to the inflation adjusted rate based on the
starting value of 2009 development charge rates," adding that this would amount
to $6,857 for a one-bedroom apartment and $11,033 for a two-bedroom apartment.







Young says that the research they conducted found that eliminating these tax
incomes for the various level governments amount to approximately 5% of
Toronto's budget, a little over 2% of Ontario's budget, and about 1% of the
federal budget.

It's not the first time these issues have been raised, but Young says the
coalition is hoping this time will be different and believes the clear-cut
pledge can make that difference. Timing is also everything, he says.

"When you're in a really good market, where interest rates are low and demand is
really high, then it's really easy for the public or the government to say
'Well, if we cut taxes, you're just going to make more profit.' That's totally
valid. But we're in a totally different time right now where nothing is selling
and nothing new is being built, so it's the perfect time to do something like
this. We're willing to have any accountability measure governments want to
implement to ensure savings get passed on, but further than that, there's a
financial incentive to ensure savings get passed on, because people can't afford
the homes that are available today and if we can lower the prices to the point
where they could afford those homes, we would start to see shovels get back in
the ground again, we would start to see building happening again, we would start
to curb the job losses that are happening in the construction industry, and we
can start to increase the supply of housing."







In other words, what the coalition is saving to governments is that the ball is
now in their court.

From Your Site Articles
 * Bosa Properties Says Burnaby Policies Make Purpose-Built Rental Projects
   "Unbuildable" ›
 * Anthem, Polygon, And Canderel Voice "Deep Concern" Over Burnaby's New ACCs ›
 * How BC's New Four-Month Eviction Notice Rule May Affect First-Time Buyers ›

Construction



TRENDING

Real Estate NewsCitiesTorontoOther (Canada)Featured
Real Estate News


“ENCOURAGING”: INTEREST RATE CUTS STARTING TO LIFT TORONTO HOME SALES


NEWLY LISTED TRINITY BELLWOODS MODERN SERVES SLEEK SOPHISTICATION

Real Estate NewsBritish Columbia / AlbertaFeatured
Real Estate News


WEAK GREATER VANCOUVER REAL ESTATE MARKET "SURPRISING" AFTER TWO RATE CUTS: GVR

Affordable HousingCitiesTorontoReal Estate NewsOther (Canada)Featured
Affordable Housing


FEDS ANNOUNCE $105M INVESTMENT IN TORONTO AFFORDABLE HOMES

Development ProjectsCitiesTorontoReal Estate NewsOther (Canada)Featured
Development Projects


42-STOREY CONDO WITH GOLDEN EXTERIOR PROPOSED STEPS FROM BAYVIEW VILLAGE




YOU MAY ALSO LIKE

Urban LivingTorontoCities
Urban Living


WHAT'S OPEN AND CLOSED IN TORONTO ON THE AUGUST CIVIC HOLIDAY


WHILE MANY BUSINESSES WILL CLOSE THEIR DOORS ON MONDAY, AUGUST 5, SOME GROCERY
STORES, SHOPPING CENTRES, AND MAJOR ATTRACTIONS WILL REMAIN OPEN FOR THE LONG
WEEKEND.

Property badge
Listed CommercialIndustryCitiesPropertiesFeaturedReal Estate NewsBritish
Columbia / AlbertaSurrey
Listed Commercial


SITE OF FORECLOSED 67-STOREY AIMFORCE PROJECT IN SURREY LISTED FOR $75M


THE 67-STOREY TOWER WAS BEING PLANNED BY AIMFORCE DEVELOPMENT AND SET FOR 10227
KING GEORGE BOULEVARD.

MortgagesFinanceReal Estate NewsOther (Canada)British Columbia / AlbertaFeatured
Mortgages


CANADA'S NEW 30-YEAR MORTGAGE AMORTIZATIONS WILL HELP VERY FEW, EXPERTS WARN


CRITICS SAY THE NEW 30-YEAR MORTGAGE AMORTIZATIONS ARE TOO RESTRICTIVE TO HAVE A
NOTABLE IMPACT IN CANADA’S PRICIER CITIES.


COUNTRY CALLING: GET TO KNOW SHERWOOD PARK, A BELOVED ALBERTA HAMLET


FOR THOSE WHO PREFER TO OPT OUT OF URBAN LIFE WITHOUT BEING TOO FAR REMOVED FROM
MODERN COMFORTS, HAMLETS LIKE SHERWOOD PARK, ALBERTA ARE A PERFECT LANDING
PLACE.

MississaugaCitiesReal Estate NewsOther (Canada)Featured
Mississauga


HOW MISSISSAUGA IS IMPROVING AND EXPANDING ITS FREE GARDEN SUITE PLANS PROGRAM


AFTER TWO MONTHS AND ONLY ONE APPLICATION, THE CITY IS LOOKING AT WAYS TO GROW
THEIR PROGRAM AIMED AT INCREASING GENTLE DENSITY.

Development ProjectsCitiesReal Estate NewsOther (Canada)Featured
Development Projects


CAR DEALERSHIP AT JANE AND ST. CLAIR COULD ADD CONDOS TO ITS MIX


A NEW DEVELOPMENT APPLICATION PROMISES TO BREATHE NEW LIFE INTO THE SITE OF A
TWO-STOREY OLD MILL CADILLAC CHEVROLET BUICK GMC DEALERSHIP.

