libertystreeteconomics.newyorkfed.org
Open in
urlscan Pro
192.0.66.62
Public Scan
Submitted URL: https://libertystreeteconomics.newyorkfed.org/2019/10/us-virgin-islands-struggle-while-puerto-rico-rebounds.html
Effective URL: https://libertystreeteconomics.newyorkfed.org/2019/10/us-virgin-islands-struggle-while-puerto-rico-rebounds/
Submission: On December 09 via api from UA — Scanned from PL
Effective URL: https://libertystreeteconomics.newyorkfed.org/2019/10/us-virgin-islands-struggle-while-puerto-rico-rebounds/
Submission: On December 09 via api from UA — Scanned from PL
Form analysis
4 forms found in the DOMGET https://www.newyorkfed.org/search
<form method="GET" action="https://www.newyorkfed.org/search" id="search">
<span class="icon-search"></span><input id="searchbox" type="text" name="text">
<input type="hidden" name="application" value="ny_pub">
<input type="hidden" name="source" value="ny_pub">
<input type="submit" id="searchbutton" value="">
</form>
GET https://www.newyorkfed.org/search
<form method="GET" action="https://www.newyorkfed.org/search" id="search">
<span class="icon-search"></span><input id="searchbox" type="text" name="text">
<input type="hidden" name="application" value="ny_pub">
<input type="hidden" name="source" value="ny_pub">
<input type="submit" id="searchbutton" value="">
</form>
GET https://libertystreeteconomics.newyorkfed.org/
<form role="search" method="get" action="https://libertystreeteconomics.newyorkfed.org/" class="wp-block-search__button-outside wp-block-search__text-button wp-block-search"><label class="wp-block-search__label screen-reader-text"
for="wp-block-search__input-1">All Liberty Street Economics</label>
<div class="wp-block-search__inside-wrapper "><input class="wp-block-search__input" id="wp-block-search__input-1" placeholder="All Liberty Street Economics" value="" type="search" name="s" required=""><button aria-label="Search"
class="wp-block-search__button wp-element-button" type="submit">Search</button></div>
</form>
https://public.govdelivery.com/accounts/USFRBNEWYORK/subscribers/qualify
<form action="https://public.govdelivery.com/accounts/USFRBNEWYORK/subscribers/qualify">
<input id="topic_id" name="topic_id" type="hidden" value="USFRBNEWYORK_104">
<fieldset>
<div class="email-alert-title">receive email alerts for this page</div>
<div class="email-alert-textbox">
<input name="email" type="text" style="background:white" size="20" value="enter your email" placeholder="enter your email">
</div>
<div class="email-alert-button_panel">
<input class="form_button" name="commit" type="submit" value="Submit">
</div>
</fieldset>
</form>
Text Content
Museum & Visits Regional Economy Data & Statistics Careers Blog Press Center MenuSearch * About the New York Fed Toggle Menu Item ABOUT THE NEW YORK FED * What We Do * Who We Are * Bank Leadership * Diversity and Inclusion * Communities We Serve * Governance * Board of Directors * Disclosures * Ethics and Conflicts of Interest * Annual Financial Statements * Org Chart * More About Us * News & Events * Advisory Groups * Vendor Information * Holiday Schedule At the New York Fed, our mission is to make the U.S. economy stronger and the financial system more stable for all segments of society. We do this by executing monetary policy, providing financial services, supervising banks and conducting research and providing expertise on issues that impact the nation and communities we serve. Introducing the New York Innovation Center: Delivering a central bank innovation execution Do you have a request for information and records? Learn how to submit it. Learn about the history of the New York Fed and central banking in the United States through articles, speeches, photos and video. * Markets & Policy Implementation Toggle Menu Item MARKETS & POLICY IMPLEMENTATION * DATA * Reference Rates * Effective Federal Funds Rate * Overnight Bank Funding Rate * Secured Overnight Financing Rate * SOFR Averages & Index * Broad General Collateral Rate * Tri-Party General Collateral Rate * Desk Operations * Treasury Securities * Agency Mortgage-Backed Securities * Repos * Reverse Repos * Securities Lending * Central Bank Liquidity Swaps * System Open Market Account Holdings * Primary Dealer Statistics * Historical Transaction Data * * * DOMESTIC MARKET OPERATIONS * Monetary Policy Implementation * Treasury Securities * Agency Mortgage-Backed Securities * Agency Commercial Mortgage-Backed Securities * Agency Debt Securities * Repos & Reverse Repos * Securities Lending * Discount Window * Treasury Debt Auctions & Buybacks as Fiscal Agent * * INTERNATIONAL MARKET OPERATIONS * Foreign Exchange * Foreign Reserves Management * Central Bank Swap Arrangements * * * ACROSS MARKETS * Statements & Operating Policies * Market Intelligence * Survey of Primary Dealers * Survey of Market Participants * Annual Reports * Counterparties * Primary Dealers * Standing Repo Facility Counterparties * Reverse Repo Counterparties * Foreign Exchange Counterparties * Foreign Reserves Management Counterparties * Operational Readiness * Central Bank & International Account Services * Programs Archive * Economic Research Toggle Menu Item ECONOMIC RESEARCH U.S. Economy * Consumer Expectations & Behavior * Survey of Consumer Expectations * Household Debt & Credit Report * Home Price Changes * Growth & Inflation * Equitable Growth Indicators * Multivariate Core Trend Inflation * New York Fed DSGE Model * New York Fed Staff Nowcast * R-star: Natural Rate of Interest * Labor Market * Labor Market for Recent College Graduates * Financial Stability * Corporate Bond Market Distress Index * Outlook-at-Risk * Treasury Term Premia * Yield Curve as a Leading Indicator * Banking * Banking Research Data Sets * Quarterly Trends for Consolidated U.S. Banking Organizations * Reserve Demand Elasticity REGIONAL ECONOMY * Empire State Manufacturing Survey * Business Leaders Survey * Regional Business Surveys: Special Topics * Regional Employment Trends * Early Benchmarked Employment Data * INTERNATIONAL ECONOMY * Global Supply Chain Pressure Index RESEARCHERS * Staff Economists * Visiting Scholars * Resident Scholars * PUBLICATIONS * Liberty Street Economics * Staff Reports * Economic Policy Review * RESEARCH CENTERS * Applied Macroeconomics & Econometrics Center (AMEC) * Center for Microeconomic Data (CMD) * CALENDAR * Economic Indicators Calendar * Financial Institution Supervision Toggle Menu Item FINANCIAL INSTITUTION SUPERVISION * Supervision & Regulation * Circulars * Regulations * Reporting Forms & Instructions * Reporting Forms * Correspondence * Bank Applications * Consumer Protection * Community Reinvestment Act Exams * Frauds and Scams As part of our core mission, we supervise and regulate financial institutions in the Second District. Our primary objective is to maintain a safe and competitive U.S. and global banking system. The Governance & Culture Reform hub is designed to foster discussion about corporate governance and the reform of culture and behavior in the financial services industry. Need to file a report with the New York Fed? Here are all of the forms, instructions and other information related to regulatory and statistical reporting in one spot. The New York Fed works to protect consumers as well as provides information and resources on how to avoid and report specific scams. * Financial Services & Infrastructure Toggle Menu Item FINANCIAL SERVICES & INFRASTRUCTURE * Financial Services & Operations * Services For Financial Institutions * Payment Services * Payment System Oversight * International Services, Seminars & Training * Financial Market Infrastructure & Reform * Tri-Party Repo Infrastructure Reform * Managing Foreign Exchange * Money Market Funds * Over-The-Counter Derivatives The Federal Reserve Bank of New York works to promote sound and well-functioning financial systems and markets through its provision of industry and payment services, advancement of infrastructure reform in key markets and training and educational support to international institutions. The New York Innovation Center bridges the worlds of finance, technology, and innovation and generates insights into high-value central bank-related opportunities. The growing role of nonbank financial institutions, or NBFIs, in U.S. financial markets is a transformational trend with implications for monetary policy and financial stability. The New York Fed offers the Central Banking Seminar and several specialized courses for central bankers and financial supervisors. * Community Development & Education Toggle Menu Item COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT & EDUCATION * Community Development * Household Financial Well-being * Climate * Health * Staff * Fed System Initiatives * Fed Communities * Fed Listens * Fed Small Business * Workforce Development * Other Community Development Work * Calendar * * Economic Education * Programs * High School Fed Challenge * College Fed Challenge * Teacher Professional Development * Classroom Visits * Museum & Learning Center Visits * Resources * Educational Comic Books * Economist Spotlight Series * Lesson Plans and Resources * Economic Education Calendar We are connecting emerging solutions with funding in three areas—health, household financial stability, and climate—to improve life for underserved communities. Learn more by reading our strategy. The Economic Inequality & Equitable Growth hub is a collection of research, analysis and convenings to help better understand economic inequality. The Governance & Culture Reform hub is designed to foster discussion about corporate governance and the reform of culture and behavior in the financial services industry. * Museum & Visits Regional Economy Data & Statistics Careers Blog Press Center Liberty Street Economics « The New York Fed DSGE Model Forecast—September 2019 | Main | Introduction to Heterogeneity Series: Understanding Causes and Implications of Various Inequalities » October 2, 2019 U.S. VIRGIN ISLANDS STRUGGLE WHILE PUERTO RICO REBOUNDS Jason Bram Two years after hurricanes Irma and Maria wreaked havoc on Puerto Rico and the U.S. Virgin Islands, the two territories’ economies have moved in very different directions. When the hurricanes struck, both were already in long economic slumps and had significant fiscal problems. As of the summer of 2019, however, Puerto Rico’s economy was showing considerable signs of improvement since the hurricanes, while the Virgin Islands’ economy remained mired in a deep slump through the end of 2018, though signs of a nascent recovery have emerged in 2019. In this post, we assess the contrasting trends of these two economies since the hurricanes and attempt to explain the forces driving these trends. BACKGROUND To put the two territories’ post-hurricane economic and fiscal situations into context, it is important to understand their respective trends over the past decade. Both had been in economic slumps since around 2006; in fact, from that time until just before the 2017 hurricanes, each area had sustained a roughly 16 percent drop in total employment as well as a sizable contraction in GDP. These protracted downturns were accompanied by high and rising public debt burdens, leading to a fiscal crisis in Puerto Rico and tremendous fiscal stress in the Virgin Islands. Severe disruptions in the aftermath of hurricanes Irma and Maria exacerbated these existing conditions, leading to a sharp drop-off in both employment and economic activity in the fourth quarter of 2017. This early-2018 New York Fed press briefing provides an overview of the two economies, both before and immediately after the hurricanes. ASSESSING THE RECOVERIES Now, just over two years after Irma and Maria, we have a clearer sense of how deep and sustained the disruptive effects of the storms were on both territories. As shown in the chart below, the Virgin Islands suffered a much steeper initial drop-off in employment (19 percent) than Puerto Rico (7 percent), and subsequently a much weaker and slower recovery. By the twelve-month anniversary of Hurricanes Irma and Maria, private-sector employment was still down 13 percent in the Virgin Islands, versus just 1 percent in Puerto Rico—thus, more than 85 percent of the initial job loss in Puerto Rico had been reversed, compared with barely over 30 percent in the Virgin Islands. In fact, as of August 2019, employment in Puerto Rico’s private sector was actually slightly above pre-hurricane levels, whereas the Virgin Islands’ private-sector job count was still down more than 3 percent, based on the New York Fed’s early benchmarked estimates—the deepest sustained post-hurricane job loss in any U.S. area, except for New Orleans following Katrina in 2005-07. In terms of total wage and salary income, however, the divergence is far less pronounced. This stems in part from the fact that the Virgin Islands sustained exceptionally steep job losses in two major low-wage industries (retail, as well as leisure and hospitality) and job gains in two high-wage sectors (construction, and professional and business services). This sizable shift in the job mix lifted average wages and thus mitigated the decline in aggregate wages. But even within a few major industries, there were some sizable jumps in wages seen in the