IndustryBreaking NewsRetailOther (Canada)CommercialCitiesTorontoReal Estate
NewsFeatured
Industry


BUYER FOUND FOR VANDYK-BACKYARD HUMBERSIDE PROPERTY, UNDER RECEIVERSHIP SINCE
MARCH


NEW COURT FILINGS SHOW THAT VANDYK-BACKYARD HUMBERSIDE’S COMMERCIAL PROPERTY AT
10 NEIGHBOURHOOD LANE RECEIVED EIGHT OFFERS THROUGHOUT THE SALES PROCESS.

PolicyCitiesFeaturedReal Estate NewsBritish Columbia / AlbertaSurrey
Policy


SURREY GREEN-LIGHTS LONG-TERM DEVELOPMENT PLAN FOR SCOTT ROAD - 72 AVENUE
CORRIDOR


THE IMAGINE SCOTT ROAD VISIONING STUDY WILL GUIDE SERVICING AND REDEVELOPMENT OF
THE SCOTT ROAD - 72 AVENUE CORRIDOR, SAYS THE CITY OF SURREY.

Development ProjectsCitiesTorontoReal Estate NewsOther (Canada)Featured
Development Projects


PROPOSAL CALLS FOR TOWERS UP TO 55 STOREYS, REUSE OF OFFICE SPACE NEAR SHEPPARD
WEST


THE AMBITIOUS DEVELOPMENT WOULD PROVIDE 1,759 CONDO UNITS, INCLUDING
ONE-BEDROOMS THAT COULD BE TURNED INTO THREE-BEDROOMS.

Development ProjectsCitiesTorontoReal Estate NewsOther (Canada)Featured
Development Projects


40-STOREY RESIDENTIAL PROPOSED STEPS FROM GLENCAIRN STATION


IF APPROVED, THE DEVELOPMENT WOULD BRING 477 NEW CONDO UNITS TO THE SITE IN
NORTH YORK, WHICH IS JUST A TWO-MINUTE WALK FROM THE GLENCAIRN SUBWAY STATION.

Development ProjectsCitiesTorontoReal Estate NewsOther (Canada)Featured
Development Projects


CAPREIT PLANS PAIR OF INFILL TOWERS FOR 'LONG-OWNED' SITE IN SCARBOROUGH


CAPREIT'S PLANS INVOLVE BRINGING 635 NEW RESIDENTIAL UNITS TO THE
MARKHAM-ELLESMERE AREA OF SCARBOROUGH, AND THE RETENTION OF AN EXISTING RENTAL
APARTMENT BUILDING ON THE SUBJECT SITE.

Development ProjectsUrban LivingOther (Canada)CitiesMississaugaReal Estate
NewsFeatured
Development Projects


MISSISSAUGA RESIDENTS VOICE CONCERNS OVER MORE DENSITY PROPOSED FOR BRIGHTWATER
COMMUNITY


THE BRIGHTWATER PROJECT WAS A HOT TOPIC AT A MISSISSAUGA PLANNING AND
DEVELOPMENT MEETING ON MONDAY, WHERE RESIDENTS VOICED THEIR CONCERNS ABOUT THE
IMPACT TO THE COMMUNITY.

PolicyReal Estate NewsBritish Columbia / AlbertaFeatured
Policy


TEN MORE BC MUNICIPALITIES RECEIVE HOUSING SUPPLY TARGETS


THE THIRD COHORT OF LOCAL GOVERNMENTS TO RECEIVE HOUSING SUPPLY TARGETS INCLUDE
NEW WESTMINSTER, THE CITY OF LANGLEY, AND WEST KELOWNA.

PolicyAffordable HousingReal Estate NewsBritish Columbia / AlbertaFeatured
Policy


EVERY BC PROJECT RECEIVING FUNDING FROM THE CMHC AFFORDABLE HOUSING FUND


FORMERLY KNOWN AS THE NATIONAL HOUSING CO-INVESTMENT FUND (NHCF), THE AFFORDABLE
HOUSING FUND PROVIDES CAPITAL FOR NEW CONSTRUCTION OR RENOVATIONS OF AFFORDABLE
HOUSING.

Development ProjectsConstructionOther (Canada)CitiesTorontoAffordable
HousingReal Estate NewsFeatured
Development Projects


‘HOUSING NOW’ DEVELOPMENT ON VICTORIA PARK AVE ADVANCES, NEW RENDERINGS RELEASED


LAST WEEK, WE SAW TORONTO CITY COUNCIL CONSIDER THE FATE OF DOZENS OF
DEVELOPMENT PROJECTS, AND AMONG THOSE WAS A NEW AFFORDABLE HOUSING HUB COMING TO
777 VICTORIA PARK AVENUE THROUGH THE ‘HOUSING NOW’ INITIATIVE.

Urbanity FairInsidersOther (Canada)Featured
Urbanity Fair


UNLIKE EUROPE, TORONTO WON'T FLOURISH WITH MID-RISE BUILDINGS (AND THAT'S OKAY)


TO MOVE FORWARD, WE NEED TO EMBRACE AND CELEBRATE TORONTO’S REALITY AND UNIQUE
URBANIZATION PATH, AND FOCUS ON LEARNING A MORE FUNDAMENTAL LESSON FROM EUROPEAN
CITIES


Privacy PolicyAbout UsTerms of UseAdvertise with UsJobsContact UsRSS Feed


2024 © STOREYS PUBLISHING INC. | ALL RIGHTS RESERVED