Virgin Islands but not in Puerto Rico—most notably in construction. This may, at least in part, reflect a steep rise in the Virgin Islands’ minimum wage. WHY SUCH A DIVERGENCE? A number of factors may have contributed to the territories’ contrasting economic performance. First, the physical damage associated with the hurricanes may have been more widespread and severe in the Virgin Islands than in Puerto Rico. Two weeks before Maria, Hurricane Irma made a direct and devastating hit on St. Thomas and St. John—the northern islands of the U.S. Virgin Islands. Then Maria hit St. Croix head on, as well as Puerto Rico. It is not clear whether Puerto Rico’s much larger “footprint” (area) was a help or a hindrance—on the one hand, the southwestern and western parts of the island were on the backside of Maria and did not experience quite as much wind damage; on the other hand, many interior parts of Puerto Rico were inaccessible for a long time. Second, and perhaps more important, are the respective compositions of the economies. While Puerto Rico’s economy is fairly diversified, with some sizable industries engaged in manufacturing, business services, and so forth, the Virgin Islands’ economy is much more based on tourism. In the aftermath of the hurricane—and as is typically the case after major local disasters—tourism-related industries like accommodation and restaurants were the hardest hit and the slowest to come back. In contrast, Puerto Rico’s professional and business services sector has seen substantial job gains since the hurricane. In fact, employment in that sector this year has been at record highs. But it is more than just industry mix. Even within specific industry sectors, glaring contrasts exist between job trends in the two territories. In the vast majority of cases, Puerto Rico has seen significantly stronger job trends than the Virgin Islands. Many sectors—most notably leisure and hospitality and retail trade, both of which are key drivers of the Virgin Islands economy—have experienced far bigger job shortfalls in the Virgin Islands than in Puerto Rico since before the storm, as shown in the chart below. A number of other differences may also help explain the sharply contrasting economic trends. One possible contributor is hotel capacity. As noted in this July 2018 post, there has been virtually no new hotel construction in the Virgin Islands for more than two decades, and hotels in Puerto Rico were much quicker to reopen after the hurricanes than those in the Virgin Islands. [At the time that post was written, nearly 90 percent of Puerto Rico’s hotels had reopened versus just 60 percent of those in the Virgin Islands.] Another possible contributor is the minimum wage. While Puerto Rico’s minimum wage has remained at the federal threshold of $7.25 an hour, the U.S. Virgin Islands ratcheted its minimum wage up from $7.25 in the first half of 2016 to $10.50 as of June 2018—a 45 percent rise—with the most recent increase coming when the territory’s economy was already severely disrupted by the hurricanes. Although recent research on adverse employment effects from minimum wage hikes has been mixed, it is plausible that such hikes may have exacerbated the disruptive employment effects of a natural disaster like the one-two punch of Irma and Maria. But the steep hike in the minimum wage and its upward effect on average wages may also help explain why the divergence between the two territories was much narrower for overall wage and salary income than for the job count. Jason Bram is a research officer in the Bank’s Research and Statistics Group. How to cite this post: Jason Bram, “U.S. Virgin Islands Struggle While Puerto Rico Rebounds,” Federal Reserve Bank of New York Liberty Street Economics, October 2, 2019, https://libertystreeteconomics.newyorkfed.org/2019/10/us-virgin-islands-struggle-while-puerto-rico-rebounds.html. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Disclaimer The views expressed in this post are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the position of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York or the Federal Reserve System. Any errors or omissions are the responsibility of the author. SHARE THIS: * X * Facebook * LinkedIn * Email * Print * Comments You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post. Jeffery: Thank you for your interest and your thoughtful questions. In this analysis, we focused only on employment and earnings, not the number of establishments. But I think it is almost certain that the USVI did indeed lose a larger proportion of such establishments, after the storms, than Puerto Rico. If so, the same question remains: why? Insofar as disruptions in the USVI (positively) affected Puerto Rico, it’s important to remember that PR’s economy and population are about 30x as large as the U.S. Virgin Islands’, so it’s unlikely that anything going on in the USVI would have any significant direct effect on Puerto Rico. As for the notion that some of the high-paying construction jobs may be going to workers imported from the mainland, that is indeed a possibility in both USVI and Puerto Rico—and that would cause *both* the post-hurricane earnings and employment levels to be somewhat overstated. However, to be included in the islands’ job and income counts, a worker has to be on the payroll of a local employer; contract workers from the mainland are not included. And finally the policy ratcheting up the minimum wage in the U.S. Virgin Islands was implemented long before Irma and Maria, so the storms would not have been a factor in that decision. Posted by: New York Fed Research | October 3, 2019 at 1:56 pm What percentage of Leisure and Hospitality establishments were affected in Puerto Rico vs. USVI? If the USVI lost a much larger share of these establishments than Puerto Rico, this could explain the slower recovery in USVI (remaining establishments in Puerto Rico getting more business than usual). What percentage of high-paying construction jobs in the USVI are held by USVI residents? If most of these jobs are filled by construction workers from outside the USVI, the wage impact for USVI residents may be as pronounced as the job impact. Did federal government contracts for recovery efforts require that a certain percentage of the jobs be filled locally? This is sometimes the case. If so, this could explain the decision to dramatically increase the minimum wage during an economic slump. If this is the case, it is a further indicator of the weakness of the USVI economy (dependence upon federally-mandated jobs overriding other considerations). Posted by: Jeffery Adkins | October 2, 2019 at 10:08 am The comments to this entry are closed. All Liberty Street Economics Search RSS Feed Follow Liberty Street Economics receive email alerts for this page About the Blog Liberty Street Economics features insight and analysis from New York Fed economists working at the intersection of research and policy. Launched in 2011, the blog takes its name from the Bank’s headquarters at 33 Liberty Street in Manhattan’s Financial District. The editors are Michael Fleming, Andrew Haughwout, Thomas Klitgaard, and Asani Sarkar, all economists in the Bank’s Research Group. Liberty Street Economics does not publish new posts during the blackout periods surrounding Federal Open Market Committee meetings. The views expressed are those of the authors, and do not necessarily reflect the position of the New York Fed or the Federal Reserve System. Economic Research Tracker Liberty Street Economics is available on the iPhone® and iPad® and can be customized by economic research topic or economist. ECONOMIC INEQUALITY This ongoing Liberty Street Economics series analyzes disparities in economic and policy outcomes by race, gender, age, region, income, and other factors. View by Topic Balance of PaymentsBank CapitalBanksCentral BankClimate ChangeCorporate FinanceCOVID-19 FacilitiesCreditCrisisCryptocurrenciesDemographicsDSGEEconomic HistoryEducationEmploymentEquitable GrowthEuro AreaExchange RatesExpectationsExportsFederal ReserveFed FundsFinancial InstitutionsFinancial IntermediationFinancial MarketsFiscal PolicyForecastingHey, Economist!Historical EchoesHousehold FinanceHousingHuman CapitalInequalityInflationInternational EconomicsLabor MarketLender of Last ResortLiquidityMacroeconomicsMonetary PolicyNew JerseyNew YorkNonbank (NBFI)PandemicPanicPuerto RicoRecessionRegional AnalysisRegulationRepoStocksStudent LoansSupply ChainSystemic RiskTariffsTreasuryUnemployment MOST READ THIS YEAR 1. Delinquency Is Increasingly in the Cards for Maxed-Out Borrowers 2. What Was Up with Grocery Prices? 3. Auto Loan Delinquency Revs Up as Car Prices Stress Budgets 4. Credit Card Delinquencies Continue to Rise—Who Is Missing Payments? 5. Taking Stock: Dollar Assets, Gold, and Official Foreign Exchange Reserves Useful Links * Economic Indicators Calendar * FRED (Federal Reserve Economic Data) * Economic Roundtable * Macro Blog * OECD Insights * World Bank/All about Finance Comment Guidelines We encourage your comments and queries on our posts and will publish them (below the post) subject to the following guidelines: Please be brief: Comments are limited to 1,500 characters. Please be aware: Comments submitted shortly before or during the FOMC blackout may not be published until after the blackout. Please be relevant: Comments are moderated and will not appear until they have been reviewed to ensure that they are substantive and clearly related to the topic of the post. Please be respectful: We reserve the right not to post any comment, and will not post comments that are abusive, harassing, obscene, or commercial in nature. No notice will be given regarding whether a submission will or will not be posted. Comments with links: Please do not include any links in your comment, even if you feel the links will contribute to the discussion. Comments with links will not be posted. Send Us Feedback Disclosure Policy The LSE editors ask authors submitting a post to the blog to confirm that they have no conflicts of interest as defined by the American Economic Association in its Disclosure Policy. If an author has sources of financial support or other interests that could be perceived as influencing the research presented in the post, we disclose that fact in a statement prepared by the author and appended to the author information at the end of the post. If the author has no such interests to disclose, no statement is provided. Note, however, that we do indicate in all cases if a data vendor or other party has a right to review a post. Archives * 2024 * December 2024 * November 2024 * October 2024 * September 2024 * August 2024 * July 2024 * June 2024 * May 2024 * April 2024 * March 2024 * February 2024 * January 2024 * 2023 * December 2023 * November 2023 * October 2023 * September 2023 * August 2023 * July 2023 * June 2023 * May 2023 * April 2023 * March 2023 * February 2023 * January 2023 * 2022 * December 2022 * November 2022 * October 2022 * September 2022 * August 2022 * July 2022 * June 2022 * May 2022 * April 2022 * March 2022 * February 2022 * January 2022 * 2021 * December 2021 * November 2021 * October 2021 * September 2021 * August 2021 * July 2021 * June 2021 * May 2021 * April 2021 * March 2021 * February 2021 * January 2021 * 2020 * December 2020 * November 2020 * October 2020 * September 2020 * August 2020 * July 2020 * June 2020 * May 2020 * April 2020 * March 2020 * February 2020 * January 2020 * 2019 * December 2019 * November 2019 * October 2019 * September 2019 * August 2019 * July 2019 * June 2019 * May 2019 * April 2019 * March 2019 * February 2019 * January 2019 * 2018 * December 2018 * November 2018 * October 2018 * September 2018 * August 2018 * July 2018 * June 2018 * May 2018 * April 2018 * March 2018 * February 2018 * January 2018 * 2017 * December 2017 * November 2017 * October 2017 * September 2017 * August 2017 * July 2017 * June 2017 * May 2017 * April 2017 * March 2017 * February 2017 * January 2017 * 2016 * December 2016 * November 2016 * October 2016 * September 2016 * August 2016 * July 2016 * June 2016 * May 2016 * April 2016 * March 2016 * February 2016 * January 2016 * 2015 * December 2015 * November 2015 * October 2015 * September 2015 * August 2015 * July 2015 * June 2015 * May 2015 * April 2015 * March 2015 * February 2015 * January 2015 * 2014 * December 2014 * November 2014 * October 2014 * September 2014 * August 2014 * July 2014 * June 2014 * May 2014 * April 2014 * March 2014 * February 2014 * January 2014 * 2013 * December 2013 * November 2013 * October 2013 * September 2013 * August 2013 * July 2013 * June 2013 * May 2013 * April 2013 * March 2013 * February 2013 * January 2013 * 2012 * December 2012 * November 2012 * October 2012 * September 2012 * August 2012 * July 2012 * June 2012 * May 2012 * April 2012 * March 2012 * February 2012 * January 2012 * 2011 * December 2011 * November 2011 * October 2011 * September 2011 * August 2011 * July 2011 * June 2011 * May 2011 * April 2011 * March 2011 * Request a Speaker * International, Seminars & Training * Governance & Culture Reform * Data Visualization * Economic Research Tracker * Markets Data APIs * Podcast * Contact Us * Terms of Use * Privacy * Site Map